In 2021, Anthony Seldon, inspired by a fallen First World War soldier who dreamed of a 'Via Sacra' to commemorate the war dead and stand as a marker for the triumph of peace, set out on a 1,000km walk tracing the historic route of the Western Front. He went on to recount that story in the widely acclaimed The Path of Peace. But there wasn't to be lasting peace, with the continent falling into an even more horrific war two decades later.
In The Path of Light, Seldon sets out to walk a new 1,300 km route from the same starting point at Kilometre Zero to Auschwitz, discovering in the towns and villages through which he walks stories of women and men who bravely protected the vulnerable and stood up to evil in the face of unimaginable brutality during the Second World War.
As he ruminates on these 'figures of light', whose uplifting stories he encounters along his path, a pattern begins to emerge about how we can draw on their lives to build a better and more peaceful world, never more needed than now, with the ominous and increasing drumbeat of belligerence globally that month by month is the constant backdrop of his walk between 2023 and 2025. It proved a harder book to write than The Path of Peace. But it was a project he knew he had to complete, whatever the cost.
Sir Anthony Francis Seldon, FRSA, FRHistS, FKC, is a British educator and contemporary historian. He was the 13th Master (headmaster) of Wellington College, one of Britain's co-educational independent boarding schools. In 2009, he set up The Wellington Academy, the first state school to carry the name of its founding independent school. He was Vice-Chancellor of the University of Buckingham from 2015 to 2020. Seldon was knighted in the 2014 Birthday Honours for services to education and modern political history.
I had two different people say to me ‘jolly reading?’ while reading this (I’m assuming most books with the word Auschwitz on the cover get this), but I was left thoroughly uplifted by this travelogue by Anthony Seldon.
While walking across Europe to the most infamous of concentration camps, Seldon tells stories of heroism and bravery (some famous, some I’d never heard of) alongside ones of barbarity from the Second World War, all the while asking what makes people good and bad. I found his writing thought provoking and tender. He concludes the best people are the ‘bridge builders’, ones who saw beyond the Nazi hatred and tried to help Jewish people. Throughout the book Seldon draws parallels to today’s world, namely Russia / Ukraine and Isreal / Palestine, whilst also comparing today’s leaders with those in the 1930’s. As a ‘fighting age male’, his thoughts on the fragility of democracy, the degrading of world institutions, the appeasement of dictators and the complacency of believing another large scale war could not happen hit home.
Where to start... When I read a book I like to know the basic premise of the story and whilst this was too a degree obvious from the title, I don't think this is the case with The Path of Light.:Walking to Auschwitz and for a number of reasons which I shall cover below I think this book is one of the poorest I have read recently. So why did I read and finish it, well firstly because it was a gift - "how rude" as Jajar Binks would say, to be bought a gift of a book and to not actually read it. My usual practice for my own books is 100 - my age (52 years this week) number of pages before I decide. Secondly, it is a really important topic that we understand and remain educated on, and actually the basic subject matter is probably the most important point of the book.
So, to the review. This book is frustrating in its attempts to try and do many things, probably too many things in my mind so lets take them piece by piece:
The Journey - Many stories are journeys and I love them, whether in fiction or non-fiction, they represent the trials over adversity or the beauty of the route or something deep about how an individual engages along the route changing as they go. This book despite the title is not a true journey book - he didn't start at point A and walk to point B. He had a series of 15km rambles whilst he was on holiday in various locations and has stitched them together to try and produce a narrative, but this just comes across as disjointed, and unclear as to where we were (I even found the hand drawn maps confusing). There are many things that could have been done to make the journey more prominent - perhaps walking the routes of the death marches, but none of this happens and basically he stays in some nice hotels and goes for lunch and then for a wander with some mates. It isn't the trials of Frodo or the bike journeys of Mark Beaumont for instance.
The History - clearly the history is important to the story of the book, but again this feels all over the place - we jump from 1600s to the second world war and then to recent history and world events with which the author is all to ready to voice an opinion. I felt that the distant history was over done and the recent history was too quasi-political to be really necessary (let the reader make their own decisions about the senior politicians of the world, we don't need your opinion.) The important history was that of what was going on in WW2 and just before, but this felt somewhat lost in the narrative jumble.
The people - I was hoping for long beautiful stories about people overcoming evil and being great citizens of the world, clearly this was the main premise of the book, but because of everything else in there, there was little page space devoted to some of these important and great stories. If as stated he was going in search of the people of light then why spend so little time on them.
The author - The character I grew to struggle with the most. I wasn't entirely sure where to place him and I think this is the problem of the book, it just felt a bit all over the place. Was he Jewish or Christian (this seemingly depended on who he was married to)? Was he a teacher, a historian or a political commentator? Was he an adventurer or an aging chap being taken to different places along the way. Was he a self-publicist (frequent references to his other books - nearly to the point of saying "avaialble at all good. book shops"), Did he care more for his first wife, who we hear a lot about or his second and in my view secondary wife - spoiler alert here, I nearly threw the book across the room when he decided that it was more important for him to go on his walking holiday than to be with his wife as her mother died in the UK. This more than anything made me wonder whether he had learnt what it menat to be a good person - if we can't do it for our own loved ones then what chance do we have for others?
Did he or didn't he find whatever he was looking for? I don't know. I got to the end of the book frustrated and angry that the gift of love that many people showed the Jews along their terrible journeys was lost and negated by aggrandisement and publicity, confused writing and too much superfluity. So why 2 stars? Well I think those stars need to go primarily to the snippets and gems that I was able to glean from the book that hitherto had remained hidden to me - stories that I can go and find out more about, about people that fundamentally really matter and allow us to understand the world. Mr Seldon however, has not got an advocate, which is a shame as some of his other titles look interesting. I shall look elsewhere for now.