True Rating: 4.5 Stars
Content/Trigger Warnings: Violence, Reference to suicide, Terminal illness, Death, Heavy references to nonconsensual kissing, References to unwanted marriages and marriage beds, Graphic depictions of illness
Representation: Adopted character, Sapphic relationships, Bisexuality, Terminally ill character
"I guess there must have been a first time each of these stories was told, somewhere in the way-back reaches of time, centuries before the Grimms ever tried to turn a profit on them. It was probably just some ordinary person whispering across a fire or carving pictures into whalebones or daubing mud on the walls of a cave, casually calling a new universe into existence."
Review TL;DR
A refreshing take on the idea of fairytale retellings, with Harrow's signature beautiful writing and descriptions, as well as an FMC that you can't help but want to root for. While there are some weaknesses, the stories together overall manage to give an important but often forgotten message. This omnibus edition shows how much better it is to read the two stories close together to really make the message sink in.
Full Review
I've been a fan of Alix. E. Harrow's writing since I first read "Starling House" a few years ago, and I've spent the time since then reading her backlist. I knew these two novellas existed, but I wanted to read them in this omnibus edition instead of on KU. I knew I was going to want to annotate the physical copy, and, honestly, I just loved the cover of this one.
Harrow definitely didn't disappoint with these stories. If you get this omnibus, I highly recommend reading the introduction. It's kind of hilarious how the idea for this these stories came about. I've read a lot of retellings in my time, many of the same ones as Harrow, and I will always read them because I think it's amazing what authors can do. Harrow definitely pushed into a slightly new area, and I enjoyed it. While the idea of alternate worlds have always existed, the way Harrow uses them in this story and the rules involved are just very clever and, at times, funny.
I loved Zinnia as our main character. She's a complicated person, who says one thing and then tends to feel or do another. Even though many won't be able to relate to her personal illness, there are many parts about her that ARE relatable. She's also extremely flawed, which comes out more in the second novella ("A Mirror Mended") than in the first one, but those flaws are things I'm sure everyone can understandable.
I will say, "A Spindle Splintered" is definitely the strongest of the two stories. It's got the tightest plot, with more action and interactions with people. This is the story that really gets the reader into Zinnia's mind and throws us into this world, showing off what's possible. It's the one that feels the most like an actual retelling, and maybe that's why it's so strong.
Still, "A Mirror Mended" IS necessary, because it shows the other side of the coin. It continues Zinnia's story and shows what can happen when you don't take the time to really consider the consequences of what you're doing -in more ways than one. While it is slower and now as action heavy, it's still a very important story and has some really good lines and moments in it.
Overall, I really enjoyed these stories and only took off half a point because the second story wasn't quite as compelling. This reminded me of how much I love Harrow's writing, just in time for her next release. If you're like me and love the author's writing style, I definitely recommend at least picking this up from your library. It's worth reading at least once.