A best-selling novelist turns to memoir in this compelling story of a son’s love, a mother’s obsession, and the malevolent grip of the past.
Indian American author Manil Suri grew up in a large crumbling apartment in Bombay (now Mumbai) which his parents, who were Hindu, shared with three Muslim families. Their single room, at times a refuge from the religious and territorial tensions pervading the apartment, was also a prison that held them captive—his parents stuck in an unhappy marriage, the author unable to explore the dawning realization he might be gay. At age 20, Suri managed to break free and come to the US, where he finally found the freedom to embrace his sexuality and find a life partner. But the room, which still held his parents hostage, kept wrenching him back to Bombay.
By now real estate prices had risen so much that neighbors had begun conspiring to take over the room, causing Suri’s parents to dig in even more. Eventually it was only his mother, Prem, left, who had staked all her happiness on her son but was unable to escape the room’s hold on her. When a rash of mysterious incidents seemed to beset the room, Suri realized how little time he had left to convince Prem that a happier life might await beyond the four walls that both enthralled and imprisoned her.
This remarkable, gripping memoir explores how an abode can shape destiny, while delving into the difficult question of how much to prioritize our parents’ happiness over our own. Inspired by over 2,700 letters the author wrote home over three decades, it is ultimately a testament to the abiding, unbreakable bond tying a son to his mother.
Manil Suri is a distinguished mathematics professor at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. Author of three acclaimed novels, including The Death of Vishnu, he is a former contributing opinion writer at the New York Times, for which he has written several widely read pieces on mathematics. He lives in Silver Spring, Maryland.
3.75* This was a book about Manil's relationship with his mom more than it was a book about Manil's life. I somehow wish we spent more time with Manil in the room in Bombay, or with Manil as he was grappling with the 'everyone is responsible for their own lives' conundrum he faced as he moved to the US. But it was nevertheless enlightening to learn about his experience growing up sharing a room with both of his parents and an apartment with what sounds like the most obnoxious people to have ever lived. I'm very appreciative that he shared his life in this book, and all i can say is that I found every detail of his early life very interesting.
Overall I think Manil does a good job at presenting and synthesising many key challenges of the life of a homosexual immigrant child of Indian parents, particularly the dilemma of choosing whether to stay or go, the startling culture shock he had as he first went back home after leaving for university, his duty to his parents vs his duty to himself, homosexuality in India class division and the limitations imposed by ones finances, marriages and many aspects of just quotidian life as it used to be for him in Bombay.
Memoirs are revealing and must take courage to write, sharing one’s life with strangers. Duty and love intertwine here with love the seemingly stronger branch. The descriptions of life in India—including people, places, things, and feelings—is quite vivid. The descriptions of picking up a new life in the States is less vivid, but still clear. A moving read.
I very much enjoyed reading this book. Manil is a friend and fellow mathematician. It was quite interesting getting to know a lot of new aspects of his life through this memoir. Even without knowing him personally, it would be a great read, focused on balancing life between two very different cultures, and trying to fulfill the familial duties at a distance.
Being an only child, an Indian son, homosexual, and the child of Hindu parents stuck in a loveless marriage, Manil Suri faced challenges.
In his memoir, A ROOM IN BOMBAY, Suri talks about his life and how it unspooled in Bombay, then stretched across the world from a Pittsburgh university to one in Maryland, with trips and vacations to New York City, London, Paris, California and Delhi. He meets the challenges of his life, crashes and burns a few times, has a loving partner, and learns that he can never quite leave home.
Home was an apartment in Razia Mansion, where Suri’s father, Ram, and his mother, Prem, moved in 1958. He was born a few months later, and they were a tight unit. They shared the apartment with three other families (all Muslims), and the many quarrels and arguments involved the refrigerator, marking floor territory, using and cleaning the toilets, and verbal spats among their visitors. Suri had shame for their situation but also was extraordinarily loyal to his parents. The machinations of maintaining this room were complex. It was ramshackle and needed repair, yet they were all bound to it. It was home.
Suri’s growing understanding and acceptance of his homosexuality is quite naturally a huge focus of his adolescence and early manhood. Prem, affectionately called Mammy, is able to somewhat comprehend what his choices meant because she read and had gotten an education, but Ram did not. It seems that Suri has a single regret about his father’s death --- that he did not speak openly with him and answer questions.
Suri returns again and again to Bombay during the 11 years after Ram’s passing. He moves Prem to America to live with him, but then she goes back to India. He visits her and the extended family, and he sees changes in Bombay, Delhi and the surrounding areas. Amidst the uncertainty of Prem’s declining health, he is steadfast in his commitment to her, finding solutions and new paths for her contentment. However, she does not always take them. During a final airplane trip to Bombay, Suri reflects on the “what-ifs” of her life. Her choices gave him life, but would her hypothetical choices have paralleled his? He does not know.
The obligations of an Indian son to his parents are immense. Social interactions, Bollywood plots, cultural and religious norms, and fables from Ramayana are all reminders of filial duty that exemplar sons are meant to achieve. After his move to America, Suri learned the precept that “everyone’s responsible for their own life,” which sounded liberating and promising. But it was not so easy to abandon his parents.
The memories of card games sitting on the edge of the single bed, the joy he recalls in his parents' faces on the balcony as he would return home from school, their shoulders lifting as they recognized him in the crowd --- Suri’s life felt bound to them and to the room in Bombay. He thought he needed to repay the “surging, overpowering, all-engulfing love” from his childhood. He was supportive and generous beyond measure, and he needed that responsibility to come to an honorable close.
In an effort to make the distance between himself and his parents more bearable, Suri writes letters --- more than 2,700 of them, all addressed to Prem. They show the richness, honesty and humor of his life. You will remember A ROOM IN BOMBAY long after you put it down as you consider your own understanding of home.
A Room in Bombay: A Memoir by Manil Suri is a thoughtful and deeply personal account of identity, family, and self-discovery. Through memories of his childhood and youth in Bombay, Suri reflects on growing up in a traditional Indian household, his love for the city that shaped him, and his journey toward understanding and accepting his sexuality.
What makes the memoir particularly compelling is the author's honesty and sensitivity. He writes with warmth about his family and vividly captures the atmosphere of Bombay, bringing its streets, homes, and social dynamics to life. His reflections on belonging, migration, and cultural expectations are both intimate and universal, making the book relatable even to readers whose experiences differ greatly from his own.
Suri's prose is elegant and reflective, balancing personal anecdotes with deeper insights into identity, love, and the search for acceptance. The memoir offers a nuanced portrait of life between cultures and the challenges of staying true to oneself while navigating family and societal expectations.
A moving and insightful read, A Room in Bombay is recommended for anyone interested in memoirs, LGBTQ+ narratives, and stories that explore the complex relationship between place, identity, and personal growth.
A ROOM BIG ENOUGH FOR LOVE -- Imagine being holed up in a 400 square foot one-room apartment for twenty years. That was Manil Suri until he fled Bombay for the U.S., where he found enough space and freedom to grow and be himself. A gay mathematician, with a gift for writing. If the room in Bombay confined Suri, it confined and defined his parents even more. Because they shared a kitchen and a couple restrooms with three other households, the Suris often found themselves at odds with their scheming neighbors and a mischievous white cat. Nevertheless, there was plenty of love in those 400 square feet. This book is a love letter to Suri's late mother, Prem, who was funny, outrageous, a complainer, a martyr, a booster, a critic. Suri writes with affection and a wry wit, deftly chronicling trials and tribulations. This book will definitely make you laugh and it may make you cry. A mother's love can be suffocating but it sure beats the alternative. Suri is a gifted storyteller whose punch-lines are both funny and profound. A delight to read!
A Room in Bombay is a well-written memoir with vivid descriptions and honest storytelling. Manil Suri paints a detailed picture of his childhood, family dynamics, and life in Bombay, and there is no denying the care and authenticity with which the story is told.
That said, I found myself a little disconnected from the narrative. One challenge with memoirs is that they often resonate more deeply when you’re already familiar with the author or have a strong reason to be invested in their life story. Since I didn’t know much about Manil Suri beforehand, some parts felt less engaging and occasionally slow-paced for me.
The book is insightful and thoughtfully written, but it didn’t fully hold my attention throughout.
Overall, a decent read—informative and sincere, but not one that left a lasting impression on me.
An interesting memoir that calls to mind what we owe our parents throughout our lives, especially as they age and become infirm in body and mind. This was fascinating in terms of showing Indian culture and ways of life that are taken for granted there, versus America. But I didn't feel it was written in a way that made me especially understand the writer or his mother in depth - it felt emotionally subdued (which may also be a cultural difference that makes it tough for this American to fully empathize). I thought the strongest part of the book was toward the end, as mom is descending into dementia. Very scary, sad, and relatable. Won in a Goodreads giveaway - thanks, Goodreads!
5/5. The prose is so beautiful and easy to follow. Although the book is centered around the room Manil grew up in, this is mainly a love letter from the son to his mother for her love and sacrifice. It conveys the complexity of family dynamic in South Asian families while highlighting the tension amongst the neighbors paralleled to the country's politics. I can't wait to read his debut novel and dive deeper in the culture of my neighbors to the west.
Manil Suri describes growing up in his family apartment among toxic neighbors and a home in shambles. His parents are stuck in the room for years and years with a fear of moving for so many reasons. This story is also so much about Manil's love and support for his mother until her death. It is very honest and poignant with excellent descriptions of difficult situations. You also learn a lot about Indian culture.
I was sobbing in my car as I listened to the end of this book. This was a raw and honest memoir. I felt the love he had for his mother even as I thought he was selfish and could have done more for her towards the end. This was a joy to read.
A beautiful, honest memoir - written with such honesty yet lending enough grace and dignity to the complex family dynamics, the dilemmas, the fatigue and the unconditional love.
Anyone who has lived in Mumbai might just connect a bit more. Recommended read.
Very rarely reading a book written by an international student. Got me thinking a lot about my own parents who live away and my duties/responsibilities.
An autobiography, primarily dedicated to the author's mother and his long-term care for her. A vivid description of her living in one room in an old building in Bombay for more than fifty years.