What do you think?
Rate this book
The General's Gift
“Unabashedly romantic, sweeping, and full of heart. Perfect for fans of Julia Quinn, Lisa Kleypas, and Sarah MacLean.” —Book Shelfie ★★★★★
She believes in poetry, stardust, and happily-ever-afters.
He believes in duty, black powder, and the chain of command.
They have one summer to turn her into a lady—
before he returns to war, and she’s matched with another.
Celeste Dubois has lived life at the edge of the stage and the margins of society. But now that she’s an heiress, she dares to dream—not of balls or titles, but of falling in love. Real love. The kind revered by Shakespeare and whispered beneath the moonlight. She’s determined to find her perfect English prince… as long as she can keep her fluttering heart from panicking first.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, General of His Majesty’s cavalry, has no patience for frills, French nonsense, or feelings. Yet he owes her father a debt—and that means transforming the tulle-wrapped ballerina into a proper young lady before the Season ends. One summer. No distractions. No attachments.
But Celeste is a whirlwind of innocence and wonder. She charms his household, unsettles his routines, and upends his well-defended heart with every sigh and smile. And the more she dreams of love, the more Hawk begins to dread the day he must give her to someone else.
A poignant, playful Regency romance about opposites who weren’t supposed to fall in love—and what happens when they do.
He believes in duty, black powder, and the chain of command.
They have one summer to turn her into a lady—
before he returns to war, and she’s matched with another.
Celeste Dubois has lived life at the edge of the stage and the margins of society. But now that she’s an heiress, she dares to dream—not of balls or titles, but of falling in love. Real love. The kind revered by Shakespeare and whispered beneath the moonlight. She’s determined to find her perfect English prince… as long as she can keep her fluttering heart from panicking first.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, General of His Majesty’s cavalry, has no patience for frills, French nonsense, or feelings. Yet he owes her father a debt—and that means transforming the tulle-wrapped ballerina into a proper young lady before the Season ends. One summer. No distractions. No attachments.
But Celeste is a whirlwind of innocence and wonder. She charms his household, unsettles his routines, and upends his well-defended heart with every sigh and smile. And the more she dreams of love, the more Hawk begins to dread the day he must give her to someone else.
A poignant, playful Regency romance about opposites who weren’t supposed to fall in love—and what happens when they do.
371 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 28, 2025
24 people are currently reading
56 people want to read
About the author
Giovanna Siniscalchi
18 books150 followersGiovanna Siniscalchi chased narrative arcs and climax points in the Nasdaq for twelve long years working as an economist. Still, her romantic imagination was wasted in the financial markets, so she decided to put it to better use: write fiction. She is married and has two great kids. Her passions are eclectic, including reading, traveling, surfing, wine, and of course, historical romance.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 154 reviews
October 28, 2025
I wish I could give this book 10 stars. I loved it so much I was never really a fan of reading historical literature but once I did i couldn’t put it down. I loved this book so much. This is the second book in the swans of Paris series and I’m excited for the next one.
Stars::⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️
Stars::⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice:🌶️🌶️🌶️
October 18, 2025
what does one say when one reads one of the most incredible books. OMG 😳 this book was everything magical and pragmatic. you take a fairy that has been a ballerina all her life living in the shadows who has an absolute love of Shakespeare and give her a fairy godfather who's a general in the queens army and they fall hopeless in love. he's supposed to be her guardian. she's the child of his deceased best friend. he took a vow to find her and make a good match. the general never thought he would fall head over wings for this tulle covered nymph.
this book blended humor with the serious side of war of the time. it's truly so magical that you experience the life of polar opposites and find them in love.
I must mention many of the side characters of this book stood out so well. you could not help be brought in further by this authors side characters. they are just so likeable.
this author has an amazing gift of writing stories. she tells the reader a story you just can't help but love. I sometimes wonder if she could write a famous Broadway play. every book I read from her tells a magical story from the past with research you can't find anywhere else. she has a true gift.
this book blended humor with the serious side of war of the time. it's truly so magical that you experience the life of polar opposites and find them in love.
I must mention many of the side characters of this book stood out so well. you could not help be brought in further by this authors side characters. they are just so likeable.
this author has an amazing gift of writing stories. she tells the reader a story you just can't help but love. I sometimes wonder if she could write a famous Broadway play. every book I read from her tells a magical story from the past with research you can't find anywhere else. she has a true gift.
November 12, 2025
3.5 – 4 stars
The General's Gift is a historical Regency romance novel and the second book in The Swans of Paris series by Giovanna Siniscalchi.
The fierce General of His Majesty’s cavalry, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, has one last mission: to find a missing girl. When he finally locates her, he does the one thing he never expected—transforming a naïve, wide-eyed girl into a captivating woman that every man will desire, including himself.
This story explores the theme of opposites attracting, featuring an older man and a younger woman. It is filled with passion, desire, drama, war, angst, pain, lust, longing, and a touch of humour.
The General's Gift is a heartfelt tale that captures the grumpy / sunshine trope, leaving you with a range of emotions.
The General's Gift is a historical Regency romance novel and the second book in The Swans of Paris series by Giovanna Siniscalchi.
The fierce General of His Majesty’s cavalry, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, has one last mission: to find a missing girl. When he finally locates her, he does the one thing he never expected—transforming a naïve, wide-eyed girl into a captivating woman that every man will desire, including himself.
This story explores the theme of opposites attracting, featuring an older man and a younger woman. It is filled with passion, desire, drama, war, angst, pain, lust, longing, and a touch of humour.
The General's Gift is a heartfelt tale that captures the grumpy / sunshine trope, leaving you with a range of emotions.
November 2, 2025
This book perfectly balances playfulness with heart. I loved that Celeste was a breath of fresh air to Alexander and his household. I really enjoyed that he was so in tune with her that he could recognize her fear and help her overcome it. They really were two opposites that were made for each other. I loved that her red hair was the only color he could see in his gray world. I loved all of the side characters to include Othello, Celeste's poodle. I loved all the references to Shakespeare as well.
What to Expect:
🩰Ballerina FMC
⚔️Military General MMC
🩰Forbidden Romance
⚔️Age Gap
🩰Plenty of Tulle
⚔️Ogling of Thighs
Thank you, Giovanna Siniscalchi for this eARC of your amazing book! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
What to Expect:
🩰Ballerina FMC
⚔️Military General MMC
🩰Forbidden Romance
⚔️Age Gap
🩰Plenty of Tulle
⚔️Ogling of Thighs
Thank you, Giovanna Siniscalchi for this eARC of your amazing book! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
October 23, 2025
If you grew up on the historical romances of the ’80s and ’90s, you are going to eat this book up. I lost my mind at the nostalgic moments throughout The General's Gift. Thanks so much to the author and Book Sirens for the complimentary early copy.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, has earned a fearsome reputation in His Majesty’s cavalry as a general who never surrenders, no matter the odds. But after his closest friend is killed in battle during the Napoleonic Wars, Hawk is left with one final duty: to find his friend’s missing daughter. Years ago, when the regiment was deployed abroad, the child’s mother returned to her family in France. Then came the Revolution, her execution during the Terror, and the baby vanished without a trace. Hawk is determined to find her and now, with the help of a Bow Street Runner, he’s finally located her in the most unlikely of places.
Celeste Dubois grew up among a small, tight-knit group of girls known as the Swans of Paris—young émigrées who escaped the Terror and found refuge as ballerinas in Covent Garden. She knows little of her past beyond her mother’s name, Angelique. So when a stern English earl appears claiming she is Lady Cecilia Stratton, the lost daughter of a marquess, she’s both startled and intrigued. Moving into Hawk’s household to learn how to be the perfect English lady should be simple enough but Celeste has spent her life avoiding men since an attack left her wary and withdrawn. Yet in Hawk’s presence, she feels unexpectedly safe… as though she’s finally come home—even if her guardian might be the starchiest, most unyielding man in England.
This book was straight out of the ’90s historical romance playbook. We rarely see guardian-ward romances anymore, mostly due to modern discomfort with that kind of age gap and power disparity. But back in Ye Olden Days, this was a trope we saw all the time and I LOVED it. Here we have the added taboo of Hawk’s relationship with Celeste’s father. She doesn’t have an issue with the fact that they were best friends, but he absolutely does.
Celeste and Hawk are an exercise in contrasts. She was raised in the theatre from infancy, a world of tulle, grace, and whimsy. He was shaped by the life-and-death stakes of military leadership. She sees the world through the lens of Shakespeare, while Hawk sees everything through the lens of duty. We also see contrast in how they believe love should factor into life. Celeste is in love with the idea of true love, while Hawk has seen the danger of loving anyone when your life is tied to the war effort.
OK, we have to talk about my absolute favorite thing in this book—the thing that had me squealing throughout. Hawk suffered a head injury in the battle where Celeste’s father died, and it took away his ability to see all color... except for the color of Celeste’s hair. Her red hair is the only color this man can see. PUT IT IN MY VEINS. I don’t care if this is medically possible; I don’t care if it makes any sense at all. GIVE ME THE COLOR-BLIND GENERAL WHO CAN ONLY SEE HER HAIR. This was old school in the most magnificent way possible.
I had so much fun reading this book. It’s definitely a different tone than The Duke’s Dream, book one of this series. I could see Giovanna’s time writing her Wanton Wallflower novellas creeping in through the supporting cast and some of the whimsy from Celeste. It gave the story a lighter tone and more fun moments, despite the heavy themes of war and loss. 4.5 stars.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, has earned a fearsome reputation in His Majesty’s cavalry as a general who never surrenders, no matter the odds. But after his closest friend is killed in battle during the Napoleonic Wars, Hawk is left with one final duty: to find his friend’s missing daughter. Years ago, when the regiment was deployed abroad, the child’s mother returned to her family in France. Then came the Revolution, her execution during the Terror, and the baby vanished without a trace. Hawk is determined to find her and now, with the help of a Bow Street Runner, he’s finally located her in the most unlikely of places.
Celeste Dubois grew up among a small, tight-knit group of girls known as the Swans of Paris—young émigrées who escaped the Terror and found refuge as ballerinas in Covent Garden. She knows little of her past beyond her mother’s name, Angelique. So when a stern English earl appears claiming she is Lady Cecilia Stratton, the lost daughter of a marquess, she’s both startled and intrigued. Moving into Hawk’s household to learn how to be the perfect English lady should be simple enough but Celeste has spent her life avoiding men since an attack left her wary and withdrawn. Yet in Hawk’s presence, she feels unexpectedly safe… as though she’s finally come home—even if her guardian might be the starchiest, most unyielding man in England.
This book was straight out of the ’90s historical romance playbook. We rarely see guardian-ward romances anymore, mostly due to modern discomfort with that kind of age gap and power disparity. But back in Ye Olden Days, this was a trope we saw all the time and I LOVED it. Here we have the added taboo of Hawk’s relationship with Celeste’s father. She doesn’t have an issue with the fact that they were best friends, but he absolutely does.
Celeste and Hawk are an exercise in contrasts. She was raised in the theatre from infancy, a world of tulle, grace, and whimsy. He was shaped by the life-and-death stakes of military leadership. She sees the world through the lens of Shakespeare, while Hawk sees everything through the lens of duty. We also see contrast in how they believe love should factor into life. Celeste is in love with the idea of true love, while Hawk has seen the danger of loving anyone when your life is tied to the war effort.
OK, we have to talk about my absolute favorite thing in this book—the thing that had me squealing throughout. Hawk suffered a head injury in the battle where Celeste’s father died, and it took away his ability to see all color... except for the color of Celeste’s hair. Her red hair is the only color this man can see. PUT IT IN MY VEINS. I don’t care if this is medically possible; I don’t care if it makes any sense at all. GIVE ME THE COLOR-BLIND GENERAL WHO CAN ONLY SEE HER HAIR. This was old school in the most magnificent way possible.
I had so much fun reading this book. It’s definitely a different tone than The Duke’s Dream, book one of this series. I could see Giovanna’s time writing her Wanton Wallflower novellas creeping in through the supporting cast and some of the whimsy from Celeste. It gave the story a lighter tone and more fun moments, despite the heavy themes of war and loss. 4.5 stars.
October 28, 2025
The General's Gift is a gift to us all! It has everything I love and can count on when reading a book by Gio but this time she added something a little unexpected and fully appreciated!
Three words come to mind when I think back on this book - heart, humor and healing. Each of these works in tandem creating a thrilling ride. 'Heart' is the emotional core of the story with characters that, despite events of their past, are genuinely kind, compassionate and maintain a capacity to love deeply and unconditionally. Celeste with her vivid imagination, enduring optimism and determination to never settle for less than true love is the perfect counter to Hawk's rigid, regimented, and, literal, black and white world. She is the color in his life, he is her anchor.
This is a journey of healing for both Celeste and Hawk. They have emotional wounds that made them feel like they'd forever be on the outside looking in, never finding the person who could accept their vulnerabilities. They move from a place of hurt to one of wholeness and acceptance. Demons are let go, perspectives are changed and a foundation of trust is built.
Woven into the story that deals with some darker issues was an unexpected lightness. The author did an excellent job of incorporating this without making it feel flippant or insensitive. Instead, it made the story feel authentic, using levity to show resilience and recovery, taking power away from their pain and allowing them to move forward.
This is a story that feels like it came straight from the author's heart directly aimed at the readers which made it so easy to connect with. The romance unfolds gracefully, showing love in all its forms. The colorful cast of characters brought the story to life, each with their own unique quirks and charm. It's a story that's both touching and entertaining with an ending that truly rewards the reader.
I was honored to receive an early copy directly from the author (Thank you!) All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Three words come to mind when I think back on this book - heart, humor and healing. Each of these works in tandem creating a thrilling ride. 'Heart' is the emotional core of the story with characters that, despite events of their past, are genuinely kind, compassionate and maintain a capacity to love deeply and unconditionally. Celeste with her vivid imagination, enduring optimism and determination to never settle for less than true love is the perfect counter to Hawk's rigid, regimented, and, literal, black and white world. She is the color in his life, he is her anchor.
This is a journey of healing for both Celeste and Hawk. They have emotional wounds that made them feel like they'd forever be on the outside looking in, never finding the person who could accept their vulnerabilities. They move from a place of hurt to one of wholeness and acceptance. Demons are let go, perspectives are changed and a foundation of trust is built.
Woven into the story that deals with some darker issues was an unexpected lightness. The author did an excellent job of incorporating this without making it feel flippant or insensitive. Instead, it made the story feel authentic, using levity to show resilience and recovery, taking power away from their pain and allowing them to move forward.
This is a story that feels like it came straight from the author's heart directly aimed at the readers which made it so easy to connect with. The romance unfolds gracefully, showing love in all its forms. The colorful cast of characters brought the story to life, each with their own unique quirks and charm. It's a story that's both touching and entertaining with an ending that truly rewards the reader.
I was honored to receive an early copy directly from the author (Thank you!) All thoughts and opinions are my own.
October 24, 2025
Never have I enjoyed Shakespeare as much as its feature in this grumpy x sunshine, guardian x ward romp. I actually enjoyed this more than the first in the series - it's less intense and more humorous, but still breathtakingly romantic and emotionally evocative.
Hawk made a promise to find and take care of Celeste, a prospect he is unenthusiastic but resigned for. As a man whose life has been the military, the explosion of life that Celeste brings is more unnerving than facing enemy fire. Celeste has lived as the comic, the side character of the ballet. With an effervescent facade which masks hidden depths, Celeste is ready to live her own grand romance. They collide in a clash of wills, and a flurry of tulle and bewildered soldiers.
Celeste and Hawk's story is wonderfully theatrical. The characters and their characteristics are exaggerated and I really enjoy it - it manages to be fun without sacrificing any emotion. Contrasting the lighthearted elements with more serious undertones makes them hit hard, and when it hits it really punches you in the heart.
If you like tortured heroes, lively heroines, and your eyes full of tears (of all kinds), add this one to your tbr. Vivid prose combines with comedy to create a roller coaster of an emotional ride. If we're talking tropes, it's full of bangers - including a wonderfully executed grovel, as well as a silver fox who doesn't understand ~frivolity~. I loved every second of it.
Hawk made a promise to find and take care of Celeste, a prospect he is unenthusiastic but resigned for. As a man whose life has been the military, the explosion of life that Celeste brings is more unnerving than facing enemy fire. Celeste has lived as the comic, the side character of the ballet. With an effervescent facade which masks hidden depths, Celeste is ready to live her own grand romance. They collide in a clash of wills, and a flurry of tulle and bewildered soldiers.
Celeste and Hawk's story is wonderfully theatrical. The characters and their characteristics are exaggerated and I really enjoy it - it manages to be fun without sacrificing any emotion. Contrasting the lighthearted elements with more serious undertones makes them hit hard, and when it hits it really punches you in the heart.
If you like tortured heroes, lively heroines, and your eyes full of tears (of all kinds), add this one to your tbr. Vivid prose combines with comedy to create a roller coaster of an emotional ride. If we're talking tropes, it's full of bangers - including a wonderfully executed grovel, as well as a silver fox who doesn't understand ~frivolity~. I loved every second of it.
October 14, 2025
Another wonderful read from Ms. Siniscalchi! If you are new to her books, you are in for a treat. The General’s Gift is truly that. A gift. The story is original, the characters are friends you care for and desperately want to see their happiness come to fruition, and humor! I love it when I find myself laughing out loud! No worn out tropes or page after page of “filler” angst until you want to scream at the page to “get on with it!”. Just a beautifully written tale with passages so stunning that you find yourself re-reading a sentence just for the pleasure of it. I love the General, his love is a woman so strong yet so vulnerable. The quirky maid and chaperone will be tucked in my memory for a long time. Isn’t that what a book should do? Leave you with new friends and a feeling of being glad you met them? If you agree, then read The General’s Gift. It’s a gift you can keep. I received an advance review copy for free, and am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 12, 2025
I loved this book. Hawk is a battle weary General who literally see's the world in black and white. Celeste a shelterd girl who is all colour and light.
Hawk made a promise to Celeste father and making good on that promises he becomes Celeste's guardian.
What follows is a slow burn romance that is forbidden. Watching Hawk navigate Celeste turning is well ordered life into a flaming mess is amazing. I found myself laughing out loud at times in the book and I am sure you will as well.
This book is stunning and I am sure you will love it as well
🌼 forbidden love
🧡 ward/guardian
🌼 silver fox
🧡 age gap
🌼 grumpy sunshine
🧡 slow burn
🌼 laugh out loud moments
Hawk made a promise to Celeste father and making good on that promises he becomes Celeste's guardian.
What follows is a slow burn romance that is forbidden. Watching Hawk navigate Celeste turning is well ordered life into a flaming mess is amazing. I found myself laughing out loud at times in the book and I am sure you will as well.
This book is stunning and I am sure you will love it as well
🌼 forbidden love
🧡 ward/guardian
🌼 silver fox
🧡 age gap
🌼 grumpy sunshine
🧡 slow burn
🌼 laugh out loud moments
October 15, 2025
Wow. I am utterly blown away by the beauty and craft of this story. It is achingly sweet, but with a dose of humor and explosions of spice. I am not a huge fan of poetry, but the author wove a poetic tale that left me reeling. Celeste and Hawk were perfect. Seeing them circle one another and fall in love was the stuff of romantic legends. And the grovel….oh so moving. And despite all the grand, emotional writing, there were so many moments that had me giggling and laughing out loud.
Bravo! I can’t wait for the next book!
Bravo! I can’t wait for the next book!
November 10, 2025
Who thought guardianship would unfold in a Shakespearean play way. This story had a bit of everything. From the seriousness of war, overcoming past fears and the magic of discovering love to the wonderful smile worthy characters and never-ending playful banter, I enjoyed every moment. Life indeed is a play that we all have roles to perform.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 21, 2025
This book is full of humor and I absolutely loved it. I have always been a fan of historical romance, and this one did not fail to impress. While there are heavy topics throughout the book, they are covered in a very gentle way that does not go into large detail. There is some spice, but for the most part it is tasteful. My only complaint is I have no earthly idea what "promise colored eyes" are. What color is that? It will likely haunt me forever.
October 22, 2025
Shoutout to Giovanna Siniscalchi for offering me a free ARC in exchange for an honest review — thank you so much for the opportunity!
The General’s Gift is the second novel in The Swans of Paris series. Set during the Napoleonic Wars, it follows Covent Garden ballerina Celeste Dubois and war hero Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst—better known as Hawk. Years ago, Hawk promised his best friend on his deathbed to find his long-lost daughter, Lady Cecilia Stratton, and bring her safely home. When he finally finds her, now living as Celeste Dubois, she’s anything but a traditional English lady. Celeste is a dreamer—artistic, impulsive, and busy fantasizing about being the heroine of a Shakespeare play. War-scarred Hawk has no idea what to do with her, but that doesn’t stop him from feeling some very un-Fairy-Godfather-like things. Determined to keep his distance, Hawk doesn’t expect his charge to slowly tear down his walls and turn her would-be guardian into her Prince Charming.
This book features several of my favorite tropes—forbidden romance, opposites attract, and an unconventional heroine—so I was immediately intrigued. I’d been craving a Luna Lovegood-esque female lead, and Celeste delivered. However, the novel also includes one of my least favorite tropes: the age gap, especially the “father’s best friend” variation. Those dynamics usually make me a bit uneasy, and there were definitely moments that gave me the ick. That said, to my own surprise, I still ended up enjoying The General’s Gift.
Tonally, this book differs quite a bit from The Duke’s Desire. While that one had a darker, melancholic atmosphere, The General’s Gift is lighter, often humorous, and at times even delightfully chaotic. It’s a tonal shift I didn’t expect, and while I usually prefer a consistent mood across a series, I did appreciate how this book balanced its levity with some heavier moments, such as Celeste’s assault. Still, if you’re expecting something similar to The Duke’s Desire, this one will feel more buoyant.
Now, onto the main characters. I adored Celeste—she’s whimsical, charming, and unapologetically herself. I loved how she interprets her life through the lens of a Shakespearean play—it’s an unusual coping mechanism that adds both humor and heart. Despite her dreamy nature, she has a strong will and challenges Hawk at every turn. At times, she did read a bit too young, which made me slightly uncomfortable given the age gap, but it also became clear that her playfulness acts as a shield. She’s both naive and knowing, which adds depth to her character.
Hawk, on the other hand, is a classic starchy hero—all rules, restraint, and suppressed emotion. War has left him scarred in ways that aren’t visible, and he clings to duty because it’s the only thing that gives him purpose. His struggle with his attraction to Celeste felt genuine and well-written; he’s aware of the imbalance between them and tries hard to navigate it responsibly. I actually appreciated how he let Celeste take the lead—she initiates their first kiss, their intimacy, their emotional connection. It balances the dynamic in a way that makes the age gap more palatable for me.
Their relationship is a quintessential grumpy x sunshine pairing: Hawk is rigid and guarded, while Celeste is pure light and chaos. Watching her coax warmth and vulnerability out of him was deeply satisfying, and I loved that she’s the pursuer for most of the book.
As always, Giovanna Siniscalchi’s writing is stunning. Her prose feels almost fairytale-like—elegant, poetic, and emotionally charged. She has a gift for making even simple scenes feel rich and alive. Honestly, I’d read anything she writes just for the beauty of her language alone.
Overall, The General’s Gift is a heartfelt and beautifully written historical romance filled with humor, emotion, and the right touch of Shakespearean whimsy. If you love stories that stray beyond the ballroom and into something a bit more wild and romantic, this one’s for you.
The General’s Gift is the second novel in The Swans of Paris series. Set during the Napoleonic Wars, it follows Covent Garden ballerina Celeste Dubois and war hero Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst—better known as Hawk. Years ago, Hawk promised his best friend on his deathbed to find his long-lost daughter, Lady Cecilia Stratton, and bring her safely home. When he finally finds her, now living as Celeste Dubois, she’s anything but a traditional English lady. Celeste is a dreamer—artistic, impulsive, and busy fantasizing about being the heroine of a Shakespeare play. War-scarred Hawk has no idea what to do with her, but that doesn’t stop him from feeling some very un-Fairy-Godfather-like things. Determined to keep his distance, Hawk doesn’t expect his charge to slowly tear down his walls and turn her would-be guardian into her Prince Charming.
This book features several of my favorite tropes—forbidden romance, opposites attract, and an unconventional heroine—so I was immediately intrigued. I’d been craving a Luna Lovegood-esque female lead, and Celeste delivered. However, the novel also includes one of my least favorite tropes: the age gap, especially the “father’s best friend” variation. Those dynamics usually make me a bit uneasy, and there were definitely moments that gave me the ick. That said, to my own surprise, I still ended up enjoying The General’s Gift.
Tonally, this book differs quite a bit from The Duke’s Desire. While that one had a darker, melancholic atmosphere, The General’s Gift is lighter, often humorous, and at times even delightfully chaotic. It’s a tonal shift I didn’t expect, and while I usually prefer a consistent mood across a series, I did appreciate how this book balanced its levity with some heavier moments, such as Celeste’s assault. Still, if you’re expecting something similar to The Duke’s Desire, this one will feel more buoyant.
Now, onto the main characters. I adored Celeste—she’s whimsical, charming, and unapologetically herself. I loved how she interprets her life through the lens of a Shakespearean play—it’s an unusual coping mechanism that adds both humor and heart. Despite her dreamy nature, she has a strong will and challenges Hawk at every turn. At times, she did read a bit too young, which made me slightly uncomfortable given the age gap, but it also became clear that her playfulness acts as a shield. She’s both naive and knowing, which adds depth to her character.
Hawk, on the other hand, is a classic starchy hero—all rules, restraint, and suppressed emotion. War has left him scarred in ways that aren’t visible, and he clings to duty because it’s the only thing that gives him purpose. His struggle with his attraction to Celeste felt genuine and well-written; he’s aware of the imbalance between them and tries hard to navigate it responsibly. I actually appreciated how he let Celeste take the lead—she initiates their first kiss, their intimacy, their emotional connection. It balances the dynamic in a way that makes the age gap more palatable for me.
Their relationship is a quintessential grumpy x sunshine pairing: Hawk is rigid and guarded, while Celeste is pure light and chaos. Watching her coax warmth and vulnerability out of him was deeply satisfying, and I loved that she’s the pursuer for most of the book.
As always, Giovanna Siniscalchi’s writing is stunning. Her prose feels almost fairytale-like—elegant, poetic, and emotionally charged. She has a gift for making even simple scenes feel rich and alive. Honestly, I’d read anything she writes just for the beauty of her language alone.
Overall, The General’s Gift is a heartfelt and beautifully written historical romance filled with humor, emotion, and the right touch of Shakespearean whimsy. If you love stories that stray beyond the ballroom and into something a bit more wild and romantic, this one’s for you.
November 15, 2025
Thanks to Booksprout for a copy of this ebook and this is my freely given opinion.
This is book 2 of the Swans of Paris, and while I did read book 1, this read to be as if it could be enjoyed as a stand alone story, and has a different feel from book 1, especially having read several of the authors much more humorous, tongue-in-cheek Wanton Wallflower stories.
The second of the Swans, Celeste, is discovered to be the orphaned lost daughter of a Marquess. She had been carried out of France and raised with the other Swans to be a ballerina, ending up in the current day of the story, in Covent Gardens, about to take the lead in the latest production. But Celeste has a past secret fear that she seeks to overcome. As a child, she was traumatized by an attack and that has left her with a fear of men and their touch, which she compensates by making up stories and living in them, centred on beloved Shakespearean stories.
Her world is completely changed when she discovers that her new leading role is not that of a ballerina, but as Lady Cecilia Stratton, English lady, heiress, daughter of a Marquess, and debutante, under the guardianship of famed war hero, and general, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, known as Hawk. He is a man driven by duty, devoted to leading the charge, and noted for holding the line and never surrendering.
This is a passionate age-gap romance of two very opposite people. He is stoic, dutiful and very much the grumpy to her sunshine. But her sunshine, frothy, tulle draped exterior hides a sensitive soul that has been traumatized and scarred, and on discovering this, a break in the hard armour of the taciturn general occurs, and this leads to Celeste infiltrating his heart. But he is determined to do his duty, no matter what his heart feels, and that includes not just his duty as a general, but also to the memory of his friend, to find a proper husband for Celeste - and because of this sense of duty, and his determination to protect Celeste's innocence and future happiness from his own perceived dark, scarred spirit, he tries hard to steer her towards what he feels is the appropriate future for her. Even if it means breaking both thier hearts
A passionate age-gap story of two very opposite personalities written with much humour, especially with the side characters, such as Celeste's hired companions, Rue and Prue. Love the side love stories and their antics because they add humour and lightness, and are a nice counterpoint to the deeper and darker emotions of the story.
4.5 stars out of 5
This is book 2 of the Swans of Paris, and while I did read book 1, this read to be as if it could be enjoyed as a stand alone story, and has a different feel from book 1, especially having read several of the authors much more humorous, tongue-in-cheek Wanton Wallflower stories.
The second of the Swans, Celeste, is discovered to be the orphaned lost daughter of a Marquess. She had been carried out of France and raised with the other Swans to be a ballerina, ending up in the current day of the story, in Covent Gardens, about to take the lead in the latest production. But Celeste has a past secret fear that she seeks to overcome. As a child, she was traumatized by an attack and that has left her with a fear of men and their touch, which she compensates by making up stories and living in them, centred on beloved Shakespearean stories.
Her world is completely changed when she discovers that her new leading role is not that of a ballerina, but as Lady Cecilia Stratton, English lady, heiress, daughter of a Marquess, and debutante, under the guardianship of famed war hero, and general, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, known as Hawk. He is a man driven by duty, devoted to leading the charge, and noted for holding the line and never surrendering.
This is a passionate age-gap romance of two very opposite people. He is stoic, dutiful and very much the grumpy to her sunshine. But her sunshine, frothy, tulle draped exterior hides a sensitive soul that has been traumatized and scarred, and on discovering this, a break in the hard armour of the taciturn general occurs, and this leads to Celeste infiltrating his heart. But he is determined to do his duty, no matter what his heart feels, and that includes not just his duty as a general, but also to the memory of his friend, to find a proper husband for Celeste - and because of this sense of duty, and his determination to protect Celeste's innocence and future happiness from his own perceived dark, scarred spirit, he tries hard to steer her towards what he feels is the appropriate future for her. Even if it means breaking both thier hearts
A passionate age-gap story of two very opposite personalities written with much humour, especially with the side characters, such as Celeste's hired companions, Rue and Prue. Love the side love stories and their antics because they add humour and lightness, and are a nice counterpoint to the deeper and darker emotions of the story.
4.5 stars out of 5
October 30, 2025
Review: “The General’s Gift”
⤷ What would you do if you, a ballerina in London, discovered you were actually an heiress—and that now your guardian is the most fearsome general of the army? If he’s a silver fox, I’d definitely catch some feels.
That’s what Celeste—Lady Cecilia—did as well. However, Hawk—the general—was the first one to fall. Little by little, they healed together. Hawk helped Celeste overcome her anxiety and trauma; while she helped him—perhaps even unconsciously so—rediscover life and dare to love, to feel, to live outside of the rules of a soldier.
This is very much an age gap romance, as well as grumpy x sunshine love. I loved seeing them grow closer together, and the spice was oh so tasteful, I was constantly blushing because it was so intimate and beautiful. Every time the MMC went “I couldn’t see color, except for her hair and her eyes” I melted a bit more.
Now, this book has a lot of Shakespearean influence. Not just the fact that the FMC was a Shakespeare nerd and was constantly quoting his plays, but the fact that Giovanna structured the plot as one of his comedies. Yknow, how everyone starts sad but by the end, EVERYONE has married? That type of comedy (LOL). Plus, there were genuine funny lines! As well as funny side characters—specifically Prue and Rue, Celeste’s female chaperones. They were insanely funny—I know that if this were a play, they would’ve made the audience cackle multiple times.
First off, I want to wholeheartedly thanks Giovanna for trusting me as part of her ARC team for another occasion! I cherish her writing so much and have loved seeing her grow as a historical romance author. I fully believe this is Giovanna’s best book yet and it’s up there along with a Julia Quinn’s books. I also love that she does her research—this one is set during the end of the napoleonic wars. The language was so lush and atmospheric I felt smarter by reading it! It fully captured me and transported me to those times.
I give it: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✨“Love, real love, did not obey rules. It arrived when mistaken identities collided in the moonlight. When banter led to breathlessness.” ✨
✨”By God, I’ll put you on my knee and tan your hide.” ✨
✨”Why indeed? Because the fairy godfather wanted to devour her.” ✨
⤷ What would you do if you, a ballerina in London, discovered you were actually an heiress—and that now your guardian is the most fearsome general of the army? If he’s a silver fox, I’d definitely catch some feels.
That’s what Celeste—Lady Cecilia—did as well. However, Hawk—the general—was the first one to fall. Little by little, they healed together. Hawk helped Celeste overcome her anxiety and trauma; while she helped him—perhaps even unconsciously so—rediscover life and dare to love, to feel, to live outside of the rules of a soldier.
This is very much an age gap romance, as well as grumpy x sunshine love. I loved seeing them grow closer together, and the spice was oh so tasteful, I was constantly blushing because it was so intimate and beautiful. Every time the MMC went “I couldn’t see color, except for her hair and her eyes” I melted a bit more.
Now, this book has a lot of Shakespearean influence. Not just the fact that the FMC was a Shakespeare nerd and was constantly quoting his plays, but the fact that Giovanna structured the plot as one of his comedies. Yknow, how everyone starts sad but by the end, EVERYONE has married? That type of comedy (LOL). Plus, there were genuine funny lines! As well as funny side characters—specifically Prue and Rue, Celeste’s female chaperones. They were insanely funny—I know that if this were a play, they would’ve made the audience cackle multiple times.
First off, I want to wholeheartedly thanks Giovanna for trusting me as part of her ARC team for another occasion! I cherish her writing so much and have loved seeing her grow as a historical romance author. I fully believe this is Giovanna’s best book yet and it’s up there along with a Julia Quinn’s books. I also love that she does her research—this one is set during the end of the napoleonic wars. The language was so lush and atmospheric I felt smarter by reading it! It fully captured me and transported me to those times.
I give it: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✨“Love, real love, did not obey rules. It arrived when mistaken identities collided in the moonlight. When banter led to breathlessness.” ✨
✨”By God, I’ll put you on my knee and tan your hide.” ✨
✨”Why indeed? Because the fairy godfather wanted to devour her.” ✨
October 29, 2025
This is a wonderful story of forbidden love and trust building after traumatic events. Like the first book, it’s set during the Napoleonic Wars, and it’s a feast of visuals and prose and emotional depth!
The FMC is Celeste Dubois, an artistic, impulsive, daydreaming ballerina . She uses her imagination to cope with trauma, which she suffered as a young dancer. She fancies herself as the heroine in a Shakespearean play, walking through life almost dissociated. This comes across often as childlike. She learns suddenly that she is the daughter of a marquess and that her life is about to change entirely. She’s very strongwilled and is undeterred by her severe new guardian, Hawk, challenging him often. Some weeks into her preparations to join society, she speaks of her trauma to the general, and everything begins to shift. Her growth from a dreamy young ballerina into a self-possessed woman was a beautiful unfolding.
The MMC is Hawk, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst. Prior to the events in this book, Hawk made a battlefield promise to his best friend Philip Stratton that, should Stratton die, he would find and protect his long-lost daughter, Cecilia. As her guardian, he aspires to have her molded into a proper Englishwoman so that she can be matched with a man that befits her station as Lady Stafford. Hawk has kept clear of the entanglements of love after the death of his wife in childbirth, and finds himself feeling some uncharacteristically intense emotions toward his charge. He finds purpose in duty and is all about discipline. Her otherworldly beauty and persistent dancing in his ballroom creating massive fissures in his carefully constructed emotional fortress. He allows her to set the pace of their relationship as it finds its beginnings, and while that is gentlemanly, it also showed that he can relinquish power and exist outside his own rules.
This author goes very deeply into the time period she sets her books in, and gives wonderfully crafted backstories and internal dialogue views to her MMCs. This was a gorgeously cinematic story!
The FMC is Celeste Dubois, an artistic, impulsive, daydreaming ballerina . She uses her imagination to cope with trauma, which she suffered as a young dancer. She fancies herself as the heroine in a Shakespearean play, walking through life almost dissociated. This comes across often as childlike. She learns suddenly that she is the daughter of a marquess and that her life is about to change entirely. She’s very strongwilled and is undeterred by her severe new guardian, Hawk, challenging him often. Some weeks into her preparations to join society, she speaks of her trauma to the general, and everything begins to shift. Her growth from a dreamy young ballerina into a self-possessed woman was a beautiful unfolding.
The MMC is Hawk, Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst. Prior to the events in this book, Hawk made a battlefield promise to his best friend Philip Stratton that, should Stratton die, he would find and protect his long-lost daughter, Cecilia. As her guardian, he aspires to have her molded into a proper Englishwoman so that she can be matched with a man that befits her station as Lady Stafford. Hawk has kept clear of the entanglements of love after the death of his wife in childbirth, and finds himself feeling some uncharacteristically intense emotions toward his charge. He finds purpose in duty and is all about discipline. Her otherworldly beauty and persistent dancing in his ballroom creating massive fissures in his carefully constructed emotional fortress. He allows her to set the pace of their relationship as it finds its beginnings, and while that is gentlemanly, it also showed that he can relinquish power and exist outside his own rules.
This author goes very deeply into the time period she sets her books in, and gives wonderfully crafted backstories and internal dialogue views to her MMCs. This was a gorgeously cinematic story!
October 22, 2025
This book is the second book from the series The Swans of Paris that followed the love stories of French emigrees. Being brought from France as a baby, ballerina Celeste finds that she is actually Lady Cecilia Stratton, daughter of an English Marquess and heir to a castle. After a promise on the battlefield, General Hawk has finally filled his late friend’s final request to find and protect his daughter. As her guardian, he plans to turn her into a proper English lady so that she can find a good marriage and his duty will be completed.
The General’s Gift has a different feel than the first book in the series, The Duke’s Dream. While they both have a dreamlike quality, where the first book was dark and dramatic, this one was light and magical. Giovanna’s playful language reminded me of books by Erica Ridley and Virginia Heath. Romantic tension and steam was mixed in throughout the story with the comedic characters and situations. It was a true balance of poetry and romcom with a solid romance arc underneath that provided the right foundation for its unique prose.
I think this book could act as a true standalone, as the previous MCs are off somewhere else having there HEA. There is also enough development of Celeste’s whimsical nature that you don’t lose anything by not having met her before you begin this story. It’s a great starting point to this author if you like these tropes (I know I do!): Grumpy/sunshine, prepare her to marry someone else, age gap, duty versus love, surprise identity.
November 3, 2025
The General’s Gift is a heartfelt story about a high-ranking military man from the ton, bound by honor, who sets out to find his deceased best friend’s daughter in the midst of war. The beginning highlights the significant age gap between the General and his ward, Celeste. She is a dreamer with rainbow eyes, coloring the world around her with imagination and guided by her love for Shakespeare and romantic ideals.
As the story progresses, Celeste matures, and the emotional distance created by their age gap begins to narrow. This shift feels natural, especially as the hero learns to appreciate her personality and spirit. His respect, devotion, and patience make their connection believable and tender.
The story is both charming and emotionally engaging. The characters are shaped by past trauma and life expectations, yet they learn not just to survive but to truly live — something reflected beautifully in several insightful passages. One line in particular struck me deeply:
“I know fear isn’t only a feeling. It lives inside us. And if we’re not careful, it seizes the reins and makes our choices. Then we’re not living anymore — we’re only existing.”
This resonated with me so much, especially during a period where I’ve been fighting that very feeling myself.
I can’t wait to read the next book in the Swans of Paris series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
As the story progresses, Celeste matures, and the emotional distance created by their age gap begins to narrow. This shift feels natural, especially as the hero learns to appreciate her personality and spirit. His respect, devotion, and patience make their connection believable and tender.
The story is both charming and emotionally engaging. The characters are shaped by past trauma and life expectations, yet they learn not just to survive but to truly live — something reflected beautifully in several insightful passages. One line in particular struck me deeply:
“I know fear isn’t only a feeling. It lives inside us. And if we’re not careful, it seizes the reins and makes our choices. Then we’re not living anymore — we’re only existing.”
This resonated with me so much, especially during a period where I’ve been fighting that very feeling myself.
I can’t wait to read the next book in the Swans of Paris series.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 6, 2025
This beautiful story is rich, flowing and soul-deep. The author’s words don’t merely tell a story but stir the heart!! I read it twice before writing this review just because I couldn’t get enough of this story.
She not only tells a story of the two characters (Alexander or Hawk or General and Lady Cecelia or Celeste) but she blends a little history in along the way which just added an extra layer and depth to the story.
And steam and spice 🔥🔥🔥
Speaking of characters, the cast of this book were endearing and funny. There were giggles aplenty and angst but above all, love!! The book had angst but just the right amount (I’m not a fan of high angst) so this was a perfect blend of angst, push and pull, giggles and poetic, beautiful moments!
The author paints pictures and touches the mind with a sweep of her pen and glides the reader along on a journey of two characters from two different worlds who push and pull each other until finally, finally the great pas de deux at the end!!
The epilogue is “chef’s kiss” perfect!!
A quote from the book: “But it was after the curtain fell that their true story began.”
I can’t wait for book 3 in this series, Duke’s Dream (book 1) was just as wonderful as this book so book 3 will be no less amazing!
If you haven’t read a Giovanna Siniscalchi’s book, then you’re missing out!
Brava Gio!! Brava!! 🌹♥️
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
She not only tells a story of the two characters (Alexander or Hawk or General and Lady Cecelia or Celeste) but she blends a little history in along the way which just added an extra layer and depth to the story.
And steam and spice 🔥🔥🔥
Speaking of characters, the cast of this book were endearing and funny. There were giggles aplenty and angst but above all, love!! The book had angst but just the right amount (I’m not a fan of high angst) so this was a perfect blend of angst, push and pull, giggles and poetic, beautiful moments!
The author paints pictures and touches the mind with a sweep of her pen and glides the reader along on a journey of two characters from two different worlds who push and pull each other until finally, finally the great pas de deux at the end!!
The epilogue is “chef’s kiss” perfect!!
A quote from the book: “But it was after the curtain fell that their true story began.”
I can’t wait for book 3 in this series, Duke’s Dream (book 1) was just as wonderful as this book so book 3 will be no less amazing!
If you haven’t read a Giovanna Siniscalchi’s book, then you’re missing out!
Brava Gio!! Brava!! 🌹♥️
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 22, 2025
Not many books make a mark. Not many leave the reader spinning like a top and reeling from the pirouette of a tale that rose ever higher to teeter perfectly on the tiptoes of perfection.
What a gift The Generals Gift is. Smart in its historical settings. Masterful in the brushstrokes painting a war too long, too lonely in foreign lands. Brilliant in its use of plays we know and love.
Then the shimmer of lightness settles around us in a ballerinas performance. Scenes set. Scenes opened and closed both with a soft sweet handling or, when our General commanded the page, strength, duty and a mans honour forming a regimental military parades of such feeling and self denial then to flow through cracks of maybes and should I's emerging to let a man form into a whole; not just a military pawn piece.
Celeste breathes light and life into every Act. Every chapter she graces. Her feelings, her emotions leaping off the page with great thought but handled with a fragile but strength filled butterfly's touch.
Side characters interesting and funny, their utterances so special it's as if they all want the author to say 'Hey! This character deserves their own book written!'
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
What a gift The Generals Gift is. Smart in its historical settings. Masterful in the brushstrokes painting a war too long, too lonely in foreign lands. Brilliant in its use of plays we know and love.
Then the shimmer of lightness settles around us in a ballerinas performance. Scenes set. Scenes opened and closed both with a soft sweet handling or, when our General commanded the page, strength, duty and a mans honour forming a regimental military parades of such feeling and self denial then to flow through cracks of maybes and should I's emerging to let a man form into a whole; not just a military pawn piece.
Celeste breathes light and life into every Act. Every chapter she graces. Her feelings, her emotions leaping off the page with great thought but handled with a fragile but strength filled butterfly's touch.
Side characters interesting and funny, their utterances so special it's as if they all want the author to say 'Hey! This character deserves their own book written!'
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 22, 2025
Celeste & Alexander
*
The only colour he sees is her.
*
Celeste is one of the Swans of Paris. A ballerina who was just about to land a main role but her past catches her. Her father's best friend is here to take her where she belongs and wants to make her a proper lady. So she gives up ballet. The dreamer in her never dies, Hawk is after all her fairy godfather 😉 This story she is writing is her love story. The best part is that the papillon in her is calm when the general is near her 🩷
Hawk promised his best friend to find his daughter and make sure she is taken care of. I doubt he meant for him to fall in love with her but alas here we are. The big age gap is also a problem, right? He is basically twice her age. She should better marry someone her age, but he can't resist her. Will he let her go or go get his woman?
I was giggling so hard when the fairy godfather was mentioned. And to have the big unyielding general blushing and climbing the windows like a young lad. And lets not forget him kneeling for her when he never kneels for anyone. The whole thing is so swoony. I loved the story from start to finish.
*
The only colour he sees is her.
*
Celeste is one of the Swans of Paris. A ballerina who was just about to land a main role but her past catches her. Her father's best friend is here to take her where she belongs and wants to make her a proper lady. So she gives up ballet. The dreamer in her never dies, Hawk is after all her fairy godfather 😉 This story she is writing is her love story. The best part is that the papillon in her is calm when the general is near her 🩷
Hawk promised his best friend to find his daughter and make sure she is taken care of. I doubt he meant for him to fall in love with her but alas here we are. The big age gap is also a problem, right? He is basically twice her age. She should better marry someone her age, but he can't resist her. Will he let her go or go get his woman?
I was giggling so hard when the fairy godfather was mentioned. And to have the big unyielding general blushing and climbing the windows like a young lad. And lets not forget him kneeling for her when he never kneels for anyone. The whole thing is so swoony. I loved the story from start to finish.
October 23, 2025
Rescued from the French Revolution as a baby, Celeste grew up to become a Covent Garden ballerina who prefers the wings to centre stage. Anxious around men, she retreats into Shakespeare’s romances. Hers is a world of tulle, dreams and fairytales that’s ruled by Papillon – until the day he showed up, and made her an heiress.
His world is discipline, order and obedience; the natural habitat of a revered Army General. Alexander swore to his best friend he would find his long-lost daughter and see her safe – and he delivered. He hadn't, however, expected the skittish pixie to irrevocably upend his life with her candid curiosity.
His world is grey, literally, an old war wound. Hers is a burst of colour.
He’s older (39), rigid and bound for deployment. She’s young (19), nimble and resilient.
He’s seen to much death. She longs to live... but spooks easily.
He needs to find her a husband. She wants him, her rock, her silver fox prince.
The Hawk may have a will of iron, but this little dove has backbone!
From gruesome battlefields to impromptu household ballet lessons.
From impish defiance to the heartbreaking realisation she’s not unruly, simply broken.
From reckless jumps and flying apples to consoling cuddles and slaying nightmares.
From soul-crushing distance to all-consuming lust and scorching passion.
From comic interludes by Rue, Pru & Graves – the chaperone, the maid & his right-hand man are brilliant – to Hawk and his army storming her castle ... to grovel, and he grovels artfully!
The constant back and fort between darkness and light made for an enthralling, emotional ride. The plot is entertaining, the characters colourful and the setting fits. This book made me sigh, snicker and sniff. It’s a regency fairytale, a heartfelt slow burn romance with a solid sprinkling of pixie dust, and a wonderful read!
His world is discipline, order and obedience; the natural habitat of a revered Army General. Alexander swore to his best friend he would find his long-lost daughter and see her safe – and he delivered. He hadn't, however, expected the skittish pixie to irrevocably upend his life with her candid curiosity.
His world is grey, literally, an old war wound. Hers is a burst of colour.
He’s older (39), rigid and bound for deployment. She’s young (19), nimble and resilient.
He’s seen to much death. She longs to live... but spooks easily.
He needs to find her a husband. She wants him, her rock, her silver fox prince.
The Hawk may have a will of iron, but this little dove has backbone!
From gruesome battlefields to impromptu household ballet lessons.
From impish defiance to the heartbreaking realisation she’s not unruly, simply broken.
From reckless jumps and flying apples to consoling cuddles and slaying nightmares.
From soul-crushing distance to all-consuming lust and scorching passion.
From comic interludes by Rue, Pru & Graves – the chaperone, the maid & his right-hand man are brilliant – to Hawk and his army storming her castle ... to grovel, and he grovels artfully!
The constant back and fort between darkness and light made for an enthralling, emotional ride. The plot is entertaining, the characters colourful and the setting fits. This book made me sigh, snicker and sniff. It’s a regency fairytale, a heartfelt slow burn romance with a solid sprinkling of pixie dust, and a wonderful read!
November 5, 2025
An enjoyable and engaging historical Regency romance which kept me happily turning the pages. Ballerina Celeste has been living life at the margins of society until she becomes an heiress, and now she must learn to become a lady. Celeste dreams of falling in love, real love like those written about in her beloved poetry and revered by Shakespeare.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, and General of His Majesty’s cavalry, owed Celeste’s father a debt, so he agrees to transform her into a proper lady before the Season ends, with the aim of finding her a suitable husband. However, as she charms his household he also finds himself captivated by her innocence and wonder. As Celeste dreams of love, Hawk is dreading the day he must give her to another man to marry.
Celeste and Hawk are definitely opposites but they our drawn to one another. Their chemistry comes across in the narrative and I liked how their relationship developed throughout the story. The descriptive narrative brought both the characters and setting vividly to life, making me feel fully immersed in the story. Whilst the added historical details made me feel as though I was transported back to the Regency era.
Alexander de Warenne, Earl of Hawkhurst, and General of His Majesty’s cavalry, owed Celeste’s father a debt, so he agrees to transform her into a proper lady before the Season ends, with the aim of finding her a suitable husband. However, as she charms his household he also finds himself captivated by her innocence and wonder. As Celeste dreams of love, Hawk is dreading the day he must give her to another man to marry.
Celeste and Hawk are definitely opposites but they our drawn to one another. Their chemistry comes across in the narrative and I liked how their relationship developed throughout the story. The descriptive narrative brought both the characters and setting vividly to life, making me feel fully immersed in the story. Whilst the added historical details made me feel as though I was transported back to the Regency era.
October 19, 2025
4.5 ⭐️ Rounded up
This one’s for the lovers of opposites-attract romances where a battle-hardened general gets absolutely wrecked by a sunshine dreamer. Hawk and Celeste’s story is tender, funny and slow-burn in the best way—more longing than lust at first, then a serious spike in temperature around a third of the way through. 🔥💋
Hawk’s military discipline and trauma are written with care and depth—you can feel the weight he carries. Celeste, meanwhile, is a light-drenched contrast: earnest and hopeful but carrying her own scars. She reads a little young early on, but as the story unfolds, you see why they fit so perfectly. He needs her warmth as much as she needs his steadiness.
Standouts: the side characters (Prue, Graves, and Rue steal scenes left and right), the clever Shakespeare nods, and the lovely twist on Hawk’s color-blindness—he can’t see much color, but he can see red, the color of her hair.
A poignant, poetic Regency with a dash of humor and a whole lot of heart.
This one’s for the lovers of opposites-attract romances where a battle-hardened general gets absolutely wrecked by a sunshine dreamer. Hawk and Celeste’s story is tender, funny and slow-burn in the best way—more longing than lust at first, then a serious spike in temperature around a third of the way through. 🔥💋
Hawk’s military discipline and trauma are written with care and depth—you can feel the weight he carries. Celeste, meanwhile, is a light-drenched contrast: earnest and hopeful but carrying her own scars. She reads a little young early on, but as the story unfolds, you see why they fit so perfectly. He needs her warmth as much as she needs his steadiness.
Standouts: the side characters (Prue, Graves, and Rue steal scenes left and right), the clever Shakespeare nods, and the lovely twist on Hawk’s color-blindness—he can’t see much color, but he can see red, the color of her hair.
A poignant, poetic Regency with a dash of humor and a whole lot of heart.
October 26, 2025
A Delightful and Witty Read!
I absolutely loved this second installment in the Swans series! The story follows Celeste, a swan with a complicated past, and Hawk, the General who becomes her guardian after promising to raise her into society and marriage. Hawk treats the task like a military campaign, while Celeste sees it as a romantic comedy—creating a hilarious and heartwarming clash of perspectives.
The supporting characters, especially Celeste’s chaperone and ladies’ maid, add so much charm and humor. The tone is delightfully tongue-in-cheek, making it a fun and satisfying read from beginning to end. I can't wait for the next book!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I’m leaving this review voluntarily.
I absolutely loved this second installment in the Swans series! The story follows Celeste, a swan with a complicated past, and Hawk, the General who becomes her guardian after promising to raise her into society and marriage. Hawk treats the task like a military campaign, while Celeste sees it as a romantic comedy—creating a hilarious and heartwarming clash of perspectives.
The supporting characters, especially Celeste’s chaperone and ladies’ maid, add so much charm and humor. The tone is delightfully tongue-in-cheek, making it a fun and satisfying read from beginning to end. I can't wait for the next book!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I’m leaving this review voluntarily.
October 31, 2025
I really loved The General’s Gift — it completely drew me in. Celeste is such a joy to follow: dreamy, bold, and full of heart. I loved seeing her grow from a carefree ballerina into someone who understands her own worth, all while keeping her spark alive. Hawk broke my heart in the best way, so rigid and duty-bound at first, but gradually letting himself feel, letting himself care. Watching him soften because of her was just… wow.
The romance hit me in all the right ways. It wasn’t rushed, and the tension between them kept me hooked. I felt excited, nervous, and even a little heartbroken along the way.
Perfect for readers who love Regency or Napoleonic-era romance with strong heroines, slow-burn chemistry, and a poetic touch.
The romance hit me in all the right ways. It wasn’t rushed, and the tension between them kept me hooked. I felt excited, nervous, and even a little heartbroken along the way.
Perfect for readers who love Regency or Napoleonic-era romance with strong heroines, slow-burn chemistry, and a poetic touch.
November 18, 2025
I am a fan of Giovanna Siniscalchi and this story in this series is probably my favorite of hers...so far!
Celeste is colorful, fun loving, care-free, and has no idea where she came from. Hawk sees life in black and white, is grumpy, and is charge of transforming Celeste into the person she's intended to be. Neither can imagine where all this is going and may be surprised by the outcome.
Giovanna has woven another beautiful story with poetry, humor, war, and so much more. Be sure to pick this one up and give it a read!
Celeste is colorful, fun loving, care-free, and has no idea where she came from. Hawk sees life in black and white, is grumpy, and is charge of transforming Celeste into the person she's intended to be. Neither can imagine where all this is going and may be surprised by the outcome.
Giovanna has woven another beautiful story with poetry, humor, war, and so much more. Be sure to pick this one up and give it a read!
October 28, 2025
This is the first book I read from Giovanna and Im hooked to her writing style. This book was so sweet, the spice and humor was chef’s kiss. Celeste and Hawk are so perfect and i could not get enough of this book, I cant wait for the next book. Thank you Giovanna and Happily Booked PR for letting me be part of the ARC team.
November 17, 2025
Love love love! This book was such a feel good read! It reminded me of Bridgerton when I read the blurb, but it’s so much more than that! The emotion behind the writing and the attention to detail was just 🤌 *chefs kiss *. The characters were easy to love and even easier to root for! The way I devoured it in a single day! Such a good read!
February 3, 2026
Wow Giovanna Siniscalchi blew me away with this book.. I thought book 1 was breathtaking but this one was just simply INCREDIBLE!
My only regret is waiting so long to read it.. I definitely won't be doing that again because as always with her books.. this one held my attention from beginning to the very end..
Celeste aka Lady Celica and Alexander are very very different people.. she's chaos and he is order and discipline but once those two worlds collide.. one finds that discipline can lead to stability and protection, the other learns that chaos can lead to not only fun but happiness..
Through in mix of crazy chaperone, lady's maid and a captain, and you get the perfect recipe for not only an amazing happily ever after but two!
This story had laughter, love, ballet, dogs, and happily ever after..
I can't wait to read the next book by Giovanna Siniscalchi!
My only regret is waiting so long to read it.. I definitely won't be doing that again because as always with her books.. this one held my attention from beginning to the very end..
Celeste aka Lady Celica and Alexander are very very different people.. she's chaos and he is order and discipline but once those two worlds collide.. one finds that discipline can lead to stability and protection, the other learns that chaos can lead to not only fun but happiness..
Through in mix of crazy chaperone, lady's maid and a captain, and you get the perfect recipe for not only an amazing happily ever after but two!
This story had laughter, love, ballet, dogs, and happily ever after..
I can't wait to read the next book by Giovanna Siniscalchi!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 154 reviews