What do you think?
Rate this book


912 pages, Paperback
First published October 17, 2023
That duology finally taught me my trees and cured me of confusing a rowan with an ash, which came in surprisingly handy when my husband and I were shopping for new parquet flooring. Never again shall I stand in a lumber aisle blinking helplessly at oak, yew, alder, and elm like I’m lost in the mist.
If One Dark Window felt like being politely mugged by a haunted forest, bewildering at first but too atmospheric to leave, you are not alone. Rachel Gillig drops you into a magic system that initially feels like a raven stitched it together out of hawthorn twigs, ivy vines, and bad intentions while everyone continues politely having court intrigue on top of it. But here’s the thing: trust the roots. Gillig knows exactly when to let the branches part. The explanations arrive organically, elegantly, and precisely when they matter most.
And if you enjoyed the first book but did not yet feel ready to carve the duology’s name into the oldest willow in the kingdom, read Two Twisted Crowns anyway. Because this second book does not merely continue the story; it illuminates the first in hindsight and elevates the entire duology from “great fantasy” to “bury me beneath this tree, I live here now.” Suddenly every vine connects, every shadow deepens, every strange little twig from book one flowers into meaning like a particularly dramatic laburnum in spring.
Also, while keeping it gloriously spoiler-free, I will still tell you that the “twisted” in Two Twisted Crowns may not refer solely to the crowns. Because, yes, there is a twist, and it lands like a cursed alder branch snapping directly above your unsuspecting little woodland head while a taxus somewhere cackles knowingly in the mist.
By the final pages, I had fully decided Rachel Gillig is now one of my auto-buy authors. I desperately hope she expands this universe with spin-offs the way Leigh Bardugo did with Shadow and Bone, because this world feels alive and invasive. It is immersive, layered, beautifully constructed, and blessed with one of the freshest magic systems fantasy has grown in years. A magnificent, arboreal triumph.