I picked this up on a whim at the library. I knew about it obviously, but hadn't really intended to read it. I like Finebaum and I (of course) love all things SEC football, but I don't particularly care for the show or the multitude of characters who call in.
I enjoyed the majority of this book. I found it to be funny and insightful, and peppered with lots of interesting examples that demonstrate the true nature of SEC football, both good and bad. As Finebaum is one of the most polarizing figures in sports media, I found his encounters with fans (and haters) to be accurate. The SEC football fan in me truly enjoyed this look at Finebaum's career, his take on why SEC football is the best (and will always be the best), and stories from the 2013 season.
The Alabama fan in me really struggled with the last few chapters. Perhaps I should have waited until the sting of the 2013 Iron Bowl to fully fade before reading this, but then again, I'm not sure it will ever truly fade. As I said on Twitter while reading chapter 17, "...I'm getting queasy. It's been 2.5 years and I'm still upset about it. My hands are a little shaky, and I want to look away, but I can't, which is exactly how I felt during that game." I went on to remark that perhaps I have grown a little because I no longer "have the urge to scream at the top of my lungs and jump up and down while proclaiming that God loves Alabama football best". There is irrationality in being a college football fan and no where is that better demonstrated than in an Alabama football fan.
I don't feel like Finebaum rubbed the lose in in any way; in fact I thought the way it was written was exactly right. Saban DID make a bad call and Bama had drank it's own Kool-Aid a little too much (see: 2013 Sugar Bowl). They lost and it was horrible. It is STILL horrible and I don't like to read about it. I was literally cringing the whole way through that portion. Finebaum (with assistance from Gene Wojciechowski) paints a very realistic picture of what that experience must have been like. I really did feel like I was there (and thank God I wasn't) which I think says a lot about this book. Maybe it's because I am an SEC fan and have experienced much of what is talked about here, but this whole book felt very real to me. I could see the crowd, feel the tension, and hear the drama. I could not smell the bourbon wafting through the Greek section, but that might be a plus.
The weak point of the book is the flow. To me, it felt very choppy and I didn't get a good sense of what games were happening when (without checking a schedule which I obviously did) and how the book chapters fit in with which games. The "season skinny" which began every chapter kind of threw me; I think the book would have been better served without that. I think it would have been better if it just flowed naturally without the need to date every chapter and try to paint a picture of what else was going on.
In general, I recommend this book for anyone who has more than a passing fancy for SEC football. I don't recommend it to those outside the SEC unless you are a fan of the show or really appreciate good football and stories about good football. This book will only piss off FSU, OSU, Oregon, Notre Dame, and probably USC fans. It is probably intended to do that because Paul Finebaum loves nothing more than making a blanket statement and sitting back to watch the fans froth at the mouth.
Final Grade: B+/4 stars