A Good Start to a Proposed Series, (and There Are Birds)
Many of the publisher reviews, blurbs and reader reviews of this book compare it favorably to the "Ivy & Bean" series and to the Clementine books. Well, I tend to think that comparisons like that are just shortcuts and usually don't mean much, but with this book the comparisons strike me as apt. Moreover, I'm a very big fan of Annie Barrows's "Ivy & Bean" books and really like Clementine, but would still give this Sadie series a bit of an edge over them on a few scores.
First off, it seemed to me that this book reads a little younger than the "Ivy & Bean" type books. Sadie's younger, the plot is milder, and the writing is just aimed a bit younger, (although some more advanced vocabulary is used almost like a good-natured joke). That's fine, but I'm thinking older elementary more than middle grade. That's especially attractive because, boy, that's an underserved demo.
Anyway, to the book. Short summary - Sadie has been left behind for the summer because her best pal could only take one friend with her on her family vacation, and her best pal chose a different girl. So Sadie is understandably bummed, and we sympathize. Then Sadie finds a witch has moved into the little old playhouse in the backyard, and she befriends the witch and then joins her on a neighborhood ramble to find the witch's missing friend. (The friend accidentally turned herself into a bird and flew away.) We have to find the witch's cat too, but mostly we do a lot of birdwatching, which is a bit more intersting than it may sound. In fact, there's a lot of birdwatching, but it's painless and fits in to the gentle overall tone of the book.
That's about it. But we get a nice tale about friendship, adventure, the limits and complications of friendship, and lots of mild Mary Poppins style advice and subtle counsel from the friendly witch. There isn't a lot magical action, although there is much said about the magic of everyday life and the witch likes to make magic jokes and references.
If that were it, this would be a mild but possibly ho-hum sort of book. What steps it up is the wise/funny bits from the witch, Sadie's own spunky and yet thoughtful personality, and the bemused and good-natured tone of the narrative. Parents are a bit clueless, but affectionately presented. The witch is alternatingly brisk, supportive, sympathetic, and no-nonsense. She's also funny, both in a deadpan sort way and sometimes in a broader and more easily understood way. That all comes together to create a pleasant, engaging, and sometimes very funny story. The whole effect is kind and gentle and patient, but never sappy. The author never overreaches or tries to invest the story with more weight than it deserves. That said, it isn't silly-willy magical stuff. You end up with a solid story, well told, about a nice funny witch lady, without any irony or detachment. How many funny witch books treat the newly independent reader with that much respect?
So, amusing, interesting, very good humored, mildly adventurous and stocked with funny bits. I call this a happy find.
(Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book in exchange for a candid review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)