What do you think?
Rate this book
Lucy Stone #31.5 - Halloween Night Murder
Halloween Night Murder
There’s usually a chill in the air when Halloween arrives—but in these three novellas by beloved cozy mystery authors Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, and Liz Ireland, the crimes are even colder than the haunted climate . . .
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER
After a tiring but satisfying day of organizing Halloween festivities, Lucy Stone is surprised by a lone late-night trick-or-treater at her home in Tinker’s Cove, Maine. The next morning, she’s heartbroken to learn that the teenager died in a hit-and-run just minutes after she gave him the last of her candy supply. Haunted, she starts digging into his story—and discovers some dark secrets . . .
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS
Bad weather has stranded restaurateur Hayley Powell and her friends in rural Maine—and the only shelter available is a spooky spot where they’re welcomed warmly by the lady of the house—but coldly by her suspicious, gun-toting son. They’re even more nervous after he scares them with his Halloween zombie costume—but the real fright is yet to come . . .
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND
Disgraced elf Flake has returned from exile just in time for Halloween, but not everyone in Christmastown thinks he’s truly reformed. When Pumblechook the snowman suffers a mysterious fate, and a fellow elf is felled by Flake’s caramels, Mrs. Claus must determine whether the sticky-fingered Flake has become a hardened criminal—or if sorcery has invaded Santaland . . .
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER
After a tiring but satisfying day of organizing Halloween festivities, Lucy Stone is surprised by a lone late-night trick-or-treater at her home in Tinker’s Cove, Maine. The next morning, she’s heartbroken to learn that the teenager died in a hit-and-run just minutes after she gave him the last of her candy supply. Haunted, she starts digging into his story—and discovers some dark secrets . . .
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS
Bad weather has stranded restaurateur Hayley Powell and her friends in rural Maine—and the only shelter available is a spooky spot where they’re welcomed warmly by the lady of the house—but coldly by her suspicious, gun-toting son. They’re even more nervous after he scares them with his Halloween zombie costume—but the real fright is yet to come . . .
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND
Disgraced elf Flake has returned from exile just in time for Halloween, but not everyone in Christmastown thinks he’s truly reformed. When Pumblechook the snowman suffers a mysterious fate, and a fellow elf is felled by Flake’s caramels, Mrs. Claus must determine whether the sticky-fingered Flake has become a hardened criminal—or if sorcery has invaded Santaland . . .
Hardcover
Published October 1, 2025
172 people are currently reading
282 people want to read
About the author
Leslie Meier
69 books2,069 followersLeslie Meier lives in Braintree and Harwich (Cape Cod), Massachusetts. She is the creator of 'Lucy Stone', a reporter and amateur sleuth in the fictional seaside village of Tinker's Cove, Maine.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews
September 10, 2025
What better than a few cozy murder mystery novellas set around Halloween from some of your favorite series authors. Whether it's a hit-and-run killer to an escaped patient with a grudge, there's sure to be some curious shenanigans. Can't wait for the season to officially start. Fans will adore this quick reads.
August 26, 2025
4.5 stars
Each of the three stories in this collection takes place on Halloween night, but they are very different. Usually these three-novella collections contain holiday-themed cozy mysteries. In my opinion, only one of the stories this time is cozy, but all are good.
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier - Lucy Stone, is a reporter in Tinker's Cove, Maine. Lucy helps organize a Halloween night fundraiser and later at home, gives candy to an older, late-night trick-or-treater. The next morning Lucy is devastated to learn the teen was killed in a hit-and-run accident in front of her house. Lucy is suspicious of the circumstances and becomes involved in a difficult situation. This suspenseful, but sad mystery deals with serious, somewhat political issues.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis is a creepy, scary story that reads like a thriller. Hayley, Mona, and Liddy are driving from Boston back to Maine on Halloween night. A car accident forces them to seek help at a spooky-looking house where a mother and son offer their hospitality but seem to be hiding something. This story is tense and has definite horror movie vibes. It's a great story for Halloween, but only Hayley's blog posts about past Halloweens that are mixed in with the story are cozy.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland is a fun, cozy mystery story. Santaland is celebrating Halloween with several different activities. Something happens to one of the town's snowmen and an elf with a checked past is blamed. April. Claus takes the drastic measure of asking a temperamental witch to help the snowman. This is a humorous story (and this entire series) will make you believe in Santa (and Mrs. Claus).
I received an advance copy of this ebook from Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley for review consideration. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
Each of the three stories in this collection takes place on Halloween night, but they are very different. Usually these three-novella collections contain holiday-themed cozy mysteries. In my opinion, only one of the stories this time is cozy, but all are good.
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier - Lucy Stone, is a reporter in Tinker's Cove, Maine. Lucy helps organize a Halloween night fundraiser and later at home, gives candy to an older, late-night trick-or-treater. The next morning Lucy is devastated to learn the teen was killed in a hit-and-run accident in front of her house. Lucy is suspicious of the circumstances and becomes involved in a difficult situation. This suspenseful, but sad mystery deals with serious, somewhat political issues.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis is a creepy, scary story that reads like a thriller. Hayley, Mona, and Liddy are driving from Boston back to Maine on Halloween night. A car accident forces them to seek help at a spooky-looking house where a mother and son offer their hospitality but seem to be hiding something. This story is tense and has definite horror movie vibes. It's a great story for Halloween, but only Hayley's blog posts about past Halloweens that are mixed in with the story are cozy.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland is a fun, cozy mystery story. Santaland is celebrating Halloween with several different activities. Something happens to one of the town's snowmen and an elf with a checked past is blamed. April. Claus takes the drastic measure of asking a temperamental witch to help the snowman. This is a humorous story (and this entire series) will make you believe in Santa (and Mrs. Claus).
I received an advance copy of this ebook from Kensington Books, Kensington Cozies, and NetGalley for review consideration. My review is voluntary and unbiased.
December 3, 2025
This book contains 3 stories. I read the stories over time. In between the stories I read novels by other authors. Thank you for your patience. My review of the third story is finally here.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER
I enjoyed Halloween Night Murder. The author was very creative. The mystery of the death of a teen trick o’ treater via hit & run prompts Lucy, a small town journalist to investigate the incident which leads to uncovering complex criminal activities leading to a powerful person in the judicial court. What particularly intrigues me about this story is how Lucy relates to her husband, family, colleagues and other people whom she interfaces with. Lucy shows sympathy and empathy towards others especially those in need or are troubled. Rather pointing out faults, she looks for ways to help them. She shows generosity and acceptance opposed to being judgmental or conveying condemnation. For me, Lucy is the “gem” of the story. I admire her character and her actions which are consistent with her character.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN STALKER
Lee Hollis
A Fun but terrifying story of three friends whose return trip home on Halloween unexpectedly turned into a night of terror. The friends were anxious to return home in time for the Halloween evening which leads to a car crash in an isolated forested area. They come across a lonely home welcomed by a woman and her son. Gradually, what appeared to be a sanctuary until the torrential rain storm subsides, degenerates into a night of terror and murder. The friends have no one but each other and their wits to survive.
There are some interesting Halloween memories of one of the friends with recipes shared.
MRS. CLAUS and THE WILEY WITCH
Liz Ireland
This story could have been called, “Halloween Murder in Santaland”. The author created an interesting world filled with Santa named Nick, Mrs. Claus, snow men, reindeer, witches and oodles of elves. The food choices were all very sweet with muffins, candies, caramels and other sweets. I felt like I gained 10 lbs just reading about all the food & eating! LOL! The story begins with the mysterious freezing of Pumblechook the snowman. Many elves believed an Exiled elf named Flake Butternut was the culprit, but Mrs. Claus had her doubts. She suspected someone put a spell on Pumblechook, and invited a friendly witch named Imelda to help remove the hex on the snowman & to investigate the murder of an elf as well as attempted murder of another elf. Together Mrs. Claus & Imelda follow leads to a successful conclusion.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER
I enjoyed Halloween Night Murder. The author was very creative. The mystery of the death of a teen trick o’ treater via hit & run prompts Lucy, a small town journalist to investigate the incident which leads to uncovering complex criminal activities leading to a powerful person in the judicial court. What particularly intrigues me about this story is how Lucy relates to her husband, family, colleagues and other people whom she interfaces with. Lucy shows sympathy and empathy towards others especially those in need or are troubled. Rather pointing out faults, she looks for ways to help them. She shows generosity and acceptance opposed to being judgmental or conveying condemnation. For me, Lucy is the “gem” of the story. I admire her character and her actions which are consistent with her character.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN STALKER
Lee Hollis
A Fun but terrifying story of three friends whose return trip home on Halloween unexpectedly turned into a night of terror. The friends were anxious to return home in time for the Halloween evening which leads to a car crash in an isolated forested area. They come across a lonely home welcomed by a woman and her son. Gradually, what appeared to be a sanctuary until the torrential rain storm subsides, degenerates into a night of terror and murder. The friends have no one but each other and their wits to survive.
There are some interesting Halloween memories of one of the friends with recipes shared.
MRS. CLAUS and THE WILEY WITCH
Liz Ireland
This story could have been called, “Halloween Murder in Santaland”. The author created an interesting world filled with Santa named Nick, Mrs. Claus, snow men, reindeer, witches and oodles of elves. The food choices were all very sweet with muffins, candies, caramels and other sweets. I felt like I gained 10 lbs just reading about all the food & eating! LOL! The story begins with the mysterious freezing of Pumblechook the snowman. Many elves believed an Exiled elf named Flake Butternut was the culprit, but Mrs. Claus had her doubts. She suspected someone put a spell on Pumblechook, and invited a friendly witch named Imelda to help remove the hex on the snowman & to investigate the murder of an elf as well as attempted murder of another elf. Together Mrs. Claus & Imelda follow leads to a successful conclusion.
May 25, 2025
Halloween Night Murder is three cozy mystery Novelas written by Leslie Meyer, Leigh Hollis and Liz Ireland. When Lucy Stone is cleaning up after the Halloween event at her home she gets a late night trick-or-treater who she can instantly tell he threw his costume together but he seems very nice so she gives him the rest of the candy in the bowl. The next day she learns not only was he hit by a car But was killed when his head struck a rock on side the road. Lucy will get involved in the case more than she thought she would one clue leads to another in the case turns out to be much bigger than she first believed. in the second book Haley and her two best friends Mona and Lydia are coming home from a concert in Boston and veer off the road to avoid hitting a buck. They wreck Lydia‘s new car. They go to a nearby home and this is where they meet Bella and her son Gregory although Bella seems like the quintessential homemaker what they really have stumbled on as much stranger than any of them can’t believe to make matters worse Mona may have a concussion and doesn’t look well at all Lydia and Haley think Mona may be in danger but they soon learn all three of them are playing with life in depth,… Their life. in the next book we spend Halloween in the North Pole, an elf was recently released he once stole a peppermint recipe but flake butter worth isn’t going to be so easily believed especially when strange things start happening can Mrs. Claus solve the case before flake is once again accused of something only this time he may be innocent. I have recently been consuming lots of cozy mysteries and think I am becoming severely addicted to them whether they’re short long or in between it seems I cannot get enough and this one did not disappoint although I did find the first book seem to be cut down to fit the book I still enjoyed the story loved Lucy and will definitely read more of her books in the future I loved Mrs. Claus and the magical Christmas village with her and husband Nick live I loved all the crazy side characters but I must admit Haley made me laugh so much all of them were great stories for one reason or another they all have their charms and I can’t say a negative thing about any of them I love them and highly recommend them if you love cozy mysteries these are three you will not be disappointed by at all.#NetGalley, #KensingtonBooks, #TheBlindReviewer, #MyHonestReview, #LeslieMeyer, #LeighHollis, #LizIreland, #HalloweenNightMurder,
November 28, 2025
Lucy Stone investigates a Halloween night death via an apparent hit and run that happens right in her street. Cute cozy mystery-nothing special but ok.
April 21, 2025
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER
Lucy Stone's Halloween has been just as she planned it. The party, the kids, and finally, the time at home with husband, Bill, after everything was over. She'd only had to deal with one trick or treater at the house before she switched off her spooky vibes for another year. The following morning Lucy hears about a hit and run which killed a young reveller close to her house and is determined to follow the case in her guise of reporter for the Chronicle, her local online and physical newspaper. There appears to be very little to actually investigate, and any available information is brief and unhelpful. Determined to dig a little deeper, Lucy is soon shocked at what she discovers, but can she present her findings to someone she can trust, or has it all been in vain?
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS
A country music concert and a road trip with your besties sounded wonderful to Hayley Powell until the weather turned, the traffic snarled up, and they crashed into a tree! That was when it started to get dangerous! The only house, seemingly for miles, looked like a rain drenched haven, but something was a bit off with the folks who lived there! Unable to contact the outside world, Hayley, Libby, and Mona find themselves more and more desperate to leave, but with no transport and no phone signal, will this be their last ever road trip?
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND
With Halloween just around the corner, and after spending five years in exile, Flake, an expert caramel maker with poor judgement, is back in Christmastown. He is home just in time for a blue ribbon cooking competition which he should easily win but, unfortunately, before that can happen, Pumblechook the snowman and one of Flake's closest elf friends are hit with Halloween misfortune and murder! Mrs Claus is almost sure Flake has been framed but must follow the clues to find out who is responsible, even if it means the little elf can no longer make the best caramels in all of Santaland as well as having to invite a witch into Santa’s home to help remedy what has happened.
I love this series of books consisting of three short stories set around special holidays and occasions. I have discovered some great cosy titles through reading them and found more authors to follow. This trio is a little different to normal, though, but no less engaging. The first two stories are more serious than usual, covering poverty, domestic abuse, seriously creepy home owners, stalking and, of course, murder! I would consider both to be crime fiction rather than cosy crime fiction. Liz Ireland's tale, however, is definitely a cosy, the eponymous witch steals every scene she's in, and Halloween in Santaland? What's not to love?
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cosies, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although not what I envisioned originally, the stories are engaging, and I enjoyed all three.
Lucy Stone's Halloween has been just as she planned it. The party, the kids, and finally, the time at home with husband, Bill, after everything was over. She'd only had to deal with one trick or treater at the house before she switched off her spooky vibes for another year. The following morning Lucy hears about a hit and run which killed a young reveller close to her house and is determined to follow the case in her guise of reporter for the Chronicle, her local online and physical newspaper. There appears to be very little to actually investigate, and any available information is brief and unhelpful. Determined to dig a little deeper, Lucy is soon shocked at what she discovers, but can she present her findings to someone she can trust, or has it all been in vain?
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS
A country music concert and a road trip with your besties sounded wonderful to Hayley Powell until the weather turned, the traffic snarled up, and they crashed into a tree! That was when it started to get dangerous! The only house, seemingly for miles, looked like a rain drenched haven, but something was a bit off with the folks who lived there! Unable to contact the outside world, Hayley, Libby, and Mona find themselves more and more desperate to leave, but with no transport and no phone signal, will this be their last ever road trip?
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND
With Halloween just around the corner, and after spending five years in exile, Flake, an expert caramel maker with poor judgement, is back in Christmastown. He is home just in time for a blue ribbon cooking competition which he should easily win but, unfortunately, before that can happen, Pumblechook the snowman and one of Flake's closest elf friends are hit with Halloween misfortune and murder! Mrs Claus is almost sure Flake has been framed but must follow the clues to find out who is responsible, even if it means the little elf can no longer make the best caramels in all of Santaland as well as having to invite a witch into Santa’s home to help remedy what has happened.
I love this series of books consisting of three short stories set around special holidays and occasions. I have discovered some great cosy titles through reading them and found more authors to follow. This trio is a little different to normal, though, but no less engaging. The first two stories are more serious than usual, covering poverty, domestic abuse, seriously creepy home owners, stalking and, of course, murder! I would consider both to be crime fiction rather than cosy crime fiction. Liz Ireland's tale, however, is definitely a cosy, the eponymous witch steals every scene she's in, and Halloween in Santaland? What's not to love?
I was able to read an advanced copy of this thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Kensington Publishing, Kensington Cosies, but the opinions expressed are my own. Although not what I envisioned originally, the stories are engaging, and I enjoyed all three.
August 19, 2025
This anthology of three Halloween-themed cozy novellas was the perfect way to slip into spooky season! Each story had its own unique charm, and while some worked better for me than others, overall it was a fun collection.
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier
This was my first introduction to Leslie Meier, and I really enjoyed it! Lucy Stone is a character I definitely want to spend more time with. The mystery pulled me in quickly and had just enough Halloween flair to keep things festive without being over the top. And with 31 books in the Lucy Stone series, I think I’ll have plenty to keep me busy for a long while.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis
My favorite of the bunch! As someone who has read and loved the entire Hayley Powell series, this novella felt like coming home to familiar characters. In true Hayley fashion, what should have been a simple Halloween night turns into chaos, danger, and of course...a dead body. It had that strange-but-wonderful charm Lee Hollis always delivers, with the humor and wild situations I’ve come to expect.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland
This one just wasn’t for me. It’s not about the writing, Liz Ireland is talented, it just wasn’t my cup of tea. I think readers who enjoy her Mrs. Claus mysteries will love this holiday-crossover spin, but I couldn’t quite get into it.
All in all, this was a fun, festive read with plenty of chills, charm, and cozy mystery vibes. If you’re looking to get into the Halloween spirit with a little murder on the side, this is a great pick!
✨ Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the advance copy.
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier
This was my first introduction to Leslie Meier, and I really enjoyed it! Lucy Stone is a character I definitely want to spend more time with. The mystery pulled me in quickly and had just enough Halloween flair to keep things festive without being over the top. And with 31 books in the Lucy Stone series, I think I’ll have plenty to keep me busy for a long while.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis
My favorite of the bunch! As someone who has read and loved the entire Hayley Powell series, this novella felt like coming home to familiar characters. In true Hayley fashion, what should have been a simple Halloween night turns into chaos, danger, and of course...a dead body. It had that strange-but-wonderful charm Lee Hollis always delivers, with the humor and wild situations I’ve come to expect.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland
This one just wasn’t for me. It’s not about the writing, Liz Ireland is talented, it just wasn’t my cup of tea. I think readers who enjoy her Mrs. Claus mysteries will love this holiday-crossover spin, but I couldn’t quite get into it.
All in all, this was a fun, festive read with plenty of chills, charm, and cozy mystery vibes. If you’re looking to get into the Halloween spirit with a little murder on the side, this is a great pick!
✨ Thanks to NetGalley and Kensington Publishing for the advance copy.
August 10, 2025
Three novellas all centered around Halloween Night. I always love these collections from Kensington Books and this one does not disappoint. It's a very fast read.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by Leslie Meier- This one feels the least like Halloween. There is a thread in the plot I found interesting, and Leslie Meier knows how to keep you reading about daily activities. I'm not sure how I felt about some parts of the mystery. It's a quick, entertaining read though.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER- by Lee Hollis- Omg. This is perfect in every way. A true Halloween read. It hits all the right notes. Well written, exciting, creepy, funny, everything you could want. I can't say all the reasons why it's perfect because I want readers to be surprised and kind of go in blind. You do not want to miss this even if you don't usually read cozy mysteries. I loved it so much I want to read it again!
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by Liz Ireland- The Mrs. Claus series is one of my favorites and this novella doesn't disappoint. It feels the most like Halloween in terms of decorations and celebration. It's funny and charming as always.
4.5 stars
Thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the chance to read!
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by Leslie Meier- This one feels the least like Halloween. There is a thread in the plot I found interesting, and Leslie Meier knows how to keep you reading about daily activities. I'm not sure how I felt about some parts of the mystery. It's a quick, entertaining read though.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER- by Lee Hollis- Omg. This is perfect in every way. A true Halloween read. It hits all the right notes. Well written, exciting, creepy, funny, everything you could want. I can't say all the reasons why it's perfect because I want readers to be surprised and kind of go in blind. You do not want to miss this even if you don't usually read cozy mysteries. I loved it so much I want to read it again!
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by Liz Ireland- The Mrs. Claus series is one of my favorites and this novella doesn't disappoint. It feels the most like Halloween in terms of decorations and celebration. It's funny and charming as always.
4.5 stars
Thank you to Kensington Books and Netgalley for the chance to read!
August 30, 2025
Gave this 4 stars because of the first story. Loved it! Heartwrenching subject matter, but handled perfectly. The second story I was rolling my eyes through most of it. Not a fan of Liddy. Reaching for her cell phone while driving in hazardous conditions! Really?? She just got done saying she could barely see the road and then she does something so dangerous! And in the aftermath, doesn't even apologize for almost killing them. Some friend. Mona I love! What a hoot.
August 25, 2025
Three fun Halloween murder mysteries featuring some of our favorite cozy mystery characters. Lucy Stone was one again fighting injustice after a young teen was mowed down in a hit-and-run and wow did she ever uncover a hornet’s nest of nasty!
It’s always a hilarious road trip when Hayley, Mona and Liddy take off for a girls’ weekend. Boy did they get more than they bargained for this Halloween! Talk about a haunted house, I think they’d probably take real ghosts over what they had to deal with.
Finally, April aka Mrs. Claus was teaming up with witch Imelda (who was an absolute hoot and reminded me of Grandma Yetta if she was an elf witch lol) to find a killer and unhex the local snowman. Trying to stay alive in the process was the big challenge, but as always April faced a killer and lived to sleuth another day.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.
It’s always a hilarious road trip when Hayley, Mona and Liddy take off for a girls’ weekend. Boy did they get more than they bargained for this Halloween! Talk about a haunted house, I think they’d probably take real ghosts over what they had to deal with.
Finally, April aka Mrs. Claus was teaming up with witch Imelda (who was an absolute hoot and reminded me of Grandma Yetta if she was an elf witch lol) to find a killer and unhex the local snowman. Trying to stay alive in the process was the big challenge, but as always April faced a killer and lived to sleuth another day.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book provided by Kensington Cozies via NetGalley, and my opinions are my own.
November 3, 2025
All three novellas were fun, but the Lee Hollis story was my favorite. A great seasonal read!
August 22, 2025
Halloween Night Murder is a Halloween cozy mystery with 3 short cozy mystery stories.
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier: Lucy Stone is at it again, this time investigating a sad Halloween night hit and run of a teenage boy who had stopped by her house trick or treating. Lucy uses her detective skills, and her reporter contacts, to try and track down the hit and run driver. This one was a little sad, with the info Lucy learns about the murder victim, but she does everything she can to help, even housing the victims siblings for a night in her home. For once I actually did guess the murderer, so might be getting better at this!
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis: 3 friends crash their car on the way home from a concert on Halloween night, and find themselves in a very mysterious situation as they knock on the door of the first, and only, house they see around. This story really kept me on the edge of my seat, and for me, bordered on a thriller vs a cozy mystery. In a good way though, because while you kind of could guess the murderer, you really were on edge with the 3 friends on how they were going to survive their situation! And the creepy lady in the house...yikes!
""Dear child, if I wanted to kill you I would find a much less messy way of doing it." Her words were not exactly reassuring."
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland: Mrs. Claus and the elves of Christmastown are working tirelessly at decorating for the Halloween festivities. Unexpectedly, the beloved Pumblechook gets hexed, and then there is a murder, seemingly all done by the same recently returned exiled elf Flake Butternut. Mrs. Claus puts on her sleuthing hat and tries to get to the bottom of who may be using witchcraft in Christmastown. I am a little biased, but this was my favorite of the 3 stories, as I absolutely love the Mrs. Claus mysteries. I laughed out loud multiple times while reading about the amusing elves as they decorated for Halloween, and the elf witch Imelda's extreme sweet tooth and lack of decorum.
"This Halloween, every dwelling on Sugarplum Mountain was going to be a stop on the first-ever Sugarplum Spooky Sleigh Ride..."
"Call me a busybody, but I'd never witnessed a doctor examining a snowman. This I had to see for myself."
"Yes. He said I didn't have a permit to peddly my caramels, but that's a load of walrus poo."
Thank you so much to Kensington Books, Netgalley, and the authors for a copy of this book!
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier: Lucy Stone is at it again, this time investigating a sad Halloween night hit and run of a teenage boy who had stopped by her house trick or treating. Lucy uses her detective skills, and her reporter contacts, to try and track down the hit and run driver. This one was a little sad, with the info Lucy learns about the murder victim, but she does everything she can to help, even housing the victims siblings for a night in her home. For once I actually did guess the murderer, so might be getting better at this!
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis: 3 friends crash their car on the way home from a concert on Halloween night, and find themselves in a very mysterious situation as they knock on the door of the first, and only, house they see around. This story really kept me on the edge of my seat, and for me, bordered on a thriller vs a cozy mystery. In a good way though, because while you kind of could guess the murderer, you really were on edge with the 3 friends on how they were going to survive their situation! And the creepy lady in the house...yikes!
""Dear child, if I wanted to kill you I would find a much less messy way of doing it." Her words were not exactly reassuring."
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland: Mrs. Claus and the elves of Christmastown are working tirelessly at decorating for the Halloween festivities. Unexpectedly, the beloved Pumblechook gets hexed, and then there is a murder, seemingly all done by the same recently returned exiled elf Flake Butternut. Mrs. Claus puts on her sleuthing hat and tries to get to the bottom of who may be using witchcraft in Christmastown. I am a little biased, but this was my favorite of the 3 stories, as I absolutely love the Mrs. Claus mysteries. I laughed out loud multiple times while reading about the amusing elves as they decorated for Halloween, and the elf witch Imelda's extreme sweet tooth and lack of decorum.
"This Halloween, every dwelling on Sugarplum Mountain was going to be a stop on the first-ever Sugarplum Spooky Sleigh Ride..."
"Call me a busybody, but I'd never witnessed a doctor examining a snowman. This I had to see for myself."
"Yes. He said I didn't have a permit to peddly my caramels, but that's a load of walrus poo."
Thank you so much to Kensington Books, Netgalley, and the authors for a copy of this book!
September 9, 2025
"Halloween Night Murder (A Lucy Stone Mystery)" by Leslie Meier has Lucy deep in some serious local political scandal investigating. A teen out trick-or-treating is the victim of a hit and run and Lucy gets involved with the care of his siblings. Leading down a rabbit hole of political corruption similar to what is in real world politics now. It also brings up domestic abuse and the extreme views pushing back at political policy currently. If you're a MAGA supporter you may not appreciate this one.
"Death of a Halloween Night Stalker (Haylee Powell Food & Cocktails Mystery)" doesn't fit as a title. There really isn't a stalker in this one. There also isn't much of a mystery either. This one is more Halloween trapped in a creepy house with a killer during a storm cozy thriller.
There isn't anything but how to get out safely to figure out. Almost a third was unrelated Halloween stories and recipes I skipped. Really, this one just didn't give me cozy mystery but rather four short Halloween themed stories on the G-PJ13 rating scale. Not what I was really looking for having been paired with the other two.
"Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch (A Mrs. Claus Mystery)" by Liz Ireland felt like the best version of Halloween Cozy Mystery Short Story of the three stories in this book. Santa Land is preparing for Halloween with a decorating competition and caramel competition. This is done the only way Santa's elves do anything. Over the too and not exactly like what you'd normally expect. April end up calling in her Winter Witch connection when someone seems to be hexing people. I didn't quite see the culprit coming. It may be due this being a short story.
All three stories were enjoyable. They were all true, format wise, to their respective series. However, only two were successful as cozy mysteries and what I expected from these authors.
The Haylee Powell story maybe would have been better off on its own and advertised as more of a Halloween thriller. Also, just one of her journalistic stories would have been more than enough for the length of actual story we got. Plus stuck at the end. They aren't connected enough to the main story line that they pull me out of the story. It's like a commercial break or ad pop up. Not what I want in the middle of a book.
"Death of a Halloween Night Stalker (Haylee Powell Food & Cocktails Mystery)" doesn't fit as a title. There really isn't a stalker in this one. There also isn't much of a mystery either. This one is more Halloween trapped in a creepy house with a killer during a storm cozy thriller.
There isn't anything but how to get out safely to figure out. Almost a third was unrelated Halloween stories and recipes I skipped. Really, this one just didn't give me cozy mystery but rather four short Halloween themed stories on the G-PJ13 rating scale. Not what I was really looking for having been paired with the other two.
"Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch (A Mrs. Claus Mystery)" by Liz Ireland felt like the best version of Halloween Cozy Mystery Short Story of the three stories in this book. Santa Land is preparing for Halloween with a decorating competition and caramel competition. This is done the only way Santa's elves do anything. Over the too and not exactly like what you'd normally expect. April end up calling in her Winter Witch connection when someone seems to be hexing people. I didn't quite see the culprit coming. It may be due this being a short story.
All three stories were enjoyable. They were all true, format wise, to their respective series. However, only two were successful as cozy mysteries and what I expected from these authors.
The Haylee Powell story maybe would have been better off on its own and advertised as more of a Halloween thriller. Also, just one of her journalistic stories would have been more than enough for the length of actual story we got. Plus stuck at the end. They aren't connected enough to the main story line that they pull me out of the story. It's like a commercial break or ad pop up. Not what I want in the middle of a book.
September 8, 2025
2.5☆ The third story I would give a solid 2☆. Couldn't finish that one!
October 26, 2025
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier; Lee Hollis; Liz Ireland
Rating: 3 Stars
I picked up Halloween Night Murder expecting a cozy, breezy set of seasonal chills — and that’s mostly what I got. This is a trio of Halloween-tinged novellas from three reliable cozy mystery writers: Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, and Liz Ireland. Each tale leans into small-town vibes and mild creepiness rather than full-on horror. I’d give the collection three stars: entertaining and well-paced, but not especially spine-tingling or memorable beyond a few bright moments.
Leslie Meier’s contribution opens the book on a melancholy note. Lucy Stone has just finished running a neighborhood Halloween event when a lone trick-or-treater shows up at her door late for one last piece of candy. The next day Lucy learns the teen was killed in a hit-and-run just minutes after leaving her house. Rattled and guilt-ridden, she starts poking into the boy’s life and uncovers secrets that suggest the accident wasn’t as simple as it first seemed. Meier sets a moody, coastal-Maine backdrop that feels lived-in and sympathetic, and Lucy’s blend of curiosity and remorse makes for a solid cozy-protagonist arc.
Lee Hollis is the strongest of the three, for me. Her story strands restaurateur Hayley Powell and friends during a storm in rural Maine, and their only refuge is a creaky house with an unnerving host and an armed, oddball son. The son’s Halloween costume and theatrics are initially played for laughs and jump-scares, but Hollis pivots to a real threat that had me turning pages faster. This novella balances tension and warmth well, and the unsettled atmosphere stayed with me after I finished — my favorite of the set.
Liz Ireland takes a more whimsical route. Her piece flips to a holiday-mashup world where Santaland’s politics and magic collide: a once-disgraced elf returns home, snow-people suffer strange mishaps, and Mrs. Claus must figure out whether mischief is the work of a rotten ex-elf or some darker enchantment. It’s charming and clever, leaning into playful fantasy more than gritty mystery, which makes it a lighter, sillier capstone to the collection.
Overall, the book’s strongest assets are its mood and authorial voices. The cover is delightful too — it gave the anthology a festive, inviting face that matched the stories inside. If you like cozy mysteries with gentle scares, small-town intimacy, and a dash of holiday whimsy, this anthology will do the trick. If you’re hoping for sustained terror or twisty, high-stakes detective work, you might find it a bit tame. For me, Lee Hollis’s story was the standout, followed by Meier’s moody seaside mystery and Ireland’s playful, Santas-meet-witches romp. Three stars: pleasant, seasonal, and a nice pick for a light Halloween read.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
Rating: 3 Stars
I picked up Halloween Night Murder expecting a cozy, breezy set of seasonal chills — and that’s mostly what I got. This is a trio of Halloween-tinged novellas from three reliable cozy mystery writers: Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, and Liz Ireland. Each tale leans into small-town vibes and mild creepiness rather than full-on horror. I’d give the collection three stars: entertaining and well-paced, but not especially spine-tingling or memorable beyond a few bright moments.
Leslie Meier’s contribution opens the book on a melancholy note. Lucy Stone has just finished running a neighborhood Halloween event when a lone trick-or-treater shows up at her door late for one last piece of candy. The next day Lucy learns the teen was killed in a hit-and-run just minutes after leaving her house. Rattled and guilt-ridden, she starts poking into the boy’s life and uncovers secrets that suggest the accident wasn’t as simple as it first seemed. Meier sets a moody, coastal-Maine backdrop that feels lived-in and sympathetic, and Lucy’s blend of curiosity and remorse makes for a solid cozy-protagonist arc.
Lee Hollis is the strongest of the three, for me. Her story strands restaurateur Hayley Powell and friends during a storm in rural Maine, and their only refuge is a creaky house with an unnerving host and an armed, oddball son. The son’s Halloween costume and theatrics are initially played for laughs and jump-scares, but Hollis pivots to a real threat that had me turning pages faster. This novella balances tension and warmth well, and the unsettled atmosphere stayed with me after I finished — my favorite of the set.
Liz Ireland takes a more whimsical route. Her piece flips to a holiday-mashup world where Santaland’s politics and magic collide: a once-disgraced elf returns home, snow-people suffer strange mishaps, and Mrs. Claus must figure out whether mischief is the work of a rotten ex-elf or some darker enchantment. It’s charming and clever, leaning into playful fantasy more than gritty mystery, which makes it a lighter, sillier capstone to the collection.
Overall, the book’s strongest assets are its mood and authorial voices. The cover is delightful too — it gave the anthology a festive, inviting face that matched the stories inside. If you like cozy mysteries with gentle scares, small-town intimacy, and a dash of holiday whimsy, this anthology will do the trick. If you’re hoping for sustained terror or twisty, high-stakes detective work, you might find it a bit tame. For me, Lee Hollis’s story was the standout, followed by Meier’s moody seaside mystery and Ireland’s playful, Santas-meet-witches romp. Three stars: pleasant, seasonal, and a nice pick for a light Halloween read.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
October 22, 2025
https://openbooksociety.com/article/h...
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I am not a fan of short stories in general but given my “interest” in Halloween and my enjoyment of the writing of Leslie Meier – I thought I would give this book a read.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER - 4 stars
Halloween Night Murder was an engaging short story. I am usually not into short stories (as indicated above) but I found with this story there was enough “story” with sufficient backstory and character development to keep me engaged and entertained by the main characters.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS - 2 stars
Well all I can say is…talk about creepy! I did find the story very slow going – I know – an interesting thing to say about a short story! The story line was captivating enough but with it SO slow moving…I did get a wee bit bored. And then the transition from one scene to the next – abrupt (this was near then end of the story – chapter 15 if I am not mistaken). Whew – talk about whiplash. However, I did like the mini story “Island Food & Spirits by Hayley Powell – the relaxing day for Hayley.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND - 5 stars
I quite enjoyed the liberal use of holiday themed names…for example: Santaland, Christmastown’s Peppermint Pond, Castle Kringle, Tinkertown (sister city of Christmastown) -> just to name a few. Had me right in the holiday mode when reading that 🙂
And lest we forget – Pumblechook – an interesting snowman. “For the past few years, denizens of the city’s snowy streets had found themselves getting dressed down for infractions real and imagined by this self-appointed icy keeper of the peace” – referring to Pumblechook. Unfortunately – he becomes “frozen” in that he cannot move. Was a spell cast? What happened? The town blames the elf known as Flake.
Favourite quote – had me chuckling big time:
“…He said I didn’t have a permit to peddle my caramels, but that’s a load of walrus poo.
Hey now, the constable warned. “Let’s watch our language. This is the constabulary, not a grog tavern.”
Overall, a fun holiday story that kept this reader chuckling. The mystery was solved in a timely fashion by Mrs. Claus.
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I am not a fan of short stories in general but given my “interest” in Halloween and my enjoyment of the writing of Leslie Meier – I thought I would give this book a read.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER - 4 stars
Halloween Night Murder was an engaging short story. I am usually not into short stories (as indicated above) but I found with this story there was enough “story” with sufficient backstory and character development to keep me engaged and entertained by the main characters.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS - 2 stars
Well all I can say is…talk about creepy! I did find the story very slow going – I know – an interesting thing to say about a short story! The story line was captivating enough but with it SO slow moving…I did get a wee bit bored. And then the transition from one scene to the next – abrupt (this was near then end of the story – chapter 15 if I am not mistaken). Whew – talk about whiplash. However, I did like the mini story “Island Food & Spirits by Hayley Powell – the relaxing day for Hayley.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND - 5 stars
I quite enjoyed the liberal use of holiday themed names…for example: Santaland, Christmastown’s Peppermint Pond, Castle Kringle, Tinkertown (sister city of Christmastown) -> just to name a few. Had me right in the holiday mode when reading that 🙂
And lest we forget – Pumblechook – an interesting snowman. “For the past few years, denizens of the city’s snowy streets had found themselves getting dressed down for infractions real and imagined by this self-appointed icy keeper of the peace” – referring to Pumblechook. Unfortunately – he becomes “frozen” in that he cannot move. Was a spell cast? What happened? The town blames the elf known as Flake.
Favourite quote – had me chuckling big time:
“…He said I didn’t have a permit to peddle my caramels, but that’s a load of walrus poo.
Hey now, the constable warned. “Let’s watch our language. This is the constabulary, not a grog tavern.”
Overall, a fun holiday story that kept this reader chuckling. The mystery was solved in a timely fashion by Mrs. Claus.
October 25, 2025
A satisfying collection of Halloween-themed cozy mysteries penned by Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, and Liz Ireland will find a perfect place on readers’ bookshelves this holiday season.
In the highlight of the novella collection, Meier’s “Halloween Night Murder,” the protagonist, newspaper reporter Lucy Stone, covers domestic violence and animal trafficking.
Lucy’s and her husband Bill’s evening is interrupted by a trick-or-treater who arrives at their house, looking disheveled and grungy in his Halloween costume, begging for candy. Lucy, shaken by the young man’s presence, older than the usual trick-or-treating age she is used to seeing at her house every year, feels sorry for the sad-looking fellow and provides him with the remaining sweets in her bowl.
The next morning, Sheriff Culpepper visits Lucy’s house, asking questions about a possible hit-and-run in the neighborhood. The lawman informs Lucy of the death of a young man, the same kid, down to his dirty clothing and appearance, who showed up at her house trick-or-treating the previous evening.
Lucy asks her own questions, which lead her down a path to inexplicable discoveries.
Lee Hollis’s entertaining story, “Death of a Halloween Stalker,” puts restaurateur columnist Hayley Powell and her friends in a life-and-death situation when their car breaks down by the side of the road during a torrential rainstorm.
Unable to call for help due to a power outage and no cell phone service, Hayley, along with BFFs Liddy and Mona, decide to stay the night at an unfamiliar residence until the storm passes.
Their spontaneous night turns into a deadly cat-and-mouse game when their only shelter from the rain is a spooky house in the Maine woods. A lady and her scary-looking son warmly welcome the three women.
The surprises climb to unnerving heights as the Halloween tale reaches its mid-point, leaving the reader spellbound, flipping pages until the nail-biting finale.
Liz Ireland’s light-fare read, “Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch,” is a welcoming tale set in the humorous world in Santaland.
Flake the Elf returns from spending five years in exile and returns in time for the spirited Halloween season and a blue-ribbon cooking competition. However, not everybody in Christmastown believes he is changed. When Pumblechook the Snowman, one of Elf’s closet friends, is down on his luck when murder and misfortune rock the town, Mrs. Claus joins the festivities and helps with the investigation to determine whether or not Flake the Elf is a hard-edged felon or if he has been framed.
Fun and lively, Ireland delivers a holiday story that makes you believe in miracles and magic among the most spirited holidays of the year.
In the highlight of the novella collection, Meier’s “Halloween Night Murder,” the protagonist, newspaper reporter Lucy Stone, covers domestic violence and animal trafficking.
Lucy’s and her husband Bill’s evening is interrupted by a trick-or-treater who arrives at their house, looking disheveled and grungy in his Halloween costume, begging for candy. Lucy, shaken by the young man’s presence, older than the usual trick-or-treating age she is used to seeing at her house every year, feels sorry for the sad-looking fellow and provides him with the remaining sweets in her bowl.
The next morning, Sheriff Culpepper visits Lucy’s house, asking questions about a possible hit-and-run in the neighborhood. The lawman informs Lucy of the death of a young man, the same kid, down to his dirty clothing and appearance, who showed up at her house trick-or-treating the previous evening.
Lucy asks her own questions, which lead her down a path to inexplicable discoveries.
Lee Hollis’s entertaining story, “Death of a Halloween Stalker,” puts restaurateur columnist Hayley Powell and her friends in a life-and-death situation when their car breaks down by the side of the road during a torrential rainstorm.
Unable to call for help due to a power outage and no cell phone service, Hayley, along with BFFs Liddy and Mona, decide to stay the night at an unfamiliar residence until the storm passes.
Their spontaneous night turns into a deadly cat-and-mouse game when their only shelter from the rain is a spooky house in the Maine woods. A lady and her scary-looking son warmly welcome the three women.
The surprises climb to unnerving heights as the Halloween tale reaches its mid-point, leaving the reader spellbound, flipping pages until the nail-biting finale.
Liz Ireland’s light-fare read, “Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch,” is a welcoming tale set in the humorous world in Santaland.
Flake the Elf returns from spending five years in exile and returns in time for the spirited Halloween season and a blue-ribbon cooking competition. However, not everybody in Christmastown believes he is changed. When Pumblechook the Snowman, one of Elf’s closet friends, is down on his luck when murder and misfortune rock the town, Mrs. Claus joins the festivities and helps with the investigation to determine whether or not Flake the Elf is a hard-edged felon or if he has been framed.
Fun and lively, Ireland delivers a holiday story that makes you believe in miracles and magic among the most spirited holidays of the year.
December 19, 2025
What a chocolate box of treats this turned out to be. I do love these threesomes that come out for various holiday where the readers is treated to three short stories by well loved authors who weave tales of beloved characters. This one presents a variety of tales. We have a straightforward mystery that highlights the failings in our society where the most vulnerable are preyed upon and the corrupt ones in power hold all the advantages. That is until someone with courage and spunk cares enough to reveal the ugly underbelly.
The second was a story that could have been a script for a horror movie, including three heroines, trapped by circumstances in a dangerous situation that seems to get worse by the minute. It has many of the tropes one expects with all the inherent suspense of how the heroines will be able to prevail.
Finally there is a story of pure fantasy that delights with every turn as the wonderful characters of Santaland and Mrs. Claus battle the forces of evil. As usual, it is fun from beginning to end.
Whatever your preference, all the stories will entertain. Five purrs and two paws up.
The second was a story that could have been a script for a horror movie, including three heroines, trapped by circumstances in a dangerous situation that seems to get worse by the minute. It has many of the tropes one expects with all the inherent suspense of how the heroines will be able to prevail.
Finally there is a story of pure fantasy that delights with every turn as the wonderful characters of Santaland and Mrs. Claus battle the forces of evil. As usual, it is fun from beginning to end.
Whatever your preference, all the stories will entertain. Five purrs and two paws up.
October 26, 2025
https://openbooksociety.com/article/h...
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I am not a fan of short stories in general but given my “interest” in Halloween and my enjoyment of the writing of Leslie Meier – I thought I would give this book a read.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER - 4 stars
Halloween Night Murder was an engaging short story. I am usually not into short stories (as indicated above) but I found with this story there was enough “story” with sufficient backstory and character development to keep me engaged and entertained by the main characters.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS - 2 stars
Well all I can say is…talk about creepy! I did find the story very slow going – I know – an interesting thing to say about a short story! The story line was captivating enough but with it SO slow moving…I did get a wee bit bored. And then the transition from one scene to the next – abrupt (this was near then end of the story – chapter 15 if I am not mistaken). Whew – talk about whiplash. However, I did like the mini story “Island Food & Spirits by Hayley Powell – the relaxing day for Hayley.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND - 5 stars
I quite enjoyed the liberal use of holiday themed names…for example: Santaland, Christmastown’s Peppermint Pond, Castle Kringle, Tinkertown (sister city of Christmastown) -> just to name a few. Had me right in the holiday mode when reading that 🙂
And lest we forget – Pumblechook – an interesting snowman. “For the past few years, denizens of the city’s snowy streets had found themselves getting dressed down for infractions real and imagined by this self-appointed icy keeper of the peace” – referring to Pumblechook. Unfortunately – he becomes “frozen” in that he cannot move. Was a spell cast? What happened? The town blames the elf known as Flake.
Favourite quote – had me chuckling big time:
“…He said I didn’t have a permit to peddle my caramels, but that’s a load of walrus poo.
Hey now, the constable warned. “Let’s watch our language. This is the constabulary, not a grog tavern.”
Overall, a fun holiday story that kept this reader chuckling. The mystery was solved in a timely fashion by Mrs. Claus.
Brought to you by OBS reviewer Andra
I am not a fan of short stories in general but given my “interest” in Halloween and my enjoyment of the writing of Leslie Meier – I thought I would give this book a read.
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER - 4 stars
Halloween Night Murder was an engaging short story. I am usually not into short stories (as indicated above) but I found with this story there was enough “story” with sufficient backstory and character development to keep me engaged and entertained by the main characters.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS - 2 stars
Well all I can say is…talk about creepy! I did find the story very slow going – I know – an interesting thing to say about a short story! The story line was captivating enough but with it SO slow moving…I did get a wee bit bored. And then the transition from one scene to the next – abrupt (this was near then end of the story – chapter 15 if I am not mistaken). Whew – talk about whiplash. However, I did like the mini story “Island Food & Spirits by Hayley Powell – the relaxing day for Hayley.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND - 5 stars
I quite enjoyed the liberal use of holiday themed names…for example: Santaland, Christmastown’s Peppermint Pond, Castle Kringle, Tinkertown (sister city of Christmastown) -> just to name a few. Had me right in the holiday mode when reading that 🙂
And lest we forget – Pumblechook – an interesting snowman. “For the past few years, denizens of the city’s snowy streets had found themselves getting dressed down for infractions real and imagined by this self-appointed icy keeper of the peace” – referring to Pumblechook. Unfortunately – he becomes “frozen” in that he cannot move. Was a spell cast? What happened? The town blames the elf known as Flake.
Favourite quote – had me chuckling big time:
“…He said I didn’t have a permit to peddle my caramels, but that’s a load of walrus poo.
Hey now, the constable warned. “Let’s watch our language. This is the constabulary, not a grog tavern.”
Overall, a fun holiday story that kept this reader chuckling. The mystery was solved in a timely fashion by Mrs. Claus.
October 31, 2025
I read two of the three authors in this collection.
The first one is Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier. It’s not very Halloween-y at all. Lucy has one trick or treater. The rest of the story is about abuse and corruption in the surrounding government and a cat mill.I was disappointed.
The next one is Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis. I usually like this series. As the night went on and Haley and her friends tried to escape the situation they were in, it just got tedious and unbelievable. I was ready for it to end long before it did. Also a disappointment, although not as bad of a one.
The final story was Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland.This was a DNF. I am unfamiliar with this series and was not in the mood to read about Mrs. Claus and elves on Halloween.
So, if you’re in the mood for traditional Halloween fare such as trick or treaters, parties, and decorations, this is not the book for you.
The first one is Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier. It’s not very Halloween-y at all. Lucy has one trick or treater. The rest of the story is about abuse and corruption in the surrounding government and a cat mill.I was disappointed.
The next one is Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis. I usually like this series. As the night went on and Haley and her friends tried to escape the situation they were in, it just got tedious and unbelievable. I was ready for it to end long before it did. Also a disappointment, although not as bad of a one.
The final story was Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland.This was a DNF. I am unfamiliar with this series and was not in the mood to read about Mrs. Claus and elves on Halloween.
So, if you’re in the mood for traditional Halloween fare such as trick or treaters, parties, and decorations, this is not the book for you.
December 13, 2025
All three of these novellas are spine-tingling. In “Halloween Night Murder,” social issues are explored. A hit-and-run accident leads Lucy to look into the cause, and she uncovers more than she bargained for, including a conspiracy. In “Death of a Halloween Night Stalker,” Haley and her friends seek shelter after a car accident in the woods, but the house the stumble upon holds even worse threats than the storm they were in. In “Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch,” a snowman is put under a spell, and when an elf is accused unjustly, Mrs. Claus decides to find the real culprit. Eventually, she must resort to getting a real witch to unmask the fake one. All three of these novellas are well-written and intriguing. Often, in a collection, one will standout as the best, but in this collection, all three are equally compelling and exciting.
October 31, 2025
This is a collection of stories that each involve Halloween in some way.
The first story was a conglomeration of every possible liberal political theme the author could squeeze into her story. I honestly can’t remember if Halloween was even involved at this point, and I just finished listening to it.
The second story was actually well written and was the saving grace for this book. It had a clear connection to Halloween and involved thrills and suspense without being overly gory.
The third story kept me wondering if I was listening to a child’s story instead of an adult’s. Halloween with Santa and the elves was ridiculous most of the time. The actual mystery and “whodunit” was a decent premise though.
The first story was a conglomeration of every possible liberal political theme the author could squeeze into her story. I honestly can’t remember if Halloween was even involved at this point, and I just finished listening to it.
The second story was actually well written and was the saving grace for this book. It had a clear connection to Halloween and involved thrills and suspense without being overly gory.
The third story kept me wondering if I was listening to a child’s story instead of an adult’s. Halloween with Santa and the elves was ridiculous most of the time. The actual mystery and “whodunit” was a decent premise though.
November 23, 2025
HALLOWEEN NIGHT MURDER by LESLIE MEIER ⭐⭐⭐
I guess I got used to ask the background information and extra drama that is usually added in Leslie Meier's books, because this one felt like it ended too soon. I didn't hate that though.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS ⭐⭐⭐.5
I enjoyed this one. With all the escape attempts, it became sort of comical to me. It wasn't hard to see where the story was going but I still enjoyed it.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND ⭐⭐⭐
The idea of Christmastown celebrating Halloween threw me off for a bit. It was a nice story, definitely fits my idea of a cozy mystery.
I guess I got used to ask the background information and extra drama that is usually added in Leslie Meier's books, because this one felt like it ended too soon. I didn't hate that though.
DEATH OF A HALLOWEEN NIGHT STALKER by LEE HOLLIS ⭐⭐⭐.5
I enjoyed this one. With all the escape attempts, it became sort of comical to me. It wasn't hard to see where the story was going but I still enjoyed it.
MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by LIZ IRELAND ⭐⭐⭐
The idea of Christmastown celebrating Halloween threw me off for a bit. It was a nice story, definitely fits my idea of a cozy mystery.
December 15, 2025
Halloween Night Murder by Leslie Meier
This was a cozy mystery that involves children, so it adds a touch of sadness to the story. Overall, it was a good mystery and I loved the ending.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis
Ooh, this was a good one and I think if it was turned into a short film, it would have quite a few jump scares. I look forward to reading more of Lee Hollis's work in the future.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland
Another fun short story in the Mrs. Claus mystery series. I love April and how she sees the good in people. I was not able to guess the ending prior to the reveal, so that was fun as well.
This was a cozy mystery that involves children, so it adds a touch of sadness to the story. Overall, it was a good mystery and I loved the ending.
Death of a Halloween Night Stalker by Lee Hollis
Ooh, this was a good one and I think if it was turned into a short film, it would have quite a few jump scares. I look forward to reading more of Lee Hollis's work in the future.
Mrs. Claus and the Wily Witch by Liz Ireland
Another fun short story in the Mrs. Claus mystery series. I love April and how she sees the good in people. I was not able to guess the ending prior to the reveal, so that was fun as well.
November 10, 2025
Three cozy mysteries in one book - good authors offering widely different Halloween stories. Leslie Meier’s Lucy Stone works to solve the trick or treat hit-and-run near her home, and discovers an exotic cat breeding black market operation and more. Lee Hollis puts three friends in the hands of too helpful woodland residents - or escapees? And finally the reader is transported by Liz Ireland to Halloween in Santa-land, complete with Mrs.Claus finding a witch to catch a witch amid snowmen, reindeer races, and spooky sleigh rides. Great variety which pleasantly stretches the imagination.
November 12, 2025
I read just one of the three stories in this book--Halloween Night Murder By Leslie Meier. I have enjoyed the Lucy Stone series for decades but have noticed recently that they aren't the fun cozy mysteries they used to be. Instead, the author inserts opinions on a variety of social/political topics and I don't want that in a book. I read for enjoyment and to escape the crazy world we are living in. I seriously need to let this series go.
December 11, 2025
This anthology of three Halloween-themed cozy novellas was the perfect way to slip into spooky season! Each story had its own unique charm, and while some worked better for me than others, overall it was a fun collection. My Fave was MRS. CLAUS AND THE WILY WITCH by Liz Ireland. I love these anthology and this one had a great variety. Highly recommend.
October 25, 2025
Title: Halloween Night Murder
Authors: Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, Liz Ireland
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
Review:
I didn’t realize going in but this book is actually 3 novellas that take place on Halloween night inside of one book.
The first story is a crime thriller that involves a trick or treater killed in a hit and run accident. This was a pretty good story and I felt for the kids involved.
The second story is a thriller that involves an auto accident in a storm with three friends looking for shelter and help. They find themselves trapped in a spooky house in the woods with a strange mother and son. This story gave me House of 1000 Corpses vibes and I really liked it, super creepy!
The third story is a cozy mystery full of magic that takes place in Santaland, involving an elf who was poisoned with caramels. This one I didn’t really care for too much in comparison with the other two. It was fun but felt out of place somewhat going from horror to Christmastown.
Overall I give the book 3.5 stars. Individually I would rate the stories 4, 5, and 2.5.
Authors: Leslie Meier, Lee Hollis, Liz Ireland
Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️✨
Review:
I didn’t realize going in but this book is actually 3 novellas that take place on Halloween night inside of one book.
The first story is a crime thriller that involves a trick or treater killed in a hit and run accident. This was a pretty good story and I felt for the kids involved.
The second story is a thriller that involves an auto accident in a storm with three friends looking for shelter and help. They find themselves trapped in a spooky house in the woods with a strange mother and son. This story gave me House of 1000 Corpses vibes and I really liked it, super creepy!
The third story is a cozy mystery full of magic that takes place in Santaland, involving an elf who was poisoned with caramels. This one I didn’t really care for too much in comparison with the other two. It was fun but felt out of place somewhat going from horror to Christmastown.
Overall I give the book 3.5 stars. Individually I would rate the stories 4, 5, and 2.5.
October 29, 2025
This was a DNF for me. I finished the first novella against my better judgement and started the second one. There's not enough depth, development and too much cheesiness in dialogue and writing from what I did read to appeal to me. Seasonal, but disappointing.
November 21, 2025
I enjoyed all 3 stories immensely! I'm am avid followers of the Santaland series n the Haley Powell series, but haven't really read the Lucy Stone one and this story was pretty good. Mary have to check it out.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 121 reviews