If you REALLY loved the author’s previous works and just want more of Memnon and Roxilana, you’ll probably enjoy this one.
But in any other case, this book isn’t really necessary, as we already knew how Memnon and Roxi’s story ended from the earlier books. Personally, I didn’t find this one particularly engaging. The ending was already known, the beginning was somewhat okay, and the middle part felt like it was just fighting, conquering, and sex.
Honestly, this book felt more like fanfiction. Maybe I’m just being picky, but I wouldn’t call it a well-developed story with a deep, well-crafted plot (if you know what I mean). There were some poorly handled details, but I will mention only those that stood out most to me.
First thing, the story starts when Roxilana is only 7 years old (then we see her at 12, 13, 16, and most of the story takes place when she’s in her 20s), but her POV never really reflects her age. It would’ve added so much depth if her thoughts and narration changed to reflect her growing up—but it didn’t. At 7 or 12, she thinks just like her older self. That was a missed opportunity.
Another detail: Roxilana was captured by the Romans when she was 7 and since then lived in Rome with a woman who adopted her. The woman didn’t treat her well and refused to call her by her real name. Apparently, because of that, Roxi forgot her actual name—but somehow still remembered the name of the island she came from. That felt off to me. If she forgot her own name, how could she remember her origins so clearly? Especially considering she was an uneducated child.
Speaking of that, Roxilana worked as a seamstress for her adoptive mother and had no access to education or books. Yet she casually thinks things like, "...like Julius Caesar and Pompey. Like Alexander the Great, Augustus, Marc Antony, and Cleopatra." How would she know all of these historical figures?
And finally, Roxilana as an FMC just didn’t work for me. She’s been living under an abusive household, never standing up for herself, and then suddenly—once she joins Memnon’s tribe—she becomes this bold, fiery girl out of nowhere. Her transformation didn’t feel earned or natural. And of course, despite Memnon being a ruthless warrior and conqueror, Roxi is the “pure soul” who feels bad about killing their enemies. It just made her character feel inconsistent and, honestly, a bit boring.
As for Memnon… well, he was just horny as always.
I know these are small details, and maybe most people wouldn’t even notice them. Maybe I overthink too much. But I believe that it’s those little things that make a story great—when they’re handled well. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case here, and because of that, I couldn’t get fully invested in the story.
To sum it up: This book is for you ONLY if you're a huge fan of the series. Otherwise, you’re not missing anything new—we already knew everything important in Selena’s flashbacks.