What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lover's Eye
Named the ROMANCE FINALIST for The 2025 BookLife Prize by Publisher’s Weekly!
"Without lapsing in her commitment to historical accuracy, Hayworth builds characters that remain compelling, contemporary, and alive (amidst well-wrought, careful prose that’s inarguably rhythmic, poetic, and masterful)." —Eliza Dumais
A Regency romance with a mysteriously gothic twist...
A lady of quiet strength
Isobel Ridgeway has never left rural Cumberland, content to the whims of her eccentric father and an overbearing suitor who grows impatient to claim her hand. But when Isobel receives word that her sister has fallen ill, she undertakes a reckless journey to Northumberland, heedless of the winter storm that looms.
In a chance encounter, Isobel must seek refuge with a man she knows in reputation only—Lord Giles Trevelyan, the earl who became a recluse after his dazzling bride-to-be vanished.
A wounded romantic
Lord Trevelyan had no desire for company, but immediately finds Miss Ridgeway engaging, intelligent, and tender—the sort of woman who could draw him out of hiding. Perhaps even resuscitate his dreams of being a happily married man. Except Isobel’s marriage has been long since arranged, her sister’s health is in dangerous fluctuation, and impressions of Trevelyan’s first bride lurk around every corner.
When the mystery of her disappearance threatens to untangle, Isobel finds herself caught in the crosshairs with love, loss, and sanity at stake.
"Without lapsing in her commitment to historical accuracy, Hayworth builds characters that remain compelling, contemporary, and alive (amidst well-wrought, careful prose that’s inarguably rhythmic, poetic, and masterful)." —Eliza Dumais
A Regency romance with a mysteriously gothic twist...
A lady of quiet strength
Isobel Ridgeway has never left rural Cumberland, content to the whims of her eccentric father and an overbearing suitor who grows impatient to claim her hand. But when Isobel receives word that her sister has fallen ill, she undertakes a reckless journey to Northumberland, heedless of the winter storm that looms.
In a chance encounter, Isobel must seek refuge with a man she knows in reputation only—Lord Giles Trevelyan, the earl who became a recluse after his dazzling bride-to-be vanished.
A wounded romantic
Lord Trevelyan had no desire for company, but immediately finds Miss Ridgeway engaging, intelligent, and tender—the sort of woman who could draw him out of hiding. Perhaps even resuscitate his dreams of being a happily married man. Except Isobel’s marriage has been long since arranged, her sister’s health is in dangerous fluctuation, and impressions of Trevelyan’s first bride lurk around every corner.
When the mystery of her disappearance threatens to untangle, Isobel finds herself caught in the crosshairs with love, loss, and sanity at stake.
382 pages, ebook
Published September 16, 2025
2 people are currently reading
136 people want to read
About the author
Lauren M. Hayworth
2 books11 followersLauren M. Hayworth is a 12th-generation North Carolinian with an insatiable interest in history and literature. As an author of historical romance, she makes the past vivid again with evocative prose and meticulously researched stories.
When not living amongst the plotlines of her imagination, Lauren works as a dental hygienist, and relishes time spent on her family’s farm with her beloved husky.
***
A note about my reviews: consider them book recommendations; I won't review anything I didn't enjoy, and may or may not attach ratings.
When not living amongst the plotlines of her imagination, Lauren works as a dental hygienist, and relishes time spent on her family’s farm with her beloved husky.
***
A note about my reviews: consider them book recommendations; I won't review anything I didn't enjoy, and may or may not attach ratings.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews
November 17, 2025
My actual rating is 3,5 .
It's a nice Regency mystery-romance set in the regency era, I was expecting gothic vibes though... but there were none despite the author's desperate attempt to take inspiration from "Rebecca", the famous novel by Daphne du Maurier.
However, she's a debut author, and her style is good...I'm rounding it up to 4 stars because I think with more experience, she'll definitely be able to write more compelling novels.
__ THE PLOT IN A NUTSHELL :
Isobel Ridgeway, is pretty content chilling in rural Cumberland, going with the flow of her quirky dad and a rather pushy suitor who’s getting antsy to make her his wife. But then, boom! She hears her sister is unwell, and without a second thought, Isobel embarks on a bit of a daring journey to Northumberland.
Fate, as it often does, intervenes in the form of a chance encounter. Isobel finds herself needing shelter with a guy she only knows by reputation: Lord Giles Trevelyan. He’s the earl who’s become a bit of a recluse since his dazzling fiancée mysteriously vanished. Lord Trevelyan, being in his hermit phase, isn't exactly thrilled about company. However, he's immediately captivated by Miss Ridgeway.
But here’s the kicker: Isobel is already promised to another, her sister’s health is hanging by a thread, AND the ghost of Trevelyan’s vanished bride seems to be lurking in every shadow.
As the mystery surrounding that disappearance starts to unravel, Isobel finds herself right in the middle of it all, with her heart, her sanity, and her future hanging in the balance.
_________________________
FIRST HALF OF THE BOOK : I defined it as a mystery romance, because this was the author's intention, actually the first half of the book could be defined as a pleasant regency romance where the two main characters immediately lose attraction towards each other, not only thanks to the physical aspect, but above all thanks to the numerous affinities that unite them: the love for books first and foremost, the desire to spend time outdoors taking care of the gardens and a difficult past.
Naturally, as in any good regency worth its salt, there are many untold thoughts and emotions that create misunderstandings and, in addition to this, also the sneaky and malevolent intervention of the negative people of the moment (there are no real villains, just people who obviously have plans for their own benefit, manipulating the lives and futures of others.)
By the end of the first half of the book, everything falls into place, and the book could almost have a happy ending here... BUT... There's a big "but." What happened to Trevellian's former fiancée?
SECOND HALF OF THE BOOK: At this point, I expected the real mystery to begin, along with all the gothic atmosphere promised by the synopsis and, to some extent, by the beautiful cover (I admit that even before reading the general plot, it was the cover that drew me in).
However, despite the hidden truths and attempts to raise suspicions about the story's hero, the epilogue wasn't that unexpected, and the entire book, in my opinion, lacks sensational twists and suspense.
I'm not saying it's a bad novel; I overall liked it, but it lacked the tension that in a mystery (and to some extent in romance novels too) provides the driving emotion that pushes the reader to eagerly turn page after page.
CHARACTERS __
I really liked the Isolbel-Trevelyan couple, and the characters are explored thoroughly through their thoughts and feelings.
The story is told in the third person, from her and his points of view in alternating (or almost alternating) chapters.
The secondary characters, however, appear every now and then, and although they have a very specific role, for me they were just extras.
It was like watching a movie directed by just two actors, where every now and then another actor appears on the scene and then almost immediately leaves.
This is why I loved the main couple, but all the others (positive or negative) were insignificant to me.
The ENDING: I always look for books with happy endings, and here I was not disappointed.
Not only does everything end on a happy note, but we have a final scene that is nothing short of idyllic.
I repeat, she writes well, and although her first novel didn't have the impact I hoped for, I believe she's well on her way to becoming a very talented and renowned author.
I eagerly await her next novel.
The story contains sweet kisses and an open-door sex scene, but it's not at all vulgar and elegantly written.
The language is also polite and clean.
Thanks for reading my opinion and please forgive my English, it's not my native language.
It's a nice Regency mystery-romance set in the regency era, I was expecting gothic vibes though... but there were none despite the author's desperate attempt to take inspiration from "Rebecca", the famous novel by Daphne du Maurier.
However, she's a debut author, and her style is good...I'm rounding it up to 4 stars because I think with more experience, she'll definitely be able to write more compelling novels.
__ THE PLOT IN A NUTSHELL :
Isobel Ridgeway, is pretty content chilling in rural Cumberland, going with the flow of her quirky dad and a rather pushy suitor who’s getting antsy to make her his wife. But then, boom! She hears her sister is unwell, and without a second thought, Isobel embarks on a bit of a daring journey to Northumberland.
Fate, as it often does, intervenes in the form of a chance encounter. Isobel finds herself needing shelter with a guy she only knows by reputation: Lord Giles Trevelyan. He’s the earl who’s become a bit of a recluse since his dazzling fiancée mysteriously vanished. Lord Trevelyan, being in his hermit phase, isn't exactly thrilled about company. However, he's immediately captivated by Miss Ridgeway.
But here’s the kicker: Isobel is already promised to another, her sister’s health is hanging by a thread, AND the ghost of Trevelyan’s vanished bride seems to be lurking in every shadow.
As the mystery surrounding that disappearance starts to unravel, Isobel finds herself right in the middle of it all, with her heart, her sanity, and her future hanging in the balance.
_________________________
FIRST HALF OF THE BOOK : I defined it as a mystery romance, because this was the author's intention, actually the first half of the book could be defined as a pleasant regency romance where the two main characters immediately lose attraction towards each other, not only thanks to the physical aspect, but above all thanks to the numerous affinities that unite them: the love for books first and foremost, the desire to spend time outdoors taking care of the gardens and a difficult past.
Naturally, as in any good regency worth its salt, there are many untold thoughts and emotions that create misunderstandings and, in addition to this, also the sneaky and malevolent intervention of the negative people of the moment (there are no real villains, just people who obviously have plans for their own benefit, manipulating the lives and futures of others.)
By the end of the first half of the book, everything falls into place, and the book could almost have a happy ending here... BUT... There's a big "but." What happened to Trevellian's former fiancée?
SECOND HALF OF THE BOOK: At this point, I expected the real mystery to begin, along with all the gothic atmosphere promised by the synopsis and, to some extent, by the beautiful cover (I admit that even before reading the general plot, it was the cover that drew me in).
However, despite the hidden truths and attempts to raise suspicions about the story's hero, the epilogue wasn't that unexpected, and the entire book, in my opinion, lacks sensational twists and suspense.
I'm not saying it's a bad novel; I overall liked it, but it lacked the tension that in a mystery (and to some extent in romance novels too) provides the driving emotion that pushes the reader to eagerly turn page after page.
CHARACTERS __
I really liked the Isolbel-Trevelyan couple, and the characters are explored thoroughly through their thoughts and feelings.
The story is told in the third person, from her and his points of view in alternating (or almost alternating) chapters.
The secondary characters, however, appear every now and then, and although they have a very specific role, for me they were just extras.
It was like watching a movie directed by just two actors, where every now and then another actor appears on the scene and then almost immediately leaves.
This is why I loved the main couple, but all the others (positive or negative) were insignificant to me.
The ENDING: I always look for books with happy endings, and here I was not disappointed.
Not only does everything end on a happy note, but we have a final scene that is nothing short of idyllic.
I repeat, she writes well, and although her first novel didn't have the impact I hoped for, I believe she's well on her way to becoming a very talented and renowned author.
I eagerly await her next novel.
The story contains sweet kisses and an open-door sex scene, but it's not at all vulgar and elegantly written.
The language is also polite and clean.
Thanks for reading my opinion and please forgive my English, it's not my native language.
August 8, 2025
One thing about me? I’m gonna eat up a gothic histrom and I devoured every last page of this gem. This was so well crafted, so carefully sewn together with rich characters, atmospheric settings and a suspenseful mystery plot that had you turning each page wondering where the story could go!
The romance. Isobel and Giles. Ugh I loved these two so so much. They were both so equally haunted in life and thrusted into lives they didn’t truly want. One chance encounter had them seeing things a little differently and I think the most accurate word that described their first meeting was hope. I think they brought that out in each other from the very beginning. I wouldn’t call this insta love/lust as I truly don’t enjoy those books this is more instant connection/curiosity which I can 110% get down with, and it was done extremely well.
The side characters. If anyone knows me they know how much I love my side characters and I do think at times side characters can be taken for granted or not used to their potential but my god are the side characters in this story brimming with personality. Marriane was my absolute favourite I took an instant liking to her, despite everything shes gone through in such a short amount of time she still comes across as strong and I will admit to shedding a few tears over her. Pemberton, Finch and Betsey are equally fantastic and it was clear that there was a lot of time put in to make them stand out on their own and it shows.
Aurelia. When I tell you this character haunted the narrative I mean it!! I actually felt like she was a present character in this timeline. I don’t want to give too much away but she feels real, messy and your heart does go out to her despite never really knowing her.
The writing was fantastic to be honest I’m shocked this was a debut as it really doesn’t read like it, it’s very clear that Lauren had a distinct vision for where she wanted this novel to go and you can tell the great efforts she went to in establishing her characters, their histories, and the story she wanted to tell surrounding them. Lauren’s writing is truly cinematic and I couldn’t help but see some of Guillermo del Toro’s aesthetics pop into my mind while reading.
Thoroughly enjoyed my time reading Giles and Isobel’s story and I cannot wait to see what Lauren does next because I’ll be front and center waiting for crumbs!
Thank you to the author for sending me an eArc all opinions are my own.
The romance. Isobel and Giles. Ugh I loved these two so so much. They were both so equally haunted in life and thrusted into lives they didn’t truly want. One chance encounter had them seeing things a little differently and I think the most accurate word that described their first meeting was hope. I think they brought that out in each other from the very beginning. I wouldn’t call this insta love/lust as I truly don’t enjoy those books this is more instant connection/curiosity which I can 110% get down with, and it was done extremely well.
The side characters. If anyone knows me they know how much I love my side characters and I do think at times side characters can be taken for granted or not used to their potential but my god are the side characters in this story brimming with personality. Marriane was my absolute favourite I took an instant liking to her, despite everything shes gone through in such a short amount of time she still comes across as strong and I will admit to shedding a few tears over her. Pemberton, Finch and Betsey are equally fantastic and it was clear that there was a lot of time put in to make them stand out on their own and it shows.
Aurelia. When I tell you this character haunted the narrative I mean it!! I actually felt like she was a present character in this timeline. I don’t want to give too much away but she feels real, messy and your heart does go out to her despite never really knowing her.
The writing was fantastic to be honest I’m shocked this was a debut as it really doesn’t read like it, it’s very clear that Lauren had a distinct vision for where she wanted this novel to go and you can tell the great efforts she went to in establishing her characters, their histories, and the story she wanted to tell surrounding them. Lauren’s writing is truly cinematic and I couldn’t help but see some of Guillermo del Toro’s aesthetics pop into my mind while reading.
Thoroughly enjoyed my time reading Giles and Isobel’s story and I cannot wait to see what Lauren does next because I’ll be front and center waiting for crumbs!
Thank you to the author for sending me an eArc all opinions are my own.
August 19, 2025
I had been looking forward to this book for a long time now, especially after the gorgeous cover reveal. Thankfully, my anticipation was validated. There are so many things that could have led this novel astray. However, Lauren M. Hayworth’s talented writing kept them in check. The risks she took made the novel a polished and enthralling example of storytelling in the historical romance genre.
First of all, she promised us Gothic and she delivered, but these vibes do not overpower the narrative. Her descriptions painted the most eerie scenes in my mind’s eye, and I could feel the chill to my bones. Just the concept of the lover’s eye jewelry had my skin crawling, even though it’s meant to be a romantic gesture. Yea, no thanks. The spooky ideas were all rooted in realism, which kept the book firmly in the realm of historical.
Whenever there are secrets in a MC’s past, there is the potential for the book to become confusing, rather than suspenseful. This was not the case at all! Giles’s POV was insightful, while still allowing his mysterious backstory with his former intended to remain veiled. It added to my curiosity rather than making me feel like I was missing parts of the plot.
The clues dropped along the way enabled me to play detective. I hate when a mystery plot hits you with a random surprise right at the end that was never supported by evidence. Even though I figured out a lot of the reveal towards the middle of the book, I still was looking for clues to confirm or adjust my suspicions. It was fun to play along until the last minute.
While the mystery kept me guessing, the romance had me saying “just one more chapter” over and over again. After Isobel ends up at the reclusive Giles’s home, there is an instant attraction between the two. I’m never one to scoff at that (maybe because of my own personal experience), but it can lead to some risky pacing challenges. Again, Lauren avoids these pitfalls. Right after the characters were able to explore that initial spark, circumstances pumped the breaks on their relationship progress, giving us the perfect opportunity for some angst, yearning, and reflection.
I loved watching Isobel’s growth throughout the novel. In the beginning, she was a timid heroine who allowed life to happen to her. However, she was at a point in time where she could no longer deal with the way her life was going and she had to fight the current. Watching her become an active participant in her own future was an empowering reminder that I find inspiring as a reader.
While Giles and Isobel do withhold secrets from each other, I didn’t find it overly frustrating. I think that was because they openly communicated about other aspects of their relationship. For example, at one point Isobel believes Giles is proposing a marriage of convenience. I was about to let out a big UGH, but Giles quickly clears it up by revealing his attraction to her. He is a sweetheart, but still brooding and delicious.
I am always excited when an author makes her debut (especially in historical romance) and it is clear that she knows what goes into writing a quality novel. The evidence of Lauren M. Hayworth’s hard work and commitment is all there in the beautiful way this novel comes together. I honestly thought I was reading a book by one of the established historical romance foremothers. I’m feeling increasingly impatient to see what comes next for her!
Thank you to the author for this ARC. This is my honest review.
First of all, she promised us Gothic and she delivered, but these vibes do not overpower the narrative. Her descriptions painted the most eerie scenes in my mind’s eye, and I could feel the chill to my bones. Just the concept of the lover’s eye jewelry had my skin crawling, even though it’s meant to be a romantic gesture. Yea, no thanks. The spooky ideas were all rooted in realism, which kept the book firmly in the realm of historical.
Whenever there are secrets in a MC’s past, there is the potential for the book to become confusing, rather than suspenseful. This was not the case at all! Giles’s POV was insightful, while still allowing his mysterious backstory with his former intended to remain veiled. It added to my curiosity rather than making me feel like I was missing parts of the plot.
The clues dropped along the way enabled me to play detective. I hate when a mystery plot hits you with a random surprise right at the end that was never supported by evidence. Even though I figured out a lot of the reveal towards the middle of the book, I still was looking for clues to confirm or adjust my suspicions. It was fun to play along until the last minute.
While the mystery kept me guessing, the romance had me saying “just one more chapter” over and over again. After Isobel ends up at the reclusive Giles’s home, there is an instant attraction between the two. I’m never one to scoff at that (maybe because of my own personal experience), but it can lead to some risky pacing challenges. Again, Lauren avoids these pitfalls. Right after the characters were able to explore that initial spark, circumstances pumped the breaks on their relationship progress, giving us the perfect opportunity for some angst, yearning, and reflection.
I loved watching Isobel’s growth throughout the novel. In the beginning, she was a timid heroine who allowed life to happen to her. However, she was at a point in time where she could no longer deal with the way her life was going and she had to fight the current. Watching her become an active participant in her own future was an empowering reminder that I find inspiring as a reader.
While Giles and Isobel do withhold secrets from each other, I didn’t find it overly frustrating. I think that was because they openly communicated about other aspects of their relationship. For example, at one point Isobel believes Giles is proposing a marriage of convenience. I was about to let out a big UGH, but Giles quickly clears it up by revealing his attraction to her. He is a sweetheart, but still brooding and delicious.
I am always excited when an author makes her debut (especially in historical romance) and it is clear that she knows what goes into writing a quality novel. The evidence of Lauren M. Hayworth’s hard work and commitment is all there in the beautiful way this novel comes together. I honestly thought I was reading a book by one of the established historical romance foremothers. I’m feeling increasingly impatient to see what comes next for her!
Thank you to the author for this ARC. This is my honest review.
September 11, 2025
Really like the atmosfer of this story, very inspiring by "Rebecca". The romance do not convince me in the start (I thought that Giles was haunted by the memory of his old bride), but in the middle of the book I did enjoy observe they together. But it is the mystery around the old bride what I much like in this story. She is a figure in the book, that keep show herself even to in dreams or create the caos. Marianne is other character that I did love, I like to see her full glowing in the end without worried about other expections.
October 22, 2025
Rebecca girls who grew up to be historical romance readers, it is our time! The Lover’s Eye by Lauren M. Hayworth was made for the teen girls who read Daphne du Maurier’s classic novel and said, “Why isn’t there more kissing?”
Isobel Ridgeway has been sequestered in Cumberland her entire life with her father and sister. Her sister married a marquess a year ago and moved away, leaving Isobel to her father’s whims and his pressure to marry their neighbor’s son. Isobel has no desire to marry this man but has spent her life complying with everyone else’s wishes to avoid conflict—so she knows she’ll eventually cave.
When Isobel receives word that her older sister is ill, she races to her side even though a winter storm has made the roads treacherous. Her carriage gets stuck in the snow only an hour from her sister’s house, but there’s no way to continue through the bad weather. She’ll have to spend the night at Lord Giles Trevelyan’s home. Since the disappearance and presumed death of his fiancée the prior year, Giles has become a recluse. Society assumes it’s because his heart is broken over Aurelia’s death—but there’s more at play than just his grief. He and Isobel are immediately drawn to each other, but with Aurelia’s specter and Isobel’s presumed betrothal hanging between them, could anything ever come of their feelings?
I am a gothic romance girl. I was raised on a steady diet of Ann Radcliffe, the Brontë sisters, and Daphne du Maurier. Give me a complicated romantic relationship surrounded by mysteries that slowly erode the trust between our two main characters, and I am in. It’s even better if there’s a sinister housekeeper or butler on the scene. Gothic romance seems to be having a bit of a renaissance in both category and indie publishing, and I am here for it.
The Lover’s Eye is the kind of book that makes me so grateful we have a thriving indie publishing scene today—because this novel would never have been picked up by a major trad publisher. The structure is gloriously old-school in the best way possible. Our main characters meet fairly early in the story but are separated while Isobel’s father and neighbor try to force her into her long-planned betrothal, and Giles contends with the ghost of his fiancée. The two spend a lot of time thinking about each other but not actually in proximity. I loved that choice. I grew up on historical romances of the ’90s and early 2000s, when it wasn’t necessary for characters to be together on-page all the time. They could be apart as long as the action was driving them back together.
Aurelia gives big Rebecca vibes. She disappeared eight months before the start of the book after an argument with Giles, but no one knows what the argument was about or where she went. All we know is that she vanished and is presumed dead. What’s so interesting about this book is that we get dual narration, with Giles as one of our narrators. We know that he knows what their conversation was about, but he keeps it secret from everyone—including the reader. There’s a great tradition of gothic fiction in first person (see Jane Eyre and Rebecca), but it’s almost impossible for a first-person narrator to withhold this kind of secret. The choice to use third person, past tense allows Hayworth to keep that information from everyone until Giles sees fit to share it.
My only complaint about the book is that I wanted a bigger blow-up at the final revelation. I understand that this book is set in the Regency, not the Victorian era, so the resolution was bound to focus more on moral reckoning than self-immolation on the moors. I’m just trash for high drama and always want more.
This is a promising debut from an exciting new voice in historical romance. I’m really looking forward to seeing what Lauren writes next (and getting on her ARC distribution list, because I am exactly her target audience). 4.5 stars.
Isobel Ridgeway has been sequestered in Cumberland her entire life with her father and sister. Her sister married a marquess a year ago and moved away, leaving Isobel to her father’s whims and his pressure to marry their neighbor’s son. Isobel has no desire to marry this man but has spent her life complying with everyone else’s wishes to avoid conflict—so she knows she’ll eventually cave.
When Isobel receives word that her older sister is ill, she races to her side even though a winter storm has made the roads treacherous. Her carriage gets stuck in the snow only an hour from her sister’s house, but there’s no way to continue through the bad weather. She’ll have to spend the night at Lord Giles Trevelyan’s home. Since the disappearance and presumed death of his fiancée the prior year, Giles has become a recluse. Society assumes it’s because his heart is broken over Aurelia’s death—but there’s more at play than just his grief. He and Isobel are immediately drawn to each other, but with Aurelia’s specter and Isobel’s presumed betrothal hanging between them, could anything ever come of their feelings?
I am a gothic romance girl. I was raised on a steady diet of Ann Radcliffe, the Brontë sisters, and Daphne du Maurier. Give me a complicated romantic relationship surrounded by mysteries that slowly erode the trust between our two main characters, and I am in. It’s even better if there’s a sinister housekeeper or butler on the scene. Gothic romance seems to be having a bit of a renaissance in both category and indie publishing, and I am here for it.
The Lover’s Eye is the kind of book that makes me so grateful we have a thriving indie publishing scene today—because this novel would never have been picked up by a major trad publisher. The structure is gloriously old-school in the best way possible. Our main characters meet fairly early in the story but are separated while Isobel’s father and neighbor try to force her into her long-planned betrothal, and Giles contends with the ghost of his fiancée. The two spend a lot of time thinking about each other but not actually in proximity. I loved that choice. I grew up on historical romances of the ’90s and early 2000s, when it wasn’t necessary for characters to be together on-page all the time. They could be apart as long as the action was driving them back together.
Aurelia gives big Rebecca vibes. She disappeared eight months before the start of the book after an argument with Giles, but no one knows what the argument was about or where she went. All we know is that she vanished and is presumed dead. What’s so interesting about this book is that we get dual narration, with Giles as one of our narrators. We know that he knows what their conversation was about, but he keeps it secret from everyone—including the reader. There’s a great tradition of gothic fiction in first person (see Jane Eyre and Rebecca), but it’s almost impossible for a first-person narrator to withhold this kind of secret. The choice to use third person, past tense allows Hayworth to keep that information from everyone until Giles sees fit to share it.
My only complaint about the book is that I wanted a bigger blow-up at the final revelation. I understand that this book is set in the Regency, not the Victorian era, so the resolution was bound to focus more on moral reckoning than self-immolation on the moors. I’m just trash for high drama and always want more.
This is a promising debut from an exciting new voice in historical romance. I’m really looking forward to seeing what Lauren writes next (and getting on her ARC distribution list, because I am exactly her target audience). 4.5 stars.
August 24, 2025
Rounded up from 4.5-ish.
This debut brings all the gothic atmosphere—windswept coasts, haunted manor, vanished bride—and pairs it with a tender Regency romance. Isobel Ridgeway, the overlooked younger daughter, braves the Northumberland coast to care for her sister and ends up snowbound with Lord Giles Trevelyan, a reclusive, haunted earl. What begins as uneasy companionship unfolds into a love story threaded with secrets, grief and redemption.
Isobel is the heart of this book. Long dismissed as “less than” by her father and her suitor’s family, she’s learned to survive by pleasing others. She’s not passive; once she commits to Giles and to solving the lingering mystery, she drives the story forward. Watching her grow into her own strength, recognize her worth and fight for her fledgling marriage was the real heart of the book.
Giles, meanwhile, is a cinnamon roll wrapped in shadows: grieving, guilty, but protective and utterly undone by Isobel. He's also suffocating under guilt that was never his to carry. He definitely falls first (and maybe harder), and his journey is about learning to trust and forgive himself. His tenderness balances beautifully against the gothic gloom.
The Northumberland setting and Cambo House give the novel its moody, windswept gothic tone. The setting is so vivid I absolutely Googled the real-life inspirations in the author's note at the end to compare what I imagined with the real-life places (it was very close!).
A little more weight on a few descriptive and emotional beats would’ve taken it fully over the top, but the threads all tied together satisfyingly. A strong debut, and one that makes me eager for whatever Hayworth writes next.
Thanks to the author for the advance copy. Put this one on your TBR.
This debut brings all the gothic atmosphere—windswept coasts, haunted manor, vanished bride—and pairs it with a tender Regency romance. Isobel Ridgeway, the overlooked younger daughter, braves the Northumberland coast to care for her sister and ends up snowbound with Lord Giles Trevelyan, a reclusive, haunted earl. What begins as uneasy companionship unfolds into a love story threaded with secrets, grief and redemption.
Isobel is the heart of this book. Long dismissed as “less than” by her father and her suitor’s family, she’s learned to survive by pleasing others. She’s not passive; once she commits to Giles and to solving the lingering mystery, she drives the story forward. Watching her grow into her own strength, recognize her worth and fight for her fledgling marriage was the real heart of the book.
Giles, meanwhile, is a cinnamon roll wrapped in shadows: grieving, guilty, but protective and utterly undone by Isobel. He's also suffocating under guilt that was never his to carry. He definitely falls first (and maybe harder), and his journey is about learning to trust and forgive himself. His tenderness balances beautifully against the gothic gloom.
The Northumberland setting and Cambo House give the novel its moody, windswept gothic tone. The setting is so vivid I absolutely Googled the real-life inspirations in the author's note at the end to compare what I imagined with the real-life places (it was very close!).
A little more weight on a few descriptive and emotional beats would’ve taken it fully over the top, but the threads all tied together satisfyingly. A strong debut, and one that makes me eager for whatever Hayworth writes next.
Thanks to the author for the advance copy. Put this one on your TBR.
August 11, 2025
Hayworth has constructed a world set in the early 1800s that feels both completely familiar and refreshingly new with 'The Lover's Eye.' I thought of du Maurier's 'Rebecca' at times, Bronte's 'Wuthering Heights' was like a specter at others, and Jane Austen's ever-present inspiration was there too at lighter moments. And yet it might be unfair to compare 'The Lover's Eye' with any other historical romance. I loved the presence of Keats' poetry and the way it was used, sparking a desire in me to re-read some of his best works. The story of Giles and Isobel unwraps itself to the reader with layers of sweetness, mystery, bits of darkness [not in any intimate scenes!], and a growing affection for all of its characters as we slowly get to know them better. 'Lover's Eye' is paced well. I never felt like I wanted to skip a passage or urge the author to "get to it" already! And that expected "happily ever after" was so satisfying once it finally came into view. If you like historical romance with a touch of intimacy and a good mystery, you should enjoy 'The Lover's Eye' just as I did. It didn't even take me more than chapter two to be fully invested, and after only putting it down for one day, I finished this easily on day two, neglecting all my other responsibilities. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 5, 2025
I seem to be an outlier on this one. I do like a Gothic novel, I really did not like any of the characters in this book, plus I figured out the "big secret " quite quickly.
Isabel Ridgeway had never left her home in Cumberland and was stifled by her father, a highly controlling man who is insisting she marry their horrible neighbor to connect their lands. Her sister has escaped by marrying but Isabel has never visited her.
When she gets a letter that her sister is ill, she insists on going.
Her erstwhile suitor and his equally odious mother warn her against the sisters reclusive and scandalous neighbor, Giles Trevelyan
of course increasing her curiosity.
Can I just say that every character acts stupidly. Giles is keeping a huge secret about his vanished betrothed and refuses to speak about her, the sister is ill and doesn't reveal why, just warns Isabel all men are bad,the husband who pays little attention to the wife because she keeps having miscarriages, the father who actually dislikes the suitor and his mother, but pushed Isabel to marry him.
And most of all Isabel, who let's her father control her, who takes forever to say no to suitor, who doesn't push Giles for answers, and keeps running off and putting herself in danger.
Oh I forgot to talk about the title. Apparently it was a romantic gesture to give your lover a necklace with your eye painted on it. This is a plot point.
Ok, got that off my chest. There are many 5 star reviews, so please read this for yourself and see what you think.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the EARC. These are obviously my honest opinions.
Isabel Ridgeway had never left her home in Cumberland and was stifled by her father, a highly controlling man who is insisting she marry their horrible neighbor to connect their lands. Her sister has escaped by marrying but Isabel has never visited her.
When she gets a letter that her sister is ill, she insists on going.
Her erstwhile suitor and his equally odious mother warn her against the sisters reclusive and scandalous neighbor, Giles Trevelyan
of course increasing her curiosity.
Can I just say that every character acts stupidly. Giles is keeping a huge secret about his vanished betrothed and refuses to speak about her, the sister is ill and doesn't reveal why, just warns Isabel all men are bad,the husband who pays little attention to the wife because she keeps having miscarriages, the father who actually dislikes the suitor and his mother, but pushed Isabel to marry him.
And most of all Isabel, who let's her father control her, who takes forever to say no to suitor, who doesn't push Giles for answers, and keeps running off and putting herself in danger.
Oh I forgot to talk about the title. Apparently it was a romantic gesture to give your lover a necklace with your eye painted on it. This is a plot point.
Ok, got that off my chest. There are many 5 star reviews, so please read this for yourself and see what you think.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the EARC. These are obviously my honest opinions.
September 18, 2025
Lauren Hayworth’s stunning debut introduces us to Isobel and Giles, two damaged souls that were destined to find each other. Isobel is an intelligent, overlooked, yet caring woman who feels dejected and lost. She tends to let life happen around her instead of taking charge. Throughout the story, we see her struggle with self-doubt, wanting to truly believe in her own worth. On the other hand, Giles is a grumpy loner with a hidden sweetness. He’s a man who has been deeply affected by the disappearance of his betrothed and finds it hard to forgive himself for the events of his past. Their chance meeting ignites an immediate and strong attraction, setting the stage for a beautiful story of connection and healing.
What really captured me was the slow-burn romance between Isobel and Giles. At first, their feelings were just simple smiles and quiet conversation, creating a bond that felt warm and safe. As they spent more time together, their relationship became more complicated, filled with unspoken worries and fears. The delicious tension and sense of anticipation kept me glued to the story. The pacing allowed me to savor each moment and appreciate how their relationship developed.
The atmospheric setting of "The Lovers Eye" plays a crucial role in enhancing the story's gothic vibes. Hayworth effectively uses the environment to invoke a sense of foreboding and unease that drew me deeper into the story. The mysterious side characters drove up the tension, making me wary of their motives which added complexity to the storyline. The writing style paints vivid scenes that triggered my imagination, making me feel the chilling winds and sense the rising tides. It’s beautifully written, with an eerie yet enchanting landscape that felt alive and integral to the characters' development.
Overall, "The Lovers Eye" stands as an excellent debut, seamlessly blending gothic and historical elements. It shines with beautiful prose that captures both the dark and the hopeful elements of romance. It includes a few open-door scenes that are on the shorter side and what I would consider non-explicit. I would have loved if there had been a true villain rather than just misunderstood side characters but, once again, this is a personal preference. Highly recommended for those who appreciate layered narratives filled with small moments that lead to something truly special and unforgettable. I am very excited to see what Lauren brings us next!
I was honored to receive an early copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
What really captured me was the slow-burn romance between Isobel and Giles. At first, their feelings were just simple smiles and quiet conversation, creating a bond that felt warm and safe. As they spent more time together, their relationship became more complicated, filled with unspoken worries and fears. The delicious tension and sense of anticipation kept me glued to the story. The pacing allowed me to savor each moment and appreciate how their relationship developed.
The atmospheric setting of "The Lovers Eye" plays a crucial role in enhancing the story's gothic vibes. Hayworth effectively uses the environment to invoke a sense of foreboding and unease that drew me deeper into the story. The mysterious side characters drove up the tension, making me wary of their motives which added complexity to the storyline. The writing style paints vivid scenes that triggered my imagination, making me feel the chilling winds and sense the rising tides. It’s beautifully written, with an eerie yet enchanting landscape that felt alive and integral to the characters' development.
Overall, "The Lovers Eye" stands as an excellent debut, seamlessly blending gothic and historical elements. It shines with beautiful prose that captures both the dark and the hopeful elements of romance. It includes a few open-door scenes that are on the shorter side and what I would consider non-explicit. I would have loved if there had been a true villain rather than just misunderstood side characters but, once again, this is a personal preference. Highly recommended for those who appreciate layered narratives filled with small moments that lead to something truly special and unforgettable. I am very excited to see what Lauren brings us next!
I was honored to receive an early copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
September 5, 2025
4 ⭐️
Nothing is more satisfying than when a highly anticipated debut author delivers the damn thing, so very well! Isabel has been a passive participant in her life, free to let her father, fiancé, and his mother decide everything for her. It’s easier to just go along to get along. That is, until she receives a letter from her sister’s husband to come urgently. On her journey, she meets Lord Giles Trevelyan, whose mysterious past has left him secluded and removed from society.
I love when the grumpy, secluded man (who’s been grumbling about his uninvited house guests and PEOPLE in general) sees the heroine for the first time and his mind just….blanks. Like, he totally forgets he’s meant to be a big grump and is instead so instantly endeared, and that absolutely happens with our boy Giles. While at times I found myself frustrated with both of these characters for their lack of transparent and clear communication, it also made so much sense for their characters. Both Giles and Isabel are deeply private and reserved individuals who have rarely felt comfortable expressing emotions to others. That’s why it makes it almost that much more impactful when they eventually build this trust with each other. The final half of the book is truly where Isobel shines in slight levels of unhinged meets her final transformation to strength. It’s a rough journey, but a powerful and raw one that I think this novel does well.
The writing here is really excellent, and I honestly had to keep reminding myself that this is a debut. You can tell Lauren not only understands historical romance but also how to build gothic tension so well. I was on the literal edge of my seat through most of this novel, wanting to uncover the mystery. And she does such an excellent job of teasing you without giving too much away. Also, her prose is so very poetic, and she has a way of setting a scene so well. You truly can feel the eerie gothic setting is almost a character and seems to embody such a presence right from the opening scenes. A perfect read to set the season, and I loved this gothic retelling inspired by Rebecca.
Thank you to the author for an eARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own, etc.
Nothing is more satisfying than when a highly anticipated debut author delivers the damn thing, so very well! Isabel has been a passive participant in her life, free to let her father, fiancé, and his mother decide everything for her. It’s easier to just go along to get along. That is, until she receives a letter from her sister’s husband to come urgently. On her journey, she meets Lord Giles Trevelyan, whose mysterious past has left him secluded and removed from society.
I love when the grumpy, secluded man (who’s been grumbling about his uninvited house guests and PEOPLE in general) sees the heroine for the first time and his mind just….blanks. Like, he totally forgets he’s meant to be a big grump and is instead so instantly endeared, and that absolutely happens with our boy Giles. While at times I found myself frustrated with both of these characters for their lack of transparent and clear communication, it also made so much sense for their characters. Both Giles and Isabel are deeply private and reserved individuals who have rarely felt comfortable expressing emotions to others. That’s why it makes it almost that much more impactful when they eventually build this trust with each other. The final half of the book is truly where Isobel shines in slight levels of unhinged meets her final transformation to strength. It’s a rough journey, but a powerful and raw one that I think this novel does well.
The writing here is really excellent, and I honestly had to keep reminding myself that this is a debut. You can tell Lauren not only understands historical romance but also how to build gothic tension so well. I was on the literal edge of my seat through most of this novel, wanting to uncover the mystery. And she does such an excellent job of teasing you without giving too much away. Also, her prose is so very poetic, and she has a way of setting a scene so well. You truly can feel the eerie gothic setting is almost a character and seems to embody such a presence right from the opening scenes. A perfect read to set the season, and I loved this gothic retelling inspired by Rebecca.
Thank you to the author for an eARC of this book. All opinions expressed are my own, etc.
September 9, 2025
I love a Gothic romance. The spooky, ominous vibes add tension to an already precarious romance, and the stakes seem higher although there is no tangible threat. In this debut from Lauren Hayworth, we're treated to a romance steeped in Gothic atmosphere, inspired by Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca.
Isobel is stifled by her insulated life, but doesn't really how much so until she encounters Giles unexpectedly. They discover a connection that neither expects, and both question their future, despite their meeting being brief. When they're drawn together, they're haunted by the spectre of Giles missing ex-fiance (Aurelia) and the secrets that their relationship seems to be mired in.
Isobels journey is steeped in uncertainty. After risking her future on Giles, she's challenged at every turn by the memory of Aurelia. She gradually descends further and further into doubt and dismay, driven by Giles reticence and her unwilling ignorance. Their story is saved from feeling tragic by the dual POV, which reveals Giles well-meaning-but-greatly-flawed logic. His aloof persona is revealed to be nothing less than a socially awkward man who has fallen hard and fast for Isobel, and is trying his best not to allow their future to be tainted by the past.
I really enjoyed the slightly unsettling atmosphere that accompanied this romance. Isobel and Giles are two kind-hearted souls caught in the grips of the past. They face adversity of a less tangible kind, and are forced to closely examine themselves and each other due to it. Their weaknesses and strengths are drawn out to great effect (don't worry, their strengths win). This was a great debut and I'll be keeping an eye on her work going forward 👁
Isobel is stifled by her insulated life, but doesn't really how much so until she encounters Giles unexpectedly. They discover a connection that neither expects, and both question their future, despite their meeting being brief. When they're drawn together, they're haunted by the spectre of Giles missing ex-fiance (Aurelia) and the secrets that their relationship seems to be mired in.
Isobels journey is steeped in uncertainty. After risking her future on Giles, she's challenged at every turn by the memory of Aurelia. She gradually descends further and further into doubt and dismay, driven by Giles reticence and her unwilling ignorance. Their story is saved from feeling tragic by the dual POV, which reveals Giles well-meaning-but-greatly-flawed logic. His aloof persona is revealed to be nothing less than a socially awkward man who has fallen hard and fast for Isobel, and is trying his best not to allow their future to be tainted by the past.
I really enjoyed the slightly unsettling atmosphere that accompanied this romance. Isobel and Giles are two kind-hearted souls caught in the grips of the past. They face adversity of a less tangible kind, and are forced to closely examine themselves and each other due to it. Their weaknesses and strengths are drawn out to great effect (don't worry, their strengths win). This was a great debut and I'll be keeping an eye on her work going forward 👁
August 25, 2025
A beautiful and lush gothic romance debut from Lauren Hayworth! This book oozes with histrom swoon that builds and builds with quiet but steady intensity, all set against a windswept coastal backdrop in regency England.
While this book is gothic in nature/vibes (complete with a mysterious manor and a secretive, brooding man), it’s a romance novel at heart. The love story between Giles and Isobel smolders quietly, insistently, beneath the weight of mystery and longing. What makes Hayworth’s writing so compelling is her ability to balance secrets with romantic intensity. Both characters are holding back, but oh do they ache for each other in ways that feel bone-deep, shaped as much by silence and distance as by desire.
I tipped headfirst into this story from the very first chapter, and the simmering romance kept me turning pages with fervor. One of my favorite romance debuts of 2025!
While this book is gothic in nature/vibes (complete with a mysterious manor and a secretive, brooding man), it’s a romance novel at heart. The love story between Giles and Isobel smolders quietly, insistently, beneath the weight of mystery and longing. What makes Hayworth’s writing so compelling is her ability to balance secrets with romantic intensity. Both characters are holding back, but oh do they ache for each other in ways that feel bone-deep, shaped as much by silence and distance as by desire.
I tipped headfirst into this story from the very first chapter, and the simmering romance kept me turning pages with fervor. One of my favorite romance debuts of 2025!
September 3, 2025
this was a great debut novel,I liked the characters. the backdrop.it is dark twisty and full of secrets just how I like my books and it reminds of Rebecca by Daphnee Du Maurier brilliant book
September 14, 2025
Isobel Ridgeway faces an unsavoury position: marrying her childhood friend, Elias Sempill. Her father is set on the notion, and Elias’s mother is pushy and conniving to see that the scheme carries through. But Isobel feels nothing at all for him, and wonders if it is her lot to be yoked to a man for whom she has no love. When rushing to visit her sister upon note of her illness, however, inclement weather forces Isobel and her party to board with Giles Trevelyan, and sparks fly. But he was once betrothed to Aurelia Gouldsmith, who hasn’t been seen for months…
What I enjoyed about it:
•The descriptions are very vivid and atmospheric; I feel as though I am walking right alongside Isobel in the beginning, for example, when they take shelter from the snowstorm.
•I like that both Giles and Isobel are coming from the same angle, both nearly married to people they didn’t love.
•I love how patient and gentle Giles is and allows Isobel to determine the course and speed of their relationship, and it’s very sexy that she’s the one who is pushing for physicality whenever he gives her multiple chances to take it slow or stop altogether.
•Had suspicions pretty early on as to the reasoning behind Aurelia Gouldsmith’s disappearance and I was correct. The book did a great job of keeping me engaged and tantalising me with what might have happened to her and why.
One thing that didn’t work for me, however:
•The chapters sometimes going from Giles’s perspective and sometimes Isobel’s works really well in most instances, but there are two chapters back-to-back where it gives the same incident with the same dialogue but only a few differences which made it tedious to read, enticing me to skim through a portion of it to get to the new material.
The Lover’s Eye by Lauren M. Hayworth is a historical fiction romance set in the early 19th century—1814 and 1815 to be specific, which places it squarely in the Regency Era, a popular time for historical romances. It has a mystery at its centre as well, which will appeal to readers wanting to unwind something while the leads fall in love.
I received an advance review copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
What I enjoyed about it:
•The descriptions are very vivid and atmospheric; I feel as though I am walking right alongside Isobel in the beginning, for example, when they take shelter from the snowstorm.
•I like that both Giles and Isobel are coming from the same angle, both nearly married to people they didn’t love.
•I love how patient and gentle Giles is and allows Isobel to determine the course and speed of their relationship, and it’s very sexy that she’s the one who is pushing for physicality whenever he gives her multiple chances to take it slow or stop altogether.
•Had suspicions pretty early on as to the reasoning behind Aurelia Gouldsmith’s disappearance and I was correct. The book did a great job of keeping me engaged and tantalising me with what might have happened to her and why.
One thing that didn’t work for me, however:
•The chapters sometimes going from Giles’s perspective and sometimes Isobel’s works really well in most instances, but there are two chapters back-to-back where it gives the same incident with the same dialogue but only a few differences which made it tedious to read, enticing me to skim through a portion of it to get to the new material.
The Lover’s Eye by Lauren M. Hayworth is a historical fiction romance set in the early 19th century—1814 and 1815 to be specific, which places it squarely in the Regency Era, a popular time for historical romances. It has a mystery at its centre as well, which will appeal to readers wanting to unwind something while the leads fall in love.
I received an advance review copy for free from BookSirens, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
December 14, 2025
This book genuinely blew me away. Not only is it VERY well-written, has a captivating plot and well-developed characters… The imagery was so good I felt transported into the book whenever I was reading. I believe it takes a special talent to write in a way that makes the reader submerge into the story, feel as if you’ve become a part of it. Lauren did exactly that.
Some of the things that stood out to me:
-Giles enjoys gardening! Such a cute little detail to his personality. We love an MMC who has hobbies.
-real gothic vibes
-lots of small details that added to the reading experience
-he gave Isobel books as a gift!
I found the relationship development REALLY good. While there was attraction between Giles and Isobel from the very start, it wasn’t insta-love. Their relationship actually took time to develop, and that made their story feel even more realistic.
Giles is such a sweet - a cinnamon roll! - hero. He cared for Isobel from the start, wanted to ensure she’s comfortable, wanted to help her in any way he could.
He also harboured a secret which he thought would destroy any chance of love between them. This was a big part of the plot, a tangle that was very well created. While Isobel believed Giles deeply loved his ex-fiancee, Aurelia, Giles couldn’t tell her the truth of that relationship. This caused a strain in their own relationship, as Isobel came to her own conclusion and kept finding details that proved her beliefs true.
It took a while for her to find out the truth, it took a lot for Giles to finally open up completely and expose his vulnerability, to trust Isobel entirely.
I also want to add how much I enjoyed Pemberton and Marianne’s relationship. Pemberton and Marianne (Isobel’s sister) are likely the most well-developed side characters I encountered. While Pemberton is somewhat of a villain in this story, he also actually appears as a complex, deep character, with reasons behind his actions. I genuinely feel like I would love to read his and Marianne’s book, learn more about their relationship from the beginning and all the way to when things are at last well between them.
I loved this book very much - the plot, the relationship development, the characters, the world that Lauren had created.
Some of the things that stood out to me:
-Giles enjoys gardening! Such a cute little detail to his personality. We love an MMC who has hobbies.
-real gothic vibes
-lots of small details that added to the reading experience
-he gave Isobel books as a gift!
I found the relationship development REALLY good. While there was attraction between Giles and Isobel from the very start, it wasn’t insta-love. Their relationship actually took time to develop, and that made their story feel even more realistic.
Giles is such a sweet - a cinnamon roll! - hero. He cared for Isobel from the start, wanted to ensure she’s comfortable, wanted to help her in any way he could.
He also harboured a secret which he thought would destroy any chance of love between them. This was a big part of the plot, a tangle that was very well created. While Isobel believed Giles deeply loved his ex-fiancee, Aurelia, Giles couldn’t tell her the truth of that relationship. This caused a strain in their own relationship, as Isobel came to her own conclusion and kept finding details that proved her beliefs true.
It took a while for her to find out the truth, it took a lot for Giles to finally open up completely and expose his vulnerability, to trust Isobel entirely.
I also want to add how much I enjoyed Pemberton and Marianne’s relationship. Pemberton and Marianne (Isobel’s sister) are likely the most well-developed side characters I encountered. While Pemberton is somewhat of a villain in this story, he also actually appears as a complex, deep character, with reasons behind his actions. I genuinely feel like I would love to read his and Marianne’s book, learn more about their relationship from the beginning and all the way to when things are at last well between them.
I loved this book very much - the plot, the relationship development, the characters, the world that Lauren had created.
September 3, 2025
This is an attempt to put my feeling about this book into words and not just gush about how much I loved it.
After reading the open I forced myself to savour reading this book but I could have easily just read it in one go. Right from the beginning it grips you.
Many books have claimed to have taken inspiration from Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier, and they often don’t manage to get anywhere close. It wasn’t till the authors note when I realised it’s because there was a focus on the shared focus on the two women’s insecurities and just what such an unrelenting comparison does to a person. This way the truly haunting feel is managed despite never having met the person.
There was a real old school classic gothic novel vibe to the entire story but without that curdled undertone that often goes along with those classics, when they can veer off into problematic elements or the relationships become toxic. This is a true modern take, where the relationship formed feels real, well founded and healthy. You can’t help but fall in love with Isobel and Giles. The secondary cast are well established without becoming overpowering of the story, I especially loved Isobel’s sister Marianne. She felt very unique and refreshing.
I happened to be reading this just after having read from a titan in the historical romance community (initials MB) who is very well known for her character work and this debut really managed to have a similar level of character work.I couldn’t believe it was a debut! The leads feel so fleshed out in my head they feel really, not just a tweaked version of an often used trope.
I don’t know if Lauren M. Hayworth plans to stick with the gothic vibe but I do know she will be releasing more Historical romance in the future. I can’t wait. She is definitely on my auto buy author list (impressive to do with only one book). I could go on and on about this book, I just want to shove it in everyone’s face and make them read it. I love having that feeling about a book.
I received an advanced copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
After reading the open I forced myself to savour reading this book but I could have easily just read it in one go. Right from the beginning it grips you.
Many books have claimed to have taken inspiration from Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier, and they often don’t manage to get anywhere close. It wasn’t till the authors note when I realised it’s because there was a focus on the shared focus on the two women’s insecurities and just what such an unrelenting comparison does to a person. This way the truly haunting feel is managed despite never having met the person.
There was a real old school classic gothic novel vibe to the entire story but without that curdled undertone that often goes along with those classics, when they can veer off into problematic elements or the relationships become toxic. This is a true modern take, where the relationship formed feels real, well founded and healthy. You can’t help but fall in love with Isobel and Giles. The secondary cast are well established without becoming overpowering of the story, I especially loved Isobel’s sister Marianne. She felt very unique and refreshing.
I happened to be reading this just after having read from a titan in the historical romance community (initials MB) who is very well known for her character work and this debut really managed to have a similar level of character work.I couldn’t believe it was a debut! The leads feel so fleshed out in my head they feel really, not just a tweaked version of an often used trope.
I don’t know if Lauren M. Hayworth plans to stick with the gothic vibe but I do know she will be releasing more Historical romance in the future. I can’t wait. She is definitely on my auto buy author list (impressive to do with only one book). I could go on and on about this book, I just want to shove it in everyone’s face and make them read it. I love having that feeling about a book.
I received an advanced copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
September 18, 2025
I feel like gothic romance is having a mini-renaissance, and The Lover's Eye is definitely a on-trend! We've got a man with secrets about his previous fiancée, a woman with her own fiancé issues, an eerie seaside setting, servants with their own agendas, a mysteriously ill sister, and more.
So, the basics: Isobel, dutiful daughter who usually goes along to get along, jumps at the chance to travel to her sister's home. And to be fair, the letter she gets is pretty alarming; her sister's husband has written to say that she's ill. Isobel knows she's got to get out while she can (her "fiancé" is getting antsy to make things official) so she leaves during a snowstorm and gets stranded about an hour from her sister's house. Luckily, she's stranded at the gate to mysterious local hottie Lord Trevelyan's house, who reluctantly agrees to put her up for the night. Surprise, surprise, Giles (that's Lord T) and Isobel feel almost irresistibly attracted to each other. (They do mange to resist for a little while ... but honestly not all that long.)
This really feels like a gothic romance to me, with touches of Bluebeard and Rebecca. Like most gothic romances, the conflict hinges on the trust between the two main characters: both Isobel and Giles have moments where they simply can't trust the other. And, like many gothic romances, there are Reasons why the characters can't simply open up to each other. Here, there's a mix of reticent Regency propriety and personal issues. It's important to go into any gothic romance knowing that the characters won't or can't fully trust one another. In some ways, gothic heroes are the OG morally gray heroes: the FMC knows she can't trust him for some reason, but she's so unbearably attracted to him that yes, she'll marry him and put herself entirely in his power.
This is a debut and it can feel like it at times: the plot takes a little bit of time to settle in, with Isobel and Giles spending much of the first half separated. It is an open door romance, although it's not super explicit. Go into this one for the relationship push-and-pull, not the bedroom hijinks!
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
So, the basics: Isobel, dutiful daughter who usually goes along to get along, jumps at the chance to travel to her sister's home. And to be fair, the letter she gets is pretty alarming; her sister's husband has written to say that she's ill. Isobel knows she's got to get out while she can (her "fiancé" is getting antsy to make things official) so she leaves during a snowstorm and gets stranded about an hour from her sister's house. Luckily, she's stranded at the gate to mysterious local hottie Lord Trevelyan's house, who reluctantly agrees to put her up for the night. Surprise, surprise, Giles (that's Lord T) and Isobel feel almost irresistibly attracted to each other. (They do mange to resist for a little while ... but honestly not all that long.)
This really feels like a gothic romance to me, with touches of Bluebeard and Rebecca. Like most gothic romances, the conflict hinges on the trust between the two main characters: both Isobel and Giles have moments where they simply can't trust the other. And, like many gothic romances, there are Reasons why the characters can't simply open up to each other. Here, there's a mix of reticent Regency propriety and personal issues. It's important to go into any gothic romance knowing that the characters won't or can't fully trust one another. In some ways, gothic heroes are the OG morally gray heroes: the FMC knows she can't trust him for some reason, but she's so unbearably attracted to him that yes, she'll marry him and put herself entirely in his power.
This is a debut and it can feel like it at times: the plot takes a little bit of time to settle in, with Isobel and Giles spending much of the first half separated. It is an open door romance, although it's not super explicit. Go into this one for the relationship push-and-pull, not the bedroom hijinks!
This objective review is based on a complimentary copy of the novel.
August 17, 2025
I liked the book and the gothic, brooding atmosphere of it. This is the first book I’ve read by this author.
Lady Semphill and her son, Elias, are slimy, nasty people. Too concerned about status, money and their own consequence to give consideration to others.
I liked Isabel, she was delightfully naive.
Poor Marianne, stuck with an uncaring husband, Lord Pemberton, who she loves so much. And so sad that she has so many miscarriages which further enraged her husband who wants an heir badly. She certainly didn’t balk at giving Isabel advice about how the world really works and what a woman’s place is but it was definitely coloured by her own experience.
I knew the minute I read Lord Trevelyan’s fiancee’s name, Miss Aurelia Gouldsmith, that I didn’t like her. lol.
The small town and society sounds like what small towns everywhere are like so that was well written by the author.
I felt Giles let Aurelia’s ghost take up far too much of his mind. He needs to move on.
I can see why Isabel feels like she can never displace Aurelia in Giles’ affections.
I liked the romance arc, the initial rush of feeling, the pull back, the obstacles and the final HEA.
There were a few odd weird choices IMO. They weren’t incorrect but felt like unusual choices to me. For instance at one point Giles sits beside Isobel and the author writes that his leg ‘bristled beside her leg’. I thought that odd since they both had clothes on so she wouldn’t have felt the hair on his leg. I could understand ‘brushed’, ‘pressed’ or ‘touched’ etc but ‘bristled’ didn’t seem to fit. Another time she used the negatively contextual word ‘obnoxious’ as in ‘Her mind was performing an obnoxious series of somersaults…’ when I think the author means Isobel was happily excited by Giles’ nearness to her. So it was not a problem but just curious to me, making me step outside the story to wonder why those words were chosen.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Lady Semphill and her son, Elias, are slimy, nasty people. Too concerned about status, money and their own consequence to give consideration to others.
I liked Isabel, she was delightfully naive.
Poor Marianne, stuck with an uncaring husband, Lord Pemberton, who she loves so much. And so sad that she has so many miscarriages which further enraged her husband who wants an heir badly. She certainly didn’t balk at giving Isabel advice about how the world really works and what a woman’s place is but it was definitely coloured by her own experience.
I knew the minute I read Lord Trevelyan’s fiancee’s name, Miss Aurelia Gouldsmith, that I didn’t like her. lol.
The small town and society sounds like what small towns everywhere are like so that was well written by the author.
I felt Giles let Aurelia’s ghost take up far too much of his mind. He needs to move on.
I can see why Isabel feels like she can never displace Aurelia in Giles’ affections.
I liked the romance arc, the initial rush of feeling, the pull back, the obstacles and the final HEA.
There were a few odd weird choices IMO. They weren’t incorrect but felt like unusual choices to me. For instance at one point Giles sits beside Isobel and the author writes that his leg ‘bristled beside her leg’. I thought that odd since they both had clothes on so she wouldn’t have felt the hair on his leg. I could understand ‘brushed’, ‘pressed’ or ‘touched’ etc but ‘bristled’ didn’t seem to fit. Another time she used the negatively contextual word ‘obnoxious’ as in ‘Her mind was performing an obnoxious series of somersaults…’ when I think the author means Isobel was happily excited by Giles’ nearness to her. So it was not a problem but just curious to me, making me step outside the story to wonder why those words were chosen.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 5, 2025
Isobel may be the daughter of a Viscount but she has spent her life sequestered in the countryside. Her vibrant sister married and left, leaving Isobel with her eccentric father, the attentions of the neighbour she’s expected to marry and his overbearing mother.
When her sister takes ill unexpectedly, Isobel seizes the opportunity to visit her sister and briefly escape her increasingly suffocating situation. However, a snowstorm forces Isobel to seek shelter with the enigmatic Giles, Earl of Cambo, a man she feels an instant connection to, despite the lingering presence of his former bride-to-be who mysteriously disappeared.
Isobel has long acted as a peacekeeper around her father and her odious neighbours, but her quiet demeanour hides an unexpected strength. She may seem a touch meek at the start of the book but she quickly reaches her tipping point and I loved Isobel’s development over the course of the book. She needs that steel and determination when others try to force her into the betrothal she’s increasingly desperate to escape.
Giles was such an intriguing character because he starts off seeming brooding and mysterious, but his POV shows that he’s actually such a sweetheart. He’s constantly putting his foot in his mouth around Isobel because he gets flustered by his attraction to her. His secrets and guilt keep him from opening up to Isobel the way he wants to, and his loneliness hurt my heart.
The connection between Isobel and Giles was instant but circumstances force them apart. It blossomed into a tender love that thrives in the quiet moments when they’re able to leave the past where it belongs.
This book had an atmospheric quality that immersed me into the story, with the windswept Northumberland countryside feeling like a character in its own right. The mystery of what happened to Aurelia, Giles’s ill-fated former betrothed, and the gothic touches added an eerie tone that was intriguing but didn’t overshadow the burgeoning romance between Isobel and Giles.
This was such a strong debut by Lauren M. Hayworth and I’m definitely impressed and looking forward to what’s next.
*I received a review copy from the author - this is my honest opinion.
When her sister takes ill unexpectedly, Isobel seizes the opportunity to visit her sister and briefly escape her increasingly suffocating situation. However, a snowstorm forces Isobel to seek shelter with the enigmatic Giles, Earl of Cambo, a man she feels an instant connection to, despite the lingering presence of his former bride-to-be who mysteriously disappeared.
Isobel has long acted as a peacekeeper around her father and her odious neighbours, but her quiet demeanour hides an unexpected strength. She may seem a touch meek at the start of the book but she quickly reaches her tipping point and I loved Isobel’s development over the course of the book. She needs that steel and determination when others try to force her into the betrothal she’s increasingly desperate to escape.
Giles was such an intriguing character because he starts off seeming brooding and mysterious, but his POV shows that he’s actually such a sweetheart. He’s constantly putting his foot in his mouth around Isobel because he gets flustered by his attraction to her. His secrets and guilt keep him from opening up to Isobel the way he wants to, and his loneliness hurt my heart.
The connection between Isobel and Giles was instant but circumstances force them apart. It blossomed into a tender love that thrives in the quiet moments when they’re able to leave the past where it belongs.
This book had an atmospheric quality that immersed me into the story, with the windswept Northumberland countryside feeling like a character in its own right. The mystery of what happened to Aurelia, Giles’s ill-fated former betrothed, and the gothic touches added an eerie tone that was intriguing but didn’t overshadow the burgeoning romance between Isobel and Giles.
This was such a strong debut by Lauren M. Hayworth and I’m definitely impressed and looking forward to what’s next.
*I received a review copy from the author - this is my honest opinion.
September 16, 2025
ARC REVIEW
This debut novel from Lauren M. Hayworth is a standalone, gothic historical romance set in 1814 Northumberland. When Miss Isobel Ridgeway finds herself stranded in a snowstorm en route to visit her sister, she must seek shelter with Lord Giles Trevelyan, Earl of Cambo. Giles is a man she knows only by his reputation - the fiancé of Aurelia Goldsmith, the renowned beauty who seemingly vanished into thin air.
I really, really enjoyed this historical romance. I made me remember why I love this genre! The characters were so well written and everything from the setting, the dialogue and the overall plot was just perfect.
Giles and Isobel were such a well matched couple. Both characters found themselves in situations that they really didn’t want for themselves. I loved watching both of them fall in love and get the happy ending they deserved. Their connection was instant and there was definite chemistry there from the beginning.
I found Isobel really empowering - once she decided the future ahead of her wasn’t what she wanted, she tried to change it. She had a plan and was not going to let anyone deter her from that. Giles was one of the few people who didn’t underestimate her and I thought that added nicely to their overall dynamic.
Since Aurelia’s disappearance, Giles has become a bit of a recluse. He had accepted his circumstances and it’s only the arrival of Isobel into his life that encourages him seek happiness again. She really helped bring out the light in him and gives him the chance to not only be better but be himself.
The gothic twist added a really interesting element and definitely helps this book stand out from the crowd. I thought it was so well done! By the end of the book I really felt like I knew Aurelia and connected with her just as much as I had connected with Giles and Isobel.
I absolutely loved this book and cannot wait to see what Lauren does next! Thank you so much to Lauren for the opportunity to read this in advance. All opinions are my own.
This debut novel from Lauren M. Hayworth is a standalone, gothic historical romance set in 1814 Northumberland. When Miss Isobel Ridgeway finds herself stranded in a snowstorm en route to visit her sister, she must seek shelter with Lord Giles Trevelyan, Earl of Cambo. Giles is a man she knows only by his reputation - the fiancé of Aurelia Goldsmith, the renowned beauty who seemingly vanished into thin air.
I really, really enjoyed this historical romance. I made me remember why I love this genre! The characters were so well written and everything from the setting, the dialogue and the overall plot was just perfect.
Giles and Isobel were such a well matched couple. Both characters found themselves in situations that they really didn’t want for themselves. I loved watching both of them fall in love and get the happy ending they deserved. Their connection was instant and there was definite chemistry there from the beginning.
I found Isobel really empowering - once she decided the future ahead of her wasn’t what she wanted, she tried to change it. She had a plan and was not going to let anyone deter her from that. Giles was one of the few people who didn’t underestimate her and I thought that added nicely to their overall dynamic.
Since Aurelia’s disappearance, Giles has become a bit of a recluse. He had accepted his circumstances and it’s only the arrival of Isobel into his life that encourages him seek happiness again. She really helped bring out the light in him and gives him the chance to not only be better but be himself.
The gothic twist added a really interesting element and definitely helps this book stand out from the crowd. I thought it was so well done! By the end of the book I really felt like I knew Aurelia and connected with her just as much as I had connected with Giles and Isobel.
I absolutely loved this book and cannot wait to see what Lauren does next! Thank you so much to Lauren for the opportunity to read this in advance. All opinions are my own.
September 26, 2025
📚✨ BOOK REVIEW ✨📚
Title: The Lover’s Eye 👁️ (Debut Novel)
Author: Lauren M. Hayworth
Genre: Historical Fiction / Gothic Mystery
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 – gorgeous atmosphere, lots of intrigue)
📝 My Take: Broodingly Beautiful Book Bolstered by Big Burdens.
For a first book, this one really impressed me. The Gothic vibe is strong, moody, mysterious, and it pulls you right in. If you like your historical reads with plenty of shadows and secrets, you’ll enjoy this.
The story centers on Isabel, who starts off innocent and a little sheltered, but quickly gets a crash course in how harsh life (and people) can be. Marianne’s storyline adds another layer, though be aware it touches on miscarriage, grief, and a cold, neglectful marriage.
I thought the author nailed the feel of suffocating small-town society, every interaction felt heavy with unspoken rules and judgment. The Semphill family? Ugh, easy to hate. And then there’s the ghost of Miss Gouldsmith lurking in the background. Lord Trevelyan is your classic brooding hero, haunted by the past and oh-so complicated which makes his chemistry with Isabel tense but rewarding. Their romance had plenty of bumps, but the payoff was worth it. Yes, it’s dark, but it’s still a satisfying love story in the end.
Standalone or series? Just one book, no series.
⚠️ Heads up: Includes a neglectful marriage, miscarriage/grief themes, and typical Gothic danger.
Who’s it for?
Anyone who likes a mix of historical romance and mystery, fans of moody, atmospheric books, and readers who appreciate a wounded hero working through his baggage before finally getting that happy ending.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
“The past couldn’t be changed, but wounds could mend into scars. Regret could percolate into virtues, lessons, teachings.
📌 Bottom Line:
A strong 4-star debut. Perfect for curling up with on a rainy afternoon when you want something atmospheric, emotional, and just a little dark.
#RNreads #TheLoversEye #LaurenMHayworth #GothicMystery #HistoricalRomance #BroodingHero #DebutAuthor #MustRead #4StarReview #Bookstagram #RNreads
Title: The Lover’s Eye 👁️ (Debut Novel)
Author: Lauren M. Hayworth
Genre: Historical Fiction / Gothic Mystery
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5 – gorgeous atmosphere, lots of intrigue)
📝 My Take: Broodingly Beautiful Book Bolstered by Big Burdens.
For a first book, this one really impressed me. The Gothic vibe is strong, moody, mysterious, and it pulls you right in. If you like your historical reads with plenty of shadows and secrets, you’ll enjoy this.
The story centers on Isabel, who starts off innocent and a little sheltered, but quickly gets a crash course in how harsh life (and people) can be. Marianne’s storyline adds another layer, though be aware it touches on miscarriage, grief, and a cold, neglectful marriage.
I thought the author nailed the feel of suffocating small-town society, every interaction felt heavy with unspoken rules and judgment. The Semphill family? Ugh, easy to hate. And then there’s the ghost of Miss Gouldsmith lurking in the background. Lord Trevelyan is your classic brooding hero, haunted by the past and oh-so complicated which makes his chemistry with Isabel tense but rewarding. Their romance had plenty of bumps, but the payoff was worth it. Yes, it’s dark, but it’s still a satisfying love story in the end.
Standalone or series? Just one book, no series.
⚠️ Heads up: Includes a neglectful marriage, miscarriage/grief themes, and typical Gothic danger.
Who’s it for?
Anyone who likes a mix of historical romance and mystery, fans of moody, atmospheric books, and readers who appreciate a wounded hero working through his baggage before finally getting that happy ending.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
“The past couldn’t be changed, but wounds could mend into scars. Regret could percolate into virtues, lessons, teachings.
📌 Bottom Line:
A strong 4-star debut. Perfect for curling up with on a rainy afternoon when you want something atmospheric, emotional, and just a little dark.
#RNreads #TheLoversEye #LaurenMHayworth #GothicMystery #HistoricalRomance #BroodingHero #DebutAuthor #MustRead #4StarReview #Bookstagram #RNreads
August 28, 2025
The Lover’s Eye, Lauren Hayworth’s stunning debut novel, brims with gothic elements, tension, well-developed characters, and beautiful writing. Inspired by Daphne Du Maurier’s Rebecca, Hayworth takes on the challenge of a dual point-of-view, maintaining enough mystery and uncertainty to keep the plot compelling, even with insight into the male main character, Giles. She also delivers a satisfying HEA, not typical of gothic fiction, but well-suited to a historical romance set in Regency Northumberland.
The relationship between Isobel and Giles, two haunted and overlooked individuals, is carefully developed following a chance encounter and a brief forced proximity during a snowstorm. A spark is evident from the beginning, though societal and familial expectations threaten to extinguish it before it can truly ignite. I appreciated the slow burn that emerged from this set-up. Isobel’s personal growth, in particular, ensures the couple’s future feels earned and believable. I loved their love story.
The Northumberland coast, complete with a Lindisfarne-like island, adds depth to the gothic atmosphere. The setting becomes a character in its own right, shaping the plot in meaningful ways. I loved all the gothic touches: the isolated and oppressive house, psychological elements, sinister side characters, a missing figure who haunts the narrative, and the dark, gloomy rooms of Cambo House.
Overall, this is a richly detailed and immersive novel. It includes some open-door scenes and offers wonderful emotional development and yearning. Once I hit the 30% mark, I didn’t want to put it down. I’m excited to see what Hayworth writes next!
I received an advanced reader copy and am leaving this review voluntarily.
The relationship between Isobel and Giles, two haunted and overlooked individuals, is carefully developed following a chance encounter and a brief forced proximity during a snowstorm. A spark is evident from the beginning, though societal and familial expectations threaten to extinguish it before it can truly ignite. I appreciated the slow burn that emerged from this set-up. Isobel’s personal growth, in particular, ensures the couple’s future feels earned and believable. I loved their love story.
The Northumberland coast, complete with a Lindisfarne-like island, adds depth to the gothic atmosphere. The setting becomes a character in its own right, shaping the plot in meaningful ways. I loved all the gothic touches: the isolated and oppressive house, psychological elements, sinister side characters, a missing figure who haunts the narrative, and the dark, gloomy rooms of Cambo House.
Overall, this is a richly detailed and immersive novel. It includes some open-door scenes and offers wonderful emotional development and yearning. Once I hit the 30% mark, I didn’t want to put it down. I’m excited to see what Hayworth writes next!
I received an advanced reader copy and am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 17, 2025
I really enjoyed this story, I could barely put it down once I started reading. The story involves Isobel who seems on course to marry an insufferable mama's boy despite her wishes as her father has arranged. Isobel gets a message from her sister's new husband who asks her to visit because her sister had become ill. Isobel rushes off to see her sister but doesn't quite make it due to her carriage being stuck in a snowstorm. She is stuck for a few days in the home of the mysterious reclusive Lord Giles Trevelyan before it's safe to travel to her sister. They develop a fondness for each other despite Gile's mysterious recent past involving a missing fiancé. Frustratingly they are unable to get around Gile's secrets and Isobel's curiosity and Isobel goes back home to deal with her fate and impending betrothal.
Things get out of hand with the truly vile intended fiancé and his mother so Isobel puts herself on track to enter the marriage mart or become a spinster or governess. The situation between Isobel and Giles improves but the missing fiancé, Giles secrets and Isobel's curiosity/insecurities threaten to destroy them all.
The main characters are both likeable and I was rooting for them thru the entire story. The story was gothic but not too dark, slow burn with a bit of spice but not enough spice to take over the plot. I Ioved the setting and how the parts all fit together at the end. I would definitely read more from this author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Things get out of hand with the truly vile intended fiancé and his mother so Isobel puts herself on track to enter the marriage mart or become a spinster or governess. The situation between Isobel and Giles improves but the missing fiancé, Giles secrets and Isobel's curiosity/insecurities threaten to destroy them all.
The main characters are both likeable and I was rooting for them thru the entire story. The story was gothic but not too dark, slow burn with a bit of spice but not enough spice to take over the plot. I Ioved the setting and how the parts all fit together at the end. I would definitely read more from this author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 19, 2025
"Their arms twined and squeezed, straining to bring them closer, and closer still. No intimacy was enough to satisfy the soul-crushing longing between then; a need as fundamental as air."
The Lover's Eye is a regency romance following Isobel Ridgeway, who is promised in marriage to a family connection, as she takes a sudden trip to Northumberland to visit her sister who is unwell. By chance, she ends up seeking refuge from Lord Trevelyan, and as their attraction to one another grows, so does the mystery surronding Lord Trevelyan's previous betrothed...
I loved this book! It was beautifully written with lovely descriptions of nature, and I enjoyed reading of the blossoming romance and connection between Isobel and Giles. The pace was just right, I enjoyed how the couple had a journey to get together, and the way the mystery unfolded surronding Aurelia was well woven throughout.
This definitely doesn't read as a debut novel and is very well finished, and Hayworth has clearly done a lot of research into the regency period. I definitely found it slightly reminiscent of Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier, which makes sense given the author's note at the end.
Overall this was wholly enjoyable, and I could definitely see myself revisting this in the future, as well as any other works that Hayworth releases.
4.5 stars
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Lover's Eye is a regency romance following Isobel Ridgeway, who is promised in marriage to a family connection, as she takes a sudden trip to Northumberland to visit her sister who is unwell. By chance, she ends up seeking refuge from Lord Trevelyan, and as their attraction to one another grows, so does the mystery surronding Lord Trevelyan's previous betrothed...
I loved this book! It was beautifully written with lovely descriptions of nature, and I enjoyed reading of the blossoming romance and connection between Isobel and Giles. The pace was just right, I enjoyed how the couple had a journey to get together, and the way the mystery unfolded surronding Aurelia was well woven throughout.
This definitely doesn't read as a debut novel and is very well finished, and Hayworth has clearly done a lot of research into the regency period. I definitely found it slightly reminiscent of Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier, which makes sense given the author's note at the end.
Overall this was wholly enjoyable, and I could definitely see myself revisting this in the future, as well as any other works that Hayworth releases.
4.5 stars
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 11, 2025
When she receives word her sister has fallen ill, Isobel Ridgeway braves an impending winter storm to reach her, but instead gets waylaid and then snowed in at the home of Lord Giles Trevelyan, a reclusive earl cloaked in rumors about the disappearance of his fiancee Aurelia six months prior. Isobel and Giles share an instant connection built on a mutual love of reading, poetry and the classics, but the shadows of the past loom heavy over them, threatening their burgeoning relationship 👀
First of all, can we get some appreciation for this cover?? It’s stunning. I didn’t know about Lover’s Eye jewelry prior to reading this book and I loved reading more about this cool (if v creepy) historical detail.
The novel really shines in its nods to Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca. I binged the back half when the mystery of what happened to Aurelia picked up and the secrets threatened to spill over, and I loveddd the windswept coastal setting. I’m excited to see what Lauren writes next!
First of all, can we get some appreciation for this cover?? It’s stunning. I didn’t know about Lover’s Eye jewelry prior to reading this book and I loved reading more about this cool (if v creepy) historical detail.
The novel really shines in its nods to Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca. I binged the back half when the mystery of what happened to Aurelia picked up and the secrets threatened to spill over, and I loveddd the windswept coastal setting. I’m excited to see what Lauren writes next!
September 15, 2025
The Lover’s Eye, by Lauren M. Hayworth, is mesmerizing tale of Isobel Ridgeway, who was betrothed by her father to someone she detests which was likely to occur on the year this story starts, 1814. What makes this story unusual is that she plans her escape and finds herself entwined with someone suspected but never accused of murdering his fiancée. She commits herself to solving the murder, wherever it might lead.
Isobel, a smart and practical woman, loves her family dearly, her father and sister. In this story, she confronts the family she knew and loved to the family that has changed primarily due to money. In this book, the lack of regard for a woman’s mind prevalent during this time period is described in her relations with with her family, the police and her (initial) fiancée.
I recommend this book to those that enjoy a romance with a mystery layered on.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
September 29, 2025
This was unlike the typical Regency in that it did not take place in London. The desolate seaside landscape created a dramatic backdrop for a troubled romance. Giles and Isobel were surrounded by potential danger and nothing was as it first seemed. Something was very wrong, and their new marriage wasn't going to survive unless the air got cleared once and for all.
I wasn't able to put this book down and the ending was not what I expected. Granted, the main characters did occasionally suffer from an inability to communicate. However, this shortcoming was outweighed by their otherwise great chemistry. The book also featured annoying neighbors, strange relatives, sinister servants and cute pets. An excellent first novel for this author!
I received a free ARC from BookSirens and this is my honest review.
I wasn't able to put this book down and the ending was not what I expected. Granted, the main characters did occasionally suffer from an inability to communicate. However, this shortcoming was outweighed by their otherwise great chemistry. The book also featured annoying neighbors, strange relatives, sinister servants and cute pets. An excellent first novel for this author!
I received a free ARC from BookSirens and this is my honest review.
August 31, 2025
The Lover’s Eye took me straight back to my 14-year-old self sneaking romance novels under the covers. It’s got all the vibes—regency elegance, a touch of gothic atmosphere, and spice that’s tastefully YA-appropriate.
The characters? Relatable and—not annoying. The FMC was strong and lovable, and the MMC was a surprise favorite: gentle yet tortured (no morally gray shadow-daddy). Honestly, it gave me Pride and Prejudice-after-the-wedding vibes… but with a murder mystery tossed in.
I devoured this cozy, adorable, and drama without the heartbreak. Lauren M. Hayworth gave us a gothic regency romance that’s as charming as it is bingeable, and I was totally vibing with it from start to finish.
The characters? Relatable and—not annoying. The FMC was strong and lovable, and the MMC was a surprise favorite: gentle yet tortured (no morally gray shadow-daddy). Honestly, it gave me Pride and Prejudice-after-the-wedding vibes… but with a murder mystery tossed in.
I devoured this cozy, adorable, and drama without the heartbreak. Lauren M. Hayworth gave us a gothic regency romance that’s as charming as it is bingeable, and I was totally vibing with it from start to finish.
October 26, 2025
Hayworth’s debut novel, The Lover’s Eye, is absolutely brilliant. A serendipitous moment brings Giles and Isobel together in the midst of a fierce snowstorm; their attraction instantaneous and their bond undeniable- threatening to grow into something more powerful and more meaningful than either could dare to dream. Hayworth’s story telling is sensational and transports you to the vivid world of Giles and Isobel seamlessly. You will not want to sit this novel down for even a moment as you try to uncover the truth behind Giles’s haunted past and the circumstances of the mysterious disappearance of his betrothed. The enthralling tale of this enamored couple will capture your heart and will serve as a gentle yet firm reminder that historical romance is not dead.
August 20, 2025
FMC: Isobel Ridgeway, is falling for Giles. Staying at his manor after a storm. Her sister Marianne is ill.
MMC: Giles Trevelyan handsome recluse is falling for her. Broody and into books. (We like them dark and intellectual)
What ever happened to his betrothed?
Talk about a SLOW burn! Um Hello! I so needed more.
The intrusive thoughts from Isobel and the lack of communication literally is made me insane. Please tell this isn’t how ppl navigated life. Uncertain and fearful.
I like the real life setting inspo and the literary inspo of Rebecca.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
MMC: Giles Trevelyan handsome recluse is falling for her. Broody and into books. (We like them dark and intellectual)
What ever happened to his betrothed?
Talk about a SLOW burn! Um Hello! I so needed more.
The intrusive thoughts from Isobel and the lack of communication literally is made me insane. Please tell this isn’t how ppl navigated life. Uncertain and fearful.
I like the real life setting inspo and the literary inspo of Rebecca.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 55 reviews