What do you think?
Rate this book
Rhona MacLeod #19
The Dead and the Dying
'One of the most satisfying characters in modern crime fiction' - Daily Mail
An ancient grave. A modern evil. The Dead and the Dying is a pulse-pounding instalment in the Rhona MacLeod series, perfect for fans of Ian Rankin, Martina Cole and Silent Witness.
In the dim morning light, Orkney’s Skaill Bay is the backdrop for a calamity of nature’s making. When forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod joins the rescue efforts as a volunteer, she uncovers more than she bargained a human skeleton entombed in a stone crypt.
The grave is believed to hail from the Viking Age, but Rhona's analysis of the content points to more recent and sinister evil. And a shadow is thrown over the investigation when the skeleton is finally identified – and unsettling connections emerge between the victim and the very people trying to solve.
As forensic clues lead Rhona to a second, horrifying discovery, the question how many more secrets are concealed in the sand?
'Lin Anderson is one of Scotland’s national treasures' - Stuart MacBride, author of the Logan McRae series
'The best Scottish crime series since Rebus' - Daily Record
Readers love Lin
'This series just keeps getting better'
'I was totally glued the whole way through'
'Atmospheric, descriptive, engrossing'
An ancient grave. A modern evil. The Dead and the Dying is a pulse-pounding instalment in the Rhona MacLeod series, perfect for fans of Ian Rankin, Martina Cole and Silent Witness.
In the dim morning light, Orkney’s Skaill Bay is the backdrop for a calamity of nature’s making. When forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod joins the rescue efforts as a volunteer, she uncovers more than she bargained a human skeleton entombed in a stone crypt.
The grave is believed to hail from the Viking Age, but Rhona's analysis of the content points to more recent and sinister evil. And a shadow is thrown over the investigation when the skeleton is finally identified – and unsettling connections emerge between the victim and the very people trying to solve.
As forensic clues lead Rhona to a second, horrifying discovery, the question how many more secrets are concealed in the sand?
'Lin Anderson is one of Scotland’s national treasures' - Stuart MacBride, author of the Logan McRae series
'The best Scottish crime series since Rebus' - Daily Record
Readers love Lin
'This series just keeps getting better'
'I was totally glued the whole way through'
'Atmospheric, descriptive, engrossing'
380 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 19, 2025
1 person is currently reading
64 people want to read
About the author
Lin Anderson
73 books385 followersLin Anderson was born in Greenock of Scottish and Irish parents. A graduate of both Glasgow and Edinburgh Universities, she has lived in many different parts of Scotland and also spent five years working in the African bush. A teacher of Mathematics and Computing, she began her writing career four years ago. Her first film, Small Love, which was broadcast on STV, was nominated for TAPS writer of the year award 2001. Her African short stories have been published in the 10th Anniversary Macallan collection and broadcast on BBC Radio Four.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
August 18, 2025
Rhona MacLeod is back and this time she’s in the Orkney Islands, where I live.
A pod of pilot whales face difficultly in Skaill Bay and volunteers are desperately trying to save them.
When digging a grave for the dead newborn whale, skeletal remains are discovered in a cist grave. The body is positioned in a way that suggest a Viking burial, and when a Viking torc bracelet is discovered, it further strengthens that argument.
However, Rhona MacLeod, a forensic scientist from Glasgow, is dubious.
Further tests reveal that the body is of a post pubescent male and it’s been in the ground for around 20 years.
DI Erling Flett, Orkney “born and bred”, thinks he may know who victim was. What’s his connection to the case?
Then, DS McNab lands in Orkney from Glasgow and he isn’t too happy about it…
I just love Lin Anderson’s books. I’ve been a huge fan of Rhona MacLeod ever since I’ve read Driftnet, the first book in the series. The books are always throughly well researched, and you can expect a great deal of happenings.
I loved how in this book, sand particles has furthered the investigation. Who knew that the composition of sand can differ from beach to beach?
The author perfectly captured the essence of the island community and what it can be like: the gossip mill and everyone knowing your business. I laughed when the temporary traffic lights in Finstown were mentioned – I forgot about them. They were a real pain at the time!
Overall, this is a great book with a compelling plot that will keep you guessing all the way to the end. I definitely recommend it.
A pod of pilot whales face difficultly in Skaill Bay and volunteers are desperately trying to save them.
When digging a grave for the dead newborn whale, skeletal remains are discovered in a cist grave. The body is positioned in a way that suggest a Viking burial, and when a Viking torc bracelet is discovered, it further strengthens that argument.
However, Rhona MacLeod, a forensic scientist from Glasgow, is dubious.
Further tests reveal that the body is of a post pubescent male and it’s been in the ground for around 20 years.
DI Erling Flett, Orkney “born and bred”, thinks he may know who victim was. What’s his connection to the case?
Then, DS McNab lands in Orkney from Glasgow and he isn’t too happy about it…
I just love Lin Anderson’s books. I’ve been a huge fan of Rhona MacLeod ever since I’ve read Driftnet, the first book in the series. The books are always throughly well researched, and you can expect a great deal of happenings.
I loved how in this book, sand particles has furthered the investigation. Who knew that the composition of sand can differ from beach to beach?
The author perfectly captured the essence of the island community and what it can be like: the gossip mill and everyone knowing your business. I laughed when the temporary traffic lights in Finstown were mentioned – I forgot about them. They were a real pain at the time!
Overall, this is a great book with a compelling plot that will keep you guessing all the way to the end. I definitely recommend it.
August 29, 2025
Dr Rhonda MacLeod is back in this 19th instalment in the forensic pathologist series. This is an atmospheric thriller that kept me gripped throughout. What I also love is that each of these books can be read as stand alone stories. I’ve read a few completely out of order and it really doesn’t matter.
This story is set in Orkney, where Rhonda finds herself helping out on the beach where a pod of whales have beached. When a grave is dug for a calf whale, a Viking stone crypt is uncovered with skeletal remains. Upon investigation though, it’s clear that these remains are much fresher than initially believed. The case soon escalates as connections between the remains and the locals and team become clearer.
Rhonda is such a good central detective in this series, she’s so dedicated and human-I loved her. The police procedural aspect is done really well and balanced with beautiful atmospheric descriptions of Orkney’s landscape and community. Well paced with good psychological suspense and interesting forensic detail, it’s a real page turner. I personally really enjoyed the Viking tomb parts too.
If you enjoy series like Elly Griffiths’ Ruth Galloway, Shetland or Silent Witness, you’ll love this.
Thank you to Pan MacMillan and Random Tours for the copy to review, I really enjoyed!
This story is set in Orkney, where Rhonda finds herself helping out on the beach where a pod of whales have beached. When a grave is dug for a calf whale, a Viking stone crypt is uncovered with skeletal remains. Upon investigation though, it’s clear that these remains are much fresher than initially believed. The case soon escalates as connections between the remains and the locals and team become clearer.
Rhonda is such a good central detective in this series, she’s so dedicated and human-I loved her. The police procedural aspect is done really well and balanced with beautiful atmospheric descriptions of Orkney’s landscape and community. Well paced with good psychological suspense and interesting forensic detail, it’s a real page turner. I personally really enjoyed the Viking tomb parts too.
If you enjoy series like Elly Griffiths’ Ruth Galloway, Shetland or Silent Witness, you’ll love this.
Thank you to Pan MacMillan and Random Tours for the copy to review, I really enjoyed!
January 27, 2026
Audiobook 2.5 stars.
An OK easy listen. For me it just seemed a bit formulaic in listening to this detective one. I’ve listened to other Lin Anderson and preferred them so maybe this one was a blip.
An OK easy listen. For me it just seemed a bit formulaic in listening to this detective one. I’ve listened to other Lin Anderson and preferred them so maybe this one was a blip.
December 21, 2025
4+ stars
October 12, 2025
I'm a devoted fan of Lin Anderson's series, having enjoyed all nine books, each earning a 5-star rating. However, "The Dead and the Dying" fell short of my expectations. While Sally Armstrong's narration is usually exceptional, the substitution with Sarah Barron was a misstep. Barron's narration made it challenging for me to engage with the story, which otherwise might have held my attention.
Despite my fondness for the series, this installment felt overly long-winded, making it a laborious listen. I'm unsure whether the issue lies with the narration, the book itself, or a combination of both. Nonetheless, I hope future installments feature Sally Armstrong's narration, which has proven to be a better fit for the series.
# Recommendation:
Fans of the series might still enjoy this book, but it's a less satisfying entry. If you're particular about narration, you might want to exercise caution.
Despite my fondness for the series, this installment felt overly long-winded, making it a laborious listen. I'm unsure whether the issue lies with the narration, the book itself, or a combination of both. Nonetheless, I hope future installments feature Sally Armstrong's narration, which has proven to be a better fit for the series.
# Recommendation:
Fans of the series might still enjoy this book, but it's a less satisfying entry. If you're particular about narration, you might want to exercise caution.
December 28, 2025
*2.75 Stars*
The Dead and the Dying is the next entry in Lin Anderson's long-running Shona MacLeod mystery series, and while I really enjoyed the archaeology aspects of this novel, I wasn't overly impressed with the mystery itself. It's not that the mystery wasn't interesting, it was the way it was written as the author didn't seem to have faith in her readers and pretty much led them by the nose throughout the entire book. I am just not a fan of this way of writing as I prefer to figure things out as I read.
There wasn't a lot of character development in this book as by the nineteenth entry readers are pretty familiar with the main characters, but it would have been nice to have somewhat developed the secondary characters involved in the mystery, to fully understand the motives and the reasons behind what they did. A few weeks after reading the book, I have to look at my notes to even remember who most of the secondary characters were as they just blend into each other as they were so blandly written.
The mystery itself started out rather interesting and I did enjoy the descriptions of the archaeological evidence as opposed to the forensic evidence. But then it just went on and on with a lot of the same things beings repeated over and over again. I almost felt like the author wasn't quite sure what to do with certain characters, but still needed them to be relevant in the story, and just made up stuff to get them to certain locations. So, the overall cohesion of the book felt off and the place was definitely on the slow side, at least for me. I don't always mind a slower pace, but not when things are repeated constantly as if the reader didn't get it the first time. Even if it's a slower pace, the plot should advance and this one felt more like it was going around in circles. And when I got to the ending, then I understood why the rest of the book felt like that.
The Dead and the Dying was one of the weaker entries in this series. I thought the mystery was interesting, but the way it was told was bland and too much showing rather than letting the reader figure things out with the main characters. At this point, I'm not sure if I will read the next entry in this series. That being said, I do recommend readers read the first ten books or so as they are quite good. And if you like forensic archaeology/pathology, then they will definitely be of interest to you.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
The Dead and the Dying is the next entry in Lin Anderson's long-running Shona MacLeod mystery series, and while I really enjoyed the archaeology aspects of this novel, I wasn't overly impressed with the mystery itself. It's not that the mystery wasn't interesting, it was the way it was written as the author didn't seem to have faith in her readers and pretty much led them by the nose throughout the entire book. I am just not a fan of this way of writing as I prefer to figure things out as I read.
There wasn't a lot of character development in this book as by the nineteenth entry readers are pretty familiar with the main characters, but it would have been nice to have somewhat developed the secondary characters involved in the mystery, to fully understand the motives and the reasons behind what they did. A few weeks after reading the book, I have to look at my notes to even remember who most of the secondary characters were as they just blend into each other as they were so blandly written.
The mystery itself started out rather interesting and I did enjoy the descriptions of the archaeological evidence as opposed to the forensic evidence. But then it just went on and on with a lot of the same things beings repeated over and over again. I almost felt like the author wasn't quite sure what to do with certain characters, but still needed them to be relevant in the story, and just made up stuff to get them to certain locations. So, the overall cohesion of the book felt off and the place was definitely on the slow side, at least for me. I don't always mind a slower pace, but not when things are repeated constantly as if the reader didn't get it the first time. Even if it's a slower pace, the plot should advance and this one felt more like it was going around in circles. And when I got to the ending, then I understood why the rest of the book felt like that.
The Dead and the Dying was one of the weaker entries in this series. I thought the mystery was interesting, but the way it was told was bland and too much showing rather than letting the reader figure things out with the main characters. At this point, I'm not sure if I will read the next entry in this series. That being said, I do recommend readers read the first ten books or so as they are quite good. And if you like forensic archaeology/pathology, then they will definitely be of interest to you.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
Read
January 22, 2026Books featuring forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod, always pack that extra special something into every book. Considering it is book nineteen of the series, author Lin Anderson has certainly offered a massive tapestry of stories that have kept readers coming back for many years.
THE DEAD AND THE DYING, is prime Lin Anderson, and now we find Rhona heading to Skaill Bay, to help with rescue of a pod of whales. They cannot save many of them, so it is decided that graves are to be dug to bury those whose died. There is no way they expected to find a burial site for what may be from the Viking era. But it is obvious that the remains found at the site are not ancient, and some of the bones are likely less than a quarter-century old. And the person in question who is in the ground is not that old.
This brings others onto the scene, such as DS Michael McNab from Glasgow, to look into the body, and try finding conclusive answers. Others soon join the investigation, such as DI Erling Flett who may somehow remotely have ties to the victim. As if not to confound the issue, it is not long before another body is discovered. It is thought that somehow the two victims may be connected, causing even more crisis with the possibility that a serial killer may be on the loose.
The community is in crisis, and also almost in denial, as there is definitely a chill surfacing as there is the race to find the person or persons who was responsible for the deaths. Soon there are assumptions and connections, and with Rhona and the others trying to put their heads together for answers, people are becoming uncomfortable with the possibilities.
With the threat of more murders imminent, it becomes a race against time to find the killer and bring justice for the deceased. If you are a fan of Patricia Cornwell and her Kay Scarpetta series , you will certainly enjoy this too, as the forensic aspects of the case, really adds to the intrigue. THE DEAD AND DYING is a masterful story, and Lin Anderson scores another winner of a book for all her fans.
THE DEAD AND THE DYING, is prime Lin Anderson, and now we find Rhona heading to Skaill Bay, to help with rescue of a pod of whales. They cannot save many of them, so it is decided that graves are to be dug to bury those whose died. There is no way they expected to find a burial site for what may be from the Viking era. But it is obvious that the remains found at the site are not ancient, and some of the bones are likely less than a quarter-century old. And the person in question who is in the ground is not that old.
This brings others onto the scene, such as DS Michael McNab from Glasgow, to look into the body, and try finding conclusive answers. Others soon join the investigation, such as DI Erling Flett who may somehow remotely have ties to the victim. As if not to confound the issue, it is not long before another body is discovered. It is thought that somehow the two victims may be connected, causing even more crisis with the possibility that a serial killer may be on the loose.
The community is in crisis, and also almost in denial, as there is definitely a chill surfacing as there is the race to find the person or persons who was responsible for the deaths. Soon there are assumptions and connections, and with Rhona and the others trying to put their heads together for answers, people are becoming uncomfortable with the possibilities.
With the threat of more murders imminent, it becomes a race against time to find the killer and bring justice for the deceased. If you are a fan of Patricia Cornwell and her Kay Scarpetta series , you will certainly enjoy this too, as the forensic aspects of the case, really adds to the intrigue. THE DEAD AND DYING is a masterful story, and Lin Anderson scores another winner of a book for all her fans.
August 20, 2025
Forensic scientist Dr Rhona Macleod is just about to leave the island of Orkney when a pod of pilot whales becomes stranded on the sands at Skaill Bay on the west shore and she joins the volunteers who are trying to save them. Sadly there are only two survivors and as the other bodies are taken away, a decision is made to bury a newly born calf on the beach. The digger hits stone and soon a Viking burial cist is unearthed but the body found inside definitely died a lot more recently. DI Erling Flett and DS Jo Green from Kirkwall station start to investigate but soon rumours of an identity for the young man start to circulate. Fleet fears it could be a boy he was in sixth form with on the island and decides he has no choice but to hand over to DS Michael McNab from Glasgow. Soon a lot of old faces, including archaeologist Prof Colin Nelson, criminal psychologist Prof Magnus Pirie and Rhona are back working together on Orkney looking into a suspicious death, whilst Rhona’s assistant Chrissy McInsh makes a startling discovery back at their Glasgow lab, DS Janice Clark tries to find a missing boy’s family and investigative journalist Ava Clouston is back on the island where she grew up making connections via her true crime podcast. Then another body is found on the other side of the island, again with Viking overtones, and it looks like the killer is much closer than they realise. Can the combined efforts of all these great minds reach the truth?
Although the latest in an excellent series, it is perfectly easy to enjoy this book as a stand-alone. It’s very well written with storylines to pull the reader in and keep them glued to the pages from start to finish. The main characters are all very likable and also highly skilled in their jobs, and together they form a great team in this totally engrossing crime mystery story. One of my favourite series where I always learn something new and interesting too.
Although the latest in an excellent series, it is perfectly easy to enjoy this book as a stand-alone. It’s very well written with storylines to pull the reader in and keep them glued to the pages from start to finish. The main characters are all very likable and also highly skilled in their jobs, and together they form a great team in this totally engrossing crime mystery story. One of my favourite series where I always learn something new and interesting too.
August 25, 2025
“The Dead and the Dying” is a whopping book 19 in Lin Anderson’s forensic scientist ‘Rhona MacLeod’ series and is yet again another fabulous read which entertains from start to finish. I’ve read quite a few books now in this series and I’m never disappointed, so it’s not surprising there’s so many of them to entertain us dedicated readers.
The story commences with a sad event of whales being beached on shore, and when rescuers are called to the scene, Rhona accompanies them. Tragically, when a baby whale can’t be saved, they set to work to bury it straight away and it’s then, that what at first is thought to be an historical burial is discovered, reveals to be more recent. Thankfully Rhona is on hand to immediately take control and with her usual dedication, care and sympathy towards the victims, she ensures her usual commitment is performed.
The author has used her experience from living on Orkney herself to create an authentic and realistic setting for the story, with a true coastal ambience of the wild and remote Scottish Orkney Isles and together with the interesting Viking theme throughout, I truly felt I was there myself witnessing the events.
I like how the author keeps mainly to one plot line, which allows for a more in depth investigation but what she also excels at is her character development and the dedicated teamwork required to solve cases. I felt genuinely sad for the victims in the story, especially the families left behind and it was reassuring to know that everything was being done to find justice for them.
It goes without saying this is another five star read for me and if you haven’t discovered Lin’s fabulous forensic scientist yet, where have you been? Don’t worry though, you’ve plenty to enjoy, so put the kettle on and immerse yourself in this fantastic, police procedural thriller series.
#TheDeadAndTheDying - ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The story commences with a sad event of whales being beached on shore, and when rescuers are called to the scene, Rhona accompanies them. Tragically, when a baby whale can’t be saved, they set to work to bury it straight away and it’s then, that what at first is thought to be an historical burial is discovered, reveals to be more recent. Thankfully Rhona is on hand to immediately take control and with her usual dedication, care and sympathy towards the victims, she ensures her usual commitment is performed.
The author has used her experience from living on Orkney herself to create an authentic and realistic setting for the story, with a true coastal ambience of the wild and remote Scottish Orkney Isles and together with the interesting Viking theme throughout, I truly felt I was there myself witnessing the events.
I like how the author keeps mainly to one plot line, which allows for a more in depth investigation but what she also excels at is her character development and the dedicated teamwork required to solve cases. I felt genuinely sad for the victims in the story, especially the families left behind and it was reassuring to know that everything was being done to find justice for them.
It goes without saying this is another five star read for me and if you haven’t discovered Lin’s fabulous forensic scientist yet, where have you been? Don’t worry though, you’ve plenty to enjoy, so put the kettle on and immerse yourself in this fantastic, police procedural thriller series.
#TheDeadAndTheDying - ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
December 29, 2025
A solid entry in this series about forensic scientist Dr Rhona Macleod. It’s a decent enough read, though it had a few too many loose ends and a rushed finale that stopped me from giving it a higher score.
It’s mostly set in Orkney, where, while on a visit to the islands, Rhona discovers the buried skeleton of a young man in a Viking grave - only these remains prove to be much more recent.
DI Erling Flett and his team start to investigate, but he soon suspects the remains may be of someone he knew back in his school days.
When the remains of a second body are found soon afterwards, it turns out they may be looking for a meticulous serial killer.
It’s an intriguing premise, and there are interesting uses of technology (eg AI AI-based facial reconstruction from skulls and DNA info), vivid descriptions of the island locations and likeable and believable characters. I liked these a lot.
However, the story itself runs out of steam towards the end and lands a bit flat as we never actually come face to face with the killer in the book - they’re only ever referred to third hand. Plus, they’re consistently referred to as a meticulous planner all the way through and then do something that clearly doesn’t fit this right at the end.
There are also some odd side secondary stories that start but then don’t go anywhere. e.g. Sean’s cousin’s reason for being in Glasgow, a paternity test that sounds like it’ll be a big plot point - and then isn’t, the homophobic stepdad of the first victim.
If you’ve read the other books in the series, you’ll enjoy the characters and locations. But the plotting isn’t the tightest here, and so it wouldn’t be among my favourite reads in this series.
It’s mostly set in Orkney, where, while on a visit to the islands, Rhona discovers the buried skeleton of a young man in a Viking grave - only these remains prove to be much more recent.
DI Erling Flett and his team start to investigate, but he soon suspects the remains may be of someone he knew back in his school days.
When the remains of a second body are found soon afterwards, it turns out they may be looking for a meticulous serial killer.
It’s an intriguing premise, and there are interesting uses of technology (eg AI AI-based facial reconstruction from skulls and DNA info), vivid descriptions of the island locations and likeable and believable characters. I liked these a lot.
However, the story itself runs out of steam towards the end and lands a bit flat as we never actually come face to face with the killer in the book - they’re only ever referred to third hand. Plus, they’re consistently referred to as a meticulous planner all the way through and then do something that clearly doesn’t fit this right at the end.
There are also some odd side secondary stories that start but then don’t go anywhere. e.g. Sean’s cousin’s reason for being in Glasgow, a paternity test that sounds like it’ll be a big plot point - and then isn’t, the homophobic stepdad of the first victim.
If you’ve read the other books in the series, you’ll enjoy the characters and locations. But the plotting isn’t the tightest here, and so it wouldn’t be among my favourite reads in this series.
August 26, 2025
Another fantastic book in the Rhona Macleod series. Visiting the Orkney islands forensic scientist Rhona joins volunteers trying to save a pod of whales, and finds herself caught up in a new case.
This book sees a mix of professions working together to hunt down a killer with a connection to ancient Viking burial grounds. With well researched detail, modern crimes with historic connections and twists which make catching the killer a matter of life and death. I loved that alongside “Traditional” forensics this book introduced more bespoke and upcoming methodologies to further the investigation.
The book captured that small island charm where the whole town/community knows the business of what is going on however hard you tried to keep it contained. This is a thrilling and gripping read that takes you through the story, as a well written police procedural. Whilst this is the latest book in a series it can be read (and enjoyed) as a standalone. I found myself drawn in by each of the characters and their unique perspectives, I would certainly want them investigating a murder. The descriptive nature of the book had me immersed in the story and the history. I certainly have learnt more about Viking burials than I ever expected to.
Overall this was a really enjoyable murder mystery/ police procedural that was hard to put down. It is a slower paced book but personally I enjoyed that as there was more detail and descriptive narrative allowing me to visualise the crimes. If you a fan of Patricia Cornwell and Silent Witness then I think you will really enjoy this book and will probably find yourself reading a whole new series following the cases of Forensic scientist Rhona Macleod and other favourite reoccurring characters.
“Remember to catch a killer you have to think like one”
This book sees a mix of professions working together to hunt down a killer with a connection to ancient Viking burial grounds. With well researched detail, modern crimes with historic connections and twists which make catching the killer a matter of life and death. I loved that alongside “Traditional” forensics this book introduced more bespoke and upcoming methodologies to further the investigation.
The book captured that small island charm where the whole town/community knows the business of what is going on however hard you tried to keep it contained. This is a thrilling and gripping read that takes you through the story, as a well written police procedural. Whilst this is the latest book in a series it can be read (and enjoyed) as a standalone. I found myself drawn in by each of the characters and their unique perspectives, I would certainly want them investigating a murder. The descriptive nature of the book had me immersed in the story and the history. I certainly have learnt more about Viking burials than I ever expected to.
Overall this was a really enjoyable murder mystery/ police procedural that was hard to put down. It is a slower paced book but personally I enjoyed that as there was more detail and descriptive narrative allowing me to visualise the crimes. If you a fan of Patricia Cornwell and Silent Witness then I think you will really enjoy this book and will probably find yourself reading a whole new series following the cases of Forensic scientist Rhona Macleod and other favourite reoccurring characters.
“Remember to catch a killer you have to think like one”
August 15, 2025
Having loved Lin’s previous book, The Whispers of the Dead, I am super excited to be reviewing the next Rhona MacLeod novel.
This time round, we find ourselves on the island of Orkney, a small community where it feels like everyone knows everyone and everything about each other too. So when one morning a set of beached whales need rescuing and the dig of the rescue operation unearths a human skeleton entombed in a stone crypt, once they realise the remains are not Viking, the local police team have a murder investigation on their hands. Is the victim (or the murderer!) from their own community and how could this have happened without someone realising that someone’s gone missing?
Forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod joins the investigation and working alongside the police, the body is soon identified and it isn’t long before the forensic work suggests the location of a second burial site.
This book has all your favourite characters from previous Rhona MacLeod books but it can 100% be read as a standalone book. It reads so well, with nice length chapters and I loved seeing all the aspects of the police work come together in trying to identify the killer.
I also really enjoyed the descriptions of the island and you will get such a good feeling for what life is like in more isolated communities like Orkney as you turn the pages. With talk of rich Viking heritage and beautiful, rugged landscape, I have to say the book has actually made me want to go and visit one day.
This time round, we find ourselves on the island of Orkney, a small community where it feels like everyone knows everyone and everything about each other too. So when one morning a set of beached whales need rescuing and the dig of the rescue operation unearths a human skeleton entombed in a stone crypt, once they realise the remains are not Viking, the local police team have a murder investigation on their hands. Is the victim (or the murderer!) from their own community and how could this have happened without someone realising that someone’s gone missing?
Forensic scientist Rhona MacLeod joins the investigation and working alongside the police, the body is soon identified and it isn’t long before the forensic work suggests the location of a second burial site.
This book has all your favourite characters from previous Rhona MacLeod books but it can 100% be read as a standalone book. It reads so well, with nice length chapters and I loved seeing all the aspects of the police work come together in trying to identify the killer.
I also really enjoyed the descriptions of the island and you will get such a good feeling for what life is like in more isolated communities like Orkney as you turn the pages. With talk of rich Viking heritage and beautiful, rugged landscape, I have to say the book has actually made me want to go and visit one day.
June 29, 2025
As a biology teacher with a long-standing love of forensic thrillers, The Dead and the Dying really hit the mark for me. This latest instalment in Lin Anderson’s Rhona MacLeod series is sharp, engaging, and clearly well-researched—especially when it comes to the forensic science, which I always appreciate.
Set in the hauntingly beautiful Orkney islands, the remote setting adds a fresh and atmospheric dimension to the plot. Rhona is, as ever, a strong and compelling lead—professional but human, and deeply committed to her work. The interplay between the setting, science, and the slow unravelling of the mystery kept me turning the pages.
A solid four stars—recommended for fans of forensic crime fiction who enjoy a clever, character-led investigation with a strong sense of place. I’ll definitely be keeping up with Rhona’s next case.
Set in the hauntingly beautiful Orkney islands, the remote setting adds a fresh and atmospheric dimension to the plot. Rhona is, as ever, a strong and compelling lead—professional but human, and deeply committed to her work. The interplay between the setting, science, and the slow unravelling of the mystery kept me turning the pages.
A solid four stars—recommended for fans of forensic crime fiction who enjoy a clever, character-led investigation with a strong sense of place. I’ll definitely be keeping up with Rhona’s next case.
August 12, 2025
A really good read. Dr Rhona MacLeod is visiting Orkney, when a pod of whales beaches. Unfortunately, despite many willing helper only two whales are refloated, of those left one is just a newborn calf and it is decided to bury the calf on the shore. Whilst digging a small grave for it the digger hits stone, it appears they have discovered a Viking kist tomb. The resident archeologist from UHI is grateful to be offered help from Rhona. However, there is a faint smell coming from the kist which alerts them to the fact the burial might not be that old.
An intriguing story set between Orkney and Glasgow with the realisation that there could be more burials and perhaps even one due now.
Although part of a series this reads perfectly as a stand alone, I have only read a couple of the Rhona MacLeod books. My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc.
An intriguing story set between Orkney and Glasgow with the realisation that there could be more burials and perhaps even one due now.
Although part of a series this reads perfectly as a stand alone, I have only read a couple of the Rhona MacLeod books. My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc.
June 19, 2025
The Dead and the Dying is the first book I’ve read by Lin Anderson. It’s actually part of the Rhona MacLeod series of books, but I managed to dip in and catch up.
I found the backdrop of Orkney and archaeological aspects of the book fascinating, as I also found the aspects of AI interesting.
The story moves along at a good pace between Orkney and Glasgow as the case is investigated. I particular found the fact that there were connections to past of the police and investigators also interesting.
It was good to discover an author who is new to me and I will certainly read more Rhona MacLeod books and will start at the beginning.
Huge thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Pan Macmillan, for making this e-ARC available to me in exchange for a fair and honest review.
I found the backdrop of Orkney and archaeological aspects of the book fascinating, as I also found the aspects of AI interesting.
The story moves along at a good pace between Orkney and Glasgow as the case is investigated. I particular found the fact that there were connections to past of the police and investigators also interesting.
It was good to discover an author who is new to me and I will certainly read more Rhona MacLeod books and will start at the beginning.
Huge thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Pan Macmillan, for making this e-ARC available to me in exchange for a fair and honest review.
August 21, 2025
Set in Skaill Bay, Orkney Forensic Scientist Dr Rhona MacLeod joins the rescue mission of a pod of beached pilot whales. From this a Viking stone cist is discovered with remains that may be Viking or perhaps more recent? This is just the start of the secrets in the sand. With inlets, sea lochs, tattie scones and drams of whisky this book had me desperate to visit that stunning part of the world one day. I liked the exploration of AI in modern forensic work and I enjoyed the pace of the book as Rhona carefully investigated the case, working out who and what she could trust.
This is the 19th book in the Dr Rhona MacLeod series but the first one for me. I read it as a stand alone and thoroughly enjoyed it.
This is the 19th book in the Dr Rhona MacLeod series but the first one for me. I read it as a stand alone and thoroughly enjoyed it.
August 12, 2025
This is such a great series featuring Rhona and her entourage. Set again on the Orkney isles (second book this month set there which I've read), Rhona ends up involved in a case even though she is meant to be on holiday. Great descriptive writing about the places and the scenery there with plenty going on to keep the reader guessing. Having visited Orkney, I was there with each character along the streets, out at Skara Brae, on the ferry but fortunately not on a helicopter !! Looking forward to book 20 !!
Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC to review.
Thanks to Netgalley for the ARC to review.
August 16, 2025
A new series to add to my list, I hadn’t heard of these books before but it’s been added to my KU wish list.
This is book 19 but easy to follow so could be read as a standalone.
Set in Oakley which has always fascinated me and the writing bought it to life so well. I expect some of the characters appear in previous books so I’ll be looking forward to finding out more in the previous books.
A great murder mystery with lots of suspense and twist and turns to keep readers hooked.
#TheDeadandtheDying @linandersonwriter
@panmacmillan @randomthingstours
#RhonaMacLeod
This is book 19 but easy to follow so could be read as a standalone.
Set in Oakley which has always fascinated me and the writing bought it to life so well. I expect some of the characters appear in previous books so I’ll be looking forward to finding out more in the previous books.
A great murder mystery with lots of suspense and twist and turns to keep readers hooked.
#TheDeadandtheDying @linandersonwriter
@panmacmillan @randomthingstours
#RhonaMacLeod
January 4, 2026
The 19th Rhona Macleod novel is brilliant. Set on Orkney, this tale involves the uncovering of a Viking burial site containing much more recent remains, which leads to a murder hunt that drags all the usual characters into its orbit as they try to solve the crime/s. Once again, Lin Anderson describes the action brilliantly and in a way that retains the reader’s interest throughout. She really is a brilliant crime writer.
September 5, 2025
Really enjoyed this latest Rhona MacLeod novel. Lin Anderson never disappoints. The main characters are always endearing - Rhona, Christie, McNab & Sean.
Looking forward to the 20th novel soon please, Lin!
Looking forward to the 20th novel soon please, Lin!
October 24, 2025
DNF at 66% I’ve given up. Did I read the same book as the rest of the reviewers? This book is just badly written. It’s repetitive, boring, and goes nowhere. I couldn’t subject myself to another dull and pointless page.
November 2, 2025
I expected more from Anderson. At best, the resolution to the crime was a little more than a place holder.
I don't understand how a writer as experienced as Anderson (or the publishers) thought that was ok.
I don't understand how a writer as experienced as Anderson (or the publishers) thought that was ok.
February 20, 2026
The usual cast are present and correct, plus the setting in Orkney works well with the story. Having said that the final quarter of the book begins to falter as if the author wasn't totally sure how to produce a satisfying ending. It sort of has an air of anti-climax, and rather fizzles out...
August 21, 2025
Was going to give this a 4 right up until the end. it's as if she can't be bothered, definite anti climax.
August 30, 2025
Unfinished! 2.5 stars… it went on…and on…and on. It could have better if more concise.
November 8, 2025
A solid police procedure with a focus on forensic bone analysis, set in an atmospheric place. Learnt a lot about facial recognition.
October 10, 2025
I enjoyed catching up with Rhona and mcnab. I was glad to see another book set in orkney. the bodies are found in old viking graves.
August 25, 2025
review to follow
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews