What do you think?
Rate this book
Win a free print copy of this book!
3 days and 04:58:00
15 copies available
U.S. only
Dissection of a Murder
Not yet published
Expected 7 May 26Win a free print copy of this book!
3 days and 04:58:00
15 copies available
U.S. only
'So gripping, so clever, so good. This brilliant book had me hooked from the beginning' – Alice Feeney, author of Beautiful Ugly
Breathlessly compulsive courtroom drama with expertly-crafted twists that you won't see coming, Dissection of a Murder is the razor-sharp debut novel from Jo Murray.
A dead judge. A silent defendant. And a courtroom full of liars.
When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked at how high-profile it the murder of a well-respected, well-known judge. This shouldn’t be the kind of case she’s leading; it’s way beyond her expertise. But the defendant, Jack Millman, is clear. He wants her, and only her.
To make things worse, he’s refusing to talk. How is she supposed to prove herself on what appears to be an unwinnable case?
Losing is not an option. She must find the most persuasive argument. Trials aren’t won by convincing judges or fellow barristers – they’re all about convincing a jury.
Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only to keep Jack out of prison, but also to keep her own secrets buried.
It’s true what they say – there are two sides to every story.
Guilty or not guilty?
You decide . . .
PRAISE FOR DISSECTION OF A MURDER:
'Absolutely outstanding' – TM Logan, author of The Mother
'What a terrific read!' – Sarah Vaughan, author of Anatomy of a Scandal
'Utterly compelling' – John Marrs, author of The Family Experiment
Breathlessly compulsive courtroom drama with expertly-crafted twists that you won't see coming, Dissection of a Murder is the razor-sharp debut novel from Jo Murray.
A dead judge. A silent defendant. And a courtroom full of liars.
When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked at how high-profile it the murder of a well-respected, well-known judge. This shouldn’t be the kind of case she’s leading; it’s way beyond her expertise. But the defendant, Jack Millman, is clear. He wants her, and only her.
To make things worse, he’s refusing to talk. How is she supposed to prove herself on what appears to be an unwinnable case?
Losing is not an option. She must find the most persuasive argument. Trials aren’t won by convincing judges or fellow barristers – they’re all about convincing a jury.
Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only to keep Jack out of prison, but also to keep her own secrets buried.
It’s true what they say – there are two sides to every story.
Guilty or not guilty?
You decide . . .
PRAISE FOR DISSECTION OF A MURDER:
'Absolutely outstanding' – TM Logan, author of The Mother
'What a terrific read!' – Sarah Vaughan, author of Anatomy of a Scandal
'Utterly compelling' – John Marrs, author of The Family Experiment
Kindle Edition
Expected publication May 7, 2026
12569 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
December 27, 2025
What is justice? It probably means different things to different people. Will Judge Anton Smythe, 56, get justice for his murder? Is the tale of the prosecutor, Julian Kesler, tells at trial the true version of events or does the defence lawyer Leila Reynolds put across a robustly different interpretation that may lead to a not guilty verdict for Jack Millman? What is Jack’s definition of justice? This indeed is a dissection of a murder, but remember, don’t trust anyone, especially the lawyers.
Oh my goodness, where to start with this one, perhaps with I reluctantly put it down when real life intrudes. There are so many layers involved in this very definition of a legal thriller that makes it such a clever novel. The dynamics are off the charts, between Julian and Leila, Leila and the characters in Chambers, Leila and Jack and so on with excellent characterisation into the bargain. Leila is especially fascinating as to whether she’s likeable, you decide. There’s so much misogyny directed at Leila my blood boils. The least said about Julian the better but I’d love to wipe that arrogant smirk of his smooth veneer. There are some side characters and I become desperate to know what the story is there and the identity of one of the points of view is a tantalising puzzle.
The author creates an escalating air of threat and menace, a watchfulness that gives prickles at the back of the neck. There’s twist upon twist, whiplash like, making it a terrific thriller as I genuinely have no idea what’s going to implode/explode next. Add in the legal element and that makes it big winner for me.
What of the trial? It’s electric, riveting and totally enthralling. It’s suspenseful, tense and very dramatic and I’ll say no more as this is one courtroom thriller that begs to be read.
Overall, it’s very clever and creative, it’s well written and perfectly paced with several points of view which works so well, building the suspense and a pile of questions. It’s a cracker of a book which praise be, has a really good conclusion.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Pan Macmillan for the much appreciated early copy in return for an honest review.
Oh my goodness, where to start with this one, perhaps with I reluctantly put it down when real life intrudes. There are so many layers involved in this very definition of a legal thriller that makes it such a clever novel. The dynamics are off the charts, between Julian and Leila, Leila and the characters in Chambers, Leila and Jack and so on with excellent characterisation into the bargain. Leila is especially fascinating as to whether she’s likeable, you decide. There’s so much misogyny directed at Leila my blood boils. The least said about Julian the better but I’d love to wipe that arrogant smirk of his smooth veneer. There are some side characters and I become desperate to know what the story is there and the identity of one of the points of view is a tantalising puzzle.
The author creates an escalating air of threat and menace, a watchfulness that gives prickles at the back of the neck. There’s twist upon twist, whiplash like, making it a terrific thriller as I genuinely have no idea what’s going to implode/explode next. Add in the legal element and that makes it big winner for me.
What of the trial? It’s electric, riveting and totally enthralling. It’s suspenseful, tense and very dramatic and I’ll say no more as this is one courtroom thriller that begs to be read.
Overall, it’s very clever and creative, it’s well written and perfectly paced with several points of view which works so well, building the suspense and a pile of questions. It’s a cracker of a book which praise be, has a really good conclusion.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Pan Macmillan for the much appreciated early copy in return for an honest review.
January 23, 2026
My fellow bookworms… may I?
Can I officially introduce the best legal thriller of 2026?
🥁 Drum roll, please… 🥁
The crown goes to Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray.
From the very first page, I fell hard for Jo Murray’s razor-sharp writing style. The second I finished, I immediately started searching for her backlist—scrolling, refreshing, scrolling again—only to realize this was her first novel. And yes… I actually screamed. Because I need more Jo Murray thrillers in my life, immediately. She is now on my auto-approved author list, and I will read anything she writes next without even checking the blurb.
A dream for legal-thriller lovers
And here’s the fun twist:
The upcoming Presumed Innocent Season 2 adaptation is already rumored to be spectacular—but I genuinely believe this story may top it.
Yes, I’ll miss Jake Gyllenhaal terribly… but with Rachel Brosnahan, Matthew Rhys, and Courtney B. Vance joining the cast, this adaptation is already screaming Emmy bait.
Rachel as Leila Reynolds? Absolute perfection. Tell me she won’t eat that role alive.
But first—let’s give this novel the standing ovation it deserves.
What makes Dissection of a Murder so addictive?
This book has everything I want in a legal thriller:
⚖️ Sharp courtroom tension
🧩 A layered mystery
🔥 High emotional stakes
👀 Dual timelines and perspectives
🕵️ A chilling, anonymous watcher
The story unfolds through Leila Reynolds and the mysterious Witness X, whose intersecting narratives blend past and present in a way that never lets you relax.
Leila learned the law from her husband and mentor, Julian—a legendary attorney who shaped her career and pushed her to the top, even helping secure her place in the Legal 500. Their relationship is built on ambition, loyalty, and shared victories… until everything cracks.
Five years earlier, Leila defended Jack Miller, a man wrongfully convicted and imprisoned for two years. Now, Jack is accused of murdering Judge Anton Smythe—the very man who once sentenced him, while Jack’s foster mother was dying of cancer.
And Jack requests only one lawyer: Leila.
The problem?
Leila has never handled a criminal murder case.
And the prosecutor?
Her own husband.
Julian plays to win. And this time, he has no intention of letting Leila save her client.
A shadow watching from the dark…
As the case grows darker, a terrifying presence emerges.
Someone is watching Leila and Julian’s home.
Someone sends Julian a cryptic birthday gift.
Someone stalks Leila, trolls her online, and knows far too much.
Who is Witness X?
What are they hiding?
And how are they connected to Jack, the judge, and Leila’s past?
Every clue is a thread—and when they finally connect, the truth is more disturbing than anything Leila is ready to face.
“Nothing is ever black and white—especially when it comes to the law.”
Final Verdict
This novel is fast, relentless, and impossible to put down.
You will:
bite off your perfectly manicured nails,
forget to blink,
and gasp at every twist.
By the end, you’ll need a spa day to recover from the stress—and it will be completely worth it.
This isn’t just a five-star book.
This is sky-full-of-stars, whole-planet-level brilliant.
The best thriller I’ve read in years.
I laughed like Villanelle at the end—shocked, thrilled, and already desperate for more.
📚 Go get your copy.
I already ordered mine for a future reread.
Endless thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for sharing this absolute MASTERPIECE in exchange for my honest thoughts.
I truly appreciate it.
medium.com
instagram
facebook
twitter
Can I officially introduce the best legal thriller of 2026?
🥁 Drum roll, please… 🥁
The crown goes to Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray.
From the very first page, I fell hard for Jo Murray’s razor-sharp writing style. The second I finished, I immediately started searching for her backlist—scrolling, refreshing, scrolling again—only to realize this was her first novel. And yes… I actually screamed. Because I need more Jo Murray thrillers in my life, immediately. She is now on my auto-approved author list, and I will read anything she writes next without even checking the blurb.
A dream for legal-thriller lovers
And here’s the fun twist:
The upcoming Presumed Innocent Season 2 adaptation is already rumored to be spectacular—but I genuinely believe this story may top it.
Yes, I’ll miss Jake Gyllenhaal terribly… but with Rachel Brosnahan, Matthew Rhys, and Courtney B. Vance joining the cast, this adaptation is already screaming Emmy bait.
Rachel as Leila Reynolds? Absolute perfection. Tell me she won’t eat that role alive.
But first—let’s give this novel the standing ovation it deserves.
What makes Dissection of a Murder so addictive?
This book has everything I want in a legal thriller:
⚖️ Sharp courtroom tension
🧩 A layered mystery
🔥 High emotional stakes
👀 Dual timelines and perspectives
🕵️ A chilling, anonymous watcher
The story unfolds through Leila Reynolds and the mysterious Witness X, whose intersecting narratives blend past and present in a way that never lets you relax.
Leila learned the law from her husband and mentor, Julian—a legendary attorney who shaped her career and pushed her to the top, even helping secure her place in the Legal 500. Their relationship is built on ambition, loyalty, and shared victories… until everything cracks.
Five years earlier, Leila defended Jack Miller, a man wrongfully convicted and imprisoned for two years. Now, Jack is accused of murdering Judge Anton Smythe—the very man who once sentenced him, while Jack’s foster mother was dying of cancer.
And Jack requests only one lawyer: Leila.
The problem?
Leila has never handled a criminal murder case.
And the prosecutor?
Her own husband.
Julian plays to win. And this time, he has no intention of letting Leila save her client.
A shadow watching from the dark…
As the case grows darker, a terrifying presence emerges.
Someone is watching Leila and Julian’s home.
Someone sends Julian a cryptic birthday gift.
Someone stalks Leila, trolls her online, and knows far too much.
Who is Witness X?
What are they hiding?
And how are they connected to Jack, the judge, and Leila’s past?
Every clue is a thread—and when they finally connect, the truth is more disturbing than anything Leila is ready to face.
“Nothing is ever black and white—especially when it comes to the law.”
Final Verdict
This novel is fast, relentless, and impossible to put down.
You will:
bite off your perfectly manicured nails,
forget to blink,
and gasp at every twist.
By the end, you’ll need a spa day to recover from the stress—and it will be completely worth it.
This isn’t just a five-star book.
This is sky-full-of-stars, whole-planet-level brilliant.
The best thriller I’ve read in years.
I laughed like Villanelle at the end—shocked, thrilled, and already desperate for more.
📚 Go get your copy.
I already ordered mine for a future reread.
Endless thanks to NetGalley and Dutton for sharing this absolute MASTERPIECE in exchange for my honest thoughts.
I truly appreciate it.
medium.com
September 13, 2025
My Rating: 5⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Oooh I loved this… twists and reveals done right!!!
A dead Judge.
A silent defendant.
And a courtroom full of liars!!
When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked at how high-profile it is, its the murder of a well respected judge.
This shouldn’t be the kind of case shes leading, its way beyond her expertise. But the defendant, Jack Millman, is clear. He wants her, and only her. To make things worse he’s refusing to speak. How is she supposed to prove herself on what appears to be an unwinnable case?
Losing is not an option.
She must find the most persuasive argument. Trials aren’t won by convincing judges or fellow barristers - they’re all about convincing a jury. Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only to keep Jack out of prison but to also keep her own secrets buried deep.
Its true what they say, there are two sides to every story.
Guilty or Not Guilty? You decide…
Ok, here we go…. I am not going to tell you must about this book you need to go in blind… the synopsis above gives you a taste but it does not tell you must compared to what this book is packing. It is not packing a punch it is packing a bag of punches!!!
I don’t know anything about this author but I am going to find out!! This is a legal thriller and thrilling is the right word. I found it really interesting the legal information that we get from this book. Our author is a former criminal barrister and it shows!!! We get all the inside information (well likely not all) and it is broken down into easy to understand parts and i found that really good. It wasn’t condescending either but for someone like me with very little knowledge of criminal law and the way trials are run (in the UK or anywhere) I loved all the information that wasn’t just spewed At us like an info dump it was interspersed into the story. Loved that!!!
I really liked Leila, even when there were things I was guessing (not all true) that might paint her in a different light.. i was still rooting for her. I liked Jack as well… and I hated Julian from the get go… but you be the judge… why? I can’t tell you at all because it will spoil not one but all the surprises in this book.
It is told from multiple pov from Leila, Witness X and a couple of others and it is interesting to pay close attention when reading the POV you will get clues… but I really don’t think you will guess everything. I had an inkling But then when I was right about one thing I was punched in the face with a different piece of information or a reveal i was not expecting at all… I loved that so much. Its been ages since I have read a book where it has actually taken me by surprise multiple times.
I actually loved the writing so much, it kept me engaged and I wanted to keep reading into the night.. the fact that I couldn't was done to the fact that I am a light weight when going to bed… and nothing to do with how interesting this novel was. I got up in the morning and just started it again!!
I have nothing but praise for this book, I really enjoyed it, and would recommend it!!
Overall, I don’t have any complaints, are there some unrealistic parts… yes!! Its fiction guys!! But the legal information alone is second to none in my opinion, the characters are expertly written and the twists were outstanding I couldn’t ask for anything else. This is my first thriller back after a bit of a break and what a winner I got!!! Loved it!!
I will absolutely be keeping my eye out for this authors next book!!!
Thank you to Netgalley, Macmillan and Jo Murray for an exceptional advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!!
A dead Judge.
A silent defendant.
And a courtroom full of liars!!
When Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked at how high-profile it is, its the murder of a well respected judge.
This shouldn’t be the kind of case shes leading, its way beyond her expertise. But the defendant, Jack Millman, is clear. He wants her, and only her. To make things worse he’s refusing to speak. How is she supposed to prove herself on what appears to be an unwinnable case?
Losing is not an option.
She must find the most persuasive argument. Trials aren’t won by convincing judges or fellow barristers - they’re all about convincing a jury. Suddenly, Leila finds herself fighting not only to keep Jack out of prison but to also keep her own secrets buried deep.
Its true what they say, there are two sides to every story.
Guilty or Not Guilty? You decide…
Ok, here we go…. I am not going to tell you must about this book you need to go in blind… the synopsis above gives you a taste but it does not tell you must compared to what this book is packing. It is not packing a punch it is packing a bag of punches!!!
I don’t know anything about this author but I am going to find out!! This is a legal thriller and thrilling is the right word. I found it really interesting the legal information that we get from this book. Our author is a former criminal barrister and it shows!!! We get all the inside information (well likely not all) and it is broken down into easy to understand parts and i found that really good. It wasn’t condescending either but for someone like me with very little knowledge of criminal law and the way trials are run (in the UK or anywhere) I loved all the information that wasn’t just spewed At us like an info dump it was interspersed into the story. Loved that!!!
I really liked Leila, even when there were things I was guessing (not all true) that might paint her in a different light.. i was still rooting for her. I liked Jack as well… and I hated Julian from the get go… but you be the judge… why? I can’t tell you at all because it will spoil not one but all the surprises in this book.
It is told from multiple pov from Leila, Witness X and a couple of others and it is interesting to pay close attention when reading the POV you will get clues… but I really don’t think you will guess everything. I had an inkling But then when I was right about one thing I was punched in the face with a different piece of information or a reveal i was not expecting at all… I loved that so much. Its been ages since I have read a book where it has actually taken me by surprise multiple times.
I actually loved the writing so much, it kept me engaged and I wanted to keep reading into the night.. the fact that I couldn't was done to the fact that I am a light weight when going to bed… and nothing to do with how interesting this novel was. I got up in the morning and just started it again!!
I have nothing but praise for this book, I really enjoyed it, and would recommend it!!
Overall, I don’t have any complaints, are there some unrealistic parts… yes!! Its fiction guys!! But the legal information alone is second to none in my opinion, the characters are expertly written and the twists were outstanding I couldn’t ask for anything else. This is my first thriller back after a bit of a break and what a winner I got!!! Loved it!!
I will absolutely be keeping my eye out for this authors next book!!!
Thank you to Netgalley, Macmillan and Jo Murray for an exceptional advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!!
November 11, 2025
One of the easiest five star reviews I have ever given, this book is a masterclass on how to deliver a courtroom thriller and has now set such a high bar that I am not sure many books in this genre will be able to reach. Yes, it is THAT good.
I don't want to delve too much into the synopsis, it is a book that you are better to go into relatively blind, but this novel tells the story of Leila, a lawyer from a working class background who has come good. However, when she is instructed on her first murder trial, she is shocked at the high profile nature of it - the victim being a well-respected judge - however the defendant has asked for her personally and she is keen to step up.
The first half of the novel builds up to the trial as Leila seeks evidence which will exonerate her client, who claims he is not guilty but will not put forward a defence. The second half then moves onto the trial itself which is explosive. That's it, I'm saying no more and I know this sounds like a 'typical' legal thriller but trust me it is not.
The multiple POVs tell the story expertly and, in addition to the legal aspects of the book, the personal lives of those within the chamber add an extra dimension without being crass.
The ending is delivered in a way which I have not experienced for a long time, it was a literal gasp out loud moment, and I can't wait for my Goodreads friends to read this so we can talk about it. This would be a good buddy read for people who have it on their TBR list. It's sure to be one of the hits of 2026.
Thanks to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan | Macmillan for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I don't want to delve too much into the synopsis, it is a book that you are better to go into relatively blind, but this novel tells the story of Leila, a lawyer from a working class background who has come good. However, when she is instructed on her first murder trial, she is shocked at the high profile nature of it - the victim being a well-respected judge - however the defendant has asked for her personally and she is keen to step up.
The first half of the novel builds up to the trial as Leila seeks evidence which will exonerate her client, who claims he is not guilty but will not put forward a defence. The second half then moves onto the trial itself which is explosive. That's it, I'm saying no more and I know this sounds like a 'typical' legal thriller but trust me it is not.
The multiple POVs tell the story expertly and, in addition to the legal aspects of the book, the personal lives of those within the chamber add an extra dimension without being crass.
The ending is delivered in a way which I have not experienced for a long time, it was a literal gasp out loud moment, and I can't wait for my Goodreads friends to read this so we can talk about it. This would be a good buddy read for people who have it on their TBR list. It's sure to be one of the hits of 2026.
Thanks to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan | Macmillan for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 28, 2025
5🌟
Like omg what do you mean? You where not ready for the gasp I gusped when the plot hitted me...
I'm going to keep this clean and simple because you just have to experience this one for yourself and I will not spoil this for anyone!
This was a thriller masterpiece 👌 Brava Jo Murray! This was deliciously thrilling, the suspension was top-notch! I finished this in under 24 hours, that is how addictive this book was!
If you are a thriller fan you should definitely pick this one up like immediately!
Thank you Netgalley and Pan Macmillan publishing for this amazing ARC! What a gift to experience this before someone could spoil this for me ❤️
Like omg what do you mean? You where not ready for the gasp I gusped when the plot hitted me...
I'm going to keep this clean and simple because you just have to experience this one for yourself and I will not spoil this for anyone!
This was a thriller masterpiece 👌 Brava Jo Murray! This was deliciously thrilling, the suspension was top-notch! I finished this in under 24 hours, that is how addictive this book was!
If you are a thriller fan you should definitely pick this one up like immediately!
Thank you Netgalley and Pan Macmillan publishing for this amazing ARC! What a gift to experience this before someone could spoil this for me ❤️
January 3, 2026
Dissection of a Murder is a gripping debut legal thriller that’s generating a huge buzz ahead of it’s publication day on 7th May 2026 and suffering from acute FOMO I knew I had to get my hands on an early copy to see what all the fuss is about and if it lives up to all the hype.
The answer is simply YES. This brilliant courtroom thriller is an absolute page-turner and literally “unputdownable”. I devoured it in two sittings (if I didn’t have to work, eat and sleep, I’m pretty sure this could have been read in one sitting).
Although there are hundreds of great legal/courtroom thrillers out there, this one stands out for me for a couple of reasons. Firstly, the author was a Criminal Barrister and provides the reader with a very helpful and detailed explanation of all the legal procedures and terminology in basic layman’s terms throughout the book. Thus helping us to understand and appreciate the situations and scenarios without being blindsided by legal jargon. Secondly, the plotline is very, very clever.
A newly qualified barrister, Leila Reynolds, is given her first murder case. Her client is Jack Millman – accused of the brutal murder of a well respected Judge. This is a very high profile case and the defendant is refusing to speak about the crime before the trial. Another concern is that the prosecuting barrister is Leila’s husband, Julian. He’s determined to win this case by any means possible and his reputation is more important than his wife or marriage.
Told from the point of view of several characters, Dissection of A Murder, takes the reader on a tense and twisty tale. With a mystery narrator called Witness X, the reader hasn’t got a clue what really happened to the judge, why Jack Millman refuses to co-operate and how low Julian will stoop to discredit his wife and win this case.
With comparisons to The Silent Patient and Blood Orange, fans of courtroom dramas and psychological thrillers will absolutely LOVE this book
I don’t want to say much more, except pop the date in your calendar (7th May 2026) and pre-order your copy now.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The answer is simply YES. This brilliant courtroom thriller is an absolute page-turner and literally “unputdownable”. I devoured it in two sittings (if I didn’t have to work, eat and sleep, I’m pretty sure this could have been read in one sitting).
Although there are hundreds of great legal/courtroom thrillers out there, this one stands out for me for a couple of reasons. Firstly, the author was a Criminal Barrister and provides the reader with a very helpful and detailed explanation of all the legal procedures and terminology in basic layman’s terms throughout the book. Thus helping us to understand and appreciate the situations and scenarios without being blindsided by legal jargon. Secondly, the plotline is very, very clever.
A newly qualified barrister, Leila Reynolds, is given her first murder case. Her client is Jack Millman – accused of the brutal murder of a well respected Judge. This is a very high profile case and the defendant is refusing to speak about the crime before the trial. Another concern is that the prosecuting barrister is Leila’s husband, Julian. He’s determined to win this case by any means possible and his reputation is more important than his wife or marriage.
Told from the point of view of several characters, Dissection of A Murder, takes the reader on a tense and twisty tale. With a mystery narrator called Witness X, the reader hasn’t got a clue what really happened to the judge, why Jack Millman refuses to co-operate and how low Julian will stoop to discredit his wife and win this case.
With comparisons to The Silent Patient and Blood Orange, fans of courtroom dramas and psychological thrillers will absolutely LOVE this book
I don’t want to say much more, except pop the date in your calendar (7th May 2026) and pre-order your copy now.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
October 20, 2025
This is one of the easiest 5 stars I gave this year. I feel so grateful to have been lucky enough to get an early copy of this book because it was amazing. It was so clever and perfectly executed and came together so perfectly. It’s made me want to pick up more legal thrillers. Jo Murray is fabulous and I’ve already pre-ordered my hardback copy! Absolutely one not to miss in 2026!
August 19, 2025
The type of twist that makes you want to go back & read it all again
November 16, 2025
What a thriller, shocking right to the end. I loved the trial, the personal stories, the characters, the setting and the tension throughout. Outstanding read! Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 20, 2025
4.5/5
Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, defending Jack Millman, who has been accused of murdering a well-respected judge. The last time Leila represented Jack, she lost. On top of that past failure, she faces the added pressure of going up against her husband, who is more senior and experienced than she is.
I love a good legal thriller, but I often find they’re not done well. This one, however, was phenomenal—and I think it helped that the author is a former criminal barrister.
The plot felt fresh, and I really enjoyed the multiple points of view. It was so clever, addictive, and well-written that I’m shocked this is a debut novel! I can’t even imagine how amazing her future books will be.
I also feel like I learned a lot about the legal system, and the definitions of legal terms at the start of the book were incredibly helpful!
This came very close to being a 5-star read for me, but I did guess a couple of the twists, and I didn’t love the way the book ended. You’ll have to read it for yourself, though—I won’t spoil anything!
Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case, defending Jack Millman, who has been accused of murdering a well-respected judge. The last time Leila represented Jack, she lost. On top of that past failure, she faces the added pressure of going up against her husband, who is more senior and experienced than she is.
I love a good legal thriller, but I often find they’re not done well. This one, however, was phenomenal—and I think it helped that the author is a former criminal barrister.
The plot felt fresh, and I really enjoyed the multiple points of view. It was so clever, addictive, and well-written that I’m shocked this is a debut novel! I can’t even imagine how amazing her future books will be.
I also feel like I learned a lot about the legal system, and the definitions of legal terms at the start of the book were incredibly helpful!
This came very close to being a 5-star read for me, but I did guess a couple of the twists, and I didn’t love the way the book ended. You’ll have to read it for yourself, though—I won’t spoil anything!
November 12, 2025
With many thanks to Netgalley for this free arc and I am leaving this unbiased review voluntarily
OOh Jo Murray this is good, seriously good. Razor sharp detail and flawless knowledge give this legal thriller a wonderful edge. The build up to the trial is sublime, the characters compelling and the court room scenes ooze with tension. Although I had an inkling who Witness X was - and without giving anything away it was just the smallest of clues that lead me there - it didn't in anyway detract from the enjoyment. Even though I didn't get that 'jaw dropping' moment when the twist was revealed, it is still an amazing reveal. It's gripping, wonderfully written and very hard to put down. This is going to be a book to read in 2026. 4.5⭐️
Review of advance copy
An edge of your seat courtroom drama so cleverly written and suspenseful with twists right up until the end..... What is justice? It had me so hooked I didn't want to put it down so I read it in one sitting (well in less than 24hrs) With this debut book, Jo Murray has basically just handed us a smoking gun..... but has certainly done it justice!
November 11, 2025
Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray wastes no time pulling you in. Leila Reynolds, a promising barrister, gets tossed straight into the deep end: her very first murder case, and she’s defending Jack Millman, accused of killing a well-loved judge. The stakes couldn’t be higher. Jack won’t say a word, which only makes Leila’s job tougher. Suddenly, she’s in a courtroom thick with secrets, agendas, and half-truths, and the truth always seems just out of reach.
Leila’s journey grabs you. She starts out overwhelmed, but you watch her steady herself, stumbling and then finding her strengths. She’s driven, but she’s got secrets of her own, and that tension between ambition and vulnerability keeps the story alive far beyond the legal chess match. Jack’s silence, the unpredictable jurors, and supporting characters who never quite do what you expect; they all add more shadows and double meanings. The result is a story that’s both tightly wound and unexpectedly intimate.
Murray doesn’t just stick to the surface details of a murder trial. The novel explores justice, truth, and the uneasy space between guilt and innocence. It echoes real debates about how much we can trust the legal system, how easily facts twist under pressure, and how much we filter everything through our own biases. The book doesn’t just tell a story; it asks you to check your own assumptions about fairness, to sit with your own uncertainty.
Murray writes with a style that’s easy to follow, but never boring. There’s a seriousness to the tone, but it never gets too heavy; there’s suspense, even a little humor, and the pacing is spot-on. The courtroom feels alive, tense, but the focus stays on what drives the characters, what scares them, what they want to hide. The language isn’t fancy, but it hits home, and you end up feeling what Leila feels, her doubts, her hopes, her frustration.
What really sets this book apart is how it balances the sharp edge of a legal thriller with the real, personal struggles of its main character. This isn’t just a clever puzzle. It feels honest, messy, human. If there’s one thing missing, it’s that a few of the side characters could have used a bit more attention. They’re interesting, but you want to know them better. Still, Dissection of a Murder leaves a mark. It forces you to look at truth and justice through Leila’s eyes, and makes you wonder what you’d do in that jury box. It’s a fresh take on the legal thriller, familiar in some ways, but with a voice and perspective that feel entirely its own.
Leila’s journey grabs you. She starts out overwhelmed, but you watch her steady herself, stumbling and then finding her strengths. She’s driven, but she’s got secrets of her own, and that tension between ambition and vulnerability keeps the story alive far beyond the legal chess match. Jack’s silence, the unpredictable jurors, and supporting characters who never quite do what you expect; they all add more shadows and double meanings. The result is a story that’s both tightly wound and unexpectedly intimate.
Murray doesn’t just stick to the surface details of a murder trial. The novel explores justice, truth, and the uneasy space between guilt and innocence. It echoes real debates about how much we can trust the legal system, how easily facts twist under pressure, and how much we filter everything through our own biases. The book doesn’t just tell a story; it asks you to check your own assumptions about fairness, to sit with your own uncertainty.
Murray writes with a style that’s easy to follow, but never boring. There’s a seriousness to the tone, but it never gets too heavy; there’s suspense, even a little humor, and the pacing is spot-on. The courtroom feels alive, tense, but the focus stays on what drives the characters, what scares them, what they want to hide. The language isn’t fancy, but it hits home, and you end up feeling what Leila feels, her doubts, her hopes, her frustration.
What really sets this book apart is how it balances the sharp edge of a legal thriller with the real, personal struggles of its main character. This isn’t just a clever puzzle. It feels honest, messy, human. If there’s one thing missing, it’s that a few of the side characters could have used a bit more attention. They’re interesting, but you want to know them better. Still, Dissection of a Murder leaves a mark. It forces you to look at truth and justice through Leila’s eyes, and makes you wonder what you’d do in that jury box. It’s a fresh take on the legal thriller, familiar in some ways, but with a voice and perspective that feel entirely its own.
November 9, 2025
An easy five stars. When I wasn’t reading this book, I was either thinking about it or waiting until I could start reading more!
A courtroom thriller which is brilliantly written throughout with drama, secrets and lies. The way in which the book is written is that we don’t have a clue as to what happened really, the defendant doesn’t give anything away by refusing to cooperate and then the legal teams are husband and wife who are the prosecution and defence teams. There are explanations of some legal jargon in the book which are laid out simply to help us understand meanings, I found this very helpful.
It is a very good storyline and has some interesting characters which all make a brilliant read. Due out in May 2026, pick it up and see what you think.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC of this ebook in exchange for my honest review.
A courtroom thriller which is brilliantly written throughout with drama, secrets and lies. The way in which the book is written is that we don’t have a clue as to what happened really, the defendant doesn’t give anything away by refusing to cooperate and then the legal teams are husband and wife who are the prosecution and defence teams. There are explanations of some legal jargon in the book which are laid out simply to help us understand meanings, I found this very helpful.
It is a very good storyline and has some interesting characters which all make a brilliant read. Due out in May 2026, pick it up and see what you think.
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC of this ebook in exchange for my honest review.
November 25, 2025
I found this book a bit boring at the beginning but it’s well written. The last 3rd is really exciting and I couldn’t read it quick enough - very clever
November 22, 2025
“It may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court”, so going ‘no comment’ is risky! When a case comes to trial, the defence team usually present a statement to the prosecution outlining the defence they are proposing and requiring the prosecution to present any evidence they have which relates to the material in the statement. This should be to the defence’s advantage, but the corollary is that it also makes the defence vulnerable. The first time junior barrister Leila Reynolds defended Jack Millman, she persuaded him to confess all, as a result of which his witness, forewarned by the statement, disappeared, and he was jailed for GBH. Now five years later he is accused of murdering a Judge and has demanded, as is his right, that Leila be his defence barrister. There are problems with this: most obviously, she has never worked on a murder case; secondly, the prosecution barrister is Julian Kesler KC, Leila’s former pupilmaster, and now husband, who is hugely and arrogantly experienced in such cases; and, trickiest of all, Jack has gone ‘No Comment’ so Leila can’t produce a defence statement, which is the classic “may harm your defence” situation. And, on top of it all, an old adversary from Leila’s past is threatening to destroy her reputation. Can justice prevail? Well you’ll have to read the book to find out.
And read it right to the end. Because this is not a straightforward court room drama – although it is a very good one – nor is it a straightforward murder mystery – although it is also a very good one. It is also, in some ways, a psychological thriller, and a domestic drama. The plot is multilayered and twisted, and spotting the main twists and working out the ending is a serious challenge to the reader. The characters are all well drawn, perhaps a bit fitted to type, but Leila is a one off, and Jack is an interesting creation. If it has a fault, it is that the pace drops through the middle, mainly because of the complexity needed in interlacing the plot strands. Not perfect but clearly more than a 4.5, so 5 stars. It is tempting to suggest that there must be a sequel.
I would like to thank NetGalley, the publishers and the author for providing me with a draft proof copy for the purpose of this review.
And read it right to the end. Because this is not a straightforward court room drama – although it is a very good one – nor is it a straightforward murder mystery – although it is also a very good one. It is also, in some ways, a psychological thriller, and a domestic drama. The plot is multilayered and twisted, and spotting the main twists and working out the ending is a serious challenge to the reader. The characters are all well drawn, perhaps a bit fitted to type, but Leila is a one off, and Jack is an interesting creation. If it has a fault, it is that the pace drops through the middle, mainly because of the complexity needed in interlacing the plot strands. Not perfect but clearly more than a 4.5, so 5 stars. It is tempting to suggest that there must be a sequel.
I would like to thank NetGalley, the publishers and the author for providing me with a draft proof copy for the purpose of this review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I usually do not read ARCs so far before their release date. But this book was an exception and I am glad I made it!
The Story:
Jack Millman is arrested for murder. He instructs Leila specifically to lead his defence. Leila is scared - this is her first murder case as a lead. What if she is unable to present Jack's defence satisfactorily? Especially when the prosecutor is her husband (and also her pupilmaster), the King's Counsel, Julian? And making the case all the more difficult is the fact that Jack is unwilling to say anything beforehand, insisting that he will speak only in front of the jury.
As Leila struggles against the inbuilt injustice of the entire system with its strict, but unsaid, rules about genders and seniority, it becomes a race against time for her. Especially with her nemesis on the prowl once again...
What I Liked:
1) The writing: The author is a barrister herself and her experience shows in the story. The cross-examination scenes in the book were my particular favourite. Moreover, the way she takes us inside the rigid law system and shows us all its parts - the highs and the lows. The author, Jo Murray, is a debutante but she shows tremendous control over her words. I will look out for her in the future.
2) Jack Millman: What a character. He talks very less in the whole book, but he remained with me long after I shut the book.
3) Leila: As a female barrister, Leila came across as very believable. She is not idealistic - she knows that as a woman, she will not be awarded the same liberties as her husband, a KC no less. But she does not let this faze her. If anything, she looks at the positives of every situation and tries to land on her feet every time.
4) The plot: As a whole, the plot was great. And the epilogue! It took me back to The Kind Worth Killing when a well-written epilogue can transform the entire story!
What I Disliked:
1) The pacing: The book lags quite a lot in the middle. It is understandable, given that the defendant is unwilling to open his mouth but even so, that part felt stretched out quite a lot.
2) The 'twist': I guessed the twist long before it came and it sounded improbable even so. I was expecting to be proved wrong but the ending seemed forced. (The epilogue made up for it, though.)
3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
Thanks to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for the ARC.
The Story:
Jack Millman is arrested for murder. He instructs Leila specifically to lead his defence. Leila is scared - this is her first murder case as a lead. What if she is unable to present Jack's defence satisfactorily? Especially when the prosecutor is her husband (and also her pupilmaster), the King's Counsel, Julian? And making the case all the more difficult is the fact that Jack is unwilling to say anything beforehand, insisting that he will speak only in front of the jury.
As Leila struggles against the inbuilt injustice of the entire system with its strict, but unsaid, rules about genders and seniority, it becomes a race against time for her. Especially with her nemesis on the prowl once again...
What I Liked:
1) The writing: The author is a barrister herself and her experience shows in the story. The cross-examination scenes in the book were my particular favourite. Moreover, the way she takes us inside the rigid law system and shows us all its parts - the highs and the lows. The author, Jo Murray, is a debutante but she shows tremendous control over her words. I will look out for her in the future.
2) Jack Millman: What a character. He talks very less in the whole book, but he remained with me long after I shut the book.
3) Leila: As a female barrister, Leila came across as very believable. She is not idealistic - she knows that as a woman, she will not be awarded the same liberties as her husband, a KC no less. But she does not let this faze her. If anything, she looks at the positives of every situation and tries to land on her feet every time.
4) The plot: As a whole, the plot was great. And the epilogue! It took me back to The Kind Worth Killing when a well-written epilogue can transform the entire story!
What I Disliked:
1) The pacing: The book lags quite a lot in the middle. It is understandable, given that the defendant is unwilling to open his mouth but even so, that part felt stretched out quite a lot.
2) The 'twist': I guessed the twist long before it came and it sounded improbable even so. I was expecting to be proved wrong but the ending seemed forced. (The epilogue made up for it, though.)
3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
Thanks to Netgalley and Pan Macmillan for the ARC.
September 6, 2025
Wow what a superb book. A court room drama with an exquisite twist.
From the intrigue of the Prologue right the way through to the incredible Epilogue this book was absolutely fabulous. So cleverly written with plotlines that astounded and delighted. It was fast past paced and utterly compelling. Right from the beginning where we meet Jack Millman accused of the brutal murder of a high profile and well respected judge, we are woven into a web of enthralling tales and secrets.
I loved that the author gave us a detailed explanation of all the legal procedures and terminology but in a very clear way that really helped me to understand and appreciate the situations and scenarios within the book. I really enjoyed learning about the legal side of things.
Then throw in the drama of a newly qualified defence barrister, Leila Reynolds who is up against the highly experienced prosecuting barrister, Julian, who also happens to be Leila's husband and this takes to another level of suspense and tension. Leila is defending Jack Millman who refuses to cooperate and speak about the crime that was committed. The power play between Leila and Julian is delectable. Julian has an impeccable reputation and he is determined to win the case no matter what the cost. Leila wants to prove that she is equally capable of winning her murder case.
The story is told from multiple points of view but is easy to follow and understand. I really relished the other characters that we meet in the book and how they and their lives introduced tantalizing aspects to the storylines.
I felt like I was in the court room listening in as the story unfolded, revelations were uncovered and the truth was teased out. I loved the line in the book 'often it's the tiniest details that reveal the greatest secrets.'
I also enjoyed the setting in Durham and Newcastle. I really appreciated the references to the old buildings and surroundings in Durham and that seemed to perfectly mirror the traditions of the legal profession and the historical details that the author shared with us throughout this book.
A superb, fast paced thriller that will get you heart racing. Highly recommended
Huge thanks to PanMacmillan/Netgalley for the ARC!
From the intrigue of the Prologue right the way through to the incredible Epilogue this book was absolutely fabulous. So cleverly written with plotlines that astounded and delighted. It was fast past paced and utterly compelling. Right from the beginning where we meet Jack Millman accused of the brutal murder of a high profile and well respected judge, we are woven into a web of enthralling tales and secrets.
I loved that the author gave us a detailed explanation of all the legal procedures and terminology but in a very clear way that really helped me to understand and appreciate the situations and scenarios within the book. I really enjoyed learning about the legal side of things.
Then throw in the drama of a newly qualified defence barrister, Leila Reynolds who is up against the highly experienced prosecuting barrister, Julian, who also happens to be Leila's husband and this takes to another level of suspense and tension. Leila is defending Jack Millman who refuses to cooperate and speak about the crime that was committed. The power play between Leila and Julian is delectable. Julian has an impeccable reputation and he is determined to win the case no matter what the cost. Leila wants to prove that she is equally capable of winning her murder case.
The story is told from multiple points of view but is easy to follow and understand. I really relished the other characters that we meet in the book and how they and their lives introduced tantalizing aspects to the storylines.
I felt like I was in the court room listening in as the story unfolded, revelations were uncovered and the truth was teased out. I loved the line in the book 'often it's the tiniest details that reveal the greatest secrets.'
I also enjoyed the setting in Durham and Newcastle. I really appreciated the references to the old buildings and surroundings in Durham and that seemed to perfectly mirror the traditions of the legal profession and the historical details that the author shared with us throughout this book.
A superb, fast paced thriller that will get you heart racing. Highly recommended
Huge thanks to PanMacmillan/Netgalley for the ARC!
December 22, 2025
Where do I start?! Firstly, I read this book in one sitting! It was a very compelling read which had so much more depth than I was expecting and it gets deeper as it goes. The book begins as a fast-paced courtroom thriller, but quickly becomes something far more psychologically complex. This isn't a simple 'whodunnit;' the novel steadily dismantles the reader’s sense of certainty - and not just about the case, but about the people involved and the assumptions we bring to them.
The legal detail felt authentic to me as though the author has first-hand experience of the UK's criminal justice system (my former career!). I looked up the author and was unsurprised to learn she is a former criminal barrister.
The courtroom scenes are sharp, the plot is fast-paced and the writing is excellent, but what really sets this book apart is its character work. The protagonist is compelling, unsettling, and increasingly difficult to categorise; the novel asks the reader to sit with that discomfort rather than resolving it neatly.
There are multiple POVs which doesn't always work for me, however I thought Murray pulled it off very well. One of the POVs is Witness X who we learn more about as the book unfolds. There are many twists and turns - a couple made me gasp(!) and even though I saw one major reveal coming, I didn't see the full intricacies of it or expect it to go where it did. This book is unlike many thrillers I've read in that it doesn't rely on reveals or cheap thrills; it has real depth and takes it further than most.
This is a debut that takes risks morally, structurally, and psychologically. It’s dark, intelligent, and thought-provoking and it's going to stick with me. I think it says a lot that as soon as I'd finished reading it I felt the need to tell my husband all about it and to dive into the questions it brings up with him! Not many thrillers make me think deeply or question my own morality - but by the end, this achieved it.
TLDR: Highly recommended for readers who enjoy legal thrillers with complex characters, depth and a touch of ambiguity.
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for this ARC. I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
The legal detail felt authentic to me as though the author has first-hand experience of the UK's criminal justice system (my former career!). I looked up the author and was unsurprised to learn she is a former criminal barrister.
The courtroom scenes are sharp, the plot is fast-paced and the writing is excellent, but what really sets this book apart is its character work. The protagonist is compelling, unsettling, and increasingly difficult to categorise; the novel asks the reader to sit with that discomfort rather than resolving it neatly.
There are multiple POVs which doesn't always work for me, however I thought Murray pulled it off very well. One of the POVs is Witness X who we learn more about as the book unfolds. There are many twists and turns - a couple made me gasp(!) and even though I saw one major reveal coming, I didn't see the full intricacies of it or expect it to go where it did. This book is unlike many thrillers I've read in that it doesn't rely on reveals or cheap thrills; it has real depth and takes it further than most.
This is a debut that takes risks morally, structurally, and psychologically. It’s dark, intelligent, and thought-provoking and it's going to stick with me. I think it says a lot that as soon as I'd finished reading it I felt the need to tell my husband all about it and to dive into the questions it brings up with him! Not many thrillers make me think deeply or question my own morality - but by the end, this achieved it.
TLDR: Highly recommended for readers who enjoy legal thrillers with complex characters, depth and a touch of ambiguity.
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for this ARC. I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I enjoy reading courtroom thrillers and so I was excited to request to read Dissection of a Murder.
Leila is defending her first murder case, but not only is she up against her husband, who is prosecuting, her client is refusing to talk which is making it impossible to work on her defence. Can she work out what happened and win the case?
The first thing that struck me when reading Dissection of a Murder was that author Jo Murray must have lived-in experience of the UK criminal justice system. I was correct on this assumption – she has previously worked as a criminal barrister. This is apparent in the writing which feels realistic and well-rounded, but Murray is quick to put the reader at ease with explanations of systems and terminology that may not be instantly familiar. The novel shows the less glamourous side of UK courtroom life where sexism, hierarchy and outdated pomp and circumstance run rife. The added dynamic of Leila’s character wanting to fight against sexism, but also getting perks from her husband being senior in the hierarchy was a nice addition.
It is hard to believe that this is Murray’s debut novel – it’s well paced and plotted with twists and turns at every junction. The narrative partially alternates between main character Leila and Witness X, whose identity the reader is kept in the dark about until the very last minute. Their chapters begin with explanation about their childhood and upbringing and slowly start to reveal how they are linked to the case.
The case itself is twisty, and there’s a lot of moving parts, but nothing felt confusing and everything felt grounded in reality. Sometimes courtroom dramas can feel a little slow, but this is a fast-paced read which I could not put down. I don’t want to give anything away, but I absolutely loved the outcome and the reveal at the end and think it was the perfect twist to the story.
Overall, Dissection of a Murder is a twisty courtroom thriller grounded in the gritty reality of the UK court system – a Kindig Gem for 2026. Thank you to NetGalley & Pan Macmillan for the chance to read the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
For more of my reviews check out Kindig Blog
Leila is defending her first murder case, but not only is she up against her husband, who is prosecuting, her client is refusing to talk which is making it impossible to work on her defence. Can she work out what happened and win the case?
The first thing that struck me when reading Dissection of a Murder was that author Jo Murray must have lived-in experience of the UK criminal justice system. I was correct on this assumption – she has previously worked as a criminal barrister. This is apparent in the writing which feels realistic and well-rounded, but Murray is quick to put the reader at ease with explanations of systems and terminology that may not be instantly familiar. The novel shows the less glamourous side of UK courtroom life where sexism, hierarchy and outdated pomp and circumstance run rife. The added dynamic of Leila’s character wanting to fight against sexism, but also getting perks from her husband being senior in the hierarchy was a nice addition.
It is hard to believe that this is Murray’s debut novel – it’s well paced and plotted with twists and turns at every junction. The narrative partially alternates between main character Leila and Witness X, whose identity the reader is kept in the dark about until the very last minute. Their chapters begin with explanation about their childhood and upbringing and slowly start to reveal how they are linked to the case.
The case itself is twisty, and there’s a lot of moving parts, but nothing felt confusing and everything felt grounded in reality. Sometimes courtroom dramas can feel a little slow, but this is a fast-paced read which I could not put down. I don’t want to give anything away, but I absolutely loved the outcome and the reveal at the end and think it was the perfect twist to the story.
Overall, Dissection of a Murder is a twisty courtroom thriller grounded in the gritty reality of the UK court system – a Kindig Gem for 2026. Thank you to NetGalley & Pan Macmillan for the chance to read the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
For more of my reviews check out Kindig Blog
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray opens with one of the most gripping premises in recent legal thrillers: newly qualified barrister Leila Reynolds is handed her first murder case – defending Jack Millman, accused of killing a well-respected judge. That in itself would be enough pressure. But Jack refuses to speak. To make matters more complicated, the prosecutor across the bar is Leila’s own husband, Julian – her mentor, rival, and the one person who knows her legal past intimately.
The courtroom scenes, drawn from Murray’s own experience as a barrister, feel lived-in and authentic rather than symbolic or performative – you get the sense of being right there under the lights, watching tactics play out in real time. Even without heavy legal jargon, the dynamics of trial strategy and jury persuasion are presented with clarity and drama.
Murray balances the external pressures of a sensational trial with the internal pressures of marriage, self-doubt, and secrecy. Leila is not just fighting for her client; she’s fighting to hold together her own life. The narrative structure, which includes perspectives from multiple characters and even a mysterious Witness X who claims to know what truly happened, adds another layer of tension.
One of the risks with mystery novels is the reveal itself. Too often, the culprit is uncovered by keeping the reader artificially in the dark, through conveniently withheld information or last-minute disclosures that feel more like sleight of hand than genuine deduction. Dissection of a Murder ultimately falls into this trap. While the build-up is tense and engaging, the resolution relies on information that the reader hasn’t been allowed to fully access, making the reveal feel less earned than it could have been.
That said, the journey remains compelling. Jo Murray’s courtroom realism and sharp pacing keep the pages turning, even if the final unravelling doesn’t quite live up to the promise of the premise.
Thanks to the publisher for the ARC.
The courtroom scenes, drawn from Murray’s own experience as a barrister, feel lived-in and authentic rather than symbolic or performative – you get the sense of being right there under the lights, watching tactics play out in real time. Even without heavy legal jargon, the dynamics of trial strategy and jury persuasion are presented with clarity and drama.
Murray balances the external pressures of a sensational trial with the internal pressures of marriage, self-doubt, and secrecy. Leila is not just fighting for her client; she’s fighting to hold together her own life. The narrative structure, which includes perspectives from multiple characters and even a mysterious Witness X who claims to know what truly happened, adds another layer of tension.
One of the risks with mystery novels is the reveal itself. Too often, the culprit is uncovered by keeping the reader artificially in the dark, through conveniently withheld information or last-minute disclosures that feel more like sleight of hand than genuine deduction. Dissection of a Murder ultimately falls into this trap. While the build-up is tense and engaging, the resolution relies on information that the reader hasn’t been allowed to fully access, making the reveal feel less earned than it could have been.
That said, the journey remains compelling. Jo Murray’s courtroom realism and sharp pacing keep the pages turning, even if the final unravelling doesn’t quite live up to the promise of the premise.
Thanks to the publisher for the ARC.
July 29, 2025
Thank you to the author and publisher for allowing me an ARC of this via NetGalley! That has not influenced my review and all opinions are my own.
Wow wow wow!!! This book is gripping, entertaining and mind bending. I love a thriller, and with this being dubbed as similar to The Silent Patient, I went into this with high expectations but this novel absolutely blew me out of the water.
Court room thrillers are incredibly hard to write; there are so many bits and pieces and medical/law jargon that we can sometimes have difficulty understanding but this was incredibly easy to read and digest. It takes the reader into the court room, and every time the page is turned we have more surprises and twists. There is a huuuuge plot twist in this book that I absolutely did not expect. This book gave me emotional whiplash (in a great way). I thought I had it figured out but then it changed direction rapidly.
It’s hard to write a spoiler free review for this book but I can’t even begin to describe how much I loved this book. I was so excited to finish it because I felt addicted, but now that I have finished it I feel like there’s a hole inside my soul!
The author does a really good job at making us feel emotions through different characters. I loved Jack and wanted to protect him with my life, and I absolutely despised Julian. The author has a great way of really dragging you into this story and making you feel like you’re living it as opposed to just reading it.
Overall I absolutely loved this book, and described it to my partner as being ‘a book that has baffled me and amazed me at the same time’. I definitely recommend this to anyone who likes mystery, crime thrillers, court rooms/law, and just generally unhinged and twisty books!
Rating: 5/5 (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️)
Wow wow wow!!! This book is gripping, entertaining and mind bending. I love a thriller, and with this being dubbed as similar to The Silent Patient, I went into this with high expectations but this novel absolutely blew me out of the water.
Court room thrillers are incredibly hard to write; there are so many bits and pieces and medical/law jargon that we can sometimes have difficulty understanding but this was incredibly easy to read and digest. It takes the reader into the court room, and every time the page is turned we have more surprises and twists. There is a huuuuge plot twist in this book that I absolutely did not expect. This book gave me emotional whiplash (in a great way). I thought I had it figured out but then it changed direction rapidly.
It’s hard to write a spoiler free review for this book but I can’t even begin to describe how much I loved this book. I was so excited to finish it because I felt addicted, but now that I have finished it I feel like there’s a hole inside my soul!
The author does a really good job at making us feel emotions through different characters. I loved Jack and wanted to protect him with my life, and I absolutely despised Julian. The author has a great way of really dragging you into this story and making you feel like you’re living it as opposed to just reading it.
Overall I absolutely loved this book, and described it to my partner as being ‘a book that has baffled me and amazed me at the same time’. I definitely recommend this to anyone who likes mystery, crime thrillers, court rooms/law, and just generally unhinged and twisty books!
Rating: 5/5 (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️)
October 21, 2025
A murder case sees Barrister Leila in the biggest case of her career, whereby she has to defend a former client against a tough prosecutor, her husband.
Already the premise of the book means that you know it will be full of the internal workings of the legal system. As someone that loves a legal thriller, it was nice to see a book about the UK system and how barristers operate. The book explains the process really well whilst not detracting too much from the plot.
What was great about the main body of the book was the reality of it - there is a point when Leila mentions that a last minute piece of smoking gun evidence arriving at the eleventh hour of a trial just doesn't happen. It makes great telly, but it isn't what actually happens.
The dynamic of the relationship between Leila and her husband is obviously affected by the trial. Within the story there is a mysterious Witness X that occasionally narrates the story -there were multiple characters that it could have been and I kept guessing who it was. This book had a definite plot twist (which I won't spoil here) that I did not expect.
The twist within the book happens near the end, which really changes the style of the story. I didn't expect it and the tonal shift added to the surprise. I like a plot twist, but this one for me did and didn't work. I'm still undecided whether I personally thought it was a good one or not. But to me the fact that I am still thinking about it, means its a good book.
I was engaged in this novel the whole time and found it fascinating, there was a modern day Kavanagh QC feel to it with the procedural elements.
I was engaged, didn't stop reading when I really needed to go to bed and am still thinking about this book. All of which for me personally are signs of a good book.
Already the premise of the book means that you know it will be full of the internal workings of the legal system. As someone that loves a legal thriller, it was nice to see a book about the UK system and how barristers operate. The book explains the process really well whilst not detracting too much from the plot.
What was great about the main body of the book was the reality of it - there is a point when Leila mentions that a last minute piece of smoking gun evidence arriving at the eleventh hour of a trial just doesn't happen. It makes great telly, but it isn't what actually happens.
The dynamic of the relationship between Leila and her husband is obviously affected by the trial. Within the story there is a mysterious Witness X that occasionally narrates the story -there were multiple characters that it could have been and I kept guessing who it was. This book had a definite plot twist (which I won't spoil here) that I did not expect.
The twist within the book happens near the end, which really changes the style of the story. I didn't expect it and the tonal shift added to the surprise. I like a plot twist, but this one for me did and didn't work. I'm still undecided whether I personally thought it was a good one or not. But to me the fact that I am still thinking about it, means its a good book.
I was engaged in this novel the whole time and found it fascinating, there was a modern day Kavanagh QC feel to it with the procedural elements.
I was engaged, didn't stop reading when I really needed to go to bed and am still thinking about this book. All of which for me personally are signs of a good book.
January 20, 2026
Unusually as I start this review, I’m really not sure what I’m going to write. My mind is full of so many superlatives, that I’m struggling to put them in to sentences, as opposed to just making a long list.
Leila Reynolds is a barrister, married to Julian Kesler, eleven years her senior, a KC, and her Pupilmaster. They are about to go to war. Leila has been requested to lead Jack Millman’s defence, while Julian will be prosecuting for the Crown. The resulting case is quite explosive, in many ways.
The victim, Anton Smythe, 56, was a Crown Court Judge, a family man, highly respected by the judiciary. The case appears to be a foregone conclusion for the prosecution. The dying judge is found in a convicted criminal’s flat, the 999 call confession recorded for all to hear. Surprisingly, the defendant pleads not guilty, the stage is then set for a mouth watering trial.
As I said above, Dissection of a Murder is the debut by Jo Murray, but having just turned the last page, I’m stunned in the very best way. It is complex, well written and incredibly well plotted. The characterisation is rich and deep. I was willing some of them on, while feeling far less charitable towards others. This isn’t just a gripping court case, it is so much more.
As I read, and the court case started, a very uneasy feeling settled on me. There was clearly something hugely significant, that was just out of the readers’ reach. Despite my very best efforts I couldn’t work it out, which made me read compulsively.
This is an assured debut, it feels like it has been written by a hugely experienced author. It is such a fabulous read, and I can’t recommend it highly enough. Dissection of a Murder has been raved about by many authors that I follow, and now I understand why. I know this 5⭐️➕ read will feature in my top books of the year. This is a WOW read.
Leila Reynolds is a barrister, married to Julian Kesler, eleven years her senior, a KC, and her Pupilmaster. They are about to go to war. Leila has been requested to lead Jack Millman’s defence, while Julian will be prosecuting for the Crown. The resulting case is quite explosive, in many ways.
The victim, Anton Smythe, 56, was a Crown Court Judge, a family man, highly respected by the judiciary. The case appears to be a foregone conclusion for the prosecution. The dying judge is found in a convicted criminal’s flat, the 999 call confession recorded for all to hear. Surprisingly, the defendant pleads not guilty, the stage is then set for a mouth watering trial.
As I said above, Dissection of a Murder is the debut by Jo Murray, but having just turned the last page, I’m stunned in the very best way. It is complex, well written and incredibly well plotted. The characterisation is rich and deep. I was willing some of them on, while feeling far less charitable towards others. This isn’t just a gripping court case, it is so much more.
As I read, and the court case started, a very uneasy feeling settled on me. There was clearly something hugely significant, that was just out of the readers’ reach. Despite my very best efforts I couldn’t work it out, which made me read compulsively.
This is an assured debut, it feels like it has been written by a hugely experienced author. It is such a fabulous read, and I can’t recommend it highly enough. Dissection of a Murder has been raved about by many authors that I follow, and now I understand why. I know this 5⭐️➕ read will feature in my top books of the year. This is a WOW read.
August 12, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan MacMillan for an advanced copy in exchange for a review.
Wow this was a stunning courtroom / psychological mystery with a plot twist towards the end that knocked my socks off! The whole way the story was told and unravelled was very original and clever, and it also dealt with some quite disturbing themes of controlling, abusive behaviour as well as sexism in the workplace and some outdated practices in the legal industry – such as the elevated King’s Counsel barristers and pupilmaster relationships.
We meet Leila Reynolds, a lawyer in her 30s living in Durham, who has fought her way to where she is through determination and hard work. Now, she’s been personally requested by Jack Millman to defend him when he is accused of murdering high profile Judge Anton Smythe. There are two problems. One, Jack won’t tell her what really happened. And two, the prosecuting lawyer is Leila’s much more experienced lawyer husband, Julian.
Julian – like her – is determined to win the case. And he is more concerned about his reputation than his relationship with his wife and former pupil. His true colours come roaring to life. And soon Leila has another problem - messages from someone in her past threaten to reveal something she wants to keep hidden.
Most intriguing of all, are the chapters written by Witness X, who knows exactly what happened on the night Judge Smythe was killed.
This was so fiendishly well-written, clever and twisty beyond twisty! Just when I thought I knew what was going on, everything would be turned on its head once more!
Wow this was a stunning courtroom / psychological mystery with a plot twist towards the end that knocked my socks off! The whole way the story was told and unravelled was very original and clever, and it also dealt with some quite disturbing themes of controlling, abusive behaviour as well as sexism in the workplace and some outdated practices in the legal industry – such as the elevated King’s Counsel barristers and pupilmaster relationships.
We meet Leila Reynolds, a lawyer in her 30s living in Durham, who has fought her way to where she is through determination and hard work. Now, she’s been personally requested by Jack Millman to defend him when he is accused of murdering high profile Judge Anton Smythe. There are two problems. One, Jack won’t tell her what really happened. And two, the prosecuting lawyer is Leila’s much more experienced lawyer husband, Julian.
Julian – like her – is determined to win the case. And he is more concerned about his reputation than his relationship with his wife and former pupil. His true colours come roaring to life. And soon Leila has another problem - messages from someone in her past threaten to reveal something she wants to keep hidden.
Most intriguing of all, are the chapters written by Witness X, who knows exactly what happened on the night Judge Smythe was killed.
This was so fiendishly well-written, clever and twisty beyond twisty! Just when I thought I knew what was going on, everything would be turned on its head once more!
October 11, 2025
Leila Reynolds, a barrister, is handed her first big case, a murder trial where the defendant is accused of killing a well know judge. She feels unprepared for such a high profile case and with the defendant refusing to talk how can she prove herself on a case that seems unwindable? All she knows is losing is not an option.
I have heard some hype around this book and was intrigued by the synopsis and the comparison to Blood Orange and The Silent Patient; both books that I have loved. Since finishing, I am still holding my breath and can safely say that this is certainly going to be a huge hit! The storyline is so intricate and compelling; you can tell the author worked in this field, as the details are rich, realistic and immersive. I came away from the story not only feeling as though I was a part of it but also gaining more knowledge of the legal world and court cases.
The story builds up slowly at first but by the second half it ramps up and becomes very fast paced, suspenseful and impossible to put down. The court case scenes were full of drama and made me question what the truth really was. The twists and turns are superb and down right. It takes a lot to throw me these days. The characters are also portrayed brilliantly, they have a lot of depth and authenticity, which helps the reader form a connection. This clever courtroom thriller is definitely one not to be missed and this author has firmly cemented herself as one to watch. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this copy in return for an honest review.
I have heard some hype around this book and was intrigued by the synopsis and the comparison to Blood Orange and The Silent Patient; both books that I have loved. Since finishing, I am still holding my breath and can safely say that this is certainly going to be a huge hit! The storyline is so intricate and compelling; you can tell the author worked in this field, as the details are rich, realistic and immersive. I came away from the story not only feeling as though I was a part of it but also gaining more knowledge of the legal world and court cases.
The story builds up slowly at first but by the second half it ramps up and becomes very fast paced, suspenseful and impossible to put down. The court case scenes were full of drama and made me question what the truth really was. The twists and turns are superb and down right. It takes a lot to throw me these days. The characters are also portrayed brilliantly, they have a lot of depth and authenticity, which helps the reader form a connection. This clever courtroom thriller is definitely one not to be missed and this author has firmly cemented herself as one to watch. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for this copy in return for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Dissection of a Murder is a breathlessly compulsive courtroom thriller that hooks you from the start and never lets go. Leila Reynolds is a young, ambitious barrister who unexpectedly finds herself handling the high-profile murder case of a well-respected judge. The defendant, Jack Millman, won’t say a word and insists she’s the only one who can defend him.
Leila is in way over her head. This case is huge and she’s not prepared for the pressure. But losing isn’t an option. As the trial unfolds, Leila must navigate a web of lies, buried secrets and courtroom drama that constantly keeps you guessing.
The pacing is fast and the twists are expertly crafted. It keeps you on your toes, always making you question who's telling the truth. And the final reveal left me completely floored.
What I loved most was Leila as a character. She’s smart, determined and full of flaws that make her feel real. Watching her struggle with her professional ambitions and personal secrets made me root for her even more. Her struggle to keep her personal and professional lives separate adds an intriguing layer to the narrative, making her much more than just the typical lawyer figure. The entire courtroom setting feels authentic and the complexity of presenting a case is vividly portrayed.
This is the kind of book that makes you question everything and leaves you thinking about it long after you’ve turned the last page. Highly recommended!
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for an advanced copy in exchange for my review.
Leila is in way over her head. This case is huge and she’s not prepared for the pressure. But losing isn’t an option. As the trial unfolds, Leila must navigate a web of lies, buried secrets and courtroom drama that constantly keeps you guessing.
The pacing is fast and the twists are expertly crafted. It keeps you on your toes, always making you question who's telling the truth. And the final reveal left me completely floored.
What I loved most was Leila as a character. She’s smart, determined and full of flaws that make her feel real. Watching her struggle with her professional ambitions and personal secrets made me root for her even more. Her struggle to keep her personal and professional lives separate adds an intriguing layer to the narrative, making her much more than just the typical lawyer figure. The entire courtroom setting feels authentic and the complexity of presenting a case is vividly portrayed.
This is the kind of book that makes you question everything and leaves you thinking about it long after you’ve turned the last page. Highly recommended!
Thank you to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for an advanced copy in exchange for my review.
July 29, 2025
Similar to what Fatal Attraction did to potential philandering husbands , this book will deter any lawyer repesenting a client in court when their spouse is in opposition. Indeed it could well put anyone off becoming a barrister. What a nasty bunch.
Leila and her husband Julian are both barristers who end up in opposition when Jack, a bouncer at an exclusive club, is accused of murdering a high court judge. But who is Witness X who has regular POV chapters throughout the book. There are a great bunch of well filled out characters as well as titbits of Witness X and an anonymous female .
One one hand the book is a courtroom battle and on the other hand it describes the history of two very disturbed people who came together at some time in the past. And there is also the mystery of the anonymous female. Plenty to interest everyone.
I am not usually a fan of courtroom dramas but I was absolutely hooked on this as well as trying to work out the identities of the unnamed characters.
And the major twist at the end took me completely by surprise and although it is slightly naughty how it was hidden , this is in keeping with the way in which this character views their life. I should not have finished this book last thing in the evening as I could not get to sleep thinking things over. Really looking forward to more from this author.
Thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for the ARC
Leila and her husband Julian are both barristers who end up in opposition when Jack, a bouncer at an exclusive club, is accused of murdering a high court judge. But who is Witness X who has regular POV chapters throughout the book. There are a great bunch of well filled out characters as well as titbits of Witness X and an anonymous female .
One one hand the book is a courtroom battle and on the other hand it describes the history of two very disturbed people who came together at some time in the past. And there is also the mystery of the anonymous female. Plenty to interest everyone.
I am not usually a fan of courtroom dramas but I was absolutely hooked on this as well as trying to work out the identities of the unnamed characters.
And the major twist at the end took me completely by surprise and although it is slightly naughty how it was hidden , this is in keeping with the way in which this character views their life. I should not have finished this book last thing in the evening as I could not get to sleep thinking things over. Really looking forward to more from this author.
Thanks to NetGalley and Pan Macmillan for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I’m a big fan of courtroom drama so this was always going to be a good read for me but I never realised quite how good it was going to be. I’ll be very surprised if it’s not among my top books of the year. Told from multiple POVs, including Witness X, this is the story of a high profile murder case, that of a High Court judge, and the accused Jack Millman, a doorman at a private club with previous convictions for assault. This was a compulsive read and I read it in a day.
Briefly, Leila Reynolds is shocked when she is told that the defendant in a murder case has requested her as his barrister until she realises that she has defended this man before. For the prosecution King's Counsel Julian Kesler, 14 years her senior and her husband! Leila only has one problem. Millman is refusing to say anything to anyone, including Leila and his solicitor Davina.
You really can’t trust anyone! The author has given us some fabulous, well fleshed characters, who I found myself either loving or hating, although I wasn’t always correct in my assessment. The treatment Leila has to deal with from the male members of her chambers, and other professionals, made my blood boil; misogyny is alive and kicking. And remember Witness X, the red herrings were so good I only worked out who it was very close to the reveal. There was an air of menace throughout and the tension was palpable. Loved it. Brilliant book.
Briefly, Leila Reynolds is shocked when she is told that the defendant in a murder case has requested her as his barrister until she realises that she has defended this man before. For the prosecution King's Counsel Julian Kesler, 14 years her senior and her husband! Leila only has one problem. Millman is refusing to say anything to anyone, including Leila and his solicitor Davina.
You really can’t trust anyone! The author has given us some fabulous, well fleshed characters, who I found myself either loving or hating, although I wasn’t always correct in my assessment. The treatment Leila has to deal with from the male members of her chambers, and other professionals, made my blood boil; misogyny is alive and kicking. And remember Witness X, the red herrings were so good I only worked out who it was very close to the reveal. There was an air of menace throughout and the tension was palpable. Loved it. Brilliant book.
August 22, 2025
Jo Murray’s Dissection of a Murder is more than a courtroom thriller—it’s a study in silence, power, and the fragile architecture of truth. When Leila Reynolds is unexpectedly handed a high-profile murder case, she steps into a courtroom thick with tension and secrets. Her client, Jack Millman, refuses to speak. Her opponent is her own husband. And the stakes are far higher than a verdict.
Murray, herself a barrister, writes with quiet authority. The legal intricacies are rendered with clarity, never overwhelming, and the emotional undercurrents—marital strain, professional ambition, buried trauma—are woven with subtlety and grace. The narrative unfolds like a chess match, each move deliberate, each revelation shifting the board.
What elevates this novel is its restraint. The twists are sharp but never sensational. The characters are flawed, human, and compelling. And the courtroom scenes pulse with authenticity, drawing the reader into a world where justice is not always synonymous with truth.
For readers who appreciate the psychological nuance of Apple Tree Yard and the moral ambiguity of Blood Orange, this debut offers a compelling new voice in legal fiction. It lingers long after the final page—like a verdict you’re not quite sure was right.
With thanks to Jo Murray, the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
Murray, herself a barrister, writes with quiet authority. The legal intricacies are rendered with clarity, never overwhelming, and the emotional undercurrents—marital strain, professional ambition, buried trauma—are woven with subtlety and grace. The narrative unfolds like a chess match, each move deliberate, each revelation shifting the board.
What elevates this novel is its restraint. The twists are sharp but never sensational. The characters are flawed, human, and compelling. And the courtroom scenes pulse with authenticity, drawing the reader into a world where justice is not always synonymous with truth.
For readers who appreciate the psychological nuance of Apple Tree Yard and the moral ambiguity of Blood Orange, this debut offers a compelling new voice in legal fiction. It lingers long after the final page—like a verdict you’re not quite sure was right.
With thanks to Jo Murray, the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews