Sealey Challenge 2026: 9/31
I was somewhat familiar with Matejka's work before reading this as I have read his poems here and there and enjoyed his editorial career with Poetry magazine. However, this was my first full collection of his works.
Be Easy was an interesting look at the evolution of Matejka's poetry, showing both the similarities and differences in his style across the years. I noticed recurring words and themes throughout the collection, which has now made me think I could pick his poetry from a line-up! I thought it was also an interesting choice to arrange the sections beginning with his newest poems and then the next section starting with his earliest and working forward through time. It hinted to the kind of back and forth narrative he had through many of his works. The individual sections also felt carefully curated, and I could understand why they were brought together here. That said, there were definitely some hits and misses for me. Editorially, I appreciate how cohesive this was and how there was a genuine flow to the collection which can often be difficult to maintain with these larger new and selected collections.
My biggest takeaway from is was that Matejka writes about relatable ideas and has some beautiful language, but I rarely felt the poems hit me as emotionally deeply as I wanted them to. There is a lot of circling and returning to ideas throughout this collection, and sometimes I felt like I was waiting for the poems to finally land. Of the selected poems, I was most impressed with the section on The Big Smoke and hope to pick it up in the future. However, I'm not sure that I would prioritize the others.
As I was reading, I wrote down my thoughts on each section and kind of a section rating to help me better reflect on my thoughts. I have adapted them for here so that there's a more comprehensive understanding of my rating:
New Poems — 3/5
Beautiful language, but didn't stir enough emotion for me. I am struggling to find the guiding theme connecting these poems, which makes some of them feel out of place. This was a bit disjointed.
The Devil's Garden — 4/5
Pulled me in a bit more. The poems felt more personal, and I've found a few poems that really shined.
Mixology — 3.5/5
The more personal poems were definitely the strongest, although I have to admit that some of these went completely over my head. There were a few where I just really didn't get it!
The Big Smoke — 5/5
By far my favorite section! I didn't know this was inspired by a true story and am very intrigued by the full work!
Map to the Stars — 3.5/5
There were some interesting poems here, but I found the section more thematically disorganized. I especially didn't connect with the poems about Prince and feel like I missed something with the way they were scattered maybe strategically?
Standing on the Verge and Maggot Brain — 1/5
This one was an absolute NOPE! I truly do not understand what was going on in some of these poems. There are bits that connect to the other works thematically, but the language in the poems themselves lost me.
Somebody Else Sold the World — 3.5/5
I wasn't particularly interested in the love poems, but I enjoyed some of the others. The ending poems gripped me a little more.
To sum up my thoughts, I appreciated getting to sample so much of Matejka's work and understand a bit more about how his style has developed and evolved over time. I personally think that's kind of the point of this specific type of poetry selection as it's almost a sampler of sorts that leaves you with the decision to explore more. For me, I will definitely be picking up at least one of the full works in the future!
Thank you to the publisher, Liveright, for an e-ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions shared in this review are my own!