What do you think?
Rate this book
Beacons of Hope #2
Hearts Made Whole
After her father’s death, Caroline Taylor has grown confident running the Windmill Point Lighthouse. But in 1865 Michigan, women aren’t supposed to have such roles, so it’s only a matter of time before the lighthouse inspector appoints a new keeper–even though Caroline has nowhere else to go and no other job available to her.
Ryan Chambers is a Civil War veteran still haunted by the horrors of battle. He’s secured the position of lighthouse keeper mostly for the isolation--the chance to hide from his past is appealing. He’s not expecting the current keeper to be a feisty and beautiful woman who’s angry with him for taking her job and for his inability to properly run the light. When his failings endanger others, he and Caroline realize he’s in no shape to run the lighthouse, but he's unwilling to let anyone close enough to help. Caroline feels drawn to this wounded soul, but with both of them relying on that single position, can they look past their loss to a future filled with hope…and possibly love?
Ryan Chambers is a Civil War veteran still haunted by the horrors of battle. He’s secured the position of lighthouse keeper mostly for the isolation--the chance to hide from his past is appealing. He’s not expecting the current keeper to be a feisty and beautiful woman who’s angry with him for taking her job and for his inability to properly run the light. When his failings endanger others, he and Caroline realize he’s in no shape to run the lighthouse, but he's unwilling to let anyone close enough to help. Caroline feels drawn to this wounded soul, but with both of them relying on that single position, can they look past their loss to a future filled with hope…and possibly love?
379 pages, Paperback
First published May 26, 2015
222 people are currently reading
2114 people want to read
About the author
Jody Hedlund
102 books4,701 followersJody Hedlund is the best-selling author of over fifty books and is the winner of numerous awards. She writes sweet historical romances with plenty of sizzle. Find out more at jodyhedlund.com.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Jody lives in central Michigan with her husband, five busy children, and five spoiled cats. When she’s not penning another of her page-turning stories, she loves to spend her time reading, especially when it also involves consuming coffee and chocolate.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 360 reviews
June 7, 2018
Another Hit From Ms. Hedlund!
So, I've been a fan of Jody Hedlund 's writing after I read, A Noble Groom (Which was my fav by the way! ) But after reading Hearts Made Whole. This one is definitely high. On. My. List. All can say is the woman does an excellent job of writing beautiful dramas.
This story was so engaging, at times heart breaking. Let's just say, I was crying after the first chapter.
Caroline is raising her younger siblings after the recent tragic loss of their father. She takes on the duties of taking care of Windmill Point Lighthouse, as her father had done previously. The only problem is that it's 1865, Michigan, and women aren't supposed to have such roles. ( I know, lame right!). When the lighthouse inspector decides to appoint a new keeper, Caroline finds herself in a desperate situation with no future job prospects and nowhere to go.
Ryan is a Civil War veteran with scars both inside and out. Tries to escape the pain and demons from his past mistakes, and he takes the job as the Lighthouse keeper, looking forward to a life of solitude. Only find that the current keeper is a fiesty and beautiful woman who is pretty angry at him for taking her job. When Ryan's failings endanger others, he and Caroline realize they both need each other to run the light.
I love it when author's are not afraid to write flawed characters. There are some choices Ryan and some of the other characters make in this story, that make you feel uncomfortable. There were times I wanted to just take them by the shoulders and shake them. :-)
Both Ryan and Caroline deal with the brokenness in their lives in different ways. But hard stories like this make redemption come across all the more sweeter. Both Caroline and Ryan go through the journey of learning to turn to God in their weaknesses.
Caroline is a book character that I reallly admired. She was strong, smart and really put her family needs first. Even though Ryan was dealing with some pretty serious things and addictions. beneath it all he was a good man. I loved how Caroline treated him with compassion without babying or condemning him. This book illustrated love well, how it covers, protects, hopes, forgives.
I am sooo looking forward to the rest of this series! k
Keep em' coming.
Favorite Quotes ♥
"My father always said that our enemy, the devil, is doing his best to get us to look to everything and everyone else to save from our pains and sorrows. The devil doesn't want us to take those pains to the Lord ,because he knows that when we cry out to God with our need, He'll rescue us from the pit."
"There was a quality about him, a vulnerability that made her want to be sensitive and patient with him. He didn't need her censure. He probably got much more thand he needed from himself already. What he needed instead was someone to encourage him and believe in him."
So, I've been a fan of Jody Hedlund 's writing after I read, A Noble Groom (Which was my fav by the way! ) But after reading Hearts Made Whole. This one is definitely high. On. My. List. All can say is the woman does an excellent job of writing beautiful dramas.
This story was so engaging, at times heart breaking. Let's just say, I was crying after the first chapter.
Caroline is raising her younger siblings after the recent tragic loss of their father. She takes on the duties of taking care of Windmill Point Lighthouse, as her father had done previously. The only problem is that it's 1865, Michigan, and women aren't supposed to have such roles. ( I know, lame right!). When the lighthouse inspector decides to appoint a new keeper, Caroline finds herself in a desperate situation with no future job prospects and nowhere to go.
Ryan is a Civil War veteran with scars both inside and out. Tries to escape the pain and demons from his past mistakes, and he takes the job as the Lighthouse keeper, looking forward to a life of solitude. Only find that the current keeper is a fiesty and beautiful woman who is pretty angry at him for taking her job. When Ryan's failings endanger others, he and Caroline realize they both need each other to run the light.
I love it when author's are not afraid to write flawed characters. There are some choices Ryan and some of the other characters make in this story, that make you feel uncomfortable. There were times I wanted to just take them by the shoulders and shake them. :-)
Both Ryan and Caroline deal with the brokenness in their lives in different ways. But hard stories like this make redemption come across all the more sweeter. Both Caroline and Ryan go through the journey of learning to turn to God in their weaknesses.
Caroline is a book character that I reallly admired. She was strong, smart and really put her family needs first. Even though Ryan was dealing with some pretty serious things and addictions. beneath it all he was a good man. I loved how Caroline treated him with compassion without babying or condemning him. This book illustrated love well, how it covers, protects, hopes, forgives.
I am sooo looking forward to the rest of this series! k
Keep em' coming.
Favorite Quotes ♥
"My father always said that our enemy, the devil, is doing his best to get us to look to everything and everyone else to save from our pains and sorrows. The devil doesn't want us to take those pains to the Lord ,because he knows that when we cry out to God with our need, He'll rescue us from the pit."
"There was a quality about him, a vulnerability that made her want to be sensitive and patient with him. He didn't need her censure. He probably got much more thand he needed from himself already. What he needed instead was someone to encourage him and believe in him."
June 18, 2017
by Andrea Renee Cox
The negative largely overshadowed the positive in this book for me, so I was quite severely disappointed in it, especially after adoring Love Unexpected, book one in this series.
Positives:
* The opening scene was gut-wrenching.
* One of the leads was maimed/wounded (which is not seen often in books these days).
* The lead was quite loyal to her family.
Negatives:
* There were no boats (other than the lead's family's) on the lake, nor did the keeper watch the lake as she should have -- most of the focus was instead on lighting and snuffing out the light.
* Smuggling was mentioned but was really a non-factor as it always took place off-screen, so to speak.
* There was an extended scene that took place over a couple of chapters early on where the lead male wore only undergarments and/or trousers and an undershirt and the lead female wore only a nightgown and eventually wrapped herself in a quilt. They had several witnesses to this immodesty. This seems historically inaccurate as well as immorally inappropriate to me.
* There were alcohol and drug usage.
* There were at least two mentions of bodies being "shows" for someone of the opposite gender.
* There were too many immoral situations, "heat" attractions/longings toward opposite gender, and it was extremely sensual in patches throughout.
* There was talk of "fornication."
* The immorality in this book was overwhelming in quantity, and it frankly outshone the faith thread to me. Characters "got away" with way more than was proper, moral, or decent -- in 1865 or any other era.
If I didn't have a couple of other Jody Hedlund books from NetGalley that I had requested based on their back cover copy, I would be done with her books after reading this one because it left me feeling quite defiled and filthy. I don't read Christian fiction to feel that way.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
The negative largely overshadowed the positive in this book for me, so I was quite severely disappointed in it, especially after adoring Love Unexpected, book one in this series.
Positives:
* The opening scene was gut-wrenching.
* One of the leads was maimed/wounded (which is not seen often in books these days).
* The lead was quite loyal to her family.
Negatives:
* There were no boats (other than the lead's family's) on the lake, nor did the keeper watch the lake as she should have -- most of the focus was instead on lighting and snuffing out the light.
* Smuggling was mentioned but was really a non-factor as it always took place off-screen, so to speak.
* There was an extended scene that took place over a couple of chapters early on where the lead male wore only undergarments and/or trousers and an undershirt and the lead female wore only a nightgown and eventually wrapped herself in a quilt. They had several witnesses to this immodesty. This seems historically inaccurate as well as immorally inappropriate to me.
* There were alcohol and drug usage.
* There were at least two mentions of bodies being "shows" for someone of the opposite gender.
* There were too many immoral situations, "heat" attractions/longings toward opposite gender, and it was extremely sensual in patches throughout.
* There was talk of "fornication."
* The immorality in this book was overwhelming in quantity, and it frankly outshone the faith thread to me. Characters "got away" with way more than was proper, moral, or decent -- in 1865 or any other era.
If I didn't have a couple of other Jody Hedlund books from NetGalley that I had requested based on their back cover copy, I would be done with her books after reading this one because it left me feeling quite defiled and filthy. I don't read Christian fiction to feel that way.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
July 17, 2016
This second book of the Beacons of Hope series was very well done. I was engaged from start to end in Ryan and Caroline's story. It wasn't what I'd frame a "page turner". It was more a steady dose of a good story line, strong characters, historical detail and hearts turning toward God that had me loving this story.
One of the things I loved most is how realistic their story was. Ryan's struggles with alcohol and opium and how he worked through it rang true. Caroline's commitment to her family was believable and oh so commendable. The way novel ends was noble and realistic. The ending was perhaps my favorite part of the entire novel.
The hand made cross which was a continuation from the first novel made my heart sing. The imagery of Willpoint, Michigan was clear and I could visualize each scene in my mind.
In the afterward, the author shares what parts of the story were based upon fact. This just added to my enjoyment.
To put it simply Hearts Made Whole was a well written novel. I look forward to reading the next in the series.
One of the things I loved most is how realistic their story was. Ryan's struggles with alcohol and opium and how he worked through it rang true. Caroline's commitment to her family was believable and oh so commendable. The way novel ends was noble and realistic. The ending was perhaps my favorite part of the entire novel.
The hand made cross which was a continuation from the first novel made my heart sing. The imagery of Willpoint, Michigan was clear and I could visualize each scene in my mind.
In the afterward, the author shares what parts of the story were based upon fact. This just added to my enjoyment.
To put it simply Hearts Made Whole was a well written novel. I look forward to reading the next in the series.
May 10, 2018
Jody Hedlund's books never fail to bring together beautiful romance, poignant interactions between characters and fascinating insights into the historical period. Hearts Made Whole is no exception! I was so eager to read Ryan’s story after meeting him in Love Unexpected, and once again, Hedlund has created a story that is entirely too hard to put down.
I think what struck me the most about this novel was the realistic, tough issues that the characters face. Hedlund's characters are always a draw for me, more than the plot, setting or any other aspect of the story. That was the case here, but even more so because they faced some really tough issues, namely healing from addiction and bias against women working in certain positions. Ryan, a Civil War veteran, did things as a soldier that he wasn’t proud of, as well as carries a physical reminder of the war with a wound that still causes him great pain. Because of this pain, he is addicted to medication that numbs the physical pain, and alcohol, which numbs him not only physically, but mentally as well. Determined to hold down this new position as a lighthouse keeper, he doesn’t expect to meet Caroline Taylor, an expert keeper, supporting her siblings. Even though the fact that she is a woman has angered the lighthouse superintendent, who is determined that she won’t be the keeper, Ryan sees quickly that she does the job as well as any man.
Ryan wants to be shed of his addiction and dependence on his opium pills and alcohol, and Jody doesn’t sugar-coat his struggle, but rather portrays his plight in a respectful, realistic way. I think often plots with a heavy romantic element use the romantic interest to “heal” one character of the other, but that’s not the case here. Caroline’s acceptance of him surely helps him along the way, but it’s not where he finds his ultimate healing.
Likewise, Caroline is in a predicament of her own. She is victim of the misconception of the time that only men could be lighthouse keepers. Women could assist their husbands, but they could not shoulder the responsibility on their own. Caroline has no other notable skills as she has been around the light her entire life and also has a family to support. Jody could have let the plot play out in a predictable way of Ryan being the light keeper and Caroline staying on to assist him, but she refrains from doing this and instead brings about an ending that was both poignant and historically relevant.
In general, with the romance, I was expecting another marriage of convenience, and while Ryan and Caroline are thrown together by circumstance, that didn’t mean marriage. It was nice to see their relationship progress without the confines of marriage. I think the story would have been a lot different and perhaps not as meaningful had it been that type of story (although as evident by the first book in the series, Hedlund truly does that storyline justice). Ryan is a flawed, yet endearing character, and Caroline has a good measure of spunk without being unrealistic for the time period. The interactions between Ryan and Caroline were a highlight of the story; the sweet, humorous moments between them are equally endearing as the tender, romantic moments.
The plot is a great mix of action, introspection and romance. I was surprised at the amount of suspense in the story, and although I didn’t find the mystery nor the antagonist to be very cryptic, that didn’t lessen my enjoyment of the story overall. The setting makes the story even more pleasurable to read; like the first book, I truly got the feeling of life within and around a lighthouse. Windmill Point is beautifully described, and I’ve really enjoyed the continuity of the history surrounding Michigan’s lighthouses that Jody has based the series upon. Helping to ground the characters in a similar continuity is the wooden cross that readers first see in the prologue, Out of the Storm. In this story, it is passed along to Tessa, Caroline’s sister, and though I didn’t care for her character, I saw the seeds of change within her. Though the consequences of her actions have laid a path for her, I know that her upcoming personal story is in good hands with Jody.
Hearts Made Whole is a great addition to the Beacons of Hope series and sure to be a hit with fans of inspirational, historical romance.
I think what struck me the most about this novel was the realistic, tough issues that the characters face. Hedlund's characters are always a draw for me, more than the plot, setting or any other aspect of the story. That was the case here, but even more so because they faced some really tough issues, namely healing from addiction and bias against women working in certain positions. Ryan, a Civil War veteran, did things as a soldier that he wasn’t proud of, as well as carries a physical reminder of the war with a wound that still causes him great pain. Because of this pain, he is addicted to medication that numbs the physical pain, and alcohol, which numbs him not only physically, but mentally as well. Determined to hold down this new position as a lighthouse keeper, he doesn’t expect to meet Caroline Taylor, an expert keeper, supporting her siblings. Even though the fact that she is a woman has angered the lighthouse superintendent, who is determined that she won’t be the keeper, Ryan sees quickly that she does the job as well as any man.
Ryan wants to be shed of his addiction and dependence on his opium pills and alcohol, and Jody doesn’t sugar-coat his struggle, but rather portrays his plight in a respectful, realistic way. I think often plots with a heavy romantic element use the romantic interest to “heal” one character of the other, but that’s not the case here. Caroline’s acceptance of him surely helps him along the way, but it’s not where he finds his ultimate healing.
Likewise, Caroline is in a predicament of her own. She is victim of the misconception of the time that only men could be lighthouse keepers. Women could assist their husbands, but they could not shoulder the responsibility on their own. Caroline has no other notable skills as she has been around the light her entire life and also has a family to support. Jody could have let the plot play out in a predictable way of Ryan being the light keeper and Caroline staying on to assist him, but she refrains from doing this and instead brings about an ending that was both poignant and historically relevant.
In general, with the romance, I was expecting another marriage of convenience, and while Ryan and Caroline are thrown together by circumstance, that didn’t mean marriage. It was nice to see their relationship progress without the confines of marriage. I think the story would have been a lot different and perhaps not as meaningful had it been that type of story (although as evident by the first book in the series, Hedlund truly does that storyline justice). Ryan is a flawed, yet endearing character, and Caroline has a good measure of spunk without being unrealistic for the time period. The interactions between Ryan and Caroline were a highlight of the story; the sweet, humorous moments between them are equally endearing as the tender, romantic moments.
The plot is a great mix of action, introspection and romance. I was surprised at the amount of suspense in the story, and although I didn’t find the mystery nor the antagonist to be very cryptic, that didn’t lessen my enjoyment of the story overall. The setting makes the story even more pleasurable to read; like the first book, I truly got the feeling of life within and around a lighthouse. Windmill Point is beautifully described, and I’ve really enjoyed the continuity of the history surrounding Michigan’s lighthouses that Jody has based the series upon. Helping to ground the characters in a similar continuity is the wooden cross that readers first see in the prologue, Out of the Storm. In this story, it is passed along to Tessa, Caroline’s sister, and though I didn’t care for her character, I saw the seeds of change within her. Though the consequences of her actions have laid a path for her, I know that her upcoming personal story is in good hands with Jody.
Hearts Made Whole is a great addition to the Beacons of Hope series and sure to be a hit with fans of inspirational, historical romance.
July 2, 2015
It’s been a long time since I’ve read such an emotionally moving book as Jody Hedlund’s Hearts Made Whole. I’m never one to miss reading one of her books since A Noble Groom is one of my all-time favorites, but this one took me by surprise and is now also one of my favorites... though at one point I did want to throw it against the wall. Instead, I set it down for a few days so I could collect myself and dove right back in with much anticipation about how Jody would bring out the happy ending I was desperate to see between Caroline and Ryan.
Jody writes characters very well–so well, that it’s like they’re right there with you. I think this is why I love her writing so much. I am never disappointed with the deep level of character development she is able to achieve. Or the way her stories, about simple, everyday people, twist and turn and are emotionally spot-on every single time.
And in case you’re not already convinced you need to read this book, I have to tell you that the kissing scenes in this book are some of the BEST I’ve ever read.
Jody writes characters very well–so well, that it’s like they’re right there with you. I think this is why I love her writing so much. I am never disappointed with the deep level of character development she is able to achieve. Or the way her stories, about simple, everyday people, twist and turn and are emotionally spot-on every single time.
And in case you’re not already convinced you need to read this book, I have to tell you that the kissing scenes in this book are some of the BEST I’ve ever read.
July 10, 2016
Another excellent Jody Hedlund book. I don't like Tessa. What a scheming little witch.
December 26, 2015
This is one of those stories that has no good place to stop! There were plenty of things not to like about Ryan but somehow he kept surprising Caroline with his moments–like when he dragged himself out of his pain-filled drugged haze (old injuries from the war) to help rescue her little brother from an old well he'd fallen into. Maybe there was hope for him yet?
Caroline Taylor is determined to keep her family together and provided for after her father's death. But all she knows is the lighthouse, and the superintendent isn't about to let her be the first woman lightkeeper. He gives her a week to move out before the new man arrives to take over.
But...Ryan, the new hire, knows very little about the job–only a few things that his sister Emma has shown him when he visits her (readers may recall her from book 1). His injuries from the war are not yet fully healed, and he is further crippled by a dependence on opium, which was the pain medicine given to him after his injury. First impressions couldn't be worse when he stumbles into the lighthouse drunk, a full week early, not thinking anyone else could be there.
Can Ryan find any shreds of his lost manhood and manage the job? What will happen to Caroline and her younger siblings? And what about the person who's determined to stalk and harm the Taylor family? Will she find a safe haven with the tavernkeeper's son Arnie...or is his offer too decent to be real? And there's the little issue of suspected smugglers to deal with...
I'd rate this 16+ for drug use, drunkenness, and a couple of accidental indecent situations as Ryan wrestles the demons of his past.
Caroline Taylor is determined to keep her family together and provided for after her father's death. But all she knows is the lighthouse, and the superintendent isn't about to let her be the first woman lightkeeper. He gives her a week to move out before the new man arrives to take over.
But...Ryan, the new hire, knows very little about the job–only a few things that his sister Emma has shown him when he visits her (readers may recall her from book 1). His injuries from the war are not yet fully healed, and he is further crippled by a dependence on opium, which was the pain medicine given to him after his injury. First impressions couldn't be worse when he stumbles into the lighthouse drunk, a full week early, not thinking anyone else could be there.
Can Ryan find any shreds of his lost manhood and manage the job? What will happen to Caroline and her younger siblings? And what about the person who's determined to stalk and harm the Taylor family? Will she find a safe haven with the tavernkeeper's son Arnie...or is his offer too decent to be real? And there's the little issue of suspected smugglers to deal with...
I'd rate this 16+ for drug use, drunkenness, and a couple of accidental indecent situations as Ryan wrestles the demons of his past.
June 8, 2015
4.5 Stars
Jody Hedlund did such a fabulous job in setting the historical backdrop of Hearts Made Whole. I also loved the characters and was immediately drawn into their lives. I wanted to cheer them on, believe in them, and see them to a happy end. It was a bit rough getting there, but I enjoyed the journey.
Caroline had such a heavy load with carry for her four siblings after her father's death. She had a heavy enough load before he passed away with a mother who had passed on, having to help her father with his duties, and help care for her little sister who was slowly dying. She was a rock, sensible, hard working, but also full of compassion and pretty as well. Then there was Ryan. He comes into the story as a lost soul, full of anguish and pain, addicted to his drugs and boos. Underneath all that is such great potential. He used to be a completely different man and unearthing that man again is rough after the war and his injury, but Caroline sees it. She believes in him and that goes a long way in him beginning to heal. It helps that he's handsome and charming as well.
There were other characters as well, such as Caroline's siblings (one of which made me really mad), the lighthouse inspector, the local barman and his son, a reclusive neighbor, and Caroline's good friend who is also the mayor's wife. Each of the characters brought a little more to the story, some having stronger roles than others. They were all well formed.
I really loved this story, the banter, the romantic tension, the soul searching pretty much the whole way through. It held my interest and even though I figured out what was going on well before the characters did, I still enjoyed reading along. The end did get a little bit too dramatic for me and there were some things that didn't quite make sense, but that would be the only thing that was a little off for me.
I'd recommend Hearts Made Whole to those who enjoy historical inspirational romance. It was well worth the read. I plan on going back and reading the author's prior books as well as picking up her future ones.
Content: There was some violence that turned my stomach slightly, but I would consider this clean.
Source: I would like to thank Bethany House through Litfuse for my complimentary copy, which did not affect my review in any way.
Jody Hedlund did such a fabulous job in setting the historical backdrop of Hearts Made Whole. I also loved the characters and was immediately drawn into their lives. I wanted to cheer them on, believe in them, and see them to a happy end. It was a bit rough getting there, but I enjoyed the journey.
Caroline had such a heavy load with carry for her four siblings after her father's death. She had a heavy enough load before he passed away with a mother who had passed on, having to help her father with his duties, and help care for her little sister who was slowly dying. She was a rock, sensible, hard working, but also full of compassion and pretty as well. Then there was Ryan. He comes into the story as a lost soul, full of anguish and pain, addicted to his drugs and boos. Underneath all that is such great potential. He used to be a completely different man and unearthing that man again is rough after the war and his injury, but Caroline sees it. She believes in him and that goes a long way in him beginning to heal. It helps that he's handsome and charming as well.
There were other characters as well, such as Caroline's siblings (one of which made me really mad), the lighthouse inspector, the local barman and his son, a reclusive neighbor, and Caroline's good friend who is also the mayor's wife. Each of the characters brought a little more to the story, some having stronger roles than others. They were all well formed.
I really loved this story, the banter, the romantic tension, the soul searching pretty much the whole way through. It held my interest and even though I figured out what was going on well before the characters did, I still enjoyed reading along. The end did get a little bit too dramatic for me and there were some things that didn't quite make sense, but that would be the only thing that was a little off for me.
I'd recommend Hearts Made Whole to those who enjoy historical inspirational romance. It was well worth the read. I plan on going back and reading the author's prior books as well as picking up her future ones.
Content: There was some violence that turned my stomach slightly, but I would consider this clean.
Source: I would like to thank Bethany House through Litfuse for my complimentary copy, which did not affect my review in any way.
March 2, 2020
This is the second book in the series and it really doesn't relate much to the first, so I would say you could read them separately. I have read all of Hedlund's books and she is a favorite author of mine. This one wasn't quite as good as the first in the series. I still really did enjoy it and couldn't put it down too often. There is a bit of a "mystery" that threads throughout the book and I didn't find it to be too mysterious. The first part of the book I just couldn't decide how I felt about all of the characters. Tessa and Caroline's relationship is a unique portrayal of sisters though it was not fun to read. There are a lot of darker heavy issues in this book that surprised me but I applaud the author for writing about it. The last part of the book was not what I was expecting and I really loved how the book ended.
While I did enjoy this book, the first remains my favorite and I give this book four stars.
"I received this book from Litfuse for free in exchange for an honest review."
April 1, 2017
A fantastic story that kept me turning the pages. I was swept into the story from the start, and the parts of the story involving the struggle for Ryan to overcome his addictions and Caroline to trust God in the midst of her anxiety for sure touched me. I liked the touch of suspense in this novel- seriously felt chills down my spine during the parts when a mystery person tried to get Caroline to leave the lighthouse. I also thought the ending was perfect!
While I didn't like it as much as some of Hedlund's other novels (some parts felt unnecessary or too much), it didn't disappoint. It definitely felt darker than her other novels (hence the chills!) and she wrote about some pretty heavy topics, but it was very well done. I look forward to reading the next one in this series, especially since I love the lighthouse aspect to the series!
While I didn't like it as much as some of Hedlund's other novels (some parts felt unnecessary or too much), it didn't disappoint. It definitely felt darker than her other novels (hence the chills!) and she wrote about some pretty heavy topics, but it was very well done. I look forward to reading the next one in this series, especially since I love the lighthouse aspect to the series!
September 14, 2022
Hearts Made Whole is the second book in the Beacons of Hope series and another good read. I feel like the romance, as with the first book, was a little heated at times.
The storyline was good and it was a fast read. I felt like the danger/mystery aspect was predictable and I easily guessed the bad guy.
All in all, though, I still really enjoyed this read and am eager to finish the series.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
The storyline was good and it was a fast read. I felt like the danger/mystery aspect was predictable and I easily guessed the bad guy.
All in all, though, I still really enjoyed this read and am eager to finish the series.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
April 14, 2021
Given her track record and beautiful prose, it’s no surprise when I say (or it shouldn’t be), Jody’s latest novel is a compelling, evocative story that doesn’t evade its obligation to show a hurting soul in need of love, healing and forgiveness. Within this, there's beauty that blooms from those cleansing emotions. The second book in Jody’s recent Bethany House series, this novel sets out to chronicle Ryan’s story, brother of Emma, our heroine in Love Unexpected. Where Emma’s story is sweeter (though not without its trials), Ryan’s goes in direct opposition; strife follows him like a bad omen. I’m leading off with the characters because, really, they are who impress in Hearts Made Whole. We get to see Ryan’s character in masterful way; the depth of his pain, the emotional turmoil he goes through and the mental anguish he endures is masterfully written.
I think for a hero in a CBA market novel, he is the first soul I can remember that's all torture. And I have to confess, I like that conflict. Not because he suffers, rather because it presents the author was some beautiful challenges. It’s not the most pleasant thing to experience, however the premise of a man whose past haunts him – a character who is more than a handsome face, is never bad. Under Jody’s talented hand, everything plays out really well and I love the progression of the characters. Ryan’s healing is a genuine aspect of the story as is Caroline’s growing affection for him. She’s an excellent buffer for his more volatile temper (though he’s not a violent person, merely lost); ultimately it’s her goodness and love that helps him. (To be honest, I’m getting a few Beauty and the Beast feels with this story.)
Fans of this author’s prior novels will appreciate this story. It’s got the usual heartwarming scenes, which ensures a lovely, quaint kind of charm, yet brims with sincerity. This book doesn’t eclipse my favorite Jody Hedlund book (that honor remains with A Noble Groom), but it’s still a poignant read. If you like books that feature flawed, occasionally brooding heroes, this might be the book to pick up. The redeeming qualities, specifically the redemptive transformation Ryan undergoes, of this story make it hard to put down. Into its pages, a genuine hero walks and in time, an honest story weaves a pattern of hope. The ending perfectly shapes this story (its jump in time allows for a full and healthy conclusion), and because of this, we're more hopeful by the ultimate journey and message.
Sincere thanks to the author, Jody Hedlund (and publisher) for providing a complimentary copy of this book, as an influence and for reviewing purposes.
I think for a hero in a CBA market novel, he is the first soul I can remember that's all torture. And I have to confess, I like that conflict. Not because he suffers, rather because it presents the author was some beautiful challenges. It’s not the most pleasant thing to experience, however the premise of a man whose past haunts him – a character who is more than a handsome face, is never bad. Under Jody’s talented hand, everything plays out really well and I love the progression of the characters. Ryan’s healing is a genuine aspect of the story as is Caroline’s growing affection for him. She’s an excellent buffer for his more volatile temper (though he’s not a violent person, merely lost); ultimately it’s her goodness and love that helps him. (To be honest, I’m getting a few Beauty and the Beast feels with this story.)
Fans of this author’s prior novels will appreciate this story. It’s got the usual heartwarming scenes, which ensures a lovely, quaint kind of charm, yet brims with sincerity. This book doesn’t eclipse my favorite Jody Hedlund book (that honor remains with A Noble Groom), but it’s still a poignant read. If you like books that feature flawed, occasionally brooding heroes, this might be the book to pick up. The redeeming qualities, specifically the redemptive transformation Ryan undergoes, of this story make it hard to put down. Into its pages, a genuine hero walks and in time, an honest story weaves a pattern of hope. The ending perfectly shapes this story (its jump in time allows for a full and healthy conclusion), and because of this, we're more hopeful by the ultimate journey and message.
Sincere thanks to the author, Jody Hedlund (and publisher) for providing a complimentary copy of this book, as an influence and for reviewing purposes.
June 12, 2015
I enjoyed this story so much! I love that the author has connections that run throughout these books that tie them together. An important item is introduced in the novella and makes an appearance in each story. I really like that continuity and seeing the way the tale behind the item helps the person who possesses it.
In Hearts Made Whole, we get to follow the story of Ryan Chambers, who is the brother of the heroine we read about in book one, Love Unexpected. He has had a tough few years and did not make it out of the Civil War unscathed in body or soul. I could not help but love this character! He struggled so much, but his growth throughout the book was all that more impressive for it.
Caroline Taylor, the heroine of the book, took my heart as well. What a strong woman! I was so impressed with the way she handled herself, her duties, and the caring attitude that she had for her brothers and sisters. I loved the way she dealt with Ryan’s issues. It really highlighted her compassionate heart.
This story was so wonderful! It took me on such an emotional journey from the very first page. Hearts Made Whole is a definite must-read for fans of historical fiction.
My thanks to the publisher and Litfuse Publicity for the complimentary copy of this book that I received in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at enter Jody Hedlund's giveaway (through 6/23/15):
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
In Hearts Made Whole, we get to follow the story of Ryan Chambers, who is the brother of the heroine we read about in book one, Love Unexpected. He has had a tough few years and did not make it out of the Civil War unscathed in body or soul. I could not help but love this character! He struggled so much, but his growth throughout the book was all that more impressive for it.
Caroline Taylor, the heroine of the book, took my heart as well. What a strong woman! I was so impressed with the way she handled herself, her duties, and the caring attitude that she had for her brothers and sisters. I loved the way she dealt with Ryan’s issues. It really highlighted her compassionate heart.
This story was so wonderful! It took me on such an emotional journey from the very first page. Hearts Made Whole is a definite must-read for fans of historical fiction.
My thanks to the publisher and Litfuse Publicity for the complimentary copy of this book that I received in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at enter Jody Hedlund's giveaway (through 6/23/15):
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
March 10, 2016
There are so many interesting things that I loved about this novel! The first being that the author doesn't shy away from portraying the hero as a doped and drunken mess in all his stinky glory, which provides a distinct contrast to the goodness in his heart and the strong, courageous man he truly is under his pain, fears, and doubts, and emphasizes the power of his transformation. We get to know Caroline and her own fears, flaws, strength and compassion through her relationships with those around her. She faces the injustice of her situation with dignity, sacrificing everything for her family. I loved the romance between her and Ryan- they strengthened each other and brought joy and laughter into what could have been a grim environment. Caroline is sweet in her inexperience with flirting and Ryan's teasing and banter lightens her worries over her family. Their chemistry together is intense as they experience the thrill of new love.
(Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Bethany House for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
(Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Bethany House for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
June 13, 2015
Another fabulous read by Jody Hedlund. I have read all her books and I can say ALL OF THEM are wonderful but this latest one is especially awesome. The Windmill Point Lighthouse is the beautiful setting for this story. The characters are expertly written. The message of healing is heart warming. The two main characters, Caroline and Ryan, have an electric chemistry from the start.
Caroline goes through so many ups and downs but through it all she keeps her sweet spirit and faith in God. Ryan is a wounded vet with a lot of baggage. His addictions keep him from being the man he wants to be. Working along side Caroline, Ryan begins to find healing. But he realizes he needs God, he needs him every hour, to find complete healing. I love how the hymn I Need Thee Every Hour was written into the story. The title, Hearts Made Whole is definitely a fitting one. I also appreciate all the character names. The are relevant to the time period yet easy to read. I highly recommend this to anyone who likes American history, romance or Christian fiction.
Caroline goes through so many ups and downs but through it all she keeps her sweet spirit and faith in God. Ryan is a wounded vet with a lot of baggage. His addictions keep him from being the man he wants to be. Working along side Caroline, Ryan begins to find healing. But he realizes he needs God, he needs him every hour, to find complete healing. I love how the hymn I Need Thee Every Hour was written into the story. The title, Hearts Made Whole is definitely a fitting one. I also appreciate all the character names. The are relevant to the time period yet easy to read. I highly recommend this to anyone who likes American history, romance or Christian fiction.
May 29, 2015
4.5 stars!!! I loved this story!!! There were a couple technical problems (like using the wrong name for Ryan's sister) and writing issues (POV not quite as deep [lots of "she knew" and "something told him that" kinds of phrases] and repetitive phrases and sentence structures that began to leap out at me ["at the VERB of" being the chief offender]).... HOWEVER, I was reading an advanced, unedited copy, so I'll reserve final judgment until I've read the final, as many of these things may be corrected. But while these inconsistencies screamed out to my editor-brain, absolutely nothing detracted from the power of this story! Jody handles tough topics like drug and alcohol addiction and terminal illness extremely well, the romance was sizzling, and the spiritual themes of redemption, grace, and God's goodness even in the midst of trials were incredibly powerful. A keeper!
February 4, 2016
Long before her father’s unexpected death, Caroline Tyler had taken on most of the responsibilities required for operating the Windmill Point Lighthouse. While other young women—including her own sister Tessa—might prefer looking after a home and tending to children, Caroline has grown to love the lighthouse where she grew up. She can’t imagine living anywhere else, or doing any other kind of job—until the lighthouse inspector arrives to inform her that she is no longer allowed to remain at the lighthouse and that a man—a veteran returning from the Civil War—is going to replace her. Allowing her and her siblings to stay in the lighthouse after her father’s death was apparently a polite courtesy, and now Caroline is faced with only a week to find somewhere new for them to live, and a new job. But if she isn’t allowed to work in a lighthouse—an occupation she is trained to do—who else will offer her employment? Will she be forced to marry simply to put a roof over the heads of her siblings?
Although Ryan Chambers applied for a job as a lighthouse keeper, he didn’t expect to be given the position. Not only is his hand crippled from the Battle of Gettysburg, but his knowledge of lighthouses is limited to what he has learned from his sister, whose husband is also a keeper. In fact, he isn’t sure if he’s the right man for this job at all. The only way he can numb the pain of the lingering shrapnel damage and rid the nightmares of war from his mind is to take opium pills and drink whisky—both of which put him into such a stupor that he might not awaken in time to attend to the lamp in the lighthouse. He longs for a second chance, and an opportunity to earn money to make amends for some of his mistakes during the war, but he isn't sure if this is the right place for him.
Ryan doesn’t expect the previous keeper to still be residing at Windmill Point when he arrives, and he’s confused as to why he’s been offered the job when Caroline seems entirely capable—especially considering that she has four siblings to support, one of whom is ill and bedridden. He and Caroline strike a deal, where her family can remain at the Point while she teaches him all there is to know about tending the light. Although Caroline talks of moving her family and finding a new job, Ryan can see how much she loves the lighthouse. Surely this is the job she was born to do? But when strange accidents begin occurring around the Point, Ryan wonders if some of the locals don’t agree with Caroline continuing to operate the lighthouse. Who is trying to scare Caroline away, and why? Can Ryan convince Caroline to stay, or will the threats—and Ryan’s nightmares—scare her away?
I read the first Beacons of Hope novel at the start of this year and absolutely fell in love with it. While Hearts Made Whole made its way on to my wishlist, I did worry that it might not live up to its predecessor. Thankfully, my worries were unfounded. While the two novels did have a similar premise—a man and woman thrown together under unexpected circumstances—Ryan and Caroline didn’t rush into their relationship or marry in haste. As much as I love a good marriage of convenience story, I enjoyed how Ryan and Caroline’s relationship developed, how they got to know each other while operating the lighthouse and spending time with Caroline’s family.
That said, this is not your sweet, fluffy romance where the characters always have a chaperone and never touch each other. There is chemistry between these two right from the start, and it’s clear that they’re almost instantly attracted to each other. I love the way that Jody Hedlund writes about passion and romance. I can’t think a lot of authors who write for the Christian market who portray relationships the way Jody does. Ryan and Caroline are attracted to each other, and embrace this attraction early on in their relationship, but they aren’t overcome with passion. There’s discussion of consent and respecting each other, and when they find themselves locked in a cellar together they continue this attitude of respect and self-control. I’m tired of reading books where characters (particularly male ones) can’t control themselves when they’re alone with someone of the opposite sex. Ryan is falling in love with Caroline and very attracted to her, but he’s a true gentleman, not an animal, and he knows how to control his desires and respect a woman. What more could you ask for in a romantic hero?
I was a little cautious about Ryan’s character initially. Tortured heroes often go one of two ways in romance novels—they need the heroine to “fix” them, or they’re not allowed to fall in love with the heroine until they’ve overcome all of their problems. Either way, they have to be perfect before they can live happily ever after. This wasn’t the case for Ryan. To put it short, when he meets Caroline he’s a crippled opium addict who has a drinking problem and is haunted by his past mistakes during the war. Surprisingly (even to me) Caroline doesn’t judge him, push him away or try to make him leave the lighthouse when she discovers the ways he manages his pain. She tries to help him, but she does so incredibly gently, and not once does she push Ryan to give up his crutches. She waits until he’s ready, and supports him fully. I was incredibly touched by the way Ryan’s addictions were dealt with. Obviously this would be an entirely different situation if Ryan’s addictions were harming anyone but himself (especially if he were a danger to Caroline’s younger siblings), but given the circumstances, this situation was dealt with carefully and without judgement. The depiction of Ryan’s struggle to give up his pain medication and learn what he could achieve without it was incredibly sympathetic. Although Ryan has to fight his demons and make amends for his past mistakes, he still isn’t entirely perfect at the end of the novel. He can’t get back the fingers that he lost in the war, and he will always have to be careful around alcohol because of his addiction—and Caroline understands this and embraces this as part of their relationship.
There's another fantastic relationship in this novel: that of Caroline and her lighthouse. Obviously, lighthouse keeping isn’t for everyone (in fact, her sister Tessa abhors it), but Caroline has clearly fallen in love with the occupation. That she should be forbidden from doing what she loves because she is female is infuriating, and I appreciated the way that Jody worked this angle into the story. Caroline’s fight to do the work she loves and support her family is one that many women in this period faced, and I understood how tempted she was to marry for convenience in order to protect her younger siblings. How many other women entered loveless—and possibly abusive—marriages because they had no male family members to support them? I also appreciated Caroline’s friend Esther, who used her husband’s political position to lobby for women’s rights, and other causes that were close to her heart.
Hearts Made Whole contained several elements that made it the perfect romance for me—a relationship full of passion (and plenty of consent and respect!), a perfectly imperfect hero, and a small victory for women’s rights. I haven’t even had time to talk about the suspense, or the tumultuous relationship between Caroline and her sister—so you’ll probably just have to read this book for yourself! In short, Jody Hedlund is quickly becoming one of my favourite historical romance authors, and I hope that Tessa’s story is the next one in the Beacons of Hope series.
Although Ryan Chambers applied for a job as a lighthouse keeper, he didn’t expect to be given the position. Not only is his hand crippled from the Battle of Gettysburg, but his knowledge of lighthouses is limited to what he has learned from his sister, whose husband is also a keeper. In fact, he isn’t sure if he’s the right man for this job at all. The only way he can numb the pain of the lingering shrapnel damage and rid the nightmares of war from his mind is to take opium pills and drink whisky—both of which put him into such a stupor that he might not awaken in time to attend to the lamp in the lighthouse. He longs for a second chance, and an opportunity to earn money to make amends for some of his mistakes during the war, but he isn't sure if this is the right place for him.
Ryan doesn’t expect the previous keeper to still be residing at Windmill Point when he arrives, and he’s confused as to why he’s been offered the job when Caroline seems entirely capable—especially considering that she has four siblings to support, one of whom is ill and bedridden. He and Caroline strike a deal, where her family can remain at the Point while she teaches him all there is to know about tending the light. Although Caroline talks of moving her family and finding a new job, Ryan can see how much she loves the lighthouse. Surely this is the job she was born to do? But when strange accidents begin occurring around the Point, Ryan wonders if some of the locals don’t agree with Caroline continuing to operate the lighthouse. Who is trying to scare Caroline away, and why? Can Ryan convince Caroline to stay, or will the threats—and Ryan’s nightmares—scare her away?
I read the first Beacons of Hope novel at the start of this year and absolutely fell in love with it. While Hearts Made Whole made its way on to my wishlist, I did worry that it might not live up to its predecessor. Thankfully, my worries were unfounded. While the two novels did have a similar premise—a man and woman thrown together under unexpected circumstances—Ryan and Caroline didn’t rush into their relationship or marry in haste. As much as I love a good marriage of convenience story, I enjoyed how Ryan and Caroline’s relationship developed, how they got to know each other while operating the lighthouse and spending time with Caroline’s family.
That said, this is not your sweet, fluffy romance where the characters always have a chaperone and never touch each other. There is chemistry between these two right from the start, and it’s clear that they’re almost instantly attracted to each other. I love the way that Jody Hedlund writes about passion and romance. I can’t think a lot of authors who write for the Christian market who portray relationships the way Jody does. Ryan and Caroline are attracted to each other, and embrace this attraction early on in their relationship, but they aren’t overcome with passion. There’s discussion of consent and respecting each other, and when they find themselves locked in a cellar together they continue this attitude of respect and self-control. I’m tired of reading books where characters (particularly male ones) can’t control themselves when they’re alone with someone of the opposite sex. Ryan is falling in love with Caroline and very attracted to her, but he’s a true gentleman, not an animal, and he knows how to control his desires and respect a woman. What more could you ask for in a romantic hero?
I was a little cautious about Ryan’s character initially. Tortured heroes often go one of two ways in romance novels—they need the heroine to “fix” them, or they’re not allowed to fall in love with the heroine until they’ve overcome all of their problems. Either way, they have to be perfect before they can live happily ever after. This wasn’t the case for Ryan. To put it short, when he meets Caroline he’s a crippled opium addict who has a drinking problem and is haunted by his past mistakes during the war. Surprisingly (even to me) Caroline doesn’t judge him, push him away or try to make him leave the lighthouse when she discovers the ways he manages his pain. She tries to help him, but she does so incredibly gently, and not once does she push Ryan to give up his crutches. She waits until he’s ready, and supports him fully. I was incredibly touched by the way Ryan’s addictions were dealt with. Obviously this would be an entirely different situation if Ryan’s addictions were harming anyone but himself (especially if he were a danger to Caroline’s younger siblings), but given the circumstances, this situation was dealt with carefully and without judgement. The depiction of Ryan’s struggle to give up his pain medication and learn what he could achieve without it was incredibly sympathetic. Although Ryan has to fight his demons and make amends for his past mistakes, he still isn’t entirely perfect at the end of the novel. He can’t get back the fingers that he lost in the war, and he will always have to be careful around alcohol because of his addiction—and Caroline understands this and embraces this as part of their relationship.
There's another fantastic relationship in this novel: that of Caroline and her lighthouse. Obviously, lighthouse keeping isn’t for everyone (in fact, her sister Tessa abhors it), but Caroline has clearly fallen in love with the occupation. That she should be forbidden from doing what she loves because she is female is infuriating, and I appreciated the way that Jody worked this angle into the story. Caroline’s fight to do the work she loves and support her family is one that many women in this period faced, and I understood how tempted she was to marry for convenience in order to protect her younger siblings. How many other women entered loveless—and possibly abusive—marriages because they had no male family members to support them? I also appreciated Caroline’s friend Esther, who used her husband’s political position to lobby for women’s rights, and other causes that were close to her heart.
Hearts Made Whole contained several elements that made it the perfect romance for me—a relationship full of passion (and plenty of consent and respect!), a perfectly imperfect hero, and a small victory for women’s rights. I haven’t even had time to talk about the suspense, or the tumultuous relationship between Caroline and her sister—so you’ll probably just have to read this book for yourself! In short, Jody Hedlund is quickly becoming one of my favourite historical romance authors, and I hope that Tessa’s story is the next one in the Beacons of Hope series.
June 11, 2019
This book was good, but probably my least favorite in the Beacons of Hope series! I do love Jody Hedlund!
June 27, 2015
It’s pretty obvious that Jody Hedlund is one of my favorite authors, so it should come as no surprise that I enjoyed her latest novel, Hearts Made Whole. We meet Caroline Taylor, a young lady with responsibilities that weigh heavily on her heart. She is always in a state of worry, either taking care of the lighthouse or her siblings, trying to keep it all together.
When Ryan Chambers shows up to take the lighthouse keeper position, he threatens everything she has in the world: her job, her income, and her home. Will Caroline and Ryan ever come to a decision that will benefit both of them? Or will one of them be forced to leave the lighthouse?
For those who have read Love Unexpected, the first book in the Beacons of Hope series, Ryan Chambers is a familiar face. He is Emma’s brother from the first book, but his life has changed a lot between the first and second books. Now he is older, has been through war, and has seen and done things he can never forget. He is wounded both physically and emotionally.
I found myself hesitate to like Ryan, as we are reintroduced to a man who deals with his pain by self-medicating with drinking and pills. His lack of drive or a desire to be present in his own life was disheartening and gave me serious reservations about him. However, there are moments of his old, vibrant self that shine through and make you root for him to get better.
The heart of this novel is about forgiveness, learning to depend on God, and trusting him with the worries of our hearts.
*Thank you to Bethany House and Jody Hedlund for a complimentary copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are my own. I am on Jody’s influencer team.*
Review originally posted on https://bookshelvesandwindows.wordpre....
When Ryan Chambers shows up to take the lighthouse keeper position, he threatens everything she has in the world: her job, her income, and her home. Will Caroline and Ryan ever come to a decision that will benefit both of them? Or will one of them be forced to leave the lighthouse?
For those who have read Love Unexpected, the first book in the Beacons of Hope series, Ryan Chambers is a familiar face. He is Emma’s brother from the first book, but his life has changed a lot between the first and second books. Now he is older, has been through war, and has seen and done things he can never forget. He is wounded both physically and emotionally.
I found myself hesitate to like Ryan, as we are reintroduced to a man who deals with his pain by self-medicating with drinking and pills. His lack of drive or a desire to be present in his own life was disheartening and gave me serious reservations about him. However, there are moments of his old, vibrant self that shine through and make you root for him to get better.
The heart of this novel is about forgiveness, learning to depend on God, and trusting him with the worries of our hearts.
*Thank you to Bethany House and Jody Hedlund for a complimentary copy of this novel in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts are my own. I am on Jody’s influencer team.*
Review originally posted on https://bookshelvesandwindows.wordpre....
August 11, 2016
This review is also posted on Book by Book.
Hearts Made Whole, the second novel in the Beacons of Hope series, easily contains all the wonderful qualities a reader should hope for and expect in one of Jody Hedlund’s novels and fans will not be disappointed. In this novel, Hedlund gives Ryan Chambers, the brother of Emma from Love Unexpected, his own story, continuing to use the setting of a lighthouse, and naturally fills the plot with action, drama, suspense and romance within a well-established historical context. Ryan and his leading lady, Caroline Taylor, both have difficulties to overcome and spiritual lessons to understand and accept as they unexpectedly and suddenly cross paths at the Windmill Point Lighthouse. They challenge and support each other in moving forward, encountering a fair share of surprises and emotions along the way. A delightfully heartwarming novel of hope and healing, Hearts Made Whole is the perfect read for fans of historical romance. I highly recommend it and now can’t wait for Undaunted Hope.
Thanks to LitFuse Publicity Group, I received a copy of Hearts Made Whole and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
Hearts Made Whole, the second novel in the Beacons of Hope series, easily contains all the wonderful qualities a reader should hope for and expect in one of Jody Hedlund’s novels and fans will not be disappointed. In this novel, Hedlund gives Ryan Chambers, the brother of Emma from Love Unexpected, his own story, continuing to use the setting of a lighthouse, and naturally fills the plot with action, drama, suspense and romance within a well-established historical context. Ryan and his leading lady, Caroline Taylor, both have difficulties to overcome and spiritual lessons to understand and accept as they unexpectedly and suddenly cross paths at the Windmill Point Lighthouse. They challenge and support each other in moving forward, encountering a fair share of surprises and emotions along the way. A delightfully heartwarming novel of hope and healing, Hearts Made Whole is the perfect read for fans of historical romance. I highly recommend it and now can’t wait for Undaunted Hope.
Thanks to LitFuse Publicity Group, I received a copy of Hearts Made Whole and the opportunity to provide an honest review. I was not required to write a positive review, and all the opinions I have expressed are my own.
June 8, 2015
Hedlund has the ability to carry her readers away to another place and time -- so much so that it's jarring to stop reading and find yourself in the 21st century again! I've always been fascinated with lighthouses. I used to think it would be so romantic to live in one so this Beacons of Hope series is sheer bliss for me.
Caroline is a strong heroine who can't afford to expose any vulnerabilities. Ryan is a flawed hero who sees them anyway. The two together seem like a disaster waiting to happen and yet they compliment each other in so many ways -- unknowingly drawing strength from each other. Oh my -- and their first meet? I didn't know whether to laugh or cry! And if you like a toe-curling romance then look no further.
A touch of spine-tingling suspense (that made me squirm a time or two!) adds an extra dimension to an already riveting read. The tension grows taut as treachery abounds and Caroline and Ryan are caught up in sinister subterfuge. Phew! An amazing book that was over way too fast. But there's no way I could have put the brakes on and tried to draw the experience out. It was just too spellbinding. I needed to know what happened. Now! So, yes, Hearts Made Whole comes highly recommended.
Thanks to Litfuse Publicity Group and Bethany House for supplying me with a review copy of this book.
Caroline is a strong heroine who can't afford to expose any vulnerabilities. Ryan is a flawed hero who sees them anyway. The two together seem like a disaster waiting to happen and yet they compliment each other in so many ways -- unknowingly drawing strength from each other. Oh my -- and their first meet? I didn't know whether to laugh or cry! And if you like a toe-curling romance then look no further.
A touch of spine-tingling suspense (that made me squirm a time or two!) adds an extra dimension to an already riveting read. The tension grows taut as treachery abounds and Caroline and Ryan are caught up in sinister subterfuge. Phew! An amazing book that was over way too fast. But there's no way I could have put the brakes on and tried to draw the experience out. It was just too spellbinding. I needed to know what happened. Now! So, yes, Hearts Made Whole comes highly recommended.
Thanks to Litfuse Publicity Group and Bethany House for supplying me with a review copy of this book.
December 30, 2015
This review originally appeared on the Historical Novel Society website.
This is the second full novel in the short Beacons of Hope series (after Love Unexpected), set in lighthouses around the Michigan shore. Caroline Taylor has been the interim lighthouse keeper since her father’s death and would like to continue in that role. But her family’s enemies are determined to drive her out by appointing a man as keeper—Ryan Chambers, a character from the first novel. Ryan has been through the Civil War and emerged as a broken man, maimed and addicted to morphine and alcohol.
Jody Hedlund is one of the authors pushing at the boundaries of inspirational historical romance, and I like the result. Ryan is far from perfect and struggles with his addictions throughout the story. Vivid instances of cruelty, compromising situations, and character outcomes that do not go in the expected direction kept me turning the pages. The spiritual arc keeps the novel firmly in the Christian sphere, yet is never over-emphasized. Sex, although never explicit, always seems to be just below the surface in Hedlund’s romance novels, a good choice for readers who like just a little heat.
This is the second full novel in the short Beacons of Hope series (after Love Unexpected), set in lighthouses around the Michigan shore. Caroline Taylor has been the interim lighthouse keeper since her father’s death and would like to continue in that role. But her family’s enemies are determined to drive her out by appointing a man as keeper—Ryan Chambers, a character from the first novel. Ryan has been through the Civil War and emerged as a broken man, maimed and addicted to morphine and alcohol.
Jody Hedlund is one of the authors pushing at the boundaries of inspirational historical romance, and I like the result. Ryan is far from perfect and struggles with his addictions throughout the story. Vivid instances of cruelty, compromising situations, and character outcomes that do not go in the expected direction kept me turning the pages. The spiritual arc keeps the novel firmly in the Christian sphere, yet is never over-emphasized. Sex, although never explicit, always seems to be just below the surface in Hedlund’s romance novels, a good choice for readers who like just a little heat.
May 20, 2015
Full review to come closer to release date.
June 26, 2018
2.5 stars.
Engagingly written, I couldn't help but keep on reading even though I found the actual story to be a bit boring. The hormonal rivalry between the sisters, the constant back and forth between both MCs staying and going, and the "does he love me" thoughts made this book read like a YA novel. I'm just too old and have too many teenagers in my house to spend my time reading YA fiction. However, I appreciated the struggles of the H and felt like his part of the story was very compelling. The author did a wonderful job highlighting the reality of someone struggling with addiction and what it actually takes to overcome it. The H's journey to sobriety was heartbreaking and convinced me of this author's writing ability. However, both MCs realized too late into the story that true freedom comes from relying on God, not on other people or their circumstances, and I spent almost the entire story in despair. The angst of everything just dragged on for too long for me. The lack of communication didn't help and neither did the crying the h does at the end of the book. Call me cold, but I really don't enjoy it when the h cries a lot.
Overall, I have the same recommendation for this book as I had for the first one of this series. I would skip it unless you find lighthouses fascinating. There are much more compelling, convicting, and encouraging inspirational historical romances out there.
Engagingly written, I couldn't help but keep on reading even though I found the actual story to be a bit boring. The hormonal rivalry between the sisters, the constant back and forth between both MCs staying and going, and the "does he love me" thoughts made this book read like a YA novel. I'm just too old and have too many teenagers in my house to spend my time reading YA fiction. However, I appreciated the struggles of the H and felt like his part of the story was very compelling. The author did a wonderful job highlighting the reality of someone struggling with addiction and what it actually takes to overcome it. The H's journey to sobriety was heartbreaking and convinced me of this author's writing ability. However, both MCs realized too late into the story that true freedom comes from relying on God, not on other people or their circumstances, and I spent almost the entire story in despair. The angst of everything just dragged on for too long for me. The lack of communication didn't help and neither did the crying the h does at the end of the book. Call me cold, but I really don't enjoy it when the h cries a lot.
Overall, I have the same recommendation for this book as I had for the first one of this series. I would skip it unless you find lighthouses fascinating. There are much more compelling, convicting, and encouraging inspirational historical romances out there.
October 1, 2022
I loved the first book and had expected to enjoy this one as much, if not more, because I loved Ryan in the few scenes from Love Unexpected. However, I just didn't care for this one as much. The opening scene was gripping and so sad, but then the story got a little dull.
3.5 stars
3.5 stars
November 10, 2024
Really good storyline.
August 24, 2015
I have read and enjoyed Jody Hedlund’s work in the past, so when the opportunity came up to review this latest release, I eagerly snapped it up. I expect toe-curling romance, intricate setting, historical immersion, and strong spiritual content when I pick up one of her books, and those expectations were exceeded in this novel!
Melancholy surrounded the opening chapters of the story, but it quickly turned a bit ominous as a mystery emerged. I didn’t expect it, but found it to be a fascinating part of the story and it provided several twists that I didn’t see coming. This added depth and complexity to an already fantastic plot and kept the action moving where it might otherwise have stalled.
A female light keeper in 1865 was an unlikely heroine in many respects, but her single status and father’s death made it a necessity for Caroline. Her love for the light as well as her desire to provide for her siblings gave her depth and interest, while the loss of her job gives the story conflict. Ryan’s Civil War experiences and resulting problems make him an almost tragic hero who desperately wanted to do the right thing and determined to do so, even when it ended his own future hopes. I loved that both of these characters were essentially good but flawed; sometimes they just couldn’t help but do what they knew they shouldn’t, creating more problems for each other and themselves.
Hope began to work its way into the characters’ lives through the spiritual content. I loved how Hedlund was able to insert strong spiritual themes into her writing, making them an integral part of the story. Many topics were addressed—I was surprised when I really stopped to consider how many: God’s goodness despite circumstances, spiritual warfare, hardships bringing about blessings in disguise, and God’s perfect timing are all addressed with some depth. Forgiveness plays a large part in the last third of the novel, and I appreciated how it wasn’t portrayed as an automatic thing but a process that had to first be chosen, then extended to someone, even one who did not deserve it. This was in turn linked back to God forgiving us when we also did nothing, in fact could do nothing, to earn it ourselves.
The romance was fantastic in this novel, though there were points were I couldn’t see how it could possibly work out. I liked that it was a combination of events, character traits, other characters, and past history that conspired to keep them apart rather than artificially throwing one obstacle after another at the couple. The distinction may be a small one, but it seemed so much more realistic the way that Ms. Hedlund wrote it. The moments they were together were beautifully written, and the prose was heartbreaking every time they separated.
The ending never felt rushed; sometimes I get frustrated by the “and they lived happily ever after” endings that happen quickly and seem unconnected to the rest of the book, but this one took its time and slowly revealed the future for the characters we had read about for the last 300 pages. When I read the final page, I was able to sigh in contentment and immediately begin anticipating the next book in the series.
I would highly recommend this novel to historical romance readers, especially those who are interested in lighthouses, but I think with the added mystery element, many historical fiction fans will find much to enjoy here, even if romance isn’t their usual genre of choice.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for this honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Melancholy surrounded the opening chapters of the story, but it quickly turned a bit ominous as a mystery emerged. I didn’t expect it, but found it to be a fascinating part of the story and it provided several twists that I didn’t see coming. This added depth and complexity to an already fantastic plot and kept the action moving where it might otherwise have stalled.
A female light keeper in 1865 was an unlikely heroine in many respects, but her single status and father’s death made it a necessity for Caroline. Her love for the light as well as her desire to provide for her siblings gave her depth and interest, while the loss of her job gives the story conflict. Ryan’s Civil War experiences and resulting problems make him an almost tragic hero who desperately wanted to do the right thing and determined to do so, even when it ended his own future hopes. I loved that both of these characters were essentially good but flawed; sometimes they just couldn’t help but do what they knew they shouldn’t, creating more problems for each other and themselves.
Hope began to work its way into the characters’ lives through the spiritual content. I loved how Hedlund was able to insert strong spiritual themes into her writing, making them an integral part of the story. Many topics were addressed—I was surprised when I really stopped to consider how many: God’s goodness despite circumstances, spiritual warfare, hardships bringing about blessings in disguise, and God’s perfect timing are all addressed with some depth. Forgiveness plays a large part in the last third of the novel, and I appreciated how it wasn’t portrayed as an automatic thing but a process that had to first be chosen, then extended to someone, even one who did not deserve it. This was in turn linked back to God forgiving us when we also did nothing, in fact could do nothing, to earn it ourselves.
The romance was fantastic in this novel, though there were points were I couldn’t see how it could possibly work out. I liked that it was a combination of events, character traits, other characters, and past history that conspired to keep them apart rather than artificially throwing one obstacle after another at the couple. The distinction may be a small one, but it seemed so much more realistic the way that Ms. Hedlund wrote it. The moments they were together were beautifully written, and the prose was heartbreaking every time they separated.
The ending never felt rushed; sometimes I get frustrated by the “and they lived happily ever after” endings that happen quickly and seem unconnected to the rest of the book, but this one took its time and slowly revealed the future for the characters we had read about for the last 300 pages. When I read the final page, I was able to sigh in contentment and immediately begin anticipating the next book in the series.
I would highly recommend this novel to historical romance readers, especially those who are interested in lighthouses, but I think with the added mystery element, many historical fiction fans will find much to enjoy here, even if romance isn’t their usual genre of choice.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher through The Book Club Network (bookfun.org) in exchange for this honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
June 6, 2015
Hearts Made Whole (Beacons of Hope #2) by Jody Hedlund is one the suspenseful, romance novels of the summer. From beginning to end the story feels like an episode of Dateline "Who did it?" mixed in with two characters finding love and comfort while depending on God. This novel will keep you anticipating the end and holding out for the war torn hero and the burdens that hang on the young heroine's shoulders. This is a must read for summer!
My Thoughts
Wow. I just finished this book and my blood is still pumping from the most intense and heart wrenching ending chapters I've ever read in a Jody Hedlund book. She has definitely stepped up her game when it comes to making the reader physically shake the book with anticipation of the next event. I liked this book. There were a few qualities that were easy to figure out before it was revealed. Yet, still it kept me on my toes as I was reading in eagerness of how it was going to be revealed to me as the reader.
This is the second book in the Beacon of Hope series and I am pleased to say that you don't have to read the first book to get to enjoy the characters of this book. I did not expect this book to be as intense as it was, there was some crazy things that took place in this book so if you are squeamish or don't like to read sections that could make you slightly uncomfortable I'm not sure if this is the book for you. I would recommend another Hedlund book if you are looking for something a little more calm. But if you like books that make you search for clues in the actions and responses of character's then this is the book for you. This book also deals with addiction and substance abuse and how healing comes into that. So this is not a light book, but there are light scenes that break up those sections that make it more enjoyable for the reader.
There were writing decisions for characters that I felt were a little overboard in my opinion, but then again this is set in a different era such as the late 1850s and people did act differently then. So that is probably just a personal commentary on my account.
I did like how independent and strong Caroline was as a character. I did wish that I got to see more interactions with her other siblings instead of just Tessa. And Ryan was as complex as it gets with character development. He was wounded physically and mentally and was constantly working on his spiritual walk with God. Yet, there is one quality that really struck me that was a writing choice and it was Ryan knew he couldn't marry Caroline until he got better himself instead of relying on her. He knew he had to rely on God and that it was a battle within himself that God could help him defeat. Great writing choice on Hedlund's part!
I think that this will be an enjoyable read for those who already love Hedlund's stories and those who haven't even read anything by her yet. It's a suspenseful read that has just the right amount of romance that will leave the reader satisfied.
Rating: 4 out of 5 bookshelves
I received a free copy from Litfuse Publicity in return for an honest review.
My Thoughts
Wow. I just finished this book and my blood is still pumping from the most intense and heart wrenching ending chapters I've ever read in a Jody Hedlund book. She has definitely stepped up her game when it comes to making the reader physically shake the book with anticipation of the next event. I liked this book. There were a few qualities that were easy to figure out before it was revealed. Yet, still it kept me on my toes as I was reading in eagerness of how it was going to be revealed to me as the reader.
This is the second book in the Beacon of Hope series and I am pleased to say that you don't have to read the first book to get to enjoy the characters of this book. I did not expect this book to be as intense as it was, there was some crazy things that took place in this book so if you are squeamish or don't like to read sections that could make you slightly uncomfortable I'm not sure if this is the book for you. I would recommend another Hedlund book if you are looking for something a little more calm. But if you like books that make you search for clues in the actions and responses of character's then this is the book for you. This book also deals with addiction and substance abuse and how healing comes into that. So this is not a light book, but there are light scenes that break up those sections that make it more enjoyable for the reader.
There were writing decisions for characters that I felt were a little overboard in my opinion, but then again this is set in a different era such as the late 1850s and people did act differently then. So that is probably just a personal commentary on my account.
I did like how independent and strong Caroline was as a character. I did wish that I got to see more interactions with her other siblings instead of just Tessa. And Ryan was as complex as it gets with character development. He was wounded physically and mentally and was constantly working on his spiritual walk with God. Yet, there is one quality that really struck me that was a writing choice and it was Ryan knew he couldn't marry Caroline until he got better himself instead of relying on her. He knew he had to rely on God and that it was a battle within himself that God could help him defeat. Great writing choice on Hedlund's part!
I think that this will be an enjoyable read for those who already love Hedlund's stories and those who haven't even read anything by her yet. It's a suspenseful read that has just the right amount of romance that will leave the reader satisfied.
Rating: 4 out of 5 bookshelves
I received a free copy from Litfuse Publicity in return for an honest review.
June 7, 2015
After the death of her father, Caroline Taylor has continued to man the light at the Windmill Point Lighthouse. It provides a home for her four siblings, yet she knows that it is just a matter of time before the lighthouse inspector removes her from the post because she is a woman. Unfortunately for Caroline, that happens sooner rather than later. When Civil War veteran Ryan Chambers accepts the position as the lighthouse keeper, he has no idea that he is causing a woman and her siblings to become homeless. All Ryan wants is someplace remote where he can chase the demons of the war away. Caroline sees Ryan's wounded heart and soul. As he comes to depend on her, she finds something she'd never dreamed possible - a chance to let someone else take care of her. Yet with someone determined to see Caroline and her family driven away, the chance for a future with Ryan seems impossible. Will she be able to trust God through this storm? And can God heal Ryan's brokenness?
While this is book 2 in the Beacons of Hope series, it can be read as a stand alone. One of the things that I love about Jody Hedlund's novels is that her books are very character driven. This particular book may be the most character driven of her novels to date. I'd kinda fallen slightly for Ryan when I met him in Love Unexpected. Seeing him in his own story, only made me like him more. Caroline is a woman working in a field where at the time, was dominated by men. And she's good at it. Yet she also has a tender heart. I loved seeing how Ryan nurtured her tender heart.
I'll admit that I never really thought about lighthouses in places other than Maine. Silly me. Yet, I feel like I've been on a trip to Michigan and visiting the lighthouses there. The research that is put into this novel is very much evident. I love how Jody Hedlund tries to be as accurate as possible.
While this one isn't my favorite one of hers, I did find it to be a delightful read. Fans of books rich in historical detail will enjoy this book. I am eagerly awaiting the next book in this series.
I received a copy of the book for free from the author for the purpose of reviewing and promoting. My thoughts and opinions are my own. As part of my agreement with her, I will be giving away my copy of the book in July during my Quarterly Giveaway.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction, Karen Witemeyer, Jody Hedlund, Laura Frantz
Rating - 4 stars
While this is book 2 in the Beacons of Hope series, it can be read as a stand alone. One of the things that I love about Jody Hedlund's novels is that her books are very character driven. This particular book may be the most character driven of her novels to date. I'd kinda fallen slightly for Ryan when I met him in Love Unexpected. Seeing him in his own story, only made me like him more. Caroline is a woman working in a field where at the time, was dominated by men. And she's good at it. Yet she also has a tender heart. I loved seeing how Ryan nurtured her tender heart.
I'll admit that I never really thought about lighthouses in places other than Maine. Silly me. Yet, I feel like I've been on a trip to Michigan and visiting the lighthouses there. The research that is put into this novel is very much evident. I love how Jody Hedlund tries to be as accurate as possible.
While this one isn't my favorite one of hers, I did find it to be a delightful read. Fans of books rich in historical detail will enjoy this book. I am eagerly awaiting the next book in this series.
I received a copy of the book for free from the author for the purpose of reviewing and promoting. My thoughts and opinions are my own. As part of my agreement with her, I will be giving away my copy of the book in July during my Quarterly Giveaway.
Recommended to fans of historical fiction, Karen Witemeyer, Jody Hedlund, Laura Frantz
Rating - 4 stars
July 21, 2015
I’ve loved this series by Jody Hedlund from the start, and Hearts Made Whole is no exception.
(See my reviews of the novella Out of the Storm and the novel Love Unexpected for my thoughts on the earlier stories.)
Ryan and Caroline’s tale in Hearts Made Whole is one of healing, redemption, mystery, suspense, and of course, love. The lead characters each start out the story with their own problems, hurting and struggling to get by. And the way they’re presented – flaws, challenges and all – I couldn’t help but feel for them, and cheer them on towards healing, character growth, and the achievement of their goals.
It was so much fun to see the romance develop between them, despite the adversarial circumstances in which they met. The tender compassion, the discovery of flirtation, and the occasional circumstance beyond their control throwing them into close proximity… all made for a delightfully romantic read. And if romance is your thing, just wait until you get to the shaving scene. That one’s my favorite. ☺
A bit of jealousy between sisters, and between potential suitors kept things interesting, and contributed to some pretty dramatic plot twists. But the thing that impressed me most about this story, was the message about relying on God rather than other people for our strength. The characters had to make some really tough decisions, but the story’s resolution was all the more powerful because of it. I am eagerly anticipating the release of Undaunted Hope, the next book in Jody Hedlund’s Beacons of Hope series.
Thank you to Bethany House for providing an electronic copy of this book via NetGalley for review purposes.
This review appeared first at the Edgy Inspirational Romance blog.
(See my reviews of the novella Out of the Storm and the novel Love Unexpected for my thoughts on the earlier stories.)
Ryan and Caroline’s tale in Hearts Made Whole is one of healing, redemption, mystery, suspense, and of course, love. The lead characters each start out the story with their own problems, hurting and struggling to get by. And the way they’re presented – flaws, challenges and all – I couldn’t help but feel for them, and cheer them on towards healing, character growth, and the achievement of their goals.
It was so much fun to see the romance develop between them, despite the adversarial circumstances in which they met. The tender compassion, the discovery of flirtation, and the occasional circumstance beyond their control throwing them into close proximity… all made for a delightfully romantic read. And if romance is your thing, just wait until you get to the shaving scene. That one’s my favorite. ☺
A bit of jealousy between sisters, and between potential suitors kept things interesting, and contributed to some pretty dramatic plot twists. But the thing that impressed me most about this story, was the message about relying on God rather than other people for our strength. The characters had to make some really tough decisions, but the story’s resolution was all the more powerful because of it. I am eagerly anticipating the release of Undaunted Hope, the next book in Jody Hedlund’s Beacons of Hope series.
Thank you to Bethany House for providing an electronic copy of this book via NetGalley for review purposes.
This review appeared first at the Edgy Inspirational Romance blog.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 360 reviews