Disclaimer: Kavyn is a friend of mine, so I have given this book a five star review even though my actual feelings do not reflect that score. I have talked with him about those feelings prior to writing this review.
The structure and premise of this story are its greatest strengths. I enjoyed the intellectual build up that leads right into a Top Gun–esque middle third. The resolution has strong overtones of humanism and empathy, which I found refreshing compared to the darker books I tend to read.
The depth of the characters were where I felt the story lacking. Some of the ways things played out were too squeaky clean to me, and not nuanced, ambiguous, or—to put it plainly—painful enough to suspend any disbelief. I would have felt more invested if I felt that Sam, for instance, had more taken from him on an emotional level. It would have felt more satisfying to see that the hero completed a great duty, but for some price.
All in all, this book was enjoyable and fast-paced with clearly stated morals, though it sometimes ran faster than its feet could take it.
Which is why I would have otherwise given this 3/5 stars.
⭐️⭐️⭐️