For fans of Jia Tolentino and Amanda Montell, a probing and lively exploration of the unlikely dwellings we regard on reality TV — and what they say about American history, modern life, and the architecture of our desires.
People like reality TV. There’s been a lot written about the cult of celebrity, how this "reality" angle draws us in through a mix of voyeurism and relatability. But when we look at the houses on these shows, what are we seeing? Predominantly, multi-million-dollar single-family homes in areas that forcibly removed minority groups and mimic the style of a whitewashed age. Why do we watch and covet these conservative homes, while professing to want lives unbound by heteronormative patriarchy and outside of suburban fantasia?
Jack posits two main that our relationships with these shows (and social media) have conflated our physical dwellings with the spaces projected onto and projected out from our screens to create a ‘physical-digital hybrid home’ that we see as representative of our actual home; and that what we actually covet when we covet these houses is safety and security, not the specifics of the styles being sold.
Dream Facades focuses on seven reality TV Selling Sunset; The Kardashians; The Real World; The Bachelor; Trading Spaces; The Real Housewives of Atlanta; and Fire Island, and their specific associated architectural style. Morley takes us through reality TV’s labyrinthine properties to illuminate what makes us covet these spaces and devour these shows, and what that says about America, ourselves, and the future of design.
Maybe it’s because my main hobby (reading) can be cognitively demanding, but I’ve never really gotten into prestige TV. I like reality shows, the dumber and more toxic the better. I want to watch beautiful, ridiculous people search for love and feud with rivals and (more often than not) end up in legal trouble. So this whip-smart book inspired by reality television represents a true marrying of my interests.
Reality shows here serve more as a jumping-off point for thoughts on architectural history, American society, and philosophical theory than the main topic of focus. The Bachelor’s mansion inspires a fascinating chapter about the history of “Mediterranean-style” homes, while home makeover shows yield thoughts on gentrification and born-again Christianity. For that reason, I think the appeal of this book is not limited to die-hard reality TV fans.
This was one of the most interesting nonfiction books I’ve read in a while and I would love to read more by this author.
Thank you to the publisher for giving me access to an eARC of this book!
Fascinating and well-researched, Dream Facades: The Cruel Architecture of Reality TV by Jack Balderrama Morley dives deep into the world of reality TV and why people love it, the desire for homeownership, popular home styles, real estate's dark past of redlining and steering, and the adverse effects on people of color and the LGBTQ+ community. Focusing on seven reality TV shows, Selling Sunset, The Kardashians, The Real World, The Bachelor, Trading Spaces, The Real Housewives of Atlanta, and Fire Island, along with their associated architectural styles, the author reveals the appeal of these spaces and why people keep tuning in.
I'm not sure quite what I expected when I requested Morley's Dream Facades, but my curiosity was piqued by two things: wanting to know why people watch reality TV and how this media could influence future design. As someone in real estate, reading this book was a cross between professional inspiration and cultural analysis.
What I enjoyed most about Dream Facades was all the historical perspective on house styles, the discussions on important pieces of legislation shaped by our biases, and a look into the start of reality TV and its continued impact. Considering my love of history and how I like to analyze popular shows from my childhood, this is likely no surprise. I took copious notes and added numerous reference books to my already enormous to-be-read pile. I also appreciated getting to know more about a television genre that I know little about, but that my children mention.
The only place I struggled was with the conclusion of the book. The passion Morley has for returning stolen land and the need to develop a process for accomplishing that task is clear, and it's not the role of this reviewer to defend or argue against it. While it ties into their larger discussion of how the multi-million dollar homes featured on reality TV are in areas where people of color were forcibly removed, and how coveting them goes against our professed desire to live "unbound by heteronormative patriarchy and outside of suburban fantasia," these statements are not as well-developed as the rest of the text, ending the book in a way that is more like, "we can do it if we try" instead of the thoughtfully crafted and spectacularly articulated information throughout. If I were yearning for a strong call to action, I didn't find it.
That aside, I would read this book again, alongside some of the resources cited, as Morley brings the reader through a riveting media study.
I requested a copy of this book from NetGalley. This review contains my honest opinions, which I have not been compensated for in any way.
What connects the history of public housing in America, a novel about interracial romance, Native Americans getting displaced, and 'The Real Housewives of Atlanta'? A lot, apparently. This book is a fascinating deep dive into the way houses and homes figure in reality TV shows. There's so much research that went into it, which is very impressive, but not as impressive as the author's almost encyclopaedic knowledge of various reality TV shows and their multiple seasons. When a writer has a personal interest in the topic, the passion shines through.
What I liked about having my attention drawn to the setting is that it is not something the audience would usually do, being busy watching drama unfold as they will. But the houses and sets are intentional too, even if we don't notice them. I haven't watch a lot of reality TV (some 'Terrace House,' a little 'Singles Inferno,' a lot of 'Drag Race,' that one viral episode of 'Temptation Island'—"Montoya por favor!"—one season of 'Queer Eye,' and a few episode of 'MTV Cribs' or '16 and pregnant' back in the day) but I might start so I can see what he means about the types of backdrops used and what aspirations they symbolise.
Houses are revealed here to be desires made visible; what someone (single, divorced, straight, gay, participant, voyeur) might wish for in love, career, or social validation is shown through their pursuit of home ownership or a specific kind of living space that externalises their ideal self. On the national scale, perhaps even the international scale, why do we the audience keep watching these shows or trad wife content? What do they give us, what secret desires do they speak to? This book breaks down in great detail the possibility that we keep feeding the entertainment machine because of historical forces so massive they're invisible despite being all-pervasive.
Thank you Netgalley for the ARC; all opinions are my own.
So brilliant how it draws you in with what seems like a cheeky premise, and before you have a minute to ponder whether the guy’s actually watched drag race, it hits you with an incredibly researched and theorized account of the history and state of America’s relationship to the home. The scope and approach reminded me a bit of Naomi Klein’s Doppelganger. I will be thinking about this book for months.