3.5 ★— If you talked to me about books between ages 10–15, I was probably neck-deep in some paranormal or urban fantasy, following a sassy heroine surviving a gritty world while her hot werewolf/angel/vampire/demon/demon hunter love interest circled her for at least three books.
So yes, I’ve been around the block with stories like this, and when I saw this title pop up, I was hit with a strong wave of nostalgia and genuine excitement at the idea of diving back into that familiar urban fantasy realm.
And Half City did start off pretty strong for me! We’re introduced to Viv, a demon hunter who has had to hide her designation from her family and friends her entire life, living in a city infested with different types of demons that humans are completely blind to. It’s a familiar setup, but it works for what it needs to do, leading me to enjoy following Viv, whose life is a tiny disaster as she juggles her secret powers with her normal life.
Where this book began to lose me was with Viv’s inner monologue. She’s a stressed and traumatized character, which makes sense given that she has to conceal her demon hunter side, but… whew. The narrative constantly circled back to her lamenting about being “different and dark” and the “black sheep” of her family and circle. So frequently, in fact, that I started to lose the empathy I should have felt for this clear internal conflict and instead found myself rolling my eyes whenever she once again went on another inner monologue about how much of a
misunderstood bad girl
she is.
I do understand that she’s only 21 and that the author wanted to portray the depth of her alienation, but if empathy fatigue for fictional characters is a real thing, I definitely experienced it here, and it overshadowed my enjoyment of the book as a whole.
That said, I did appreciate the book's emphasis on her bloodlust, which felt like an interesting take on the demon hunter archetype. Watching Viv struggle with not being able to hunt, and seeing that be another thing that sets her apart from other demon hunters, was actually solidly done and well executed.
As for the romance, I'll be honest... her dynamic with Reid did very little for me. Instructor/student dynamics (shoutout: Vampire Academy!) can be interesting and titillating. Here, though, it felt mostly flat and almost useless in its trope. For one, she barely treats the MMC, Reid, like an instructor and basically shows zero respect for him from the start, which removes much of the tension that usually makes this dynamic exciting! On top of that, Reid himself is a fairly bland love interest who doesn’t bring much to the table personality-wise. Thus, I was mostly uninterested in their scenes together and didn't feel like their steamy moments were all that intriguing.
Really, this book incorporates countless elements anyone who's read more than two urban fantasy series has encountered, and it never quite excels in any one area or offers particularly fresh or exciting aspects.
I did ultimately have some fun with it, as the prose is quite easy and engaging, and at the end of the day, a middling urban fantasy is still enjoyable for someone like me who has a soft spot for the genre and misses how ubiquitous it used to be.
And I will say this: the ending, which leans heavily into cliffhanger territory, did leave me a little curious. If the story takes the route I’m hoping for, I could see myself being much more invested in where this plotline goes next.
So, if you’re craving urban fantasy and don’t mind well worn tropes in exchange for some nostalgic vibes, I’d recommend it. If your expectations are sky high and you were raised on the urban fantasy heavy hitters of the late 2000s to early 2010s, you will likely find yourself underwhelmed.
___________________
Thank you to Berkley Publishing for the ARC.