Received a free copy from NetGalley in exchange for a review. Spoilers below.
I’ll start this review off by saying that I am very picky about sci-fi dystopian stories. For some reason, I tend to only vibe with a few.
My other disclaimer is that I did not finish this book. I hate DNFing, especially when it’s a book for review, but life is too short to make yourself read things you don’t like.
From the start of the book, I was very nervous about a couple things. I could see it very easily embracing a load of girlbashing and I could it see it easily falling into the “not like other girls trope”. Unfortunately, the book did fall into both traps. I think I’m getting to the point where I’m just a little too old and YA-read to ignore those things while I’m reading.
Not all of it was bad, obviously. I really enjoyed the “perfection details” like the pink kitten and the crystal birds, and how everything in the world was polished and smooth like plastic. That was such a clear visual for me, and the pretty and twinkly aspects of the world lay in stark contrast to Alina’s feelings in it. It was great detailing.
I also really enjoyed the “brainwashing” aspect of Father Sampson’s regime. It really reminded me of “there is no war in Ba Sing Se” and it was truly creepy and effective. I thought that was a great idea, rather than going the death route.
This book also really reminded me of the Uglies series, which kind of made me think that this book felt like that 2010-2015 era of dystopian YA novels where every book was a different take on the genre. I think if it had come out then, it probably would have been quite well received.
I also really wished there were maps of Pria and Carthem because I was very lost a lot of the time. We’re given a lot of street names, distances, and building names, but I would have loved a map so I could put those in context.
A big fault for me as well was the exposition. Everything was exposition and big villain monologuing. Except when I actually needed to understand things like who is Rex? Who is Camden? Is Pria��s world based on science or magic or both? It would be okay if these were presented as mysteries, but Alina doesn’t seem to need more into, so I guess neither does the reader!
I also just didn’t get why Alina was allowed to live out in the world. Why not just put her into permanent sleep as a baby? Or send her to Carthem or prison or something? Why allow her freedom and let others know of her?
Also this line appears as an insult from the boy who’s ~different~ and ~sees past how ugly and gross Alina is~. “You are like all the other girls.” Gross!
Also, I kind of wanted the book to end with Alina in eternal sleep, and then a flash to the rest of Pria in perfection. And it would be all about how these are the kinds of sacrifices and horrors people commit for the “perfect world”. That would be so eerie and poignant. But obviously, that did not happen.
I also absolutely hated the Alina’s change when they entered Carthem.
I was really hoping this wasn’t going to be a “ugly girl becomes pretty thus giving her a sense of self worth” Story. I guess it is.
So, this one is gonna be two stars for me. I think you can just go reread the Uglies series and skip this one.