Boldly going... where it all started! Presenting the first comic book adventures of the U.S.S. Enterprise and her crew! Fully remastered with new colors, Volume 3 collects issues #13-18, including stories such as "Dark Traveler," "The Enterprise Mutiny," "The Hijacked Planet," and more.
Len Wein was an American comic book writer and editor best known for co-creating DC Comics' Swamp Thing and Marvel Comics' Wolverine, and for helping revive the Marvel superhero team the X-Men (including the co-creation of Nightcrawler, Storm, and Colossus). Additionally, he was the editor for writer Alan Moore and illustrator Dave Gibbons' influential DC miniseries Watchmen.
Wein was inducted into the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame in 2008.
This volume is all about the improvements. Alberto Giolitti kept learning about how real Star Trek was supposed to look (the characters began to look like themselves and even Scotty got his proper look), Enterprise's Warp nacelles aren't drown as the exhaust nozzles anymore, we've got NCC-1701⁄7 Galileo as a shuttlecraft instead of that batmobile-like monstrosity we had before and so on. Also, most of this volume is all about Len Wein. Which is a good thing, sine at least he tried and made heck of a lot of nods to the original series. With various success, sure, but still.
For example, in an issue called Day of the Inquisitors, Mr. Wein decided to make a nod to an episode called The Conscience of the King and included a planet Tarsus IV. Unfortunately, it didn't work well and ended up messing up all the lore. Like, you know. In the original series Tarsus IV was an Earth colony that was established long ago. Here? It's an alien civilization that was just discovered by Enterprise. So... yeah. As usual with Gold Key, it's a mess.
Still, it's not nearly as big as what we had during Dick Wood times, while a story called Museum at the End of Time even looks like it inspired one of the episodes from The Animated Series. The one called The Time Trap. By pure incident, sure (Gold Key did the same exact "storm" thing again and again and the fact that they've added Klingons to the formula this time wasn't really a creative touch, it was just a random decision), but still.
Also, the last two stories introduced Arnold Drake. And yes, co-creator of Guardians of the Galaxy did work on this series for some time. Can't say he did much good, though. Actually, he brought the series back to post-Wood times with all of those ridiculous mistakes that don't even make sense in Star Trek lore. How about Mr. Spock altering the way for the entire civilization, for example? Sure, not as bad as Kirk destroying the entire populated planet in one of Dick Wood's stories, but still, it felt a lot like all the progress Len Wein did was reversed. Or at least most of it.
Heck, even George Wilson (cover artist) started to contribute to the mess. Sure, it felt good when we started to get proper covers at some point, instead of random photo still from the original show that we had before, but seriously, Mr. Wilson? Mr. Spock in the red jacket? Seriously?Leonard Nimoy's stills were on many previous Gold Key covers. How hard it was to paint him right? Good grief... Then again, it was only at this point that we started to get something besides green and blue for jackets, so... Yeah.
Star Trek. Comics. An absolute winner, right? Well...
Gold Key Comics made the early gamble and purchased the rights to publish a comic book series based on the then new television program, Star Trek. The artists and writers during the first year of publication had actually never seen an episode of the program. And it shows. The work was based on a few publicity photos given to them, and a synopsis of the show and main characters.
But comic writer Len Wein joined the team and he was actually familiar with the show and brought a little more familiarity to the books, even getting artist Alberto Giolitti to include things such as the arrow insignia on the chest of the uniforms (not all the time, which gets a little frustrating).
The stories start getting a little bit better. A little bit. They still seem very much geared to children comic book readers and not the adults who were watching the show.
"Dark Traveler" has an intruder come to get the Enterprise's help on a Utopian world where a bad man is operating robots to take control.
"The Enterprise Mutiny" - Captain Kirk takes the Enterprise into dangerous regions and the crew mutinies.
"Museum At the End of Time" - the Enterprise is caught in a space storm and taken through a hole in space and comes to a strange world where a collector has specimens from all over the galaxy. The Klingons are also caught in the storm and Kirk and crew must convince the Klingons to work together in order to escape the strange world.
"Day of the Inquisitors" - this has some of the finest, most recognizable Star Trek-like artwork (it includes the shuttlecraft Galileo ... and it looks like the shuttlecraft Galileo!) though we still have green uniforms. In fact, we now have two shades of green uniforms. Kirk and company spend time on a medieval world.
"The Cosmic Cavemen" - finally we have gold uniforms on the crew! On a prehistoric world, where cavemen ride pterodactyls, Spock is recognized as a god because his likeness (including his uniform tunic) are carved in stone in their worship area.
"The Hijacked Planet" - there's love in the air, and a dog saves the day.
This is the first volume where we actually feel like we're seeing characters from the television series, and that makes this collection just a bit more fun.
Looking for a good book? Star Trek: Gold Key Archives: Volume 3 starts to become recognizable Star Trek and Trekkies will want to add this to their collection.
I borrowed this book through the Kindle Unlimited program.
These retro comics take the reader back to the earliest days of Star Trek, when artistic creators were just beginning to flesh out the universe that Gene Roddenberry created. These depictions bring to mind the simplicity of Saturday morning comics, taking us to worlds where good people battled evil, the Enterprise was sent to mysterious planets where cave men made war with clubs and bewitching females enchanted Scotty and Spock (yes, Spock pretends to fall in love to trap a female spy), it's all good fun and the artwork is well-done. I remember reading Star Trek comics when they first came out and I was glad they were available after the original TV series was cancelled.
Definitely another product of its time. I did enjoy the camp-factor a bit, but it was definitely a skim-read to get a sense of the story instead of a deeper read, taking in more details like the drawings and inking. There is something interesting in reading this now, as a retro-futurist type of comic. Kirk gets cloned by Klingons so that they can frame the Federation for something, magnetic tape gets invented that can hold worlds and human/animal patters in storage indefinitely and are lots of space funnels (like space whirlpools that suck your ship in)...and a psychedelic space museum of sorts.
I only read half of this book and I'm not really very well versed in TOS (I was and am a HUGE DS9 fan, but not very well versed in any other Trek series - except the largely enjoyable PRODIGY, which I watched with my kids), so take it all with a grain of salt.
Classic Gold Key Star Trek comics, how do I love thee? Let me count the ways! Okay, okay, issues 13 through 18 certainly aren't perfect, but they're awfully, awfully good in so many wonderful, wonderful ways. It's easy enough to focus on the nitpicky inconsistencies that quite naturally arose during the production of this first ever Star Trek comic book series, when Western Publishing had actually been so bold as to hire an artist that had NEVER even seen a single episode of Star Trek! No lie, folks! But then, most die-hard Star Trek and Gold Key comics fans know all of that interesting trivia by now. So yada yada yada, whatever!
The important thing to keep in mind, rather, is that Alberto Giolitti was a fantastic artist, and his work on the 6 issues included in Star Trek: Gold Key Archives Volume 3 is absolutely luscious stuff. Given the fact that the guy was in Rome, while the TV show and the publishing people he was working for were based in the United States, it is little wonder that there were plenty of small details that got, shall we say, "lost in translation," here and there. So despite the fact that the black collars of the crew members of the starship Enterprise aren't quite the right shape, and even more troubling, the interiors of the Enterprise itself don't always look like our heroes are even on the same ship, Giolitti still managed to draw spot on likenesses of almost all the cast members in practically every single panel. And come on, you didn't see THAT back when Marvel Comics was doing their own Star Trek comics series in 1979-80! Nor did Marvel do all that well with likenesses when they did Star Wars or Battlestar Galactica back in the day either. So there, fanboy nitpickers! So there!
At any rate, I AM a fanboy nitpicker (well, mostly), so it's not like I don't notice the fact that Gold Key continued to get the color of the crew's tunics wrong up until pretty much issue number 18. And even in issue 18, The Hijacked Planet, some members of the crew are still wearing green shirts, but at least Captain Kirk is finally wearing his trademark command gold. Though really, to be fair to the folks at Gold Key, from what I've been told by people who've seen one of the actual tunics that William Shatner wore during the production of the original series, what looked gold or yellow on film was actually a unique shade of GREEN! I kid you not! So maybe that's why Gold Key had the idea from the very beginning that starfleet crew members wore either blue or green shirts. And hey, who really knows? Gold Key started publishing original Star Trek stories back in the late 1960s, when the show was still on the air, so who can say for sure now, right? But then... it still doesn't explain why there weren't many crew members with red colored shirts in those first batch of issues either. Hmm.
And to be quite honest, some of the stories in this volume are a little off base when it comes to the characters and how they're presented. But only sometimes, really, and not all that much. In most cases, Spock is still logical to a fault. Kirk is still intrepid and daring, and Dr. McCoy is still a space faring curmudgeon who doesn't always get along real well with Spock. Come on, THAT'S original series Star Trek in a nutshell, is it not? More often than not though, the real problem was the jargon that was used in many of the first issues of Gold Key Star Trek, that was at first different from what we all came to know and love from watching the TV series. Like, how Gold Key began their comic book serial by calling the transporter a "teleporter." Odd stuff like that, that may not have made some readers back in the late '60s and early '70s bat an eye, but after the show had been on TV for a good long while, and had become such a mainstay in syndication, showing practically every single day of the week in many countries around the world, any minor inconsistencies in the GK Trek comics now naturally tend to stick out like a sore thumb.
All things considered, the bottom line is that as far fetched and sometimes even silly and formulaic some of the Gold Key Star Trek plot lines may in fact be, there is a very, very good reason why this comic book series is still so beloved by so many fans. The art, despite minor flaws, inconsistencies, and sometimes inexplicable color choices, really is top notch, and many of the stories were really very innovative and entertaining. And seriously, how can you really ask for much more from a comic book adaptation that was mostly drawn by an artist who'd never even seen the TV show it was based on? So just take my advice and read this lovingly restored collection of issues 13 through 18 with an open mind. Forget about all that nitpicky little stuff and just enjoy the ride into the far flung reaches of space, the final frontier. After all, these ARE just some of the more or less obscure voyages of the starship Enterprise, in its original five year mission: to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, and to boldly go where no man has gone before.
In line with the previous Gold Archives volumes, this one is full of fantastic tales that seem to have a very tenuous connection with the Star Trek mythology. A plan to replace Kirk with a mad clone in order to give an advantage to (some rather human-like) Klingons. ¿A visit to Limbo? Medieval planets and all these talk of prime directives that are clearly forgotten in the next page. Still entertaining, but at least the first two volumes were more slapstick, if that can be said.
One of these stories is a classic "Which one is the real one and whom do I shoot?" story. Another uses the cliche robot uprising trope, though it is pointed out in the introduction that this was prior to it being overused. I'm not so sure about this, but without some references off the top of my head, I can't dispute it right now. And Spock being viewed as a God and as a guardian of a planet is entertaining.
Okay, so I get why die-hard TOS fans may give these Gold Key comics a low rating. The stories are sappy, sometimes a bit silly, and don't fully follow TOS protocol. But for me, I really love seeing the characters in these new situations, and the artwork is amazing. Fantastic bright colors used together - who cares if the shirts aren't always the right colors when they look so good!