What do you think?
Namkeen Panion Ka Safar (Urdu Novel) By Munam Malik
Namkeen Panion Ka Safar is a soul-stirring Urdu novel by renowned writer Munam Malik, celebrated for her deep, emotional, and thought-provoking storytelling. This novel takes readers on a heartfelt journey through the complexities of love, relationships, and inner transformation. The story unfolds with rich emotions, tender moments, and unforgettable characters that resonate with the reader's own experiences. With her signature style, Munam Malik paints vivid images of bittersweet memories and moments that are both intensely personal and universally relatable. Whether you're a lover of modern Urdu fiction or just discovering Munam Malik's work, Namkeen Panion Ka Safar is a must-read that stays with you long after the last page. Munam Malik is a distinguished name in contemporary Urdu literature. Known for her powerful command over language and storytelling, her novels are admired for their emotional intensity, moral depth, and literary richness. She has a loyal fanbase both online and in print and continues to inspire readers with each new publication. Namkeen Panion Ka Safar novel Munam Malik Urdu novel Urdu romantic novels Best Urdu novels 2025 Munam Malik books Pakistani Urdu literature Social romantic Urdu novel Emotional Urdu story Urdu novels by female writers Urdu fiction bestseller Urdu love story book Heart-touching Urdu novel
704 pages, Hardcover
Published January 1, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
June 30, 2025
There are some books that stay with you, not because they offer grand lessons, but because they quietly touch something inside you. Namkeen Panion Ka Safar is one of those books. It doesn’t try to impress; it simply tells the truth… and that’s what makes it unforgettable. This Story was a whole ocean of emotions where every character was drowning in something. Love, guilt, silence, loss, or waiting. And the most painful part? No one really said what needed to be said, when it needed to be said. Munam Malik didn’t give us heroes and villains. She gave us people....flawed, real, soft from the inside, hard from the outside. People who loved deeply but couldn’t always love right. The kind of people we know in our own lives. Maybe even the kind we are. The book doesn't promise healing, but it shows what breaking looks like. And sometimes, that’s more powerful. By the end, I didn’t want to judge anyone. I just wanted to sit in silence and feel it all. This book didn’t give me answers. But it gave me a mirror. And that’s more than enough.
July 29, 2026
I can't believe I have never heard anything about this novel before reading it.Why is this novel so underrated. It deserves so much love 💗💗💗
July 15, 2025
One of the best novels I've ever read, it's such an underrated novel.. it's 100% worth it. I wish I could express my feelings after reading this novel.There's a lot to express but I don't have words.. it's a masterpiece
February 1, 2026
نمکین پانیوں کا سفر ۔یہ کتاب کے اتخاتیطام پر مجھے احساس ہوا کہ یہ نام مصنفہ نے کیوں چنا کیوکہ زندگی ایک نمکین پانیوں کا سفر ہی تو ہے ،جسمیں ہسی ،دکھ، بے بسی، مجبوری، صبر ،خالق پر تواکُل سب گزرتا ہے ،اس کتاب میں یہ سب ہے اور محض صرف کہنے کے لئے نہیں ،اسکے کردار آپکو یہ سب احساسات سے گُزارےگے
وہ بی بہت خوبصورت طریقے سے ۰
اس کتاب کی pdf میرے پاس تقریباً ایک سال سے پڑھی تھی اور بالآخر مینے اسے اس سال پڑھ لیا اور یقین مان نے یہ میرے اس سال کی اب تک کی بہترین کتاب میں سے ایک ہے ،اسکی سٹوری سادہ پر ٹوسٹ سےبرپور ،یہ کتاب لمبی سہی پر ایک جگہ پر بی مجھے بوریت نہیں ہوئ،یہ کتاب ان میں شامل ہوتی ہے جو آپکے ساتھ رہے جسکے کردار آپکو یاد رہیں اور مجھے سب سے زیادہ پسند بی اسکے کردار اے ،اتنے حقیقی پھر بی پور خلوص چیے وہ مثبت
ہوؤ یا منفی ,بہت بہترین طریقے سے لکھے گئے تھے ،اور ان منصفہ کی لکھائی ہی ہے جو بہت دلچسپ بہت منفرد انداز ہوتا ہے ،انکی لکھائی میں ایک الگ پختگی پائی جاتی ہے جو بہت کم دیکھنے کو ملتا ہے ،وہ یوں ہوتی ہے کہ آپکو ایک ہی جھملے میں بہت کچھ نہ کہ صرف کہہ جاتی ہے بلکہ احساس بی کراتی ہے ۰
اس کہانی کا مرکزی نکتہ تھا “مولوی حیات لادو اور شکلو ،پھر چائیے وہ ماضی کے ہو یا موجودازندگی کے ،جو زندگی کی حقیقتوں سے آن گزرے پر پھر بی صبر ،تحامُل شکر ،اپنے عزتِ نفس کو چونا ،منصفہ نے ایک جگہ پر کہا تھا “حالات انسان کو کبھی پستی میں گرنے پر مجبور نہیں کرتے جب تک اسکی اپنی سرشست نہ ایسے ہو “اور یہ بات میرے ساتھ رہ گئی کیوکہ میں ہمیشہ سے اس بات کی قائل تھی ،یہ بات اپنے اندر بہت گہرائے رکھتی ہے ،کہانی کے حوال سے بی اور زندگی کے حوال سے بی ؛کہانی کے لحاظ سے یو کہ کئی کردار آپکو اپنے لئے پستی چنتے ہوے خود دیکھیگے ،محض اپنے ایک غلط فیصلے سے وہ دوسروں کی زندگیاں مُشکلات سے بر دیتے ہے جب انکا امتحان آیا تو وہ کھرے نا اترے اور بعد کا پچھتاوا ،پر شائد حقیقی زندگی میں بی ایسا ہی ہوتا ہے ،آپ کسی ایک نتیجے پر نہیں اتر پاتے ،اور یہاں بی میں منصفہ کی لکھائی کو ڈاٹ دوگی جو اپنے قارئین پر یہ فیصلہ چور دیتی ہے کہ؛ آپ بتائیں کون غلط اور کون صحیح ذیادہ۔ سیریس ہوگیا !ہے نا؟! ،پر رکیے کہانی تو مازیکا بی تھی ایک دم چوبولی ،چھوٹے موٹے نوک جھوک ،ثانیہ اور سیمی کی شراتیں ،خضر کے انفنی جوکس اور اسکا رومانوی پین جو کہ بقول اسکی منقوحہ “چولے پر ابلنے والے دُھوھ کی طرح ہے “
اس کہانی نے مجھے رلایا بی ہے ہسایا بی ہے ،غصہ بی دلایا ہے ،اور اطمینان بی ،بہرحال جیساہم انگریزی میں کہتے ہے “it was a roller coaster”,ایک اطمینان بارے اختتام کے ساتھ ۰
وہ بی بہت خوبصورت طریقے سے ۰
اس کتاب کی pdf میرے پاس تقریباً ایک سال سے پڑھی تھی اور بالآخر مینے اسے اس سال پڑھ لیا اور یقین مان نے یہ میرے اس سال کی اب تک کی بہترین کتاب میں سے ایک ہے ،اسکی سٹوری سادہ پر ٹوسٹ سےبرپور ،یہ کتاب لمبی سہی پر ایک جگہ پر بی مجھے بوریت نہیں ہوئ،یہ کتاب ان میں شامل ہوتی ہے جو آپکے ساتھ رہے جسکے کردار آپکو یاد رہیں اور مجھے سب سے زیادہ پسند بی اسکے کردار اے ،اتنے حقیقی پھر بی پور خلوص چیے وہ مثبت
ہوؤ یا منفی ,بہت بہترین طریقے سے لکھے گئے تھے ،اور ان منصفہ کی لکھائی ہی ہے جو بہت دلچسپ بہت منفرد انداز ہوتا ہے ،انکی لکھائی میں ایک الگ پختگی پائی جاتی ہے جو بہت کم دیکھنے کو ملتا ہے ،وہ یوں ہوتی ہے کہ آپکو ایک ہی جھملے میں بہت کچھ نہ کہ صرف کہہ جاتی ہے بلکہ احساس بی کراتی ہے ۰
اس کہانی کا مرکزی نکتہ تھا “مولوی حیات لادو اور شکلو ،پھر چائیے وہ ماضی کے ہو یا موجودازندگی کے ،جو زندگی کی حقیقتوں سے آن گزرے پر پھر بی صبر ،تحامُل شکر ،اپنے عزتِ نفس کو چونا ،منصفہ نے ایک جگہ پر کہا تھا “حالات انسان کو کبھی پستی میں گرنے پر مجبور نہیں کرتے جب تک اسکی اپنی سرشست نہ ایسے ہو “اور یہ بات میرے ساتھ رہ گئی کیوکہ میں ہمیشہ سے اس بات کی قائل تھی ،یہ بات اپنے اندر بہت گہرائے رکھتی ہے ،کہانی کے حوال سے بی اور زندگی کے حوال سے بی ؛کہانی کے لحاظ سے یو کہ کئی کردار آپکو اپنے لئے پستی چنتے ہوے خود دیکھیگے ،محض اپنے ایک غلط فیصلے سے وہ دوسروں کی زندگیاں مُشکلات سے بر دیتے ہے جب انکا امتحان آیا تو وہ کھرے نا اترے اور بعد کا پچھتاوا ،پر شائد حقیقی زندگی میں بی ایسا ہی ہوتا ہے ،آپ کسی ایک نتیجے پر نہیں اتر پاتے ،اور یہاں بی میں منصفہ کی لکھائی کو ڈاٹ دوگی جو اپنے قارئین پر یہ فیصلہ چور دیتی ہے کہ؛ آپ بتائیں کون غلط اور کون صحیح ذیادہ۔ سیریس ہوگیا !ہے نا؟! ،پر رکیے کہانی تو مازیکا بی تھی ایک دم چوبولی ،چھوٹے موٹے نوک جھوک ،ثانیہ اور سیمی کی شراتیں ،خضر کے انفنی جوکس اور اسکا رومانوی پین جو کہ بقول اسکی منقوحہ “چولے پر ابلنے والے دُھوھ کی طرح ہے “
اس کہانی نے مجھے رلایا بی ہے ہسایا بی ہے ،غصہ بی دلایا ہے ،اور اطمینان بی ،بہرحال جیساہم انگریزی میں کہتے ہے “it was a roller coaster”,ایک اطمینان بارے اختتام کے ساتھ ۰
August 29, 2026
A treat for my soul -
The story revolves around the family of Maulvi Hayat and the sons of his brother.
Maulvi Hayat had married his elder daughter to his nephew, Hakim Hussain. Later, Hakim’s family also sought the hand of Maulvi Hayat’s younger daughter, Shakila, for Hakim’s elder brother, Saddam. However, when Maulvi Hayat learned about Saddam’s immoral lifestyle and his involvement with various women, he refused the proposal and called off the marriage.
Hakim took this rejection as a personal insult to his ego. As a result, he forbade his wife from visiting her parents or maintaining any relationship with her family. In response, Maulvi Hayat arranged Shakila’s marriage with Dastagir, the son of his sister-in-law.
Hakim eventually proved to be an extremely controlling and suspicious husband. He constantly doubted his wife’s character, subjected her to emotional and physical abuse, and imposed strict restrictions on her life. Despite everything, she tried her best to preserve her marriage and fulfill her duties as a wife.
When Hakim learned that Shakila was getting married, he arranged a marriage for his brother Saddam as well. Saddam was married to a respectable young woman from a nearby town. Soon afterward, both Hakim’s wife and Saddam’s wife became pregnant. Hakim’s wife gave birth to a healthy and beautiful son, but tragedy struck when Saddam’s wife died during childbirth.
On the very day of his wife’s death, Saddam reunited with a woman he had loved years earlier. He brought her home and married her. This woman was named Saba.
Around the same time, Hakim and Saddam’s mother suffered a paralytic stroke and became bedridden for the remainder of her life. One day, when her condition worsened and she repeatedly called for her sons, Hakim went searching for Saddam. During this search, he discovered Saddam living with a woman. Saddam quickly covered the situation by claiming that he had already married her, and thus Saba was formally accepted into the family.
After arriving at the family home, Saba insisted on living in the same household as everyone else. Over time, the entire family continued living together, and children were born into both households. As the years passed, the children grew into handsome, intelligent, and capable young adults.
Saba, however, carried deep insecurities. She could not tolerate the respect and admiration Hakim’s wife received from everyone around her. While Hakim’s wife was regarded as a woman of dignity and good character, Saba constantly felt judged because of her own past. This jealousy gradually developed into resentment.
The story then shifts to the younger generation, particularly to Shamaila Khan. Shamaila was the daughter of Bahadur Khan, one of the wealthiest and most influential men in the village. She lived in the grand Bahadur Haveli and was best friends with Seemi, Hakim Hussain’s daughter.
Seemi possessed exceptional writing talent and secretly wrote novels and stories. Shamaila would publish these writings under her own name and receive all the praise and recognition. Through these novels, Shamaila came into contact with Khizar, and eventually they appeared to fall in love. However, Khizar did not know that Seemi was the true author behind the works he admired.
As time passed, Seemi’s marriage was arranged with her cousin. Shortly before the wedding, she was caught meeting Khizar. In reality, she had only gone there because Shamaila had asked her to deliver a manuscript. However, nobody listened to her explanation. To protect herself, Shamaila denied any involvement and pretended she knew nothing about the situation.
All the blame fell on Seemi. Her reputation was ruined, and her father decided to marry her to Karam Ilahi, a man who was even older than her own father. Realizing the injustice of the situation, Seemi’s mother secretly helped her escape and arranged her marriage to Khizar instead.
Khizar was later revealed to be the son of Shakila and Dastagir. After the marriage, Khizar and Seemi moved to the city and slowly developed understanding and affection for one another.
Eventually, Khizar discovered the truth about the novels. He learned that Seemi, not Shamaila, had been the real writer all along. He confronted Shamaila and admitted that he had always admired and loved the person behind the writing. The feelings he believed he had for Shamaila had originated entirely from Seemi’s words and talent.
This revelation shattered Shamaila. Unable to accept the truth, she became obsessed with taking Khizar away from Seemi. Driven by jealousy and wounded pride, she contacted Seemi’s family and her former fiancé, informing them of Seemi’s whereabouts.
They tracked Seemi down and forcibly brought her back to the village. During this period, Seemi was poisoned. Initially, everyone suspected her father, but the truth was eventually revealed: the culprit was her uncle’s wife, a woman who had long harbored envy and resentment toward Seemi’s mother and her daughters.
The poisoning left Seemi in a coma for a long time. Her survival became uncertain, and the entire family was forced to confront the consequences of their actions. Eventually, she regained consciousness, and one by one, long-buried truths came to light.
Meanwhile, because Seemi had escaped marriage to Karam Ilahi, her sister Saima was married to him instead. Despite the enormous age difference, Saima proved to be a devoted and compassionate wife. She cared for Karam Ilahi faithfully during his final years. In return, he developed deep affection and respect for her and eventually transferred his property and assets into her name before his death.
As the truth emerged and family conflicts began to settle, many characters were forced to face their mistakes. Hakim finally realized the damage his suspicions, cruelty, and pride had caused throughout his life. However, his repentance came too late.
His wife, after enduring years of abuse, finally decided she had suffered enough. She told him that she had tolerated his brutality when it was directed at her, but she would never allow him to harm their children. Having raised a son capable of supporting her, she no longer felt compelled to remain in the marriage. She left Hakim and returned to Maulvi Hayat’s house with her children.
Saba also underwent a transformation. Believing that her own reputation and past mistakes might negatively affect her daughter’s future, she quietly left the family home, leaving behind only a note.
In the end, Seemi and Khizar’s relationship was publicly accepted. Their marriage was celebrated properly, and many of the wedding customs and ceremonies that had been missed the first time were finally completed. The hidden truths were exposed, misunderstandings were resolved, and justice was served.
Although the novel contains tragedy, betrayal, and loss, it ultimately ends on a hopeful note. Some relationships are repaired, some mistakes are forgiven, and others leave permanent scars. Yet the story closes with the message that truth eventually prevails, and that patience, integrity, and sincerity are ultimately rewarded.
The story revolves around the family of Maulvi Hayat and the sons of his brother.
Maulvi Hayat had married his elder daughter to his nephew, Hakim Hussain. Later, Hakim’s family also sought the hand of Maulvi Hayat’s younger daughter, Shakila, for Hakim’s elder brother, Saddam. However, when Maulvi Hayat learned about Saddam’s immoral lifestyle and his involvement with various women, he refused the proposal and called off the marriage.
Hakim took this rejection as a personal insult to his ego. As a result, he forbade his wife from visiting her parents or maintaining any relationship with her family. In response, Maulvi Hayat arranged Shakila’s marriage with Dastagir, the son of his sister-in-law.
Hakim eventually proved to be an extremely controlling and suspicious husband. He constantly doubted his wife’s character, subjected her to emotional and physical abuse, and imposed strict restrictions on her life. Despite everything, she tried her best to preserve her marriage and fulfill her duties as a wife.
When Hakim learned that Shakila was getting married, he arranged a marriage for his brother Saddam as well. Saddam was married to a respectable young woman from a nearby town. Soon afterward, both Hakim’s wife and Saddam’s wife became pregnant. Hakim’s wife gave birth to a healthy and beautiful son, but tragedy struck when Saddam’s wife died during childbirth.
On the very day of his wife’s death, Saddam reunited with a woman he had loved years earlier. He brought her home and married her. This woman was named Saba.
Around the same time, Hakim and Saddam’s mother suffered a paralytic stroke and became bedridden for the remainder of her life. One day, when her condition worsened and she repeatedly called for her sons, Hakim went searching for Saddam. During this search, he discovered Saddam living with a woman. Saddam quickly covered the situation by claiming that he had already married her, and thus Saba was formally accepted into the family.
After arriving at the family home, Saba insisted on living in the same household as everyone else. Over time, the entire family continued living together, and children were born into both households. As the years passed, the children grew into handsome, intelligent, and capable young adults.
Saba, however, carried deep insecurities. She could not tolerate the respect and admiration Hakim’s wife received from everyone around her. While Hakim’s wife was regarded as a woman of dignity and good character, Saba constantly felt judged because of her own past. This jealousy gradually developed into resentment.
The story then shifts to the younger generation, particularly to Shamaila Khan. Shamaila was the daughter of Bahadur Khan, one of the wealthiest and most influential men in the village. She lived in the grand Bahadur Haveli and was best friends with Seemi, Hakim Hussain’s daughter.
Seemi possessed exceptional writing talent and secretly wrote novels and stories. Shamaila would publish these writings under her own name and receive all the praise and recognition. Through these novels, Shamaila came into contact with Khizar, and eventually they appeared to fall in love. However, Khizar did not know that Seemi was the true author behind the works he admired.
As time passed, Seemi’s marriage was arranged with her cousin. Shortly before the wedding, she was caught meeting Khizar. In reality, she had only gone there because Shamaila had asked her to deliver a manuscript. However, nobody listened to her explanation. To protect herself, Shamaila denied any involvement and pretended she knew nothing about the situation.
All the blame fell on Seemi. Her reputation was ruined, and her father decided to marry her to Karam Ilahi, a man who was even older than her own father. Realizing the injustice of the situation, Seemi’s mother secretly helped her escape and arranged her marriage to Khizar instead.
Khizar was later revealed to be the son of Shakila and Dastagir. After the marriage, Khizar and Seemi moved to the city and slowly developed understanding and affection for one another.
Eventually, Khizar discovered the truth about the novels. He learned that Seemi, not Shamaila, had been the real writer all along. He confronted Shamaila and admitted that he had always admired and loved the person behind the writing. The feelings he believed he had for Shamaila had originated entirely from Seemi’s words and talent.
This revelation shattered Shamaila. Unable to accept the truth, she became obsessed with taking Khizar away from Seemi. Driven by jealousy and wounded pride, she contacted Seemi’s family and her former fiancé, informing them of Seemi’s whereabouts.
They tracked Seemi down and forcibly brought her back to the village. During this period, Seemi was poisoned. Initially, everyone suspected her father, but the truth was eventually revealed: the culprit was her uncle’s wife, a woman who had long harbored envy and resentment toward Seemi’s mother and her daughters.
The poisoning left Seemi in a coma for a long time. Her survival became uncertain, and the entire family was forced to confront the consequences of their actions. Eventually, she regained consciousness, and one by one, long-buried truths came to light.
Meanwhile, because Seemi had escaped marriage to Karam Ilahi, her sister Saima was married to him instead. Despite the enormous age difference, Saima proved to be a devoted and compassionate wife. She cared for Karam Ilahi faithfully during his final years. In return, he developed deep affection and respect for her and eventually transferred his property and assets into her name before his death.
As the truth emerged and family conflicts began to settle, many characters were forced to face their mistakes. Hakim finally realized the damage his suspicions, cruelty, and pride had caused throughout his life. However, his repentance came too late.
His wife, after enduring years of abuse, finally decided she had suffered enough. She told him that she had tolerated his brutality when it was directed at her, but she would never allow him to harm their children. Having raised a son capable of supporting her, she no longer felt compelled to remain in the marriage. She left Hakim and returned to Maulvi Hayat’s house with her children.
Saba also underwent a transformation. Believing that her own reputation and past mistakes might negatively affect her daughter’s future, she quietly left the family home, leaving behind only a note.
In the end, Seemi and Khizar’s relationship was publicly accepted. Their marriage was celebrated properly, and many of the wedding customs and ceremonies that had been missed the first time were finally completed. The hidden truths were exposed, misunderstandings were resolved, and justice was served.
Although the novel contains tragedy, betrayal, and loss, it ultimately ends on a hopeful note. Some relationships are repaired, some mistakes are forgiven, and others leave permanent scars. Yet the story closes with the message that truth eventually prevails, and that patience, integrity, and sincerity are ultimately rewarded.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 14, 2025
The writing style was too good. This novel is so well written especially the 2nd half, I COULDN'T stop reading it.
بہت عمدہ طریقے سے کہانی کو سمیٹا گیا ہے۔ ❤️❤️
بہت عمدہ طریقے سے کہانی کو سمیٹا گیا ہے۔ ❤️❤️
June 4, 2026
یہ اس مصنفہ کی میری دوسری کتاب تھی، اور ایک بار پھر انہوں نے کوئی کسر نہیں چھوڑی کہ قاری سکون سے بیٹھ کر کتاب پڑھے ہی نہ۔ 😭
کہانی ایک ایسے خاندان کے گرد گھومتی ہے جہاں ہر کردار اپنی الگ شناخت رکھتا ہے؛ کوئی مکمل سیاہ، کوئی سفید، کوئی سرمئی، اور کوئی تمام رنگ اپنے اندر سموئے ہوئے۔
یہ ایک ایسا خاندان تھا جس کے لیے انا اور دنیا کی نظر اتنی اہم تھی کہ اس کی بھینٹ ان کے اپنے رشتے چڑھ گئے۔
کہانی کا ایک پہلو جو جتنا جاندار تھا، اتنا ہی میرے لیے تکلیف دہ بھی، وہ دوستی تھی جو بہترین انداز میں شروع ہوئی مگر اختتام دشمنی سے بھی بڑھ کر ہوا۔
حسد، انا، برابری اور حاصل کرنے کی جنگ پر لکھی گئی یہ ایک عمدہ کتاب ہے۔ تجسس سے بھرپور اور اندازِ تحریر ایسا کہ کتاب مکمل کیے بغیر رکھ دینا گویا کہانی کی روح کھو دینا ہے۔*
کہانی ایک ایسے خاندان کے گرد گھومتی ہے جہاں ہر کردار اپنی الگ شناخت رکھتا ہے؛ کوئی مکمل سیاہ، کوئی سفید، کوئی سرمئی، اور کوئی تمام رنگ اپنے اندر سموئے ہوئے۔
یہ ایک ایسا خاندان تھا جس کے لیے انا اور دنیا کی نظر اتنی اہم تھی کہ اس کی بھینٹ ان کے اپنے رشتے چڑھ گئے۔
کہانی کا ایک پہلو جو جتنا جاندار تھا، اتنا ہی میرے لیے تکلیف دہ بھی، وہ دوستی تھی جو بہترین انداز میں شروع ہوئی مگر اختتام دشمنی سے بھی بڑھ کر ہوا۔
حسد، انا، برابری اور حاصل کرنے کی جنگ پر لکھی گئی یہ ایک عمدہ کتاب ہے۔ تجسس سے بھرپور اور اندازِ تحریر ایسا کہ کتاب مکمل کیے بغیر رکھ دینا گویا کہانی کی روح کھو دینا ہے۔*
December 30, 2025
Deserve all the stars>>>>>>
June 22, 2026
I loveeeee munam's writing style!!!
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews