A collection of stories about love of all kinds from YAs top authors – sounds perfect, right? It missed the mark for me.
At nearly 600 pages, Love Hurts should be cram-packed full of wonder, but in the entire book there are only six original short stories; the rest is extracts! I’m personally not a huge fan of extracts and most of the ones in this collection are from books I’ve either read or already know I’m not that fussed by, but the variety in them is wonderful. Full diversity in character, author, theme, style and protagonist is displayed and I think that Love Hurts is more for a YA newbie than a seasoned reader. I can imagine someone new to YA picking this up, reading the extracts and stories and then devouring each novel and author in the book in turn. But as I only read the short stories, here’s what I thought:
HUMMING THROUGH MY FINGERS, MALORIE BLACKMAN
I enjoyed this one, but I didn’t love it. It was sweet, original and eye-opening (Amber is blind and has synaesthesia) but I’m still waiting to fall in love with Malorie Blackman’s writing – my brain must be wired differently to ever other fan of YA!
TUMBLING, SUSIE DAY
This story is a fangirl’s dream story. Sherlock, fandom, falling in love with a like-minded soul over the internet and meeting them living up to every expectation. Tumbling is a really sweet story with a POC heroine and LGBT relationship that will resonate with every internet dweller out there.
GENTLEWOMAN, LAURA DOCKRILL
I love Laura Dockrill. She’s extremely talented with characters and humour and this story of a transgender teen working up the courage to come out to her best friend and everyone in school. It’s a soft, quiet story of strength and friendship and it really showed off Dockrill’s talents.
MISS LUCY HAD A STEAMBOAT, DAVID LEVITHAN
I’ve actually read this story before – it’s featured in Levithan’s collection How We Met and Other Stories and I liked it just as much the second time around. As always, Levithan delivers frank, honest and often brutal feelings with a hefty punch.
ENDLESS LOVE, LAUREN KATE
Honestly, I didn’t read this one. I got a page in and skipped ahead. It was linked to Luce and Daniel from her Fallen series.
THE LIAR’S GIRL, CATHERINE JOHNSON
This is the most surprising story in the collection, in my opinion. Set in 19th Century London, Catherien Johnson explores race, class, love, betrayal and revenge and delivers a shocking twist in only a few pages. I’m definitely interested in seeking out more from this author.
THE UNICORN, JAMES DAWSON
I loved this story. I was really glad to end the book on it. Told in retrospective, Reg looks back to the 60s and his time in the Navy where he fell in love with Frankie. It’s a sad story full of longing and impending heartbreak – forbidden relationships with serious consequences and a lost love that haunts him forever. Gorgeous. My favourite in the collection.
So if you have a budding YA fan in your midst, Love Hurts is for you.