If life were a bingo card, I’d be really close to winning one of the saddest rounds in history.
Orphaned at a young age? Check.
Plopped into a small town where gossip flowed easier than water down the Mississippi River? Check.
Primary target of Bellevue’s cruelest bullies, who branded me the town witch? Checkity-check, check.
Okay, so technically the last bit was true—but no one knew that.
But of all the squares that could have been called, having one of my tormentors ask me out on a date sure as hell wasn’t one I’d ever thought I’d cross off.
Taylor Hallows left our tiny town twelve years ago and seemingly never looked back. But now that he’s returned, I can’t seem to avoid him.
He’s everywhere I look. The bar, the grocery store—even my own shop. He’s like a weed that refuses to go away.
I don’t want him there, but I also find myself constantly looking for him. He’s charming and sweet and seems so genuine. An annoyingly beautiful, bespectacled, six-foot contradiction to the smug kid I knew in high school. Despite all signs pointing to a new and improved Taylor, the hurt little girl in the back of my mind reminds me of how he used to be.
His relentless determination to earn a second chance has me wondering—does time really heal all wounds, or will letting him in be the worst mistake this witch ever makes?
✨With Practical Magic and Gilmore Girls inspired vibes this book was a perfect fall read. It’s a cozy witchy romcom set in a small town of Louisiana where you get that southern charm feel,the small town drama and a little bit of magic running beneath the surface. ✨ I really enjoyed the FMC Magnolia, she was unique in both personality and looks. And then there’s the MMC Taylor who is not only a hot doctor but also a walking green flag. Mags and Taylor had a rough past in high school with the town and his friends bullied her and her family after accusing them of being witches. Now that he’s back in town and completely smitten with her, despite not being 100% sure she can open her heart and trust him, she can’t deny the chemistry and attraction between them. Taylor is so kind and patient with her and continues to prove that not only has he changed for the better he also wasn’t willing to give up on her or their connection. The tension, banter and spice were chefs kiss 💋 I loved the side characters as well, they were so funny. Including her maincoon familiars, Meowfoy and Hermeownie. 🐈⬛🐈
✨This was such a cute book, I definitely look forward to reading the rest of series. Thank you again Jessica Hoffa for allowing me to read the arc.
Just finished “Charmed, I’m Sure” by Jessica Hoffa and I’m absolutely in love! 😍 This small-town romance is perfect for cozy fall vibes, where he falls first. The story has just the right amount of spice, and the characters are simply unforgettable. I’m thrilled to hear that Jessica has more stories coming our way from Bellevue!
You know a book is good when you can read it twice and love it just as much the second time around!
This small town witchy read is perfect for readers who love authors such as- Lucy Score (for her small town) x Meghan Quinn (for her romcom LOL moments) x Catherine Cowels (for her quirky aunt/ side characters) x Jessica Claire (for her witchy romcom vibes)
🪄🐈⬛☀️💕
Tropes include
💕Small town Romance 🖤 Reverse Grumpy x Sunshine 💕Tension, Witty & Banter filled 🐈⬛ Magical cat familiars 🪄 Witchy Sisters 💕 Gilmore Girls x Practical Magic 🖤New Orleans/ Louisiana lore
This was so cute! I’ve been reading different genres and this was the heart melting love story I didn’t know I needed! It’s set in small town Louisiana with a witchy history. The witch magic is kept a secret but the blooming love is magical in its own way. There’s fighting, there’s loving, there’s secrets, there’s magical cats! It was a fun love story to read!
Enjoyed this first installment in what I hope is the Witches of Bellevue series! It was an enemies to lovers romance story focusing on Magnolia Bellevue & Taylor Hallows, who had attended high school together. Taylor returns to town after some years and is immediately taken with Magnolia (he falls first ... swoon!). Magnolia isn't initially sure she wanted to befriend Taylor, as he was part of a group of kids that bullied her. The Bellevue family is tormented by the town residents (who accuse them of being witches) and that's an issue that tries to stand in the way of their romance.
Bonus points for Taylor being a great MMC, who cares about consent and works to understand where Magnolia is coming from. He knows early on how he feels for Magnolia and is patient and waits for her to catch up. In the end, we get our happily ever after.
I was picked to be an ARC for this book 5⭐️ for the story line and for me a 3.5 on 🌶️.
Being from the South, it was nice to read about an area I actually knew about. The small hints towards Disney things was great! I just wanted to kick Kyle in the face like bro you are too old for all this. But it makes sense with a small town. I loved the ending this book had. Reading it was wonderful. I couldn’t put it down. Every chance I had to read this, I took it. The spice was perfectly introduced. I loved how I got to like live in the characters head. The off the wall corny stuff being said reminded me so much of home. Thank you giving the chance to be an ARC, I loved it. I am (impatiently) patiently waiting for book two!
If you’re looking for the perfect spooky/cozy season read, Charmed, I’m Sure is THAT!
This is book 1 in the Witches of Bellevue series.
Gilmore Girls x Practical Magic Hilarious aunt Small town romance Reverse grumpy / sunshine The tension and banter 🥵 Magical cats (Meowfy & Hermeownie!!!) Witchy Sisters
This follows our FMC Magnolia and our MMC Taylor. Magnolia and her family have always been bullied in their town and Taylor is the now walking green flag of a doctor who is trying his best to show magnolia he’s not the guy he used to be. She has a guarded heart. But the tension and banter 🥵
I look forward to reading the rest of this series! Thank you Jessica for the opportunity to ARC read this.
The first book in the Witches of Bellevue series was the perfect cozy, fall read! I knew I needed to read it as soon as I saw the tropes and blurb, and it did not disappoint!
Located in small town Louisiana, the book follows Magnolia and Taylor who went to high school together. Now adults, they meet again, and the tension is high right from the beginning. Taylor (now hot doctor) was part of the group who bullied Mags back in school. He falls head over heels for her. Magnolia (witch and now baker), on the other hand, is not happy to see him back in town. Yet somehow, he is everywhere she goes, and she can't quite deny the chemistry they have.
The banter is immediate when you open the book, and I am here for it! Being from the south (and a frequent visitor of NOLA and surrounding towns) I really enjoyed how clearly the southern drawl came through the writing. I loved the side characters and the setting, the music and Disney references. The spice was perfect too!
Jessica was already on autobuy for me after her fantasy duology, but she knocked it out of the park with this witchy contemporary! I am (impatiently) waiting for book two!
Trope Menu for Charmed, I'm Sure: Magic & Witches Smalltown Romance Reverse Grumpy x Sunshine Banter & Tension Cat Familiars Second Chance Baker x Doctor
4⭐️, 3🌶️ This is a great book to read this Spooky season. Just like I’d imagine Magnolia’s are, this book is like the perfect recipe. A pinch of magic with a heap of sass, a dash of mystery, a sprinkle of bossy familiars, & splash of absolute adorableness, wrapped up in a nice romance bow. Loved Magnolia & Taylor’s love story. Magnolia was an adorable, quirky FMC & I really want to color my hair pink & blue now! Taylor was such a golden retriever & I loved every minute of his dedication to Magnolia. There was a bit of spice but nothing too over powering of the overall story. I am so glad I requested to read this book! I received an advance copy for free at my request after seeing the blurb for it. All my reviews are made voluntarily & are my honest thoughts/opinions. I do wish we got more insight/clarification on their past & certain things that happened during the book. But other than wanting more in-depth look at certain events, this book really was an enjoyable read. The writing was great & the pace was perfect. Would recommend this to anyone looking for a feel good, low angst love story with bit of a magical twist. I am looking forward to the future books in this series!
if you are gilmore girls and practical magic fan this is the book for you!!
i could not put this down once i started it! i was hooked from the beginning. the characters were all so great in their own ways too. normally i am not a big fan of the whole bully in high school/in the past so i was a little weary of taylor from the start. but then as i got to know him i really loved him. he was such a nice guy and really cared for magnolia.l, a character whom i respect so much. she was alwaya true to herself, was strong and honestly a better person than i am. if someone treated me the way they treated her and i was a witch, i definitely would have hexed one or two, or even a few more for it😅😅.
i really loved this book and i have a feeling it is going to be a major hit! thank you so much jessica hoffa for giving me this opportunity to read this arc
What To Expect: - witch fmc - enemies to lovers - cinnamon roll mmc - small town - reverse grumpy x sunshine - cat familiars - new orleans/louisiana
**I received an ARC copy of this book to give my honest feedback. 4-⭐ 3.5 🌶️
Set in Louisiana, this witchy romance has a large dash of Southern Charm, Small Town drama, love, cats, nosey sisters and of course magic. The banter between Taylor and Magnolia is a perfect balance. Grab a coffee and some pastries and settle in to read about Taylor and Magnolia. Taylor Hallows recently moved back home to his small town. While in high school he hung out with a group of kids that made Magnolia’s life not so pleasant an experience. He may not have done anything directly, but he certainly didn’t do anything to stop it. Now, he’s back and popping up everywhere. Magnolia Bellevue with her Cotton Candy colored hair is someone he can’t get out of his system. She’s fiery, sexy, funny and he wants more. Tropes: He falls first and waits, cinnamon roll, kisses in disguise, high school bully, Sassy Kittens, Sexy Dr.
I loved every single thing about this book! From the millennial lingo to the references to my favorite bands, this book was just *chefs kiss* Magnolia Bellevue & Taylor Hallows are perfectly made for each other. He’s a (hot) doctor and she owns a bakery/catering business. Her whole life she’s been tormented by the town accusing her and her family of being witches. Taylor happens to be one of the people who made her high school life horrible. It takes some time, but of course they get their happy ending 😍 I love that he wants to make her happy no matter what it takes or what it costs. He’s BIG on consent even if it’s implied and I love a self aware king! Taylor is officially added to my ever growing list of book boyfriends 😍
Honorable mention to the family’s cat familiars Meowfoy & Hermeownie 🥰
This is everything you would expect from a small town romance book. It did not disappoint this is my first book by Jessica Hoffa and I can't wait to read more. Magnolia is a quirky firecracker who had a tough time growing up losing her parents and then bullied and tormented throughout high school but she never let it affect her. Now a successful business owner she has regained control of her life until Taylor Hallows walks into it. One of her tormentors from school, now a successful doctor has changed and has Magnolia in his sights. He falls first but never gives up and slowly he breaks down her barriers and the chemistry is off the charts between them. They never give up even tho whispers through town are her family are witches. They conquer and get the happily ever after they both want. Would highly recommend this book. Thank you for letting me have an early ARC for an honest review
Hmmm…it was nice? Not a whole lot happens. I had a hard time staying focused and it took me a while to get through it. It wasn’t a bad book, it was just not holding my attention. It is a feel good, cozy romance with a dash of spice. Talking about spice though…. I really hate it when authors start a spicy scene and the MCs get interrupted continuously. Unfortunately that happens in this book…every time things started getting heated, something or someone interrupted them. And then it took a while for something to happen again. I mean…major bangxiety! The MCs were a bit bland. Taylor was sweet, but I didn’t get his infatuation with Magnolia. I don’t really know what else to say about the book, it was just a bit bland for me I guess.
Safety: - No OW/OM - No cheating - Short third act break up (a pause?) - Deals with bullying and loss of parents
I received an ARC for Third Times the Charm. It's the second book in the Witches of Bellevue series. I decided to start from the beginning and im so glad I did. This is Charmed, Im sure. I loved this book i Loved all the Princess Bride References and they music mentioned sounds like my Playlist. This is Magnolia and Taylor's story... Magnolia is a witch she owns a Chachutery company. Taylor is a Doctor. He just moved back to his hometown. Taylor was one of Magnolia's Childhood bullies not that he did anything to her. He just never stopped his "friends". When they meet again he is determined to prove that that he has changed and he wants a chance with her.He asks he to help his find a house. They are perfect together he never let's her down and is there for her. She is stubborn but she has a hard past. I cant wait for book 2.
This was such fun, easy and a wonderful read. I loved it from the moment I picked it up and read it so quickly because I couldn’t put it down. It gave Practical Magic vibes but small town in Louisiana with a tonne of spice hehe. Not really intense magic but just the little uses of magic to help everyday life was quite refreshing for a cosy read. It’s a contemporary romance with some excellent banter - Magnolia (FMC) is fierce, loyal and one of the sweetest people ever. I loved reading her story and how much she went through to become who she was. When Taylor is introduced (MMC), sparks FLEW. I was obsessed with their chemistry the whole time. I highly highly recommend reading this book! You will not be disappointed
if you’re a *gilmore girls* or *practical magic* girly, this book is absolutely your vibe.
i picked it up and didn’t put it down once (except to sleep)—hooked from page one. every character had their own charm, and honestly, i wasn’t sure how i’d feel about taylor at first. i’m usually not a fan of the whole “high school bully” backstory, so i went in a little skeptical. but the more i got to know him, the more i adored him. he’s such a soft, genuine guy who truly cares for magnolia.
and magnolia? i love her. she’s strong, stays true to herself, and handles things with a grace i can only aspire to. because let’s be real… if i were a witch and people treated me the way they treated her, i’d have hexed a *few* folks without a second thought. ✨
This cozy, witchy story was a perfect fall read. It gave off total Practical Magic vibes. Magnolia was such a unique character. I really liked her positivity, strength, and determination in the face of the adversity she'd faced in her life. Her high school tormentor turned hot doctor, Taylor, is the book boyfriend I didn't know I needed. He's a walking green flag. Hoffa also gives us a great cast of quirky side characters. I can't decide who liked more - her aunt, sisters, or best friend Jae. Even better we get "talking" cat familiars. With the cutest names!
Our story provides great themes on consent and mental health. And I loved all the little southern touches. Including the pronunciation guide/ dictionary at the beginning of the book.
Featured tropes: small town, he falls first, witches, reverse grumpy sunshine
I can't wait to see what else Hoffa and the town of Bellevue have to offer!
This book somehow combines Gilmore Girls, Charmed and everything I loved as a young adult. I love the small-town setting and the female main character. She is truly unique as far as looks and character go. I really enjoy the fact that she gives the MMC a second chance sort of and Taylor is all green flags ever combined into one guy. I would have loved a bit more magic in the books but it would not have fit with the plot too well and I get that. I also love the cat names and the fact that she listens to Paramore and all those 2000s emo classics. It made my heart sing. It is an amazing witchy romance read by an Indie author you should definitely add to your tb!
What an absolutely great witchy small town romance! I love that Magnolia actually has and uses magic. Taylor is a freaking swoony hot as hell doctor! I couldn’t get enough of them! The enemies to lovers aspect gave me all the feels! I laughed, I got teary eyed, I got frustrated. Loved the location setting for the book with the appropriate weather included. And let’s not forget the side character pets! Loved those cats and made me wish I could communicate with my animals but then I thought better of it and now I don’t actually want to know what my pets have to say to me!🤣 Great book and I am very much looking forward to the next book! Definitely recommend!
I just knew I was going to love this book! It had so many of my favorite tropes: witty/banter filled, reverse grumpy x sunshine, witchy sister, sassy familiars, and so many more. Plus, after reading the Gems of Ixora duology by Jessica, I had high expectations and she did not disappoint.
This is a perfect read for this time of year. Its full of all of the witchy Practical Magic vibes and the sister and town dynamics gave Gilmore Girls. Magnolia and Taylor were fantastic characters and I loved the dual POV so we got to really know each one of them. I LOVED Taylor. He is officially a new book boyfriend. Jessica just knows how to write MMCs.
Just read this book! Its amazing. Enjoyed every second of reading it. Jessica is an auto-buy author for me. I gotta support PNW authors!
What to expect: Magic & Witches Sister bonds Smalltown Romance Set in New Orleans area Cat familiars Second chance Baker x Doctor Reverse Grumpy x Sunshine TENSION Spice level 3.5🌶️
This was cute as hell and I loved every minute of it. Magnolia is a bad ass who has grown used to being the pariah and on the outskirts of her town, while Taylor is the kid who wanted to fit in when he was in high school and has now come back a totally different person.
He is the epitome of a green flag golden retriever - even if he has some communication issues. She is, understandably, guarded and fights their chemistry due to how the rest of the town is and their own history.
But when they finally come together and she believes this new side of him? Ugh, perfection! And those cats! I just loved all of this so much!
I’ve seen many books claim to be a mix of Gilmore Girls and Practical Magic and have been let down by them but this, this really is that book!!! I loved our FMC Magnolia (and wish I could have her hair). I was horribly bullied when I was growing up and moved away from my small town as soon as I could so I definitely connect with her and the things she’s had to deal with. I’m not sure I’d be as forgiving as her though lol. This book has all the cosy small town vibes, romance, suspense, drama and quite possible the book boyfriend to ruin everyone’s relationships lol. I highly recommend this book to everyone and cannot wait to read the rest of the series when it’s written!
I absolutely adored this book. I am a sucker for cozy fall reads when transitioning from the blistering Texas heat to a more mellow fall weather, and this book hit the spot. The beautiful town of Bellevue, had the perfect mix of magic, romance and culture. Jessica portrays the town outcast well, and brings such a beautiful ending to a romantic journey. I resonate with Mags so much as someone who didn’t quite fit in, but is finding her place in her small town. This checks all the boxes for the perfect cozy romance. I can’t want to read the rest of the series!
This was such a perfect fall/ spooky season book! I love books in the fall that are supernatural, but still contemporary and this one gave the best cozy vibes! I loved the growth between Mags and Taylor and how you slowly got to see Mags let her walls down. I loved the warmth of their family’s and how supportive they were of each other. It gave all the cozy feels. The angsty and hard times didn’t hit quite as hard as I wanted them to since they were moved past so quickly. I really like to sit in my misery before I’m lifted back up hahaha.
Charmed, I’m Sure is a cozy, witchy second-chance romance with plenty of charm (and snark). Maggie is a funny, relatable heroine, and watching her navigate old wounds and new sparks with Taylor her former bully turned unexpected suitor kept me hooked.
The small-town setting, magical vibes, and slow-burn tension hit all the right notes. A few tropes felt familiar, but the heart and humor more than made up for it. Great for fans of quirky towns, redemption arcs, and witches who don’t take any crap. 🖤
First I want to say thank you for providing me an ARC 💕 Secondly I gave this book a 4.5!! It was a charming (literally) book and I just fell in love with the MMC Taylor 🥰 He was sooo sweet, enduring and overall just really cared so much for Magnolia that I just loved them together. The only reason I gave it 4.5 and not 5 was I felt there could have be more tension in the plot instead of the usual high school bullies that don’t grow up type of thing so it could have been more Imo. Overall definitely a Gilmore vibe and a perfect cozy read for the season 🫶🏽
Are you in the mood for a "Fall" book? Maybe something akin to Practical Magic meets Sabrina with some Charmed thrown in there? This book has it all.
Cozy Fall vibes, useful and fun magic, groveling, banter, awesome familiars that are just as sassy as their witches. Taylor and Magnolia are the perfect balance of sass and genuinely fun banter. So if you need a book for some October vibes, mixed with romance, some spice, and a lot of small town fun - look no further.