The Dead Beneath Us is a tightly plotted whodunnit in the style of Agatha Christie. And it is a very good whodunnit.
It tells the tale of the search for the murderer of Charles Brady, a reserved teacher at a prestigious public school. The top cop is Benjamin Dinescu and he leads a diverse team of investigators, each with their own issues and foibles.
There is a focus on the relationship between Dinescu and his newly arrived, keen to impress, Detective Sergeant. DS Emily Summers is the new broom that rubs up his settled crew, the wrong way. They need to sort themselves out before they can perform as a team.
There are a lot of partly broken people in this book. There are acknowledgements to PTSD, domestic abuse, disability, blindness and gambling addiction among others. They are not discussed in depth or at length but are used to point out that everyone has history, there are no "perfect" people and to a greater or lesser extent we are all vulnerable to something, but the important thing is not our weakness but our strength of character in overcoming the afflictions that life has dealt. This is a recurring but subtle theme throughout this novel.
The motley crew of investigators uncover a myriad of potential killers and indeed another historic murder. Two whodunnits for the price of one! The headmaster wants to keep media fallout to a minimum, One of the older students is infatuated with a young teacher who responds. The caretaker is also involved in dirty dealings. It's a web of lies and intrigue that goes back for decades.
The beauty of this novel is that it is authentic in that the author is an ex copper with 18years experience. This really tells in the latter stages of the book where the cumulative interrogations escalate to a crescendo. As well as being intense they are also educational. Did you know that, in UK law, an arrested person is not entitled to one phonecall or a solicitor cannot demand a break in questioning?
The spotlight falls on several red herrings and false trails before the final reveal. I'll be honest I didn't spot the killer and I'm normally pretty good at that. In hindsight the clues were all there. And at the end there's a little twist on top of the twist.
The writing style is spare and workmanlike, no verbosity or purple process. The plot is all.
This is such a cleverly plotted murder, police procedural. Well worth a read. This novel is the first in a series. I for one will be buying the rest in the series.
from grumpyoldbooks.blogspot.com