What do you think?
Rate this book
The Summer House Murder
A summer trip to the Adirondacks is turned upside down when a woman’s body is discovered in the lake in this twisty thriller, perfect for fans of Liane Moriarty and Paula Hawkins.
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their remote summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation. Each has their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. Esme, the oldest sister, is desperate to keep up appearances after discovering her husband’s infidelity with the one person who hurts her the most. Piper, the middle child, has a four-month-old baby boy and is too tired to keep playing peacekeeper to her siblings. Regina, the youngest, is a sarcastic rule breaker with a secret to hide that could cost her everything.
After tension boils over into an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions. Like most of their blowouts, they think they’ll cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning. Only this time when dawn comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As a criminal investigation narrows in on their family home, it becomes clear that the sister’s web of lies and secrets is inextricably linked to the woman in the lake.
A tense and fast-paced thriller, The Summer House Murder will leave audiences breathlessly listening until they reach the thrilling conclusion to this twisted family drama.
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their remote summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation. Each has their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. Esme, the oldest sister, is desperate to keep up appearances after discovering her husband’s infidelity with the one person who hurts her the most. Piper, the middle child, has a four-month-old baby boy and is too tired to keep playing peacekeeper to her siblings. Regina, the youngest, is a sarcastic rule breaker with a secret to hide that could cost her everything.
After tension boils over into an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions. Like most of their blowouts, they think they’ll cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning. Only this time when dawn comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As a criminal investigation narrows in on their family home, it becomes clear that the sister’s web of lies and secrets is inextricably linked to the woman in the lake.
A tense and fast-paced thriller, The Summer House Murder will leave audiences breathlessly listening until they reach the thrilling conclusion to this twisted family drama.
320 pages, Paperback
First published April 7, 2026
About the author
Ava Roberts
6 books199 followersAva Roberts is a clinical psychologist turned author who knows that the most unsettling things often lurk just beneath the surface. She is the author of The Vanishing Neighbor, Juniper Isle, the Thistler Thrillers series, and The Summer House Murder (2026). Kirkus Reviews called The Summer House Murder “a whirlwind domestic thriller that’s also a pitiless anatomy of the costs of motherhood and sisterhood.” She lives in Massachusetts with her husband, two kids, and an overactive imagination.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 128 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Three sisters reunite at a secluded lake house, but what should have been a peaceful vacation turns deadly. Old grudges resurface, a body is discovered, and suddenly no one can be trusted.
The writing is so vivid and immersive, I felt like the fourth sister, watching the chaos unravel firsthand. Every revelation had me second-guessing everyone – and getting it wrong every time.
If you love domestic thrillers with messy families, dark secrets, and shocking twists, you won’t want to miss this one.
The writing is so vivid and immersive, I felt like the fourth sister, watching the chaos unravel firsthand. Every revelation had me second-guessing everyone – and getting it wrong every time.
If you love domestic thrillers with messy families, dark secrets, and shocking twists, you won’t want to miss this one.
June 24, 2026
Thank you thank you to Ava Robert’s and Crooked Lane Books for my gifted copy of this great summer thriller!
I truly enjoyed this one and it was the perfect summer thriller beach read! I love a twisty domestic family drama and this one did not disappoint.
Three sisters reunite at their summer house with their families. Secrets, lies, and betrayals tensely rise to the surface between these sisters. While trying to keep themselves together none of their skeletons in their closet are safe from being revealed.
I enjoyed the characters and loved the sister dynamic between them. I thought it was twisty and kept me on the edge of my seat guessing and thoroughly entertained.
The setting was very cool because it is close to home for me and have vacationed there before!
I truly enjoyed this one and it was the perfect summer thriller beach read! I love a twisty domestic family drama and this one did not disappoint.
Three sisters reunite at their summer house with their families. Secrets, lies, and betrayals tensely rise to the surface between these sisters. While trying to keep themselves together none of their skeletons in their closet are safe from being revealed.
I enjoyed the characters and loved the sister dynamic between them. I thought it was twisty and kept me on the edge of my seat guessing and thoroughly entertained.
The setting was very cool because it is close to home for me and have vacationed there before!
April 19, 2026
I mean… Ava Roberts is already an auto buy author for me, but every book I read just magnifies that. I absolutely love her writing style & definitely looking forward to more of her work.
What made this story stick out.. Well there’s a lot lol.. First off, it was waayyy too much going at this Summer House and I absolutely would have wanted to return home immediately. This story was messy in the best way possible and the drama just continued to suck me in as the chapters continued. The complex, family dynamics and toxicity that went back decades, set the premise for a great story. Ava continued to build suspense along with my anxiety as I wondered how this story would unfold.
Esme, Piper & Regina already lead separate lives but these sisters’ antics toward each other had my mouth on the floor! The alternating timelines & POVs was the perfect set up to be able to see the story told from everyone in first person! Overall, another great read by one of my favs & perfect for fans of Domestic Thrillers!
What made this story stick out.. Well there’s a lot lol.. First off, it was waayyy too much going at this Summer House and I absolutely would have wanted to return home immediately. This story was messy in the best way possible and the drama just continued to suck me in as the chapters continued. The complex, family dynamics and toxicity that went back decades, set the premise for a great story. Ava continued to build suspense along with my anxiety as I wondered how this story would unfold.
Esme, Piper & Regina already lead separate lives but these sisters’ antics toward each other had my mouth on the floor! The alternating timelines & POVs was the perfect set up to be able to see the story told from everyone in first person! Overall, another great read by one of my favs & perfect for fans of Domestic Thrillers!
July 28, 2026
So many typos, I ended up reaching out to the publisher. Finished purely out of spite.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.5 stars!
Drama! Drama! Drama! With a big family comes an abundance of drama, secrets, and unnecessary conflicts among siblings and close relatives. I can relate all too well, having grown up in a large family where constant competition and someone always getting blamed for something was the norm—UGH!
A summer trip to the Adirondacks turns into a thriller when a woman's body is found in the lake. Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina arrive at their summer house on Lake George, each grappling with personal issues and secrets. Following a family fight, they separate, only to discover the body the next morning. As a criminal investigation unfolds, the sisters' hidden truths become intertwined with the mystery.
The story is narrated from the perspectives of Esme, Regina, Piper, Alexis, and Lana, weaving together two timelines: one from the past and one in the present. This approach helps us to fully understand what went wrong between the cousins and, most importantly, why. But you’ll have to keep reading to uncover the why, as that revelation is saved for the end! The characters in this tale can be quite unlikeable, while some are more relatable, but it’s fascinating to see how one person can manipulate the others—a scenario that hits close to home for many of us.
This well-crafted domestic murder mystery serves up revenge hot and delves into the concept of karma! The story captures the attention of everyone, until it doesn’t. Esme is left to grapple with the consequences of her actions regarding Alexis, and the twists in the storyline left me stunned. The ending, in particular, feels like a long-planned act of revenge. After all, some traumas can’t simply be brushed aside without facing repercussions—can they?
If you’re comfortable with toxic family dynamics, deeply buried secrets, and morally ambiguous characters, you’re in for a treat. The secluded setting plays a significant role in character development, so buckle up and pay attention, because this family trip is one you won’t soon forget—and hopefully, you’ll survive it! Now, if you’ll excuse me, I can only hope that no one in my immediate circle holds a grudge that could come back to haunt me in my golden years! Ha!
Thank you, Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley, for the DRC copy. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Drama! Drama! Drama! With a big family comes an abundance of drama, secrets, and unnecessary conflicts among siblings and close relatives. I can relate all too well, having grown up in a large family where constant competition and someone always getting blamed for something was the norm—UGH!
A summer trip to the Adirondacks turns into a thriller when a woman's body is found in the lake. Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina arrive at their summer house on Lake George, each grappling with personal issues and secrets. Following a family fight, they separate, only to discover the body the next morning. As a criminal investigation unfolds, the sisters' hidden truths become intertwined with the mystery.
The story is narrated from the perspectives of Esme, Regina, Piper, Alexis, and Lana, weaving together two timelines: one from the past and one in the present. This approach helps us to fully understand what went wrong between the cousins and, most importantly, why. But you’ll have to keep reading to uncover the why, as that revelation is saved for the end! The characters in this tale can be quite unlikeable, while some are more relatable, but it’s fascinating to see how one person can manipulate the others—a scenario that hits close to home for many of us.
This well-crafted domestic murder mystery serves up revenge hot and delves into the concept of karma! The story captures the attention of everyone, until it doesn’t. Esme is left to grapple with the consequences of her actions regarding Alexis, and the twists in the storyline left me stunned. The ending, in particular, feels like a long-planned act of revenge. After all, some traumas can’t simply be brushed aside without facing repercussions—can they?
If you’re comfortable with toxic family dynamics, deeply buried secrets, and morally ambiguous characters, you’re in for a treat. The secluded setting plays a significant role in character development, so buckle up and pay attention, because this family trip is one you won’t soon forget—and hopefully, you’ll survive it! Now, if you’ll excuse me, I can only hope that no one in my immediate circle holds a grudge that could come back to haunt me in my golden years! Ha!
Thank you, Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley, for the DRC copy. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
April 11, 2026
Well written, great character development, amazing plot & twists I never saw coming!! I literally binge listened to this audiobook!!
🎧The narration really brought out the individuality of each character, amped up the already intense suspense & kept my ears glued to every word!
💬 A family lake house, a small Adirondack town, sisters that never get along & each with their own secrets. What could go wrong when they all come back together for the Summer? Lies upon lies stack up to some pretty intense & gripping drama. I was fully buckled in & enjoyed every moment of this suspenseful, fast paced, jaw dropping ride!!
🎧The narration really brought out the individuality of each character, amped up the already intense suspense & kept my ears glued to every word!
💬 A family lake house, a small Adirondack town, sisters that never get along & each with their own secrets. What could go wrong when they all come back together for the Summer? Lies upon lies stack up to some pretty intense & gripping drama. I was fully buckled in & enjoyed every moment of this suspenseful, fast paced, jaw dropping ride!!
October 7, 2025
This book was packed with drama, suspense, and great twists. I loved the fast pace and how easy it was to follow. What an amazing cast or strong characters! The way the lies can get uncovered and come back to haunt them added to the suspense on every page. I felt like I was right there in the middle of everything watching it all unfold! This is a must read! I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 14, 2026
Despite not liking the writing style and it needing an editor badly right from the beginning, I got sucked into the story, so I kept reading. But by the end it was mostly out of spite. There were a few sparks that kept me going, but just not enough for my final judgement to be anything but shallow and cliche. And worse- predictable. Plus, every single character (especially the men) should be jealous of the strength and dimension of cardboard cutouts left outside in a hurricane. They were, every single one of them, cartoonishly one-dimensional.
November 2, 2025
The Summer House Murder
A Novel by Ava Roberts
Pub Date: April 7, 2026
Crooked Lane Books
Genre: Mystery & Thrillers | General Fiction (Adult)
#TheSummerHouseMurder #NetGalley
My Review:🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
This story is fresh, amazing, and incredibly entertaining! It’s packed with suspense in every chapter and keeps you hooked from the start. What begins as a tense family getaway soon turns into a dark, emotional thriller full of secrets and shocking twists.
The story follows three sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina who return to their summer house on Lake George. After a heated argument one night, a woman’s body is found in the lake, and their lives spiral out of control. Each sister’s point of view adds mystery and emotion, revealing how deep their secrets go.
I loved Piper and Regina, especially Regina strong, complicated, and impossible not to root for. George and Alexis were characters I truly disliked but added the perfect tension.
There’s mystery in every scene who is the woman in the lake, who killed her, and what happened to the missing baby? The twists kept coming, and the ending completely blew me away.
Ava Roberts has written a gripping and emotional thriller that’s impossible to put down. Definitely a five-star read!
Thank you to #NetGalley and @CrookedLaneBooks for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
A Novel by Ava Roberts
Pub Date: April 7, 2026
Crooked Lane Books
Genre: Mystery & Thrillers | General Fiction (Adult)
#TheSummerHouseMurder #NetGalley
My Review:🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
This story is fresh, amazing, and incredibly entertaining! It’s packed with suspense in every chapter and keeps you hooked from the start. What begins as a tense family getaway soon turns into a dark, emotional thriller full of secrets and shocking twists.
The story follows three sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina who return to their summer house on Lake George. After a heated argument one night, a woman’s body is found in the lake, and their lives spiral out of control. Each sister’s point of view adds mystery and emotion, revealing how deep their secrets go.
I loved Piper and Regina, especially Regina strong, complicated, and impossible not to root for. George and Alexis were characters I truly disliked but added the perfect tension.
There’s mystery in every scene who is the woman in the lake, who killed her, and what happened to the missing baby? The twists kept coming, and the ending completely blew me away.
Ava Roberts has written a gripping and emotional thriller that’s impossible to put down. Definitely a five-star read!
Thank you to #NetGalley and @CrookedLaneBooks for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
January 4, 2026
The Summer House Murders by Ava Roberts. Thanks to @crookedlanebooks for the gifted Arc ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Three sisters meet at their house in the Adirondacks for their annual summer visit, expecting a tense vacation. Sure enough, a big fight ensues and they go their own ways for the night. The next morning a woman’s body is found in their lake and tensions get worse as law enforcement investigates them.
While a story about sisters, none of them seem to like each other or get along very well, which makes for interesting drama but also made me sad. I kept waiting for them to have each others’ backs, but as the history of their past comes out, it becomes more understandable. That said, I did like each of their characters individually. The story was fast paced and had some twists and turns I wasn’t expecting.
“It was rigged. I was always going to be the loser, and she was always going to be the winner. The only way to play a rigged game is to cheat. So here we go.”
Read this if you like:
-Dysfunctional families and sibling relationships
-Infidelity tropes
-Adirondacks setting
The Summer House Murders comes out 4/17.
Three sisters meet at their house in the Adirondacks for their annual summer visit, expecting a tense vacation. Sure enough, a big fight ensues and they go their own ways for the night. The next morning a woman’s body is found in their lake and tensions get worse as law enforcement investigates them.
While a story about sisters, none of them seem to like each other or get along very well, which makes for interesting drama but also made me sad. I kept waiting for them to have each others’ backs, but as the history of their past comes out, it becomes more understandable. That said, I did like each of their characters individually. The story was fast paced and had some twists and turns I wasn’t expecting.
“It was rigged. I was always going to be the loser, and she was always going to be the winner. The only way to play a rigged game is to cheat. So here we go.”
Read this if you like:
-Dysfunctional families and sibling relationships
-Infidelity tropes
-Adirondacks setting
The Summer House Murders comes out 4/17.
May 24, 2026
3 sisters with equally unlikeable personalities.
Esme is controlling, cruel, and a self-absorbed narcissist who looks down on everyone else. It’s honestly no mystery why her husband (equally annoying and painfully predictable) decided to look elsewhere and have an affair with… you guessed it: THE NANNY.
Regina’s sarcastic, dull, pessimistic attitude absolutely grinded my gears. Like please, for once, stop having a negative retort for every single thing. She also has that exhausting habit of thinking only her perspective is the correct one.
And lastly, Piper — the biggest pushover I have ever encountered in fiction. She’s paranoid, meek, weak, and never stands up for herself or anyone else. I understand she’s a new mother, but good lord, grow a backbone.
None of these women were particularly likeable, but if I had to be trapped in a room with one of them, I’d pick Esme. At least she got stuff done.
And Alexis? I genuinely didn’t know what to think about her. I felt sorry for her and sympathised with how she grew up with her awful Aunt Audrey after her mother died, but plotting this entire thing? Even after Greg gave her money so she could start fresh? She definitely started losing the plot when she killed Bridgit and tried to trick Luna. That was properly psychotic.
Also… Piper didn’t kill her? Did Piper even check her pulse??
And the men. The husbands. They contributed about as much to the story as edible flowers contribute to a dish — sprinkled on top and mostly decorative. Although honestly, everyone except Greg and Esme seemed to have decent relationships.
I did really enjoy the 4 POV structure. Seeing how each sister viewed the situation, and each other, was probably the strongest part of the book. It really showed how every story has multiple sides to it.
The ending was a little fluffy, but I still liked it, especially getting Alexis’ perspective and seeing her plotting unfold.
Overall, I’d still recommend this. Even though I had serious beef with all the sisters, it portrayed a sibling dynamic that feels different from what most books usually show.
Esme is controlling, cruel, and a self-absorbed narcissist who looks down on everyone else. It’s honestly no mystery why her husband (equally annoying and painfully predictable) decided to look elsewhere and have an affair with… you guessed it: THE NANNY.
Regina’s sarcastic, dull, pessimistic attitude absolutely grinded my gears. Like please, for once, stop having a negative retort for every single thing. She also has that exhausting habit of thinking only her perspective is the correct one.
And lastly, Piper — the biggest pushover I have ever encountered in fiction. She’s paranoid, meek, weak, and never stands up for herself or anyone else. I understand she’s a new mother, but good lord, grow a backbone.
None of these women were particularly likeable, but if I had to be trapped in a room with one of them, I’d pick Esme. At least she got stuff done.
And Alexis? I genuinely didn’t know what to think about her. I felt sorry for her and sympathised with how she grew up with her awful Aunt Audrey after her mother died, but plotting this entire thing? Even after Greg gave her money so she could start fresh? She definitely started losing the plot when she killed Bridgit and tried to trick Luna. That was properly psychotic.
Also… Piper didn’t kill her? Did Piper even check her pulse??
And the men. The husbands. They contributed about as much to the story as edible flowers contribute to a dish — sprinkled on top and mostly decorative. Although honestly, everyone except Greg and Esme seemed to have decent relationships.
I did really enjoy the 4 POV structure. Seeing how each sister viewed the situation, and each other, was probably the strongest part of the book. It really showed how every story has multiple sides to it.
The ending was a little fluffy, but I still liked it, especially getting Alexis’ perspective and seeing her plotting unfold.
Overall, I’d still recommend this. Even though I had serious beef with all the sisters, it portrayed a sibling dynamic that feels different from what most books usually show.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 25, 2026
I was all in once we got to the middle, just for this whole web of secrets, lies, and sibling rivalry to end in a way that had me like… THAT was the payoff?! 🙃😵💫🥴 I will say the Alexis chapters definitely brought more life to the book, but the ending just wasn’t worth the headache for me lolol. 3/5 ⭐️
July 13, 2026
the absolute fastest read ever. the pages just kept turning!
October 6, 2026
uhhhh idk how I felt about this, the characters weren't really enjoyable and the plot was interesting but not my favourite
April 10, 2026
Loaded to the brim with family drama! Unlikable people in a likable kind of way. That was fun.
June 8, 2026
3.5 Stars
The. Summer House Murder was definitely a fun mystery to read. My one criticism would be, between the multiple characters and the alternating timelines I found it to be confusing at times.
The. Summer House Murder was definitely a fun mystery to read. My one criticism would be, between the multiple characters and the alternating timelines I found it to be confusing at times.
April 5, 2026
What a twisty domestic thriller! So many family secrets and clashing personalities made for a wild ride. If you love dysfunctional family drama, you won’t want to miss this roller coaster of a ride.
Many thanks to Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Book for my gifted copy!
Many thanks to Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Book for my gifted copy!
June 28, 2026
The time line and multiple P.O.V.s got confusing at times.
The story itself was great and the ending was perfect
The story itself was great and the ending was perfect
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
In Ava Roberts' gripping and atmospheric domestic thriller, THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER, three estranged sisters—Esme, Piper, and Regina—return to their idyllic Lake George home, a place once filled with laughter and shared memories, now tinged with unresolved toxic tensions. The reunion quickly spirals into chaos after a fierce argument erupts, shattering the fragile peace among them.
Amidst the backdrop of the vibrant summer landscape, the sisters find themselves embroiled in a chilling mystery following the shocking murder of the nanny, Brigit. As they navigate the complicated web of family secrets and drama, the plot thickens with a cast of intriguing suspects, including their seemingly charming husbands and a bitter cousin, Alexis, whose determination to claim their inheritance adds a sinister twist to the unfolding drama.
As accusations fly and trust erodes, the sisters must confront not only their past but also the dark truths that lurk within their own family.
Highlights...
My thoughts...
The captivating twisty narrative explores the complex and often turbulent dynamics of family relationships (sisterhood and motherhood), peeling back the layers of emotional turmoil and unspoken tensions buried beneath the surface.
At the heart of THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER is a poignant examination of the profound sacrifices made to maintain an illusion of perfection in the eyes of society. The characters grapple with their own desires and struggles, all while desperately trying to uphold a veneer of harmony and success, ultimately revealing the cost of such façades on their lives and connections.
Drawing from her background as a clinical psychologist, Roberts intricately interlaces profound psychological insights with the familiar elements of thriller storytelling. This blend not only enhances the tension but also provides a richer understanding of the characters' motivations and struggles, making the story both compelling and thought-provoking.
The isolated Lake George setting is lush and beautiful, creating a "locked room" vibe where the quiet water reflects the creeping feeling that something is wrong beneath the surface. The oppressive weather serves as a physical manifestation of the simmering tensions between the characters.
The central takeaway of character-driven, THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER is that secrets and suppressed trauma are more destructive than any external threat.
While the sisters fight for the house, it eventually becomes their prison, proving that material gain at the expense of relationships is a hollow victory. The inheritance turns toxic; it does not bring them together, but poisons their remaining bond.
Ultimately, the book warns that you can never truly outrun your past. The author focuses on the "why," not just "how," as the secrets are revealed. Denial is a deadly blind spot; the more you try to look perfect, the more vulnerable you are to being destroyed.
Recs...
If you are a fan of Jamie Day's The Lake Escape with high-stakes tension and a lake house setting, you will enjoy THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER with family secrets, psychological twists, and an isolated getaway thriller. Both stories turn a serene vacation setting into a claustrophobic psychological battleground where you can't even look out your own window without seeing your enemy.
Blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: April 7, 2026
April Newsletter
Amidst the backdrop of the vibrant summer landscape, the sisters find themselves embroiled in a chilling mystery following the shocking murder of the nanny, Brigit. As they navigate the complicated web of family secrets and drama, the plot thickens with a cast of intriguing suspects, including their seemingly charming husbands and a bitter cousin, Alexis, whose determination to claim their inheritance adds a sinister twist to the unfolding drama.
As accusations fly and trust erodes, the sisters must confront not only their past but also the dark truths that lurk within their own family.
Highlights...
Per their mother's will, the sisters must spend two weeks together to keep their lake house, creating high tension.
A woman named Brigit is found dead in the lake, forcing the sisters to hide secrets while suspecting their own families.
Esme’s husband is cheating, Piper suffers from postpartum issues, and Regina is broke.
Then there is the sisters' half-sister/cousin, Alexis, who brings more suspense and drama.
The narrative deepens with complex character motivations, revealing a rich tapestry of hidden agendas and desires. As the story unfolds, a tangled web of deeply rooted family secrets emerges, adding layers of intrigue and tension that keep readers on the edge of their seats.
My thoughts...
The captivating twisty narrative explores the complex and often turbulent dynamics of family relationships (sisterhood and motherhood), peeling back the layers of emotional turmoil and unspoken tensions buried beneath the surface.
At the heart of THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER is a poignant examination of the profound sacrifices made to maintain an illusion of perfection in the eyes of society. The characters grapple with their own desires and struggles, all while desperately trying to uphold a veneer of harmony and success, ultimately revealing the cost of such façades on their lives and connections.
Drawing from her background as a clinical psychologist, Roberts intricately interlaces profound psychological insights with the familiar elements of thriller storytelling. This blend not only enhances the tension but also provides a richer understanding of the characters' motivations and struggles, making the story both compelling and thought-provoking.
The isolated Lake George setting is lush and beautiful, creating a "locked room" vibe where the quiet water reflects the creeping feeling that something is wrong beneath the surface. The oppressive weather serves as a physical manifestation of the simmering tensions between the characters.
The central takeaway of character-driven, THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER is that secrets and suppressed trauma are more destructive than any external threat.
While the sisters fight for the house, it eventually becomes their prison, proving that material gain at the expense of relationships is a hollow victory. The inheritance turns toxic; it does not bring them together, but poisons their remaining bond.
Ultimately, the book warns that you can never truly outrun your past. The author focuses on the "why," not just "how," as the secrets are revealed. Denial is a deadly blind spot; the more you try to look perfect, the more vulnerable you are to being destroyed.
Recs...
If you are a fan of Jamie Day's The Lake Escape with high-stakes tension and a lake house setting, you will enjoy THE SUMMER HOUSE MURDER with family secrets, psychological twists, and an isolated getaway thriller. Both stories turn a serene vacation setting into a claustrophobic psychological battleground where you can't even look out your own window without seeing your enemy.
Blog review posted @
JudithDCollins.com
@JudithDCollins | #JDCMustReadBooks
Pub Date: April 7, 2026
April Newsletter
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
The Summer House Murder by Ava Roberts is a solid, atmospheric summer thriller. The kind you pick up planning to read a little bit and suddenly it’s way too late and you’re side-eyeing everyone.
The story centers around three sisters and their complicated, deeply strained relationships, all tied to a summer house where, unsurprisingly, things go very wrong. This is not a warm, sentimental take on sisterhood. There’s tension from the start, and not much love underneath it. What you get instead is resentment, long-held grudges, and a level of deliberate cruelty that makes every interaction feel sharp and intentional.
It’s told through four POVs and moves between past and present, which really works here. The timeline shifts add context to the sisters’ history without slowing things down, and seeing events from multiple perspectives keeps you constantly reevaluating what you think you know. Everyone has their own version of the truth, and none of them are completely reliable.
The pacing really worked for me. It leans slow-burn at first, building tension through past dynamics, subtle digs, and things left unsaid, then gradually tightens until everything starts unraveling. Once it hits that turning point, it’s hard to put down. I was fully in “okay one more chapter” mode for the last stretch.
The sister dynamics are easily the strongest part of the book. Their history feels messy and layered, and I liked that nothing is softened. Everyone has their own reasons for the resentment they carry, but no one is willing to take responsibility for their actions. There’s a lot of blame-shifting, finger-pointing, and buried anger, which made the story even more compelling.
Everyone has a motive, and none of them are particularly easy to root for. And I mean that literally. Most of these characters are unlikeable in one way or another. Some more than others. For a good chunk of the book, the person I was most invested in (and the only one I was rooting for) was the villain, which made the whole experience even more entertaining in a slightly chaotic way.
The supporting characters, especially the husbands, felt underdeveloped to the point where they could’ve been removed without changing the story much. Even Greg, Esme’s husband, who plays a major role in the plot, lacked real substance. There were also a few details that seemed important when introduced but were never fully explored or revisited, which made parts feel a little incomplete.
The atmosphere, though, really delivers. The summer house setting is isolated, slightly claustrophobic, and filled with the kind of history that makes everything feel heavier. There’s a constant sense that something is off, and it builds nicely as the story unfolds.
The twists were satisfying. I was able to piece together some elements, but not the full picture, which is kind of my ideal balance. There were plenty of turns to keep things interesting.
This is a character-driven domestic thriller that leans hard into messy family dynamics, revenge, and the idea that everyone is the hero of their own story, even when they’re clearly not. It’s not a “love these characters” kind of book, but it is a “can’t look away” kind of book.
Huge thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for an advanced copy to review!
The story centers around three sisters and their complicated, deeply strained relationships, all tied to a summer house where, unsurprisingly, things go very wrong. This is not a warm, sentimental take on sisterhood. There’s tension from the start, and not much love underneath it. What you get instead is resentment, long-held grudges, and a level of deliberate cruelty that makes every interaction feel sharp and intentional.
It’s told through four POVs and moves between past and present, which really works here. The timeline shifts add context to the sisters’ history without slowing things down, and seeing events from multiple perspectives keeps you constantly reevaluating what you think you know. Everyone has their own version of the truth, and none of them are completely reliable.
The pacing really worked for me. It leans slow-burn at first, building tension through past dynamics, subtle digs, and things left unsaid, then gradually tightens until everything starts unraveling. Once it hits that turning point, it’s hard to put down. I was fully in “okay one more chapter” mode for the last stretch.
The sister dynamics are easily the strongest part of the book. Their history feels messy and layered, and I liked that nothing is softened. Everyone has their own reasons for the resentment they carry, but no one is willing to take responsibility for their actions. There’s a lot of blame-shifting, finger-pointing, and buried anger, which made the story even more compelling.
Everyone has a motive, and none of them are particularly easy to root for. And I mean that literally. Most of these characters are unlikeable in one way or another. Some more than others. For a good chunk of the book, the person I was most invested in (and the only one I was rooting for) was the villain, which made the whole experience even more entertaining in a slightly chaotic way.
The supporting characters, especially the husbands, felt underdeveloped to the point where they could’ve been removed without changing the story much. Even Greg, Esme’s husband, who plays a major role in the plot, lacked real substance. There were also a few details that seemed important when introduced but were never fully explored or revisited, which made parts feel a little incomplete.
The atmosphere, though, really delivers. The summer house setting is isolated, slightly claustrophobic, and filled with the kind of history that makes everything feel heavier. There’s a constant sense that something is off, and it builds nicely as the story unfolds.
The twists were satisfying. I was able to piece together some elements, but not the full picture, which is kind of my ideal balance. There were plenty of turns to keep things interesting.
This is a character-driven domestic thriller that leans hard into messy family dynamics, revenge, and the idea that everyone is the hero of their own story, even when they’re clearly not. It’s not a “love these characters” kind of book, but it is a “can’t look away” kind of book.
Huge thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for an advanced copy to review!
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Fast-paced, twisted, and deliciously unhinged, The Summer House Murders was a rollicking rollercoaster ride of suspense that I couldn’t put down. You see, with dysfunctional family dynamics, toxic relationships, and one heck of a root-for-able villain, I was fully invested from beginning to end. The messy sibling rivalries, however, were what made me an instant fan. Perfect for fans of Sally Hepworth or Darby Kane, this popcorn thriller/family drama had a web of dark secrets, well-hidden motives, and manipulative lies that kept me guessing throughout. A mix of true-to-life and over-the-top, the sisters at the center of the story were full of grudges, resentments, and even a bit of hate. So it ultimately came as no big surprise when some secret alliances and revenge took center stage. After all, this cast of mostly unlikeable characters were hiding far more than even I could figure out.
Alongside of the character-driven storyline, though, was an atmospheric setting that I could easily “see” in my head and some of my absolute favorite thriller themes. Exploring family relationships, sibling dynamics, and marriage in one action-packed story, it was an easy one-sitting read that also delivered on the scandal and intrigue. I mean, not only was there cheating and lying going on in this truly messed-up family, but even the kids got in on the action. A drama-fueled tale told via dual timelines and multiple POVs, it was pure dynamite from the first attention-grabbing sentence to the grin-inducing last chapter. So if you’re looking for a quick, easy read that is sure to keep you in guessing, grab this book now. After all, there was even a “HOLY S***!!” twist thrown in for good measure. Explosive, tense, and binge-able in the extreme, this one was an absolute gem. Rating of 4.5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their remote summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation. Each has their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. Esme, the oldest sister, is desperate to keep up appearances after discovering her husband’s infidelity with the one person who hurts her the most. Piper, the middle child, has a four-month-old baby boy and is too tired to keep playing peacekeeper to her siblings. Regina, the youngest, is a sarcastic rule breaker with a secret to hide that could cost her everything.
After tension boils over into an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions. Like most of their blowouts, they think they’ll cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning. Only this time when dawn comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As a criminal investigation narrows in on their family home, it becomes clear that the sister’s web of lies and secrets is inextricably linked to the woman in the lake.
Thank you Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Books for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: April 7, 2026
Content warning: anxiety, bullying, infidelity, drug use, mental health, strangulation, murder, violence, gaslighting, mention of: death of a parent
Alongside of the character-driven storyline, though, was an atmospheric setting that I could easily “see” in my head and some of my absolute favorite thriller themes. Exploring family relationships, sibling dynamics, and marriage in one action-packed story, it was an easy one-sitting read that also delivered on the scandal and intrigue. I mean, not only was there cheating and lying going on in this truly messed-up family, but even the kids got in on the action. A drama-fueled tale told via dual timelines and multiple POVs, it was pure dynamite from the first attention-grabbing sentence to the grin-inducing last chapter. So if you’re looking for a quick, easy read that is sure to keep you in guessing, grab this book now. After all, there was even a “HOLY S***!!” twist thrown in for good measure. Explosive, tense, and binge-able in the extreme, this one was an absolute gem. Rating of 4.5 stars.
SYNOPSIS:
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their remote summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation. Each has their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. Esme, the oldest sister, is desperate to keep up appearances after discovering her husband’s infidelity with the one person who hurts her the most. Piper, the middle child, has a four-month-old baby boy and is too tired to keep playing peacekeeper to her siblings. Regina, the youngest, is a sarcastic rule breaker with a secret to hide that could cost her everything.
After tension boils over into an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions. Like most of their blowouts, they think they’ll cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning. Only this time when dawn comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As a criminal investigation narrows in on their family home, it becomes clear that the sister’s web of lies and secrets is inextricably linked to the woman in the lake.
Thank you Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Books for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.
PUB DATE: April 7, 2026
Content warning: anxiety, bullying, infidelity, drug use, mental health, strangulation, murder, violence, gaslighting, mention of: death of a parent
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
The Summer House Murder by Ava Roberts
4.5/5 ☆
𝐓𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐞𝐬:
☆ Dysfunctional families
☆ Domestic thriller
☆ Lake house
𝐏𝐥𝐨𝐭: During an annual summer trip to their remote lake house in the Adirondacks, three sisters—each carrying their own secrets and strained relationships—find tensions reaching a breaking point after a late-night fight. But by morning, everything changes when a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As the investigation begins to close in, it becomes clear that the sisters’ hidden pasts and tangled lies may be more connected to the murder than they ever expected.
𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰:
Literally flew through this in one sitting. I’m always gonna love a lake house thriller.
This is exactly what I want in a domestic thriller: messy family dynamics, buried secrets, and characters you can’t trust.
The sister relationships were the standout for me. They felt so real, complicated, and layered. There’s love there, but also resentment, jealousy, and years of unspoken tension, which made everything hit harder as the story unfolded. Everyone had something to hide, and I loved how my opinions kept shifting with every new reveal.
I loved the setting and the writing was so atmospheric I felt like I was there. I could picture everything so clearly, like I was right there watching it all unravel in real time.
The pacing is super fast with short, punchy chapters. I loved how the story slowly peeled back each layer of the family dynamic.
I will say I guessed part of the twist, but honestly it didn’t take away from the experience for me. There were still enough surprises and smaller reveals along the way to keep me hooked, and the tension never really let up. If anything, it made me more invested in seeing how everything would play out.
If you love domestic thrillers packed with toxic family dynamics, secrets, a hint of female rage, and nonstop drama, this one is such a fun, bingeable read.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for the gifted copy!
4.5/5 ☆
𝐓𝐫𝐨𝐩𝐞𝐬:
☆ Dysfunctional families
☆ Domestic thriller
☆ Lake house
𝐏𝐥𝐨𝐭: During an annual summer trip to their remote lake house in the Adirondacks, three sisters—each carrying their own secrets and strained relationships—find tensions reaching a breaking point after a late-night fight. But by morning, everything changes when a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake. As the investigation begins to close in, it becomes clear that the sisters’ hidden pasts and tangled lies may be more connected to the murder than they ever expected.
𝐑𝐞𝐯𝐢𝐞𝐰:
Literally flew through this in one sitting. I’m always gonna love a lake house thriller.
This is exactly what I want in a domestic thriller: messy family dynamics, buried secrets, and characters you can’t trust.
The sister relationships were the standout for me. They felt so real, complicated, and layered. There’s love there, but also resentment, jealousy, and years of unspoken tension, which made everything hit harder as the story unfolded. Everyone had something to hide, and I loved how my opinions kept shifting with every new reveal.
I loved the setting and the writing was so atmospheric I felt like I was there. I could picture everything so clearly, like I was right there watching it all unravel in real time.
The pacing is super fast with short, punchy chapters. I loved how the story slowly peeled back each layer of the family dynamic.
I will say I guessed part of the twist, but honestly it didn’t take away from the experience for me. There were still enough surprises and smaller reveals along the way to keep me hooked, and the tension never really let up. If anything, it made me more invested in seeing how everything would play out.
If you love domestic thrillers packed with toxic family dynamics, secrets, a hint of female rage, and nonstop drama, this one is such a fun, bingeable read.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books for the gifted copy!
July 20, 2026
I love books about family dynamics/drama and I also enjoy books with a summer house setting. Check and check! The setting was described in such vivid detail that I felt as if I was right there. This book did not disappoint in that sense. I am not a fan of alternating POV’s but the three sisters were all so different with totally different problems so it was easy to keep track of who was who. They all seemed like real people, albeit unlikable, yet there was one character who was a complete caricature…..Alexis. For the most part this book was very entertaining and engaging. Whenever I had a few extra minutes, I would reach for it and that’s my test for a good book. I’ve read so many clunkers I had no interest in even picking up once I started them. This one I couldn’t put down….for the most part. Unfortunately like 99.9% of the thrillers I read, the ending was so convoluted and preposterous that I wound up skimming pages just to finish the book. I don’t understand why authors continue to try to pass off ridiculous plot lines as shocking twists. It didn’t ruin the whole book for me, but definitely took away from it as I took a star away from this book. The reason another star was taken away was due to incorrect grammar and typos!
Here are a few examples out of MANY!
1. I feel asleep right after the phone call.
2. It was between Esme and I. (It was between Esme
and me.)
3. He sees Alexis and I. (He sees Alexis and me.)
This grammatical error happened throughout the book.
There were also words missing from sentences and the wrong sister’s named was stated at one point.
Was this book even edited? If it was, I would demand my money back! Maybe AI is doing the editing these days? Some things simply cannot be replaced with AI.
All and all, it was a good thriller that held my attention, but it could have been a great thriller. Unfortunately with a VERY far fetched ending and SO MUCH incorrect grammar and lack of editing/proofreading, it lost a lot of points with me and along with that…… two stars!
Here are a few examples out of MANY!
1. I feel asleep right after the phone call.
2. It was between Esme and I. (It was between Esme
and me.)
3. He sees Alexis and I. (He sees Alexis and me.)
This grammatical error happened throughout the book.
There were also words missing from sentences and the wrong sister’s named was stated at one point.
Was this book even edited? If it was, I would demand my money back! Maybe AI is doing the editing these days? Some things simply cannot be replaced with AI.
All and all, it was a good thriller that held my attention, but it could have been a great thriller. Unfortunately with a VERY far fetched ending and SO MUCH incorrect grammar and lack of editing/proofreading, it lost a lot of points with me and along with that…… two stars!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
𝑰𝒏 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒔 𝒎𝒐𝒎𝒆𝒏𝒕, 𝑰 𝒅𝒐𝒏'𝒕 𝒊𝒎𝒂𝒈𝒊𝒏𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒊𝒔 𝒕𝒐 𝒃𝒆 𝒐𝒖𝒓 𝒍𝒂𝒔𝒕 𝒑𝒆𝒂𝒄𝒆𝒇𝒖𝒍 𝒅𝒂𝒚 𝒃𝒚 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒍𝒂𝒌𝒆. 𝑩𝒖𝒕 𝒊𝒕 𝒊𝒔.
This was a twisty, explosive thriller that explores family secrets and all the things we desperately try to keep buried. Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina aren't naturally close, but provisions in their mother's will force them to vacation together every year for two weeks at the family's lake house. It's always tense, but this year each sister is bringing baggage that can't be rolled into the house on wheels.
Esme is the controlling older sister who comes across as dominant, cold, and unfeeling, but no one can guess the gut-wrenching secret she's holding on to. She can't confide in her sisters for support for fear they will judge her, so she suffers in silence. Piper is the exhausted middle sister who finally has her own baby to love, but her four-month-old doesn't sleep through the night, and she feels like a failure. Motherhood comes so easily to others, so why can't it to her? And then there's Regina, the free-spirited youngest who is holding on to something that could implode everyone's comfortable life.
The women snip back and forth at each other until the tension explodes late one night. The women go in separate directions to cool off, believing when morning comes, they will once more start again. However, the morning brings not peace and reconciliation but the discovery of a young woman's body in the lake. Through alternating points and view and dual timelines, I thought it was easy to guess the identity of the victim, but there is more here than meets the eye. This was a fun, totally immersive read that will have you second-guessing ever vacationing with family again. Many thanks to Crooked Lane Books for the early copy. This book is scheduled to publish April 7, 2026.
This was a twisty, explosive thriller that explores family secrets and all the things we desperately try to keep buried. Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina aren't naturally close, but provisions in their mother's will force them to vacation together every year for two weeks at the family's lake house. It's always tense, but this year each sister is bringing baggage that can't be rolled into the house on wheels.
Esme is the controlling older sister who comes across as dominant, cold, and unfeeling, but no one can guess the gut-wrenching secret she's holding on to. She can't confide in her sisters for support for fear they will judge her, so she suffers in silence. Piper is the exhausted middle sister who finally has her own baby to love, but her four-month-old doesn't sleep through the night, and she feels like a failure. Motherhood comes so easily to others, so why can't it to her? And then there's Regina, the free-spirited youngest who is holding on to something that could implode everyone's comfortable life.
The women snip back and forth at each other until the tension explodes late one night. The women go in separate directions to cool off, believing when morning comes, they will once more start again. However, the morning brings not peace and reconciliation but the discovery of a young woman's body in the lake. Through alternating points and view and dual timelines, I thought it was easy to guess the identity of the victim, but there is more here than meets the eye. This was a fun, totally immersive read that will have you second-guessing ever vacationing with family again. Many thanks to Crooked Lane Books for the early copy. This book is scheduled to publish April 7, 2026.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
What a great family drama this was. From the outside everything appears to be beautiful, friendly, loving, but dig even just a little bit under the surface and there's simmering sibling rivalry, secrets, lies and betrayal. A great mix for a fabulous storyline.
And not just siblings, but three sisters, which is even better! Esme, Regina, and Piper share a lavish lakeside property left to them by their parents. The drama is brought to us right from the outset. The story is told primarily from the point of view of the three sisters. We soon realise that there is a lot of friction, they have different personalities, and the pecking order is apparently well established. Then throw into the mix, Alexis, their cousin, who lost her parents at an early age. Her Aunt reluctantly took on the guardianship of Alexi but threw her out of the family home pretty quickly.
All of this underlying tension builds up to a maelstrom of events, emotions and bitter conflict. Especially when a big fight ensues and they go their own ways for the night. The next morning a woman’s body is found in the lake and tensions get worse as a police investigation points the finger at the sister's and their family.
The writing was sharp, fast paced and really drew you into the storyline and characters. The characters jumped off the pages and into my living room as I read this. They were flawed and challenging. My opinion of them kept changing throughout the book, which I really enjoyed. My favourite character turned out to be Piper.
This is an intelligent and well crafted thriller that leans heavily on family relationships, suspicion, intrigue and sibling rivalries. And an ending that I really didn't see coming.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to review this ahead of publication date.
And not just siblings, but three sisters, which is even better! Esme, Regina, and Piper share a lavish lakeside property left to them by their parents. The drama is brought to us right from the outset. The story is told primarily from the point of view of the three sisters. We soon realise that there is a lot of friction, they have different personalities, and the pecking order is apparently well established. Then throw into the mix, Alexis, their cousin, who lost her parents at an early age. Her Aunt reluctantly took on the guardianship of Alexi but threw her out of the family home pretty quickly.
All of this underlying tension builds up to a maelstrom of events, emotions and bitter conflict. Especially when a big fight ensues and they go their own ways for the night. The next morning a woman’s body is found in the lake and tensions get worse as a police investigation points the finger at the sister's and their family.
The writing was sharp, fast paced and really drew you into the storyline and characters. The characters jumped off the pages and into my living room as I read this. They were flawed and challenging. My opinion of them kept changing throughout the book, which I really enjoyed. My favourite character turned out to be Piper.
This is an intelligent and well crafted thriller that leans heavily on family relationships, suspicion, intrigue and sibling rivalries. And an ending that I really didn't see coming.
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for the chance to review this ahead of publication date.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
《4.5⭐️ rounded up to 5⭐️》
Each year, sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina reunite with their families at their remote summer house on Lake George. This year however, the trip is already tense. Esme is hiding the humiliation of her husband's affair, Piper is overwhelmed as a sleep deprived new mother, and Regina is dealing with financial problems that threaten her future. After a heated argument one night, the sisters storm off in different directions. By morning, the lake delivers something far worse than another family fight... a young woman's body floating in the water. As the police investigation closes in on their summer home, the sisters realize the victim may be tied to their past and to the web of secrets they've been desperately hiding. Old resentments, buried family history, and long-held grudges began to surface, and the sisters must confront the possibility that the killer may be someone within their own circle.
This story follows three sisters gathering at their family summer house, each carrying their own emotional baggage. What starts as a tense but normal family getaway quickly spirals when a body turns up and suddenly everyone is looking a little suspicious. The vibes shift fast from "family drama" to "someone here might be a killer". What I loved most was the sister dynamics! The relationships felt messy, complicated, and real. Watching the layers peel back on the secrets everyone had was half the fun. The setting is also perfect. Quiet water and that creeping feeling something isn't right? Perfect! It had that locked room vibe where all the suspects are all circling the same world. Family secrets, betrayal, and a murder investigation? Say less!
Thank you to NetGalley, Ava Roberts, and Crooked Lane Books for both an eARC and physical copy!
Each year, sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina reunite with their families at their remote summer house on Lake George. This year however, the trip is already tense. Esme is hiding the humiliation of her husband's affair, Piper is overwhelmed as a sleep deprived new mother, and Regina is dealing with financial problems that threaten her future. After a heated argument one night, the sisters storm off in different directions. By morning, the lake delivers something far worse than another family fight... a young woman's body floating in the water. As the police investigation closes in on their summer home, the sisters realize the victim may be tied to their past and to the web of secrets they've been desperately hiding. Old resentments, buried family history, and long-held grudges began to surface, and the sisters must confront the possibility that the killer may be someone within their own circle.
This story follows three sisters gathering at their family summer house, each carrying their own emotional baggage. What starts as a tense but normal family getaway quickly spirals when a body turns up and suddenly everyone is looking a little suspicious. The vibes shift fast from "family drama" to "someone here might be a killer". What I loved most was the sister dynamics! The relationships felt messy, complicated, and real. Watching the layers peel back on the secrets everyone had was half the fun. The setting is also perfect. Quiet water and that creeping feeling something isn't right? Perfect! It had that locked room vibe where all the suspects are all circling the same world. Family secrets, betrayal, and a murder investigation? Say less!
Thank you to NetGalley, Ava Roberts, and Crooked Lane Books for both an eARC and physical copy!
Review of advance copy received from Author
"Maybe this year, she and Regina and I can get along. Move forward from the strife that always follows us."
It's official, after reading this, I'm glad I don't have sisters! These three sisters—Esme, Piper, and Regina—are dysfunctional to say the least. While not exactly likable, they're believable and each compelling in their own right. Somewhat estranged, they all stay together, with their families, for two weeks at the summer house left to them by their mother—a period required by her will for them to maintain ownership. Hidden feelings, past history, and personal agendas cause rising tension—and then a woman's body is found in the lake near their property.
With rotating perspectives of the sisters and dual timelines, the short, punchy chapters were easy to fly through with a steady stream of suspense. There are a few additional POVs that provide more intrigue—including someone from the past. The psychological dynamics of the sisters were compelling, especially the role birth order plays in family hierarchy and how it can affect personalities. It's clear 𝘼𝙫𝙖 𝙍𝙤𝙗𝙚𝙧𝙩𝙨' experience and depth of knowledge as a former psychologist come through in her skillful writing.
Between the sisters, their husbands, their children, and additional folks, there's a ton going on; I always enjoy that as there's never a dull moment! Though it wasn't difficult to figure things out, I really enjoyed being a 'fly-on-the-wall' in the lives of these families. If you enjoy toxic family drama, secrets and lies, and karmic revenge, then you'll definitely enjoy 𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗦𝘂𝗺𝗺𝗲𝗿 𝗛𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝗠𝘂𝗿𝗱𝗲𝗿!
____
Thank you Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Books for my gifted copy. All opinons are my own and given voluntarily.
It's official, after reading this, I'm glad I don't have sisters! These three sisters—Esme, Piper, and Regina—are dysfunctional to say the least. While not exactly likable, they're believable and each compelling in their own right. Somewhat estranged, they all stay together, with their families, for two weeks at the summer house left to them by their mother—a period required by her will for them to maintain ownership. Hidden feelings, past history, and personal agendas cause rising tension—and then a woman's body is found in the lake near their property.
With rotating perspectives of the sisters and dual timelines, the short, punchy chapters were easy to fly through with a steady stream of suspense. There are a few additional POVs that provide more intrigue—including someone from the past. The psychological dynamics of the sisters were compelling, especially the role birth order plays in family hierarchy and how it can affect personalities. It's clear 𝘼𝙫𝙖 𝙍𝙤𝙗𝙚𝙧𝙩𝙨' experience and depth of knowledge as a former psychologist come through in her skillful writing.
Between the sisters, their husbands, their children, and additional folks, there's a ton going on; I always enjoy that as there's never a dull moment! Though it wasn't difficult to figure things out, I really enjoyed being a 'fly-on-the-wall' in the lives of these families. If you enjoy toxic family drama, secrets and lies, and karmic revenge, then you'll definitely enjoy 𝗧𝗵𝗲 𝗦𝘂𝗺𝗺𝗲𝗿 𝗛𝗼𝘂𝘀𝗲 𝗠𝘂𝗿𝗱𝗲𝗿!
____
Thank you Ava Roberts and Crooked Lane Books for my gifted copy. All opinons are my own and given voluntarily.
March 10, 2026
It’s the annual visit at the summer house on Lake George, and Esme, Piper, and Regina, show up with their families. Each of the girls have their own secrets. Esme is the older sister. Her husband is a neurosurgeon, so she’s always trying to keep up appearances. Piper is the quiet one that no one notices and everyone walks all over. Regina is the youngest. They don’t always get along. More often than not, they don’t. After a fight one night, they each go their separate ways. Come morning, a body is found in the lake. As the investigation ensues, secrets come to light, and it seems this family is tied to the body in the lake.
I really enjoyed this author! Roberts’ writing is so vivid and it just flows so easily. Roberts easily makes you care about what is happening in the story, which way it’s going to go, and how it’s going to end. The book is told from multiple points of view, told both in the present and the past. One of the reasons that I really enjoy this author’s books is that everything in the book matters. It brings together pieces of the puzzle.
The family dynamics are intricate. It seems like multiple family members could have reason to kill someone, but who is responsible for the body in the lake? Who is the body in the lake? The way that Roberts reveals some of the twists is brilliant. There was one moment that I was so shocked, I gasped!
The ending was particularly ironic. But it was the perfect ending to this book. If you haven’t read this author, please make sure to add some of her books to your TBR. This one will be out in April!
I really enjoyed this author! Roberts’ writing is so vivid and it just flows so easily. Roberts easily makes you care about what is happening in the story, which way it’s going to go, and how it’s going to end. The book is told from multiple points of view, told both in the present and the past. One of the reasons that I really enjoy this author’s books is that everything in the book matters. It brings together pieces of the puzzle.
The family dynamics are intricate. It seems like multiple family members could have reason to kill someone, but who is responsible for the body in the lake? Who is the body in the lake? The way that Roberts reveals some of the twists is brilliant. There was one moment that I was so shocked, I gasped!
The ending was particularly ironic. But it was the perfect ending to this book. If you haven’t read this author, please make sure to add some of her books to your TBR. This one will be out in April!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3.5 stars
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation, as they all have their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. After an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions to cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning, like usual. However, this time, when morning comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake.
A good, drama filled thriller that knows how to hook you in and keep you on your toes the entire time. There is enough mystery on each sister's part to make it impossible to put this down. The writing is so sharp and fun, it makes it so easy to fly though the story; I read it so quickly, dreading having to put it down, and I wanted to do nothing more than to get back to it as soon as possible. The characters feel very real in how flawed and, most of the time, hard to like they are, in a way— they keep messing up, doing things that have you rolling your eyes and wanting to do nothing more than to shake some sense into them, but also you can see where it's coming from, and it makes sense. It's honestly a very fast paced, entertaining read, and I had a great time. My only issue would be that the pacing felt a little weird at times— some bits in the middle felt very dragged and repetitive, while the ending felt very rushed in a way. But, overall, it didn't impact my reading experience all that much.
Many thanks to Crooked Lane Books & NetGalley for the eARC. All opinions are my own.
Sisters Esme, Piper, and Regina go on their annual visit to their summer house on Lake George expecting a tense vacation, as they all have their own families to deal with plus their own secrets to hide. After an ugly fight late one night, the sisters go off in separate directions to cool off and resume the trip like normal the next morning, like usual. However, this time, when morning comes, a young woman’s body is discovered in the lake.
A good, drama filled thriller that knows how to hook you in and keep you on your toes the entire time. There is enough mystery on each sister's part to make it impossible to put this down. The writing is so sharp and fun, it makes it so easy to fly though the story; I read it so quickly, dreading having to put it down, and I wanted to do nothing more than to get back to it as soon as possible. The characters feel very real in how flawed and, most of the time, hard to like they are, in a way— they keep messing up, doing things that have you rolling your eyes and wanting to do nothing more than to shake some sense into them, but also you can see where it's coming from, and it makes sense. It's honestly a very fast paced, entertaining read, and I had a great time. My only issue would be that the pacing felt a little weird at times— some bits in the middle felt very dragged and repetitive, while the ending felt very rushed in a way. But, overall, it didn't impact my reading experience all that much.
Many thanks to Crooked Lane Books & NetGalley for the eARC. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A twisty, engaging, and fun to read murder mystery, set in a gorgeous vacation home in the Adirondacks, and centering on a hugely dysfunctional family.
Sisters Esme (horribly status conscious), Piper (anxious and obsessive) and Regina (cocky and impulsive) are all married, all mothers, and all messed up. Particularly in their relationship with each other. So much so, that their mother, recently deceased, has left them the family lakeside vacation home, but with a caveat — they must spend two weeks every August vacationing in it, together. And that, indeed, is the catch, as these sisters are far from what one might consider as close.
Burdened with secrets, jealousy, competitiveness, and even raw and seething dislike, the sisters have each come to a bad place in their lives, for various reasons, when they find themselves in forced togetherness at their August summer home.
And it’s not long before one secret, refusing to remain long buried, breaches the forefront to stir the pot — in a terrible way — that will ultimately lead to murder.
A terrifically compelling story, which kept this reader hanging on, right to the satisfying and smile-inducing ending. Highly recommended for mystery lovers, and in particular, lovers of character-based plots writhing with families, dysfunction, and of course, murderous intent.
A great big thank you to Netgalley, the author and the publisher for an ARC of this book. All thoughts presented are my own.
(Four and half shiny stars, rounded up)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 128 reviews