Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Witch and the Woodcutter

Rate this book
This is not a story of magic. This is a story of persecution...

The Far Isles are in a witch-hunting frenzy. Neighbour turns against neighbour, women are hanged from trees, and girls are thrown to the pyre. At the head of this fever is the Inquisitorum: the branch of the Church dedicated to the ways of hunting witches, their subsequent torture, and execution.

Beorn is the woodcutter for the small town of Brexton. He lives a solitary life in the woods that provide him his livelihood, far from civilisation and inquisitive eyes. He takes no part in the witch-hunting frenzy that grips the kingdom, but nor does he lift a hand in defence of those condemned to die. He lives by a simple
I don't get involved.

That is until a young witch is dragged into the town square to be burnt at the stake. The sight of her breathes life into old ghosts Beorn had long thought buried. Against his better judgement, he breaks his one rule. What follows is an adventure across a kingdom. Beorn will be faced with many thorn-helmed knights, black-robed Inquisitors, a head-strong young witch, and even his own world view.

310 pages, Kindle Edition

Published May 22, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

L.S. Walker

3 books19 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
133 (40%)
4 stars
116 (35%)
3 stars
54 (16%)
2 stars
17 (5%)
1 star
10 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews
Profile Image for muhgooo.
319 reviews41 followers
August 13, 2025
Sigh. I’m sad I didn’t like this book. BUT, just because I don’t like it, doesn’t mean that you won’t! I fear this book just wasn’t for me.

I loved the message, I had a soft spot for both main characters, and the premise was interesting. I loved finally reading a book that made me think, vs the romantic trash I usually read.

The problem I had with this book is the fact that there is mostly telling, and VERY little showing.
We started off strong, with the bakers wife being hit in the street and Beorn just walking by, not caring at all. It def set the tone for the book. I also loved, LOVED, loved the story with the rovers. Showing not only the persecution they faced, but the sacrifices the women made and why. The sacrifices a mother has to make. That whole scene was incredibly moving and I wish there had been more. It even had me a little choked up.

But then, we are mostly beaten over the head with atrocities against women. And a pattern begins to emerge of Beorn asking a leading question or a making a blunt statement after one of these tragic events transpires, and then feral 15 year old girl makes a very long and poignant speech about how women are treated.

Before the 60% mark, they encounter a bunch of crimes against women including, but not limited to:

- 2 robbers on a bridge who want to rape Morrigan for the “toll”
- A woman who is about to be hanged on a back road by two drunk guards
- ANOTHER witch hanging in another town where 3 innocent people are accused of witchcraft
- countless corpses hanging in trees (mostly women)
- A long history lesson from the supposedly illiterate feral 15 year old about a woman in history who was raped and killed
- An extended encounter with a priest and 6 nuns who were all being sent to a “workhouse” to reform women of sin
- Multiple long explanations from the priest how women are lowly and the source of sin and temptation
- The characters come across a brutal crucifixion of a man still clinging to life, who is of a different religion from the one faith (at least it was a man, but it was still graphic and the characters discussed it at length)
- A brief stop at a barn where two skeletons are found, one of which is holding a diary detailing her brutal beatings and eventual murder by her husband
- The characters come across ANOTHER witch trial, where an innocent woman has been accused of witchcraft. (This is the THIRD wrongly accused witch encounter at 60% through the book)
- There were more crimes against women, but I can’t recall all of them

This was the point I stopped reading, because I was 60% in and I just couldn’t be battered over the head about more dialogue between Morrigan and Beorn about the plight of women.

Again, this was a good story. It made me think, and its message is impactful. But I think this would have been an incredible story with some subtlety.

Maybe instead of having SO many crimes against women, it could have focused on a couple. And not everything had to be discussed by the characters in detail, because it became repetitive. A lot can be said by saying nothing at all. I would have liked to have seen more of a relationship building between our two characters. I REALLY would have liked to see more growth from Morrigan, but there was none that I saw at the 60% mark. I also think it would have been more impactful to have her act her age, and show real fear. She had a lot of trauma to unpack, but her character was the same on page one as it was by the time I stopped reading. But hey, I love a fierce redhead that hates men too lol.

Idk I don’t want to talk anyone out of reading this book. Because it is a cool book. And I think the prose is great and the premise is awesome. It just wasn’t my cup of tea. I’m very interested to read whatever else the author rights in the future!
Profile Image for Amy Bennett.
21 reviews1 follower
August 18, 2025
A cracking opening act in literary fiction with a professionally researched, empathic gendered understanding of the evergreen struggle of not only women, but all living under systemic patriarchal oppression. The Witch and the Woodcutter sits exactly where it should as a debut - concisely intentional, explicitly transparent, and as any story with this much hurt and suffering, fuelled by rage.

"Your guilt doesn't absolve you."

Notifications remain on for L. S. Walker's next work.
Profile Image for tay.
36 reviews1 follower
July 12, 2025


⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

📖 - paperback

As I was reading this I kept forgetting my LITERAL friend wrote this. This was incredible from start to finish, the characters, the dialogue, the world and most importantly the message were all expertly constructed. I am someone who reads fiction to escape so to be completely honest, I was worried that this would be too dark and disheartening - but despite its immense and very real horrors I still found hope in this world - as I am prone to do. An incredible book of feminine rage written by the only man alive I think capable of doing it justice. So proud and cannot wait for Walker’s next work ;)
Profile Image for Katie.
302 reviews
May 28, 2025
"I am the product o' generations o' women who drowned on their own blood from biting their tongues. I am the product of their sacrifices. I am their rage incarnate. I am their vengeance."

What an emotional rollercoaster. At times, my heart was in my mouth. HUGE thank you to the author, not just as a woman, but as a practitioner of witchcraft for representing the awful world in which women lived and continue to live in. I have an enormous amount of respect for him after reading his preface and acknowledgements. You can feel his true feelings through the words.

A true passion for fantasy is evident, and so well done. I love that it has a map, that it wasn't a romatasy for once, and the gore/horror aspects. I get sprinkles of The Witcher or The Last of Us vibes. This author would give any fantasy author a run for their money. It is also well researched in terms of the witch trials, herbal remedies, etc.
Profile Image for Gina.
152 reviews2 followers
May 2, 2026
This is a historical fiction story set during a witch hunting frenzy in a remote region, where we meet our protagonist, Beorn, a solitary woodcutter living on the outskirts of a small town called Brexton. He keeps to himself, avoids gossip and lives a quiet, isolated life in the woods.

That all changes when he comes into town to sell his wares and witnesses a young girl about to be burned at the stake for witchcraft. Seeing her stirs something in him, memories and ghosts from from his past. Guided by an inner voice he can’t ignore, despite his mantra to not get involved, he makes a split-second decision to save her.

We learn the girl’s name is Morrigan and she comes from the Northern realm. With no other option after rescuing her, Beorn reluctantly agrees to escort her back home. What follows is a tense, character-driven journey as they try to reach safety while being hunted by the Inquisitorium, a brutal arm of the church dedicated to capturing and executing witches. The northern realm offers some hope, as its old beliefs still hold stronger there than in the south.

The real strength of this book lies in its characters. Beorn is a grizzled, emotionally scarred man with a complicated past, while Morrigan, though young, is incredibly resilient. She was raised in a harsh environment, escaped an abusive father, and trained under a wise woman as a healer and midwife, so she’s seen the harsh realities of life up close.

Though the pair grow more amiable as the story progresses, tension remains between them. Beorn was once a soldier in the King’s army and took part in the slaughter of many Northerners during the war, something Morrigan, understandably, still harbours a great deal of anger about.

This isn’t a light read. There are moments of intense, visceral violence, and the prose is descriptive and immersive, which makes you feel like you’ve truly gone on this journey with the pair. Historically it’s incredibly well-researched and focuses on some deeply rooted themes, which sadly still exist today. Particularly the persecution of women and gender-based violence.

You can really feel the author’s background coming through here. L.S. Walker has professional experience in criminal justice and gender-based violence, and that authenticity gives the story a lot of weight.

I’ve seen a few reviews claiming this book feels like a lecture and that they couldn’t connect with the characters. Some even argue that, to a certain extent, Morrigan emasculates Beorn with her insights into womanhood, and argue that she wouldn’t know as much about life as he does. It doesn’t surprise me that many of these takes come from men, and even some women expressing internalised misogyny.

One reviewer, for example, praised The Shepherd King Duology as a five star read, you know, the story with flat characters, a dull female protagonist with little to no interiority and the same descriptors repeated endlessly.

I’m not a snob, and I genuinely believe people should read and enjoy what they like. Different opinions are inevitable. But I find it baffling when someone claims to feel “lectured” by discussions of gender-based violence, whilst praising a story in which one of the characters rapes and subjugates his future wife, and consider it a top tier read. The inconsistency is hard to ignore.

Personally, I didn’t feel that Morrigan was too outspoken. Given what she has lived through and her experience in her life, her perspective feels earned and believable.

One of the most interesting aspects of the story is Beorn’s internal conflict. He doesn’t agree with the witch hunts or the treatment of women but until now, he’s never acted against them. It raises powerful questions about complicity, does standing by and doing nothing make you just as guilty? Does your silence and lack of action make you complicit? What if you made a vow to someone no longer alive to never kill or be violent?

The dynamic between Beorn and Morrigan is fantastic. They’re very different, yet strangely similar, and watching their relationship develop was one of my favourite parts of the book. There are also other strong female characters throughout, and even a subtle sapphic undertone at one point.

Overall, I absolutely loved this book. The writing is rich, the characters are layered, and the world-building, especially the exploration of religion, power and history, is incredibly immersive.

I gave this five stars. It’s easily one of my favourite reads of the year so far!

I’ve been lucky enough to receive an ARC of the sequel, A Daughter’s Vengeance, and I’ll be posting a full review as soon as I’m finished.
Profile Image for Amanda.
255 reviews20 followers
January 30, 2026
There is a very important story to be told about the atrocious treatment of women and others deemed unworthy by the church/Christianity throughout history, but this wasn't it. The execution of this story just didn't work for me. There was so much repetition of key plot points and way too much telling instead of showing. I wanted to feel feminist rage but the only rage I felt was that of constantly being lectured at. It's such a shame because the opening scenes of this book were great and had such potential. I just didn't vibe with how this story was told.

2.5 stars
Profile Image for Hannah Goodwin.
1 review1 follower
July 25, 2025
A feminist literature must-read. Just finished reading this book and feel like I will be spending the next 24 hours staring at the wall. So much emotion and so much dark, yet important commentary. The characters in this book are so unique- lots of morally grey characters and situations where you are made to look through each characters eyes and question your own morals and biases. Cried, chuckled, and nodded in agreement with some fantastic lines. Certainly not the kind of book that you feel light after reading, but the kind that will stick in your head while you think it over. Also, fantastically written.
Profile Image for Mads ੈ✩‧₊˚.
141 reviews5 followers
July 6, 2026
⭐︎⭐︎⭐︎⭐︎⭐︎/ 5 stars.

I absolutely loved this book. It is so well written and I enjoyed the developing father-daughter relation between Morrigan and Beorn. It was nice watching them get closer throughout their journey and to help each other heal from their traumatic pasts.
Morrigan is so wise beyond her years. I love how hard she fights to help other women who are experiencing hardships.
I think she has to be one of my favorite characters.
I'm really excited for the sequel.
Profile Image for Piiki.
145 reviews
October 19, 2025
4.5 ⭐️| phew~ this book just blew my mind. Very graphic & gory. Loved the plot, the characters felt so raw too. Bittersweet ending, very realistic 😣

“He who sees evil and does naught is just as complicit as those who stain their hands with the act.”
1 review
July 13, 2025
An amazing and harrowing read. Moments of blissful respite show amazing character writing and world building between true abject horror. Harsh realities collide with the medieval fantasy world in a way that is unlike anything else I've read in a very long time.

The preface cemented my trust in the author to tell a story like this one, and the afterward was a perfect reminder that the horrors are not left behind when we leave The Far Isles.
Profile Image for Rachel | fullybookedtbr.
Author 1 book49 followers
October 17, 2025
Characters: 4.25⭐️
Setting: 4.00⭐️
Plot: 4.50⭐️
Themes: 4.50⭐️
Personal enjoyment: 4.50⭐️
Emotional Impact: 4.25⭐️
Overall rating: 4.50⭐️

The Witch and the Woodcutter is a grimdark fantasy novel in a world where there is religious extremism and witch-hunting is a normal thing. Beorn is the lord's woodcutter for a small town when he goes into town he is about to bare witness to a public burning of a young girl who was condemned as a witch by the Church's Inquisitorium. Something stirs without Beorn and without hesitation he jumps in to rescue the young girl, and agrees to bring her home Northwards.

I really enjoyed this book. There were great themes of religious extremism, women's rights and how women were and are still treated to this day. The tale of Beorn and Morrigan felt familiar but unique all in its own. I enjoyed travelling along with them on their journey and meeting a diverse cast of characters.

L.S. Walker's writing is fluid and engaging. I really enjoyed this story and it left me wanting more!

Would I recommend this book? Yes!

Thank you to L.S. Walker for sending me a finished copy of this book.
Profile Image for Audrey Vahle.
44 reviews1 follower
December 2, 2025
It was well written, and the action scenes were incredible. I finished the book feeling genuinely exhausted, like I’d been on that long-ass journey with them. I’m not a fan of tropes, but I have such a soft spot for the dynamic of a faithless older man slowly growing to love the stubborn (and pissy) young girl he’s forced to travel with as if she were his own daughter. The character development is always predictable, but I love it every single time.
I had many favorite parts of this book, especially the Preface and the Afterword (which is a first for me lol). I don’t think the story would have hit nearly as hard without them emphasizing that every extreme instance of brutality against women in the book is rooted in real events, both historical and present day. It is what the entire book is about: the persecution and violence women have always faced, and how deeply it still persists today
1 review
September 30, 2026
En general me gustó mucho los arcos de los personajes y la forma en la que se comportan, es un libro crudo pero efectivo sin caer demasiado en el morbo para poder dar su perspectiva feminista

Siento que muchas veces la premisa es bastante obvia y eso hace que muchos temas sean predecibles tanto en nudo como en moraleja.

También se sintió como un libro muy episódico en la forma que las aventuras venían contenidas y usualmente prefiero historias que se sientan más orgánicas y entremezcladas en lugar de un formato que a mi parecer es formulaico

Lo puedo recomendar si te gusta un drama medieval con énfasis feminista y no te molesta llorar un rato de lo crudo de sus relatos

El libro se manda unas frases increíbles eso sí
9 reviews
March 24, 2026
Hated this book. Would give 0 stars if I could. I could see a particular type of person liking this book but it is not me.

Would have loved some nuance past “man bad women good” and there was absolutely 0.

I couldn’t get past the 15 year old constantly showing up the wizened soldier. Do you mean to tell me a man that has seen the brutality of war is ALWAYS wrong or naive to the horror of life????

This is the only book I’ve ever read and wished I hadn’t finished. There are certainly horrific stories to be told about women throughout history but this wasn’t one of them. Morrigan was insufferable and the modernity bled through the pages. I did not once feel that I was reading a story in a time period before 1950. There was somehow no realism in this story for me because there was so much lecturing from Morrigan and long discussions about why crimes against women are bad. WE KNOW. this story comes off as trying to be smart and trying to earn sympathy for the plight of women but anyone reading this book already has empathy for the cruelties against women. I needed to hear more than “this man killed this woman and here’s why that’s bad”. The only people I cared about in this book were the rovers. There is very little story to be read here
Profile Image for Lisa Smith.
20 reviews
August 13, 2025
Absolutely incredible! this right here should be required reading for every single human.
Profile Image for Jackie Lomeli.
42 reviews
November 11, 2025
Thank you to L.S. Walker for reaching out to me on social media and introducing me to “The Witch and the Woodcutter.” I am so glad I picked it up.

This story pulled emotions from every direction. It is dark, powerful, and beautifully written. I especially loved how the book weaves historical retellings into the narrative, including the story of the Rape of Lucretia, grounding the fantasy elements in real history and giving the themes even more weight. The writing made me feel everything: anger, sorrow, hope, and a fierce sense of justice.

If you enjoy stories that blend myth, history, and emotion in a way that stays with you long after the last page, this one is a must read.
Profile Image for Julia.
154 reviews13 followers
January 7, 2026
I rated this 5 stars not because I'd read it again, but because it is something everyone should read at least once. A deeply emotional journey containing found family, challenges and confrontation. This was truly a statement on the treatment of women and morality as a whole.
Profile Image for Shannon Watkins.
53 reviews2 followers
November 1, 2026
I feel like the book had too much of a mix of modern language and of the time. It felt like the real voice wasn’t there.
Profile Image for Becky.
4 reviews
November 6, 2025
Wow. This is hands down one of the best and most important books I have ever had the pleasure of reading, I would and will recommend it to everyone.
Profile Image for Nikki Wilbur.
Author 5 books20 followers
November 25, 2025
This is without a doubt one of my favorite reads--ever.
This book had me either teetering on tears or rage. There was no in between.
Profile Image for Kitty.
67 reviews
April 30, 2026
A retired solider come woodcutter helps a witch condemned to fire escape her execution and return to her homeland, embarking on a cross country journey & encountering first hand the injustices against women and the evil the woodcutter previously turned a blind eye to - i liked that this was based on true events and thought the ending was sad but this wasn’t a book for happy endings. Loved Beorn and Morrigan- took me a while to read but was interested til the end.
Profile Image for Car✿lina .
39 reviews
June 18, 2026
I really thought she would have a good ending, but in reality, the patriarchy is our biggest enemy.
Profile Image for Moses Martinez.
46 reviews
May 1, 2026
Truly enjoyed this medieval journey. The banter of the two main characters was engaging and provoking. I can not recall a time when the preface and afterword from the author brought up feelings which only reinforces my beliefs and energy to be on the right side of history, always.
Profile Image for Emily Jacob.
29 reviews4 followers
August 20, 2025
The Witch and the Woodcutter by L.S. Walker is one of those books that reminds me why I love folklore-inspired tales. It’s dark, enchanting, and layered with meaning. The writing style feels timeless yet fresh, pulling you right into the eerie atmosphere of the story.

What I really appreciated was how the author balanced the mystical elements with very human emotions, fear, desire, betrayal, and resilience. The witch isn’t a one-dimensional villain; she has depth, and the woodcutter’s choices feel both tragic and inevitable. It made me think about how stories shape our understanding of morality and power.

This book is short but impactful, the kind of story that lingers with you long after you’ve finished. If you enjoy fairy tales with a darker edge, or narratives that make you question who the “monster” really is, I’d highly recommend picking this one up.
Profile Image for Autumn Nicole.
89 reviews
April 26, 2026
A great book to entertain while also making you absolutely furious at the horrific things we’ve done to each other in the name of progress and god. Alternate history to make you go “oh i see what he did there!” in between bouts of wanting to punch a wall.
Profile Image for M.M..
251 reviews3 followers
September 4, 2025
My enjoyment was helped tremendously by the author's forward and afterword explaining why they thought it was important to tell this story. Namely how their day criminal justice day job in "death investigations, including intimate-partner homicides, has provided him with firsthand experience of how destructive patriarchal ideology can be." I was compelled when reading it, I wanted to know what would happen next and the ultimate fate of the characters yet I still found it to be a very basic, by the numbers, fantasy story. Even the grim, crapsack world, and overbearing religious authorities were not overly notable. However-- the ending. Holy smokes. It was an unexpected and pretty powerful. It changes the preceding story into something much bleaker and seems to level an accusation against both Beorn the reluctant "hero" and us, the passive reader/citizen of the world, who has been his companion throughout the story for turning a blind eye and only taking action when it suits his (our) own interests. Beorn's latent commitment to justice does not absolve responsibility for evil that has been allowed to unchecked for so long. Time to think honestly about how that same trait manifests itself in my own life and the imperfect world I live in. Impressive turn!

It's really hard to give this a star rating based solely on my own enjoyment of it let alone the trickier basis of quality/craftsmanship. Additional aspects really need to be included imo. Story is 3 stars, extra half star for that downer ending, extra half star for the Author's message and intent.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Emma Olafsen.
75 reviews2 followers
April 18, 2026
A sad story

This is a sad story. Women have always gone through so much and this book doesn’t flinch from the truth of men’s power over women and they ways they can and do hurt them. I like that it brings the truth about violence and hatred against women out into the open. However, don’t read this if you are a woman and you read for fun, this one hits a little too close to home.
Profile Image for Kelsey.
15 reviews
August 8, 2026
Being a woman sucks and you will never run into a decent man ever. Except for maybe one, briefly.

Misogyny is pervasive! The institution keeps us down! Conform or be burned at the stake! Are you vibrating with feminine rage yet?

The story is okay. The characters don't really have a strong arc. They move from violence against women set piece to violence against women set piece so they can have a meaningful discussion on how it sucks to be a woman. At least the action scenes were cool.

I don't know who this was written for. Women already know about misogyny. It brings forth feelings of frustration because a lot of the violence in the book still exists today. But it is so preachy that I cannot imagine a man who needs to hear its message would ever pick it up, much less finish it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 54 reviews