What do you think?
Rate this book


Paperback
First published September 9, 2025
“There is no ‘somebody’ until somebody tells their story. The world needs witnesses.” She shook her head, sensing something still unsaid. “And you don’t need the dead’s permission. It’s your story, too.”
I think I can speak in general when I say that all of us who loved If We Were Villains were eager for M.L. Rio to publish a new full-length novel. A mystery about a 1980s rock band? I didn’t need to know anything else; Hot Wax went straight to my most anticipated books of 2025 list. And it now goes to my most disappointing reads of the year.
Somewhere between a coming-of-age novel and a mystery, Hot Wax is a novel that I don’t think quite fits into any specific genre. It alternates between past and present, following Suzanne, a woman in her forties who decides to leave her husband and begin a relationship with a much younger couple. But the death of her father brings to light a childhood trauma that she’s been trying to forget.
There are several aspects that made this story not work for me, but after racking my brains over the couple of days since I finished it, I’ve come to the conclusion that my main disappointment lies in the characters. If more than a week ago someone had told me I wouldn’t be invested in M.L. Rio’s characters, I wouldn’t have believed it. Not only because their complexity was one of the strong points of If We Were Villains, but also because even in the mere 100 pages of Graveyard Shift, she managed to get me interested in them. But in this book, I didn’t care about them.
I feel like the author didn’t know where to take the story. Much of it is narrated by a 10-year-old Suzanne, whose internal monologues don’t match those of a girl that age. Suddenly, we jumped to the present, her on the run and her husband chasing her, and then to her teenage years, a period I still don’t understand what contributed to the story. The pacing was completely off and jarring, and the supposed mystery—and I say supposed because it’s obvious from the beginning what happened—is never resolved.
I was completely underwhelmed by Hot Wax. I would have preferred the story to focus more on the present, to explore Suzanne dealing with her trauma as an adult, rather than going back and forth without rhyme or reason. At least I’m left with the good for her feeling about something that happens toward the end.