What do you think?
Rate this book
Shaker #6
The Innocent
She longs for peace - for her land and her heart - but can it truly be found at Harmony Hill?
Carlyn Kearney spends two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. When the war ends without further word, Carlyn finds herself penniless, in debt, and forced from her home. With nowhere else to go, she seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill.
The Shakers profess peace through simple living, but to Carlyn the Shaker life seems anything but simple. When mysterious deaths disturb the peace of the village, Carlyn falls under intense scrutiny. Can a kind sheriff help her expose the true culprit?
Carlyn Kearney spends two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. When the war ends without further word, Carlyn finds herself penniless, in debt, and forced from her home. With nowhere else to go, she seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill.
The Shakers profess peace through simple living, but to Carlyn the Shaker life seems anything but simple. When mysterious deaths disturb the peace of the village, Carlyn falls under intense scrutiny. Can a kind sheriff help her expose the true culprit?
400 pages, Paperback
First published June 30, 2015
76 people are currently reading
909 people want to read
About the author
Ann H. Gabhart
49 books1,062 followersAnn H. Gabhart grew up on a farm in Kentucky. At the age of ten, she started dreaming of writing stories others would want to read. That dream has come true as she's published over thirty-five novels. She and her husband have three children married to three beautiful in-law children who have gifted her nine grandchildren. She still lives on a farm not far from where she grew up. She loves playing with her grandkids, walking with her dogs, reading, and, of course, writing. Her Shaker books, set in her fictional Shaker village of Harmony Hill in the 1800's, are popular with readers. The Outsider was a Christian Fiction Book Award Finalist in 2009. Her Heart of Hollyhill books are Small Town, America books set in the 1960's. Angel Sister, a Rosey Corner book set during the Great Depression, was a best-seller and was followed up by two more stories about the Merritt sisters. She keeps her stories in Kentucky and has enjoyed going to the Kentucky Appalachian Mountains for some stories including These Healing Hills and Along a Storied Trail. And if you like mysteries, you can try her Hidden Springs Mysteries published under the author name, A.H. Gabhart. Visit Ann's website http://annhgabhart.com to find out more. There you can sign up for her newsletter where she does giveaways several times a year.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 86 reviews
July 9, 2015
When I decided to go back to my fictional village of Harmony Hill for one more story, I wanted to tell a story that was different from my other Shaker novels. And so I set the story after the Civil War and mixed in a dog and a little mystery. I liked writing about Carlyn and Mitchell and I hope others will enjoy reading their story.
November 2, 2021
Dreadfully dull and boring. If you want to understand Shaker life you can read this book but be prepared for tedium. I found little of interest; in fact it was the dullest book that I think I have ever read. Apparently there is a market for this type of novel and I mean no disrespect; I simply need to be forthright in my reviews. I believe that the aspect that bothered me was that the main character had little merit except a) she was so beautiful that males couldn't resist her and b) females mostly hated her.
To put this read into better perspective, I captured another reviewers thoughts which brought giggles to my day..."Carlyn wonders how she will ever manage to live with the Shakers when they have such different beliefs but she lives with them anyway, Then gorgeous Carlyn thinks about her long lost Ambrose, then the beautiful Carlyn thinks about the sheriff, she thinks about her dog, and she thinks about Ambrose some more, and then her dog, and then the sheriff, all the while acting like a shrinking violet. Then the plot switches to the sheriff who thinks about the beautiful and alluring Carlyn and of course her dog and then he thinks about how he would like to kiss her...the gorgeous Carlyn of course...although I personally found the dog much more worthy of some hugs and kisses...
.
To put this read into better perspective, I captured another reviewers thoughts which brought giggles to my day..."Carlyn wonders how she will ever manage to live with the Shakers when they have such different beliefs but she lives with them anyway, Then gorgeous Carlyn thinks about her long lost Ambrose, then the beautiful Carlyn thinks about the sheriff, she thinks about her dog, and she thinks about Ambrose some more, and then her dog, and then the sheriff, all the while acting like a shrinking violet. Then the plot switches to the sheriff who thinks about the beautiful and alluring Carlyn and of course her dog and then he thinks about how he would like to kiss her...the gorgeous Carlyn of course...although I personally found the dog much more worthy of some hugs and kisses...
.
June 30, 2015
About the Book:
Carlyn Kearney has spent two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. The war ends without further word. Now penniless, in debt, and forced from her home, Carlyn seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill, only to discover that they will not allow her to keep her beloved dog, an animal that has been her faithful companion since her husband went off to war. Sheriff Mitchell Brodie has pity on the lovely young woman and agrees to take the dog. Carlyn is just settling into life as a sister in the Shaker village when she receives a devastating letter confirming her worst fears. As she wrestles with whether to commit herself fully to the Shaker life, mysterious deaths begin to occur, and Carlyn comes under suspicion. Can Sheriff Mitchell help her expose the true culprit?
My Review:
The Civil War marked a time in history that should and does stand out to others especially fellow Americans. Many families lost their love ones all in the name of the war between the states. The nation was fighting against itself, with that thought in mind it can never be a good outcome. To the fate of many lives lost slavery was abolished. This was good BUT it still caused many to lose their loved ones. No one was spared from that grief, no one.
Carlyn Kearney was always looking for the day that her husband Ambrose would return to her and they could move on with their lives, but now according to the Union Army that day was never going to happen. Her husband is now missing.
Carlyn is now forced out of her home because of the inability to pay for that or the mounting debt given to her. She seeks refuge in a Shaker village, it seems harmless enough. Carlyn is again thrown another stone to the already growing pile on top of her. When a mystery that she gets pulled into may threaten her existence in the Shaker village as well.
Ann Gabhart is an excellent writer. she takes a simple story line and can expand it beyond your wildest expectations. She does it so subtly that before you even realize what is happen you have come to the last page of the story. The story is one that pulls you in and causes you to look for God in every situation just like the main character.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Revell.
Carlyn Kearney has spent two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. The war ends without further word. Now penniless, in debt, and forced from her home, Carlyn seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill, only to discover that they will not allow her to keep her beloved dog, an animal that has been her faithful companion since her husband went off to war. Sheriff Mitchell Brodie has pity on the lovely young woman and agrees to take the dog. Carlyn is just settling into life as a sister in the Shaker village when she receives a devastating letter confirming her worst fears. As she wrestles with whether to commit herself fully to the Shaker life, mysterious deaths begin to occur, and Carlyn comes under suspicion. Can Sheriff Mitchell help her expose the true culprit?
My Review:
The Civil War marked a time in history that should and does stand out to others especially fellow Americans. Many families lost their love ones all in the name of the war between the states. The nation was fighting against itself, with that thought in mind it can never be a good outcome. To the fate of many lives lost slavery was abolished. This was good BUT it still caused many to lose their loved ones. No one was spared from that grief, no one.
Carlyn Kearney was always looking for the day that her husband Ambrose would return to her and they could move on with their lives, but now according to the Union Army that day was never going to happen. Her husband is now missing.
Carlyn is now forced out of her home because of the inability to pay for that or the mounting debt given to her. She seeks refuge in a Shaker village, it seems harmless enough. Carlyn is again thrown another stone to the already growing pile on top of her. When a mystery that she gets pulled into may threaten her existence in the Shaker village as well.
Ann Gabhart is an excellent writer. she takes a simple story line and can expand it beyond your wildest expectations. She does it so subtly that before you even realize what is happen you have come to the last page of the story. The story is one that pulls you in and causes you to look for God in every situation just like the main character.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from Revell.
May 4, 2023
Each person is faced with different challenges. Different hardships. Such is the way of the world. We must pray to have the courage to pick up whatever cross we are given and carry it with the help of our Lord.
First of many I hope that I have read of Ann H. Gabhart. A gift of story telling with human nature and the nature of God. I do not know about the ways of the Shaker lifestyle but I can see for the time it's pull to those that are down trodden.
Carlyn Kearney is one such young woman. She is waiting for her husband to come home from Civil War. She has not heard from her husband Ambrose for two years. Her heart is broken for her husband as she is left on her own with a small farm to keep. She is not totally alone. With her dog Asher who is her protector and best friend. Carlyn is faced with the truth that her husband may be dead when the landlord comes for his payment. He has brought the new sheriff Mitchell Brody to kick out Carlyn from her home. There is a attraction of character between the two that builds a foundation as they come to know each other. With no where to go she goes to the Shaker community where she leaves all to be in community with them. She cannot bring her dog and the community tells her that she take Asher to a friend. The only person that she think of is the sheriff.
The Shaker lifestyle proves to be difficult but she knows that the Lord has brought her to this community for a reason. With taking care of Carlyn's dog, she is always on his mind. He worries for her and when he is brought to the community for a crime, the worry intensifies.
Carlyn and Mitchell not only have a attraction in character but I think what drives that attraction is the similarities they have. Each of their mother's gave them knowledge of the Lord in how they loved their children. Each had contrasting parents. One that was ruled by the law and the other by grace. It is a good lesson for Christians to see the difference and how it can build our faith and weaken it. Loved their story!
A special thank you to Revell and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
First of many I hope that I have read of Ann H. Gabhart. A gift of story telling with human nature and the nature of God. I do not know about the ways of the Shaker lifestyle but I can see for the time it's pull to those that are down trodden.
Carlyn Kearney is one such young woman. She is waiting for her husband to come home from Civil War. She has not heard from her husband Ambrose for two years. Her heart is broken for her husband as she is left on her own with a small farm to keep. She is not totally alone. With her dog Asher who is her protector and best friend. Carlyn is faced with the truth that her husband may be dead when the landlord comes for his payment. He has brought the new sheriff Mitchell Brody to kick out Carlyn from her home. There is a attraction of character between the two that builds a foundation as they come to know each other. With no where to go she goes to the Shaker community where she leaves all to be in community with them. She cannot bring her dog and the community tells her that she take Asher to a friend. The only person that she think of is the sheriff.
The Shaker lifestyle proves to be difficult but she knows that the Lord has brought her to this community for a reason. With taking care of Carlyn's dog, she is always on his mind. He worries for her and when he is brought to the community for a crime, the worry intensifies.
Carlyn and Mitchell not only have a attraction in character but I think what drives that attraction is the similarities they have. Each of their mother's gave them knowledge of the Lord in how they loved their children. Each had contrasting parents. One that was ruled by the law and the other by grace. It is a good lesson for Christians to see the difference and how it can build our faith and weaken it. Loved their story!
A special thank you to Revell and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
September 4, 2017
The Civil War has been over for two years, but Carlyn's husband has not returned. Though others are calling her the Widow Kearney, she hasn't accepted that designation. Still, her dreams of a future with her husband seem to be only that, a dream. Unable to make the payments on their house, she is forced to leave and seek refuge at the only option available to her, the Shaker village. Obeying the rules are a struggle, especially when she is forced to relinquish her beloved dog. But she may lose more than her dog if she stays there. This story is an interesting mix of mystery and romance overlaid with Christian beliefs.
July 7, 2015
The Innocent gives an interesting look at the Shaker life, which I must admit I didn’t know about except for a brief mention in Robert Newton Peck’s book A Day No Pigs Would Die. It was interesting to see what they believed and how Carlyn managed to live among them when they had such radically different beliefs from hers.
However, The Innocent is, quite frankly, boring, and it plods along noticeably. Even the attempts at mystery and tension fall flat, since they are spaced far apart and in between the same things happen over and over: Carlyn wonders how she will ever manage to live with the Shakers when they have such different beliefs, she thinks about Ambrose, she thinks about the sheriff, she thinks about her dog, and she acts like a shrinking violet. Then there’s an interlude where the sheriff thinks about how beautiful/strong/alluring Carlyn is and then talks to her dog. Then there’s some sort of tension or mystery, then the same pattern repeats.
I honestly could not stand Carlyn as a character. She was too squishy for me. She had a sort of faux-strength about her, as if the author wanted us to think she was a strong character but ended up just showing us how much Carlyn isn’t strong, in many ways. If something more exciting had happened in the novel, maybe I wouldn’t have thought that Carlyn was so vanilla, but she plodded along just as the plot did. And the romance was beyond predictable and, as a result, boring.
The Innocent, though with an interesting look at Shaker life and history, is ultimately boring. The mystery is stretched out way too much (and not completely resolved, to boot); the characters do and think the same things over and over; the romance is uninteresting; and I had to fight to actually finish the book.
Disclaimer: copy given by publisher in exchange for honest review
However, The Innocent is, quite frankly, boring, and it plods along noticeably. Even the attempts at mystery and tension fall flat, since they are spaced far apart and in between the same things happen over and over: Carlyn wonders how she will ever manage to live with the Shakers when they have such different beliefs, she thinks about Ambrose, she thinks about the sheriff, she thinks about her dog, and she acts like a shrinking violet. Then there’s an interlude where the sheriff thinks about how beautiful/strong/alluring Carlyn is and then talks to her dog. Then there’s some sort of tension or mystery, then the same pattern repeats.
I honestly could not stand Carlyn as a character. She was too squishy for me. She had a sort of faux-strength about her, as if the author wanted us to think she was a strong character but ended up just showing us how much Carlyn isn’t strong, in many ways. If something more exciting had happened in the novel, maybe I wouldn’t have thought that Carlyn was so vanilla, but she plodded along just as the plot did. And the romance was beyond predictable and, as a result, boring.
The Innocent, though with an interesting look at Shaker life and history, is ultimately boring. The mystery is stretched out way too much (and not completely resolved, to boot); the characters do and think the same things over and over; the romance is uninteresting; and I had to fight to actually finish the book.
Disclaimer: copy given by publisher in exchange for honest review
August 12, 2015
BACK OF THE BOOK BLURB
Carlyn Kearney has spent two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. When the war ends without further word, Carlyn finds herself penniless, in debt, and forced from her home. With nowhere else to go, she seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill.
The Shakers profess peace through simple living, but to Carlyn, the Shaker life seems anything but simple. When mysterious deaths disturb the peace of the village, Carlyn falls under intense scrutiny. Can a kind sheriff help her expose the true culprit?
MY REVIEW
This may be the best book in the series so far. A great story of love, faith and strength by one woman, who thinks she is alone against the world. Even a little bit of murder and mystery, so good. The one thing she encourages, through her mother, is to "pray anyway". What a good thing to remember/do, even if you think God isn't listening, if you have temporarily lost your faith, anytime you need help with anything, no matter how trivial it may seem to someone else, "PRAY ANYWAY".
This has been a very interesting series and I would encourage all to read it. I learned a lot about the Shakers, even though they seem peaceful, loving and faithful, I almost feel like there is a problem with their lifestyle and sometimes they seem mean to me. I really don't think I could be a Shaker. I'd be interested to know what others opinions are.
Carlyn Kearney has spent two lonely years not knowing whether to mourn or to hope after she receives word from the Union Army that her husband is missing. When the war ends without further word, Carlyn finds herself penniless, in debt, and forced from her home. With nowhere else to go, she seeks refuge at the Shaker village of Harmony Hill.
The Shakers profess peace through simple living, but to Carlyn, the Shaker life seems anything but simple. When mysterious deaths disturb the peace of the village, Carlyn falls under intense scrutiny. Can a kind sheriff help her expose the true culprit?
MY REVIEW
This may be the best book in the series so far. A great story of love, faith and strength by one woman, who thinks she is alone against the world. Even a little bit of murder and mystery, so good. The one thing she encourages, through her mother, is to "pray anyway". What a good thing to remember/do, even if you think God isn't listening, if you have temporarily lost your faith, anytime you need help with anything, no matter how trivial it may seem to someone else, "PRAY ANYWAY".
This has been a very interesting series and I would encourage all to read it. I learned a lot about the Shakers, even though they seem peaceful, loving and faithful, I almost feel like there is a problem with their lifestyle and sometimes they seem mean to me. I really don't think I could be a Shaker. I'd be interested to know what others opinions are.
July 8, 2015
The Innocent by Ann H. Gabhart is yet another terrific installment in the series of Shaker novels set at Harmony Hill. Set directly following the Civil War, it features a beautiful war widow, her dog, and a handsome sheriff. Centered around mysterious happenings at the Shaker village and the town surrounding Harmony Hill, The Innocent is a little more suspenseful than the previous Shaker titles, but no less fascinating. I don't think I will ever tire of reading these fictionalized stories of this strange sect. The Innocent is slightly lacking as far as romances go and I wish there could have been more interaction between the hero and heroine, but the sisterly camaraderie between Carlyn and Sister Berdine makes up for it. Overall, The Innocent is worth the read and deserving of a permanent spot on the shelf in the library!
~ My Rating: 4 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
~ My Rating: 4 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
December 27, 2018
This is the sixth novel of Ann H. Gabhart's Shaker series, and I liked it just as much as I like the first five (and a half :)) books. As I expected, this novel was well written, and the characters were well drawn and interesting. I especially enjoyed Carlyn's spirited and headstrong debates with Sister Edna in this story. The historical setting among this short lived cult was also intriguing as well because I believe that if a novel also makes you think of what you believe and why as well as entertains, it is a bonus to a well written story.
May 16, 2020
Good story. A few plot twists were unexpected, but the ending was pretty predictable.
July 9, 2017
Carlyn thinks her only decent chance for a food and roof over her head is to join the Shakers, the Christian sect nearby. After all, her husband is still missing from war and her prayers seem to go unanswered. But she prays anyway.
What an intelligent, mature writing! Ms Gabhart truly writes to serve you a food for thought while you can enjoy real characters who think and feel like adults.
They have their doubts, they have their sins, they have their fights and they have very real problems.
Carlyn Kearney was hurt enough in her life - a tyrannical preacher for a father who had tried his best to break her spirit (thanks be to God for a tender, God-loving mother) and a short-lived happiness in happy marriage - till the war. Now her husband is missing for two years and everybody else thinks that she is a widow - but how can SHE know? And there are debts - and a ruthless man offering her payments - with her body. So a gun and a smart dog with lots of teeth are her only weapons, right? But her mother always say "pray anyway". So Carlyn prays - and the nearby Shaker village seems as an answer. But the place is not the oasis of peace on earths it seems and claims to be - there was a fire and a man died.
And handsome sheriff is decided not only to find a culprit, but also a way into a beautiful widow's heart.
I can't heap enough superlatives for the in-depth storytelling and issues presented. Carlyn is of curious, intelligent mind and can't accept any "truths" without understanding them. And Shakers, the Christian sect, has a lot of controversial teachings to make her sharp mind to ponder about - like why is marriage a sin? But they also offer a lot of charity and goodwill. I have never heard of Shakers before and I am glad to have this possibility to know more about them.
I also love my characters intelligent - and here I have plenty of that. Sheriff Brodie is complex character, too - a man with trust issues as his beloved had betrayed him, but he also knows a right girl when she comes around - even if the girl is maybe a widow, and also an independent being marching to the sound of her own drum.
Even the dog is smart! Asher, I would offer you a place in a minute.
I strangely also like Sister Edna, a strict tutor to Carlyn, addicted to following the rules, but also a tormented, sad woman with doubts hidden deep in her heart. Can you accept my hug and well wishes, Sister, even if I am of the world?
As for the cons - the plot is a bit prolonged and Sister Edna's doubts deserve to be explored in more details.
But still - what a mature, intelligent, high-quality read this is! After this novel I will read anything Ms Gabhart writes.
What an intelligent, mature writing! Ms Gabhart truly writes to serve you a food for thought while you can enjoy real characters who think and feel like adults.
They have their doubts, they have their sins, they have their fights and they have very real problems.
Carlyn Kearney was hurt enough in her life - a tyrannical preacher for a father who had tried his best to break her spirit (thanks be to God for a tender, God-loving mother) and a short-lived happiness in happy marriage - till the war. Now her husband is missing for two years and everybody else thinks that she is a widow - but how can SHE know? And there are debts - and a ruthless man offering her payments - with her body. So a gun and a smart dog with lots of teeth are her only weapons, right? But her mother always say "pray anyway". So Carlyn prays - and the nearby Shaker village seems as an answer. But the place is not the oasis of peace on earths it seems and claims to be - there was a fire and a man died.
And handsome sheriff is decided not only to find a culprit, but also a way into a beautiful widow's heart.
I can't heap enough superlatives for the in-depth storytelling and issues presented. Carlyn is of curious, intelligent mind and can't accept any "truths" without understanding them. And Shakers, the Christian sect, has a lot of controversial teachings to make her sharp mind to ponder about - like why is marriage a sin? But they also offer a lot of charity and goodwill. I have never heard of Shakers before and I am glad to have this possibility to know more about them.
I also love my characters intelligent - and here I have plenty of that. Sheriff Brodie is complex character, too - a man with trust issues as his beloved had betrayed him, but he also knows a right girl when she comes around - even if the girl is maybe a widow, and also an independent being marching to the sound of her own drum.
Even the dog is smart! Asher, I would offer you a place in a minute.
I strangely also like Sister Edna, a strict tutor to Carlyn, addicted to following the rules, but also a tormented, sad woman with doubts hidden deep in her heart. Can you accept my hug and well wishes, Sister, even if I am of the world?
As for the cons - the plot is a bit prolonged and Sister Edna's doubts deserve to be explored in more details.
But still - what a mature, intelligent, high-quality read this is! After this novel I will read anything Ms Gabhart writes.
May 12, 2021
Loved it!
I believe I have finished all of the Shaker stories in Ann H. Gabhart's collection. I'm glad I read this one last, it was nice to see familiar characters, and see some of those characters change. I won't give spoilers but you'll be surprised as I was by 1 Sister in particular. I love the Christian message in all of the books, but the book in particular held the message "Pray anyway." Something we can all take away and apply to our daily lives. This book held quite a bit of suspense and has to be one of my favorites the other being the Innocent. I hope you all enjoy this book as much as I did and I look forward to more books by Ann, and can't wait to enjoy them as well!
Thank you Ann for your devotion to your readers and also for the research you do for the Shaker books, to make sure the lives the Shakers lead are depicted correctly in your characters daily lives and the readers get an inside view of what it was like to live as a Shaker. Much appreciation to you!
I believe I have finished all of the Shaker stories in Ann H. Gabhart's collection. I'm glad I read this one last, it was nice to see familiar characters, and see some of those characters change. I won't give spoilers but you'll be surprised as I was by 1 Sister in particular. I love the Christian message in all of the books, but the book in particular held the message "Pray anyway." Something we can all take away and apply to our daily lives. This book held quite a bit of suspense and has to be one of my favorites the other being the Innocent. I hope you all enjoy this book as much as I did and I look forward to more books by Ann, and can't wait to enjoy them as well!
Thank you Ann for your devotion to your readers and also for the research you do for the Shaker books, to make sure the lives the Shakers lead are depicted correctly in your characters daily lives and the readers get an inside view of what it was like to live as a Shaker. Much appreciation to you!
November 11, 2021
The Innocent
Of all the books in this Shaker series, I enjoyed this one the best. It is a beautiful love story for Carlyn and Mitchell. Carlyn stayed true to her love of Ambrose who was declared missing while fighting as a Union soldier. Everyone in town called her a widow but she never gave up hope that he was alive. All she had left of her marriage was a house and her faithful dog until she lost her house and joined the Shakers for protection from her evil landlord and to have something to eat. When arson and murder happened soon after she arrived in the Shaker Village, Sheriff Mitchell rescued her and her dog. I highly recommend this book as a clean romantic suspense. Each book in the series were a joy to read and each was a standalone with a HEA ending.
Of all the books in this Shaker series, I enjoyed this one the best. It is a beautiful love story for Carlyn and Mitchell. Carlyn stayed true to her love of Ambrose who was declared missing while fighting as a Union soldier. Everyone in town called her a widow but she never gave up hope that he was alive. All she had left of her marriage was a house and her faithful dog until she lost her house and joined the Shakers for protection from her evil landlord and to have something to eat. When arson and murder happened soon after she arrived in the Shaker Village, Sheriff Mitchell rescued her and her dog. I highly recommend this book as a clean romantic suspense. Each book in the series were a joy to read and each was a standalone with a HEA ending.
July 31, 2023
Carlyn Kierney doesn't know whether her husband is dead or alive. All she knows is that he has been missing in action for the past two years since he left to fight for the Union in the Civil War. Since her husband hasn't returned, there is no way for her to finish paying off her debt to her landlord. Her landlord is an unpleasant person and forces her out of home. With no place to go, she goes to the Shaker Village for refuge. However, even among the Shakers, Carlyn faces danger. Sheriff Mitchell Brady is concerned about some of the goings-on in the village. More importantly, he is concerned about keeping Carlyn safe and winning her heart if she ever finds the truth about her late husband.
September 21, 2018
Such a good book!!
Once again, Ann H. Gabhart puts forth another Shaker book, which I just loved! I always enjoy reading her historical Shaker books, they always hold my interest throughout the whole book! My favorite characters were Asher, a loyal and protective wonderful dog of his owner, I actually cried when his owner had to part with him! Then of course, there was handsome, Sheriff Brodie, he was not only a great lawman, but a good man!
I highly recommend this book, you will enjoy it, also!
Once again, Ann H. Gabhart puts forth another Shaker book, which I just loved! I always enjoy reading her historical Shaker books, they always hold my interest throughout the whole book! My favorite characters were Asher, a loyal and protective wonderful dog of his owner, I actually cried when his owner had to part with him! Then of course, there was handsome, Sheriff Brodie, he was not only a great lawman, but a good man!
I highly recommend this book, you will enjoy it, also!
January 8, 2026
Rollercoaster!
Ok this book gives all the feels in spades!! I love that Asher, the dog is the true hero of the story. Carlyn and Mitchell deserve a wonderful happy ever after.
After every Shaker book I finish, I keep wondering how they can be so very wrong about love. They only see the failed side of marriage. This comes from a self named old maid. Just because some marriages fail, doesn’t mean all will. True love is never wrong.
Ok this book gives all the feels in spades!! I love that Asher, the dog is the true hero of the story. Carlyn and Mitchell deserve a wonderful happy ever after.
After every Shaker book I finish, I keep wondering how they can be so very wrong about love. They only see the failed side of marriage. This comes from a self named old maid. Just because some marriages fail, doesn’t mean all will. True love is never wrong.
March 5, 2020
Loved Carolyns story
Another Shaker village story that I’ve enjoyed :) Always hoping to see another character turn up in the next book so I’ll be off to find another ASAP. Ann Gabhart is a gifted storyteller. I’ve been sucked into each book I’ve read, no matter the time or place. Carolyn & Asher are worth the read!
Another Shaker village story that I’ve enjoyed :) Always hoping to see another character turn up in the next book so I’ll be off to find another ASAP. Ann Gabhart is a gifted storyteller. I’ve been sucked into each book I’ve read, no matter the time or place. Carolyn & Asher are worth the read!
May 31, 2020
This author is an extremely great author. All of the Shaker books are so interesting and the stories really get you at the heart. I just loved learning more about the shaker ways . Ann hit a grand slam with this!
September 14, 2018
Entertaining light read 👍🏼
August 25, 2020
Best one yet
Enjoyed this book. Very well written and filled with intrigue and romance. You won’t be disappointed in this wonderful book!
Enjoyed this book. Very well written and filled with intrigue and romance. You won’t be disappointed in this wonderful book!
October 9, 2020
Good read.
December 8, 2020
I really enjoyed reading this book and learning more about the Shaker way of life. Easy, relaxing, but interesting read.
November 20, 2021
3.5 Stars...
October 14, 2023
Carlyn moves to the Shaker village hoping for some peace. I liked the bit of mystery in this one.
November 3, 2024
very good book
August 13, 2015
The Innocent by Ann H. Gabhart is an historical Christian novel. It is September of 1865 and Carlyn Kearney has not heard from her husband in two years. He went off to fight in the Civil War and she did not hear from him after the summer of 1863. Carlyn is out of money and has no way to pay the lien on their property and home. Carlyn does not know what to do. She does not want to leave their home in case her husband, Ambrose comes back. Ambrose was listed as missing in action.
Sheriff Mitchell Brodie arrives one day with Curt Whitlow. Curt owns the lien on the property. He has offered to help Carlyn out in exchange for certain favors (we all know he means sex). Curt is married with a family of his own, but that does not stop his roving ways. Sheriff Brodie is very nice and polite to Carlyn. Carlyn greets them at the door with a shotgun and her dog, Asher. Asher has been her friend since the day he arrived starving on her doorstep. Asher does not like Curt and is very protective of Carlyn. Carlyn has one week to leave.
After much prayer Carlyn decides to go to the nearby Shaker village of Harmony Hill. Carlyn is accepted into the village, but not Asher. Carlyn asks Sheriff Brodie to watch Asher for her and give him a good home. Carlyn tries to fit into life at the village, but it is very different. They all have to dress the same way, no violence, a lot of work, many rules, and they are always being watched. Sister Edna is assigned to be Carlyn’s teacher or guide. Sister Edna seems to resent Carlyn (for her looks) and is always finding fault. One day Carlyn overhears an argument between Brother Henry Stratton and Curt Whitlow. The next night their barn with the horses is on fire and Brother Henry cannot be found. Sheriff Brodie sets out to find out who set fire to the barn and who wanted Brother Henry dead (poor man is found under a hay bale). Then Curt Whitlow is missing (and assumed guilty). When Sister Edna is found at the bottom of some steps during the night by Carlyn, Carlyn is accused of pushing her. What is going on in this village? Sheriff Brodie has his work cut out for him. Mitchell Brodie is also having feelings for Carlyn. He would like to get to know her better, but he is unable to with her in the village (Shaker’s are against marriage). Can Mitchell keep her safe and find a way to get to know her better? Does Carlyn have feelings for Mitchell?
Read The Innocent to find out who is messing with the Shaker village and the fate of Carlyn and Mitchell. I give The Innocent 4 out of 5 stars. I liked it, but I admit to not loving it. It is heavy in scripture (a tad preachy). I enjoyed the mystery in the story (I cannot help it if I like mysteries). I found pleasure in how the story ended. Ann H. Gabhart is a good storyteller. I have read books of hers before, and I will definitely will read more of them in the future. She has a good understanding of the Shaker culture and put it together very nicely into this book (there are others as well).
I received a complimentary copy of The Innocent from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The review and opinions expressed are my own.
http://bibliophileandavidreader.blogs...
Sheriff Mitchell Brodie arrives one day with Curt Whitlow. Curt owns the lien on the property. He has offered to help Carlyn out in exchange for certain favors (we all know he means sex). Curt is married with a family of his own, but that does not stop his roving ways. Sheriff Brodie is very nice and polite to Carlyn. Carlyn greets them at the door with a shotgun and her dog, Asher. Asher has been her friend since the day he arrived starving on her doorstep. Asher does not like Curt and is very protective of Carlyn. Carlyn has one week to leave.
After much prayer Carlyn decides to go to the nearby Shaker village of Harmony Hill. Carlyn is accepted into the village, but not Asher. Carlyn asks Sheriff Brodie to watch Asher for her and give him a good home. Carlyn tries to fit into life at the village, but it is very different. They all have to dress the same way, no violence, a lot of work, many rules, and they are always being watched. Sister Edna is assigned to be Carlyn’s teacher or guide. Sister Edna seems to resent Carlyn (for her looks) and is always finding fault. One day Carlyn overhears an argument between Brother Henry Stratton and Curt Whitlow. The next night their barn with the horses is on fire and Brother Henry cannot be found. Sheriff Brodie sets out to find out who set fire to the barn and who wanted Brother Henry dead (poor man is found under a hay bale). Then Curt Whitlow is missing (and assumed guilty). When Sister Edna is found at the bottom of some steps during the night by Carlyn, Carlyn is accused of pushing her. What is going on in this village? Sheriff Brodie has his work cut out for him. Mitchell Brodie is also having feelings for Carlyn. He would like to get to know her better, but he is unable to with her in the village (Shaker’s are against marriage). Can Mitchell keep her safe and find a way to get to know her better? Does Carlyn have feelings for Mitchell?
Read The Innocent to find out who is messing with the Shaker village and the fate of Carlyn and Mitchell. I give The Innocent 4 out of 5 stars. I liked it, but I admit to not loving it. It is heavy in scripture (a tad preachy). I enjoyed the mystery in the story (I cannot help it if I like mysteries). I found pleasure in how the story ended. Ann H. Gabhart is a good storyteller. I have read books of hers before, and I will definitely will read more of them in the future. She has a good understanding of the Shaker culture and put it together very nicely into this book (there are others as well).
I received a complimentary copy of The Innocent from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. The review and opinions expressed are my own.
http://bibliophileandavidreader.blogs...
July 1, 2015
Page 140, that is where this book came alive for me. Prior to that point, it was a pleasant read, but not compelling in any way. From that point, and through the remaining 242 pages, I could not put the book down. I am so glad that I had agreed to review the novel, otherwise I may not have continued reading, and I truly would have missed out.
While I have read a number of Amish fiction novels, this is the first Shaker novel I have read. I will be looking for other Shaker novels by Gabhart. I know that there are at least five more from which to choose. While I have visited the Shaker Village of Pleasant Hill near Danville, Kentucky several times, I learned a great deal more about the Shakers while reading The Innocent. I did do an internet search on some of the information included in the text, and found it to be accurate every time.
Carlyn Kearney, Gabhart’s main character, grew up under her pastor father’s legalistic thumb, cushioned only slightly by her mother’s teaching of God’s grace and love. After marrying Ambrose, Carlyn blossomed as she came to understand the joy of the Lord. That joy was difficult to sustain, however, due to Ambrose’s uncertain fate two years after the end of the Civil War. Being unable to support herself, let alone pay her debts, Carlyn seeks shelter and peace within the boundaries of the Shaker village of Harmony Hill. While thankful for food and shelter, Carlyn does not readily fit into the Shaker way of life. Sheriff Mitchell Brodie cannot deny his attraction to Carlyn, but respects her faithfulness to her husband even though the townsfolk assume that she is indeed a widow. He longs to insure her safety as every instinct within him is on alert to something being very wrong in the Shaker village. It is at that page 140 mark that Carlyn herself becomes aware of dangerous undercurrents among the sisters and brethren.
One thing I really appreciate about Christian fiction is the lessons that one can take away. I hope that in the darkest and most difficult times, the times when hope seems lost or when my body is exhausted, I will remember the echo of Carlyn’s mother’s admonishment to, “Pray anyway.” When looking for the answers I desire, the good I want to come, I hope I recall her saying, “Assuredly. God is love. But he sees the whole woven fabric of our lives and not simply the few threads we are trying to twine together at the moment. Good and bad weave into the pattern of our lives. Together they make us strong and able to endure whatever must be endured.” God equips us in many ways, some easier than others.
I recommend this book to those who have the time and patience to allow the author to develop her characters before increasing the tension that drives the reader forward. It is my belief that readers will find it worth the wait; I certainly did. I thank Revell Publishers and Christian Fiction Blog Alliance for providing The Innocent for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed here are strictly my own.
While I have read a number of Amish fiction novels, this is the first Shaker novel I have read. I will be looking for other Shaker novels by Gabhart. I know that there are at least five more from which to choose. While I have visited the Shaker Village of Pleasant Hill near Danville, Kentucky several times, I learned a great deal more about the Shakers while reading The Innocent. I did do an internet search on some of the information included in the text, and found it to be accurate every time.
Carlyn Kearney, Gabhart’s main character, grew up under her pastor father’s legalistic thumb, cushioned only slightly by her mother’s teaching of God’s grace and love. After marrying Ambrose, Carlyn blossomed as she came to understand the joy of the Lord. That joy was difficult to sustain, however, due to Ambrose’s uncertain fate two years after the end of the Civil War. Being unable to support herself, let alone pay her debts, Carlyn seeks shelter and peace within the boundaries of the Shaker village of Harmony Hill. While thankful for food and shelter, Carlyn does not readily fit into the Shaker way of life. Sheriff Mitchell Brodie cannot deny his attraction to Carlyn, but respects her faithfulness to her husband even though the townsfolk assume that she is indeed a widow. He longs to insure her safety as every instinct within him is on alert to something being very wrong in the Shaker village. It is at that page 140 mark that Carlyn herself becomes aware of dangerous undercurrents among the sisters and brethren.
One thing I really appreciate about Christian fiction is the lessons that one can take away. I hope that in the darkest and most difficult times, the times when hope seems lost or when my body is exhausted, I will remember the echo of Carlyn’s mother’s admonishment to, “Pray anyway.” When looking for the answers I desire, the good I want to come, I hope I recall her saying, “Assuredly. God is love. But he sees the whole woven fabric of our lives and not simply the few threads we are trying to twine together at the moment. Good and bad weave into the pattern of our lives. Together they make us strong and able to endure whatever must be endured.” God equips us in many ways, some easier than others.
I recommend this book to those who have the time and patience to allow the author to develop her characters before increasing the tension that drives the reader forward. It is my belief that readers will find it worth the wait; I certainly did. I thank Revell Publishers and Christian Fiction Blog Alliance for providing The Innocent for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation for a favorable review and the opinions expressed here are strictly my own.
March 3, 2017
Not an Amish story, but the Shakers. Christiansburg with a "western" flavor.
July 8, 2015
Reviewed at The Power of Words: http://bit.ly/1S2ZklH
Ann H. Gabhart is an excellent storyteller. The Innocent is an intriguing novel - well written, with compelling characters, romance, mystery, rich historical detail, and a strong storyline that captured my interest on the first page. The story is tender, bittersweet and heartwarming, with the emotional depth and subtle humor that are trademarks of Ann's writing, which make for a very enjoyable read.
The Innocent, set at the close of the Civil War in 1865, is Ann's seventh stand-alone story set in the fictional Shaker village of Harmony Hill, based on the actual Shaker village of Pleasant Hill, Kentucky. The Shaker faith is unusual and fascinating, as are the followers themselves, and these elements work well as a backdrop for the stories. Sister Edna explains to Carlyn: "In heaven there are no marriages, only children of God. We, here in Harmony Hill . . . have brought heaven down to us in order to live a perfect life and shut out worldly things." The teachings of Mother Ann, legalistic rules, and passionate dances of worship are contrasted with their work ethic, having all things in common for the good of the community, simple living, and a welcoming spirit to those in need.
Carlyn and Mitchell are strong, compelling characters - fresh and appealing - and I was quickly drawn to them. Carlyn, a widow without proof of widowhood, came to the Shakers for sustenance and security. Mitchell, a war veteran who longs for a family of his own, has a sensitivity and wisdom that serve him well as sheriff. Carlyn and Mitchell didn't have as much time together as I hope for in romantic storylines, but allowances can made because of the time period and Shaker setting. Their relationship is still very satisfying. And it's Carlyn's dog, Asher, who practically becomes a main character, often stealing the show. I may technically be a cat person, but Asher captured my heart.
Through the Shaker beliefs and the misguided understanding of righteousness passed down by Carlyn's father, we see a contrast between legalism and grace, making me ever thankful for the abounding grace that only comes through Christ. But the overarching theme is reflected in the teaching of Carlyn's mother, to "pray anyway," in all circumstances of life - and those are words to live by. Mitchell thought he had left his need for prayer on the battlefield and Carlyn tended to only want the answers she begged for, causing her to reflect that perhaps God "would have already sent her an answer if she had stopped making demands and simply listened." Wow, that certainly hits close to home! It was good to see Mitchell and Carlyn grow spiritually in ways that I could identify with.
Reading any of Ann H. Gabhart's stories is pure pleasure, and I thoroughly enjoyed returning to the Shaker setting in The Innocent. Highly recommended.
Thank you to Ann H. Gabhart and Revell for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Ann H. Gabhart is an excellent storyteller. The Innocent is an intriguing novel - well written, with compelling characters, romance, mystery, rich historical detail, and a strong storyline that captured my interest on the first page. The story is tender, bittersweet and heartwarming, with the emotional depth and subtle humor that are trademarks of Ann's writing, which make for a very enjoyable read.
The Innocent, set at the close of the Civil War in 1865, is Ann's seventh stand-alone story set in the fictional Shaker village of Harmony Hill, based on the actual Shaker village of Pleasant Hill, Kentucky. The Shaker faith is unusual and fascinating, as are the followers themselves, and these elements work well as a backdrop for the stories. Sister Edna explains to Carlyn: "In heaven there are no marriages, only children of God. We, here in Harmony Hill . . . have brought heaven down to us in order to live a perfect life and shut out worldly things." The teachings of Mother Ann, legalistic rules, and passionate dances of worship are contrasted with their work ethic, having all things in common for the good of the community, simple living, and a welcoming spirit to those in need.
Carlyn and Mitchell are strong, compelling characters - fresh and appealing - and I was quickly drawn to them. Carlyn, a widow without proof of widowhood, came to the Shakers for sustenance and security. Mitchell, a war veteran who longs for a family of his own, has a sensitivity and wisdom that serve him well as sheriff. Carlyn and Mitchell didn't have as much time together as I hope for in romantic storylines, but allowances can made because of the time period and Shaker setting. Their relationship is still very satisfying. And it's Carlyn's dog, Asher, who practically becomes a main character, often stealing the show. I may technically be a cat person, but Asher captured my heart.
Through the Shaker beliefs and the misguided understanding of righteousness passed down by Carlyn's father, we see a contrast between legalism and grace, making me ever thankful for the abounding grace that only comes through Christ. But the overarching theme is reflected in the teaching of Carlyn's mother, to "pray anyway," in all circumstances of life - and those are words to live by. Mitchell thought he had left his need for prayer on the battlefield and Carlyn tended to only want the answers she begged for, causing her to reflect that perhaps God "would have already sent her an answer if she had stopped making demands and simply listened." Wow, that certainly hits close to home! It was good to see Mitchell and Carlyn grow spiritually in ways that I could identify with.
Reading any of Ann H. Gabhart's stories is pure pleasure, and I thoroughly enjoyed returning to the Shaker setting in The Innocent. Highly recommended.
Thank you to Ann H. Gabhart and Revell for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
July 2, 2015
The post-Civil war period was one of the most difficult times in history, not only for surveying soldiers, but also the families they left behind. This novel gave me an even deeper glimpse into how hard it was.
In 1865, young Carlyn Kearney was one of those facing the aftermath. Her situation was complicated by the fact that her beloved husband, Ambrose, was reported missing 2 years ago. The last time she had heard from him was in 1863. Was he dead? Was she a widow? How long did she wait for him to return. She loved him and didn’t want to give up hope, but this was only a small part of the hardships she faced. I cannot imagine being a widow during that time. Tending the home was more than cleaning and paying the electric bill. There were animals to care for, a garden, and much more.
Unable to pay the loan on their farm, Carlyn was being harassed and threatened by her repugnant and cruel landlord, Curt Whitlow. All she had for protection was her gun and her very capable dog Asher, whom she loved deeply. Finally the day came when Curt and Sheriff Mitchell Brodie, gave her a deadline to be out of her home. Sheriff Brodie was immediately taken with her courage, beauty, and vulnerability.
Everything looks hopeless for the young widow but a saying of her mother’s continues to come to mind, “Pray anyway.” And that she does!
She decides to join the local Shaker Community where she will receive food and shelter while she waits for word of Ambrose. She does not believe as they do, but she feels she can live with them for her needs to be met. Not allowing dogs, she is forced to give Asher to the Sheriff. Mitchell is fine with that as it gives him a way to keep in touch and feed his growing attraction to her.
I knew little about the Shaker’s beliefs and practices other than their simplicity in living and ban against marriage. I was shocked and how far they took their strict behavior and lifestyle. It seemed a sad life built around rules and legalism. From how you spoke, to what you wore, and how you ate, their guidelines were extremely unyielding. Caryln found herself in a different kind of suffering and questioned if her decision to join was the right one. Strange things began to happen after Caryln arrived and of course the Shakers blamed her.
This book is filled with many surprises and lots of excitement! Woven right through middle of all the action is a beautiful story of 2 people learning to love again, and strong faith in the midst of harrowing trials. What really left an impression on me was Caryln’s mother’s spiritual teaching, “Pray anyway.” It has come back to e many times since I read the book, and know it will continue to.
I received this book free from Revell Reads Blog Tour Program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I stated are my own.
In 1865, young Carlyn Kearney was one of those facing the aftermath. Her situation was complicated by the fact that her beloved husband, Ambrose, was reported missing 2 years ago. The last time she had heard from him was in 1863. Was he dead? Was she a widow? How long did she wait for him to return. She loved him and didn’t want to give up hope, but this was only a small part of the hardships she faced. I cannot imagine being a widow during that time. Tending the home was more than cleaning and paying the electric bill. There were animals to care for, a garden, and much more.
Unable to pay the loan on their farm, Carlyn was being harassed and threatened by her repugnant and cruel landlord, Curt Whitlow. All she had for protection was her gun and her very capable dog Asher, whom she loved deeply. Finally the day came when Curt and Sheriff Mitchell Brodie, gave her a deadline to be out of her home. Sheriff Brodie was immediately taken with her courage, beauty, and vulnerability.
Everything looks hopeless for the young widow but a saying of her mother’s continues to come to mind, “Pray anyway.” And that she does!
She decides to join the local Shaker Community where she will receive food and shelter while she waits for word of Ambrose. She does not believe as they do, but she feels she can live with them for her needs to be met. Not allowing dogs, she is forced to give Asher to the Sheriff. Mitchell is fine with that as it gives him a way to keep in touch and feed his growing attraction to her.
I knew little about the Shaker’s beliefs and practices other than their simplicity in living and ban against marriage. I was shocked and how far they took their strict behavior and lifestyle. It seemed a sad life built around rules and legalism. From how you spoke, to what you wore, and how you ate, their guidelines were extremely unyielding. Caryln found herself in a different kind of suffering and questioned if her decision to join was the right one. Strange things began to happen after Caryln arrived and of course the Shakers blamed her.
This book is filled with many surprises and lots of excitement! Woven right through middle of all the action is a beautiful story of 2 people learning to love again, and strong faith in the midst of harrowing trials. What really left an impression on me was Caryln’s mother’s spiritual teaching, “Pray anyway.” It has come back to e many times since I read the book, and know it will continue to.
I received this book free from Revell Reads Blog Tour Program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I stated are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 86 reviews