What do you think?
Rate this book
Nyes Landing Crime Mystery #2
A Fatal Affair
A mysterious death, a town on edge, and a relationship on the rocks—can Officer Nowak uncover the truth before he loses everything?
When an outbreak of food poisoning disrupts the opening night party for the Nyes Landing Players’ debut production, paramedics rush a drunken actor to the hospital—where he later dies. The medical examiner rules his death was due to “acute mixed drug and alcohol toxicity.” But Officer Cal Nowak has seen his share of overdoses, and something doesn’t sit right. He suspects there’s more to the incident than a bad batch of meatballs.
A cheating wife, a ruthless husband, feuding neighbors, a skittish housekeeper, and a mysterious woman with a dark secret all test Cal’s investigative skills at every turn. But his relentless pursuit of the truth comes at a personal cost. His relationship with Demetrius—a divorced father navigating his first relationship with a man—begins to fracture under the strain. As Cal’s obsession with the case deepens, Demetrius questions their future together.
Tensions rise as the mayor pressures the police chief to rein Cal in, delivering an ultimatum: drop the case or lose his badge. Undeterred, Cal risks his career—and his heart—to bring a killer to justice.
Set in 2003, A Fatal Affair is the second novel in the Nyes Landing Crime Mystery series. If you enjoy small town murder mysteries that feature a gay romance, like Joseph Hansen’s Fadeout, Michael Nava’s Lay Your Sleeping Head, or Pretty Pretty Boys by Gregory Ashe, don’t miss this absorbing mystery layered with emotion and secrets that refuse to stay buried.
When an outbreak of food poisoning disrupts the opening night party for the Nyes Landing Players’ debut production, paramedics rush a drunken actor to the hospital—where he later dies. The medical examiner rules his death was due to “acute mixed drug and alcohol toxicity.” But Officer Cal Nowak has seen his share of overdoses, and something doesn’t sit right. He suspects there’s more to the incident than a bad batch of meatballs.
A cheating wife, a ruthless husband, feuding neighbors, a skittish housekeeper, and a mysterious woman with a dark secret all test Cal’s investigative skills at every turn. But his relentless pursuit of the truth comes at a personal cost. His relationship with Demetrius—a divorced father navigating his first relationship with a man—begins to fracture under the strain. As Cal’s obsession with the case deepens, Demetrius questions their future together.
Tensions rise as the mayor pressures the police chief to rein Cal in, delivering an ultimatum: drop the case or lose his badge. Undeterred, Cal risks his career—and his heart—to bring a killer to justice.
Set in 2003, A Fatal Affair is the second novel in the Nyes Landing Crime Mystery series. If you enjoy small town murder mysteries that feature a gay romance, like Joseph Hansen’s Fadeout, Michael Nava’s Lay Your Sleeping Head, or Pretty Pretty Boys by Gregory Ashe, don’t miss this absorbing mystery layered with emotion and secrets that refuse to stay buried.
278 pages, Paperback
Published June 17, 2025
9 people are currently reading
8 people want to read
About the author
S.F. Williams
2 booksS. F. Williams is a member of the Alliance of Independent Authors (ALLi), the Mystery Writers of America (MWA), and the NYC Writers Critique Group. He has a diverse portfolio that ranges from published short stories and poetry to reflections on fatherhood as a single gay man, but his roots lie in the theater. Williams holds a BFA from the University of Oklahoma and membership in the Actor’s Equity Association, and he has acted in, directed, produced, and written over a hundred productions for the stage.
Williams’s novels, characterized by their fast-paced narratives and resilient protagonists, reflect the diverse tapestry of our world.
A Fatal Affair releases June 2025!
Williams’s novels, characterized by their fast-paced narratives and resilient protagonists, reflect the diverse tapestry of our world.
A Fatal Affair releases June 2025!
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews
June 29, 2025
I'm really bad at writing reviews but I'll give it a go. I did enjoy the first book in this series but I think this book is much better in character development. We get to see the relationships between the characters deepen and growth from the main character. The crime and suspect was a bit obvious half way through the book, but that didn't take away my enjoyment of the story and how Nowak pieced the evidence together.
If you enjoyed the first book I definitely recommend the sequel, and I'll be keeping an eye out for a third book.
If you enjoyed the first book I definitely recommend the sequel, and I'll be keeping an eye out for a third book.
October 17, 2025
There are a lot of characters continuing from the first book, the back stories of many of these are not always fully recapped so new readers to the series should be forewarned. That said, I enjoyed this better than the first - Cal's hard edges are beginning to be rubbed off somewhat and I still believe Demetrius is too good to be true. I did work out the plot twist to the murder around the midway mark but the brisk plot pacing kept me going til the end. I'm also quite invested with the overarching plot regarding our MC's parents (and what happened to them).
July 21, 2025
A Fatal Affair is a cozy mystery with a sharp, sly, character-rich story set in the sleepy town of Nyes Landing, where drama unfolds both on stage and off. The plot kicks off with Officer Callum Nowak dealing with a belligerent actor at a local tavern, and it snowballs into a tangled mess involving poisoned meatballs, backstabbing actors, an ambitious theater production, and one very chaotic opening night. As the small-town cops try to uncover what made a dozen townsfolk sick and nearly killed Oliver Crispin, the reader is treated to a fast-paced, often hilarious, and sometimes poignant whodunit.
From the very first chapter, I was thoroughly engaged. Callum emerges as a compelling narrator, direct, introspective, and burdened with a complex personal history that adds real depth to the narrative. From the opening barroom confrontation with the volatile Crispin, a character who consistently tests the boundaries of acceptable behavior, it’s clear this is no conventional detective story. Williams's writing is sharp and kinetic, with brisk dialogue and a narrative pace that rarely lets up. Scenes unfold with a kind of controlled chaos, where tension builds only to erupt in the most unexpected ways, such as the unforgettable moment during the theater scene, when guests begin hallucinating and turning on each other in a frenzy of accusations. It's outrageous, unpredictable, and thoroughly compelling.
Williams also handles the emotional undercurrents of the story with remarkable sensitivity. Callum’s relationships, particularly with his boyfriend, Demetrius, and his longtime friend, Annie, are portrayed with nuance and authenticity. His emotional distance and reluctance to fully embrace intimacy add a compelling layer to the central mystery. Moments like the tense camping discussion, the uneasy dinner with Demetrius and Annie, and the confrontation at the crime scene reveal a man grappling not only with external conflict but with internal scars that refuse to fade. This is as much a story of emotional survival as it is of uncovering the truth.
Some of the dialogue occasionally veers into melodramatic territory. Characters like Daphne, the self-styled diva, and her theatrical circle often feel as though they’ve stepped out of a reality television set, with moments of exaggerated flair that strain plausibility. Lines such as “They’re witches!” or Ernest Drucker’s over-the-top reactions can be both amusing and distracting. However, this heightened drama ultimately suits the tone of the novel. Nyes Landing is a town brimming with unresolved tensions, long-standing feuds, and relentless gossip, and it’s this very turbulence that fuels the narrative’s energy. Even the local goat farm is not without its share of theatrics.
A Fatal Affair is sharp-witted, queer-friendly, and packed with snappy dialogue and messy humans. If you're into small-town mysteries with theater kids, found families, emotional baggage, and a touch of camp, this book’s for you. Fans of Only Murders in the Building, Knives Out, or even Gilmore Girls with body bags will feel right at home in Nyes Landing.
From the very first chapter, I was thoroughly engaged. Callum emerges as a compelling narrator, direct, introspective, and burdened with a complex personal history that adds real depth to the narrative. From the opening barroom confrontation with the volatile Crispin, a character who consistently tests the boundaries of acceptable behavior, it’s clear this is no conventional detective story. Williams's writing is sharp and kinetic, with brisk dialogue and a narrative pace that rarely lets up. Scenes unfold with a kind of controlled chaos, where tension builds only to erupt in the most unexpected ways, such as the unforgettable moment during the theater scene, when guests begin hallucinating and turning on each other in a frenzy of accusations. It's outrageous, unpredictable, and thoroughly compelling.
Williams also handles the emotional undercurrents of the story with remarkable sensitivity. Callum’s relationships, particularly with his boyfriend, Demetrius, and his longtime friend, Annie, are portrayed with nuance and authenticity. His emotional distance and reluctance to fully embrace intimacy add a compelling layer to the central mystery. Moments like the tense camping discussion, the uneasy dinner with Demetrius and Annie, and the confrontation at the crime scene reveal a man grappling not only with external conflict but with internal scars that refuse to fade. This is as much a story of emotional survival as it is of uncovering the truth.
Some of the dialogue occasionally veers into melodramatic territory. Characters like Daphne, the self-styled diva, and her theatrical circle often feel as though they’ve stepped out of a reality television set, with moments of exaggerated flair that strain plausibility. Lines such as “They’re witches!” or Ernest Drucker’s over-the-top reactions can be both amusing and distracting. However, this heightened drama ultimately suits the tone of the novel. Nyes Landing is a town brimming with unresolved tensions, long-standing feuds, and relentless gossip, and it’s this very turbulence that fuels the narrative’s energy. Even the local goat farm is not without its share of theatrics.
A Fatal Affair is sharp-witted, queer-friendly, and packed with snappy dialogue and messy humans. If you're into small-town mysteries with theater kids, found families, emotional baggage, and a touch of camp, this book’s for you. Fans of Only Murders in the Building, Knives Out, or even Gilmore Girls with body bags will feel right at home in Nyes Landing.
Displaying 1 - 3 of 3 reviews