CN. Religious Abuse, Execution, Torture, Stoning, Crucifiction, Self Mutilation (Glossectomy), Child Death
I received an ARC through Book Sirens for an honest review.
The cover, title, and description all had me instantly intrigued in this dark fantasy novella. I have not read the novel this is a prequel to and this was my first experience with this author.
The story follows a village healer who is granted prophetic visions from the eponymous orchard, the Whispergrove, and the tragedy that leads him into an ominous symbiosis with the ancient trees.
I feel incredibly conflicted and powerfully ambivalent about this novella because at times the writing was sublimely lyrical and poetic and vivid, but then it would feel incredibly overwrought and unnecessarily verbose.
The prophetic dream sequence that the novella opens with is opulent and foreboding and absolutely packed with deliciously descriptive language, but there was something about the use of similes that felt a little strange to me. The tragic and violent events were conveyed with a visceral and distressing detail (complimentary). I did find them incredibly depressing to read, but that's on me.
The real issue for me came in the third and final part in which the devastated healer undergoes an ordeal and metamorphosis. Something about the repetitive and what read to me as overly descriptive and almost self-indulgent prose made me feel increasingly detached from the experience of the Silent One. I feel awful saying this, but it became a real struggle to finish it.
I think my AuDHD, personal preferences, and the uncanny valley of this, on paper, being so unbelievably my sort of thing came together to spoil my experience of this novella.
I cannot stress how beautiful and well crafted I found some of the writing and I could definitely see this being far more appealing to other readers. I also think a great audiobook would really make this style of writing sing.