Loved this book as a kid, still love it as an adult.
Is it entirely realistic for ten year olds to teach themselves how to be plumbers and electricians, simply by reading books? Probably not. But then I think of the kids in Dickens novels, and how much more resilient you have to be when no one else is going to ride in on a white horse and take care of you, and I think...hey, maybe it's possible. They certainly all wanted it enough, and worked hard to achieve their dreams.
Their collective dream is a simple one, really: to build a family. One made out of the people they choose, constructed solidly enough to last forever.
Annie, one of the 10 year old twins, narrates the story of how their unconventional, socially unacceptable family was formed. She and four other kids - plus 18 year old Lola - fled from their orphanage late one night, spending a couple months on the road and eventually settling down in a small town where they could buy a house and be left in peace. Or so they thought.
The problem with small towns is that everyone notices everything - and the first thing newcomers have to deal with is someone butting into their business. None of these kids really fall into the category of "normal," so every single one of them sticks out like a sore thumb.
When I was younger, I was delighted by the issues that made each of them unadoptable. 9 year old Edmund regularly throws temper tantrums, stripping off all his clothes and screaming at the top of his lungs. 13 year old James refuses to leave his room - ever. 5 year old Ben will eat anything he can fit into his mouth, including keys, toys, paperclips, buttons, and barrettes. And the twins, Annie and Al-Willie, will do absolutely anything to ensure they remain together, including pretending to be lions and biting their foster parents.
Everything I found hilarious as a kid is pretty sad now - still effective, but in a different way. As a judge later points out, each one of their issues stems from deeper problems that Annie (as a 10 year old and thus limited narrator) doesn't dig into. James, in particular, has some pretty intense trauma that he won't talk about with anyone, and that we still don't know by the end of the book - only the judge does, thanks to a very long letter that swayed him a little, but not enough for it to matter.
This is a fantasy story in some ways, but it's also pretty realistic. It's not all that easy to get - or to keep - a happy ending. But they do their best.
The problem, you see, is two-fold:
1. No one wants to adopt, or foster, more than one kid, which means that the twins are constantly separated. If two kids are impossible, then all six of them winding up in one house is completely off the table, as long as they follow the rules and let other people make their decisions for them.
2. These kids aren't "normal". They don't want to be, and they know from a lot of painful, traumatic experience that anyone who takes them in will force them to fit into molds that range from uncomfortable to unbearable.
So their solution, if they can't find a family that will allow them to be true to themselves, is to make their own. And it works, for a while.
Lola, who's been on his own since he was very small, makes a decent amount of money by writing a nationally syndicated advice column. (Basically Dear Abby.) No one suspects that this highly popular advice is coming from an 18 year old orphan, and as long as that remains a secret, Lola (actual name: Arthur) can continue earning a living that allows him to buy a house and take care of all the kids he's not legally able to adopt.
The rest of the kids pull their weight, too. They study on their own and with Lola's help, learning everything from cooking to plumbing to electrical wiring - anything they'll need to get their rundown new house in shape and to keep it that way.
And, at Lola's insistence, they go to school and do their best to fit in. Unfortunately, that's where they fail, and from the start, the most influential townspeople have it out for them. So when things fall apart, in a devastating scene that made me squirm a lot more this time around, they have to make some more decisions. Do they put their fate in the hands of the court, trusting that a judge will rule in their favor, or do they run again? And if they run now, with their faces and all their secrets plastered all over the news, will they ever be able to stop running?
I hadn't actually remembered the ending, so I held my breath through those last few pages. It's satisfying. It does make me want more. But it feels true to this story and these characters. This is a really unique, sensitively written book that I think deserves a readership nearly as wide as Lola's column.