I wanted this book simply for the illustrations alone.
This book was so well put together and held so many little stories. It was so easy to follow and had great translations of words and the accompanying art/pictures/scripts were neatly added to the explanations and retellings.
It can be debated that the chapters could have been a bit longer and be a bit more in depth, but for me it worked well. Wonderful book.
3.5 For the average greek/roman classics and medieval enjoyer most of these stories would already be known to the reader. Some of the chapters tell a general list of what things mean and where it can be found, making the chapters rather dull or very short. The illumination are amazing and were also the primary source as to why I initially bought this book.
This is the most beautiful book that I ever had in my possession, and perhaps also the most beautiful book that I ever held in my hands. The visual accomplishment is just breathtaking. The content is also very interesting, but not much more. The individual chapters are summaries of some of the famous individual stories from the Middle Ages, or groups of stories, archetypes, tropes etc. that the reader will be mostly familiar with if above a certain age. Nevertheless, reading through this book while admiring the illustrations was a wonderful experience.
I bought this because the book itself is a tempting article, with a gorgeous cover and sumptuously reproduced illustrations that are, for obvious reasons, the focus of the text. It is rather amusing to note that all the manuscript art within shares the same ‘Baby’s First Attempt’ aesthetic. It’s weird that within that no one seemed to progress technique in art for like, several centuries.
For the most part, I knew all the cultural, mythological, and actual history that Westwell reproduces in bite-size, unstylish chunks. For this is, at the end of the day, a small coffee table book, designed to flip through and marvel at what people in 1340 thought feet looked like. I did learn that unicorn is a mis-translation of a Hebrew word for ox, which explains why they showed up so much in the Bible. This might be a nice gift or display book, but it is not one for serious scholars or enthusiastic amateurs on any of the subjects within. Which is fine! Not everything has to be.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
If you love mediaeval illumination, this book is a feast. It covers a huge period, focusing mainly on the 14th and 15th centuries, discussing manuscripts collected together by broad themes: love stories, bestiaries, histories, and the like. In the process it also elaborates the underlying stories, so that the illumination makes sense. A lot of these are intricate and deserving whole books in themselves (which many have had, of course): different manuscripts use different variants of the same underlying myths. I was unfamiliar with most of the detail.
But it's the illustrations that are the jewels, of course. Westwell works at the British Library, and so has access to one of the world's largest collections of illuminated manuscripts. The individual letters, borders, and marginal drawings are a complete joy to explore, often with several manuscripts on a common theme set side by side to show the evolution of style and the ways in which the illuminators were thinking about their subjects. Together with the often rude and/or surreal images common to the period, this is a book I will be coming back t time and again.
I bought this book because the first word in the title is "Dragons", and was disappointed to find ... um... one? dragon story... no "Magic" really, but plenty "Heroes and Myths" So if you´re looking for dragons (pictures or any information) look somewhere else. This book is mostly summaries of stories, by the time I finished reading it, I had forgotten most of them. The title should be just "The Medieval Art of Storytelling" withouth the first 4 words. Not exactly what I was looking for, but I enjoyed the lovely pictures from old manuscripts. And it will look good on the bookshelf :)
The illuminated manuscripts were superb; the quality was better than any other book I’ve seen. However, the storytelling was quite bland. It was interesting to learn about some of the stories in medieval literature — and I found some new books to explore — but it was clearly written for a broad public. I would’ve liked to see more analysis/depth to the stories and the books themselves. Looking forward to reading de Hamel’s manuscript book as a nice counter!
Description of various Medieval stories and legends is too brief, although the accompanying images of manuscripts and illustrations were beautiful; would've preferred a more detailed telling of each story for those who are unfamiliar with them, and a deeper exploration on their origin and background, particularly their connection/basis to historical facts.
A really accessibly written introduction, but what I really appreciated as an artist was the quality of the book as an object itself which really did justice to its subject matter. Printed on good quality matte paper which shows off the illuminations and illustrations perfectly no horrible gloss which I find often darkens print reproductions.
This is the kind of book that only works when you read a physical copy. The author covers 40 different illuminated manuscripts from the medieval period. Each has multiple images of the various panels, the basics of the story told, and a short history of what is known about it. Really enjoyed this one, if you like looking at illuminated manuscripts in museums you will find a lot here to like.