Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Better Mother

Rate this book
A woman ends up pregnant after a casual fling, but the father's girlfriend has much more sinister intentions in this plot-driven suspense debut.

A modern spin on Fatal Attraction meets The Hand that Rocks the Cradle, perfect for fans of The Last Mrs. Parrish.


Still recovering from a devastating breakup, 34-year-old Savannah Mitchell has finally managed to put her life back together when she gets the shock of her life—after a brief fling with a man named Max, she is pregnant.

When she gets in touch to tell him, he reveals that he’s just gotten back together with his ex, Madison, and he will need time to break it to her. Surprisingly, Madison isn’t upset—in fact, she’s excited, and wants to help.

Max insists Madison has the best of intentions, but Savannah finds her efforts—popping by uninvited, demanding lifestyle changes, and pretty much trying to take over the pregnancy—anything but helpful. When Savannah finally stands up for herself, Madison’s treatment of her goes from casually cruel to downright dangerous.

All Savannah wanted to do was form a friendly co-parenting relationship with the father of her child—but his new girlfriend obviously has much more sinister plans in mind.

She has no plans to co-parent at all.

336 pages, Paperback

First published February 10, 2026

213 people are currently reading
22722 people want to read

About the author

Jennifer van der Kleut

1 book171 followers
Jennifer van der Kleut (née McBride) is an award-winning former journalist of both print and digital publications, including the D.C. affiliate of ABC7 News.

A graduate of San Jose State University, she spent most of her life in the San Francisco Bay Area before moving to the Northern Virginia suburbs of D.C., where she currently lives with her husband and two sons.

For nearly a decade, she was the lead singer of the Bay Area-based band SweetDuration, and performed with artists like Jason Mraz, Big Country, Chantal Kreviazuk, and Stabbing Westward.

When she’s not writing, she loves going to the beach with her family, going to concerts with her girlfriends, and getting lost in the pages of a book.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
450 (27%)
4 stars
688 (42%)
3 stars
350 (21%)
2 stars
103 (6%)
1 star
27 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 446 reviews
Profile Image for Nilufer Ozmekik.
3,172 reviews61.8k followers
March 6, 2026
Wow. There’s a new thriller queen in the house. This book is fast-paced, twisty, deeply unsettling—in the best, shout-into-a-pillow way—and impossible to put down. It reads like a treadmill set to sprint: heart-pounding chapters, razor-sharp cliffhangers, and just enough menace between scenes to make you demolish a family-size bag of popcorn. If you love the high-tension vibes of Freida McFadden, add this to the top of your list. And Hollywood, if you’re listening: please option this. (Casting wish: Olivia Cooke as Madison. She can do “girlfriend from hell” with unnerving precision—Capricorn fire with Aries chaos.)

The hook: Savannah Mitchell is clawing her way back after a brutal breakup and the loss of her dream job. Six months into a new agency role and finally settled in a small one-bedroom, she’s convinced she’s turning a corner. Then life throws the cruelest curveball: after a brief fling with Max, Savannah discovers she’s pregnant—right as Max reunites with his ex, Madison. Red flag: didn’t he mention Madison’s jealous streak?

When Madison insists on meeting, Savannah decides to rip the Band-Aid. At first, Madison presents like a polished Stepford-adjacent dream: poised, pretty, overly tactile, and way too invested. What starts as “helpful” quickly turns invasive. Madison knows Savannah’s address (and uses the buzzer liberally). She brings groceries and “remedy” teas, drops off books thick with highlighted “advice,” and somehow keeps tabs on everything: Uber trips, meeting schedules, girls’ nights with Ellie—even Savannah’s food orders. The texts pile up, urgent and relentless, like a fire alarm you can’t switch off.

Small things begin to vanish—most chillingly, the ultrasound photo—and Madison’s language shifts from “your baby” to “our child,” as if Savannah is merely the surrogate for Madison’s fantasy life. The tighter Savannah tries to draw boundaries (without detonating her co-parenting plan with Max), the more Madison constricts the loop: surveillance masquerading as concern, gaslighting dressed as friendship. Is this obsession? A calculated campaign? Or something darker rooted in Madison’s past?

What makes the book sing is the escalation. Every chapter raises the stakes without breaking the spell of plausibility; the author nails how control can creep in dressed as caretaking. The themes—stalking, motherhood, bodily autonomy, digital surveillance, emotional exploitation—are threaded with nerve-scraping precision. Savannah is a heroine you ache for: smart enough to spot the red flags, human enough to hope for the best. Madison, meanwhile, is the kind of villain who weaponizes niceness. (You will invent new curse words. I did.)

Craft-wise, it’s tight: crisp prose, short scenes that pop, and reveals that land like trapdoors. The office politics are deliciously petty, the best-friend beats with Ellie give oxygen, and the final act delivers jolts without devolving into nonsense. Yes, it’s disturbing. Yes, you’ll keep reading at 2 a.m. anyway.

Overall: a run-run-RUN thriller—nail-biting, compulsively readable, and tailor-made for a weekend binge. I’ve officially added this author to my auto-approve thriller queens list. If you want something delicious, sinister, and instantly addictive, this is your next read.

A very huge thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for sharing this unputdownable thriller with me in exchange for my honest thoughts.

Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:

medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
Profile Image for Hades ( Disney's version ).
259 reviews71 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
February 21, 2026
Thank you Netgalley and Dreamscape Media for an ALC of The Better Mother by Jennifer van de kleut


Life is unpredictable, crazy, and run by the wealthy.. just like this book. Which is what makes it so shockingly terrifying. I will point out every time, how extremely talented of a writer one must be.. To allow the reader to have a good idea of what's to come, while still remaining all engrossed and entertained. That's what we have here and it's absolutely riveting.. if this one's not on my 2026 top 10, it'll be number #11. Very, very good, definitely worthy of a Limited Series on Netflix, or movie. I couldn't help but think how equally amazing this would be on screen throughout my read.


If you're a thriller fan one of your missions for 2026 should definitely be getting your hands on a copy of this book! I was hooked like a Floridian Bass, and I don't think I'll be the only one.




Until next time 
Hades
🩵
Profile Image for Linzie (suspenseisthrillingme).
915 reviews1,036 followers
February 27, 2026
OMG! A blindingly fast-paced novel of sinister manipulations and despicable underhanded motives, The Better Mother was a wild rollercoaster ride that I couldn’t put down. Starting off with a bang, the rest of the book was filled with ever increasing dread and nonstop action. You see, this debut was a brilliant combo of Freida McFadden’s twists and turns and Kaira Rouda’s deliciously unhinged characters. Using them to turn a simple unplanned pregnancy into an over-the-top disaster, I was beyond riveted by the root-for-able narrator and her detestable enemies. After all, this one-sitting read was everything I love in an inhale-able popcorn thriller. With cat-and-mouse games, a character you’ll love to hate, and plenty of nefarious schemes, it had everything I could want plus just a little bit more.

All said and done, Ms. van der Kleut hit it out of the park on her very first go. Twisty, taut, and filled with high-stakes chills and thrills, the domestic drama in this unputdownable novel would give any soon-to-be mother some serious nightmares. I mean, how would you like for your pregnancy to turn into a Fatal Attraction-esque horror show? Between the dueling threats of control and obsession, there wasn’t a moment of downtime from beginning to end. Don’t get me wrong, you have to be in the mood for a book where you need to suspend all disbelief. Once you do that, though, you’ll be utterly addicted. So before you pick this one up, be sure to have all of your chores finished and with plenty of time to read. After all, this relentless tour-de-force will surely keep your eyes glued to the pages. Rating of 5 stars.

P.S. Dear author, can we please have a sequel? I’m sure there could be more to this story… After all, while it was perfectly wrapped up, I still want more time with Savannah!

SYNOPSIS:

Still recovering from a devastating breakup, 34-year-old Savannah Mitchell has finally managed to put her life back together when she gets the shock of her life—after a brief fling with a man named Max, she is pregnant.

When she gets in touch to tell him, he reveals that he’s just gotten back together with his ex, Madison, and he will need time to break it to her. Surprisingly, Madison isn’t upset—in fact, she’s excited, and wants to help.

Max insists Madison has the best of intentions, but Savannah finds her efforts—popping by uninvited, demanding lifestyle changes, and pretty much trying to take over the pregnancy—anything but helpful. When Savannah finally stands up for herself, Madison’s treatment of her goes from casually cruel to downright dangerous.

All Savannah wanted to do was form a friendly co-parenting relationship with the father of her child—but his new girlfriend obviously has much more sinister plans in mind.

She has no plans to co-parent at all.

Thank you Jennifer van der Kleut and Crooked Lane Books for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.

PUB DATE: February 10, 2026

Content warning: pregnancy, stalking, catfishing, gaslighting, miscarriage, kidnapping, violence, gun violence, blood, mention of: blackmail, infidelity
Profile Image for Jayne.
1,066 reviews728 followers
February 26, 2026


Did I just listen to a "good/bad" Lifetime movie audiobook?

This compulsively readable and OTT domestic/psychological thriller about pregnancy, obsession, and control was engaging and completely bonkers -- all at the same time.

Even though I absolutely/positively wanted to push the STOP button on my phone, I was unable to do so.

➡️ Was the book's storyline high art? No.

➡️ Was it realistic? Not even slightly.

➡️ Were the coincidences too convenient? Yes.

➡️ Was the dialogue too melodramatic? Yes.

➡️ But was it entertaining? TOTALLY!!!!!!

I listened to the audiobook narrated by Xe Sands.

I usually am not a fan of Xe Sands' narrations, but this narration was one of her better ones.

If you enjoy "good/bad" Lifetime movies as much as I do, this was a very impressive debut by author Jennifer van der Kleut.
Profile Image for Dennis.
1,107 reviews2,072 followers
November 30, 2025
I have never wanted to 🔪 a character more in my life.

Jennifer van der Kleut’s debut thriller, THE BETTER MOTHER, immediately hooked me with his intense and intriguing cover, but I was a bit apprehensive since “mommy thrillers” tend to frustrate me. This book is NO “mommy thriller,” it is so much more. Thank you @crookedlanebooks for sending me this 🦇 💩 thriller!

Savannah Mitchell is trying to rebuild her life after a painful breakup when a brief fling with Max leaves her pregnant. The timing could not be worse. Max has reconciled with his ex, Madison, who arrives in Savannah’s life with a perceived innocence and smile, but also an obsessive interest in the pregnancy. What begins as polite involvement quickly turns intrusive as Madison inserts herself into Savannah’s home, routines, and personal boundaries, all while presenting herself as helpful.

As Savannah tries to protect her privacy, Madison’s behavior darkens in ways that feel both calculated and unhinged. Small possessions disappear, conversations shift toward ownership of the baby, and Madison’s constant monitoring grows suffocating. The tension builds with precision, balancing emotional realism with high-stakes suspense. The story becomes a study in manipulation, control, and the danger lurking beneath manufactured kindness. It is addictive, unsettling, and impossible to stop reading once the spiral begins. THE BETTER MOTHER grabs you instantly with its sharp pacing, spiraling tension, and uncanny sense of dread. I was immediately hooked and read this book in two sittings. THE BETTER MOTHER starts with a hook but the level of suspense that escalates each chapter kept me on the edge of my seat. There will be characters you love and some you will want to 🔪, but one thing is for certain, this book is an absolute page turner! I read this book in two sittings and could not put it down. This book is one of the most FUN thrillers I’ve read in a while and is a Q1 2026 MUST READ. STARS: 5, PUB: 2/10/26
Profile Image for Andye.Reads.
971 reviews988 followers
February 1, 2026
DNF at 13%

The main character is too stupid to bear, and the audiobook narrator is sending me into a murderous spiral.

Update: put it on 2x and finished. This has to be one of the stupidest books I've ever read. I wish I had kept track of all the plot conveniences and utterly ridiculous characters, conversations, and situations. Honestly would've rooted for the villain if they weren't just as stupid as the MC.
Profile Image for Victoria (storieswithtorie).
209 reviews14 followers
February 3, 2026
The Better Mother was honestly so well done. It was one of those thrillers that actually made me squirm while reading, because the situations were so uncomfortable and intense, and the author did a great job making everything feel very real.

I could not stop rooting for Savannah. You just want her to catch a break so badly, and the deeper it goes, the more invested you get because the things happening to her are genuinely shocking and unsettling in a way that gets under your skin. It’s messy, tense, and just stressful in the best thriller way.

My only reason for not giving this five stars is that it felt a little longer than it needed to be. There were a few parts that could’ve been tightened up, but overall, I flew through it and couldn’t wait to see how it all played out.

If you like domestic thrillers that feel creepy, twisty, and make you feel personally involved, this one is definitely worth picking up.
Profile Image for April.
700 reviews195 followers
February 13, 2026
Anytime a story can bring this many emotions out of me, I have to consider it a great read! These were some of the most frustrating characters I’ve ever read about but I mean that in the most addictive, intriguing way possible. I was hooked & invested!

The red flags were flagging from very early on in the story! Savannah was just mistaken manipulation for kindness, as Madison absolutely gave “I’m crazy and I’m taking your baby” vibes from the first time she was mentioned! What I didn’t expect of how many twists & turns it took to get to the root of what was really happening. & let’s just say that something sinister was evidently lurking, but it was waaayyy deeper than I could have ever imagined! Nobody and I do mean nobody could be trusted in their story!

The audiobook narration was absolutely amazing! I have officially added this author and narrator into my “dig more in their catalog” list! Overall very well written, engaging & kept my attention the entire time. Thank you NetGalley & Dreamscape Media for an advanced listening copy.

Publication 🗓️ : 02.10.26

Professional Reader200 Book Reviews
Profile Image for Amy.
2,700 reviews2,035 followers
February 7, 2026

The Better Mother by Jennifer Van Der Kleut was exactly the kind of wildly entertaining, can’t look away domestic thriller I love most, the kind where you keep muttering “what the actual hell am I reading” while immediately turning the page. From the jump, the premise hooks you, but it’s the execution that really shines: fast paced, sharply written, and dripping with unease. I tore through this in just a couple sittings because the tension never lets up and the story constantly escalates in ways that feel both inevitable and completely bananas.

Savannah’s situation—unexpected pregnancy, messy emotional fallout, and an overly involved girlfriend who insists she “just wants to help”quickly slides from uncomfortable to deeply sinister. Madison is the kind of character you know is bad news but can’t stop watching, and the mounting sense of suspicion and dread is deliciously effective. The author does an excellent job of turning everyday interactions into something chilling, making even seemingly small moments feel loaded with threat.

This is a pure popcorn thriller in the best way: dark, sharp, and wildly fun, filled with awful characters you’ll absolutely despise, and that’s half the joy. If you love plot driven suspense, morally questionable people, and stories that feel like a modern mashup of Fatal Attraction and The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, this one delivers. Easily one of the more entertaining and compulsively readable thrillers I’ve picked up lately.
Profile Image for Susan.
744 reviews26 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
January 27, 2026
It had a solid premise, but the execution didn’t work for me. What starts out feeling like it might build into something tense and unsettling quickly becomes predictable, with characters who grew more frustrating the longer the story went on.

As the plot unfolded, the decisions made by the characters felt increasingly unrealistic, which made it hard to stay invested. Instead of tightening the tension as it moved toward the climax, the story became more irritating than suspenseful.

By the end, I wasn’t caught up in the outcome—I was just ready for it to be over.

That said, the audiobook itself has a definite bright spot. Xe Sands continues to be one of my favorite narrators. Her performance adds polish and emotional clarity to the material, even when the story itself falls short.
Profile Image for Savitri (IG: abookishcookie).
392 reviews8 followers
December 26, 2025
Special thanks to Jennifer and Crooked Lane Books for the gifted advance copy!
——

After coming out of a previous relationship where Savannah wanted a baby but the ex didn’t, Savannah now finds out she’s pregnant from a casual fling with Max. She decides to get in touch about it with Max, and to her surprise, he wants to be part of raising their child even though Max is back with his gf, Madison.

At first, Savannah is even more surprised that Madison is also welcoming with the idea of raising the baby. Madison is extra helpful with groceries and parenting advice until it gets to a point where Madison starts showing zero boundaries in Savannah’s life. Soon enough, Savannah’s life becomes a terrifying nightmare with Madison having a special agenda of her own.

This thriller is INTENSE, guys! We’re not talking about a character who’s just a little cray cray, we’re talking UNHINGED in full caps. Never have I wanted a fictional character to be unalived so deeply and I read a lot of dark books! There’s an astronomical level of gaslighting and manipulation inflicted by a character towards a heavily pregnant woman to the point of violence so this is perhaps a book to set aside if the reader is pregnant. The second half of the book had me holding my breath several times and the tension never relents until the grand finale.

This is Jennifer’s debut?! Well, now guess who’s my new favorite thriller author! 𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝐵𝑒𝑡𝑡𝑒𝑟 𝑀𝑜𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑟 is by far one of the best thriller books I’ve ever read tackling fierce motherhood. I can’t wait for its February release. Trust me, the buzz it’s been getting is worth every penny!!
Profile Image for Celeste Velocci (bookrecs_by_celeste).
471 reviews142 followers
January 20, 2026
What a great debut! Many thanks to Dreamscape Media and NetGalley for the ALC of The Better Mother. All opinions are my own.

First off - this one gave me such anxiety (in a good way) I actually felt the terror as my stomach churned while listening to this audiobook. I loved the main character and was really rooting for her. The plot was diabolical and seriously had me questioning all of humanity. This was definitely one of those psychological thrillers that makes you think and puts yourself in the main character’s shoes asking yourself what would you do in this particular situation.

After a casual hook up Savannah finds herself pregnant. When the father of her baby’s obsessive ex girlfriend enters the chat all things go haywire. A mix of obsession and being engulfed in what it feels to have a mother’s love you’ll be shocked as the twists and plot thickens. Like I mentioned above my stomach actually churned while listening - it was twisty and terrifying the lengths a crazy person will go to get their way.

The hype is real this one be sure to add it to your tbr it releases 2/10!
Profile Image for Jill.
386 reviews73 followers
February 15, 2026
THE BETTER MOTHER
By Jennifer van der Kleut
Narrated by Xe Sands

(3.5 stars, rounded down)

The narration by Xe Sands captured the emotions and nuances of this twisted story perfectly and truly enhanced the listening experience. This was my first time hearing a performance from her, and I was impressed by how well she brought the tension and unease to life.

Savannah ends up single and pregnant after a short fling with Max. Meanwhile, Max slides right back to his ex, Madison, as if nothing ever happened. Savannah decides she’ll raise the baby on her own—and if Max wants to co-parent, she’s open to it.

Then Madison starts posting all over social media about how happy she and Max are, dropping hints about the baby and presenting it as part of their perfect future. At first, it’s awkward. Then it’s uncomfortable. Then it’s just plain strange.

As secrets begin to unravel, Savannah’s mind—and mine—starts reeling. The tension builds steadily, and while the story is definitely over the top at times, I found it undeniably entertaining. I was anxious to see how it would all play out and ultimately answer the question: Who is the better mother?

A solid debut and I would definitely read future books by Jennifer van der Kleut.
Profile Image for Stacy40pages.
2,289 reviews174 followers
February 7, 2026
The Better Mother by Jennifer van der Kleut. Thanks to @booksparks #WRC2026 for the gifted copy ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Savannah is shocked when she becomes pregnant after a fling. When she tells him, he’s excited to be a father but has gotten back together with his girlfriend, Madison, and wants to arrange a co-parenting relationship. Madison is eager to help but her eagerness quickly becomes scary.

I absolutely devoured this one. I read it in one sitting in about three hours. It is one of the tensest books I’ve read and really caused my anxiety to spike! It’s just one horror after another, in an unbelievable but wildly entertaining story. Highly recommend this one!

Read if you like:
-Pregnancy tropes
-Stalking or obsession stories
-Tense plot lines

The Better Mother comes out 2/10.
Profile Image for Ty.
576 reviews118 followers
February 23, 2026
These are the type of thrillers I really enjoy. I was hooked from the very beginning and I never wanted to put it down. I felt so bad for Savannah and there were moments where I felt I was going crazy right along with her, trying to figure out why Madison was tormenting her so much. There were definitely times when I thought Savannah could have put the pieces together a little quicker, but I actually ended up enjoying how naive she was at times, it made everything more entertaining and a little more chaotic. The ending was super fast paced, so much was going on and I really enjoyed how it all wrapped up. I will absolutely pick up something else from this author!

I received an ARC copy from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review
Profile Image for Jeanie ~ fables.and.fur.
658 reviews82 followers
January 21, 2026
“Madison can get pretty jealous.” That may be a teeny weeny understatement. I do enjoy a good unhinged character. Be careful reading reviews on this one since I’ve seen a few spoilers. I was worried this would be a mommy drama trope, but it wasn’t that at all. It’s a great thriller debut and I’m looking forward to more books by this author!

Xe Sands is the voice actor on the audiobook production and she’s perfect in this role. I’d recommend the audiobook format if you can get a copy. Thank you @dreamscape_media and @jennvdk for an ALC of The Better Mother.
Profile Image for Cayla.
1,502 reviews333 followers
February 19, 2026
4.5 Stars for this one! What a crazy book this was and man oh man I never have wanted to punch someone so much in a book than a character in this one. If you know, you know. I really enjoyed this one though despite the annoyance and anger I had for certain reasons when reading this one. The overall story was great, it was super fast paced and one you just couldn't put down.

We have Savannah who is our main character who ends up becoming pregnant by a random guy she met for a few drinks a few times and what do you know becomes pregnant like I said. She always wanted a baby so she knew she would keep it. She has to tell the father though. At first he is "shocked" but then is okay with it and this guy's girlfriend wants to be apart of this process too with the baby. Little did we know things start getting out of hand and Savannah wants nothing more then to get this woman to go away. Things start getting serious and story just keeps getting crazier and we get thrown with some twists that you wont expect!

Definitely a very great Mystery Thriller you will want to pick up!
Profile Image for Casey Bee.
747 reviews62 followers
March 1, 2026
This is a 4.5 stars that I might wind up bumping up to 5! I love unhinged characters in my books and THIS IS IT! Savannah finds herself accidentally pregnant from a one-night-stand with a guy named Max. After contacting Max, he’s pretty cool about it and they’re going to approach this situation together. He just has to tell his girlfriend who he recently got back together with. She is surprisingly excited for them and wants to be involved every step of the way. Savannah quickly realizes that she wants to be a little TOO involved. What transpires is a WILD ride! And I loved being along for it every step of the way! And trust me, there are twists. It’s not as straightforward as you expect!

People are CRAZY! I feel like this story toes the line between, “this could be a real story on the news” and “this is too crazy to happen irl”. And that’s such a fun line to toe! I literally loved it.
Profile Image for MrsHarvieReads.
427 reviews
December 25, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for an advanced reader copy of The Better Mother by Jennifer van der Kleut in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

The Better Mother is a psychological thriller featuring 34-year old Savannah who finds herself unexpectedly pregnant. She hopes to have a friendly co-parenting relationship with Max, her fling and the father of her child, but his ex and rekindled girlfriend, Madison, has more sinister plans in mind.

This debut reminded me of a Frieda McFadden novel. It’s fast paced and suspenseful. Once the premise is established, the story became somewhat predictable but kept me entertained and turning the pages. I kept hoping that Savannah would stop falling into all of Madison’s carefully laid traps. But I found the ending to be satisfying. Ultimately I would recommend this novel to fans of popcorn thrillers looking for a book to breeze through. 3/5⭐️
Profile Image for Stephanielikesbooks.
735 reviews84 followers
February 4, 2026
An entertaining debut popcorn thriller about how far someone will go to become a mother.

Told in three parts, and in two first-person POVs, the story had suspense building to a solid twist in part two. The second half of the novel was fast-paced and intense but definitely required suspension of belief.

An entertaining, captivating quick read that I read in just a little over a day.

Thanks to the publisher for the complimentary digital copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for LaceyBanana Reads.
584 reviews29 followers
February 28, 2026
4.5. A series of events leads Savannah to a situationship where she ends up pregnant. She decides to contact the father and together they agree to navigate this while the father has reconnected with his ex who wants to be supportive. Only she becomes a little TOO supportive and boundaries seem like a foreign concept to her.

THIS BOOK!! My blood was boiling, I was yelling at my Kindle, and I couldn’t put it down. It was so suspenseful and wild that I’m not forcing my husband to read it 😂 I am the biggest fan of unlikeable characters and while I liked Savannah, I had some words for others in this book. I’m a hater at my core and I enjoyed every second of hating I did during my read. Such a fun and twisted story, I’m so glad I requested this!

Thank you so much to Netgalley, Jennifer van der Kleut, and Crooked Lane Books for providing this free E-ARC. This published on February 10th. This is my honest review!
Profile Image for Kay Oliver.
Author 11 books197 followers
November 15, 2025
A captivating unraveling. The characters drove this story. They were genuine and believable with complex layers. I was frantically turning pages to find out what they would do next. After such a phenomenal buildup, though, I would have liked a bit more from the ending.
816 reviews47 followers
October 13, 2025
2⭐️

The premise sounded promising but the execution was terrible. Everything was predictable and cliche. All the characters were one dimensional and boring.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for ♡Heather✩Brown♡.
1,097 reviews79 followers
November 23, 2025
Still need to edit this a bit - it doesn’t read or feel right to me. Gonna let it sit for a bit. (MY REVIEW NOT THE BOOK 😂) Just clarifying that. Why’d I wait a day to write this? 😭 Prob bc I was too occupied loving the 💩 outta this book!

#ad much love for my advance copy @crookedlanebooks #partner

🆃🅷🅴 🅱🅴🆃🆃🅴🆁 🅼🅾🆃🅷🅴🆁
< @jennvdk >
ʀᴇʟᴇᴀꜱᴇꜱ: ꜰᴇʙʀᴜᴀʀʏ 𝟣𝟢, 𝟤𝟢𝟤𝟨
ᴅᴏᴍᴇꜱᴛɪᴄ/ᴘꜱʏᴄʜᴏʟᴏɢɪᴄᴀʟ ᴛʜʀɪʟʟᴇʀ | ꜱᴜꜱᴘᴇɴꜱᴇ

I had the best time reading this book - every word, every page, every chapter gave me some type of reaction. This is the first book I posted my thoughts and theories on after each chapter. Just a fabulously fun read. You’ll want to buddy read this one, because it’s just too fun of a read to not share with your best friend.

Oof! The Better Mother by Jennifer Van Der Kleut is coming in HOTT. They say it takes a village to raise a kid, but this is one village you’d probably be better off hightailing it away from. So buckle up, hold on to your hats, and yes, this is one of those books you’ll need a Xanax for.

Who would be the better mother? It’ll be a fight to the death before that answer is revealed. You’ll want to finish this book in a day. It’s impossible to stop reading.

A gripping and twisty read that you won’t want to put down. There are some serious high-voltage twists and turns you won’t see coming. This is one of those books that will leave your head spinning. You won’t know what’s up, down, right, or left. It’ll give you a 100 different theories and suspects, but when the truth is revealed, you’ll still be shocked. It’ll zap the life right out of you while slapping you across the face.

So sharpen those detective skills, grab a glass of wine, relax, and cancel all your plans, because this is a one-night-stand type of read. And it’ll satisfy you in every way possible, leaving you wanting more. Definitely up there as one of funnest books I’ve read this year.

When Savvy becomes pregnant after a brief fling with Max, she feels they can co-parent this baby together - Max, his girlfriend Madison, and Savvy. They’ve got this. But Madison is like that bad best friend who shows up uninvited to your house randomly and sticks to you like chewed gum. You can’t be rid of her no matter what you do. Unhinged in the best possible way.

This book delivers everything us thriller readers love most. I had high expectations for this one and it did not disappoint. You’ll be completely gripped by the end of chapter one.

A debut?! Jennifer has just put herself on the map! Netflix, Hulu, Amazon WHERE YOU AT BRO’S?! I got your next favorite read right here, and it would make a KILLER movie or limited series.

A hilarious (in that deranged sense - which I find hilarious), edge-of-your-seat read that you won’t walk away from unscathed. An unforgettable must-read.

Read. This. Book. Or else.

Can’t wait to see what twisty and unhinged story Van Der Kleut comes up with next, because I’ll be there for it. Guaranteed!
2 reviews
February 23, 2026
A frustrating and far-out read… SPOILERS AHEAD

I may be in the minority here, but I highly disliked this book. The protagonist’s inaction and gullibility was incredibly frustrating, at least for me to read about. It’s as if she had absolutely no life experience. She ignored so many red flag behaviors that I was rolling my eyes while reading.
I also felt the story was way too dragged out… could’ve been a novella. Didn’t need all the extra fluff. Predictable as well.
And the ending? Completely over-the-top and unbelievable. No self-respecting nurse would take a job in a remote cabin and then actually believe a woman who is screaming and tied down and being drugged against her will is an actual surrogate. 😂 I personally felt that almost every character in this book was either willfully ignorant or completely idiotic. Sort of mad I paid for this.
Profile Image for Wanetta.
159 reviews1 follower
February 17, 2026
4.75 ⭐️
OMG! This was so well written. This thriller had me asking a lot of questions. It was intene because honestly stuff like this can happen in real life. All the characters were questionable except for Savannah who is the main character. I was rooting for her to get through this craziness. The things she went through stress me out and I felt for her.

It was twisty and just absolutely creepy. If you like thrillers like this, well this is the one.
Profile Image for Kayda Noelle.
170 reviews3 followers
February 18, 2026
What a wild ride. Super fast paced! Had my jaw on the floor many times, and had me fuming…what more could I ask for from a thriller? 😂
It was predictable in that I guessed the twist in the beginning, but the content in between was so entertaining that I didn’t even care that I knew what would happen. Well done 👏🏼

A big thank you to Booksparks and the author for sending me a gifted copy
💕
Profile Image for Taylor Mae.
270 reviews139 followers
February 18, 2026
I didn't know what to expect when I picked up "The Better Mother," but it exceeded any expectations I could've had! It was twisted, fast-paced, surprising, and at times made me uncomfortable in the best way. The manipulation was so well done and really made me think.

Jennifer van Der Kleut's writing was incredible. The way she easily made me feel every different emotion throughout was an experience I don't often have. It kept me on the edge of my seat and interested the whole time. I highly recommend picking this one up if you want a crazy, creepy, yet amazing thriller!
Profile Image for Monsi A..
234 reviews9 followers
February 15, 2026
Have you ever watched the news and thought to yourself, “this is like reading a book”? This is that book. I like looking at reviews before jumping into a book, but nothing could have prepared me for Madison. I have never hated a character more than I hated Madison.

This book had my heart racing, my blood boiling, and I think I knew early on that it was going to be a five star read for me. It had tension, so much that I was on edge of my seat the entire book. At no point was there a lull in the tension or the pacing of this book.

There is a fine like in thrillers between being realistic, and too far fetched. The Better Mother is right on that line. I think what made this book so thrilling, was just how plausible it seemed. I could definitely see a story like this on the news, and I think that’s why I hated Madison so much.

This is a stunner for a debut and I catch wait to see what the author comes up with next. She has easily become an auto-buy author, no questions asked.

Thank you so much to Jennifer Van Der Kleut and BookSparks for a gifted physical copy in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 446 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.