What do you think?
Rate this book
Muse
Sophie didn’t expect much when she agreed to go out that night.
Definitely not him.
The stranger with the quiet intensity and a devastating smile.
At eighteen, with graduation on the horizon, Sophie let her guard down and allowed him to pull her onto the dance floor, getting lost in a moment that would change their lives forever. No names. No expectations. Just a connection that lingered long after the night ended.
She thought she’d never see him again.
Until he walks into her high school classroom and introduces himself. Mr. Hayes—her new English teacher.
Now he’s untouchable. Distant. Pretending like nothing happened. But Sophie can’t forget the way he looked at her, or the way her heart skips a beat whenever he’s near.
He’s guarded by grief and guilt. She’s desperate for freedom and chasing a future that finally feels possible. Neither of them planned for this. Neither of them should want more.
But the line between right and wrong is starting to disappear. Falling for each other could cost them everything.
Because some connections don’t fade.
And some rules are meant to be broken.
Definitely not him.
The stranger with the quiet intensity and a devastating smile.
At eighteen, with graduation on the horizon, Sophie let her guard down and allowed him to pull her onto the dance floor, getting lost in a moment that would change their lives forever. No names. No expectations. Just a connection that lingered long after the night ended.
She thought she’d never see him again.
Until he walks into her high school classroom and introduces himself. Mr. Hayes—her new English teacher.
Now he’s untouchable. Distant. Pretending like nothing happened. But Sophie can’t forget the way he looked at her, or the way her heart skips a beat whenever he’s near.
He’s guarded by grief and guilt. She’s desperate for freedom and chasing a future that finally feels possible. Neither of them planned for this. Neither of them should want more.
But the line between right and wrong is starting to disappear. Falling for each other could cost them everything.
Because some connections don’t fade.
And some rules are meant to be broken.
384 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 28, 2025
37 people are currently reading
301 people want to read
About the author
Isla Starling
2 books22 followersIsla Starling writes emotionally charged, angsty, contemporary romance with a forbidden edge. Her stories explore age-gap dynamics, complicated desires, and the kind of tension that keeps you turning pages late into the night. A proud mom and animal lover, Isla lives in the US with a house full of chaos and cuddles (courtesy of her many pets). When she’s not writing, she’s usually lost in a book, chasing her kids and pets, or plotting her next forbidden love story.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 204 reviews
August 5, 2025
This was ur average teacher x student book.
The structure and plot of this book was as expected but the last 10% was an interesting change in pace. I would’ve rather the author paid more attention to their reconciliation than the breakup though.
The dialogue felt a little unoriginal which is what took me out of the story quite a bit. It just felt very surface level to me.
It was basic and dependable for satisfying the craving and sometimes that’s exactly what you need.
Thank you love notes pr for the eARC!
The structure and plot of this book was as expected but the last 10% was an interesting change in pace. I would’ve rather the author paid more attention to their reconciliation than the breakup though.
The dialogue felt a little unoriginal which is what took me out of the story quite a bit. It just felt very surface level to me.
It was basic and dependable for satisfying the craving and sometimes that’s exactly what you need.
Thank you love notes pr for the eARC!
October 12, 2025
2.5⭐️
це було точно не те, чого я очікувала й хотіла. хоча я полюбляю читати троп різниця у віці, а тут ще й student × teacher, але мені зовсім не сподобався стиль авторки. книга написана занадто просто, наївно, по-дитячому. короткі речення, пласкі діалоги та примітивна поведінка гг відштовхували протягом усього читання 😩
проблеми, з якими зіштовхуються гг, теж вгадуються одразу, але й вони тут поверхнево розкриті, як і «шикарне» їхнє вирішення. мені не вистачило банального розкриття персонажів, особливо тео та його драми ☹️
у будь-якому випадку я чомусь дочитала історію софі та тео до кінця, тому округлю до трійки, най буде. плюс тут ще підіймається тема mommy and daddy issues, яка теж так-сяк розкрита 🥲
о, і якщо лінія про джейса та сал, зведених брата та сестру, - це натяк на наступну книгу, то авторка точно збирає мої улюблені тропи. аби ж ще писала про них цікаво 🤞
це було точно не те, чого я очікувала й хотіла. хоча я полюбляю читати троп різниця у віці, а тут ще й student × teacher, але мені зовсім не сподобався стиль авторки. книга написана занадто просто, наївно, по-дитячому. короткі речення, пласкі діалоги та примітивна поведінка гг відштовхували протягом усього читання 😩
проблеми, з якими зіштовхуються гг, теж вгадуються одразу, але й вони тут поверхнево розкриті, як і «шикарне» їхнє вирішення. мені не вистачило банального розкриття персонажів, особливо тео та його драми ☹️
у будь-якому випадку я чомусь дочитала історію софі та тео до кінця, тому округлю до трійки, най буде. плюс тут ще підіймається тема mommy and daddy issues, яка теж так-сяк розкрита 🥲
о, і якщо лінія про джейса та сал, зведених брата та сестру, - це натяк на наступну книгу, то авторка точно збирає мої улюблені тропи. аби ж ще писала про них цікаво 🤞
November 23, 2025
REVIEW
Rating: 3/5
POV: 1st, dual
Tropes: Teacher/Student; Age Gap (17 years); Slow Burn; Artist FMC
Heat Level:4/5
Kinks:N/A
Likes:
* the Teacher/Student dynamic was done very well. It never felt icky even with the huge age gap.
Dislikes:
* the family dynamic for Sophie and her parents could’ve gone a bit more in depth. It didn’t quite make complete sense.
Conclusion:
Not sure how I came across this book but I found it last night and just immediately was like you know what, I want to read this right now and I’m glad I did.
This book did the teacher/student romance so well. The author got the angst, the yearning, the sneaking around, etc done so well.
The reason for the 3 stars is because the writing itself was a bit elementary level feeling. I can tell when an almost 400 page book isn’t written very “deep” when I can finish it in like 4 hours. It can mean two things - either I LOVED the book and couldn’t put it down OR it’s just a really easy read haha.
Hopefully the author continues to work on becoming a better, more in depth, writer. She does plan to write at least two more books according to the last page in this book and I will read them! I definitely want to read Sals story.
3/5
Rating: 3/5
POV: 1st, dual
Tropes: Teacher/Student; Age Gap (17 years); Slow Burn; Artist FMC
Heat Level:4/5
Kinks:N/A
Likes:
* the Teacher/Student dynamic was done very well. It never felt icky even with the huge age gap.
Dislikes:
* the family dynamic for Sophie and her parents could’ve gone a bit more in depth. It didn’t quite make complete sense.
Conclusion:
Not sure how I came across this book but I found it last night and just immediately was like you know what, I want to read this right now and I’m glad I did.
This book did the teacher/student romance so well. The author got the angst, the yearning, the sneaking around, etc done so well.
The reason for the 3 stars is because the writing itself was a bit elementary level feeling. I can tell when an almost 400 page book isn’t written very “deep” when I can finish it in like 4 hours. It can mean two things - either I LOVED the book and couldn’t put it down OR it’s just a really easy read haha.
Hopefully the author continues to work on becoming a better, more in depth, writer. She does plan to write at least two more books according to the last page in this book and I will read them! I definitely want to read Sals story.
3/5
August 1, 2025
Full review coming soon, but this story was absolutely incredible! I can’t wait to reread it when it comes out and highlight the entire thing.
HOLY HECK I’m obsessed. Isla’s writing style was incredible to read and she made it so easy to get into the flow of the characters which I adored. She also managed to put some of my deepest and darkest thoughts and feelings into words which is something I totally didn’t expect going into the story, but I felt so seen through her writing and through Sophie’s character. I can’t wait for the world to meet these characters and fall head over heels for Theo & Sophie.
HOLY HECK I’m obsessed. Isla’s writing style was incredible to read and she made it so easy to get into the flow of the characters which I adored. She also managed to put some of my deepest and darkest thoughts and feelings into words which is something I totally didn’t expect going into the story, but I felt so seen through her writing and through Sophie’s character. I can’t wait for the world to meet these characters and fall head over heels for Theo & Sophie.
August 3, 2025
Love:
The plot was engaging from the start, and I throughly enjoyed the forbidden/ tension relationship to have read it in one day! The author captured the essence of the main character’s tortured souls to inevitably finding each other in this book perfectly. I also enjoyed the relationship of the side characters going on in the background… I’m so excited to read more about it in book 2!
Don’t Love:
There were a few parts that felt a bit slow, I personally would have liked more detail in the family dynamics to explain why the FMC’s family was so hostile towards her. I would have also liked to have known more of the MMC’s backstory in his family dynamics to explain how he grew up into an amazing man and then to have become so angsty to begin with. So moral of the story - I need more background information.
The plot was engaging from the start, and I throughly enjoyed the forbidden/ tension relationship to have read it in one day! The author captured the essence of the main character’s tortured souls to inevitably finding each other in this book perfectly. I also enjoyed the relationship of the side characters going on in the background… I’m so excited to read more about it in book 2!
Don’t Love:
There were a few parts that felt a bit slow, I personally would have liked more detail in the family dynamics to explain why the FMC’s family was so hostile towards her. I would have also liked to have known more of the MMC’s backstory in his family dynamics to explain how he grew up into an amazing man and then to have become so angsty to begin with. So moral of the story - I need more background information.
August 28, 2025
First I want to thank Love Notes PR for providing me with the e-ARC.
Here's my spoiler-free, honest review:
This was one of those romance reads you could read in one sitting, or a good book to read in between. The book totally gave me Ezra and Aria vibes from Pretty Little Liars because of the student-teacher trope. The writing is super easy to follow and the pace is very fast. This is a dual POV book of both the male and female main characters. I liked MMC Theo a bit more than I liked FMC Sophie, but that’s probably because I'm about the same age as Theo, and Sophie was definitely behaving like a teenager at certain points. There were definitely some recognisable moments from when I was a teenager, which made this such a fun read. I'm also very curious about the side characters, which I believe will get their story told in another book in this series. The forbidden romance gave a lot of sneaking around, dealing with guilt, but also very cutesy moments. There is also some spice in the book, which fits the plot well. I do feel like the ending was a little bit rushed, I'd have rather liked to have read a bit more about Sophie's time at college. Another thing I missed a bit was more background information on why Sophie's parents seem to resent her so much, and how Theo became who he is.
Overall, I had a great time reading this book. If the tropes of this book appeal to you, definitely give Muse a try!
Here's my spoiler-free, honest review:
This was one of those romance reads you could read in one sitting, or a good book to read in between. The book totally gave me Ezra and Aria vibes from Pretty Little Liars because of the student-teacher trope. The writing is super easy to follow and the pace is very fast. This is a dual POV book of both the male and female main characters. I liked MMC Theo a bit more than I liked FMC Sophie, but that’s probably because I'm about the same age as Theo, and Sophie was definitely behaving like a teenager at certain points. There were definitely some recognisable moments from when I was a teenager, which made this such a fun read. I'm also very curious about the side characters, which I believe will get their story told in another book in this series. The forbidden romance gave a lot of sneaking around, dealing with guilt, but also very cutesy moments. There is also some spice in the book, which fits the plot well. I do feel like the ending was a little bit rushed, I'd have rather liked to have read a bit more about Sophie's time at college. Another thing I missed a bit was more background information on why Sophie's parents seem to resent her so much, and how Theo became who he is.
Overall, I had a great time reading this book. If the tropes of this book appeal to you, definitely give Muse a try!
September 1, 2025
Thank you Love Notes PR for the eARC
This was a fantastic age gap story !!
Sophie is 18 and about to start her Senior year of highschool. Her and her Bestie Sal are snuck into this bar to watch her stepbrothers band play .
A man strikes up a convo with her and they spend the entire night dancing and talking and the chemistry is just right: but she gets takes away without ever knowing his name.
First hour first day of school Sophie and Sal are just sitting in the back of class and in walks the new teacher …. And it’s HIM !!
This was a fantastic age gap story !!
Sophie is 18 and about to start her Senior year of highschool. Her and her Bestie Sal are snuck into this bar to watch her stepbrothers band play .
A man strikes up a convo with her and they spend the entire night dancing and talking and the chemistry is just right: but she gets takes away without ever knowing his name.
First hour first day of school Sophie and Sal are just sitting in the back of class and in walks the new teacher …. And it’s HIM !!
August 2, 2025
✨ ARC REVIEW ✨
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/🌶️🌶️
This is not as dark as my usual reads at all, BUTTTT this was really good 🤭. I read this arc so quickly and i’m so excited for more. The next story. I have a feeling i’ll really love Jace & Sal 🫣, such a good trope.
Sophie, she’s such a sweetheart 🥹 her and Sal are THE duo, their friendship is absolutely everything. The way they understand each other so easily and are always there, no matter what. Everyone needs their own Sal. She deserves sooo much better. I wanted to throw my phone during so many chapters 😭
Theo, 😩😩😩😩. Is that enough said? The way he talked about her, made sure that confidence was growing and growing 🤭. Full of love and warmth. I was tearing up honestly. I just KNOW he’s cherishing her and probably getting on his knees for her. I lowkey hated him a bit at one point (read and you’ll know) but did he redeem himself so good? FUCK YES. I’m living for the last few chapters. They couldn’t get any more cute. I was smiling so much.
So Isla, very patiently waiting over here for that next book. Again one of my favorite tropes 😏 i’d be so happy to arc read for you again 🫶🏻
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/🌶️🌶️
This is not as dark as my usual reads at all, BUTTTT this was really good 🤭. I read this arc so quickly and i’m so excited for more. The next story. I have a feeling i’ll really love Jace & Sal 🫣, such a good trope.
Sophie, she’s such a sweetheart 🥹 her and Sal are THE duo, their friendship is absolutely everything. The way they understand each other so easily and are always there, no matter what. Everyone needs their own Sal. She deserves sooo much better. I wanted to throw my phone during so many chapters 😭
Theo, 😩😩😩😩. Is that enough said? The way he talked about her, made sure that confidence was growing and growing 🤭. Full of love and warmth. I was tearing up honestly. I just KNOW he’s cherishing her and probably getting on his knees for her. I lowkey hated him a bit at one point (read and you’ll know) but did he redeem himself so good? FUCK YES. I’m living for the last few chapters. They couldn’t get any more cute. I was smiling so much.
So Isla, very patiently waiting over here for that next book. Again one of my favorite tropes 😏 i’d be so happy to arc read for you again 🫶🏻
August 24, 2025
Rating ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice 🌶️🌶️
Sophie is out for a night with her bestie when she meets Theo. They have an insane connection but before she can get information her bestie drags her away.
A few months later the man of her dreams walks in as her high school teacher. Now they fight their feelings while being forced to see each other everyday.
Great story. The forbidden was well done IMO. I enjoyed getting to read this book. And look forward to book 2.
#muse #islastarlingauthor #theforbiddenhearts #book1 #studentxteacher #bookboyfriendsdoitbetter #idratherbereading #onenight #seeme #kismet #rulesaremeanttobebroken
Spice 🌶️🌶️
Sophie is out for a night with her bestie when she meets Theo. They have an insane connection but before she can get information her bestie drags her away.
A few months later the man of her dreams walks in as her high school teacher. Now they fight their feelings while being forced to see each other everyday.
Great story. The forbidden was well done IMO. I enjoyed getting to read this book. And look forward to book 2.
#muse #islastarlingauthor #theforbiddenhearts #book1 #studentxteacher #bookboyfriendsdoitbetter #idratherbereading #onenight #seeme #kismet #rulesaremeanttobebroken
August 2, 2025
Theo and Sophie had so much chemistry and passion! This book had my emotions in a chokehold I experienced them all from crying, to laughing, then to anger with some characters in the book. I loved the friendship Sal and Sophie had.
August 15, 2025
I’ll admit it—I’m a sucker for a forbidden romance, and if it’s got the teacher × student trope? I’m already intrigued. So when I picked up Muse, I was curious but went in with no real expectations, especially since it’s a debut.
And honestly? I’m glad I did, because this turned out to be a good, quick read that kept me hooked.
The story kicks off with Sophie meeting a mysterious stranger on a night out—there’s chemistry, sparks, the whole deal. No names. Just vibes. But plot twist? He ends up being her new English teacher, Mr. Hayes.
And honestly? I’m glad I did, because this turned out to be a good, quick read that kept me hooked.
The story kicks off with Sophie meeting a mysterious stranger on a night out—there’s chemistry, sparks, the whole deal. No names. Just vibes. But plot twist? He ends up being her new English teacher, Mr. Hayes.
August 28, 2025
I will be forever grateful to Love Notes PR and Isla for allowing me to arc read this book.
If you were an Ezria stan while watching Pretty Little Liars, this book is for you. Girl (18yo) meets older guy in bar, but before they can exchange names or numbers, gets pulled away… Then finds out he’s her new teacher—in high school, making their connection forbidden. Cue hateful, judgy parents, who make her life a living hell. Will their relationship survive 3 more months of high school? Read it to find out.
I honestly can’t explain why, but this book has a hold on me like no other. Maybe because I resonated with so much in the story? Or maybe because this book is a masterpiece. It left me with a broken heart and so much anger, especially when the other shoe dropped… I’m an emotional mess after reading it, but I wouldn’t have it any other way!t
If you were an Ezria stan while watching Pretty Little Liars, this book is for you. Girl (18yo) meets older guy in bar, but before they can exchange names or numbers, gets pulled away… Then finds out he’s her new teacher—in high school, making their connection forbidden. Cue hateful, judgy parents, who make her life a living hell. Will their relationship survive 3 more months of high school? Read it to find out.
I honestly can’t explain why, but this book has a hold on me like no other. Maybe because I resonated with so much in the story? Or maybe because this book is a masterpiece. It left me with a broken heart and so much anger, especially when the other shoe dropped… I’m an emotional mess after reading it, but I wouldn’t have it any other way!t
October 26, 2025
This story follows Sophie and Theo. One night, after being invited by her best friend to a bar to watch a band play, Sophie finds herself sitting alone when a gentleman approaches her. They hit it off, but no names are exchanged. Fast forward and its four months before college begins Sophie walks into class to discover her new teacher is none other than the man she hasn’t been able to stop thinking about from that night at the bar. Is he worth the risk?
This was a good read. I enjoyed the storyline, but I wish it had been executed a little differently, as I was left with quite a few questions. I did enjoy Sophie and Theo’s chemistry the sneaking around is always delicious. The spice was great, and I loved the tension between Sal and Jace, which I assume will carry into the next book.
Now, let’s dive into my struggles. First off, the parents why are they so horrible to Sophie? I really don’t understand. There was no backstory, it just happened, and I would have liked to see a resolution or at least a conversation about it, but it never came. As for Theo, I liked him at first. He started out mature, but then his character shifted into being wrapped around Sophie’s finger, with corny lines and mugs. Did he resign just in case? What happened to his house after he packed up and left? And since he bought the apartment, what job is he doing now?
Regarding Sophie, how did her parents so easily let her go to college? I thought they would have flipped, but she just… went. When the incident with Cole happened, she didn’t stick up for herself or even try to tell her mum because she immediately assumed she’d side with Cole. Personally, I would have liked to see more of an argument there. Also, what happened to her phone at the end? Why didn’t she attempt to contact Theo? I know she was upset, but in her shoes, I think I would have tried at least once. If he ignored her, fine, but the lack of effort felt odd especially considering how things ended.
Overall, this was still an enjoyable read, but I’m left with a lot of unanswered questions that keep circling in my mind.
Genre/Type: Adult Romance 18+
APK: Kindle ARC
Pages: 318
Rating: 🌟🌟🌟
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Series or Standalone: Book One In The Forbidden Hearts Romance Series
Tropes or Themes: Forbidden, Age Gap (17), Student Teacher, Close Proximity, Sneaking Around, FMC Artist, MMC Teacher, Family Drama, Grief, Loss, Drug Use, Sexual Content, Oral Scenes and Kitchen Scene.
Check Triggers ⚠️ 💫
All Round Romance Reader
Sienasummerrreads 💕📚
TikTok | Instagram | Goodreads | StoryGraph | Fable | Everand | Amazon | Audible Reviews 💫
This was a good read. I enjoyed the storyline, but I wish it had been executed a little differently, as I was left with quite a few questions. I did enjoy Sophie and Theo’s chemistry the sneaking around is always delicious. The spice was great, and I loved the tension between Sal and Jace, which I assume will carry into the next book.
Now, let’s dive into my struggles. First off, the parents why are they so horrible to Sophie? I really don’t understand. There was no backstory, it just happened, and I would have liked to see a resolution or at least a conversation about it, but it never came. As for Theo, I liked him at first. He started out mature, but then his character shifted into being wrapped around Sophie’s finger, with corny lines and mugs. Did he resign just in case? What happened to his house after he packed up and left? And since he bought the apartment, what job is he doing now?
Regarding Sophie, how did her parents so easily let her go to college? I thought they would have flipped, but she just… went. When the incident with Cole happened, she didn’t stick up for herself or even try to tell her mum because she immediately assumed she’d side with Cole. Personally, I would have liked to see more of an argument there. Also, what happened to her phone at the end? Why didn’t she attempt to contact Theo? I know she was upset, but in her shoes, I think I would have tried at least once. If he ignored her, fine, but the lack of effort felt odd especially considering how things ended.
Overall, this was still an enjoyable read, but I’m left with a lot of unanswered questions that keep circling in my mind.
Genre/Type: Adult Romance 18+
APK: Kindle ARC
Pages: 318
Rating: 🌟🌟🌟
Spice: 🌶️🌶️
Series or Standalone: Book One In The Forbidden Hearts Romance Series
Tropes or Themes: Forbidden, Age Gap (17), Student Teacher, Close Proximity, Sneaking Around, FMC Artist, MMC Teacher, Family Drama, Grief, Loss, Drug Use, Sexual Content, Oral Scenes and Kitchen Scene.
Check Triggers ⚠️ 💫
All Round Romance Reader
Sienasummerrreads 💕📚
TikTok | Instagram | Goodreads | StoryGraph | Fable | Everand | Amazon | Audible Reviews 💫
June 7, 2025
This book has my whole heart. I laughed, I cried, I wanted to jump into the book and put hands on certain characters.
Muse was beautifully written and made me feel all of the emotions. Isla was able to bring out so many reactions and feelings while reading. I didn’t want to put my book down.
The passion and chemistry between the Sophie and Theo was undeniable. They were drawn to one another like two half’s of a whole. My absolute favourite though was a supporting character, my girl Sal.
The friendship Isla portrayed with Sophie and Sal is one some women only dream of finding. Supportive, uplifting and the definition of a true ride or die friendship.
I’m so excited to see what else Isla writes and my hopes are high for a continuation of the forbidden hearts romances.🖤
Muse was beautifully written and made me feel all of the emotions. Isla was able to bring out so many reactions and feelings while reading. I didn’t want to put my book down.
The passion and chemistry between the Sophie and Theo was undeniable. They were drawn to one another like two half’s of a whole. My absolute favourite though was a supporting character, my girl Sal.
The friendship Isla portrayed with Sophie and Sal is one some women only dream of finding. Supportive, uplifting and the definition of a true ride or die friendship.
I’m so excited to see what else Isla writes and my hopes are high for a continuation of the forbidden hearts romances.🖤
September 10, 2025
"𝚂𝙷𝙴 𝙳𝙾𝙴𝚂𝙽'𝚃 𝙺𝙽𝙾𝚆 𝙸𝚃 𝚈𝙴𝚃, 𝙱𝚄𝚃 𝙸'𝙼 𝙰𝙱𝙾𝚄𝚃 𝚃𝙾 𝚁𝚄𝙸𝙽 𝙷𝙴𝚁 𝙵𝙾𝚁 𝙰𝙽𝚈𝙾𝙽𝙴 𝙴𝙻𝚂𝙴. 𝚂𝙷𝙴'𝚂 𝙶𝙾𝙸𝙽𝙶 𝚃𝙾 𝙱𝙴 𝙼𝙸𝙽𝙴."
We are back with another new author and a debut novel!! I always get so excited when someone new pops up...and I especially get excited when they are writing something my dark little heart loves like forbidden dark romances. This book was definitely a fun read...with some good twists and turns....but I will warn you now...it reads like a wattpad fan fic...which...IS FINE...some of those are FIRE...and if you are into it, then go for it! But I'm just throwing it out there...it's wattpad style.
Sophie is our high school FMC who is out with friends for a fun night on the town when she meets a mysterious stranger...sparks fly and the connection is undeniable...but before things can get good, her friends drag her away. Months later, shes starting her senior year and her jaw drops when she comes face to face with her mysterious stranger once again...only this time his name is Theo Hayes and he is her new English teacher.
Theo is our MMC...broody...mysterious and all things delicious and devious that we love...when he sees Sophie he is both excited and angry...the woman who stole his attention that night and left before he could get her name is now sitting in his class as his student...this has WRONG written all over it and he is not going to risk his career for some high school girl...or is he?
The tension between these two is palpable...theres a lot of...we shouldn't but I can't stay away...back and forth laced with intense anger...but the anger felt misplaced. It seemed like there was a lot of drama for dramas sake with no real purpose. What are we even angry about? Every chapter it seemed like these two were going for the jugular with no real reason...if fighting was an olympic sport, these two would win gold.
Sophie...she grated my nerves in a way that made my eye twitch. She was so immature...and yes...I know shes in high school...I GET IT...but she was acting like she was in grade school and wanted to throw a fit because she wasn't getting what she wanted. Stomping her feet and crossing her arms. I wanted to yoink her by the ponytail and shake her...it was infuriating...
Theo was a patient man but also...how devoid of human attention are you that this girl...because thats what she is...A GIRL...is what you want and need. Like sir...please...I feel a tension headache coming on just reading their interactions...
There was a lot that I feel was missing...most importantly was the back story on Sophies family. They are TERRIBLE...I can see why Sophie was the way she was (sort of) because of how awful and abusive her family was. They HATED her...loathed her...but heres the thing...WHY??? We never know where this hate and resentment comes from...and I feel like there was a deeper story there that we never even get a hint of. The same thing with Theo...he was raised by an amazing family...yet this man turned out to be the most surely man ever. What happened that caused him to be so angry and against the world? We may never know...but also....I really want to know 👀
As if you couldn't see it coming, these two have a massive breakup...and honestly...it was much needed...Sophie wasn't mature enough to handle a relationship that complicated and that tension filled. So I wasn't all that upset when they broke up...but we spent entirely WAY TOO MUCH TIME discussing their being broken up...like the majority of the book was about it...and the end when they finally make their way back together...we ran through that like our panties were on fire...WHY??? I think it would have been amazing to see how Sophie managed and grew during college...I wanted to see her character growth and see how they both grew to be better no just from themselves but for each other...but we never get it.
In my opinion...not so taboo because all they did was fight all the time...and there wasn't really much darkness. It had the bones of something good, but followed the predictability of a taboo student x teacher romance playbook...which is fine as long as you give it your own twist. It just felt generic to me. Again...very wattpady..but if that's your thing then you will definitely love this one.
Thank you to Isla Starling and LoveNotes PR for the opportunity to ARC read this book.
📚Taboo Romance
🩷Student x Teacher
📚Forced Proximity
🩷High School Student FMC
📚English Teacher MMC
🩷Angst / Tension
📚Age Gap
🩷Toxic Family
📚Forbidden
🩷Emotional Read
📚Secrets
🩷3rd Act Breakup
📚Dual POV
🩷HFN
We are back with another new author and a debut novel!! I always get so excited when someone new pops up...and I especially get excited when they are writing something my dark little heart loves like forbidden dark romances. This book was definitely a fun read...with some good twists and turns....but I will warn you now...it reads like a wattpad fan fic...which...IS FINE...some of those are FIRE...and if you are into it, then go for it! But I'm just throwing it out there...it's wattpad style.
Sophie is our high school FMC who is out with friends for a fun night on the town when she meets a mysterious stranger...sparks fly and the connection is undeniable...but before things can get good, her friends drag her away. Months later, shes starting her senior year and her jaw drops when she comes face to face with her mysterious stranger once again...only this time his name is Theo Hayes and he is her new English teacher.
Theo is our MMC...broody...mysterious and all things delicious and devious that we love...when he sees Sophie he is both excited and angry...the woman who stole his attention that night and left before he could get her name is now sitting in his class as his student...this has WRONG written all over it and he is not going to risk his career for some high school girl...or is he?
The tension between these two is palpable...theres a lot of...we shouldn't but I can't stay away...back and forth laced with intense anger...but the anger felt misplaced. It seemed like there was a lot of drama for dramas sake with no real purpose. What are we even angry about? Every chapter it seemed like these two were going for the jugular with no real reason...if fighting was an olympic sport, these two would win gold.
Sophie...she grated my nerves in a way that made my eye twitch. She was so immature...and yes...I know shes in high school...I GET IT...but she was acting like she was in grade school and wanted to throw a fit because she wasn't getting what she wanted. Stomping her feet and crossing her arms. I wanted to yoink her by the ponytail and shake her...it was infuriating...
Theo was a patient man but also...how devoid of human attention are you that this girl...because thats what she is...A GIRL...is what you want and need. Like sir...please...I feel a tension headache coming on just reading their interactions...
There was a lot that I feel was missing...most importantly was the back story on Sophies family. They are TERRIBLE...I can see why Sophie was the way she was (sort of) because of how awful and abusive her family was. They HATED her...loathed her...but heres the thing...WHY??? We never know where this hate and resentment comes from...and I feel like there was a deeper story there that we never even get a hint of. The same thing with Theo...he was raised by an amazing family...yet this man turned out to be the most surely man ever. What happened that caused him to be so angry and against the world? We may never know...but also....I really want to know 👀
As if you couldn't see it coming, these two have a massive breakup...and honestly...it was much needed...Sophie wasn't mature enough to handle a relationship that complicated and that tension filled. So I wasn't all that upset when they broke up...but we spent entirely WAY TOO MUCH TIME discussing their being broken up...like the majority of the book was about it...and the end when they finally make their way back together...we ran through that like our panties were on fire...WHY??? I think it would have been amazing to see how Sophie managed and grew during college...I wanted to see her character growth and see how they both grew to be better no just from themselves but for each other...but we never get it.
In my opinion...not so taboo because all they did was fight all the time...and there wasn't really much darkness. It had the bones of something good, but followed the predictability of a taboo student x teacher romance playbook...which is fine as long as you give it your own twist. It just felt generic to me. Again...very wattpady..but if that's your thing then you will definitely love this one.
Thank you to Isla Starling and LoveNotes PR for the opportunity to ARC read this book.
📚Taboo Romance
🩷Student x Teacher
📚Forced Proximity
🩷High School Student FMC
📚English Teacher MMC
🩷Angst / Tension
📚Age Gap
🩷Toxic Family
📚Forbidden
🩷Emotional Read
📚Secrets
🩷3rd Act Breakup
📚Dual POV
🩷HFN
August 11, 2025
⭐️⭐️.5
✨Huge thank you to Isla Sterling and her team for sending me an ARC of Muse!✨
Okay, so here’s the thing—this book had had me in the first couple of chapters. Like, genuinely. The opening was solid. We had intrigue, we had chemistry, we had a setup that made me think, ohhh, this is going to be so good. Sophie and Theo’s initial encounter? Chef’s kiss. I was all in. And it wasn’t just them—I was actually getting invested in the side characters too. I thought I’d found my next addictive, can’t-put-it-down forbidden romance read.
Then… somewhere a few chapters in, the wheels started wobbling. And by the halfway point, they were rolling away completely. The dialogue between characters often felt really immature—not just in the “these are high school students” kind of way, but in the “I just unlocked my old Wattpad account from 2012” kind of way. Which is fine if that’s the vibe you’re going for…but it threw me, especially after such a promising start.
I also couldn’t help feeling like some of the plot points were there just for drama’s sake, without any actual resolution. The big one for me? Sophie’s parents. We get all this buildup showing how truly awful they are to her—like villain origin story levels of awful—but we never get an explanation why. No messy family secret, no backstory reveal, nothing. It’s just…they suck, end of story. It made their inclusion feel more like a device to make Sophie’s life extra miserable rather than a layered part of the narrative.
The forbidden romance trope is tricky to pull off because it needs to feel earned. There has to be enough tension, longing, and emotional connection to make the “this is so wrong but so right” dynamic believable. The early chapters nailed that vibe—Theo had the whole mysterious, magnetic thing going on, and Sophie’s reactions felt natural. But as the story went on, their dynamic started feeling less like slow-burn intensity and more like dramatic back-and-forth with occasional bursts of tension. I found myself more frustrated than invested.
That said, I did like the bones of the story. I think Isla Starling has a strong handle on creating atmosphere in certain scenes—the bar scene in the beginning, for example, was great at setting the tone and drawing me in. And for readers who love a slightly melodramatic, Wattpad-flavoured forbidden romance, Muse might absolutely hit the spot. It just wasn’t quite what I was hoping for after such a promising setup.
Final verdict: started as a five-star first date, ended as an “it’s not you, it’s me” breakup text.
✨Huge thank you to Isla Sterling and her team for sending me an ARC of Muse!✨
Okay, so here’s the thing—this book had had me in the first couple of chapters. Like, genuinely. The opening was solid. We had intrigue, we had chemistry, we had a setup that made me think, ohhh, this is going to be so good. Sophie and Theo’s initial encounter? Chef’s kiss. I was all in. And it wasn’t just them—I was actually getting invested in the side characters too. I thought I’d found my next addictive, can’t-put-it-down forbidden romance read.
Then… somewhere a few chapters in, the wheels started wobbling. And by the halfway point, they were rolling away completely. The dialogue between characters often felt really immature—not just in the “these are high school students” kind of way, but in the “I just unlocked my old Wattpad account from 2012” kind of way. Which is fine if that’s the vibe you’re going for…but it threw me, especially after such a promising start.
I also couldn’t help feeling like some of the plot points were there just for drama’s sake, without any actual resolution. The big one for me? Sophie’s parents. We get all this buildup showing how truly awful they are to her—like villain origin story levels of awful—but we never get an explanation why. No messy family secret, no backstory reveal, nothing. It’s just…they suck, end of story. It made their inclusion feel more like a device to make Sophie’s life extra miserable rather than a layered part of the narrative.
The forbidden romance trope is tricky to pull off because it needs to feel earned. There has to be enough tension, longing, and emotional connection to make the “this is so wrong but so right” dynamic believable. The early chapters nailed that vibe—Theo had the whole mysterious, magnetic thing going on, and Sophie’s reactions felt natural. But as the story went on, their dynamic started feeling less like slow-burn intensity and more like dramatic back-and-forth with occasional bursts of tension. I found myself more frustrated than invested.
That said, I did like the bones of the story. I think Isla Starling has a strong handle on creating atmosphere in certain scenes—the bar scene in the beginning, for example, was great at setting the tone and drawing me in. And for readers who love a slightly melodramatic, Wattpad-flavoured forbidden romance, Muse might absolutely hit the spot. It just wasn’t quite what I was hoping for after such a promising setup.
Final verdict: started as a five-star first date, ended as an “it’s not you, it’s me” breakup text.
August 24, 2025
I want to start by thanking Isla and Love Notes PR for the ARC! I’m always grateful for these amazing opportunities to support indie authors 🥰
Now, onto my review of Muse. I’m a certified taboo girlie—I’ll eat up anything with an off-limits trope (and yes, I’ve said it before, but I’ll say it again: we need more of this trope, pls). Isla’s book immediately stood out thanks to its bold student/teacher storyline.
The writing is immersive and emotionally intense. I’m not usually drawn to student/teacher romances, but this one was executed with surprising sensitivity. The age gap didn’t feel overwhelming, and the FMC never once came across as victimized. That said, I did find myself wondering if the story might’ve worked better as a college romance, and if it would’ve felt less uncomfortable. I mean, imagine her classmates graduating and realizing she’s been involved with their teacher… yikes. That’s the glaring downside of the setup. But honestly? Isla’s writing is so compelling, you forget you’re reading something that’s pushing ethical boundaries.
Now, here’s the twist: what I found myself most excited about was Sal and Jace. Isla… I need you to keep me in mind for whatever comes next because I will combust if I don’t find out what happens between them. I am the moth, and they are the flame. Give me a single paragraph about them and I’ll be content. Their chemistry was truly FELT. Step-sibling romance is my ultimate vice.
All that said, I’m keeping this spoiler-free. I’m genuinely impressed by Isla’s world-building and her fearless embrace of taboo themes. Some authors shy away from the controversial—thankfully, Isla isn’t one of them. This book made a fan out of me, and I already know Sal and Jace’s story is going to knock me out cold.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
Now, onto my review of Muse. I’m a certified taboo girlie—I’ll eat up anything with an off-limits trope (and yes, I’ve said it before, but I’ll say it again: we need more of this trope, pls). Isla’s book immediately stood out thanks to its bold student/teacher storyline.
The writing is immersive and emotionally intense. I’m not usually drawn to student/teacher romances, but this one was executed with surprising sensitivity. The age gap didn’t feel overwhelming, and the FMC never once came across as victimized. That said, I did find myself wondering if the story might’ve worked better as a college romance, and if it would’ve felt less uncomfortable. I mean, imagine her classmates graduating and realizing she’s been involved with their teacher… yikes. That’s the glaring downside of the setup. But honestly? Isla’s writing is so compelling, you forget you’re reading something that’s pushing ethical boundaries.
Now, here’s the twist: what I found myself most excited about was Sal and Jace. Isla… I need you to keep me in mind for whatever comes next because I will combust if I don’t find out what happens between them. I am the moth, and they are the flame. Give me a single paragraph about them and I’ll be content. Their chemistry was truly FELT. Step-sibling romance is my ultimate vice.
All that said, I’m keeping this spoiler-free. I’m genuinely impressed by Isla’s world-building and her fearless embrace of taboo themes. Some authors shy away from the controversial—thankfully, Isla isn’t one of them. This book made a fan out of me, and I already know Sal and Jace’s story is going to knock me out cold.
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️
August 11, 2025
Thank you Love notes pr for the arc!
I am such a sucker for teacher x student romances, so when I saw this one come up, I was applying for it.
Unfortunately, I'm going to leave this as a dnf, because of several factors.
1. The dialogue is awkward and clunky. It's not anything other than surface level. It's not believable
2. The pop culture references. There are so many of them. I also love sleep token, but I don't want to hear about another character fawning over how amazing the other person's taste is for introducing them to it.
3. The writing style is inconsistent. Not even for the different characters, but it felt like each character's tone wasn't consistent.
4. Just the FMCs whole vibe made me cringe. Sorry.
She gets assigned a writing assignment and draws the teacher's portrait instead? And turns it in? Then she keeps doing it?
And he's just blown away with how amazing she is.
5. The repetition in the writing bothers me. The taste of the FMCs lips is mentioned twice on the same page, as an example.
6. There's skipping over details in writing and it bothered me, more of a nit-pick I know. Like the shower scene. Did he go down on her while she was soapy? Did she swallow? Answers. I need answers, people 😂
I am such a sucker for teacher x student romances, so when I saw this one come up, I was applying for it.
Unfortunately, I'm going to leave this as a dnf, because of several factors.
1. The dialogue is awkward and clunky. It's not anything other than surface level. It's not believable
2. The pop culture references. There are so many of them. I also love sleep token, but I don't want to hear about another character fawning over how amazing the other person's taste is for introducing them to it.
3. The writing style is inconsistent. Not even for the different characters, but it felt like each character's tone wasn't consistent.
4. Just the FMCs whole vibe made me cringe. Sorry.
She gets assigned a writing assignment and draws the teacher's portrait instead? And turns it in? Then she keeps doing it?
And he's just blown away with how amazing she is.
5. The repetition in the writing bothers me. The taste of the FMCs lips is mentioned twice on the same page, as an example.
6. There's skipping over details in writing and it bothered me, more of a nit-pick I know. Like the shower scene. Did he go down on her while she was soapy? Did she swallow? Answers. I need answers, people 😂
August 12, 2025
Muse follows Sophie, who one night meets a gorgeous, older stranger. They dance, laugh, and share an instant spark… but no names. Fast-forward to the start of the school year, and guess who walks into her classroom? Mr. Theo Hayes, her mystery man, now her teacher. He’s nearly twice her age, but the connection is undeniable. What begins as a secret reconnection quickly spirals into something that could cost them everything…
Was it the best book I’ve ever read? No. But for a debut, I genuinely enjoyed it. The friendship between Sophie and her best friend Sal was a highlight. Their bond was so heartfelt and beautifully written. I did wish for more depth in certain areas: the age gap and student-teacher dynamic are barely addressed, which felt like a missed opportunity. Theo’s grief over his parents is mentioned but not explored, and Sophie’s strained relationship with her own parents is touched on but never really unpacked.
Still, I had a good time reading it, and I’m very intrigued by what’s next. I have a feeling book two might center around Sal and her stepbrother Jace — and I’m already here for it. 👀💫
Was it the best book I’ve ever read? No. But for a debut, I genuinely enjoyed it. The friendship between Sophie and her best friend Sal was a highlight. Their bond was so heartfelt and beautifully written. I did wish for more depth in certain areas: the age gap and student-teacher dynamic are barely addressed, which felt like a missed opportunity. Theo’s grief over his parents is mentioned but not explored, and Sophie’s strained relationship with her own parents is touched on but never really unpacked.
Still, I had a good time reading it, and I’m very intrigued by what’s next. I have a feeling book two might center around Sal and her stepbrother Jace — and I’m already here for it. 👀💫
September 4, 2025
This has some great build up to it, I like the trope and all. The connection of the main characters were there, definitely magnetic from the start. Their tension on every encounter can light up the scenes immediately. However, it keeps building up and making you excited then it would just land downhill. It was a roller coaster, and it started to feel a little disappointing.
Sophie and Sal (bestfriend) had more interactions than Theo. As a reader, which relationship does the author prioritizing and focusing here? There were some scenes as well that the flow was kind of confusing. It would say one thing, then it was different all of a sudden. There were information that were left out and suddenly popping up in the next chapter.
Towards the end, it focused more on their separation than the building those connections between characters, development seems rush and all over the place. However, this has some great potential, just need some couple of improvements.
Sophie and Sal (bestfriend) had more interactions than Theo. As a reader, which relationship does the author prioritizing and focusing here? There were some scenes as well that the flow was kind of confusing. It would say one thing, then it was different all of a sudden. There were information that were left out and suddenly popping up in the next chapter.
Towards the end, it focused more on their separation than the building those connections between characters, development seems rush and all over the place. However, this has some great potential, just need some couple of improvements.
October 7, 2025
Sophie never imagined she would see the stranger she met months ago, ever again. Wishful thinking has her mind reeling over a mysterious dark-haired man and why she didn’t even think to get a name. But it’s her first day of senior year and her future feels within reach, but so is that handsome stranger, Mr. Hayes. Her English teacher.
Theo thought returning to his childhood home would offer some stability and a quiet place to heal from heartache. Teaching at the high school wasn’t what he had planned for himself, but neither was seeing the girl he had hoped to find from the bar 4 months ago sitting in his classroom as a student. His attraction, the subtle touches and their almost kiss can’t be anything more than that now, almost.
Isla had me squealing and kicking my feet reading Sophie and Theo’s story. I am a sucker for an age gap, and this author’s debut novel really packed in all of the angst and slow burn moments!! I love the connection that continues to develop between Sophie and Theo after lines are drawn.
As all girls should, Sophie has that one ride or die best friend who is there for her just as equally as she is. So not only are you reading Theo and Sophie’s love story, you get friends that are family, ride or die besties that like to smoke a little pot and someone to pick up the pieces after the heartbreak.
Theo thought returning to his childhood home would offer some stability and a quiet place to heal from heartache. Teaching at the high school wasn’t what he had planned for himself, but neither was seeing the girl he had hoped to find from the bar 4 months ago sitting in his classroom as a student. His attraction, the subtle touches and their almost kiss can’t be anything more than that now, almost.
Isla had me squealing and kicking my feet reading Sophie and Theo’s story. I am a sucker for an age gap, and this author’s debut novel really packed in all of the angst and slow burn moments!! I love the connection that continues to develop between Sophie and Theo after lines are drawn.
As all girls should, Sophie has that one ride or die best friend who is there for her just as equally as she is. So not only are you reading Theo and Sophie’s love story, you get friends that are family, ride or die besties that like to smoke a little pot and someone to pick up the pieces after the heartbreak.
August 2, 2025
I devoured Muse in one sitting because I clearly have a weakness for forbidden tension, emotionally guarded English teachers, and strong-willed women who know what they want—even when they’re told they shouldn’t. Add in a connection that screams it was always you from the very first chapter, and I was hooked.
Sophie Wilson and Theo Hayes aren’t just navigating rules—they’re unraveling grief, guilt, and a connection that refuses to fade. He sees her in a way no one else does, and she just might be the one to remind him what it feels like to hope again. Together, they’re healing, aching, yearning—and yes, doing it all with the kind of chemistry that practically fogs up the page.
What to expect:
🤭 Forbidden
🕰️ Age Gap
📚 Student x Teacher
⏳ Will they, Won’t they
🤫 Secrets
🌶️ Spice
🧡 Found Family
💔 Healing from the past
💘 “It was always you” vibes
Sophie Wilson and Theo Hayes aren’t just navigating rules—they’re unraveling grief, guilt, and a connection that refuses to fade. He sees her in a way no one else does, and she just might be the one to remind him what it feels like to hope again. Together, they’re healing, aching, yearning—and yes, doing it all with the kind of chemistry that practically fogs up the page.
What to expect:
🤭 Forbidden
🕰️ Age Gap
📚 Student x Teacher
⏳ Will they, Won’t they
🤫 Secrets
🌶️ Spice
🧡 Found Family
💔 Healing from the past
💘 “It was always you” vibes
August 4, 2025
Seriously Isla, how is this your debut book 😍 I am in awe over this story, you have knocked it out of the park.
You gave us an age gap, a forbidden professor x student and so much angst I was dying.
Sophie and Theo were amazing characters with sexual chemistry that was electric. Every interaction I was on the edge of my seat.
We have two seriously strong characters who know what it’s like to be beaten down in life but have survived. They were exactly what the other needed and it was such a beautiful story.
There is a third act breakup and this book is very angsty so be aware going into it.
Thank you to Isla for the ARC.
P.S Can we talk about Sal and Jace because Jesus Christ their book is going to be immense ❤️🔥
You gave us an age gap, a forbidden professor x student and so much angst I was dying.
Sophie and Theo were amazing characters with sexual chemistry that was electric. Every interaction I was on the edge of my seat.
We have two seriously strong characters who know what it’s like to be beaten down in life but have survived. They were exactly what the other needed and it was such a beautiful story.
There is a third act breakup and this book is very angsty so be aware going into it.
Thank you to Isla for the ARC.
P.S Can we talk about Sal and Jace because Jesus Christ their book is going to be immense ❤️🔥
August 2, 2025
Age gap romances are my absolute fav, and this one totally delivered! The tension between the FMC and MMC was sweet, spicy, and sooo satisfying. There was just enough steam to keep things hot without overdoing it. Her home life was pretty sad, but her best friend was such a bright spot—fun, loyal, and always in her corner. I’m not a fan of third act breakups, but this one gave the FMC room to grow. & the sweet HEA made it all worth it. 🩷
August 10, 2025
Pensei que gostaria bem mais do que gostei, na verdade.
Professor x aluna é uma das tropes que mais gosto, juntamente com o age gap.
Mas, honestamente, este livro não me conquistou. Acho que não gostei da diferença de idade deles juntamente com as atitudes que cada um dia.
Achei muito rápido a mudança de "não podemos fazer isto", para "fuck it".
No entanto, gostei muito da escrita da autora, além da irmã da Sophie.
Professor x aluna é uma das tropes que mais gosto, juntamente com o age gap.
Mas, honestamente, este livro não me conquistou. Acho que não gostei da diferença de idade deles juntamente com as atitudes que cada um dia.
Achei muito rápido a mudança de "não podemos fazer isto", para "fuck it".
No entanto, gostei muito da escrita da autora, além da irmã da Sophie.
August 26, 2025
I loved their chemistry and genuine connection, the tension of all their forbidden interactions, and Theo's protectiveness. I also loved the way he encouraged her art and passions, and tried to protect her from her trouble.
I felt really immersed in the story, and invested in their romance.
I liked Sophie's friendship with Sal and how they supported each other, and really despised Sophie's family and all their hostility.
This was a sweet forbidden love story.
I felt really immersed in the story, and invested in their romance.
I liked Sophie's friendship with Sal and how they supported each other, and really despised Sophie's family and all their hostility.
This was a sweet forbidden love story.
September 19, 2025
I enjoyed this one and did find the characters interesting. I do feel like it was rushed at points, which made me then feel like I couldn't connect with the characters or really get fully hooked into their story. I do feel like they balanced each other nicely and I was happy that they got the ending they deserved. I'm still intrigued to explore more of the characters and dive deeper into their story as I think there are some interesting ones to come.
September 12, 2025
dnf, I read better wattpad story
September 26, 2025
Devoured this eArc in less than 24 hours. I couldn't put it down. Theo and Sophie stole a piece of my heart. I know many have thier doubts with the teacher x student trope but honestly it was super well executed here. I liked the ending because it was different than usual and I wish we could have had a glimpse in their life some years later.
Poor Sophie was treated so badly by her family, and obviously didn't deserve any of that, but Theo 🤩 I think he healed some of my own wounds too.
thank you for the eArc LoveNotesPr
Poor Sophie was treated so badly by her family, and obviously didn't deserve any of that, but Theo 🤩 I think he healed some of my own wounds too.
thank you for the eArc LoveNotesPr
August 26, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️🌶️🌶️
This book has me in tears. It was so beautifully written. I genuinely couldn’t put this book down. I’m also very excited to read Sal and Jace’s story.
I really understood and resonated with Sophie, especially her family life which made me love her. Most of the chapters were in her POV and a lot of the times, I hate when authors do that bc a lot of FMCS arw insufferable but thank god, Sophie was likeable.
I wish we could’ve seen more of Theo. Like I said before, most of the chapters are in Sophies POV, so we really don’t know anything about Theo other than the fact that he wants to be a writer and that his parents died.
The plot was entertaining, it was your typical ‘teacher x student’ book, but I didn’t find it to be repetitive. The beginning really reminded me of Pretty Little Liars, specifically Aria and Ezra so if you liked them, I’d suggest you give this book a read. There were some parts that had me confused, like where Sophie puts her phone in the glove compartment in her car then storms inside her house without it and never goes back out to get it, but suddenly when she wakes up , it was right next to her?? Sure, maybe a family member could’ve brought it in, but none of her family members knew her phone was in there, and trust me, none of her family members would do that. Also there were details that we really don’t need, like how Theo puts garlic powder, salt, and pepper on his eggs. Like it was pointless but these things weren’t so constant to the point where they drove me insane. Also, Sal and Sophie really seemed like current day, high school students. They weren’t saying a bunch of “tiktok slang” like most millennials believe teens do (basically like the ginny and georgia dialogue) but there were little things that reminded me of teenagers that just seemed so real to me.
Thank you so much to Love Notes PR and to Isla Starling, I’m so grateful to be an ARC reviewer on your first book!!
Here’s a few quotes that stood out to me:
“I wouldn't want to be the reason you get in trouble. I hesitate, just a fraction of a second too long. And then, like an idiot, I say, "I mean... wouldn't mind that." Silence.
I die a little inside. Then.. A slow grin. Dimples. Kill me now. I turn on my heels and bolt, leaving my dignity on the floor by his feet.”
“You see me," I whisper, almost without meaning to. “I have since the first night
we met."
“I could fall for him, I accept that truth in this moment. So easily, so deeply. He's going to steal my heart.”
“The truth is, Sophie isn't just some girl I hooked up with, some passing fling to kill time until something easier came along. She's it. She's the fucking sun and I'm just a man stupid enough to think I could keep orbiting her without burning up completely.”
"I'm falling in love with you, Sophie," he says, almost like he can't believe it himself. "And yeah, it's too soon. And yeah, you're my student, and yeah, the world will lose its fucking mind if they ever find out. But I don't give a damn about any of it."
“Theo: Wish you didn't have to leave. Now what am I supposed to do all day?
I chuckle, rolling my eyes.
Sophie: I'm sure you'll find some way way to keep yourself entertained.
Theo: Sure, but nothing is as
entertaining as you.”
🌶️🌶️🌶️
This book has me in tears. It was so beautifully written. I genuinely couldn’t put this book down. I’m also very excited to read Sal and Jace’s story.
I really understood and resonated with Sophie, especially her family life which made me love her. Most of the chapters were in her POV and a lot of the times, I hate when authors do that bc a lot of FMCS arw insufferable but thank god, Sophie was likeable.
I wish we could’ve seen more of Theo. Like I said before, most of the chapters are in Sophies POV, so we really don’t know anything about Theo other than the fact that he wants to be a writer and that his parents died.
The plot was entertaining, it was your typical ‘teacher x student’ book, but I didn’t find it to be repetitive. The beginning really reminded me of Pretty Little Liars, specifically Aria and Ezra so if you liked them, I’d suggest you give this book a read. There were some parts that had me confused, like where Sophie puts her phone in the glove compartment in her car then storms inside her house without it and never goes back out to get it, but suddenly when she wakes up , it was right next to her?? Sure, maybe a family member could’ve brought it in, but none of her family members knew her phone was in there, and trust me, none of her family members would do that. Also there were details that we really don’t need, like how Theo puts garlic powder, salt, and pepper on his eggs. Like it was pointless but these things weren’t so constant to the point where they drove me insane. Also, Sal and Sophie really seemed like current day, high school students. They weren’t saying a bunch of “tiktok slang” like most millennials believe teens do (basically like the ginny and georgia dialogue) but there were little things that reminded me of teenagers that just seemed so real to me.
Thank you so much to Love Notes PR and to Isla Starling, I’m so grateful to be an ARC reviewer on your first book!!
Here’s a few quotes that stood out to me:
“I wouldn't want to be the reason you get in trouble. I hesitate, just a fraction of a second too long. And then, like an idiot, I say, "I mean... wouldn't mind that." Silence.
I die a little inside. Then.. A slow grin. Dimples. Kill me now. I turn on my heels and bolt, leaving my dignity on the floor by his feet.”
“You see me," I whisper, almost without meaning to. “I have since the first night
we met."
“I could fall for him, I accept that truth in this moment. So easily, so deeply. He's going to steal my heart.”
“The truth is, Sophie isn't just some girl I hooked up with, some passing fling to kill time until something easier came along. She's it. She's the fucking sun and I'm just a man stupid enough to think I could keep orbiting her without burning up completely.”
"I'm falling in love with you, Sophie," he says, almost like he can't believe it himself. "And yeah, it's too soon. And yeah, you're my student, and yeah, the world will lose its fucking mind if they ever find out. But I don't give a damn about any of it."
“Theo: Wish you didn't have to leave. Now what am I supposed to do all day?
I chuckle, rolling my eyes.
Sophie: I'm sure you'll find some way way to keep yourself entertained.
Theo: Sure, but nothing is as
entertaining as you.”
Displaying 1 - 30 of 204 reviews