This is one of those books where the oodles of charm can be at odds with the quality of the material and in order to rate it you have to decide which wins out. Lets first tackle what I had trouble with.
Typically I can easily overlook dialect in a book but right off the bat I was confused, annoyed and also a bit charmed by the Southern slang/phrases/names and some dialogue. The characters use the word "least" as in, "I'm all yours. Least tonight" or "Least I remember how to kiss" so often that I stopped reading at one point to google 'least' vs 'atleast' since it was so distracting. I got over it eventually and shrugged it off as a Southern thing.
Then names like LulaJean, Prissy, Minerva and Bebe which could be widely used in the South for all I know started to bother me. Other character names like Charlotte, Camilla, RL and Griff were just as "Southern" but without being distracting. At some point however Prissy (short for Priscilla) grew on me (how embarrassing!) but others felt contrived (like Minerva who is a Voodoo/Vodou mambo).
Speaking of contrived, this story has a paranormal aspect to it that I felt kind of came out of left field. Maybe I missed the ques but I didn't expect it. That could be because often one paragraph to the next there was suddenly a major shift in the action. More than once I had to back track and reread because I was sure I had missed several important paragraphs in between.
The setting is smack dab in the heart of Savannah and for someone who has visited or lived there I'm sure the familiarity of the locales is a treat. For me, having only recently wanted to visit but never having been, I thought it was overdone. I didn't mind the few mentions of what tourists seek out (like the Paula Deen stuff) or the mentions of local hangouts but there were so many mentions just for the heck of it that they become distracting.
Another distraction was that several times a character is talked about as if we've already met them. The 'who they are' isn't explained until several sentences, paragraphs or even pages later. More than once I flipped back several pages to try to figure out who and why she was talking about this new person. Then once I realized this was a pattern I stopped looking back to save time, but not confusion.
The H/h attraction is years and years and years in the making and it was a bit unrealistic that all of a sudden they decide they are going to try to be together. The actual getting together takes mere days and then it's on and off and on and off and... That's not generally something I would complain about as it adds tension but it was a distraction too.
There are several unanswered questions like what are Vincent and Anthony up to? Where is the necklace? Why do 3 of the 4 ladies get a love story but only 2 of the 4 get a HEA?
There's just a lot (a lot) going on in this book and I think that's what gave me the most trouble. I had the whole story figured out by page 33 but everything still took a long, convoluted time to come together.
Also, apparently there is a class war that is still prevalent in Savannah and while the book makes several mentions it doesn't really explain it. Had I not read the back jacket I probably wouldn't have even noticed. I'd recommend not reading the jacket. It's misleading. I don't need an explanation of what a class war is but since it played a part in the story, maybe a little background with specifics would have helped. Perhaps it's a Southern thing? Not class wars...the whole 'explaining things' idea. I kid. I have nothing against Southerners (though Yanks get no love in this book) and notwithstanding my complaints I did actually find the book as a whole to be a good read...and charming.
The love scenes were nicely done. Some were steamy, some were hot, some were brazen and some coy. I ended up liking every character, even ones you were meant to dislike. I did like the Southern aspect like calling your Dad, Daddy and the attitude on cursing and some of the little phrases like 'good gravy.' So I liked the Southern charm even when I didn't like it. It made me what to visit Savannah even more. Though this isn't a series it looks as if two books by Castell are in the same vein as this one; one is even about the 4th girl I mentioned above who doesn't get a love story in this book. While I'm mildly interested in her story (Bebe's) I am not eager to read more. I will read Castell again if her books pop up at my library but I won't immediately seek them out. I know where to go when I'm in the mood for a little Southern hospitality though.