What do you think?
Rate this book
Love Comes Softly #4
Love's Abiding Joy
A Birthday Surprise, a New Journey West, and a Delightful Reunion! But Then Comes Tragedy.
Marty and Clark Davis's daughter Missie and her husband had homesteaded land in the far West, many weeks' journey away by covered wagon. But with the coming of the frontier railroad, the miles are suddenly bridged, making possible their long-awaited reunion.
Grandparents Marty and Clark are thrilled to meet their two little grandsons for the first time. Missie, anxious to hear news from home, plies her mother with questions about her brothers and sisters. And as Willie proudly shows the two visitors around his successful ranch, Missie, just as proudly, shows them the little soddy that was their original home.
But the joyful reunion is shattered by a tragic accident. Will they ever be a happy family again?
Marty and Clark Davis's daughter Missie and her husband had homesteaded land in the far West, many weeks' journey away by covered wagon. But with the coming of the frontier railroad, the miles are suddenly bridged, making possible their long-awaited reunion.
Grandparents Marty and Clark are thrilled to meet their two little grandsons for the first time. Missie, anxious to hear news from home, plies her mother with questions about her brothers and sisters. And as Willie proudly shows the two visitors around his successful ranch, Missie, just as proudly, shows them the little soddy that was their original home.
But the joyful reunion is shattered by a tragic accident. Will they ever be a happy family again?
240 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1983
235 people are currently reading
4076 people want to read
About the author
Janette Oke
347 books3,429 followersJanette Oke is a Canadian author known for her inspirational fiction, often set in a pioneer era and focused on female protagonists. Her debut novel, Love Comes Softly (1979), became the foundation for a successful series, followed by over 75 other novels. The first book in her Canadian West series, When Calls the Heart (1983), inspired the popular television series of the same name.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 266 reviews
April 12, 2023
Lately, I've been struggling to accept that God's plan is better than mine. I re-read this book because I needed examples (even fictional ones) of people accepting His plan over whatever they might have imagined their lives would look like.
Love's Abiding Joy is probably my favorite book from the Love Comes Softly series. I laughed and cried my way through this inspiring novel.
Marty is a great example of a strong woman. She faces her trials with faith, even though she still has struggles.
Clark is an amazing man. Even after he , he faces the future with faith. He even uses his harrowing experiences to help others.
Favorite quote: "Iffen the Lord hadn'ta figured I could do without , he wouldn't've 'llowed this, now would He?"
I would highly recommend this book to anyone struggling (like me) to accept God's will in their lives.
Love's Abiding Joy is probably my favorite book from the Love Comes Softly series. I laughed and cried my way through this inspiring novel.
Marty is a great example of a strong woman. She faces her trials with faith, even though she still has struggles.
Clark is an amazing man. Even after he , he faces the future with faith. He even uses his harrowing experiences to help others.
Favorite quote: "Iffen the Lord hadn'ta figured I could do without , he wouldn't've 'llowed this, now would He?"
I would highly recommend this book to anyone struggling (like me) to accept God's will in their lives.
April 25, 2013
Reviewed for THC Reviews
Love's Abiding Joy is another lovely addition to the Love Comes Softly series, but unlike the first three books in the series, this one is pretty much pure inspirational, historical fiction. There's really no romance to speak of. The story is primarily a continuation of Clark and Marty's relationship as they face more trials and joys with a side helping of Willie and Missie. There are no new budding romances, and even these two married couples don't so much as share a kiss on the lips, only extremely chaste pecks on the cheek or forehead. This was a tad disappointing, because the first three books had just enough romance for me to be comfortable categorizing them as such. However, it was still a wonderful book that is every bit as good as the Little House on the Prairie series, which it resembles, and fans of frontier stories are sure to enjoy it.
In the last book of the series, Love's Long Journey, Missie and Willie headed west in a covered wagon to settle on the frontier and build a cattle ranch. They are now prospering in their new home, but Clark and Marty dearly miss their oldest daughter. With a new rail line now running through a town not far from Missie and Willie's ranch, Clark and Marty are finally able to go visit them. Although this part of the story moved a little slowly for me, I did find it interesting. Compared to modern-day travel, their week-long journey by stagecoach and train seemed downright primitive, but in many ways, Clark and Marty felt like they were traveling in luxury. Although it was still exhausting for them, I suppose when you consider the alternative of traveling overland by covered wagon it was luxurious. The accommodations in their departure city were as well, but from there on, not so much, which makes me very thankful for our modern hotels and travel conveniences.
When Clark and Marty finally arrive, they couldn't be more thrilled to finally see Missie and Willie again and be introduced to the grandchildren they've never met. After a rocky beginning, Missie has settled into her life on the frontier very nicely, and they have built a wonderful group of people around them as a support system. Missie now loves life on the ranch every bit as much as Willie always did, and their two boys are as cute as a button. Clark and Marty only plan on staying for two weeks before heading back to the family they left behind, but a tragic accident, extends their stay for much longer.
Just like the first two books of the series, a large part of this book is in Marty's perspective, but a decent chunk of it is from Clark's POV, which was a refreshing change. I've always adored Clark for his patience and gentleness, and I loved the way he teases Marty. He has always been the perfect foil for Marty's bluntness and impatience. We see a touch of that here, but it's mostly about her strength and resilience which I admire. What I've always admired more though, is Clark's quiet faith and optimism. When tragedy strikes, he does get upset to some extent, but only for a short time, and he doesn't allow himself to dwell on it too much. That's because he believes wholeheartedly that everything that happens to him, good or bad, has a purpose. He also believes everything will be OK no matter what, because God is watching out for us and wants the best for us. With that in mind, he also puts his sharp mind to work figuring out ways to overcome these new obstacles with which he is faced. The other thing I've always loved about Clark is how he quietly lives out his faith in a way that is easy for others to see but non-threatening. That's because he never tries to shove his religion down anyone's throat, but instead, is a good friend and gentle teacher to everyone, no matter where they are in their walk with God. In this way, he is able to reach many people in a positive and often life-changing way. Clark is such an easy man to fall in love with even when the book technically isn't a romance.
Overall, Love's Abiding Joy was a very pleasant and heartwarming read. I love that the faith message is a more gentle one, and not preachy, like many inspirational books nowadays. It also paints a vivid picture of life on the frontier and many of the difficulties inherent in living so far from civilization. I very much enjoyed my time reading Love's Abiding Joy. It has earned a spot on my keeper shelf next to its predecessors, and I look forward to continuing the series.
Love's Abiding Joy is another lovely addition to the Love Comes Softly series, but unlike the first three books in the series, this one is pretty much pure inspirational, historical fiction. There's really no romance to speak of. The story is primarily a continuation of Clark and Marty's relationship as they face more trials and joys with a side helping of Willie and Missie. There are no new budding romances, and even these two married couples don't so much as share a kiss on the lips, only extremely chaste pecks on the cheek or forehead. This was a tad disappointing, because the first three books had just enough romance for me to be comfortable categorizing them as such. However, it was still a wonderful book that is every bit as good as the Little House on the Prairie series, which it resembles, and fans of frontier stories are sure to enjoy it.
In the last book of the series, Love's Long Journey, Missie and Willie headed west in a covered wagon to settle on the frontier and build a cattle ranch. They are now prospering in their new home, but Clark and Marty dearly miss their oldest daughter. With a new rail line now running through a town not far from Missie and Willie's ranch, Clark and Marty are finally able to go visit them. Although this part of the story moved a little slowly for me, I did find it interesting. Compared to modern-day travel, their week-long journey by stagecoach and train seemed downright primitive, but in many ways, Clark and Marty felt like they were traveling in luxury. Although it was still exhausting for them, I suppose when you consider the alternative of traveling overland by covered wagon it was luxurious. The accommodations in their departure city were as well, but from there on, not so much, which makes me very thankful for our modern hotels and travel conveniences.
When Clark and Marty finally arrive, they couldn't be more thrilled to finally see Missie and Willie again and be introduced to the grandchildren they've never met. After a rocky beginning, Missie has settled into her life on the frontier very nicely, and they have built a wonderful group of people around them as a support system. Missie now loves life on the ranch every bit as much as Willie always did, and their two boys are as cute as a button. Clark and Marty only plan on staying for two weeks before heading back to the family they left behind, but a tragic accident, extends their stay for much longer.
Just like the first two books of the series, a large part of this book is in Marty's perspective, but a decent chunk of it is from Clark's POV, which was a refreshing change. I've always adored Clark for his patience and gentleness, and I loved the way he teases Marty. He has always been the perfect foil for Marty's bluntness and impatience. We see a touch of that here, but it's mostly about her strength and resilience which I admire. What I've always admired more though, is Clark's quiet faith and optimism. When tragedy strikes, he does get upset to some extent, but only for a short time, and he doesn't allow himself to dwell on it too much. That's because he believes wholeheartedly that everything that happens to him, good or bad, has a purpose. He also believes everything will be OK no matter what, because God is watching out for us and wants the best for us. With that in mind, he also puts his sharp mind to work figuring out ways to overcome these new obstacles with which he is faced. The other thing I've always loved about Clark is how he quietly lives out his faith in a way that is easy for others to see but non-threatening. That's because he never tries to shove his religion down anyone's throat, but instead, is a good friend and gentle teacher to everyone, no matter where they are in their walk with God. In this way, he is able to reach many people in a positive and often life-changing way. Clark is such an easy man to fall in love with even when the book technically isn't a romance.
Overall, Love's Abiding Joy was a very pleasant and heartwarming read. I love that the faith message is a more gentle one, and not preachy, like many inspirational books nowadays. It also paints a vivid picture of life on the frontier and many of the difficulties inherent in living so far from civilization. I very much enjoyed my time reading Love's Abiding Joy. It has earned a spot on my keeper shelf next to its predecessors, and I look forward to continuing the series.
April 5, 2025
SO good!
September 25, 2018
I think I enjoyed the third book a little more, but this one was nice too. I watched the movie last night and it was way different from the book...I hope to start the 5th one soon though :)
February 1, 2016
These books are sooooo good. When you feel tired of the usually things you read these are defiantely a go to book for me at least. They have beautiful story lines and amazing characters that you just fall in love with. Highly suggest this book and really think anyone would enjoy this.
May 28, 2018
This was not what I was expecting, but I loved it anyway. I love watching these characters grow. <3
December 1, 2023
This one will always be one of my favorites in this series.
February 10, 2024
The most inspirational book in the series, and perfect to remind me to trust God through my current situation. A wonderful story of love, family, caring, hardships, and surrender to God.
August 25, 2017
This is my second time reading this book. My goal is to read all 8 books this year unlike in 2012 when I only made it to about 6.
This book is probably my favourite in the series so far. It's suspenseful, deals with day to day life on the Canadian prairies in pioneer times, faith, and especially how medical emergencies were dealt with back then.
However, just like the 1st 3 books I have found a couple of holes in this story (Go to my reviews of the books if you want the whole rants):
Book 1, the hole was there was no way Marty would be THAT ignorant about the Christian faith since the church had such a powerful presence everywhere.
Book 2, the hole was not dealing with racism issues in a realistic way between the Graham boy and a First Nations lady.
Book 3, the hole was the realistic-ness of having Mexican immigrants and several other characters who unrelatedly happened to know Spanish(I did research and I couldn't find anything about Mexican immigrants on the Canadian prairies at this time) Recently figured out this was set in the states; I just assumed it was Canada cause the author is Canadian.
and as for this book (SPOILERS AHEAD) the hole had to deal with when Clark realized he lost his leg. I honestly don't believe he would be that okay with it. When Marty told him he lost his leg he looked shocked, turned to the wall for a sec, then a minute later the doctor came in and he was sympathizing with the doctor's tough decision and giving praises of joy. Sure, it said that in the days following he wept, but really, when a person loses a limb like that unexpectedly (especially being a farmer in the 1800s!) I couldn't imagine he wouldn't be thinking about how much this would impact him and his work. Clark's reaction is not realistic and I believe Oke wrote Clark to basically have no faults. Looking back on the 4 books I can point to instances of Marty's stubbornness and other characters' faults, but not Clark's, and yet he's always doing the preaching about how much of a sinner he was, and yet Oke wrote him to be almost sinless!
I still like the series- it's nice brain candy and I enjoy reading about day-to-day life of pioneers, but Oke has made a lot of careless mistakes. My Mother and Father in law say that this is just fiction and one should make allowances for inaccuracies, but I disagree- all of these mistakes are obvious and careless.
This book is probably my favourite in the series so far. It's suspenseful, deals with day to day life on the Canadian prairies in pioneer times, faith, and especially how medical emergencies were dealt with back then.
However, just like the 1st 3 books I have found a couple of holes in this story (Go to my reviews of the books if you want the whole rants):
Book 1, the hole was there was no way Marty would be THAT ignorant about the Christian faith since the church had such a powerful presence everywhere.
Book 2, the hole was not dealing with racism issues in a realistic way between the Graham boy and a First Nations lady.
and as for this book (SPOILERS AHEAD) the hole had to deal with when Clark realized he lost his leg. I honestly don't believe he would be that okay with it. When Marty told him he lost his leg he looked shocked, turned to the wall for a sec, then a minute later the doctor came in and he was sympathizing with the doctor's tough decision and giving praises of joy. Sure, it said that in the days following he wept, but really, when a person loses a limb like that unexpectedly (especially being a farmer in the 1800s!) I couldn't imagine he wouldn't be thinking about how much this would impact him and his work. Clark's reaction is not realistic and I believe Oke wrote Clark to basically have no faults. Looking back on the 4 books I can point to instances of Marty's stubbornness and other characters' faults, but not Clark's, and yet he's always doing the preaching about how much of a sinner he was, and yet Oke wrote him to be almost sinless!
I still like the series- it's nice brain candy and I enjoy reading about day-to-day life of pioneers, but Oke has made a lot of careless mistakes. My Mother and Father in law say that this is just fiction and one should make allowances for inaccuracies, but I disagree- all of these mistakes are obvious and careless.
January 17, 2022
I loved this book. It dealt with so many emotions: kids moving away, having family in more than one location, loss, handicaps, past hurt, friendship, and just doing life together with the people in your circle.
I love the old fashioned family life.
Notes for me to remember: Clark and Marty visit out West. Clark loses his leg.
I love the old fashioned family life.
Notes for me to remember: Clark and Marty visit out West. Clark loses his leg.
December 7, 2017
This book was so frustrating! The beginning wasn't that bad. I was excited to return to Marty and Clark while reading more about Missie's budding family. So far, the books have been sweet with a dash of drama. I didn't mind the slower, calmer pace. What I do mind is unrealistic optimism.
To lose a limb is devastating, regardless of who you are. While there are people who've recovered (somewhat) and made their stories inspirational, they only succeeded after months or even years of struggling. That is completely fair. Their entire life has changed. For a farmer like Clark, losing his leg could mean the difference between life and death. He wouldn't be able to plow his fields or feed his family.
When this horrible thing happened, I settled in to read about how this inspirational family overcame this tragedy. Instead, that was solved in one page. I kid you not. Clark spends a page - one afternoon - crying and praying, and then he's fine. That's it. One afternoon of wallowing, and then he's accepted it. Not only is it unrealistic, it's just uneventful. There's no point in the rest of the book. Not only did Clark accept his new life, so did everyone else. No more conflict. No more struggle. No more story.
I guess Clark is supposed to be a Christian's fantasy: a simple yet manly man whom other men look up to who is also very spiritual. Taking this into consideration, it makes sense why Clark would get over his loss so quickly. That said, it doesn't excuse the poor storytelling. What strengthens faith is doubt. It's ironic, but it's like having day without night. You need one to really value the other. Since Clark never doubts, never struggles, neither his character nor his faith grows. This book is preachy and bland and did a disservice to the more complex character in the first Love Comes Softly book.
To lose a limb is devastating, regardless of who you are. While there are people who've recovered (somewhat) and made their stories inspirational, they only succeeded after months or even years of struggling. That is completely fair. Their entire life has changed. For a farmer like Clark, losing his leg could mean the difference between life and death. He wouldn't be able to plow his fields or feed his family.
When this horrible thing happened, I settled in to read about how this inspirational family overcame this tragedy. Instead, that was solved in one page. I kid you not. Clark spends a page - one afternoon - crying and praying, and then he's fine. That's it. One afternoon of wallowing, and then he's accepted it. Not only is it unrealistic, it's just uneventful. There's no point in the rest of the book. Not only did Clark accept his new life, so did everyone else. No more conflict. No more struggle. No more story.
I guess Clark is supposed to be a Christian's fantasy: a simple yet manly man whom other men look up to who is also very spiritual. Taking this into consideration, it makes sense why Clark would get over his loss so quickly. That said, it doesn't excuse the poor storytelling. What strengthens faith is doubt. It's ironic, but it's like having day without night. You need one to really value the other. Since Clark never doubts, never struggles, neither his character nor his faith grows. This book is preachy and bland and did a disservice to the more complex character in the first Love Comes Softly book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 16, 2020
This is the fourth book of the Love Comes Softly series. Marty and Clark take a train trip out west to visit Missy, Willy and the two grandsons, Nathan and Josiah. They plan to stay two weeks but sometimes even a well organized schedule can fall apart. There is no way that the couple could have foreseen the tragedy that awaited them during their visit with Missy and her family.
I have enjoyed the four books of this series that I've read so far. I'm going to say this one is my favorite. The trip out west on two different trains. The long awaited reunion with Missy, Willie and the boys. This book drew me in and I laughed and cried along with the characters. I enjoyed my reading experience with Love's Abiding Joy. Most have probably read this series long ago but it's my first time reading it so every book is a new experience for me.
For those who love reading classic books this series is for you. Those that have read it already might enjoy rereading it. I have loved every book or series written by Janette Oke that I have read.
I was fortunate to find a complete original set of this series at a garage sale. A review was not requested. I share here my honest thoughts and opinions about Love's Abiding Joy.
I have enjoyed the four books of this series that I've read so far. I'm going to say this one is my favorite. The trip out west on two different trains. The long awaited reunion with Missy, Willie and the boys. This book drew me in and I laughed and cried along with the characters. I enjoyed my reading experience with Love's Abiding Joy. Most have probably read this series long ago but it's my first time reading it so every book is a new experience for me.
For those who love reading classic books this series is for you. Those that have read it already might enjoy rereading it. I have loved every book or series written by Janette Oke that I have read.
I was fortunate to find a complete original set of this series at a garage sale. A review was not requested. I share here my honest thoughts and opinions about Love's Abiding Joy.
April 6, 2015
What a wonderful story ... a reunion between parents and child who have not seen each other for several years ... and a beautiful story of how to smile through adversity, how to let God be God, and how to trust Him for everything! Very inspirational!
April 2015 ... my very favorite of the entire series. Reunion of Clark & Marty with daughter Missie ... and then a terrible tragedy, which a deep and abiding faith can turn to a deep and, indeed, abiding joy.
April 2015 ... my very favorite of the entire series. Reunion of Clark & Marty with daughter Missie ... and then a terrible tragedy, which a deep and abiding faith can turn to a deep and, indeed, abiding joy.
October 13, 2025
2024 reread, Kindle edition.
June 30, 2021
Always heartwarming to read! 😍
October 4, 2023
Excellent series!
December 5, 2023
3.5ish? Nothing I didn't like but nothing amazing. These are so wholesome and sweet, and I do love the way Oke portrays community and supporting and loving others.
May 29, 2021
Good book! Very exciting!
November 4, 2025
4.5 ⭐ Full review here: https://boundlessbookshelfreviews.blo...
March 29, 2021
The Transcontinental Railroad has been built, and a months-long excursion is now about a week. Clark and Marty take advantage of modern times and take a trip west to see Missy and meet their grandchildren. After the last couple of books it is so sweet to read about their reunion and for them to see the success of Willie's ranch. But it's not long before tragedy strikes and their world is turned upside down. The faith of this family is uplifting and inspiring.
March 10, 2024
Welcome back to the Davis family saga with the fourth book in Janette Oke's Love Comes Softly series, Love's Abiding Joy.
Marty Davis has missed the oldest daughter she shares with her beloved husband Clark in the years since Missie married Willie LaHaye and moved farther west to start his cattle ranch. Letters aren't nearly enough to bridge the miles between them. But thanks to the Transcontinental Railroad and tons of support from their family, Clark surprises Marty with a birthday present of tickets to see their darling daughter.
The train ride seems like it will never end, but one day Marty and Clark get to see Missie, Willie and their grandsons, Nathan and Josiah, along with all the ranchers that have helped to make the LaHayes successful ranchers.
Clark and Marty settle in for a few weeks' visit, but when tragedy strikes, they must stay with the LaHayes longer than expected, bringing changes for the entire family. The Davis and LaHaye families must lean on their faith to get them through, and as tragedy turns to a renewed need to seek a closer relationship with God for the residents of this western town, Clark is called to help.
What a wonderful addition to this Christian historical series Loves Abiding Joy is. A parents' joyful reunion with their daughter and her family turns to tragedy when Clark is critically injured rescuing children. Oke portrays this family in crisis well: Marty and Missie's different approaches to praying for and helping Clark in the days after his accident; Clark adjusting to a different way to approach the physical aspects of his life; strong, silent Willie who bears a change in his family dynamic; and Missie's guilt over believing this tragedy happened because her parents were visiting.
Love's Abiding Joy further strengthens Clark's personality as a strong man of faith guiding his loved ones as the patriarch of the Davis family. His thoughtful insights into situations viewed through the ever-loving grace of God also help members of the community Missie and Willie call home. And when Clark and Marty finally board the train back to their own hometown, it goes without saying that the entire community will miss them.
Marty Davis has missed the oldest daughter she shares with her beloved husband Clark in the years since Missie married Willie LaHaye and moved farther west to start his cattle ranch. Letters aren't nearly enough to bridge the miles between them. But thanks to the Transcontinental Railroad and tons of support from their family, Clark surprises Marty with a birthday present of tickets to see their darling daughter.
The train ride seems like it will never end, but one day Marty and Clark get to see Missie, Willie and their grandsons, Nathan and Josiah, along with all the ranchers that have helped to make the LaHayes successful ranchers.
Clark and Marty settle in for a few weeks' visit, but when tragedy strikes, they must stay with the LaHayes longer than expected, bringing changes for the entire family. The Davis and LaHaye families must lean on their faith to get them through, and as tragedy turns to a renewed need to seek a closer relationship with God for the residents of this western town, Clark is called to help.
What a wonderful addition to this Christian historical series Loves Abiding Joy is. A parents' joyful reunion with their daughter and her family turns to tragedy when Clark is critically injured rescuing children. Oke portrays this family in crisis well: Marty and Missie's different approaches to praying for and helping Clark in the days after his accident; Clark adjusting to a different way to approach the physical aspects of his life; strong, silent Willie who bears a change in his family dynamic; and Missie's guilt over believing this tragedy happened because her parents were visiting.
Love's Abiding Joy further strengthens Clark's personality as a strong man of faith guiding his loved ones as the patriarch of the Davis family. His thoughtful insights into situations viewed through the ever-loving grace of God also help members of the community Missie and Willie call home. And when Clark and Marty finally board the train back to their own hometown, it goes without saying that the entire community will miss them.
April 15, 2023
Love’s Abiding Joy
Love’s Abiding Joy by Janette Oke is Book number 4 in the Love Comes Softly series. I read these books when I need a comforting book, the spirit of the Lord, or just because. This series is appropriate for the young and the old. I started reading them in my teens and am continuing to do so in mid-life.
Love’s Abiding Joy by Janette Oke is Book number 4 in the Love Comes Softly series. I read these books when I need a comforting book, the spirit of the Lord, or just because. This series is appropriate for the young and the old. I started reading them in my teens and am continuing to do so in mid-life.
May 22, 2022
Loved these books as a teen and young adult until I read Mrs. Mike and realized that this author merely copied another author's work as her own without giving them credit. She plagerized almost the entire Canadian West series but it really put a bad taste in my mouth for any of her other books including her animal series.
October 21, 2015
A Quickie Review
It's been a while since I've read any installments in this series, but, I remembered the characters and situations well enough to follow this one. Fans of books like this know what to expect, and that's just what they get here.
Score: 4/5
It's been a while since I've read any installments in this series, but, I remembered the characters and situations well enough to follow this one. Fans of books like this know what to expect, and that's just what they get here.
Score: 4/5
February 6, 2013
Beautiful series of Christian fiction.
October 13, 2021
I thoroughly enjoyed this book. I loved that Marty and Clark got to see Missie and Willie again. This book was also filled with great scriptural truths.
June 14, 2018
This is the fourth book of the series. Like the others, reading the previous books in order adds some depth of feeling and identification, but it probably isn't absolutely necessary. And like the others, this story is complete at the end, but with the promise that the saga continues.
This is a Christian book and as much as any previous book, faith and God are an essential part of this story. The beginning drags a bit as Clark and Marty journey to see Missie and her family and that journey is drawn out. There is also a portion at the end which is somewhat anti-climactic. The reunion is nice, but the heart of the story is the "tragedy". That story and how that event plays out as part of this family's faith journey is what makes this book stand out.
The author explores how Christians deal with God's will. Part of that is how they pray in the midst of crisis. The author presents through the story her explanation of how God works in these things and this explanation is probably good as far as it goes.
***There may be a bit of a spoiler in the paragraph that follows, but I don't think so. If you open this "spoiler", it reveals some of the feel of the climax, but no specifics.
Both Clark and Marty show deep and mature faith in this story. At times Willie fades into the background. Missie is not the center of this story, but rather she is in many ways back to being Clark and Marty's daughter. There are significant contributions by several other people in this story.
It is hard to say that there are mature themes in this book, but there are a couple of things worth noting. There is still no sex. There is a brief mention in a backstory of a suicide. And of course the central tragedy touches on why bad things happen to good people.
This is a Christian book and as much as any previous book, faith and God are an essential part of this story. The beginning drags a bit as Clark and Marty journey to see Missie and her family and that journey is drawn out. There is also a portion at the end which is somewhat anti-climactic. The reunion is nice, but the heart of the story is the "tragedy". That story and how that event plays out as part of this family's faith journey is what makes this book stand out.
The author explores how Christians deal with God's will. Part of that is how they pray in the midst of crisis. The author presents through the story her explanation of how God works in these things and this explanation is probably good as far as it goes.
***There may be a bit of a spoiler in the paragraph that follows, but I don't think so. If you open this "spoiler", it reveals some of the feel of the climax, but no specifics.
Both Clark and Marty show deep and mature faith in this story. At times Willie fades into the background. Missie is not the center of this story, but rather she is in many ways back to being Clark and Marty's daughter. There are significant contributions by several other people in this story.
It is hard to say that there are mature themes in this book, but there are a couple of things worth noting. There is still no sex. There is a brief mention in a backstory of a suicide. And of course the central tragedy touches on why bad things happen to good people.
September 4, 2025
Number of pages: 240
Genre: Historical Fiction Romance
Series: Love Comes Softly #4
Age recommendation: 16+
Summary: Clark and Marty go out west to visit Missie and Willie on the ranch. A tragic accident has them staying longer than they intended… can they trust God even through that?
My thoughts: I admire Clark and Marty’s attitude throughout the whole book. They are so thoughtful of other people and their feelings, as well as leaning on God's guidance and trusting His plans in their life even when things are tough.
This book was really good for Christian content. The gospel is clearly explained, and there is a lot of talking about praying, trusting God and accepting that His will, not ours, be done. This especially comes out with Clark’s accident: Missie wants to pray for a miracle, and while Marty wants a miracle as well, she prays that God's will is done. It isn’t always easy for her to accept, but she trusts that ultimately God is in control and will do what’s best.
There are a few scenes talking about a broken leg that might be a bit much for sensitive readers
I loved hearing more of Juan and Maria’s story in this book. I don’t want to say too much and spoil anything, but it was very nice that they could help out Clark and Marty’s family, and that they could resolve some issues of their own.
I think it’s cool how much of a witness Lane can be to the other cowboys. He doesn’t necessarily talk with them about his faith, but they see him reading his Bible, going to church, and just in general how he acts in a way pleasing to God… it leaves an impression and that’s amazing.
Overall, I really enjoyed this story and would definitely recommend! This might even be my favourite book in the series yet!
My personal rating: 4.5/5 stars.
Link to blog: https://karinaschristianreads.wordpre...
Genre: Historical Fiction Romance
Series: Love Comes Softly #4
Age recommendation: 16+
Summary: Clark and Marty go out west to visit Missie and Willie on the ranch. A tragic accident has them staying longer than they intended… can they trust God even through that?
My thoughts: I admire Clark and Marty’s attitude throughout the whole book. They are so thoughtful of other people and their feelings, as well as leaning on God's guidance and trusting His plans in their life even when things are tough.
This book was really good for Christian content. The gospel is clearly explained, and there is a lot of talking about praying, trusting God and accepting that His will, not ours, be done. This especially comes out with Clark’s accident: Missie wants to pray for a miracle, and while Marty wants a miracle as well, she prays that God's will is done. It isn’t always easy for her to accept, but she trusts that ultimately God is in control and will do what’s best.
There are a few scenes talking about a broken leg that might be a bit much for sensitive readers
I loved hearing more of Juan and Maria’s story in this book. I don’t want to say too much and spoil anything, but it was very nice that they could help out Clark and Marty’s family, and that they could resolve some issues of their own.
I think it’s cool how much of a witness Lane can be to the other cowboys. He doesn’t necessarily talk with them about his faith, but they see him reading his Bible, going to church, and just in general how he acts in a way pleasing to God… it leaves an impression and that’s amazing.
Overall, I really enjoyed this story and would definitely recommend! This might even be my favourite book in the series yet!
My personal rating: 4.5/5 stars.
Link to blog: https://karinaschristianreads.wordpre...
September 28, 2017
Marty misses Missie and Willie and the granchildren she's never met. Her family is helping her celebrate her forty-second birthday and Clark gives her a wonderful gift - train tickets out West! She's going to see Missie!
The travel is not comfortable - Marty wonders if it's any better than a wagon - but it's much quicker and soon she is hugging her daughter and meeting her grandsons, Nathan and Josiah.
Willie's ranch has grown and they have a real rock house now. The LaHayes have made a good life out West and that makes Clark and Marty happy.
The time together passes quickly, but due to an accident in a mine, the Davis' stay is greatly extended. Clark loses his left leg as a result and must recuperate. Missie spends so much time fussing over him and caring for him, that she is neglecting her husband and sons. Clark and Marty both realize this, so they move out to the soddy for the winter. I think they end up staying out there almost two years? Year and a half? It's a long time.
Things go well back home. Clare got married, Clae and Joe moved to the city so Joe could go to seminary, Luke is training with the doctor.
During the time out west, Clark helps start a church, a school is built, and they get a doctor. Turns out that Willie and Missie's neighbor, Juan de la Rosa, is a doctor. He lost confidence after a tragedy, but helping Clark and talking things through, as well as reconciliation with his family, restored his confidence and he is back to being a doctor.
The book ends with Clark and Marty heading back home, leaving behind Willie, Missie, the boys, and a soon-to-arrive grandchild, as well as all the friends they've made during their stay.
The travel is not comfortable - Marty wonders if it's any better than a wagon - but it's much quicker and soon she is hugging her daughter and meeting her grandsons, Nathan and Josiah.
Willie's ranch has grown and they have a real rock house now. The LaHayes have made a good life out West and that makes Clark and Marty happy.
The time together passes quickly, but due to an accident in a mine, the Davis' stay is greatly extended. Clark loses his left leg as a result and must recuperate. Missie spends so much time fussing over him and caring for him, that she is neglecting her husband and sons. Clark and Marty both realize this, so they move out to the soddy for the winter. I think they end up staying out there almost two years? Year and a half? It's a long time.
Things go well back home. Clare got married, Clae and Joe moved to the city so Joe could go to seminary, Luke is training with the doctor.
During the time out west, Clark helps start a church, a school is built, and they get a doctor. Turns out that Willie and Missie's neighbor, Juan de la Rosa, is a doctor. He lost confidence after a tragedy, but helping Clark and talking things through, as well as reconciliation with his family, restored his confidence and he is back to being a doctor.
The book ends with Clark and Marty heading back home, leaving behind Willie, Missie, the boys, and a soon-to-arrive grandchild, as well as all the friends they've made during their stay.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 27, 2025
A short, easy read. It doesn’t have the same magic as the first book for sure, but it’s a solid next installment in the series. Having only ever seen the movie adaption of this book before, I was surprised how much it differs. I think my only thing that I don’t love about this book (and the others in the series) is that when you have a lighter book the characters seem less real and complex and so it doesn’t feel as genuine when they are preaching. For example, a book with predictable plot is not always a bad thing, but it’s hard to get awed by “God’s miracles” therein when they lend themselves so conveniently to the plot of the book. Doesn’t always feel as much like a miracle as a lazy storytelling method. Thinking through it I don’t know if there is a way around this unless you wrote books that were more complex in characters and plot. Otherwise, I liked this book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 266 reviews