Not enough superlatives for this one.
I avidly read the Tillerman cycle (seven books) several years ago, and since then, have constantly recommended them to others. My sister finally took me up on that, and two volumes in, agrees that Voigt and her characters and stories are worth the praise. However, she listened to 'Homecoming' and 'Dicey's Song,' and raved about Barbara Caruso's narration.
So now, thanks to my sister, I have had the treat of revisiting a good friend, as well as seeing (hearing) that friend from a new perspective. Caruso does do a stellar job, and 'Homecoming,' if anything, was even more powerful and engrossing the second time around.
My sister noted that the basic premise of 'Homecoming' is quite similar to that of 'The Boxcar Children.' It's a 'Boxcar Children' with profound depth and character development, a novel whose categorization as YA is far too limiting. It is a book about and for children, but just as much it is a book for adults, and to a lesser degree, about adults. Voigt's writing is lyrical and evocative, and her characters are unique and true.
The chief character is Dicey Tillerman, a thirteen-year-old whose distraught, depressed mother abandons Dicey, her sister, and two brothers in the parking lot of a shopping mall one summer afternoon in the 1980s. The Tillermans had been escaping hard times on Cape Cod by driving to the home of an aunt the children had never met in Bridgeport, Connecticut.
Dicey is a self-assured girl with great common sense, extraordinary intelligence, stubborn will power, and untapped reserves. She turns her family's bleak circumstances around in a journey as compelling as the 'Odyssey'--a journey full of unlikely adventures, good fortune and bad, kind strangers, evil strangers, strangers between those extremes, relatives who try to care but really don't, and relatives who don't seem to care but really do.
Those strangers and relatives, and especially Dicey's younger siblings, James, Maybeth, and Sammy, are deep, full characters who have stayed with me as I wander through my own interior journeys, reflecting on this marvelous book. At the end of 'Homecoming,' the Tillermans end up on the eastern shore of Maryland, but they will keep travelling through your mind, and they are likely to persuade you to read more of the Tillerman cycle.
Highly recommended for sixth graders and up.