In the ancient city of York, winter brings Christmas markets, cold weather…and murder.
Snow dusts the cobbled streets of York as tourists flock to its famous Christmas markets. But for DCI Oldroyd, what starts as a peaceful evening on a ghost tour quickly turns deadly.
The tour guide’s grim discovery is no theatrical performance—he finds the body of Henry Marlow, a notorious local landlord, in the doorway of a derelict building. Oldroyd soon has no shortage of a resentful ex-wife, angry tenants, and even the guide who knows every secret passage of the old city.
As festive lights sparkle above the narrow passageways of York, darkness gathers below when a second body is found in the shadow of the ancient cathedral. Can Oldroyd untangle the web of secrets and lies before anyone else dies? As the holiday season approaches, it seems the killer is planning on making this a Christmas to remember—for all the wrong reasons…
During a long career teaching English, I wrote plays for children and occasional ghost stories. I have always been fascinated by the paranormal and by mysteries, conspiracy theories and unexplained crimes. My love of my native county is deep and the settings of my Yorkshire Murder Mysteries within Yorkshire's varied landscapes are important. I have made a study of the sub-genre of the Locked Room Mystery during the height of its popularity between 1930 - 1960 in the stories of writers such as John Dickson Carr, Clayton Rawson and Ellery Queen. I was an avid watcher of BBC's "Jonathan Creek" in its heyday. I believe the element of puzzle is essential to crime fiction and my novels contain a double mystery: the standard "who dunnit?" but also "how dunnit?!" I avoid the dark and gruesome in my writing and I strive to include some humour and elegance in style, a vivid sense of place and a compelling mystery! My characters both innocent and guilty are mostly ordinary people. I am a member of a writers' group in Otley which has inspired me to write poetry and various forms of short fiction.
The twelfth book in the series and I have read all of them. This time the action takes place in York, a city I used to know well, and it was fun to read about the history and the all touristy things everyone does when visiting.
DCI Oldroyd is there for a conference but he spends some free time going on a ghost tour where he discovers a dead body in a narrow alley. He manages to get himself placed to assist the local police in what is obviously a murder case. It turns out to be a very complex case with more deaths and a huge number of possible suspects.
I enjoy all of the characters in this series and look forward to finding out what is happening to each one in every new episode. A new baby on the way is a huge development for two of my favourite characters. Looking forward to more about that in the next book.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this book.
I received a free copy of, Murder in York, by J. R. Ellis, from the publisher and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This is book 12 of 12 in the Yorkshire Murder Mysteries series. Its Christmas in York, but murder does not stop just because the weather turns cold or there is a holiday. This was a good read, I enjoyed the tidbits of history at the start of the chapters.
DCI Oldroyd is in York for a rather tiresome training course, so he decides to go on one of the city's ghost tours. Unexpectedly, they come across a murder victim, an unkind property developer with similarities to Ebenezer Scrooge. The local police ask Oldroyd to help with the case. No one really mourns this unpleasant miser, so there are plenty of suspects. An estranged wife or her boyfriend who will reap financial rewards? One of his tenants for whom he refused to fix the mold in the flat which was harming their daughter?
Great book from start to finish, its so lovely and great to read a book depict the city I currently live in so well. I know there are some areas that have been made up in fiction, but I learnt alot whilst reading this book that I didn't think I would. I like how each chapter has a touch of history displayed which really adds to the descriptions of the scenery and wonderful city. This is a light comfortable read, which at points were unpredictable to guess, which had me on my toes whilst reading. Furthermore, add in the natural character development of the team which comes across natural and authentic (and not forced). A solid read, defiantly would recommend, this book also does touch upon key issues York is currently facing, only making the book feel more genuine and authentic.
The book centres around DCI Oldroyd who is visiting York on a conference. One night, whilst going on a ghost walk to pass time, he finds a body in an alleyway known as Henry Marlow who is a notorious local landlord outside a derelict building. Oldroyd soon figures that the list of suspects is ever growing. As Christmas is nearing sooner in York, a second body is discovered in the shadow of the ancient catherdral. Its a race against time with Oldroyd to uncover the secrets and web of lies before another body is discovered.
Overall its a great book, great series. Will be keeping my eye out for the next book of the series.
This was an intriguing murder mystery set in York. I enjoyed the brief history at the start of each chapter. However, there were too many points of view for my liking. I prefer to follow the thoughts and actions of just one or two characters. With so many characters it is hard to get attached or get to know any one in particular. I look for memorable and likeable detectives in my crime series. DCI Oldroyd was just okay. There were a few side characters and subplots that did not interest me. While the book was entertaining enough, it does not stand out in the many crime novels I have read.
Thanks to Netgalley and Amazon Publishing UK for the ARC.
It’s always good to be back with Oldroyd and his team, and this book is set in York so what could be better? How about adding a bit of a Scrooge, Dickens and Christmas theme into the mix. With all these elements how could the book be anything but a hit!
Whilst on a conference in York, as part of a Ghost Tour during his down time Oldroyd comes across a body in a snickelway. The murder isn’t on his patch but he offers his services, and those of his team, and this is very quickly taken up by the Detective in charge of the case. This sets off quite a complex case for Oldroyd, as every man, woman and his dog seems to have a grudge against the victim, and if anything there are too many suspects.
I love the writing of these books and the pace that is kept up with them, and even better if you haven’t read any books in the series they read well as standalones. Oldroyd is a fantastic and a fascinating character, and is ably supported by a great team. It’s also good to see in the is book police from two areas working together collaboratively without the usual antithesis towards each other you usually come across in books.
These books always give a good overview of the case, the various suspects, and the investigation of the crime, very much a purest in terms of police procedural. This is exactly what I want to see in a police procedural, and as usual J R Ellis delivers. The tenacity of Oldroyd is always good to see as he sets about finding out and getting his man or woman! As usual there are a few twists, turns and dead ends along the way. At points in the book retirement was discussed or thought about by Oldroyd, and I only hope that he stays right away from that, I think he’d be a nightmare and at a loss if he retired, and I might just cry!
I liked in this book how each chapter started with a small snippet of the history of York, that only added to the book.
If you love police procedural I definitely recommend this book and the whole series which is set in and around rural Yorkshire.
This is my first time reading this series and I am looking forward to reading more. I live in Yorkshire and visit York frequently. So to see this story set there intrigued me, especially as I knew most of the places that was mentioned. This brought the book to life for me.
The story is a set around Christmas in York ( it’s such a beautiful time of year with the Christmas markets). DCI Oldroyd’s Ghost tour turned darker than he imagined when he finds a real dead body and its secrets begin to unravel. With many suspects this is a wonderful ‘who done it’ story that keeps you guessing until the end.
I found the story easy to read. The mixture of old and new skills of the police officers involved made the investigation and interactions between the characters more realistic for me.
Even though this is part of a series. I feel that I was able to read it as a standalone.
Thank you to Netgallery, the Author and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to review this book.
3.5 stars rounded up. I've recently vacationed in York myself, so why not pick up a murder mystery set there? Well, I was captivated, but not fully convinced. The plot itself was straighforward, easy to follow and the suspect was not quite who it thought. That was an actual fun (but really a sad-ish twist!). The downside was that there were a POV or two too much included for me. Some POVs did not contribute much to the overall plot in my opinion and took away a bit of my enjoyment. There was also a lot of telling, instead of showing, which i am not that much used to - but that might be because contemporary fiction isnt my usual forte. Great read for anyone who wants a cozy (as cozy as a murder mystery can be!) season read, set in a great atmospheric city.
DCI Oldroyd is in York being bored at one of those awful conventions that so many of us have to go to for work. In an effort to learn more about the town, he decides to take a ghost tour. While on tour, Oldroyd comes across a dead body, and offers to help the officers with his expertise. The body is that of Henry Marlow, a notoriously bad local landlord. And did I mention it is also Christmastime? Definitely shades of Dickens' A Christmas Carol...
This was my first of the series, but I have already added it to my to-buy list. DCI Oldroyd and his cohorts are all interesting characters, I liked the use of the York setting, and the narrative was engaging. Overall, this is a great police procedural.
Snow dusts the cobbled streets of York as tourists flock to its famous Christmas markets. But for DCI Oldroyd, what starts as a peaceful evening on a ghost tour quickly turns deadly. The tour guide’s grim discovery is no theatrical performance—he finds the body of Henry Marlow, a notorious local landlord, in the doorway of a derelict building. Oldroyd soon has no shortage of suspects. Then a second body is found. The twelfth book in the series & another well written cosy mystery. I do like Oldroyd & thoroughly enjoyed this book. There are quite a few suspects plus the usual twists, turns & red herrings, I was kept guessing which is always a plus. Also it’s set in my native Yorkshire & in one of my favourite cities I voluntarily read and reviewed a special copy of this book; all thoughts and opinions are my own
I enjoyed this book. It took me a little while to get into it for two reasons. First you are given a little bit of history about York at the start of each chapter and I was trying to work out how it related to the story, it didn't it. Secondly this is my first adventure into DCI Oldroyd world and as the story gives you a number of perspectives from different characters, you were introduced to lots of characters right from the start and not knowing who was who I struggled to begin with. As the story unfolded I soon got a better understanding and enjoyed it more. I can see why the author did it that way because with all the different perspectives you got a lot of suspects and more of an understanding of why so many people hated him. I did come to like the characters and the author even had me hoping that certain ones had nothing to do with the deaths. I liked the fact that the two police forces were working together to resolve the murder, without any rivalry. It was a good job DCI Oldroyd and the team were working the case because I had no clue who the killer was. The story mostlly focused on the case, which is what I like but you had the occasional shopping trip in the run up to Christmas, which set the scene and mood for the listener and it was a nice insight into the characters home life drama, without taking over. A nicely balanced police procedural mystery, that despite being set in York had me thinking of Morse for some reason.
DCI Oldroyd conference is cut short, when trying to unwind after a particularly boring talk he discovers a dead body on a ghost walk. He offers his services to the detective in charge and soon finds himself knee feel in suspects. The dead man was a notoriously cheep landlord and not many people liked him. Things get more complicated when a homeless person is found dead in another alleyway. With officers down with winter bugs and not many more shopping days to go in the busy streets, tension is high and the homeless are not the only ones worrying, Can Oldroyd wrap things up quickly? And more importantly before anybody else gets hurt? I liked the narrator. He was a good choice for the role and with his fairly deep voice he was still pleasant to listen too. I was given this free review copy audio book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
Murder in York by JR Elllis is a compelling and confusing series of murders taking place on old town York. Because Detective Chief Inspector Jim Oldroyd of Harrogate happened to be in York for a conference and happened to take a ghost tour that evening, he was now included in the investigation. He had found the body. He was able to have his sergeant, Andy Carter, join him. He enjoyed not being the inspector-in-charge and was enjoying York. The dead man was called Henry Marlow and to be blunt, he was a slum lord, found dead in one of his own slums. Plenty of suspects there. It was an intriguing mystery, visiting sites in old York that anyone who is familiar, will enjoy revisiting. Then there was another murder: a homeless man; and another: another homeless man. Were they right in investigating Marlow’s murder as personal or was one just one of many by a serial killer. They kept investigating, talking to people. Meanwhile there were others involved: Marlow’s estranged wife, who was having a crisis of conscience, for one; Samantha a homeless woman who wanted the murders to stop and did something about it, and Philip Storey, the curator of a highly interesting small museum of Roman artifacts. Oldroyd thoroughly enjoyed that one.
Oldroyd is now middle-aged, divorced, with a new partner. He felt bad abut his ex-wife. He knew he had let her and the kids down, but he was happy in his new relationship, as was is ex-wife, so all is well. Andy and Steph, both sergeants, were kind of his protegees. He considered retirement, but he was not ready. He could do to slow down a little, though. He was enjoying not being in charge. When all the existing leads dried up, he went with his gut, as he had often in the past. It worked. Oldroyd is a fabulous character, a mix of old world and new. He is a man with a sense of humor, who cares deeply for others. Some of this book was him looking back on his life and assessing, if you will. It was a good and complicated mystery, tough for the constabulary to get its collective minds around. Kept the reader guessing, too. Good read.
I was invited to read Murder in York by Amazon Publishing UK. All thoughts and opinions are mine. #Netgalley #AmazonPublishingUK #ThomasAndMercer #JREllis #MurderInYork
"Murder In York" is book #12 in "Yorkshire Murder Mysteries" by J. R. Ellis.
While attending a conference in York, DCI Jim Oldroyd takes a break one evening to take part in a ghost walk. During the walk, the group discovers a body in a derelict building. The victim turns out to be a slum landlord named Henry Marlow who only cared about lining his own pockets. Within days, a second body is found - this time a homeless man. As Oldroyd was on the scene, the York police ask him to consult on the case. It's a complicated case and not what anyone wanted just a couple of weeks before Christmas.
The murders create an interesting case but the story also explores the struggles of the homeless population, those who live in poorly maintained dwellings and how various services try to help those in need. It wasn't done in a preachy sort of way just laying out some of the realities that people may face.
There were any number of people who may have wanted the property owner dead and it took a while to sort out alibis - especially after the second murder. I had a strong hunch as to who killed the slumlord but there were some very good twists along the way to make the truth of the entire situation more complicated once it was fully revealed.
As always with this series, readers get to know the core characters a bit more. Not at all surprised at the development with one of the couples...
Though there were several minor typos - mostly a word missing here or there but not enough to loose the meaning of the sentence.
Overall this was a interesting murder mystery with excellent insight into living conditions on and off the street.
Atmospheric, thoughtful, and deeply special — one of the best in the series.
Murder in York is the 12th book in the series, and it reminded me once again why I love these books so much. Oldroyd continues to be a marvellous protagonist — steady, thoughtful, and always guided by a quiet sense of justice. He’s one of those characters who feels completely real, and returning to him feels like reconnecting with someone you know well and genuinely admire.
One of the things I especially appreciated in this instalment is how J.R. Ellis weaves important real-world issues into the narrative. The book handles themes of homelessness and inadequate housing with sensitivity and weight, giving the mystery emotional depth beyond just “whodunnit.” It feels grounded and human, which I really value.
As always, I adored the descriptive opening paragraphs to each chapter. The way Ellis introduces landmarks, streets, and historical notes brings the city alive on the page. These books are set where I was born, and every time I read one, I feel like I’m walking familiar paths. It’s both comforting and emotional in the best way.
I also listened to the audiobook, and the narrator is wonderful. The accent, the rhythm, the tone — it made me miss home so much I could have cried, in the loveliest way.
A beautifully written mystery with heart, atmosphere, and a deep sense of place. This series continues to mean a lot to me, and this instalment is one I’ll remember fondly.
My thanks to Netgalley and Brilliance audio and Thomas & Mercer for the ARC in the form of an audiobook!
DCI Oldroyd is in historic York for a boring seminar on policing. Since he already uses his brain full time on investigations, he takes a breather to entertain himself in a Ghost Tour. But this is Oldroyd, so of course he finds a nearly fresh body in a building whit a puddle of blood seeping under an unlocked door. Turns out that the victim is a modern-day Scrooge, so there's no shortage of suspects. It's nearing Christmas, but his department lets him assist the York station (since he did find the body) and even lets him bring in his offsider. And so the investigation begins and it's all amazingly twisty. Fun read full of misdirection and seriously baffling plot twists. Lots about the history of the area from Roman times to the present. Super! Guilty of a biased review because I love this series. I really like this bunch of coppers, especially DCI Oldroyd. I requested and received a temporary uncorrected review galley from Amazon Publishing UK | Thomas & Mercer via NetGalley. #MurderinYork by #JREllis #YorkshireMurderMysteriesBk12 #NetGalley #goodreads #bookbub #librarythingofficial #barnesandnoble ***** Review #booksamillion #bookshop_org #bookshop_org_uk #bookshop_org_ca #kobo #Waterstones #England #Procedural #thriftbooks #murders @the.storygraph #majorcrimes #secrets #lies #crimethriller #BrillianceAudio #cozycrime #familydynamics #friendship #witty #slyhumor #historicalinfo #historicalresearch
DCI Oldroyd is on a ghost tour in ancient York, when he comes across the body of Henry Marlow, a local landlord despised by many of his tenants. Oldroyd is in York at a convention, and then offers to stay and work on the murder investigation - an offer that is quickly accepted.
It turns out that this is quite a complex case - with too many suspects, especially when an additional body is found. We get to see the detective working in a new location and with the local force, allowing for some additional characters. The story is set in the run up to Christmas, and we get the lovely descriptions of the area at this time of year, as well as some of the home life dynamics of the officers as they try to get ready for Christmas while working on a difficult case.
The author manages to touch on some difficult social situations too, as homelessness and slum landlords are covered in the plot.
This was another very enjoyable book in the series, and the narrator did (yet again) a really good job with the audiobook. He manages to convey the typical Yorkshire characteristics of Oldroyd and the other regular characters as well as a strong sense of the location.
As usual, there is always a little too much praise for Oldroyd at the end, as we get told just what a marvelous man he is. The books show this, so I never feel the need for this at the end -but it is the same in each of the book in the series!
Go on a ghost tour and end up investigating a murder
While at a less-than-inspiring training course, DCI Oldroyd takes a break for a ghost tour. Thinking the tour will give him a bit of history about the area, DCI Oldroyd instead finds a dead body. The victim, a largely disliked property owner. There are plenty of suspects, and things worsen when a second body is found. Oldroyd skips the rest of the training course and, with Andy, his trusty left hand, investigates. His trusty right hand, Steph, is on another assignment. Given the closeness to the intended release date, I could not help but draw similarities between the first victim to Scrooge. There were so many possible suspects it almost seemed as though the cause might not get resolved.
Is Oldroyd looking to return? What would he do with his days? While I know that eventually this will occur, it is not a day that I am looking forward to. There is also some future planning for Andy and Steph.
As with all the books in this series so far, the pace has been great, the story captivating, and the narration on point. I enjoyed on things evolved with this series and the characters.
I also like how this book can be read standalone without feeling like missing something. It also works great when it has been a while since reading the previous book.
Thank you, #Netgalley and #ThomasMercer, for the early read and the opportunity to share my thoughts.
There’s something deliciously atmospheric about a murder mystery set against the backdrop of York’s snow-dusted cobbled streets and twinkling Christmas markets. J.R. Ellis captures that magic with ease in Murder in York, weaving a tale that’s as cozy as it is chilling.
DCI Oldroyd returns in this twelfth installment, and he’s as sharp and quietly compelling as ever. What begins as a ghost tour on a wintry evening quickly spirals into a layered investigation when a local landlord is found dead in a derelict doorway. Ellis doesn’t just give us suspects—he gives us characters with depth, grudges, secrets, and just enough ambiguity to keep us guessing.
The pacing is gentle but deliberate, like a stroll through York’s winding alleyways. And while the mystery unfolds with satisfying twists, it’s the setting that truly sings: the ancient cathedral casting long shadows, the festive lights flickering above narrow lanes, and the ever-present chill that seems to seep into the bones of the story.
This is a book to curl up with—preferably with a blanket, a cup of something warm, and maybe a mince pie or two. It’s not just a whodunit; it’s a love letter to Yorkshire in winter, with all its charm and quiet menace. As a Yorkshire lass myself i really enjoyed this one!
With thanks to J R Ellis, the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
In the historic city of York, a murderer is on the loose after the stabbing of a local landlord—infamous for being Scrooge incarnate and treating his tenants terribly. DCI Oldroyd happens upon the body while on a Ghost Hunt, and he and his partner Andy take on the case, navigating a trail full of twists and turns.
I really enjoyed the descriptive writing and strong scene setting. The interesting York facts at the start of each chapter were such a nice touch. As a Yorkshire girl with a background in legal and police work, I instantly liked Oldroyd’s old-school style, and the narrator’s accent suited the story perfectly.
I didn’t realise this book was part of a series, so I’ll definitely be picking up the earlier installments. I also appreciated how the story shines a light on the devastating truth of homelessness across the UK. Having visited York many times—and it being one of my favourite places—I loved hearing the street names and picturing them clearly in my mind.
The mystery kept me guessing right to the end; it certainly wasn’t easy to identify the killer. I also enjoyed the dynamic between Oldroyd and Andy—they make a great team. And the ending tied everything up nicely.
Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance Publishing for this lovely ARC.
This police procedural revolves around the investigation of what initially appears to be a deeply personal murder, but as the body count rises, the fear grows that a serial killer might be on the loose. Thankyou to NetGalley and Amazon Publishing UK for the ARC. My review is voluntary. The story unfolds in and around the Snickelways of York, where the city's December atmosphere provides the perfect backdrop for a murder mystery. The location, with its unique physical traits and the mood it evokes, transforms York into a character in its own right. In the prefaces to each chapter the magnificent history of York is described. It contrasts sharply with one of the main motifs of the book which is poverty particularly homelessness and poor housing conditions. By the end of the book the historical and social strands are brought together. because of a man who held both in disdain. There is just enough insight into the police officers' private lives to make them three-dimensional while avoiding becoming overly domestic. Characters act in surprising ways, challenging our assumptions and biases. For example, homeless Samantha emerges as a strong leader. However, Janice's transformation felt a bit abrupt to me. Fans of Val McDermid and Ann Cleeves will enjoy this book.
J.R. Ellis's latest installment in the DCI Oldroyd series is a deliciously atmospheric murder mystery set against the enchanting backdrop of York's snow-dusted, cobbled streets and twinkling Christmas markets. Ellis weaves a tale that's both cozy and chilling, capturing the magic of the season with ease. DCI Oldroyd remains as sharp and quietly compelling as ever. The story begins with a ghost tour on a wintry evening, quickly escalating into a complex investigation when a local landlord is found dead in a derelict doorway. Ellis masterfully crafts characters with depth, grudges, and secrets, keeping us guessing until the very end. The pacing is gentle yet deliberate, reminiscent of a leisurely stroll through York's winding alleyways. The setting truly shines, with the ancient cathedral casting long shadows, festive lights flickering above narrow lanes, and an ever-present chill that seeps into the bones of the story. This is the perfect book to curl up with—preferably with a blanket, a warm drink, and perhaps a mince pie or two. It's more than just a whodunit; it's a love letter to Yorkshire in winter, filled with charm and a touch of menace. Thanks to J R Ellis, the publisher, and NetGalley for the ARC.
The Yorkshire Mysteries series is hit or miss with me. I figured out how it depends on the underlying theme: vampires, trains? Yes! Beer manufacturers? No. This one is about Christmas, history and the Romans, so I knew I’d love it and was not disappointed. It’s almost Christmas and, in the middle of a ghost tour in York, Oldroyd finds a dead body. The victim was Ebenezer Scrooge. Well, not really but he was also a horrible human, cheap, selfish and spread misery wherever he went. Oldroyd is only helping this time, but there are so many suspects, that they have to work hard to close the case before the Holidays. Then, a homeless man is also murdered so, is this a serial killer choosing whatever victim is convenient? Another thing I’ve found about this series is that I don’t enjoy it half as much in print. I need Michael Page’s audiobook narration to really get into it. His Oldroyd is the voice I hear in my head when I read. I enjoyed this performance as usual. He is very skilled and I love his voices. It may be Page, the plot or the Christmas setting, but I enjoyed this one. I chose to listen to this audiobook and all opinions in this review are my own and completely unbiased. Thank you, NetGalley/Brilliance Audio.
Murder in York (Yorkshire Murder Mysteries #12) by J.R. Ellis
DCI Oldroyd is in York for a training course which he wishes not to be at, so he goes on one of the city's ghost tours. Unexpectedly, they come across a murder victim, a property developer that doesn't take care of his properties basically he is a slum lord. The local police ask Oldroyd to help with the case no one really cares that property manager is dead, so there are plenty of suspects. An estranged wife or her boyfriend who will reap financial rewards? One of his tenants for whom he refused to fix the mold in the flat which was harming their daughter? Then some homeless individuals end up murdered is there a serial killer on the lose?
I love the British mysteries they tend to be so entertaining. This is no different I loved getting to know DCI Oldroyd and his desire to solve crimes. This was a well written story, and I plan at some point going back to read the series. This can be read as a standalone. I highly recommend this book is you like British mysteries and mysteries in general.
This audio book was narrated by Michael Page, and he did a great job bringing the characters to life.
Thank you to NetGalley and Brilliance audio for a free audio copy of Murder in York for an honest review.
I chose this book because I was looking for an easy read after some heavy duty December books and a busy season. I was looking for a Christmas theme and, as I have been to York a couple of years ago AND gone on one of their ghost tours, this seemed the ticket. It isn’t a deep read but the tidbits about York, especially references to its Roman past and the famous Quaker family the Rowntrees, made an interesting addition to the story. Also the murder touches on modern issues of homelessness and poverty, which seemed fitting given the allusions to the Rowntrees’ study of the causes of poverty. In the Acknowledgements the author asks if the reader “got” the hints about A Christmas Carol. Well, with the first victim being called Marley and his being a skinflint, one could hardly miss it :) There were references to other books that Ellis has written and I might dip into a couple of the earlier ones as those plots sounded a bit more complex than this one where the emphasis is more on York and its history than the murder. Not that I’m complaining at all. York is a beautiful city, I’m going to go look at my photo album of my visit there tonight :) Merry Christmas!
Reading Murder in York by J.R. Ellis felt like settling into my favourite armchair, a soft blanket wrapped around me, while the warmth of an open fire flickered nearby. The atmosphere of the story, much like the changing season outside the window, was both inviting and chilling. Ellis’s evocative descriptions of York brought the city vividly to life—I could almost hear my own footsteps echoing along the cobblestones and picture myself slipping into one of those narrow snickelways. At times, the imagery was so immersive it sent shivers down my spine.
The familiar cast of characters made the experience even more special. Having read previous books by this author, it felt like returning to the company of old friends—comfortable, reliable, and always intriguing. Their interactions and insights gave the narrative a warmth that balanced beautifully against the darker threads of the mystery.
This truly was a page-turner. The combination of atmospheric setting, compelling storytelling, and beloved characters made me reluctant to put it down. Murder in York is not just a mystery; it’s an experience that makes you feel at home while keeping you deliciously on edge.
DCI Oldroyd is in York for a tiresome training course and takes an evening off to go on a ghost tour. During the tour, he finds the real body of a murder victim and he stays in York to assist the York police in their investigation. The victim is a real Scrooge character; a slumlord who refuses to fix his rundown properties and thinks Scrooge has the right idea about the poor. When he is killed, there is a long list of potential suspects, but the investigation gets complicated when homeless men are killed, too. This is all set against the historic town of York during the Christmas season. I enjoyed the York history that was included at the beginning of each chapter and learning about the current day York. The mystery is solved in time for everyone to enjoy their holiday with family and friends and ends with a very warm, coziness. Thanks to Amazon Publishing UK and NetGalley for the ARC.
Good old DCI Oldroyd. Imagine going to a work conference and actually having to work! What’s supposed to be a relaxing ghost tour in York turns into yet another murder for Oldroyd to solve.
I loved how each chapter begins with a little slice of York’s history since it gives the story such depth and charm. The mystery itself is full of twists and turns, especially since the victim isn’t exactly everyone’s favorite person. There are suspects everywhere you look! I also laughed out loud at the small, thoughtful touches, like a wife sending her husband on a shopping errand to share the mental load. So relatable.
Michael Page did a tremendous job of both being engaging and bringing the characters to life in a style befitting of the story. I can’t wait to start recommending this Christmastime murder mystery when it releases on November 18th! Huge thanks to NetGalley and Brilliance Audio for the advanced listening copy.
DCI Oldroyd returns in top form! Book 12 in the series doesn't disappoint, but if you're new to these books, don't worry, it's easily read as a standalone. Stuck at a tedious conference in York, Oldroyd's evening ghost tour takes a dark turn when he discovers the body of the Scrooge-like property developer, Marlow tucked away in a snickelway. Suddenly, Oldroyd is knee-deep in a murder case alongside the local team. With an abundance of suspects and a quickly rising body count, the investigation is packed with false leads and red herrings. I absolutely loved the fast pace and the author's illustrative narrative, which brings historic York to life. The character development is second to none and the brief, fascinating history lesson at the start of each chapter added a brilliant informative dimension. The ending was constructed as neatly as an ancient Roman mosaic and I simply cannot wait for the next one. I received an advance copy of this book and this is my own view.
In writing and in narration, this has the feel of a classic British murder mystery. The moment that Michael Page, the narrator, began talking, it put a big smile on my face.
I have read or listened to a lot of mystery/thrillers lately and they have been dark and sometimes graphic in nature. This is just plain fun. Sure, murder is involved, but the characters are so good and quirky. It is a lighthearted read/listen. In a way, it was good to cleanse the palate.
I was pleased to find out this was a series, and I look forward to catching up on the previous eleven (!) novels. But to be honest, I will probably find the audiobooks so I can hear the brilliant Michael Page once again. He added so much to this novel.
I received this ARC from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an unbiased review.
The 12th book in the Yorkshire Murder series. Oldroyd and his superior Tom are at a conference in York. One evening, Oldroyd takes a walk to join a ghost tour, but gets more than he bargained for when he sees a body slouched in a doorway, with blood seeping from it. In the coming days Oldroyd is allowed to stay and help with the investigation, drafting in his trusty Sergeant Andy Carter. The victim, Henry Marlow, was a rogue landlord and property developer and there’s certainly no shortage of potential victims!
As time moves on, another two murders are committed and the police are secretly saying it’s the same murderer trying to mislead them. Oldroyd has one of his famous lightbulb moments, but, as usual, does not want to show his hand before he logically thinks things through.
As always, it’s a pleasure to read one of this series of books.