This short story collection is divided into two halves, and it is this division that gives me pause to recommending it with anything more than a "meh" for anyone who is looking to read Russell Banks. The first half of the collection is brilliant and Banks at his best, including a nascent version of Hamilton Stark called "The Conversion." However, unlike Hamilton Stark, which concerns itself more with the author of the fictional account of miscreant Hamilton Stark, "The Conversion" is more a look into how someone could become like Stark is in the novel.
The second half of the collection is not so successful, as Banks dips his toe into historical fiction that sometimes comes off as a book report rather than fiction. There is an obvious linkage of the title story to Banks' next novel The Book of Jamaica, but again, I feel that the historical fiction of "The New World" falls short of Banks' best work.