What do you think?
Rate this book
Three Dahlias Mysteries #4
A Lively Midwinter Murder: A gripping cosy mystery to curl up with this Christmas
Not yet published
Expected 17 Feb 26Planning the perfect Christmas wedding can be murder . . .
A high society Christmas Eve wedding at a remote Scottish castle sounds like the perfect winter getaway for the three Dahlias and their partners - until a snowstorm hits, cutting them off from the mainland, and civilization.
Which, of course, is when the dead body of one of the other guests turns up in the snow outside the family chapel. A dead body wearing a wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace...
The Dahlias were ready for mulled wine, roaring fires, and romance this Christmas. Now, they're on the hunt for another murderer. And if their suspicions are right, it looks like the wedding may be off ...
A high society Christmas Eve wedding at a remote Scottish castle sounds like the perfect winter getaway for the three Dahlias and their partners - until a snowstorm hits, cutting them off from the mainland, and civilization.
Which, of course, is when the dead body of one of the other guests turns up in the snow outside the family chapel. A dead body wearing a wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace...
The Dahlias were ready for mulled wine, roaring fires, and romance this Christmas. Now, they're on the hunt for another murderer. And if their suspicions are right, it looks like the wedding may be off ...
352 pages, Paperback
First published November 5, 2024
137 people are currently reading
957 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews
dnf
December 7, 2024Ugh... guess what happened? I managed to read 20 pages and I simply can't anymore.
Honestly, Rosalind is my favourite character.
Pardon me, she was my fav character. But I feel like the author is not doing her justice.
I don't think we need to pair up every Dahlia. We established that Rosalind is a strong lady, let her be single, why are we forcing this Jack relationship?
(and if she breaks up with him in this book, good for her - please for the love that is holy, leave her love life alone)
Rosalind and Jack should never have happened. Period.
And this series and I should not have met either - maybe I will come back to this next year, maybe I won't....
I'm out for now - merry Christmas y'all.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I know I gave this series a second chance in the last book and it blew it...
But - I so want to love this series :(
Please please don't disappoint me again.
Honestly, Rosalind is my favourite character.
Pardon me, she was my fav character. But I feel like the author is not doing her justice.
I don't think we need to pair up every Dahlia. We established that Rosalind is a strong lady, let her be single, why are we forcing this Jack relationship?
(and if she breaks up with him in this book, good for her - please for the love that is holy, leave her love life alone)
Rosalind and Jack should never have happened. Period.
And this series and I should not have met either - maybe I will come back to this next year, maybe I won't....
I'm out for now - merry Christmas y'all.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I know I gave this series a second chance in the last book and it blew it...
But - I so want to love this series :(
Please please don't disappoint me again.
December 4, 2024
I really enjoyed this - possibly because I’m a bit of a sucker for mysteries set at Christmas in remote castles isolated by a snow storm.
There’s a wedding in Scottish Castle, a historical family feud, a couple of deaths and a whole lot of snow. Very festive.
Probably my favourite of the Lively books - the characters have matured to the point we know them. The mystery is good, but it’s the setting that made this book for me.
There’s a wedding in Scottish Castle, a historical family feud, a couple of deaths and a whole lot of snow. Very festive.
Probably my favourite of the Lively books - the characters have matured to the point we know them. The mystery is good, but it’s the setting that made this book for me.
November 9, 2024
i don't know why exactly, but this installment didn't quite catch me.
i feel like there are somewhat too many characters at this point and kit especially seems vaguely nice but we really don't know much about him.
the setting was cute and the mystery was ok but i just wasn't really invested.
i felt like there was a lot of pseudo-philosophic talk of what the dahlias do better than the police but then they just solved the murders off page (or at least we weren't given all the important clues, especially the budapest flyer thingy or maybe i missed it?).
i just felt i knew nothing of so many of the characters. libby and fiona seemed very similar and duncan and kit too in some ways. they just didn't quite jump off the page for me. i would have loved for this to explore each person's interests and motivations more and then of course the meta-thing with caro writing these novels. it bugs me that the books are called the same as hers but the citations don't match. maybe i wouldnprefer it if each book focused more on one daliah and her views instead of jumping between them, so we could maybe hear their voices or learn more about their backgrounds.
annie is my favourite character for sure, and caro my favourite daliah, i think. posy and rosalind's love stories just don't interest me that much. roaslind and jack especially didn't seem right in this at all, i'm glad they don't marry for the moment. i didn't think that was handled quite so well. might be biased because jack used to be a cop tho.
i did appreciate the murderer's cognitive dissonance. i think many murder mysteries portray murderers as too ok with their murderous identity. i believe human brains actually more often work like this murderers.
alao the way some of the minor mysteries were tied in was actually quite neat i think, but the big one and the motive just didn't quite do it for me.
i feel like there are somewhat too many characters at this point and kit especially seems vaguely nice but we really don't know much about him.
the setting was cute and the mystery was ok but i just wasn't really invested.
i felt like there was a lot of pseudo-philosophic talk of what the dahlias do better than the police but then they just solved the murders off page (or at least we weren't given all the important clues, especially the budapest flyer thingy or maybe i missed it?).
i just felt i knew nothing of so many of the characters. libby and fiona seemed very similar and duncan and kit too in some ways. they just didn't quite jump off the page for me. i would have loved for this to explore each person's interests and motivations more and then of course the meta-thing with caro writing these novels. it bugs me that the books are called the same as hers but the citations don't match. maybe i wouldnprefer it if each book focused more on one daliah and her views instead of jumping between them, so we could maybe hear their voices or learn more about their backgrounds.
annie is my favourite character for sure, and caro my favourite daliah, i think. posy and rosalind's love stories just don't interest me that much. roaslind and jack especially didn't seem right in this at all, i'm glad they don't marry for the moment. i didn't think that was handled quite so well. might be biased because jack used to be a cop tho.
i did appreciate the murderer's cognitive dissonance. i think many murder mysteries portray murderers as too ok with their murderous identity. i believe human brains actually more often work like this murderers.
alao the way some of the minor mysteries were tied in was actually quite neat i think, but the big one and the motive just didn't quite do it for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 5, 2024
I adore this series, Katy Watson is such a fantastic author. This book was so entertaining, I loved being back with the three Dahlias again. This book emitted warmth and coziness perfect to get you in the winter mood, albeit surrounded by murder and mystery. I absolutely loved the writing, the setting was totally enchanting in stunning Scotland. I was completely shocked by the mysteries revealed inside, and of course how the Dahlias solved the different mysteries with their usual swagger. It was such a joy and a total treat to read!
February 17, 2025
I have a tendency to rate individual books in a series based on my feelings on the series in general, but I just had to be honest with myself on my rating for this one.
I loved the first book in this series (The Three Dahlias) and I love the characters, the concept and the premise of these books. However, I do think this series is starting to suffer a bit from a rushed publication schedule (there's been 4 books in a little over 2 years). The mystery in the first book was so good, it was tightly plotted but well-paced, the reveals were good, there were twists but you could tell the clues had been planted throughout the book. Unfortunately, none of the following mysteries have been as good.
Again, this book had all of the ingredients to be great, the location, the locked-room nature of the mystery, the inclusion of the Dahlias' partners but the pacing of the plot and the resolution of the mystery let it down.
Nothing happened in this book. It's a fast, easy, enjoyable read but it's a lot of talk and no action from the Dahlias. They talk CONSTANTLY about how they need to start investigating, good thing they're here to investigate, okay here they go investigating another murder...but they never actually do it? They don't anything particularly active to try and solve the case and as a result this book ends up committing the cardinal sin of murder mysteries - the resolution relies on information that the reader has no way of knowing. It was almost as if the author was concerned about revealing too much too early and so instead opted to go round and round in circles for 300 pages and then pull the important information out of nowhere at the last minute.
I do still have a soft spot of this series and I will continue to read the books as they come out...but I'd be happy to wait a bit longer for them in the future if the mysteries could be a bit more tightly plotted.
I loved the first book in this series (The Three Dahlias) and I love the characters, the concept and the premise of these books. However, I do think this series is starting to suffer a bit from a rushed publication schedule (there's been 4 books in a little over 2 years). The mystery in the first book was so good, it was tightly plotted but well-paced, the reveals were good, there were twists but you could tell the clues had been planted throughout the book. Unfortunately, none of the following mysteries have been as good.
Again, this book had all of the ingredients to be great, the location, the locked-room nature of the mystery, the inclusion of the Dahlias' partners but the pacing of the plot and the resolution of the mystery let it down.
Nothing happened in this book. It's a fast, easy, enjoyable read but it's a lot of talk and no action from the Dahlias. They talk CONSTANTLY about how they need to start investigating, good thing they're here to investigate, okay here they go investigating another murder...but they never actually do it? They don't anything particularly active to try and solve the case and as a result this book ends up committing the cardinal sin of murder mysteries - the resolution relies on information that the reader has no way of knowing. It was almost as if the author was concerned about revealing too much too early and so instead opted to go round and round in circles for 300 pages and then pull the important information out of nowhere at the last minute.
I do still have a soft spot of this series and I will continue to read the books as they come out...but I'd be happy to wait a bit longer for them in the future if the mysteries could be a bit more tightly plotted.
November 16, 2024
I just want to start off by saying thank you to NetGalley and Publishers for sending me this arc as I really do enjoy this Agatha Christie like murder mystery.
I think there were just a few too many character to keep up with and found it was a little difficult to remember how they were all connected familiar wise.
I really liked the setting of the book, very isolated and alienated from the rest of the world so they didn’t have any back up from the police. I would have liked to see a bit more about Rosalind and Jacks relationship as we finally get to see them together however I do love Annie and Caro! Annie is such a contrast to Caro and balances each other out beautifully.
I feel like the big mystery came out the blue and there wasn’t any real clues to go back to so that you could slightly figure it out for yourself.
I think there were just a few too many character to keep up with and found it was a little difficult to remember how they were all connected familiar wise.
I really liked the setting of the book, very isolated and alienated from the rest of the world so they didn’t have any back up from the police. I would have liked to see a bit more about Rosalind and Jacks relationship as we finally get to see them together however I do love Annie and Caro! Annie is such a contrast to Caro and balances each other out beautifully.
I feel like the big mystery came out the blue and there wasn’t any real clues to go back to so that you could slightly figure it out for yourself.
January 13, 2025
3.5 stars
This was a fun (very wintery!) read. I’ve never really read cosy crime before but I can see why it’s so beloved – it’s gripping! Loved the cosiness of it all and I’m a sucker for the snowed in trope. Definitely a page turner!
I didn’t realise this was part of a series before reading so it did take some time to work out who was who. I also do feel like some of the Dahlia’s characterisation could have been a bit more developed as they do kinda merge into one. Still good fun and if there’s another on the way I’d definitely consider reading.
This was a fun (very wintery!) read. I’ve never really read cosy crime before but I can see why it’s so beloved – it’s gripping! Loved the cosiness of it all and I’m a sucker for the snowed in trope. Definitely a page turner!
I didn’t realise this was part of a series before reading so it did take some time to work out who was who. I also do feel like some of the Dahlia’s characterisation could have been a bit more developed as they do kinda merge into one. Still good fun and if there’s another on the way I’d definitely consider reading.
December 26, 2024
Vanocni cas. Svatba na skotskem hrade. Snehova boure. A jedna vrazda.
Toto je takova fajn vanocni detektivka ve stylu Agathy Christie - uzavrena spolecnost, omezeny okruh podezrelych. Stare krivdy, rodinne tajemstvi a 3 amaterske detektivky.
Me se pribeh libil, ale ano...mandat na vysetrovani tam nemel nikdo, tak proc poslouchat prave ty tri. Je fakt, ze jsem se zamyslila: skutecne to za to stalo?
Toto je takova fajn vanocni detektivka ve stylu Agathy Christie - uzavrena spolecnost, omezeny okruh podezrelych. Stare krivdy, rodinne tajemstvi a 3 amaterske detektivky.
Me se pribeh libil, ale ano...mandat na vysetrovani tam nemel nikdo, tak proc poslouchat prave ty tri. Je fakt, ze jsem se zamyslila: skutecne to za to stalo?
December 27, 2024
Loved the scenic Scottish setting! Very atmospheric!
February 7, 2025
i like these series and these people and so find the stories relaxing and also fun to read.
December 21, 2025
Actual Rating: 3.5/5 stars
April 11, 2025
An isolated mystery, set in a Scottish castle at Christmas time - what’s not to love!
October 30, 2024
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-arc. What is better than a cosy murder mystery? A cosy Christmas murder mystery! Another fantastic Three Dalia’s mystery by Katy Watson, this time with a festive twist. A good, intriguing murder mystery, set in a remote castle in the Scottish highlands. The three Dahlias and their partners expect a charming Christmas wedding, but things turns sinister when a body washes up on shore and the bride, their old friend Libby, warns them something more menacing is at play.
Ghost stories, a centuries old feud and a snow storm create an almost gothic backdrop to this three dahlias mystery, changing up the atmosphere from the normal charming summer countryside setting. A typical closed circle mystery, reminiscent of golden age murder mysteries with high society traditions and glamour, whilst also paying homage to traditional haunting Christmas tales.
It was really good to see the three Dahlias with their respective partners for this story. It gave more depth to their characters and it was charming seeing Kit and Annie become honorary Dahlias. I’m glad we got to see more of Posy and Kit together, seeing how much their relationship has developed from the first book. Similarly with Jack and Rosalind, who have also come along way since reuniting in the first mystery. The author has done a lovely job of conveying not just the highs but the lows of their relationship within the short time we spend in Rosalind’s pov. Managing to create three relationships that the audience can invest in as a side plot to a murder is no easy feat but Watson succeeds spectacularly.
The story has a slight lull just before the middle but otherwise is fast paced enough to keep you entertained throughout. Multiple twists kept the plot engaging and meant even if I guessed an aspect of the story, I couldn’t guess every reveal.
This book doesn’t disappoint. It delivers an easy to read, cosy, clever murder mystery.
Ghost stories, a centuries old feud and a snow storm create an almost gothic backdrop to this three dahlias mystery, changing up the atmosphere from the normal charming summer countryside setting. A typical closed circle mystery, reminiscent of golden age murder mysteries with high society traditions and glamour, whilst also paying homage to traditional haunting Christmas tales.
It was really good to see the three Dahlias with their respective partners for this story. It gave more depth to their characters and it was charming seeing Kit and Annie become honorary Dahlias. I’m glad we got to see more of Posy and Kit together, seeing how much their relationship has developed from the first book. Similarly with Jack and Rosalind, who have also come along way since reuniting in the first mystery. The author has done a lovely job of conveying not just the highs but the lows of their relationship within the short time we spend in Rosalind’s pov. Managing to create three relationships that the audience can invest in as a side plot to a murder is no easy feat but Watson succeeds spectacularly.
The story has a slight lull just before the middle but otherwise is fast paced enough to keep you entertained throughout. Multiple twists kept the plot engaging and meant even if I guessed an aspect of the story, I couldn’t guess every reveal.
This book doesn’t disappoint. It delivers an easy to read, cosy, clever murder mystery.
October 31, 2024
The Three Dahlias are my favourite cozy mystery detectives. Although it's a bit early in the year to be getting stuck into Christmas stories, I couldn't pass up the opportunity to read this as soon as it was available on netgalley.
Posy, Caro, and Rosalind attend a wedding at a remote Scottish castle. What should be a happy occasion is marred by the note the bride-to-be, Libby, included in their invitations: something isn't right in the Highlands, and she's scared. As a blizzard closes in, and tensions are palpable, the gathered guests trade ghost stories by the light of the hearth, only to find a corpse in the morning. Cut off from the nearest village by the storm, and with the electricity and communication lines down, the Dahlias must step up once again to solve a murder. And perhaps save Libby from wedding the culprit...
I would definitely recommend reading The Three Dahlias first to get up to speed with all the characters, but after that, if you're in a festive mood, you can skip straight to this one without being spoiled for previous mysteries. This had the right amount of wintery, Christmas elements to feel like a cozy seasonal read, but it wasn't so bedecked with tinsel and mistletoe as to feel gimmicky. The Three Dahlias always deliver a solid mystery with Golden Age vibes but modern sensibilities. I love the cross-generational friendship between the main characters and how they bring out the best in each other.
Posy, Caro, and Rosalind attend a wedding at a remote Scottish castle. What should be a happy occasion is marred by the note the bride-to-be, Libby, included in their invitations: something isn't right in the Highlands, and she's scared. As a blizzard closes in, and tensions are palpable, the gathered guests trade ghost stories by the light of the hearth, only to find a corpse in the morning. Cut off from the nearest village by the storm, and with the electricity and communication lines down, the Dahlias must step up once again to solve a murder. And perhaps save Libby from wedding the culprit...
I would definitely recommend reading The Three Dahlias first to get up to speed with all the characters, but after that, if you're in a festive mood, you can skip straight to this one without being spoiled for previous mysteries. This had the right amount of wintery, Christmas elements to feel like a cozy seasonal read, but it wasn't so bedecked with tinsel and mistletoe as to feel gimmicky. The Three Dahlias always deliver a solid mystery with Golden Age vibes but modern sensibilities. I love the cross-generational friendship between the main characters and how they bring out the best in each other.
October 27, 2024
When they arrive at the remote Scottish castle for the Christmas wedding, our three Dahlias could not foresee getting embroiled in another murder investigation. As soon as they arrive the body of an unknown man is found on the nearby beach, and as they try to find out more about him other events somewhat take over.
One of the party is discovered dead on the cliffs wearing a wedding dress and stolen diamonds. Suddenly everyone is a suspect and they need to try and establish just who might have had motive to kill her.
A cosy Christmas murder mystery. Thanks to NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this before publication.
One of the party is discovered dead on the cliffs wearing a wedding dress and stolen diamonds. Suddenly everyone is a suspect and they need to try and establish just who might have had motive to kill her.
A cosy Christmas murder mystery. Thanks to NetGalley for giving me the opportunity to read and review this before publication.
December 2, 2024
A Lively Midwinter Murder by Katy Watson published November 5th with Constable (Little Brown Books) and is the fourth mystery in the Three Dahlias series. It can be read as a standalone but I do think it would be beneficial to read the previous novels in the series, in order to get a more complete picture of the cast and their backstory.
Rosalind King, Caro Hooper and Posy Starling, aka The Three Dahlias, are at Dunwick Castle in a remote part of the Scottish Highlands for the wedding of their friend Libby McKinley to Duncan Alexander. Dunwick Castle has been owned by the same family for generations and now Libby is due to marry into the fold. The wedding has all the trademarks of an elaborate event and Rosalind, Caro and Posy are all looking forward to enjoying the celebrations in this stunning part of the world.
On arrival, they witness a serious incident involving a drowning but, as it apparently has nothing to do with Libby’s upcoming nuptials, they initially shelve their innate curiosity. The Dahlias’ observations and ability to communicate with each other, through years of investigating and acting, soon become central to this novel when another tragedy takes place. As the weather turns increasingly hostile, the body of a fellow guest is discovered in the snow and it soon becomes very clear that something sinister is afoot. Inclement weather leads to road closures and loss of communication to the outside world, leaving the residents and guests of Dunwick Castle isolated. The Three Dahlias immediately get to work and, using their individual skills and investigative analysis, they begin to untangle a web of deceit, greed and toxic relationships but can they catch a killer?
The Three Dahlias series is a throwback to the Golden Age of Detective fiction when the amateur sleuth was all the rage. The inclusion of an original Dahlia Lively series of mysteries, written by a fictional author, Lettice Davenport, is an interesting concept, with each chapter opening with a snippet from one of her books. Rosalind, Caro and Posy now know the role they each need to play in order to uncover the truth. They work in tandem, taking notes and examining clues as they subtly investigate the crime. Katy Watson has completely embraced the whole cosy crime genre, capturing the very essence of the classic novels of that era. Although a murder has taken place, there is a light-hearted element to the series which makes this the perfect read for anyone who prefers less grit and violence in their crime fiction.
A Lively Midwinter Murder is a well-crafted mystery, entertaining and charming. With it’s rugged and wild atmospheric setting, the visuals are very strong throughout allowing all to easily imagine the scene depicted on the page. With accessible entry into the plot, the reader feels included in the investigation, solving the puzzle alongside the protagonists. Although set in modern day, there is a timeless feel to Katy Watson’s writing that should appeal to all Agatha Christie fans and readers who enjoy a classic cosy crime novel with a more contemporary flair.
Rosalind King, Caro Hooper and Posy Starling, aka The Three Dahlias, are at Dunwick Castle in a remote part of the Scottish Highlands for the wedding of their friend Libby McKinley to Duncan Alexander. Dunwick Castle has been owned by the same family for generations and now Libby is due to marry into the fold. The wedding has all the trademarks of an elaborate event and Rosalind, Caro and Posy are all looking forward to enjoying the celebrations in this stunning part of the world.
On arrival, they witness a serious incident involving a drowning but, as it apparently has nothing to do with Libby’s upcoming nuptials, they initially shelve their innate curiosity. The Dahlias’ observations and ability to communicate with each other, through years of investigating and acting, soon become central to this novel when another tragedy takes place. As the weather turns increasingly hostile, the body of a fellow guest is discovered in the snow and it soon becomes very clear that something sinister is afoot. Inclement weather leads to road closures and loss of communication to the outside world, leaving the residents and guests of Dunwick Castle isolated. The Three Dahlias immediately get to work and, using their individual skills and investigative analysis, they begin to untangle a web of deceit, greed and toxic relationships but can they catch a killer?
The Three Dahlias series is a throwback to the Golden Age of Detective fiction when the amateur sleuth was all the rage. The inclusion of an original Dahlia Lively series of mysteries, written by a fictional author, Lettice Davenport, is an interesting concept, with each chapter opening with a snippet from one of her books. Rosalind, Caro and Posy now know the role they each need to play in order to uncover the truth. They work in tandem, taking notes and examining clues as they subtly investigate the crime. Katy Watson has completely embraced the whole cosy crime genre, capturing the very essence of the classic novels of that era. Although a murder has taken place, there is a light-hearted element to the series which makes this the perfect read for anyone who prefers less grit and violence in their crime fiction.
A Lively Midwinter Murder is a well-crafted mystery, entertaining and charming. With it’s rugged and wild atmospheric setting, the visuals are very strong throughout allowing all to easily imagine the scene depicted on the page. With accessible entry into the plot, the reader feels included in the investigation, solving the puzzle alongside the protagonists. Although set in modern day, there is a timeless feel to Katy Watson’s writing that should appeal to all Agatha Christie fans and readers who enjoy a classic cosy crime novel with a more contemporary flair.
December 29, 2024
When the three best friends Caro, Rosalind, and Posy, actors and amateur sleuths, known as the three Dahlia’s, are invited to the Christmas society wedding of their friend Libby to Duncan Alexander, held in his remote Scottish castle. They are in no time packed and ready for good food and plenty of mulled wine, accompanied of course by their partners.
Initially all looks good. The castle is amazing, and the location is stunningly beautiful all set for enjoyment and romance. Unfortunately, the weather has distinctly other ideas, and the storm of the century brings unprecedented heavy snow and leaves them with no electricity, phone connection, internet, and in short, they are completely cut off from the mainland.
It could be worse, they have food, and Bill the husband of Nora, the parents of Duncan manages to get an old generator working providing some heat for the castle. But then the dead body of one of the guests is found outside in the snow dressed in Libby’s wedding gown and wearing a necklace of diamonds that the housekeeper Elsbeth has been trying to find, as they are family heirlooms and Nora wants Libby to wear them on her wedding day.
Unable to contact the police, or leave the castle, Jack, Rosalind’s partner, who is ex-police takes it upon himself to question everyone to get someone idea of their whereabouts during the day, as he does so secrets start to immerge. And there are a lot of secrets. The three Dahlia’s put their heads together to unravel the history of Dunwick Castle, and Kinley House that is situated on the other bank of the loch. The two families fell out decades ago, but why? There are many twists and turns in this fascinating book. It will keep you reading into the early hours it did me. Highly recommended.
-------
Reviewer: Lizzie Sirett
Initially all looks good. The castle is amazing, and the location is stunningly beautiful all set for enjoyment and romance. Unfortunately, the weather has distinctly other ideas, and the storm of the century brings unprecedented heavy snow and leaves them with no electricity, phone connection, internet, and in short, they are completely cut off from the mainland.
It could be worse, they have food, and Bill the husband of Nora, the parents of Duncan manages to get an old generator working providing some heat for the castle. But then the dead body of one of the guests is found outside in the snow dressed in Libby’s wedding gown and wearing a necklace of diamonds that the housekeeper Elsbeth has been trying to find, as they are family heirlooms and Nora wants Libby to wear them on her wedding day.
Unable to contact the police, or leave the castle, Jack, Rosalind’s partner, who is ex-police takes it upon himself to question everyone to get someone idea of their whereabouts during the day, as he does so secrets start to immerge. And there are a lot of secrets. The three Dahlia’s put their heads together to unravel the history of Dunwick Castle, and Kinley House that is situated on the other bank of the loch. The two families fell out decades ago, but why? There are many twists and turns in this fascinating book. It will keep you reading into the early hours it did me. Highly recommended.
-------
Reviewer: Lizzie Sirett
November 12, 2024
A Lively Midwinter Murder by Katy Watson is a delightful, festive addition to the Three Dahlias series that immerses readers in the eerie charm of a Scottish Highlands Christmas wedding. When Posy, Caro, and Rosalind arrive at the castle for their friend Libby's big day, they're greeted by an ominous note from the bride herself, warning that something unsettling is at play. The celebratory mood takes a dark turn when a body washes up on the shore, setting the stage for a classic closed-circle mystery filled with clever clues, red herrings, and surprising twists.
Watson’s skillful writing brings a gothic, almost haunting atmosphere to this wintery mystery, with ghost stories, a centuries-old feud, and a brewing snowstorm adding layers of suspense. The Scottish Highlands setting, complete with a remote castle and roaring hearth, perfectly captures the essence of a cozy, seasonal murder mystery with just enough festive touches to make it feel like a holiday treat.
The Three Dahlias are as engaging as ever, with their cross-generational friendship providing warmth and humor that balance the darker undertones of the plot. It was a pleasure to see the main characters’ relationships evolve, especially as their partners play more prominent roles, offering a new dynamic to the team and allowing readers to invest more deeply in their lives beyond sleuthing.
Fast-paced and full of unexpected reveals, A Lively Midwinter Murder is an entertaining and heartwarming mystery. With Watson's nod to Golden Age traditions and her own modern flair, this is a cozy seasonal read that doesn’t disappoint. Perfect for fans of atmospheric mysteries looking for a festive twist!
Thank you to NetGalley and Bonnier Books for providing this advanced copy!
Watson’s skillful writing brings a gothic, almost haunting atmosphere to this wintery mystery, with ghost stories, a centuries-old feud, and a brewing snowstorm adding layers of suspense. The Scottish Highlands setting, complete with a remote castle and roaring hearth, perfectly captures the essence of a cozy, seasonal murder mystery with just enough festive touches to make it feel like a holiday treat.
The Three Dahlias are as engaging as ever, with their cross-generational friendship providing warmth and humor that balance the darker undertones of the plot. It was a pleasure to see the main characters’ relationships evolve, especially as their partners play more prominent roles, offering a new dynamic to the team and allowing readers to invest more deeply in their lives beyond sleuthing.
Fast-paced and full of unexpected reveals, A Lively Midwinter Murder is an entertaining and heartwarming mystery. With Watson's nod to Golden Age traditions and her own modern flair, this is a cozy seasonal read that doesn’t disappoint. Perfect for fans of atmospheric mysteries looking for a festive twist!
Thank you to NetGalley and Bonnier Books for providing this advanced copy!
December 5, 2024
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with an eArc of one of my most anticipated reads of 2024.
Boy was I looking forward to this one!
A Lively Midwinter Wedding is the fourth instalment in the Three Dahlias Mysteries series by Katy Watson. In this novel, the three dahlias are invited to a wedding held on Christmas Eve at a private Scottish castle seems like the most wonderful winter getaway… until a dead body wearing a wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace turns up and suddenly the prime suspects in this murder case are the Bride and Groom.
I really enjoyed this story and I am a lover of the closed circle mystery. I love the chemistry of the dahlias and how they work together. They complement each other so much in their mystery solving ways. I enjoyed the more in-depth look at the dahlias relationships with their significant others. It was nice to see and made the emotional moments in the book more powerful due to the depth of the relationships were written about previously.
The plot of this instalment had me intrigued from every page, the turns the story took and when we finally uncover who the murderer is I was shocked, as the reader we weren’t given the clue that tipped the dahlias off to the murderer but the reveal was enjoyable. I never guessed it could have been that character. It was a medium-to-fast paced story that I HAD to finish or I would be wondering and wondering what the next page held.
I loved this book, it is such a cosy mystery that you can read cosied up during the holiday season with a belly full of any other Christmas treat other than mince pies.
Boy was I looking forward to this one!
A Lively Midwinter Wedding is the fourth instalment in the Three Dahlias Mysteries series by Katy Watson. In this novel, the three dahlias are invited to a wedding held on Christmas Eve at a private Scottish castle seems like the most wonderful winter getaway… until a dead body wearing a wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace turns up and suddenly the prime suspects in this murder case are the Bride and Groom.
I really enjoyed this story and I am a lover of the closed circle mystery. I love the chemistry of the dahlias and how they work together. They complement each other so much in their mystery solving ways. I enjoyed the more in-depth look at the dahlias relationships with their significant others. It was nice to see and made the emotional moments in the book more powerful due to the depth of the relationships were written about previously.
The plot of this instalment had me intrigued from every page, the turns the story took and when we finally uncover who the murderer is I was shocked, as the reader we weren’t given the clue that tipped the dahlias off to the murderer but the reveal was enjoyable. I never guessed it could have been that character. It was a medium-to-fast paced story that I HAD to finish or I would be wondering and wondering what the next page held.
I loved this book, it is such a cosy mystery that you can read cosied up during the holiday season with a belly full of any other Christmas treat other than mince pies.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 8, 2024
I was very kindly given an e-ARC of this book via Netgalley and Little, Brown Group UK.
As with pretty much all of the Three Dahlia mysteries, I find that I enjoyed 'A Lively Midwinter Murder', but in a few weeks I'll likely have forgotten all about it. Despite the author continually dropping in clunky sentences into her prose about plot points that happened in previous (just in case you decided to pick up book four on a complete whim without first readings books 1-3), it's an interesting mystery. I didn't guess who had done the murder and there were a lot of much deeper plot lines that were intriguing enough to follow. This is something of a locked-room mystery as they're stuck in this grand Scottish house during a snow storm, and Watson successfully managed to keep things intriguing without having to move the characters around a lot. Personally, I felt there were far too many supporting characters who had little to do with the overall action and weren't at all distinct from each other. I also felt as though there wasn't enough time really spent with the three central women actually solving the crime - another character is far more heavily involved and the answer seems to come to them all of a sudden, rather than through any detective work they might do.
I don't know if I'll pick up another one of these books, it's been a string of three stars for me. But if you like your murder mysteries Christie-esque, this is probably something you'll enjoy.
'A Lively Midwinter Murder' is available now.
As with pretty much all of the Three Dahlia mysteries, I find that I enjoyed 'A Lively Midwinter Murder', but in a few weeks I'll likely have forgotten all about it. Despite the author continually dropping in clunky sentences into her prose about plot points that happened in previous (just in case you decided to pick up book four on a complete whim without first readings books 1-3), it's an interesting mystery. I didn't guess who had done the murder and there were a lot of much deeper plot lines that were intriguing enough to follow. This is something of a locked-room mystery as they're stuck in this grand Scottish house during a snow storm, and Watson successfully managed to keep things intriguing without having to move the characters around a lot. Personally, I felt there were far too many supporting characters who had little to do with the overall action and weren't at all distinct from each other. I also felt as though there wasn't enough time really spent with the three central women actually solving the crime - another character is far more heavily involved and the answer seems to come to them all of a sudden, rather than through any detective work they might do.
I don't know if I'll pick up another one of these books, it's been a string of three stars for me. But if you like your murder mysteries Christie-esque, this is probably something you'll enjoy.
'A Lively Midwinter Murder' is available now.
Read
December 2, 2024DNF'd it at 50%. I hated it. Maybe I would have felt differently had I read the previous books, but I did not realize it was the fourth book in a series when I purchased it.
First, there was no backstory to the characters, and there were soooo many characters. I could not keep them straight; they were too similar with no defining characteristics.
Second, the author included so much extraneous information that I couldn't stay focused. Here is a sample paragraph:
"Posy was rather relieved when Duncan offered to meet them at the airport. Kit's schedule had meant that driving up from London would have been cutting things far too fine and while Caro had offered her a lift up with them so Kit could follow later, Posy hadn't been able to face another lengthy journey in the back seat of Caro's tiny red sports car. Not to mention the fact that Caro and Annie planned to stop for a night or two on the way, and visit a few antique emporiums en route. Posy had pictured herself pinned to the back of the car by an antique grandfather clock and promptly booked plane tickets for both her and Kit from London to Glasgow."
Why did I need to know any of this information? The book is constantly like this! Unimportant ramblings that just seem like filler to make the book hit a particular word count.
Third, the book was so boring. It advanced at a snail's pace... no tension or suspense. It was painful to read and was killing any desire I had to read. I absolutely hate DNF'ing books, but I just couldn't keep going with this one.
First, there was no backstory to the characters, and there were soooo many characters. I could not keep them straight; they were too similar with no defining characteristics.
Second, the author included so much extraneous information that I couldn't stay focused. Here is a sample paragraph:
"Posy was rather relieved when Duncan offered to meet them at the airport. Kit's schedule had meant that driving up from London would have been cutting things far too fine and while Caro had offered her a lift up with them so Kit could follow later, Posy hadn't been able to face another lengthy journey in the back seat of Caro's tiny red sports car. Not to mention the fact that Caro and Annie planned to stop for a night or two on the way, and visit a few antique emporiums en route. Posy had pictured herself pinned to the back of the car by an antique grandfather clock and promptly booked plane tickets for both her and Kit from London to Glasgow."
Why did I need to know any of this information? The book is constantly like this! Unimportant ramblings that just seem like filler to make the book hit a particular word count.
Third, the book was so boring. It advanced at a snail's pace... no tension or suspense. It was painful to read and was killing any desire I had to read. I absolutely hate DNF'ing books, but I just couldn't keep going with this one.
December 30, 2024
The Three Dahlias – Rosalind, Caro, and Posy – and their respective partners – Jack, Annie, and Kit – arrive at Dunwick Castle for a wedding of their friend, Libby.
Libby is due to marry Duncan, the future laird of Dunwick. The chosen location of the wedding is the castle where Duncan grew up, which is now his and Libby’s home. The castle is located on an island accessible only via a bridge.
When Libby invited the Dahlias to the wedding, she added that something wasn’t right at the castle. Upon their arrival, the Dahlias discover that a body of a man washed up on the shore. No one in the castle, or in the neighbouring village, seems to have recognised him.
Then, one of the guests staying at the castle turns up dead, wearing Libby’s wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace.
With the snowstorm cutting them off, it seems like the killer is in their midst. It’s another case for the Dahlias!
This is the fourth book in the Three Dahlias, but it can be enjoyed as a standalone novel. I haven’t read the previous Dahlias books (but I will remedy that as I loved the characters), but I quickly got the gist of the characters and what happened in the previous stories.
The Three Dahlias are all actresses famous for portraying a 1930s detective, Dahlia Lively. I really enjoyed getting to know these women and learning more about their personalities and quirks. I also loved the fact that everyone at the castle had a secret – expect a couple of twists, too!
This is a perfect book to read over the Christmas period. You will love it.
Libby is due to marry Duncan, the future laird of Dunwick. The chosen location of the wedding is the castle where Duncan grew up, which is now his and Libby’s home. The castle is located on an island accessible only via a bridge.
When Libby invited the Dahlias to the wedding, she added that something wasn’t right at the castle. Upon their arrival, the Dahlias discover that a body of a man washed up on the shore. No one in the castle, or in the neighbouring village, seems to have recognised him.
Then, one of the guests staying at the castle turns up dead, wearing Libby’s wedding dress and a stolen diamond necklace.
With the snowstorm cutting them off, it seems like the killer is in their midst. It’s another case for the Dahlias!
This is the fourth book in the Three Dahlias, but it can be enjoyed as a standalone novel. I haven’t read the previous Dahlias books (but I will remedy that as I loved the characters), but I quickly got the gist of the characters and what happened in the previous stories.
The Three Dahlias are all actresses famous for portraying a 1930s detective, Dahlia Lively. I really enjoyed getting to know these women and learning more about their personalities and quirks. I also loved the fact that everyone at the castle had a secret – expect a couple of twists, too!
This is a perfect book to read over the Christmas period. You will love it.
December 6, 2024
I have to own up and say that haven’t read the previous three books in this Three Dahlia’s cosy crime series so it took me a little while to get to know who was who and where they all connected, however, once I got the dynamics of the characters settled in my head, I began to gel more with the story and who doesn’t love a good fictional murder at Christmas.
Rosalind King, Caro Hooper and Posy Starling are the trio of amateur sleuths who make up the Three Dahlias and who are attending the wedding of their friend Libby who is marrying into the family who own the magnificent Dunwick Castle in Scotland. With this high society wedding taking place at the castle and with guests arriving to enjoy the celebrations the last thing anyone needs is a dead body but never daunted by a crime scene the three Dahlias soon get cracking on trying to solve the murder/ mystery.
Overall, I thought this was an entertaining read with enough twists, turns and red herrings in the plot to keep me guessing and with interesting characters who each add a sense of mystery to the proceedings. The setting is wonderfully festive, I mean who can resist a Scottish castle at Christmas, and with more than a nod towards the golden age of crime writing, the author brings the whole thing together in a satisfying way.
A Lively Midwinter Murder is a cosy Christmas read which, I’m sure, fans of this series will love as much as the previous three books.
December 17, 2025
advance review copy received from NetGalley in return for an honest review
A Lively Midwinter Murder was an enjoyable, cosy read that really leaned into its wintry setting. The Scottish castle, the snow, and the sense of being cut off from the outside world created a wonderfully atmospheric backdrop, and that was easily one of the book’s strongest elements. It captured the feel of a classic festive mystery without becoming overly cute or gimmicky.
I also appreciated that the Christmas angle didn’t overwhelm the story. The seasonal details enhanced the mood rather than distracting from the plot, which was a pleasant surprise. The mystery itself was solid and, importantly, made sense — the clues were woven through the story clearly and fairly, so the solution felt earned rather than pulled out of thin air. It’s a fairly standard whodunnit in structure, but one that was pleasing in its execution and conclusion.
While I enjoyed reading it, this one didn’t quite linger with me once finished. Some aspects felt familiar, and although the characters were likeable, I didn’t feel especially invested beyond the immediate puzzle. That said, it was consistently engaging and well put together, which goes a long way in this genre.
Overall, this was a comfortable, satisfying read — ideal for fans of cosy, atmospheric mysteries who enjoy a classic setup and a neat, logical resolution.
With thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy.
A Lively Midwinter Murder was an enjoyable, cosy read that really leaned into its wintry setting. The Scottish castle, the snow, and the sense of being cut off from the outside world created a wonderfully atmospheric backdrop, and that was easily one of the book’s strongest elements. It captured the feel of a classic festive mystery without becoming overly cute or gimmicky.
I also appreciated that the Christmas angle didn’t overwhelm the story. The seasonal details enhanced the mood rather than distracting from the plot, which was a pleasant surprise. The mystery itself was solid and, importantly, made sense — the clues were woven through the story clearly and fairly, so the solution felt earned rather than pulled out of thin air. It’s a fairly standard whodunnit in structure, but one that was pleasing in its execution and conclusion.
While I enjoyed reading it, this one didn’t quite linger with me once finished. Some aspects felt familiar, and although the characters were likeable, I didn’t feel especially invested beyond the immediate puzzle. That said, it was consistently engaging and well put together, which goes a long way in this genre.
Overall, this was a comfortable, satisfying read — ideal for fans of cosy, atmospheric mysteries who enjoy a classic setup and a neat, logical resolution.
With thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy.
December 30, 2024
Actresses and amateur sleuths Caro, Posy and Rosalind travel to Scotland to celebrate the Christmas Eve wedding of their friend Libby in a remote Scottish castle. It should be a supremely happy occasion - but Libby has already shared that something unsettling is happening at the castle and with a snowstorm coming in, and after an evening spent sharing ghost stories, things take a dramatic turn when the body of one of the guests is found the next day. Cut off by the snow, and with the electricity and all means of communication knocked out, the Three Dahlias set about uncovering the truth behind the mysterious death.
Having not read the earlier books in the series (this is the fourth) it did take me a little while to get to grips with who everyone was in the extensive cast of characters (though there is a helpful Cast List at the beginning of the book). But once I did I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know the three women and their inter-generational friendship. I loved the nod to Golden Age crime, there are plenty of twists and a generous helping of humour - and a thoroughly atmospheric setting brought to life. All in all a delightful read - and the other books in the series have been added to my TBR.
Having not read the earlier books in the series (this is the fourth) it did take me a little while to get to grips with who everyone was in the extensive cast of characters (though there is a helpful Cast List at the beginning of the book). But once I did I thoroughly enjoyed getting to know the three women and their inter-generational friendship. I loved the nod to Golden Age crime, there are plenty of twists and a generous helping of humour - and a thoroughly atmospheric setting brought to life. All in all a delightful read - and the other books in the series have been added to my TBR.
December 10, 2024
3.75 rounded to 4.0
The Three Dahlias are actresses (Posy, Caro, and Rosalind) who have all played the part of a mystery heroine from a classic “who dun it” series. Along with their partners, they have gathered together to share Christmas and attend the wedding of one of the Dahlias. After a hair raising evening of ghost stories on their first night, they are primed for the snowstorm that cuts them off from the outside and the death first of a mysterious stranger followed by one of the guests. This is a homage to the classic mystery trope of the amateur detective, racing to find the murderer before anyone else is killed and very well done—a prime example of the cozy mystery trope as well. The characters are likable, the plot interesting and well resolved, and the settings unique and rich in depth. This is the fourth book in the Three Dahlias series. I plan to go back and catch up with the earlier titles while waiting for the next one in the series . Recommend to readers who appreciate classic mysteries, quirky characters, amateur detectives, mature women and cross generational friendships.
The Three Dahlias are actresses (Posy, Caro, and Rosalind) who have all played the part of a mystery heroine from a classic “who dun it” series. Along with their partners, they have gathered together to share Christmas and attend the wedding of one of the Dahlias. After a hair raising evening of ghost stories on their first night, they are primed for the snowstorm that cuts them off from the outside and the death first of a mysterious stranger followed by one of the guests. This is a homage to the classic mystery trope of the amateur detective, racing to find the murderer before anyone else is killed and very well done—a prime example of the cozy mystery trope as well. The characters are likable, the plot interesting and well resolved, and the settings unique and rich in depth. This is the fourth book in the Three Dahlias series. I plan to go back and catch up with the earlier titles while waiting for the next one in the series . Recommend to readers who appreciate classic mysteries, quirky characters, amateur detectives, mature women and cross generational friendships.
November 11, 2024
The three Dahlia's are invited to the Christmas wedding of Libby and Duncan in the Scottish Highlands and, like Miss Marple or Poirot who are walking magnets for mysteries, they inevitably discover the dead body of one of the guests.
It had many interesting mysteries that all appear to occur in isolation until it all comes together at the end and the mysteries are wrapped up in a nice Christmassy bow. Setting it in an isolated castle in the Scottish Highlands at Christmas is a nice contrast and creates a sense of foreboding.
I really like that we have returning characters from previous books as I find it's a shame when we grow to like characters in one book and they never appear again. I think it adds nice layers to future books as they become more developed and not one-dimensional.
Overall, another hit by Katy Watson and I hope to read more about the exploits of the three Dahlia's very soon!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
It had many interesting mysteries that all appear to occur in isolation until it all comes together at the end and the mysteries are wrapped up in a nice Christmassy bow. Setting it in an isolated castle in the Scottish Highlands at Christmas is a nice contrast and creates a sense of foreboding.
I really like that we have returning characters from previous books as I find it's a shame when we grow to like characters in one book and they never appear again. I think it adds nice layers to future books as they become more developed and not one-dimensional.
Overall, another hit by Katy Watson and I hope to read more about the exploits of the three Dahlia's very soon!
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
December 20, 2024
A Christmas Eve wedding in a remote Scottish castle. What could be more romantic? Shame that the bride has pre wedding jitters that have nothing to do with the groom but with the feeling that the castle is, well, haunted and the ghost in question seems to have it in for her. It's also a shame that a once in a generation storm has snowed the family and first guests in and the rest of the world out with no phone signal, hardly any food except mince pies and canapes and one creaky generator. And it's a real shame that one of the guests has been murdered. On the other hand it's a very good thing the three Dahlias, Rosalind, Caro and Posy are there, along with Rosalind's retired policeman boyfriend and Caro's steady wife who can wrangle both a kitchen and a generator. But with the snowfall increasing, tensions racheting and danger increasing can they find the murderer in time to stop any more murders and save the wedding?
A delightfully Christmassy take on a classic locked in mystery with my three favourite detectives. Highly recommended.
A delightfully Christmassy take on a classic locked in mystery with my three favourite detectives. Highly recommended.
December 25, 2024
4.5/5 ⭐️
The fourth Three Dahlias mystery finds Posy, Caro, and Rosalind in Scotland for their friend Libby's wedding. She had written them saying strange things were happening so they are already on edge. Things become deadly when first, a mysterious body washes up on shore near the castle. Then, someone there for the wedding is murdered. Stranded at the castle by a storm, the Three Dahlias set out to find out who is the culprit.
Another enjoyable entry in the series! I enjoyed that the three significant others (Jack, Kit, and Annie) were there as well as I find them fun supporting characters. I really didn't see the whodunit coming either! It was a good mystery (in terms of investigating and clues), something this series has been really good at. I think I can see where the next book might go in terms of murder, but I can't wait to see! I always look forward to reading these when I see another one has been released.
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
The fourth Three Dahlias mystery finds Posy, Caro, and Rosalind in Scotland for their friend Libby's wedding. She had written them saying strange things were happening so they are already on edge. Things become deadly when first, a mysterious body washes up on shore near the castle. Then, someone there for the wedding is murdered. Stranded at the castle by a storm, the Three Dahlias set out to find out who is the culprit.
Another enjoyable entry in the series! I enjoyed that the three significant others (Jack, Kit, and Annie) were there as well as I find them fun supporting characters. I really didn't see the whodunit coming either! It was a good mystery (in terms of investigating and clues), something this series has been really good at. I think I can see where the next book might go in terms of murder, but I can't wait to see! I always look forward to reading these when I see another one has been released.
I received my copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
November 9, 2024
The fourth in the series, but Katy catches you up enough so that you understand who the three Dahlias are and how they work together. (I'd recommend reading the series, though, because it's very enjoyable!)
A romantic winter wedding at a remote Scottish castle turns out to be nothing of the kind - especially as the bride-to-be sends a note with the invitations saying that something isn't quite right. Ghost stories told by firelight, tales of ancient family feuds... and then in the morning they find a corpse, wearing the bride's dress and stolen family jewels. Cut off by a snowstorm, and with electricity and phone lines down, the Dahlias need to solve the murder and save their friend...
Beautifully twisty plot, lots of good misdirection, great chemistry between the sleuths (and it's lovely to see them with their partners), and a thoroughly good read.
A romantic winter wedding at a remote Scottish castle turns out to be nothing of the kind - especially as the bride-to-be sends a note with the invitations saying that something isn't quite right. Ghost stories told by firelight, tales of ancient family feuds... and then in the morning they find a corpse, wearing the bride's dress and stolen family jewels. Cut off by a snowstorm, and with electricity and phone lines down, the Dahlias need to solve the murder and save their friend...
Beautifully twisty plot, lots of good misdirection, great chemistry between the sleuths (and it's lovely to see them with their partners), and a thoroughly good read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 77 reviews