REVIEW ON "THE POPE OF ATLANTIS" BY WILLIAM FERRAIOLO
The Pope of Atlantis" by William Ferraiolo is a philosophical and satirical novel that blends elements of speculative fiction, theology, and political allegory. Ferraiolo, primarily known for his work on Stoicism, uses this narrative to explore the intersection of power, belief, and human nature.
Review on Plot
The novel is set in a fictionalized version of Atlantis—not as a sunken myth, but as a thriving, technologically advanced, yet spiritually decadent society. The plot centers on the unexpected elevation of a new "Pope" to lead the Atlantean religious-political machine.
Unlike traditional tales of Atlantis that focus on its destruction, Ferraiolo focuses on its internal rot. The story follows the protagonist’s journey through the labyrinthine bureaucracy and moral compromises of the Atlantean elite. The narrative serves as a vehicle for the author to critique modern religious institutions and the ways in which spiritual truths are often weaponized for political control. The "fall" of Atlantis in this book is less about a physical flood and more about a slow-motion ethical collapse.
Critical Review:
Strengths:
Intellectual Depth: Ferraiolo’s background in philosophy shines through. The book is dense with ideas about Stoicism, the nature of God, and the corrupting influence of absolute power. It challenges the reader to think rather than just consume a story.
Satirical Wit: The book is effectively "mean" in its satire. It successfully skewers the pomposity of organized religion and the absurdity of political posturing.
Unique World-Building: Instead of the standard "swords and sandals" Atlantis, the author creates a world that feels eerily relevant to 21st-century concerns regarding technology and moral decay.
Ferraiolo takes the "immortal man" concept and strips away the glamour. Usually, being unable to die is a superpower; here, it is a spiritual prison. The book shines when it explores the psychological toll of outliving the world.
Weaknesses:
Pacing: Because the book is so focused on philosophical discourse, the plot can sometimes feel secondary. Readers looking for a fast-paced action-adventure may find the long meditative passages and dialogues tedious.
Dense Prose: Ferraiolo uses a sophisticated, sometimes academic vocabulary. While this fits the "Pope" persona and the setting, it can make the book less accessible to a general audience.
Character Relatability: The characters often feel more like "types" or "philosophical positions" rather than flesh-and-blood people. It can be hard to form an emotional connection with the protagonist when he is so occupied with abstract thought.
Conclusion:
"The Pope of Atlantis" is a thinking person’s fantasy novel. It is less about the "where" of Atlantis and more about the "why" of human civilization. It is a recommended read for anyone interested in a Stoic’s take on the collapse of a superpower. It is a haunting reminder that the greatest threat to any society is rarely an external enemy, but its own loss of purpose.