What do you think?
Rate this book


297 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 20, 2014
Hayley Lawson is a first time author and, for her first work, she has courageously chosen a huge and urgent topic: the civil war in Syria and its impact on the innocent chidren of the country. She has bitten off a massive chunk of tragedy for her first effort and sometimes it's almost more than she can chew. The sheer weight of the events she describes strains her nascent capabilities, resulting in a somewhat uneven narrative. But Hayley's great strength is her emotional commitment to her subject. She sees the plight of these children with a mother's heart and she relentlessly portrays the violence, chaos and sheer agony caused by the conflict. Several times, I had to put the book down, saying to myself, "Enough! Enough!" Hayley's professed aim is to evoke an emotional response from the reader, to make the reader feel with the children. On this level, the book is a success. The suffering of the children drives this book into the "Must Read" column.
The book does have limitations. First, it fails to develop the context in which the conflict occurs and so, while it tells the reader how to feel, it does not give him a framework in which to think. It begins with the chaos of a bloodbath in which unidentified soldier hunt down and murder schoolchildren. Chaos and disorientation can be a useful device, but the book never moves beyond them. Everything is chaos and the conflict never comes into focus.
Second, the book does not explore the way in which the different children, Muslim and Christian, think about the conflict. The failure of modern, secular Westerners to recognize the essential role of religion in the Middle East is part of the ongoing tragedy of the region. It makes us incapable of understanding the people and their motivations and of developing effective strategies to deal with them.
Third, the chief characters, a boy and girl who are each 14-15 years old, should be more mature than their Western counterparts. But the mental world they inhabit, aside from a puppy love subplot which doesn't really work, is largely indistinguishable from that of the younger children. These characters are old enough, and should be canny enough, to know what's going on in their immediate surroundings. But they appear completely baffled by, even unaware of, the political and religious conflicts engulfing them.
Nevertheless, the emotional strength of this book overcomes its limitations. It demands to be read.

is released? 
