What do you think?
Rate this book
Saints and Monsters
With her crooked spine and reckless heart, Princess Meera always knew she wasn't meant to become queen of Ezo. But when her sister, the rightful heir, is cursed on the eve of her coronation, Meera must defend her kingdom from ruthless invaders by taking the throne. Yet, while some countries have simple coronations, in Ezo . . .
The princess must first claim a sea dragon.
Only the dragon is vicious, perfect, and whole-everything Meera is not. And if the dragon doesn't deem her worthy, it will devour her. Turning to the Saints for help, she doesn't anticipate that her actions will transform the dragon into a mortal, or that she'll steal his heart . . . literally.
Now, as two hearts beat inside Meera's chest, she's reminded that her life is entwined with a dragon, who despises her weaknesses. Despite their differences, they must work together to reverse the curse and save the kingdom before more is lost than their stolen hearts.
The princess must first claim a sea dragon.
Only the dragon is vicious, perfect, and whole-everything Meera is not. And if the dragon doesn't deem her worthy, it will devour her. Turning to the Saints for help, she doesn't anticipate that her actions will transform the dragon into a mortal, or that she'll steal his heart . . . literally.
Now, as two hearts beat inside Meera's chest, she's reminded that her life is entwined with a dragon, who despises her weaknesses. Despite their differences, they must work together to reverse the curse and save the kingdom before more is lost than their stolen hearts.
392 pages, Paperback
Published March 5, 2024
128 people are currently reading
2110 people want to read
About the author
Ellen McGinty
4 books184 followersEllen McGinty is an author and editor of Young Adult fantasy and historical fiction. She lives in the Tokyo metropolis with her husband, three boys, and a hypoallergenic cat. When not writing or editing, you can find her exploring the wilds of Japan with an abundance of espresso and the occasional kimono.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews
July 8, 2025
3-ish stars ⭐️ Clean Fiction - Fantasy
This was a really interesting novel. I liked some parts, but also have some mixed feelings on other parts, so let’s list them out:
Liked- Meera and her character. It’s super easy to have a character with struggles (either a disability or major self-doubting) turn into a “woe is me” festival and while that can be understandable, it can be a bit much to read about time and time again. Meera was not this way at all and I truly liked her as a character.
Liked- the setting of this world was very creative and I found all the different aspects unique. Perhaps it was the heavy Japan influence, but it felt like reading a manga at times. (I’m more familiar with Korean manhwas, though, so I pictured it more in the colorful art style.)
Liked- the first half of this story, particularly the first third. I was most interested in this part of the story for some reason and the rest of the book fell a little flat for me (probably because of the love triangle really coming in to play for the rest of the book).
Mixed feeling- While I really liked Meera, I do have to agree with other reviews, though, that it didn’t seem like Meera’s “disease” held her back through the events of this book and was some times just a passing mention in heightened moments.
Mixed feeling- the religion aspect of this world. I did like how when Meera would curse by using the Saints’ names, others would comment on her disrespecting the very faith she claims to have. I was glad it was called out because that didn’t make sense to me why she would say such a thing when wanting to be a saint/nun herself. Else wise, I thought the religion aspect was more so a blend of different religions and I didn’t love the nuns reverence for the sea serpents—especially when neighboring countries hunting them? It seems like the countries wouldn’t be on good terms if that was the case, but they were mostly…? Regardless, I didn’t really care for the religion aspect as it didn’t fully make sense to me.
Mixed feeling- the dragons in this story are more-so sea serpents than winged beasts. I liked this difference, but I’m also coming away from the book slightly confused because of their magic and magical abilities? I don’t know if it’s my brain (that was having a very rough week when I was reading this book) or if there was actual plot holes.
Mixed feeling- the ending. It reeked of Disney magic. 😅 I mean, yay for a happy ending, but?? It felt a little too obvious how it was going to go and how everything would play out. I like a happy ending—I always want a happy ending—but perhaps it was partially because of how the love triangle went—and how obvious it was—which slightly tainted my enjoyment of the ending as well.
Disliked- the love triangle. I feel like I can just say “enough said” with this element. I had my hope for her pick, but I also knew this was a fantasy book and most FMCs end up with a dragon if that’s an option. 🤷🏻♀️ I won’t say more. Okay, actually, I will say more:
Overall I wouldn’t call this book bad at all. It just had things I liked and didn’t love, to say the least. I really appreciate how clean it was and I would say my main “complaint” would be that I wished things were fleshed out a little more.
The author’s newest book, “The Wayfinder”, which will be releasing on Kickstarter soon is set in the same world as “Saints and Monsters”. According to an Instagram comment, that book is the wayfinder we see in this book, daughter’s story and set 20 years after “Saints and Monsters”.
Age suggestions for this book: 16+ if the reader is a fantasy fan.
Main Content-
The queens of Meera’s country are required to be connected with the dragons (which will connect her to their magic for the sake of the kingdom, but if they don’t find her worthy, she will be killed); It’s commented that dragons have souls; A dragon is able to sing to use their magic (including to take away another’s pain; Meera describes it as like an angel sining; seen on-page and affects the human-dragon’s lifespan); Meera’s country views dragons as scared, but other countries hunt them for different reasons (her country believes that they helped restore the world, but another country believes they are the demons trying to destroy the world); Meera says that dragons “are supposed to be pure and just, warriors and guardians, impartial like angels in the Furan myths.”; Dragons’ wills is usually tethered to their elders and their knowledge of the Saint and it’s noted that “whatever free will they have” is buried deep down; *Spoiler* ; Dragon magic cannot raise a soul from the dead because that “belongs to the realm of miracles”.
Meera thinks that thoughts can be curses and spells that need to be broken; Another magic user is able to bend metals.
Meera thinks the closest she’ll get to heaven now (after harming an immortal being) is a place in a monastery.
Their are “Saints” who have cathedrals and temples, but also the book titled the “holy testaments of the saints”; The saints are also called nuns and “sisters of the light”; The first saint is called the Bleeding Saint and it’s said that he created all dragons from his tears and placed them on earth to govern man and beast (’H’s are mostly capital when referring to this Saint); However, one dragon craved things against his nature and caused distraction before the Saint conquered him and sealed him within “Mortua”, a place beneath the sea; Another saint/nun leads a wedding ceremony; Meera thanks the saints for her safe return; A mention of a woman who believed that the Saint “threads all things together for good”.
Meera wants to join the saints (nuns) in the monastery as she enemies their freedom; Meera wears a charm of the mother saint as a necklace around her neck.
Others call Meera cursed or using sorcery because of her condition; Meera teasingly tells someone that she’ll be her fairy godmother because others already think she’s a sorceress anyway “as if only old witches have curved backs”; A few mentions of more mentions of sorcery throughout the book (such as the definition of sorcery being “taking magic by force”).
Another group are “Ainur wayfinders” and they are able to see glimpses of the future and someone’s fate due to their magic (one of the group says that she’s not a fortune teller, but she “interprets the paths as the Saint shows” her for his will, not hers).
All about & many mentions of dragons, them being immortal, their magic (which are called “ancient art” and is an “innate power connected to the earth to heal, create, or destroy”), & shapeshifting; All about & many mentions of a poison & curse (which will lead to death if not treated); Many mentions of saints, a monastery, cathedrals, & the abbess (who is called Mother); Mentions of praying (one unhappily because the saints/nuns won’t talk to Meera when they’re praying & later Meera asking the saints to help her; Another character also later says that the Saint really does answer prayers); Mentions of magical poisons & being cursed; A few mentions of protection charms; A couple mentions of the dragons’ oath being “a gift of the gods” to a human queen; A couple mentions of battling demons (ie dragons); A couple mentions of dragons who where banished into the sea and lost their wings; A couple mentions of fates; A couple mentions of Meera commenting on believing in choices and not luck; A mention of the saints/nuns’ incantations holding back a curse; A mention of Meera visiting her mother’s ashes often to seek her blessing; A mention of the saints blessing someone; A mention of someone sensing another’s energy.
“Unholy” is used to describe a few events; A mention of hellfire being released if the oath is broken with the dragons; Casmir says “saints and monsters be cursed” when upset.
No major language is used, curses are said but not written; In-world fictional curses/phrases like “saints” (x9), “boiling saints” (x2), “blessed saints” (x1), and “how in the Saint’s good earth” (x1) are said (All of these are said by Meera and someone else tells her that she’ll never be a nun with all that cussing and she says she wouldn’t say it about the Bleeding Saint; Later, she realizes she shouldn’t curse the saints); Other phrases like “what in the eight kingdoms”, “by the stars”, and “hearts” are said; Eye rolling & Sarcasm; A bit of lying.
*Spoilers* ; Near death experiences, Fighting (including fighting dragons and assassins), Being attacked, Being beaten, Being choked, Being poisoned, Stabbing, Being arrested and tied-up, Major Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, Passing out, & Throwing up (up to a few sentences); Nightmares (of worst fears & of being attacked by dragons, up to a few sentences); Recalling domestic violence (up to a few sentences); Seeing someone poisoned, attacked, beaten, held with a hot tong, choked, injured, & blood/bleeding (up to a few sentences); Casmir has backhands someone & chokes another; A child is also grabbed by her hair and dragged.
Meera drinks wine at banquets.
Meera has what is called the “blue disease” which is a genetic “disorder” and has to wear a back brace for her “bent spine” and weak joints; Partially because of this (and also her mother’s death which made him bitter), her father makes some belittling comments about her being fragile and wants her to look “whole” by hiding her brace; Meera stares at her reflection and notices the whispers inside herself that tells her she’s alone, not enough, and broken; While someone else tells her she’s not cursed, she says she knows she is; *Spoiler* .
Many mentions of deaths (including a wolf attack killing someone), near deaths, people being close to dying, & grief; Many mentions of poisons (including magical ones), being poisoned, the culprit, & bodies; Many mentions of fighting & killing dragons; Mentions of dragon attacks, fires, & destroyed towns; Mentions of possible wars; Mentions of murders; Mentions of dragons burning people alive & tearing people into pieces; Mentions of assassins & assassination attempts; Mentions of injuries, pain, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of thieves, stealing, & stolen items; Mentions of criminals, prisons, & arrests; Mentions of threats; Mentions of lies & lying; Mentions of nightmares; Mentions of wine, drinking, & drunks (including a drunk husband throwing a bottle at his wife and pouring hot tea on her face); Mentions of cigarettes & smoking; Mentions of tattoos; A few mentions of domestic violence (a drunk husband throwing a glass bottle at his wife and pouring hot tea on her face; Also beating his son and scaring his face); A few mentions of hatred; A couple mentions of animal sacrifices to feed the dragons; A couple mentions of throwing up; A couple mentions of the smell of urine.
1 hand kiss,
1 cheek kiss,
1 forehead kiss,
1 kiss with no details,
2 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
2 kisses lasting a few sentences,
Remembering kisses & staring at lips (up to a couple sentences);
Wanting to kiss (up to a couple sentences).
Touches, Embraces, Sparks/Tingles, Flutters, Warmth, Nearness, Smelling, & Noticing (including muscles and a bare chest, up to a few sentences); Blushes.
Casmir teases Meera about seeking him out in his bedroom (twice) & Meera rather that they meet in the library in the monastery, which he comments that he could “think of no place more celibate”; *Spoiler* .
A few others think that Meera is having a romantic tryst with a lover that isn’t Casmir; When in a disguise, Meera smiles at Soran (a guy) dressing like a courtesan.
Mentions of kisses & kissing; Mentions of handsome men & pretty women; A couple mentions of winks & blushes; A mention of brothels; A mention of jealousy.
This was a really interesting novel. I liked some parts, but also have some mixed feelings on other parts, so let’s list them out:
Liked- Meera and her character. It’s super easy to have a character with struggles (either a disability or major self-doubting) turn into a “woe is me” festival and while that can be understandable, it can be a bit much to read about time and time again. Meera was not this way at all and I truly liked her as a character.
Liked- the setting of this world was very creative and I found all the different aspects unique. Perhaps it was the heavy Japan influence, but it felt like reading a manga at times. (I’m more familiar with Korean manhwas, though, so I pictured it more in the colorful art style.)
Liked- the first half of this story, particularly the first third. I was most interested in this part of the story for some reason and the rest of the book fell a little flat for me (probably because of the love triangle really coming in to play for the rest of the book).
Mixed feeling- While I really liked Meera, I do have to agree with other reviews, though, that it didn’t seem like Meera’s “disease” held her back through the events of this book and was some times just a passing mention in heightened moments.
Mixed feeling- the religion aspect of this world. I did like how when Meera would curse by using the Saints’ names, others would comment on her disrespecting the very faith she claims to have. I was glad it was called out because that didn’t make sense to me why she would say such a thing when wanting to be a saint/nun herself. Else wise, I thought the religion aspect was more so a blend of different religions and I didn’t love the nuns reverence for the sea serpents—especially when neighboring countries hunting them? It seems like the countries wouldn’t be on good terms if that was the case, but they were mostly…? Regardless, I didn’t really care for the religion aspect as it didn’t fully make sense to me.
Mixed feeling- the dragons in this story are more-so sea serpents than winged beasts. I liked this difference, but I’m also coming away from the book slightly confused because of their magic and magical abilities? I don’t know if it’s my brain (that was having a very rough week when I was reading this book) or if there was actual plot holes.
Mixed feeling- the ending. It reeked of Disney magic. 😅 I mean, yay for a happy ending, but?? It felt a little too obvious how it was going to go and how everything would play out. I like a happy ending—I always want a happy ending—but perhaps it was partially because of how the love triangle went—and how obvious it was—which slightly tainted my enjoyment of the ending as well.
Disliked- the love triangle. I feel like I can just say “enough said” with this element. I had my hope for her pick, but I also knew this was a fantasy book and most FMCs end up with a dragon if that’s an option. 🤷🏻♀️ I won’t say more. Okay, actually, I will say more:
Overall I wouldn’t call this book bad at all. It just had things I liked and didn’t love, to say the least. I really appreciate how clean it was and I would say my main “complaint” would be that I wished things were fleshed out a little more.
The author’s newest book, “The Wayfinder”, which will be releasing on Kickstarter soon is set in the same world as “Saints and Monsters”. According to an Instagram comment, that book is the wayfinder we see in this book, daughter’s story and set 20 years after “Saints and Monsters”.
Age suggestions for this book: 16+ if the reader is a fantasy fan.
Main Content-
The queens of Meera’s country are required to be connected with the dragons (which will connect her to their magic for the sake of the kingdom, but if they don’t find her worthy, she will be killed); It’s commented that dragons have souls; A dragon is able to sing to use their magic (including to take away another’s pain; Meera describes it as like an angel sining; seen on-page and affects the human-dragon’s lifespan); Meera’s country views dragons as scared, but other countries hunt them for different reasons (her country believes that they helped restore the world, but another country believes they are the demons trying to destroy the world); Meera says that dragons “are supposed to be pure and just, warriors and guardians, impartial like angels in the Furan myths.”; Dragons’ wills is usually tethered to their elders and their knowledge of the Saint and it’s noted that “whatever free will they have” is buried deep down; *Spoiler* ; Dragon magic cannot raise a soul from the dead because that “belongs to the realm of miracles”.
Meera thinks that thoughts can be curses and spells that need to be broken; Another magic user is able to bend metals.
Meera thinks the closest she’ll get to heaven now (after harming an immortal being) is a place in a monastery.
Their are “Saints” who have cathedrals and temples, but also the book titled the “holy testaments of the saints”; The saints are also called nuns and “sisters of the light”; The first saint is called the Bleeding Saint and it’s said that he created all dragons from his tears and placed them on earth to govern man and beast (’H’s are mostly capital when referring to this Saint); However, one dragon craved things against his nature and caused distraction before the Saint conquered him and sealed him within “Mortua”, a place beneath the sea; Another saint/nun leads a wedding ceremony; Meera thanks the saints for her safe return; A mention of a woman who believed that the Saint “threads all things together for good”.
Meera wants to join the saints (nuns) in the monastery as she enemies their freedom; Meera wears a charm of the mother saint as a necklace around her neck.
Others call Meera cursed or using sorcery because of her condition; Meera teasingly tells someone that she’ll be her fairy godmother because others already think she’s a sorceress anyway “as if only old witches have curved backs”; A few mentions of more mentions of sorcery throughout the book (such as the definition of sorcery being “taking magic by force”).
Another group are “Ainur wayfinders” and they are able to see glimpses of the future and someone’s fate due to their magic (one of the group says that she’s not a fortune teller, but she “interprets the paths as the Saint shows” her for his will, not hers).
All about & many mentions of dragons, them being immortal, their magic (which are called “ancient art” and is an “innate power connected to the earth to heal, create, or destroy”), & shapeshifting; All about & many mentions of a poison & curse (which will lead to death if not treated); Many mentions of saints, a monastery, cathedrals, & the abbess (who is called Mother); Mentions of praying (one unhappily because the saints/nuns won’t talk to Meera when they’re praying & later Meera asking the saints to help her; Another character also later says that the Saint really does answer prayers); Mentions of magical poisons & being cursed; A few mentions of protection charms; A couple mentions of the dragons’ oath being “a gift of the gods” to a human queen; A couple mentions of battling demons (ie dragons); A couple mentions of dragons who where banished into the sea and lost their wings; A couple mentions of fates; A couple mentions of Meera commenting on believing in choices and not luck; A mention of the saints/nuns’ incantations holding back a curse; A mention of Meera visiting her mother’s ashes often to seek her blessing; A mention of the saints blessing someone; A mention of someone sensing another’s energy.
“Unholy” is used to describe a few events; A mention of hellfire being released if the oath is broken with the dragons; Casmir says “saints and monsters be cursed” when upset.
No major language is used, curses are said but not written; In-world fictional curses/phrases like “saints” (x9), “boiling saints” (x2), “blessed saints” (x1), and “how in the Saint’s good earth” (x1) are said (All of these are said by Meera and someone else tells her that she’ll never be a nun with all that cussing and she says she wouldn’t say it about the Bleeding Saint; Later, she realizes she shouldn’t curse the saints); Other phrases like “what in the eight kingdoms”, “by the stars”, and “hearts” are said; Eye rolling & Sarcasm; A bit of lying.
*Spoilers* ; Near death experiences, Fighting (including fighting dragons and assassins), Being attacked, Being beaten, Being choked, Being poisoned, Stabbing, Being arrested and tied-up, Major Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, Passing out, & Throwing up (up to a few sentences); Nightmares (of worst fears & of being attacked by dragons, up to a few sentences); Recalling domestic violence (up to a few sentences); Seeing someone poisoned, attacked, beaten, held with a hot tong, choked, injured, & blood/bleeding (up to a few sentences); Casmir has backhands someone & chokes another; A child is also grabbed by her hair and dragged.
Meera drinks wine at banquets.
Meera has what is called the “blue disease” which is a genetic “disorder” and has to wear a back brace for her “bent spine” and weak joints; Partially because of this (and also her mother’s death which made him bitter), her father makes some belittling comments about her being fragile and wants her to look “whole” by hiding her brace; Meera stares at her reflection and notices the whispers inside herself that tells her she’s alone, not enough, and broken; While someone else tells her she’s not cursed, she says she knows she is; *Spoiler* .
Many mentions of deaths (including a wolf attack killing someone), near deaths, people being close to dying, & grief; Many mentions of poisons (including magical ones), being poisoned, the culprit, & bodies; Many mentions of fighting & killing dragons; Mentions of dragon attacks, fires, & destroyed towns; Mentions of possible wars; Mentions of murders; Mentions of dragons burning people alive & tearing people into pieces; Mentions of assassins & assassination attempts; Mentions of injuries, pain, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of thieves, stealing, & stolen items; Mentions of criminals, prisons, & arrests; Mentions of threats; Mentions of lies & lying; Mentions of nightmares; Mentions of wine, drinking, & drunks (including a drunk husband throwing a bottle at his wife and pouring hot tea on her face); Mentions of cigarettes & smoking; Mentions of tattoos; A few mentions of domestic violence (a drunk husband throwing a glass bottle at his wife and pouring hot tea on her face; Also beating his son and scaring his face); A few mentions of hatred; A couple mentions of animal sacrifices to feed the dragons; A couple mentions of throwing up; A couple mentions of the smell of urine.
1 hand kiss,
1 cheek kiss,
1 forehead kiss,
1 kiss with no details,
2 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
2 kisses lasting a few sentences,
Remembering kisses & staring at lips (up to a couple sentences);
Wanting to kiss (up to a couple sentences).
Touches, Embraces, Sparks/Tingles, Flutters, Warmth, Nearness, Smelling, & Noticing (including muscles and a bare chest, up to a few sentences); Blushes.
Casmir teases Meera about seeking him out in his bedroom (twice) & Meera rather that they meet in the library in the monastery, which he comments that he could “think of no place more celibate”; *Spoiler* .
A few others think that Meera is having a romantic tryst with a lover that isn’t Casmir; When in a disguise, Meera smiles at Soran (a guy) dressing like a courtesan.
Mentions of kisses & kissing; Mentions of handsome men & pretty women; A couple mentions of winks & blushes; A mention of brothels; A mention of jealousy.
March 10, 2024
I want to start off this review by saying that I am a VERY avid manga reader and haven't read a novel in well over a year. I had slight reservations that my brain would not be able to make a smooth switch from pictures with little words to NO pictures and A LOT of words. LOL!
I ended up reading this book in ONE day!! A day!! :o :o :o
To say I'm shook is an understatement because I thought it would take me AT LEAST a week to read a 300+ page book, but I just could not put this book down! And when I HAD to put it down (eating food when you're hungry being a thing…LOL), I just kept thinking about it and decided I would do nothing else that wasn't essential and just read read read!
This was a very engaging and compelling story that was very rich in creating a world that felt very dangerous but also hopeful. Some of that was because of how Meera viewed herself, which I think was the biggest thing that spoke to me when it came to her story. From how low she viewed herself at the beginning to how she viewed herself at the end was deeply impactful. I have always struggled with my self-worth and learned last year that all my bouts of depression have always come from me loathing many parts of myself. In that, Meera and I's hearts closely matched.
However, I haven't had to face dragons, save my sister from dying, and just a bunch of other things that involve putting one's life on the line. :p Learning to (and continuing to) love myself and see my own worth even when I feel broken and not whole has been a new journey in the last year with constant ups and downs, making Meera's story of pain, challenge, not giving up, and victory one that encouraged me on a very personal level.
I had honestly been SO invested in one of the characters, Casmir, and her relationship with this character that I pretty much zoned in on that for well over half the book. LOL! It honestly wasn't until I felt Meera made a not smart decision (even though it was something I had SOOOOO desperately been craving to happen, but it was like the worst possible time ever) and put the book down for a few hours that I was able to come back and see the young woman Meera was fighting to be. She is deeply stubborn, but very strong, loyal, and caring. She made mistakes and caused a bunch of "bad things" to happen, but she continued to move forward and find solutions to the problems at hand. (Vaguely worded there so I don't give spoilers LOL)
I really liked a lot of the characters! I DEEPLY and I mean DEEPLY struggled with liking Dragon's character until probably the last 100 pages are so because I am hardcore #TeamCasmir! LOL! Casmir is hands down my favorite character and I want nothing but happiness upon happiness for him! He may seem like a tyrant in another country, but that man is doing all he can to protect and watch over those under him. Plus, the way he treated Meera countless times when/after she made certain decisions spoke SO much of his character! Definitely an amazing man!! (Also I did like Dragon by the end and was able to appreciate his character despite some of my own misgivings I had towards him. LOL!)
The world building was very rich and I was overjoyed to have a story with dragons that was NOT based on Western mythology! YESSSSSSS!! I LOVED the descriptions of the water serpents and how scary, powerful, and dangerous they were!! Absolutely fantastic!! I loved other parts of this world, but hands down that was my favorite!
Overall, I'm so so so glad I read this! I have so many quotes I will need to come add to this review later because there were MANY that spoke to me (No pun intended!) and know I will want to come back to this review and read them later.
Definitely would recommend this story if you're wanting dragons/water serpents like that in Asian mythology, compelling heroines who grow and change as the story progresses, and fantastic sibling relationships (which was VERY good and another favorite part when reading)!
*(I received a physical copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
I ended up reading this book in ONE day!! A day!! :o :o :o
To say I'm shook is an understatement because I thought it would take me AT LEAST a week to read a 300+ page book, but I just could not put this book down! And when I HAD to put it down (eating food when you're hungry being a thing…LOL), I just kept thinking about it and decided I would do nothing else that wasn't essential and just read read read!
This was a very engaging and compelling story that was very rich in creating a world that felt very dangerous but also hopeful. Some of that was because of how Meera viewed herself, which I think was the biggest thing that spoke to me when it came to her story. From how low she viewed herself at the beginning to how she viewed herself at the end was deeply impactful. I have always struggled with my self-worth and learned last year that all my bouts of depression have always come from me loathing many parts of myself. In that, Meera and I's hearts closely matched.
However, I haven't had to face dragons, save my sister from dying, and just a bunch of other things that involve putting one's life on the line. :p Learning to (and continuing to) love myself and see my own worth even when I feel broken and not whole has been a new journey in the last year with constant ups and downs, making Meera's story of pain, challenge, not giving up, and victory one that encouraged me on a very personal level.
I had honestly been SO invested in one of the characters, Casmir, and her relationship with this character that I pretty much zoned in on that for well over half the book. LOL! It honestly wasn't until I felt Meera made a not smart decision (even though it was something I had SOOOOO desperately been craving to happen, but it was like the worst possible time ever) and put the book down for a few hours that I was able to come back and see the young woman Meera was fighting to be. She is deeply stubborn, but very strong, loyal, and caring. She made mistakes and caused a bunch of "bad things" to happen, but she continued to move forward and find solutions to the problems at hand. (Vaguely worded there so I don't give spoilers LOL)
I really liked a lot of the characters! I DEEPLY and I mean DEEPLY struggled with liking Dragon's character until probably the last 100 pages are so because I am hardcore #TeamCasmir! LOL! Casmir is hands down my favorite character and I want nothing but happiness upon happiness for him! He may seem like a tyrant in another country, but that man is doing all he can to protect and watch over those under him. Plus, the way he treated Meera countless times when/after she made certain decisions spoke SO much of his character! Definitely an amazing man!! (Also I did like Dragon by the end and was able to appreciate his character despite some of my own misgivings I had towards him. LOL!)
The world building was very rich and I was overjoyed to have a story with dragons that was NOT based on Western mythology! YESSSSSSS!! I LOVED the descriptions of the water serpents and how scary, powerful, and dangerous they were!! Absolutely fantastic!! I loved other parts of this world, but hands down that was my favorite!
Overall, I'm so so so glad I read this! I have so many quotes I will need to come add to this review later because there were MANY that spoke to me (No pun intended!) and know I will want to come back to this review and read them later.
Definitely would recommend this story if you're wanting dragons/water serpents like that in Asian mythology, compelling heroines who grow and change as the story progresses, and fantastic sibling relationships (which was VERY good and another favorite part when reading)!
*(I received a physical copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
January 31, 2025
For fans of Rebecca Ross, Ellen McGinty has a beautifully lyrical writing style.
My Quick Takes:
- 4.5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (rounded up for Goodreads)
- Language 🤐 none
- Spice ❤️🔥 none, just a kiss or two
- Content 🤔 violence, killing
- Reader Age 🎟️ YA
A fantastic debut that only left me wanting more. I have so many questions about the lore and world building that I would love to see fleshed out. Hope to see more adventures and trials from this realm that McGinty beautifully crafted. I listened to the audiobook and the narrator, Jane Maree, was PHENOMENAL.
Tropes: love triangle, disability rep, enemies to more
My Quick Takes:
- 4.5/5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨ (rounded up for Goodreads)
- Language 🤐 none
- Spice ❤️🔥 none, just a kiss or two
- Content 🤔 violence, killing
- Reader Age 🎟️ YA
A fantastic debut that only left me wanting more. I have so many questions about the lore and world building that I would love to see fleshed out. Hope to see more adventures and trials from this realm that McGinty beautifully crafted. I listened to the audiobook and the narrator, Jane Maree, was PHENOMENAL.
Tropes: love triangle, disability rep, enemies to more
April 30, 2024
“Cherry blossoms are fragile, but no one ridicules them. Your queensguard bear the symbol on their swords and helmets. It is very strong indeed to be fragile and beautiful and not afraid.”
This was so beautiful and unique. I teared up. Meera’s journey from self loathing to confidence is especially powerful. I love the chronic illness rep and the strong sibling relationships, and I was surprised at how much I ended up loving Meera and Soran together. The dragons were at turns awe inspiring and terrifying, and I loved seeing Soran grapple with the reality of becoming human and the many emotions that come with it. The whole premise of Meera literally possessing Soran’s heart was so beautiful. (The line at the end. 😭😭😭) Also I’m very conflicted because we sort of share a name but Cass can go die.
One of my favorite parts was when Meera went to Fever House, the healing onsen that is the setting for her story “Soul Threader” in the anthology THE SUN STILL RISES. I was over here squealing like, “I know this place!!!”
Very much recommend this book. I hope Ellen writes more stories in this world!
This was so beautiful and unique. I teared up. Meera’s journey from self loathing to confidence is especially powerful. I love the chronic illness rep and the strong sibling relationships, and I was surprised at how much I ended up loving Meera and Soran together. The dragons were at turns awe inspiring and terrifying, and I loved seeing Soran grapple with the reality of becoming human and the many emotions that come with it. The whole premise of Meera literally possessing Soran’s heart was so beautiful. (The line at the end. 😭😭😭) Also I’m very conflicted because we sort of share a name but Cass can go die.
One of my favorite parts was when Meera went to Fever House, the healing onsen that is the setting for her story “Soul Threader” in the anthology THE SUN STILL RISES. I was over here squealing like, “I know this place!!!”
Very much recommend this book. I hope Ellen writes more stories in this world!
October 28, 2024
This story was a delight to narrate! The powerful messages of the worth of every soul, themes of the small against the mighty, and also dragons... I mean, what's not to love?
December 16, 2023
“Saints and Monsters is one of those books you know you’ll revisit again and again. McGinty, with a skilled hand, weaves together a tale of love, sacrifice, and heart-pounding action set in a world of dragons, royalty, and curses. This sweeping tale leaves you with one of the most powerful reminders I’ve found in fiction: What if what we think makes us broken … is what actually makes us whole? Saints and Monster is an absolute must read and a new favorite book of mine.” -Caitlin Miller, author of The Memories We Painted and Our Yellow Tape Letters
December 16, 2023
My book is finally on Goodreads! It feels like a dream. I poured into Saints and Monsters all the things I love: dragons, beautiful themes, onsen, adventure, fun characters, good food, and a sprinkling of romance. I hope you'll love it as much as I do!
January 25, 2024
Amazing. The writing: spectacular. The romance: enemies to lovers done RIGHT! The plot: a tale I couldn’t stop reading until I reached the very end.
ENDORSEMENT:
“Filled with original storytelling and vivid imagery, prepared to get swept away to a girl at war with herself and a kingdom on the precipice of a crushing end. This story is a reminder of the beauty of our brokenness and how to overcome even the most uncertain of times through faith and love.”
ENDORSEMENT:
“Filled with original storytelling and vivid imagery, prepared to get swept away to a girl at war with herself and a kingdom on the precipice of a crushing end. This story is a reminder of the beauty of our brokenness and how to overcome even the most uncertain of times through faith and love.”
February 6, 2024
"I may not be adept at politics, boys, or fancy ballrooms, but I do have enough courage for two hearts."
this book is so beautiful from the world building to the characters I love it all. From start to finish this book grabbed my heart.....
I love being an arc reader, I get to discover new authors and new stories. I was excited to read this new release from Quill and flame publishing as I have yet to be disappointed with one of their releases. after reading this arc from new Author Ellen McGinty I can safely say I have never been disappointed by a release Ellen writes with her whole heart which leads to a emotional and heartfelt adventure. I can't wait to see what the future holds for this author cause I am looking forward to what ever adventure she wants to take me on.......
this book is so beautiful from the world building to the characters I love it all. From start to finish this book grabbed my heart.....
I love being an arc reader, I get to discover new authors and new stories. I was excited to read this new release from Quill and flame publishing as I have yet to be disappointed with one of their releases. after reading this arc from new Author Ellen McGinty I can safely say I have never been disappointed by a release Ellen writes with her whole heart which leads to a emotional and heartfelt adventure. I can't wait to see what the future holds for this author cause I am looking forward to what ever adventure she wants to take me on.......
September 5, 2025
FIVE STARS!!! ALL. OF. THE. STARS!!!!!!
Y’all. Y’ALL !!
If there was anything wrong with this book it doesn’t even matter because it was PERFECT even in some of its imperfections. (which is like, the theme of the book haha)
I don’t think I can write a full review without screeching, because this was so so good!
HOLY DRAGONS BATMAN….
(Okay, yeah, if I’m pulling Batman into this I just needa chill and come back and write this later 😂🤣😂🤣)
But I just could NOT put this down. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
Immediately need a physical copy!
Also immediately supported the Kickstarter for another book in this universe (even though it’s not about Meera or Soran) I can handle it, I just need more of McGinty’s writing !!!!!
Y’all. Y’ALL !!
If there was anything wrong with this book it doesn’t even matter because it was PERFECT even in some of its imperfections. (which is like, the theme of the book haha)
I don’t think I can write a full review without screeching, because this was so so good!
HOLY DRAGONS BATMAN….
(Okay, yeah, if I’m pulling Batman into this I just needa chill and come back and write this later 😂🤣😂🤣)
But I just could NOT put this down. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
Immediately need a physical copy!
Also immediately supported the Kickstarter for another book in this universe (even though it’s not about Meera or Soran) I can handle it, I just need more of McGinty’s writing !!!!!
January 15, 2024
Captivating, magical, enchanting.
Ellen McGinty's debut novel, Of Saints & Monsters, is packed with daring princesses, deadly poisons, and dangerous dragons. With descriptive prose and characters that will tug at your heartstrings, McGinty creates a world that will make you want to jump into the pages of her story. A must read for lovers of loyalty, perseverance, and finding your true worth.
Ellen McGinty's debut novel, Of Saints & Monsters, is packed with daring princesses, deadly poisons, and dangerous dragons. With descriptive prose and characters that will tug at your heartstrings, McGinty creates a world that will make you want to jump into the pages of her story. A must read for lovers of loyalty, perseverance, and finding your true worth.
June 27, 2025
Now THAT was a good book.
If you love the lyrical writing style of Divine Rivals, beautiful world building, and inspiring characters—this is the book for you.
No language, no spice—just great storytelling.
Also the new cover on Amazon is stunning 🤩
If you love the lyrical writing style of Divine Rivals, beautiful world building, and inspiring characters—this is the book for you.
No language, no spice—just great storytelling.
Also the new cover on Amazon is stunning 🤩
March 5, 2024
Dragons, bargains, and Meiji-inspired fantasy kingdoms, oh my! For the setting and premise alone, I’d recommend this book to most YA lovers.
Right from the start, McGinty’s writing is lush, vivid, and imaginative; in just about three seconds I was drawn into the kingdom of Ezo. The MC’s character is established not much later — in spite of her physical limitations, her heart is brave and true. I’m not sure what I expected, but her character took me by surprise in the most refreshing way. I haven’t encountered many YA heroines like Princess Meera.
Likewise, the other main characters are fleshed out wonderfully. There are some I had trouble connecting with more than others, but I found the inclusion of their POVs a fascinating addition, especially on the part of Cassian — I won’t say more. That struggle of conflicting motives between characters who don’t hate each other is something I will never tire of seeing.
The world is very unique and beautifully crafted, probably my favorite part of the book (that, and possibly the boy with the pink pants) (*cough* there’s a double layer of inside joke in that). I think this book is a standalone, but I wouldn’t mind exploring more of this world.
I think the main thing that cut down my enjoyment of this book was the portrayal of the sister. I’m all for strong sister relationships in fiction, but I can’t be the only one who’s noticed them being everywhere recently? Personally I’m just not a fan of the “perfect older sister who is actually perfect” type of character because I’m never too clear on exactly what kind of role they’re meant to have. (A realistic portrayal of a sibling certainly seems out of the question…) Anyway, I just thought I’d throw that out there. As a whole, I quite enjoyed this book!
In conclusion, I’d recommend Saints & Monsters for just about anyone who enjoys romantic YA fantasy with fantastic worldbuilding, gorgeous prose, and complex and driven characters with a wholesome message at heart. Thanks to the author for an ARC of this book!
Right from the start, McGinty’s writing is lush, vivid, and imaginative; in just about three seconds I was drawn into the kingdom of Ezo. The MC’s character is established not much later — in spite of her physical limitations, her heart is brave and true. I’m not sure what I expected, but her character took me by surprise in the most refreshing way. I haven’t encountered many YA heroines like Princess Meera.
Likewise, the other main characters are fleshed out wonderfully. There are some I had trouble connecting with more than others, but I found the inclusion of their POVs a fascinating addition, especially on the part of Cassian — I won’t say more. That struggle of conflicting motives between characters who don’t hate each other is something I will never tire of seeing.
The world is very unique and beautifully crafted, probably my favorite part of the book (that, and possibly the boy with the pink pants) (*cough* there’s a double layer of inside joke in that). I think this book is a standalone, but I wouldn’t mind exploring more of this world.
I think the main thing that cut down my enjoyment of this book was the portrayal of the sister. I’m all for strong sister relationships in fiction, but I can’t be the only one who’s noticed them being everywhere recently? Personally I’m just not a fan of the “perfect older sister who is actually perfect” type of character because I’m never too clear on exactly what kind of role they’re meant to have. (A realistic portrayal of a sibling certainly seems out of the question…) Anyway, I just thought I’d throw that out there. As a whole, I quite enjoyed this book!
In conclusion, I’d recommend Saints & Monsters for just about anyone who enjoys romantic YA fantasy with fantastic worldbuilding, gorgeous prose, and complex and driven characters with a wholesome message at heart. Thanks to the author for an ARC of this book!
July 15, 2024
Thank you to the author for sending an ebook.
WHAT A SURPRISE.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
I had seen this around a touch and didn’t know if it would be a hit or miss for me. But an opportunity presented itself, I took it, and then proceeded to binge this book in two days. There’s your review, clearly you need to pick this up too.
BUT, I will give you more. I loved Meera. I loved her strength and loyalty to her family and kingdom. Her journey was amazing and I loved how things came together. This is a standalone and while usually a struggle for me, I had none of those issues this time. I loved the world building, the magic, the DRAGONS and all of the characters. I felt like I got enough of everything needed to feel like it was a well rounded story and closed off all of the plot lines by the end.
There’s a subtle romance woven in that was sweet to watch unfurl. I adored the connection and how slowly but surely (through my favorite forced proximity) they started to work together and solving problems. I don’t want to give too much away in the romance aspects so trust me!!
This was truly a gem of a read. I had a wonderful time and it was the fantasy book I didn’t know I was craving. I look forward to more books by this author!
Overall audience notes:
- YA Fantasy + Romance
- Language: none
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: moderate
WHAT A SURPRISE.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
I had seen this around a touch and didn’t know if it would be a hit or miss for me. But an opportunity presented itself, I took it, and then proceeded to binge this book in two days. There’s your review, clearly you need to pick this up too.
BUT, I will give you more. I loved Meera. I loved her strength and loyalty to her family and kingdom. Her journey was amazing and I loved how things came together. This is a standalone and while usually a struggle for me, I had none of those issues this time. I loved the world building, the magic, the DRAGONS and all of the characters. I felt like I got enough of everything needed to feel like it was a well rounded story and closed off all of the plot lines by the end.
There’s a subtle romance woven in that was sweet to watch unfurl. I adored the connection and how slowly but surely (through my favorite forced proximity) they started to work together and solving problems. I don’t want to give too much away in the romance aspects so trust me!!
This was truly a gem of a read. I had a wonderful time and it was the fantasy book I didn’t know I was craving. I look forward to more books by this author!
Overall audience notes:
- YA Fantasy + Romance
- Language: none
- Romance: kisses
- Violence: moderate
April 3, 2025
5 Stars.
🐉 The vibes:
- Queens. Assassins. Dragons.
- Autoimmune rep
- YA fantasy
- Multi pov
- closed door
🐉 My thoughts:
I debated sharing a synopsis type of intro like I normally do, but I am fully refraining because this is fantasy and I feel a type of way about giving anything away for fantasy books.
🐉 I will tell you this… there are Queens, sea dragons, assassins, lies, and betrayals. Meera, the FMC, has a crooked spine but the bravest soul. Her weakness is a main point of the plot in the most redemptive sort of way.
🐉 This book was a wonderful ride to be on. Not only is it a great epic fantasy that can be read as a one and done, but the author has recently announced that she is working on another book set in this universe with the POV of a character from this book.
🐉 My one comment that I think is a good heads up is on the writing style between the POVs.
I noticed there were writing style changes depending on which pov we were in. For example, in Meera’s POV, it was written in first person (Ie. I resist the effect her voice has on me…”
In the other POVS, it was written in third person limited (ie. Casmir liked the attention. It fed smoothly into his plans…”)
It didn’t bother me, but I did notice it.
🐉 The vibes:
- Queens. Assassins. Dragons.
- Autoimmune rep
- YA fantasy
- Multi pov
- closed door
🐉 My thoughts:
I debated sharing a synopsis type of intro like I normally do, but I am fully refraining because this is fantasy and I feel a type of way about giving anything away for fantasy books.
🐉 I will tell you this… there are Queens, sea dragons, assassins, lies, and betrayals. Meera, the FMC, has a crooked spine but the bravest soul. Her weakness is a main point of the plot in the most redemptive sort of way.
🐉 This book was a wonderful ride to be on. Not only is it a great epic fantasy that can be read as a one and done, but the author has recently announced that she is working on another book set in this universe with the POV of a character from this book.
🐉 My one comment that I think is a good heads up is on the writing style between the POVs.
I noticed there were writing style changes depending on which pov we were in. For example, in Meera’s POV, it was written in first person (Ie. I resist the effect her voice has on me…”
In the other POVS, it was written in third person limited (ie. Casmir liked the attention. It fed smoothly into his plans…”)
It didn’t bother me, but I did notice it.
January 25, 2025
First, I should say, I think this book was mostly not for me.
I wanted to give some more fantasy a try. I like light fantasy- this is heavier than I typically read, but hey, this came highly recommended, so why not? Fantasy with no porn is a hard thing to find these days.
But I need to admit it-- I'm really just not interested in dragons. Even the dragons in A Song of Ice and Fire are among the most boring parts to me.
The two other things I am even more disinterested in are Asian culture (sorry, it's not one I like to read up on -- unless we are talking Russia, and I am game for any and all literature there) or love triangles.
And, oh boy, did this novel have a love triangle.
The Synopsis
Meera is 2nd in line in the Queendom of Ezo -- a longstanding empire with its history intertwined with the mysterious dragons. These ancient beings of old strike up a deal with the incoming Queen of Ezo to provide the realm protection through dragon magic. This, however, does not provide any benefits for the queen, who ends up having a shortened life because of the the power of the magic.
Meera's sister, Runa, is in line to take her place as Queen of Ezo. One thing Meera is excited about. Meera herself would rather enter the sect of nuns in this land, which are called "Saints" and who preserve the respect and tradition toward the ancient Saints -- including the Bleeding Saint himself (a not-so-hidden image of Jesus if you piece together the backstory sprinkled throughout -- the most powerful Saint to descend and gave his life so that others could live) and the dragons of old. In part, Meera wants to become a saint because she is known as a cerulean princess. This genetic disorder (?) means she inherited distinct blue hair, a twisted spine, and cool eyes? It is also why she is scorned by her father and, apparently, people in the realm.
However, Meera has been groomed to consider Casmir, the duke from Taiga (a neighboring realm and ally), in order to seal the political alliance between the two realms and continue peace throughout the nation. Meera, however, has little interest in marrying Casmir, though she adores him and has a great relationship with the handsome young man. She dreams at the start of the novel of hiding herself in the cloister for the rest of her life.
That is until coronation day. This is the day Runa is expected to take her place as Queen of Ezo and approach the dragons to strike a new peace deal, proving herself as worthy queen if they allow her to live and continuing the tradition of the magical protection over Ezo. All is going well (though Meera is slightly nervous about her sister being denied and then destroyed by dragons for not being worthy enough) until the coronation feast. At this feast, an unknown spell is cast on Runa and several of the other attendees, causing her to fall into a coma, which is most certainly beginning to kill her body slowly.
Armed with the need to save her sister, Meera teams up with Casmir. Now that she is certainly going to become the next queen, she must decide two things -- either to accept her fate as becoming the next queen to try to strike a deal with the dragons and continue peace or to take the little loophole she has as a 2nd born princess and marry Casmir now, ensuring her queendom and prolonging the peace of the dragons (I think -- I'll be honest, I was really confused at this portion). So, she and Casmir decide the best thing to do is to get hitched in the morning before Meera needs to sacrifice herself to the dragons -- a task she would certainly die doing because everyone in the kingdom knows that Meera isn't good enough. After all, she is a cerulean princess. She would never be worthy. This would then buy them some time to help Runa wake up from the sleeping curse and continue the deal with the dragons by following through with the coronation, trial, and blessing.
Before they plan to get married, Meera and Casmir decide to explore the local cathedral where the ancient artifacts of Ezo are kept. There is a rumor of a dagger hidden among the crypt that can force the stabbed dragon to listen to the one that took hold of it. Hoping that she could use the dagger to save her sister, Meera relays the information to Casmir's closest guard and scout Jey, who assures the two he knows where the dagger is kept. While almost intercepted by the head nun, Mother Ema (I am not sure if the name is meant to relate to the Hebrew name for mother ima), Meera and gang can find the precious dagger, sneaking it back to the castle late at night. Meera gets little sleep before arising for the early morning marriage between her and Casmir.
Several hours later, dagger stored in her skirts, Meera shows up to the cliffs before the sea of dragons where a Mother is going to marry her to Casmir. The mother leads them through the marital vows of this kingdom, but before Meera makes her to Casmir, she leans in to apologize to him with a kiss and then plunges into the ocean.
It isn't long before she nearly drowns that a dragon appears and tries to attack her. She is successful in stabbing the dragon in its weak spot. The dragon writhes in pain and seems to go on the attack, knocking Meera out with his anesthetic-like breath.
Meera awakens in a cave to find that the dragon has been turned into a human and that she now contains one of the dragon's two beating hearts. He explains to her that she will need to face a jury of dragons for being a dragon slayer herself, and from there, she might be able to pass a series of trials that could give her back the kingdom of Ezo -- and her sister.
From here, the crossover between The Princess Diaries 2: A Royal Engagement and The Voyage of the Dawn Treader adds in Dragonheart influences and a very obvious connection to The Lord of the Rings as Meera and the dragon team up as an unlikely team to try to save Meera's sister and give the dragon back his heart.
The Good
I can appreciate the world-building that McGinty does in her novel. While at times it gets a little purple prose-y (yes, novels can do that for me) and at times cheesy in her description, its clear she has put a lot of thought into how she can bend her understanding of Asian culture into a Westeros-as-England version of Japan. I am sure I would appreciate even more of the references and world-building if Asian culture was something I enjoyed spending my time studying. I just have little interest in history and culture; not that I think it's bad or should be ignored, it's just a period of history of understanding.
I also really like Casmir as a character. I think there is even more McGinty can do to build up this character, but he is definitely nuanced. I would have loved to explore more of the experience of growing up with such an embittered and hard father, and a mother who seemed to give her his grace and patience. At one point, he even focuses on forgiveness and how his mother was able to learn to forgive his father for his abuse and hardness, but that it was something that Casmir himself was trying to learn. The chapter we spent on this tension was beginning to lead to even more interesting complexity to his character.
I also appreciate the religion-building McGinty brought to this world. It's clear she was heavily influenced by her belief in Christianity in creating this order. Still, it is interesting to see how she translated a Western monastic practice into the Eastern world (which I do know was heavily influenced by Catholic priests during the dynasties that heavily traded with Western religions). There were moments I wished we explored this more in the novel than the rest of the story.
Finally, thank you for no porn in your fantasy book. It's so nice to read a novel that has some form of romance that doesn't involve people taking their clothes off every five minutes.
The Bad
McGinty struggles badly with telling and not showing in her books. This makes a lot of decisions feel unearned or pointless. For example -- apparently, Casmir is supposed to be the terrible dragon slayer, and Soran speaks of what a monster he is. But McGinty never shows this. She simply goes on and on from the dragon's perspective that he was so horrible and was doing nothing out of the good of his heart for Meera. Yet all of his choices and the way he responds to . I guess we are supposed to take the idea of him killing dragons and selling their parts to help people in Taiga, his native realm, as him being terrible
Even Soran's character change was shocking to me. At first, he is rude and terrible to Meera because she is a human and takes his heart. Okay, cool, that makes sense. Until McGinty, I guess, explains her symbol as a plot device where, in the midst of the first trial, Soran decides that Meera is endearing because she....is kind? I am not even sure. Suddenly, he is trying to save her life and is all, "She has my heart...but she also has my emotional heart," and just blah. It was the really bad character redemption of Nicholas' character in The Princess Diaries 2 where he went from trying to steal the throne to actually falling in love with Mia. For granted, at least the two of them had a little more one-on-one time to develop a relationship and share information about one another to each other, but that romance also feels entirely unearned. Soran just decides to like people because he just does. The end. But he hates Casmir. Mostly because he is supposed to marry Meera and then he says it's because he's a dragon slayer, though we really see none of this in the text or really any cruelty from him. Casmir has an attitude at some point? He wants to have power in Ezo? But genuinely, he mostly appears to have cared for Meera.
This gets to the other point of this novel I really just didn't like. Meera's blue disease. Or whatever it's called. It gets brought up at the most convenient of times -- but it doesn't seem to actually hold Meera back at any point in this novel. We are told as an audience that people think she is so terrible because of how she appears. But aside from her father making most off-screen comments that she reflects on, no one does.
Her brother Bastian adores her. Runa is nothing but kind and good to her. Even Casmir finds her endearing and lovely, never once focusing on the fact that the woman he is engaged to marry is seen as a scourge in her land.
No one mistreats Meera for her issue at all in the novel, so it makes it really hard to believe that it's actually an issue for her, and one that seems to weigh on her self-worth.
I think it is in part because we forget what Meera looks like all the time. She apparently has such a twisted back that she has to wear a brace all the time in the novel. It made me think of the character Yennefer from The Witcher before she sold her soul and became even more insufferable. Yennefer, however, was actually kept from doing all sorts of things and had limitations because of her disfiguration.
Meera only has them when it's convenient. Most of the time, it's a backache, and I think once or twice it kept her from moving quickly, but for the most part, to have such a large deformity keeps her from doing little. She's able to jump off cliffs. She swims pretty adeptly for being so twisted. She can run from and stab multiple dragons. Her deformity does not, for the most part, hinder much of her movement. For me, I would have moments where she would be in the midst of the action, and I would question how? But McGinty sort of Deus Machina'ed the issue.
The Ugly
This is more preference than anything, but the love triangle felt so unearned. It was clear that as soon as Soran was turned into a dragon and was her enemy that he was the one that she would end up in. But just like in The Princess Diaries 2 the ultimate decision of Soran (sort of Nicholas in the movie -- though both girls end up "single") feels incredibly unearned. I think she was working toward an enemies-to-lovers romance (which is typically my type of couple when done correctly) but at no point did I have a Katara-and-Zuko-in-the-cave with all the romantic tension moment. He just started liking her and calling her worthy, saying that she was a star and blah blah blah. Casmir was a much better pick and a much more developed character. I had moments where I was like, "Meera, my friend, why are we choosing Soran? Casmir is the catch here. You are an idiot."
So, long story short, the love triangle felt forced and unearned.
Final Thoughts
The book is fun. The book is clean. I appreciate all of that. There was just a lot for me in this novel that didn't work in part because of personal preferences. But there were other parts that I think could have just been fixed with a better editor.
I am glad I gave it a try. But I think dragons and fantasy are just not for me for the most part.
I wanted to give some more fantasy a try. I like light fantasy- this is heavier than I typically read, but hey, this came highly recommended, so why not? Fantasy with no porn is a hard thing to find these days.
But I need to admit it-- I'm really just not interested in dragons. Even the dragons in A Song of Ice and Fire are among the most boring parts to me.
The two other things I am even more disinterested in are Asian culture (sorry, it's not one I like to read up on -- unless we are talking Russia, and I am game for any and all literature there) or love triangles.
And, oh boy, did this novel have a love triangle.
The Synopsis
Meera is 2nd in line in the Queendom of Ezo -- a longstanding empire with its history intertwined with the mysterious dragons. These ancient beings of old strike up a deal with the incoming Queen of Ezo to provide the realm protection through dragon magic. This, however, does not provide any benefits for the queen, who ends up having a shortened life because of the the power of the magic.
Meera's sister, Runa, is in line to take her place as Queen of Ezo. One thing Meera is excited about. Meera herself would rather enter the sect of nuns in this land, which are called "Saints" and who preserve the respect and tradition toward the ancient Saints -- including the Bleeding Saint himself (a not-so-hidden image of Jesus if you piece together the backstory sprinkled throughout -- the most powerful Saint to descend and gave his life so that others could live) and the dragons of old. In part, Meera wants to become a saint because she is known as a cerulean princess. This genetic disorder (?) means she inherited distinct blue hair, a twisted spine, and cool eyes? It is also why she is scorned by her father and, apparently, people in the realm.
However, Meera has been groomed to consider Casmir, the duke from Taiga (a neighboring realm and ally), in order to seal the political alliance between the two realms and continue peace throughout the nation. Meera, however, has little interest in marrying Casmir, though she adores him and has a great relationship with the handsome young man. She dreams at the start of the novel of hiding herself in the cloister for the rest of her life.
That is until coronation day. This is the day Runa is expected to take her place as Queen of Ezo and approach the dragons to strike a new peace deal, proving herself as worthy queen if they allow her to live and continuing the tradition of the magical protection over Ezo. All is going well (though Meera is slightly nervous about her sister being denied and then destroyed by dragons for not being worthy enough) until the coronation feast. At this feast, an unknown spell is cast on Runa and several of the other attendees, causing her to fall into a coma, which is most certainly beginning to kill her body slowly.
Armed with the need to save her sister, Meera teams up with Casmir. Now that she is certainly going to become the next queen, she must decide two things -- either to accept her fate as becoming the next queen to try to strike a deal with the dragons and continue peace or to take the little loophole she has as a 2nd born princess and marry Casmir now, ensuring her queendom and prolonging the peace of the dragons (I think -- I'll be honest, I was really confused at this portion). So, she and Casmir decide the best thing to do is to get hitched in the morning before Meera needs to sacrifice herself to the dragons -- a task she would certainly die doing because everyone in the kingdom knows that Meera isn't good enough. After all, she is a cerulean princess. She would never be worthy. This would then buy them some time to help Runa wake up from the sleeping curse and continue the deal with the dragons by following through with the coronation, trial, and blessing.
Before they plan to get married, Meera and Casmir decide to explore the local cathedral where the ancient artifacts of Ezo are kept. There is a rumor of a dagger hidden among the crypt that can force the stabbed dragon to listen to the one that took hold of it. Hoping that she could use the dagger to save her sister, Meera relays the information to Casmir's closest guard and scout Jey, who assures the two he knows where the dagger is kept. While almost intercepted by the head nun, Mother Ema (I am not sure if the name is meant to relate to the Hebrew name for mother ima), Meera and gang can find the precious dagger, sneaking it back to the castle late at night. Meera gets little sleep before arising for the early morning marriage between her and Casmir.
Several hours later, dagger stored in her skirts, Meera shows up to the cliffs before the sea of dragons where a Mother is going to marry her to Casmir. The mother leads them through the marital vows of this kingdom, but before Meera makes her to Casmir, she leans in to apologize to him with a kiss and then plunges into the ocean.
It isn't long before she nearly drowns that a dragon appears and tries to attack her. She is successful in stabbing the dragon in its weak spot. The dragon writhes in pain and seems to go on the attack, knocking Meera out with his anesthetic-like breath.
Meera awakens in a cave to find that the dragon has been turned into a human and that she now contains one of the dragon's two beating hearts. He explains to her that she will need to face a jury of dragons for being a dragon slayer herself, and from there, she might be able to pass a series of trials that could give her back the kingdom of Ezo -- and her sister.
From here, the crossover between The Princess Diaries 2: A Royal Engagement and The Voyage of the Dawn Treader adds in Dragonheart influences and a very obvious connection to The Lord of the Rings as Meera and the dragon team up as an unlikely team to try to save Meera's sister and give the dragon back his heart.
The Good
I can appreciate the world-building that McGinty does in her novel. While at times it gets a little purple prose-y (yes, novels can do that for me) and at times cheesy in her description, its clear she has put a lot of thought into how she can bend her understanding of Asian culture into a Westeros-as-England version of Japan. I am sure I would appreciate even more of the references and world-building if Asian culture was something I enjoyed spending my time studying. I just have little interest in history and culture; not that I think it's bad or should be ignored, it's just a period of history of understanding.
I also really like Casmir as a character. I think there is even more McGinty can do to build up this character, but he is definitely nuanced. I would have loved to explore more of the experience of growing up with such an embittered and hard father, and a mother who seemed to give her his grace and patience. At one point, he even focuses on forgiveness and how his mother was able to learn to forgive his father for his abuse and hardness, but that it was something that Casmir himself was trying to learn. The chapter we spent on this tension was beginning to lead to even more interesting complexity to his character.
I also appreciate the religion-building McGinty brought to this world. It's clear she was heavily influenced by her belief in Christianity in creating this order. Still, it is interesting to see how she translated a Western monastic practice into the Eastern world (which I do know was heavily influenced by Catholic priests during the dynasties that heavily traded with Western religions). There were moments I wished we explored this more in the novel than the rest of the story.
Finally, thank you for no porn in your fantasy book. It's so nice to read a novel that has some form of romance that doesn't involve people taking their clothes off every five minutes.
The Bad
McGinty struggles badly with telling and not showing in her books. This makes a lot of decisions feel unearned or pointless. For example -- apparently, Casmir is supposed to be the terrible dragon slayer, and Soran speaks of what a monster he is. But McGinty never shows this. She simply goes on and on from the dragon's perspective that he was so horrible and was doing nothing out of the good of his heart for Meera. Yet all of his choices and the way he responds to . I guess we are supposed to take the idea of him killing dragons and selling their parts to help people in Taiga, his native realm, as him being terrible
Even Soran's character change was shocking to me. At first, he is rude and terrible to Meera because she is a human and takes his heart. Okay, cool, that makes sense. Until McGinty, I guess, explains her symbol as a plot device where, in the midst of the first trial, Soran decides that Meera is endearing because she....is kind? I am not even sure. Suddenly, he is trying to save her life and is all, "She has my heart...but she also has my emotional heart," and just blah. It was the really bad character redemption of Nicholas' character in The Princess Diaries 2 where he went from trying to steal the throne to actually falling in love with Mia. For granted, at least the two of them had a little more one-on-one time to develop a relationship and share information about one another to each other, but that romance also feels entirely unearned. Soran just decides to like people because he just does. The end. But he hates Casmir. Mostly because he is supposed to marry Meera and then he says it's because he's a dragon slayer, though we really see none of this in the text or really any cruelty from him. Casmir has an attitude at some point? He wants to have power in Ezo? But genuinely, he mostly appears to have cared for Meera.
This gets to the other point of this novel I really just didn't like. Meera's blue disease. Or whatever it's called. It gets brought up at the most convenient of times -- but it doesn't seem to actually hold Meera back at any point in this novel. We are told as an audience that people think she is so terrible because of how she appears. But aside from her father making most off-screen comments that she reflects on, no one does.
Her brother Bastian adores her. Runa is nothing but kind and good to her. Even Casmir finds her endearing and lovely, never once focusing on the fact that the woman he is engaged to marry is seen as a scourge in her land.
No one mistreats Meera for her issue at all in the novel, so it makes it really hard to believe that it's actually an issue for her, and one that seems to weigh on her self-worth.
I think it is in part because we forget what Meera looks like all the time. She apparently has such a twisted back that she has to wear a brace all the time in the novel. It made me think of the character Yennefer from The Witcher before she sold her soul and became even more insufferable. Yennefer, however, was actually kept from doing all sorts of things and had limitations because of her disfiguration.
Meera only has them when it's convenient. Most of the time, it's a backache, and I think once or twice it kept her from moving quickly, but for the most part, to have such a large deformity keeps her from doing little. She's able to jump off cliffs. She swims pretty adeptly for being so twisted. She can run from and stab multiple dragons. Her deformity does not, for the most part, hinder much of her movement. For me, I would have moments where she would be in the midst of the action, and I would question how? But McGinty sort of Deus Machina'ed the issue.
The Ugly
This is more preference than anything, but the love triangle felt so unearned. It was clear that as soon as Soran was turned into a dragon and was her enemy that he was the one that she would end up in. But just like in The Princess Diaries 2 the ultimate decision of Soran (sort of Nicholas in the movie -- though both girls end up "single") feels incredibly unearned. I think she was working toward an enemies-to-lovers romance (which is typically my type of couple when done correctly) but at no point did I have a Katara-and-Zuko-in-the-cave with all the romantic tension moment. He just started liking her and calling her worthy, saying that she was a star and blah blah blah. Casmir was a much better pick and a much more developed character. I had moments where I was like, "Meera, my friend, why are we choosing Soran? Casmir is the catch here. You are an idiot."
So, long story short, the love triangle felt forced and unearned.
Final Thoughts
The book is fun. The book is clean. I appreciate all of that. There was just a lot for me in this novel that didn't work in part because of personal preferences. But there were other parts that I think could have just been fixed with a better editor.
I am glad I gave it a try. But I think dragons and fantasy are just not for me for the most part.
September 23, 2024
What a ride! Time will tell if this is more of a 4.25 or a 4.5 star read, but I really enjoyed it.
December 13, 2024
I read this cover to cover in one day (3pm-5am, y'all. Great story, dreadful time slot), but I did not want to put it down! Within a richly crafted world reminiscent of Meiji-era Japan—that delightful mix of ancient culture and new invention—McGinty weaves a timeless tale of hearts and kingdoms alike in upheaval and teetering on the brink of collapse. This is a story of courage, learning self-worth, and the power (both good and bad) of choices.
Though we did not get nearly enough of it (in my opinion) I could not adore more the sibling bond between our main heroine Meera, her sister Runa, and their brother. Their shared love and humor warmed my heart and made me laugh—which was needful, considering some of the heartbreak that ensues. Devotion to her sister is Meera's driving force, and while I cringed at some of the decisions she made, choices that had and will continue to have painful consequences, I appreciated that very same thing. It displays that we all make mistakes, not all the decisions we make are necessarily the best or wisest ones, and while there are always consequences, we can choose to move forward.
I don't want to ramble on about our two studs (read it and we can chat, yeah?) But I liked how rounded both of them were, along with their contrasting and conflicting personalities. Dragon is blunt with underwhelming communication skills and Casmir scorched cinnamon roll (though that still feels like an oversimplification of all that he is—that they both are). We laughed, we cried, we jumped off cliffs and plotted in boiler rooms with too much coffee and garishly pink pants. It was great.
Just...Don't eat the pudding.
Overall, this is a wholesome and heartfelt story with endearing characters and a twist at the end that glued me down to that last, beautiful beat. I highly recommend it.
Though we did not get nearly enough of it (in my opinion) I could not adore more the sibling bond between our main heroine Meera, her sister Runa, and their brother. Their shared love and humor warmed my heart and made me laugh—which was needful, considering some of the heartbreak that ensues. Devotion to her sister is Meera's driving force, and while I cringed at some of the decisions she made, choices that had and will continue to have painful consequences, I appreciated that very same thing. It displays that we all make mistakes, not all the decisions we make are necessarily the best or wisest ones, and while there are always consequences, we can choose to move forward.
I don't want to ramble on about our two studs (read it and we can chat, yeah?) But I liked how rounded both of them were, along with their contrasting and conflicting personalities. Dragon is blunt with underwhelming communication skills and Casmir scorched cinnamon roll (though that still feels like an oversimplification of all that he is—that they both are). We laughed, we cried, we jumped off cliffs and plotted in boiler rooms with too much coffee and garishly pink pants. It was great.
Just...Don't eat the pudding.
Overall, this is a wholesome and heartfelt story with endearing characters and a twist at the end that glued me down to that last, beautiful beat. I highly recommend it.
January 21, 2024
This book is such a great blend for readers who love to read for vibes, but also need a strong plot. It’s hard these days to find books that have both but I think Saints and Monsters knocks it out of the park. Although this is a romance it doesn’t really feel that way as the FMC really makes a point that her duty comes first (which I love!) I think Ellen did an incredible job and I would recommend this book for anyone who likes more fanciful writing, lyrical prose, slow burn romance, and political intrigue.
Solid 4.5 out of 5!!
Characters - 8/10
Atmosphere - 10/10
Writing Style - 8/10
Plot - 8/10
Intrigue - 9/10
Logic/Relationships - 9/10
Enjoyment/Vibes - 10/10
62/70 = 8.9 = ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
Solid 4.5 out of 5!!
Characters - 8/10
Atmosphere - 10/10
Writing Style - 8/10
Plot - 8/10
Intrigue - 9/10
Logic/Relationships - 9/10
Enjoyment/Vibes - 10/10
62/70 = 8.9 = ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
March 5, 2024
This was such a fun story with themes of sacrifice, loyalty, and love woven into each page. Meera was the perfect MC, and her character arc from frightened princess to one who truly knew her worth was a fabulous journey of discovering how to turn your weakness into your greatest strength. Soran captured my heart, haha, and I enjoyed the chapters written from his POV. I also loved all the little details that kept me grounded in the setting. Imaginative and unique world-building, fast-paced adventure, an enemies-to-lovers subplot: Saints and Monsters has it all.
March 29, 2024
I enjoyed the adventure, cultural nuances, and the romance. I recommend this to YA fantasy fans.
August 22, 2025
"The saints say that hope is closer than the stars, brighter than the sun, and just as painful to hold."
I gobbled this book up, as I SHOULD, since it was my most anticipated release of the year. I'm in love with Ellen McGinty's writing style - omg was it beautiful! I thought her world building was great, too. The Japan-inspired setting was a nice change from the typical fantasy setting we're all used to.
The story subverted my expectations from the very first page, which was so fun. I wanted to just keep reading, which I think is about the best compliment I can give! Everything about this was well done - although, I can't lie, I definitely still have some questions that need answering... 👀
You know those stories where you're either reading it or you're thinking about it? Yeah, Saints and Monsters was like that. It was such a joy to read something with actual character arcs after so many recent disappointing reads. The balance between the character arcs and the plot arc was so good that I want to study it, lol. Meera being so strongly motivated by her love for her sister was sweet. 🥹 I'm here for the sibling bonds. Also, I really enjoyed uncovering the meaning of the title throughout my read - very few books have that added touch, and it's super special.
Based on a few hints, I'm anticipating more stories from this world, and I absolutely cannot wait to learn more about the magic that lies therein. Please give me more about the Saints and the Anuir! 🙏🏻 I'm ready to devour many more books set in Ezo and beyond - catch me preordering every single thing Ellen McGinty writes!
Indie / small publisher ✅
Unique fantasy ✅
Solid character arcs ✅
Clean romance ✅
Intriguing magic ✅
Engaging plot ✅
Great message ✅
Sibling bonds ✅
Gorgeous cover ✅
Sea dragons ✅
Chronic illness rep that's relevant & potent instead of being forgotten halfway through ✅
Bonus points for Ellen being such a fun and encouraging person to follow online! ☺️ If you've somehow found her book without giving her a follow, you definitely need to go remedy that right now (I'm especially looking at you, aspiring writers 👀)!
The worldbuilding reminded me of the Grishaverse and the magic reminded me of Studio Ghibli. The bottom line is that it was beautiful and if you're looking for fresh fantasy, you should definitely give it a read. 🐉🗡️🫀
I gobbled this book up, as I SHOULD, since it was my most anticipated release of the year. I'm in love with Ellen McGinty's writing style - omg was it beautiful! I thought her world building was great, too. The Japan-inspired setting was a nice change from the typical fantasy setting we're all used to.
The story subverted my expectations from the very first page, which was so fun. I wanted to just keep reading, which I think is about the best compliment I can give! Everything about this was well done - although, I can't lie, I definitely still have some questions that need answering... 👀
You know those stories where you're either reading it or you're thinking about it? Yeah, Saints and Monsters was like that. It was such a joy to read something with actual character arcs after so many recent disappointing reads. The balance between the character arcs and the plot arc was so good that I want to study it, lol. Meera being so strongly motivated by her love for her sister was sweet. 🥹 I'm here for the sibling bonds. Also, I really enjoyed uncovering the meaning of the title throughout my read - very few books have that added touch, and it's super special.
Based on a few hints, I'm anticipating more stories from this world, and I absolutely cannot wait to learn more about the magic that lies therein. Please give me more about the Saints and the Anuir! 🙏🏻 I'm ready to devour many more books set in Ezo and beyond - catch me preordering every single thing Ellen McGinty writes!
Indie / small publisher ✅
Unique fantasy ✅
Solid character arcs ✅
Clean romance ✅
Intriguing magic ✅
Engaging plot ✅
Great message ✅
Sibling bonds ✅
Gorgeous cover ✅
Sea dragons ✅
Chronic illness rep that's relevant & potent instead of being forgotten halfway through ✅
Bonus points for Ellen being such a fun and encouraging person to follow online! ☺️ If you've somehow found her book without giving her a follow, you definitely need to go remedy that right now (I'm especially looking at you, aspiring writers 👀)!
The worldbuilding reminded me of the Grishaverse and the magic reminded me of Studio Ghibli. The bottom line is that it was beautiful and if you're looking for fresh fantasy, you should definitely give it a read. 🐉🗡️🫀
February 29, 2024
A beautifully written no-spice romance with disability representation, healthy relationships and a breathtaking setting. The protagonist, Princess Meera, is a brave, unlikely hero. She redefines her worth and how she sees herself through a compelling character arc. The author explores themes of how every person has inherent value and she subverts expectations on common tropes, like the love triangle.
Fantasy readers searching for familiar tropes, like an arranged marriage, poison, magic, curses and enemies-to-lovers will be delighted with this book. At the same time, they'll get to read something refreshingly new with the cherry-blossom-dotted setting, the colourful and frightening sea-serpent dragons and a dragon-turned-man who wears a pair of pink pants and tries to figure out what it means to be human. This lyrically written story will appeal to fans of Spirited Away and Avatar the Last Airbender.
Fantasy readers searching for familiar tropes, like an arranged marriage, poison, magic, curses and enemies-to-lovers will be delighted with this book. At the same time, they'll get to read something refreshingly new with the cherry-blossom-dotted setting, the colourful and frightening sea-serpent dragons and a dragon-turned-man who wears a pair of pink pants and tries to figure out what it means to be human. This lyrically written story will appeal to fans of Spirited Away and Avatar the Last Airbender.
April 3, 2025
Saints and Monsters reads like an epic. It’s prose absolutely beautiful & the lore will ignite imagination and wonder. Ellen paints the world in vivid color making you wish you could dive into the book. Throughout the story Meera faces incredible odds finding more in herself then she could have ever imagined when she is thrust into a role she didn’t ask for. Maybe there is a bit of saint and a bit of monster and beauty in what the world says is a weakness. I love how dragon is portrayed in this novel and you’ll find many surprises and lessons learned my only complaint…. I want more! I can’t wait to see what novel Ellen writes next because I will for sure be reading it! Jane Marie does a fabulous job as always making the characters and story come even more to life with her narration.
Read
March 12, 2024This is a beautifully produced YA novel that will have a lot of appeal for fans of Elizabeth Lim or THE GIRL WHO FELL INTO THE SEA. It has rich prose and an intriguing setting inspired by 19th century Japan. I loved the choice of theme and the analogy with cherry blossoms. Personally, I felt a bit too distracted by the love triangle to invest fully in the romance, which ultimately left me feeling a bit disappointed. But I’m keen to read the other books that are coming out in this same story world as I find this author and her world really promising and appealing.
February 5, 2025
Oh my goodness, let me count the ways I loved this incredibly unique story filled with adventure, dragons, political intrigue, love of family, and gorgeously woven Japanese culture and themes! I loved the strength and character growth of the FMC, and the MMC for that matter. It was my night time read that I finished way too quickly, and honestly, I look forward to re-reading this amazing tale to revisit this beautiful world.
July 22, 2025
4.5 stars rounded up.
Saints and Monsters is such a fun book! I finished it in one and a half days because it was page-turn worthy and compelling. The plot is nicely structured. I felt like the first half of the book was written better than the second half (a few lines in the second half felt cliche but the majority of my favorite quotes from this book originated from the second half!
Saints and Monsters is such a fun book! I finished it in one and a half days because it was page-turn worthy and compelling. The plot is nicely structured. I felt like the first half of the book was written better than the second half (a few lines in the second half felt cliche but the majority of my favorite quotes from this book originated from the second half!
December 30, 2024
Realizing I never reviewed this amazing book here.
Charming and such a great read.
Charming and such a great read.
September 15, 2025
There were so many twists and turns in this book and it kept me engaged from the get go. I loved the theme of knowing your worth and that it doesn't come from what others say or what you do but how you feel about yourself. I'll definitely read the next in the series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 223 reviews