What do you think?
Rate this book
The Bone Men #1
First Oaths
“We weren’t meant to burn our dead.”
After escaping the cult that nearly destroyed him, Kit Mosel has built a new life. He’s sure that no one in town knows his real name or what he did, until Penwell Oliver appears, desperate for help retrieving his father’s stolen remains from the very cult Kit fled.
Kit knows he should say no, but there's something about Penny he can't refuse.
Together, Penny and Kit plan to infiltrate the cult and earn their trust. Kit knows how to blend in and play their games, but Penny isn’t like him; he’s always been too soft. Too quick to trust. Worse, Penny draws attention from people who would gladly hurt him just to punish Kit.
The deeper they go, the more Kit unravels. Penny isn’t just a liability—he’s a temptation. A reminder of everything Kit thought he didn’t deserve. And in a place where weakness is punished and love is weaponized, wanting each other could cost them both everything.
After escaping the cult that nearly destroyed him, Kit Mosel has built a new life. He’s sure that no one in town knows his real name or what he did, until Penwell Oliver appears, desperate for help retrieving his father’s stolen remains from the very cult Kit fled.
Kit knows he should say no, but there's something about Penny he can't refuse.
Together, Penny and Kit plan to infiltrate the cult and earn their trust. Kit knows how to blend in and play their games, but Penny isn’t like him; he’s always been too soft. Too quick to trust. Worse, Penny draws attention from people who would gladly hurt him just to punish Kit.
The deeper they go, the more Kit unravels. Penny isn’t just a liability—he’s a temptation. A reminder of everything Kit thought he didn’t deserve. And in a place where weakness is punished and love is weaponized, wanting each other could cost them both everything.
370 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 1, 2025
42 people are currently reading
751 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 123 reviews
November 7, 2025
Arc Review: First Oaths (The Bone Men Book 1) by C.J. Tuma & Quinn Cameron
MC:Kit&Penny 4 ⭐
Tropes & tags
🦴Grumpy+Sunshine
🦴Slow Burn
🦴Dystopian
🦴Dark/Cult
🦴Demi Awakening
🦴Virgin MC
🦴Trauma
🦴Guilt/Redemption
It took me a while to really get into this one, I admit. The pacing felt uneven at times, and I wasn’t always sure what the endgame was meant to be. The goal was to find and infiltrate the Bone of Man, but there were so many detours along the way — and before that, they spent quite a bit of time at Pen’s farm doing, well, everything except that.
Their first journey from Kit’s village to Pen’s farm happens entirely off-page, so we miss all the initial talks about the cult, how they planned to approach it, and especially how they actually connected. I really wish we’d seen that part, because it would’ve added a lot of emotional depth to their bond later on. This time on the farm felt right, felt like they belonged, especially Kit who was so eager to help with everything.
That said, I still really enjoyed it. The writing is beautiful, the world feels lived-in, and there’s a strong emotional thread running through the story that pulled me back in every time I got distracted. It’s a slow burn in every sense, but one that rewards patience.
The romance its only begining here, they only kiss, i felt it was a bit once sided, but lets see where this takes us.
It ends on a cliffhanger.It’s not an abrupt mid-scene cut, but the story clearly doesn’t resolve the main conflict. Several key threads — especially regarding Kit, Pen, and the Bone of Man — are left open, and the emotional tension between the leads remains unresolved too. It feels very much like Book 1 of a continuing series, setting up the stakes for what’s to come rather than offering closure.
A strong start to the series — a bit slow paced but deeply engaging, and even with the slow start I'm excited for book 2!
I received a free copy of this book from the authors and am voluntarily leaving a review.
⚠️Author TWs
PTSD/flashbacks of traumatic events
Mild homophobia (not by a main character)
Alcohol consumption and abuse
On page mutilation
❣️Book Safety & Content
Cheating: N/A
OM/OW Drama: No
Sharing: N/A
Third-Act Breakup: No
Role Dynamics: N/A
POV: 1st person (dual)
Format: Duet
Ending: Minor Cliffhanger
Angst Level: Low / Medium
Spice Level: n/a
Communication: Some miscommunication
Pining:Mutual
MC:Kit&Penny 4 ⭐
Tropes & tags
🦴Grumpy+Sunshine
🦴Slow Burn
🦴Dystopian
🦴Dark/Cult
🦴Demi Awakening
🦴Virgin MC
🦴Trauma
🦴Guilt/Redemption
It took me a while to really get into this one, I admit. The pacing felt uneven at times, and I wasn’t always sure what the endgame was meant to be. The goal was to find and infiltrate the Bone of Man, but there were so many detours along the way — and before that, they spent quite a bit of time at Pen’s farm doing, well, everything except that.
Their first journey from Kit’s village to Pen’s farm happens entirely off-page, so we miss all the initial talks about the cult, how they planned to approach it, and especially how they actually connected. I really wish we’d seen that part, because it would’ve added a lot of emotional depth to their bond later on. This time on the farm felt right, felt like they belonged, especially Kit who was so eager to help with everything.
That said, I still really enjoyed it. The writing is beautiful, the world feels lived-in, and there’s a strong emotional thread running through the story that pulled me back in every time I got distracted. It’s a slow burn in every sense, but one that rewards patience.
The romance its only begining here, they only kiss, i felt it was a bit once sided, but lets see where this takes us.
It ends on a cliffhanger.It’s not an abrupt mid-scene cut, but the story clearly doesn’t resolve the main conflict. Several key threads — especially regarding Kit, Pen, and the Bone of Man — are left open, and the emotional tension between the leads remains unresolved too. It feels very much like Book 1 of a continuing series, setting up the stakes for what’s to come rather than offering closure.
A strong start to the series — a bit slow paced but deeply engaging, and even with the slow start I'm excited for book 2!
I received a free copy of this book from the authors and am voluntarily leaving a review.
⚠️Author TWs
PTSD/flashbacks of traumatic events
Mild homophobia (not by a main character)
Alcohol consumption and abuse
On page mutilation
❣️Book Safety & Content
Cheating: N/A
OM/OW Drama: No
Sharing: N/A
Third-Act Breakup: No
Role Dynamics: N/A
POV: 1st person (dual)
Format: Duet
Ending: Minor Cliffhanger
Angst Level: Low / Medium
Spice Level: n/a
Communication: Some miscommunication
Pining:Mutual
September 2, 2025
How do you make a death cult cozy? Idk but these authors did that. This was so atmospheric, I swear I could see the world through a blue Twilight-esque film.
Very hoahoahoa vibes. But make it gay.
I love these boys. I can’t wait for the sequel. I really enjoyed everything about this. The slow burn, the characters, the world, the plot. I’m invested.
The pacing was a little off in the last 20%, and Kit seemed to change his tone about Penny real quick. Other than that, perfection.
Very hoahoahoa vibes. But make it gay.
I love these boys. I can’t wait for the sequel. I really enjoyed everything about this. The slow burn, the characters, the world, the plot. I’m invested.
The pacing was a little off in the last 20%, and Kit seemed to change his tone about Penny real quick. Other than that, perfection.
September 17, 2025
With the setting of a cult I expected a gritty and dark book but this book was so cozy at times.
Kit and Penny are such loveable characters. Penny deserves all the good things in the world and I wish I could wrap him a blanket and protect him so he could stay his naive and innocent self. And Kit... I think a hug would help him sometimes.
The pacing slowed a bit toward the end, and I couldn’t tell if it was because I was impatient for the first oath to happen or if the story itself eased up.
Either way, I’m hooked and so excited to see where their story goes next.
tropes:
slow burn
grumpy mmc
Forced proximity
caretaking
spice:
/
info:
names: Kit & Penny
age: 30 & 22
pov: dual, first person
break up: no
Kit and Penny are such loveable characters. Penny deserves all the good things in the world and I wish I could wrap him a blanket and protect him so he could stay his naive and innocent self. And Kit... I think a hug would help him sometimes.
The pacing slowed a bit toward the end, and I couldn’t tell if it was because I was impatient for the first oath to happen or if the story itself eased up.
Either way, I’m hooked and so excited to see where their story goes next.
tropes:
slow burn
grumpy mmc
Forced proximity
caretaking
spice:
/
info:
names: Kit & Penny
age: 30 & 22
pov: dual, first person
break up: no
August 28, 2025
I am utterly invested. It ended too soon for me, I wish book two was already out!
This is a suuuuper slow burn romance with creepy cult vibes as well as super cozy vibes. I never thought I would be so in to reading about a character baking.
Despite the fact that the stakes are high, this book is still delightfully cozy and slowly paced in the in-between spaces. The deep bond that forms between the main characters Kit and Penny through the mundane acts of life gave so much contrasting substance to the traumas they also hold each other through. A perfect balance.
The trauma these two characters have been through and held each other through wrenched open my heart. Penny and Kit felt so real to me that I felt anger towards all those that harmed them.
I will be making lavender shortbread while I wait for book 2!!
This is a suuuuper slow burn romance with creepy cult vibes as well as super cozy vibes. I never thought I would be so in to reading about a character baking.
Despite the fact that the stakes are high, this book is still delightfully cozy and slowly paced in the in-between spaces. The deep bond that forms between the main characters Kit and Penny through the mundane acts of life gave so much contrasting substance to the traumas they also hold each other through. A perfect balance.
The trauma these two characters have been through and held each other through wrenched open my heart. Penny and Kit felt so real to me that I felt anger towards all those that harmed them.
I will be making lavender shortbread while I wait for book 2!!
October 14, 2025
So far, I’ve read all of Cameron Quinn’s work with great pleasure, so when I got the chance to read her newest book, I didn’t hesitate. Since I absolutely love her writing style, I was a bit worried that it might ‘clash’ with someone else’s, as this book was written by two authors, but it was hard to tell that it had been written by two different people.
Once again, the authors completely enchanted me with their characters: I really liked both of them — they have depth, and they complement each other beautifully. The slow burn romance is well developed, and I also found the relationships with the side characters interesting. However, I did find it hard to understand why all those lovely side characters would want to be part of such a dark cult — their motivations weren’t really explored. The story also has a slower pace than I usually prefer, but the interactions between Penny and Kit more than make up for that. It’s a heartwarming story, though it definitely has a darker edge as well. I’m looking forward to the sequel!
Once again, the authors completely enchanted me with their characters: I really liked both of them — they have depth, and they complement each other beautifully. The slow burn romance is well developed, and I also found the relationships with the side characters interesting. However, I did find it hard to understand why all those lovely side characters would want to be part of such a dark cult — their motivations weren’t really explored. The story also has a slower pace than I usually prefer, but the interactions between Penny and Kit more than make up for that. It’s a heartwarming story, though it definitely has a darker edge as well. I’m looking forward to the sequel!
September 18, 2025
This is the perfect example of a fall vibes book, through and through. Cozy, slow paced and a little creepy, it was easy to get lost in and to look forward to sitting down with every chance I got.
Even though these two are out to do some pretty macabre stuff, [infiltrate a death cult, get some bones, ??? [redacted] ;) ] this first entry into the Bone Men series concentrates more on our two main characters learning to trust one another. To let each other in, which one seems to have a lot more issues with than the other.
Kit and Penny are both different flavours of sweet - Kit, prickly and closed off, just waiting to be cracked and pried open like the shell of a pecan, and Penny, with his heart on his sleeve and his head in the clouds. I have to say, Penny's dialogue made me laugh out loud more than once, and I treasured how silly he was. He spends most of this book pining and nesting, and I love this for him. The romance here is definitely a slow burn, though, so don't expect any spice. (Unless we're talking pumpkin spice!! Because of... the baking... you know. Ahhh, I tried lol :( )
While I did enjoy the domestic, fantasy village setting and a glimpse of what life could be like for Kit and Penny at the end of it all, it was almost *too* idyllic for me. It was charming and warm to read, but for all that we spend a good deal of time stressing the horrible things that the cult (and the people in it) have done, you really don't see much evidence of any of that. There's a lot of vague allusions to horrible things going on, and a few definite incidents, but the cult itself doesn't seem to have any real teeth. I'm hoping that we get more of a glimpse into that in subsequent books. I really want to know why all of these lovely people we're meeting are willing to do what they do.
Still, this was a pleasure to read. If you want to dig into something that won't stress you out too much, but will definitely put you in the mood for spooky season (just around the corner!!), this is the cozy book for you.
Even though these two are out to do some pretty macabre stuff, [infiltrate a death cult, get some bones, ??? [redacted] ;) ] this first entry into the Bone Men series concentrates more on our two main characters learning to trust one another. To let each other in, which one seems to have a lot more issues with than the other.
Kit and Penny are both different flavours of sweet - Kit, prickly and closed off, just waiting to be cracked and pried open like the shell of a pecan, and Penny, with his heart on his sleeve and his head in the clouds. I have to say, Penny's dialogue made me laugh out loud more than once, and I treasured how silly he was. He spends most of this book pining and nesting, and I love this for him. The romance here is definitely a slow burn, though, so don't expect any spice. (Unless we're talking pumpkin spice!! Because of... the baking... you know. Ahhh, I tried lol :( )
While I did enjoy the domestic, fantasy village setting and a glimpse of what life could be like for Kit and Penny at the end of it all, it was almost *too* idyllic for me. It was charming and warm to read, but for all that we spend a good deal of time stressing the horrible things that the cult (and the people in it) have done, you really don't see much evidence of any of that. There's a lot of vague allusions to horrible things going on, and a few definite incidents, but the cult itself doesn't seem to have any real teeth. I'm hoping that we get more of a glimpse into that in subsequent books. I really want to know why all of these lovely people we're meeting are willing to do what they do.
Still, this was a pleasure to read. If you want to dig into something that won't stress you out too much, but will definitely put you in the mood for spooky season (just around the corner!!), this is the cozy book for you.
September 4, 2025
Kit carries the heavy weight of his past involvement with the Bone Men, and in an effort to atone, he takes a dangerous step—helping Penny recover his father’s body by infiltrating the cult. Kit’s history is dark, shaped by a father who forced him into unspeakable acts, and that guilt runs deep in every choice he makes.
Penny, meanwhile, lives under the shadow of his half-brother Merrick, who takes credit for Penny’s hard work on the family farm but refuses the responsibility. Penny doesn’t even want the farm—it was entrusted to him by his father—but that doesn’t ease the constant tension between the brothers. Merrick has secrets, and the more they’re revealed, the heavier the story becomes.
There was also a twist part way through that caught me completely off guard, and it pushed the story in a direction I didn’t expect.
One thing that really struck me while reading, was how much grief ties Kit and Penny together. They’re each mourning in their own way, but you can feel how they recognize that ache in one another. That aspect I found really beautiful.
This book is a slow-burning, cozy death cult mystery romance—yes, all of those things at once, and yes, it works. The blend of grief, tenderness, and creeping dread is unlike anything I’ve read before. And there’s so much lore waiting to be uncovered. I’m ridiculously excited for the next book because I can feel how deep this story runs.
Penny, meanwhile, lives under the shadow of his half-brother Merrick, who takes credit for Penny’s hard work on the family farm but refuses the responsibility. Penny doesn’t even want the farm—it was entrusted to him by his father—but that doesn’t ease the constant tension between the brothers. Merrick has secrets, and the more they’re revealed, the heavier the story becomes.
There was also a twist part way through that caught me completely off guard, and it pushed the story in a direction I didn’t expect.
One thing that really struck me while reading, was how much grief ties Kit and Penny together. They’re each mourning in their own way, but you can feel how they recognize that ache in one another. That aspect I found really beautiful.
This book is a slow-burning, cozy death cult mystery romance—yes, all of those things at once, and yes, it works. The blend of grief, tenderness, and creeping dread is unlike anything I’ve read before. And there’s so much lore waiting to be uncovered. I’m ridiculously excited for the next book because I can feel how deep this story runs.
September 22, 2025
This was an EPIC read! Wow, I don’t know where the time went, I spent the whole day reading this and I was completely immersed. Fantastic world building, everything is perfectly paced, introduced to add layers to the myth and lore of the characters lives and the legends of the Bone Men. The story is full of adventure, a righteous quest, heroes a tad worn maybe not perfect, battling the burdens of their pasts, their families curses but with enough resilience and fire to right the wrongs they see. You want to rally with them.. goosebumps
I loved Kit and Penny, epitome of grumpy sunshine, soft and prickly, even and hot tempered. They are characters that truly invite you along, characters that make you curious to want to know them.
I also loved Sayla and Rosie, Thom and Redington and even Levitt, I’m not sure how I feel about Violette but I do sincerely hate Merrick, I hope the fates heap misfortune on him!!!
I was dreading the cliffhanger but it isn’t bad at all, sort of a sweet pause in the story which is a slow slow burn the romance builds very gently in this one. I am dying for the next book to see where these two go in the dynamic now and also the overall plot.
I loved Kit and Penny, epitome of grumpy sunshine, soft and prickly, even and hot tempered. They are characters that truly invite you along, characters that make you curious to want to know them.
I also loved Sayla and Rosie, Thom and Redington and even Levitt, I’m not sure how I feel about Violette but I do sincerely hate Merrick, I hope the fates heap misfortune on him!!!
I was dreading the cliffhanger but it isn’t bad at all, sort of a sweet pause in the story which is a slow slow burn the romance builds very gently in this one. I am dying for the next book to see where these two go in the dynamic now and also the overall plot.
September 3, 2025
Finding love in the midst of destroying a cult.... yes yes yes.... a slow burn romance that centres on finding oneself, loving oneself, opening up to others, and letting others love you, despite the traumas suffered.
September 29, 2025
I was blessed to read an Advanced Reader Copy of First Oaths and all opinions are my own.
Kit Mosel has been enjoying a life of solitude for years now as the blacksmith in a town that doesn't condemn him for his past. When Penny Oliver shows up at Kit's door, he thinks it will be easy to scare him away, but Penny is more stubborn than he could ever guess. Penny is determined to get his deceased father's bones back, and he needs Kit to lead him to the Bone Men, the cult who stole them. Kit always knew he would need to go back to take the cult down, but bringing Penny with him is a gamble. Clumsy and sweet, Penny isn't made for the horrors of the Bone Men. And yet Kit finds he enjoys Penny's company, and indeed, Penny is far braver than Kit gave him credit for. But getting back into the fold is more complicated than Kit thought it would be, and there are enemies lurking in the corners that he didn't bargain for. Penny is charmed by the bright facade of the town and people there, blissfully ignorant of the horrors awaiting them. And on top of it all is an irresistible pull that neither can resist. Kit is determined to protect Penny at all costs, but his secrets could get them both killed, and he knows they aren't safe here. Penny always sees the good in people, in Kit. Can he convince Penny that he's the type of man Penny believes in, or will his past and his mission to bring down the Bone Men destroy everything good between them before it has a chance to grow?
This book has been a wild ride. I didn't know what to expect, but I enjoyed every minute of the journey. I have really enjoyed Kit and his brand of gruff loner. He doesn't really need anyone and has a hard time accepting kindness. But I loved that he is determined to right his wrongs. I am glad he hates every second of being back with the Bone Men. And I absolutely love the way he is with Penny. He is accepting and affectionate in his own way, grateful for Penny's company and supportive of his art. I love that he never let's anyone put Penny down, not even himself. Kit is sweet under all that grumpiness. I really, really loved Penny. He is a steak of sunshine in the dreary darkness of the cult and everything weighing on Kit. I love that he sees the best in people and tries his best even when it's hard. I love that he brings brightness into Kit's life. They are kind of opposites, but I really enjoyed how they are together. And I love that they lean on each other when things start to get hard.
I absolutely loved the world building in this book. I was sucked in from the beginning. The Bone Men and their mission are creepy. The Oaths are horrific. And I haaaaate the Shroud Warden. I am suspicious of everyone except Kit and Penny, and I can't wait to see what else awaits them.
The banter is really excellent, too. Penny is sassy and Kit is straight to the point. I love that Penny is so possessive of Kit and that he can be a little petty. And I love that Kit always puts Penny first. The pacing was great. I was never bored. I even enjoyed the slowest of slow burns in this book! And the mini cliffhanger. How could we leave it at that?!
Overall I am caught hook, line, and sinker. The prose is beautifully written, and I really enjoyed the buildup in this book. There is so much that still has to happen, and I can't wait to get my hands on the next book to find out what happens next! 5/5 🌟
Kit Mosel has been enjoying a life of solitude for years now as the blacksmith in a town that doesn't condemn him for his past. When Penny Oliver shows up at Kit's door, he thinks it will be easy to scare him away, but Penny is more stubborn than he could ever guess. Penny is determined to get his deceased father's bones back, and he needs Kit to lead him to the Bone Men, the cult who stole them. Kit always knew he would need to go back to take the cult down, but bringing Penny with him is a gamble. Clumsy and sweet, Penny isn't made for the horrors of the Bone Men. And yet Kit finds he enjoys Penny's company, and indeed, Penny is far braver than Kit gave him credit for. But getting back into the fold is more complicated than Kit thought it would be, and there are enemies lurking in the corners that he didn't bargain for. Penny is charmed by the bright facade of the town and people there, blissfully ignorant of the horrors awaiting them. And on top of it all is an irresistible pull that neither can resist. Kit is determined to protect Penny at all costs, but his secrets could get them both killed, and he knows they aren't safe here. Penny always sees the good in people, in Kit. Can he convince Penny that he's the type of man Penny believes in, or will his past and his mission to bring down the Bone Men destroy everything good between them before it has a chance to grow?
This book has been a wild ride. I didn't know what to expect, but I enjoyed every minute of the journey. I have really enjoyed Kit and his brand of gruff loner. He doesn't really need anyone and has a hard time accepting kindness. But I loved that he is determined to right his wrongs. I am glad he hates every second of being back with the Bone Men. And I absolutely love the way he is with Penny. He is accepting and affectionate in his own way, grateful for Penny's company and supportive of his art. I love that he never let's anyone put Penny down, not even himself. Kit is sweet under all that grumpiness. I really, really loved Penny. He is a steak of sunshine in the dreary darkness of the cult and everything weighing on Kit. I love that he sees the best in people and tries his best even when it's hard. I love that he brings brightness into Kit's life. They are kind of opposites, but I really enjoyed how they are together. And I love that they lean on each other when things start to get hard.
I absolutely loved the world building in this book. I was sucked in from the beginning. The Bone Men and their mission are creepy. The Oaths are horrific. And I haaaaate the Shroud Warden. I am suspicious of everyone except Kit and Penny, and I can't wait to see what else awaits them.
The banter is really excellent, too. Penny is sassy and Kit is straight to the point. I love that Penny is so possessive of Kit and that he can be a little petty. And I love that Kit always puts Penny first. The pacing was great. I was never bored. I even enjoyed the slowest of slow burns in this book! And the mini cliffhanger. How could we leave it at that?!
Overall I am caught hook, line, and sinker. The prose is beautifully written, and I really enjoyed the buildup in this book. There is so much that still has to happen, and I can't wait to get my hands on the next book to find out what happens next! 5/5 🌟
October 3, 2025
Okay, this book is the slowest of slow burns. A simple “oh, I think I fancy you” at 93%?! Alright, Tuma and Cameron—I’ll ride this one out with you. You had me hooked, and then you left me on a cliffhanger too 😭
I absolutely LOVE Kit and Penny. My two broken boy babies. Family can be messy and rough, but I’m so excited to see them slowly build one of their own together.
Yes, this book involves a cult—death and bones to be exact—but somehow it still feels cozy? How does that even make sense?! Idk, but I love it.
I’m so ready to see what happens next.
I absolutely LOVE Kit and Penny. My two broken boy babies. Family can be messy and rough, but I’m so excited to see them slowly build one of their own together.
Yes, this book involves a cult—death and bones to be exact—but somehow it still feels cozy? How does that even make sense?! Idk, but I love it.
I’m so ready to see what happens next.
September 11, 2025
Thanks so much to the authors for sending me an ARC for this!!
Im so invested into Penny and Kit and their story. I cannot wait for the second book to be available for me to read because MAN THIS WAS A SLOW BURN and i need more of them STAT
I adore them with all my heart and why must they be getting hurt that's very sad :(
The whole topic of trying to bring down a cult from the inside and having to deal with the cruelty that comes with having to be part of said cult is really morbidly fascinating to read to me and definitely hurt my little heart a few times <\3
Super excited to see where this story goes with the next book and if there will be more than 2 books (i don't know how many are planned but I'm here for the whole journey!)
Im so invested into Penny and Kit and their story. I cannot wait for the second book to be available for me to read because MAN THIS WAS A SLOW BURN and i need more of them STAT
I adore them with all my heart and why must they be getting hurt that's very sad :(
The whole topic of trying to bring down a cult from the inside and having to deal with the cruelty that comes with having to be part of said cult is really morbidly fascinating to read to me and definitely hurt my little heart a few times <\3
Super excited to see where this story goes with the next book and if there will be more than 2 books (i don't know how many are planned but I'm here for the whole journey!)
October 8, 2025
4'5🌟
повторила свою помилку з сорсері енд смол меджик і почала коузі гей книжкову серію онлі з однією написаною частиною (з плюсів вже є приблизні дати виходу інших частин)
i don't have anything bad to say really, можливо воно ту мач козі і зеро токсісіті. вони рішають кожну свою сітуейшн словами через рот прям зразу як вона відбувається 🙂↕️. exited to read the next one already 🤭
повторила свою помилку з сорсері енд смол меджик і почала коузі гей книжкову серію онлі з однією написаною частиною (з плюсів вже є приблизні дати виходу інших частин)
i don't have anything bad to say really, можливо воно ту мач козі і зеро токсісіті. вони рішають кожну свою сітуейшн словами через рот прям зразу як вона відбувається 🙂↕️. exited to read the next one already 🤭
September 12, 2025
Thank you for the opportunity to read an ARC of this book.
What an amazing read! I was absolutely enamoured with the characters, and felt my love for them blossom as theirs did for each other.
The character development was perfect, and they felt genuine, believable and complex. I am thoroughly invested in the plot and I'm eager to see how the story advances!
What an amazing read! I was absolutely enamoured with the characters, and felt my love for them blossom as theirs did for each other.
The character development was perfect, and they felt genuine, believable and complex. I am thoroughly invested in the plot and I'm eager to see how the story advances!
September 9, 2025
Cozy fall story but make it a death cult
September 28, 2025
Cozy trauma bonding while infiltrating a cult. ✅
The slow burn is real in this one, but the character development makes up for that one. Kit & Penny are the perfect grumpy/sunshine. This is the first book in this new The Bone Men Series and I'm fully invested in their growing relationship and how they take down a cult that is the reason for so much if their trauma & grief. This ends on a HFN, but I'm excited to continue their journey to see them find their HEA.
One of my favorite quotes:
“You see good in everyone, Penny, and I envy you that. But you don’t know the world like I do. You haven’t seen its darker side. I wish you didn’t have to.” -Kit
The slow burn is real in this one, but the character development makes up for that one. Kit & Penny are the perfect grumpy/sunshine. This is the first book in this new The Bone Men Series and I'm fully invested in their growing relationship and how they take down a cult that is the reason for so much if their trauma & grief. This ends on a HFN, but I'm excited to continue their journey to see them find their HEA.
One of my favorite quotes:
“You see good in everyone, Penny, and I envy you that. But you don’t know the world like I do. You haven’t seen its darker side. I wish you didn’t have to.” -Kit
September 5, 2025
Ahhhh! I’m so excited I was able to be an ARC reader for this book because it is SO GOOD! I couldn’t put it down to function as an adult 😅
The storyline is so unique, and I loooooove a good slow burn. No spice in this but it wasn’t needed!! The yearning and the little touches, the uncertainty and new feelings…ahh! So good! I cannot wait for number two!
The storyline is so unique, and I loooooove a good slow burn. No spice in this but it wasn’t needed!! The yearning and the little touches, the uncertainty and new feelings…ahh! So good! I cannot wait for number two!
August 29, 2025
The slowest burn you’ll never want to let go of. Kit and Penny are the perfect grumpy/sunshine match, backed by a cast of side characters that make the world even richer. The first oath is rough, and with the promise of a gruesome second and downright terrifying third still to come, the stakes are set sky-high. Penny shines with determination, Kit makes you wait but delivers in the end, and together they’ll keep you hooked from page one. An epic start to a series I can’t wait to keep following — thank you CJ Tuma and Quinn Cameron for the ride.
October 2, 2025
This book sucks you in from the start, and you find yourself staying up until after two in the morning trying to finish it. C.J. and Quinn really brought to life the two main characters, Kit and Penny, and I can empathize with both of them about feeling inadequate because of the things people close to you say to your face.
I enjoyed how the talkative Penny pulls Kit out of his darkness and how Kit tries to build Penny up. This book had me rooting for the two from the start and I can not wait for the rest of this series!
I enjoyed how the talkative Penny pulls Kit out of his darkness and how Kit tries to build Penny up. This book had me rooting for the two from the start and I can not wait for the rest of this series!
August 26, 2025
This book has a fascinating take on cults and deity worship.
Kit is a solitary man who narrowly escaped from a terrible childhood.
His past was brought back to bear when Penny shows up at his door requesting help in retrieving the body of his recently deceased father.
This quest leads both of them into the death cult that Kit had escaped from years ago.
This story has fascinating world building and both MCs are flawed but likeable.
This is a slow burn book with very little spice but this will likely change with the sequel. This book ends with a mostly HFN.
Kit is a solitary man who narrowly escaped from a terrible childhood.
His past was brought back to bear when Penny shows up at his door requesting help in retrieving the body of his recently deceased father.
This quest leads both of them into the death cult that Kit had escaped from years ago.
This story has fascinating world building and both MCs are flawed but likeable.
This is a slow burn book with very little spice but this will likely change with the sequel. This book ends with a mostly HFN.
October 8, 2025
A book about a death cult shouldn't be this cozy, I have zero doubts that if one of these characters showed up to recruit me, I'd fall for it way too easily. Sure I might be a bit put off by the bones and branding and you know, it being some kind of death cult, but then there's also a small village with kinda sweet villagers who bake bread and don't let strangers wander in? I mean, how bad could it be? (hello cult leaders, don't try to recruit me, I'd be very bad at everything I promise)
Anyway, where to actually begin this review? I don't even know. It was so good, that I'd like to quote the whole thing and be done with it, but you know, then you might as well just read the book yourself instead (which you should anyway).
So we have Kit, and Penny, and a cult they want to destroy. Kit who has been told over and over he's not good enough, and Penny who is feeling like he's failed his family once again. At first glance, they seem like complete opposites. The grumpy guy living alone not wanting to be bothered by anyone, and the chatty, warm, friendly young man who smiles at everyone and who is bound to drive our grumpy darling mad before the story even has time to properly start.
Kit, who sees danger and enemies everywhere, who knows how cruel the world can be. And Penny, who wants to see the best in people, despite knowing not everyone is as kind as he is.
"Penny was too earnest to be a liar, and I hated that I had to forge him into one."
The perfect setup, isn't it?
But then they start to get to know each other, and they get to find out that they aren't so different after all.
“You and I are alike, in more ways than I realized. We’ve both endured suffering and come out of it new.”
To infiltrate the cult they will need to go through things that no man should have to endure, and while Kit knows what awaits them, he doesn't tell Penny right away. To begin with he decides to use Penny as a way to be welcomed back despite being gone for so long, but as time goes and things shift between them, Kit knows what he's doing might be unforgivable.
"He’d come seeking an easy answer, a quick solution, and instead, he followed me like a sheep to slaughter."
The deeper they get into the grasp of the cult, the more dangerous it will be. How much will what they will have to go through change them? And what will such a cruel world do to a gentle soul like Penny? Will Kit be able to leave it all behind once again, or will this ruin him forever?
"If I lost my soul in the process, it was a small price to pay to save the world."
So what did I think of this book?
Well. I spent a lot of it crying, meaning I also spent a lot of time spamming the poor authors with my updates on Instagram. Who will end up on their mute list for next release? Zarlina. No doubt. (No, these authors are lovely. Really lovely. They care so much about their readers and that itself is such a wonderful trait. They calmed my anxiety over being late with this review in such sweet ways, I almost didn't even panic the last few times I tagged them lol)
Anyway;
The story is full of pain, angst, danger. The characters need the cult members to trust them while they also need to make sure not to lose themselves in the process. And I'm already worried for where this will lead, especially as they start making friends with the villagers who they will one day have to betray. Or will they save them? I believe it can be messy, and I'm so here for it.
I spent so much time being in pain for both Kit and Penny, and when I read the part of them taking the first oath I had to pause just to sob my damn heart out for a bit. And when one certain character started to try to make Penny believe his awful words about him I wanted to throw the book in the lake. Which would have been bad because I read on my kindle and those are expensive. And also then I wouldn't have been able to finish it and read about Kit being an absolute darling making the pain ease a little.
At times I wanted to scream in frustration, AND delight. Because some parts were so brilliant it almost took my breath away. You know when words are so beautiful you just need to sit there and stare for a bit? Yeah, that was me. A lot.
And chapter 16? I was at work, doing the night shift where everyone in the building but me were asleep, and I wanted to literally yell a I KNEW IT, because while I saw it coming, it was so perfectly laid out. Stunning. I was so happy. Not because it was a happy part of the story, but because there's just something about the way some authors write those scenes that makes me proud over someone I've never even met, and this was one of them.
Perfection.
Anyway, I'm rambling a lot. Writing reviews clearly isn't my strongest suit. I don't think you can learn anything from what I'm trying to say, so let's just get to the part where I tell you to read this book because you will not regret it for a second. It was such a gorgeous read and I already can't wait for the next one. Only downside of starting a series early, now I have to wait for the rest, and I already miss the characters so much, I don't know how to stand it.
Read this book. You won't regret it.
Anyway, where to actually begin this review? I don't even know. It was so good, that I'd like to quote the whole thing and be done with it, but you know, then you might as well just read the book yourself instead (which you should anyway).
So we have Kit, and Penny, and a cult they want to destroy. Kit who has been told over and over he's not good enough, and Penny who is feeling like he's failed his family once again. At first glance, they seem like complete opposites. The grumpy guy living alone not wanting to be bothered by anyone, and the chatty, warm, friendly young man who smiles at everyone and who is bound to drive our grumpy darling mad before the story even has time to properly start.
Kit, who sees danger and enemies everywhere, who knows how cruel the world can be. And Penny, who wants to see the best in people, despite knowing not everyone is as kind as he is.
"Penny was too earnest to be a liar, and I hated that I had to forge him into one."
The perfect setup, isn't it?
But then they start to get to know each other, and they get to find out that they aren't so different after all.
“You and I are alike, in more ways than I realized. We’ve both endured suffering and come out of it new.”
To infiltrate the cult they will need to go through things that no man should have to endure, and while Kit knows what awaits them, he doesn't tell Penny right away. To begin with he decides to use Penny as a way to be welcomed back despite being gone for so long, but as time goes and things shift between them, Kit knows what he's doing might be unforgivable.
"He’d come seeking an easy answer, a quick solution, and instead, he followed me like a sheep to slaughter."
The deeper they get into the grasp of the cult, the more dangerous it will be. How much will what they will have to go through change them? And what will such a cruel world do to a gentle soul like Penny? Will Kit be able to leave it all behind once again, or will this ruin him forever?
"If I lost my soul in the process, it was a small price to pay to save the world."
So what did I think of this book?
Well. I spent a lot of it crying, meaning I also spent a lot of time spamming the poor authors with my updates on Instagram. Who will end up on their mute list for next release? Zarlina. No doubt. (No, these authors are lovely. Really lovely. They care so much about their readers and that itself is such a wonderful trait. They calmed my anxiety over being late with this review in such sweet ways, I almost didn't even panic the last few times I tagged them lol)
Anyway;
The story is full of pain, angst, danger. The characters need the cult members to trust them while they also need to make sure not to lose themselves in the process. And I'm already worried for where this will lead, especially as they start making friends with the villagers who they will one day have to betray. Or will they save them? I believe it can be messy, and I'm so here for it.
I spent so much time being in pain for both Kit and Penny, and when I read the part of them taking the first oath I had to pause just to sob my damn heart out for a bit. And when one certain character started to try to make Penny believe his awful words about him I wanted to throw the book in the lake. Which would have been bad because I read on my kindle and those are expensive. And also then I wouldn't have been able to finish it and read about Kit being an absolute darling making the pain ease a little.
At times I wanted to scream in frustration, AND delight. Because some parts were so brilliant it almost took my breath away. You know when words are so beautiful you just need to sit there and stare for a bit? Yeah, that was me. A lot.
And chapter 16? I was at work, doing the night shift where everyone in the building but me were asleep, and I wanted to literally yell a I KNEW IT, because while I saw it coming, it was so perfectly laid out. Stunning. I was so happy. Not because it was a happy part of the story, but because there's just something about the way some authors write those scenes that makes me proud over someone I've never even met, and this was one of them.
Perfection.
Anyway, I'm rambling a lot. Writing reviews clearly isn't my strongest suit. I don't think you can learn anything from what I'm trying to say, so let's just get to the part where I tell you to read this book because you will not regret it for a second. It was such a gorgeous read and I already can't wait for the next one. Only downside of starting a series early, now I have to wait for the rest, and I already miss the characters so much, I don't know how to stand it.
Read this book. You won't regret it.
September 15, 2025
I was provided with a free e-copy of the book by the author for review. All thoughts and opinions are my own. Thanks, you for this!
This book felt really short, I wants more!
Kit just wants to live alone in peace, after escape the Bone men, a cult where he grew up.
He pretty much keeps for himself and stays in an isolated house until a young man, Penny comes knocking at his door, asking for help and information about the cult, to retrieve his father’s body back.
Kit closes the door to his face and tells him to leave, but he soon finds out that Penny is quite determined. He realizes that this is the perfect opportunity to take down the cult once and for all.
The two men infiltrated the Bone men, Kit pretending to be who he once was, but is still a shadow of his father. Penny also found out some secrets about his own family.
Kit & Penny slowly became closer, since they only have each other to rely on. Penny sees the good in him (he also have a crush on the older man), and Kit defends him against the other, making him realize he is worth fighting for. The young man has a low self-esteem, see himself as a fool, a failure and a burden for his family.
The bone men are quite mysterious, while some of the members seems friendly, their rituals are brutal and dangerous, to become a full member, oaths need to be taken where a lot of apprentices don’t survive. They are worshipper of Eeus, a dark God and believe that pain is part of their faith, they are also bodies snatchers. Penny is a little bit naïve and see the good in people, while Kit doesn’t trust any of them.
I am curious to find out more about the other oaths and more about the Bone men. Also looking forward to the development of the romance between Kit and Penny, it is on the slow burn side but is really sweet.
This book felt really short, I wants more!
Kit just wants to live alone in peace, after escape the Bone men, a cult where he grew up.
He pretty much keeps for himself and stays in an isolated house until a young man, Penny comes knocking at his door, asking for help and information about the cult, to retrieve his father’s body back.
Kit closes the door to his face and tells him to leave, but he soon finds out that Penny is quite determined. He realizes that this is the perfect opportunity to take down the cult once and for all.
The two men infiltrated the Bone men, Kit pretending to be who he once was, but is still a shadow of his father. Penny also found out some secrets about his own family.
Kit & Penny slowly became closer, since they only have each other to rely on. Penny sees the good in him (he also have a crush on the older man), and Kit defends him against the other, making him realize he is worth fighting for. The young man has a low self-esteem, see himself as a fool, a failure and a burden for his family.
The bone men are quite mysterious, while some of the members seems friendly, their rituals are brutal and dangerous, to become a full member, oaths need to be taken where a lot of apprentices don’t survive. They are worshipper of Eeus, a dark God and believe that pain is part of their faith, they are also bodies snatchers. Penny is a little bit naïve and see the good in people, while Kit doesn’t trust any of them.
I am curious to find out more about the other oaths and more about the Bone men. Also looking forward to the development of the romance between Kit and Penny, it is on the slow burn side but is really sweet.
September 26, 2025
This book has been one of my most anticipated reads for October, and it did not disappoint. Somehow the authors have made a book about a scary death cult have such a cozy vibe that leaves you feeling warm and fuzzy? I really lost myself in this fictional world, and I’m so happy that we get three more books to continue this journey.
“Everyone has scars. Some are more visible than others, but they make us who we are.”
Penny is such a lovable mess that struggles with his insecurities after being bullied by his older brother his whole life. Kit is a grumpy loner that just wants to escape his past and forget his history with the grave-robbing cult. As disparate as they seem, it soon becomes clear that these two are more alike than you think.
"“We were both desperate to live up to the expectations of someone who would never be satisfied no matter how close we got. Unable to fit into the molds made for us. Doubting every action because we were told so often that everything we did was wrong.”
The romance is a slooooow burn — after all, we have four whole books with these two, so don’t expect to get the whole song and dance within this first book. But the slow build, the rising tension, the flows of jealousy, the pining and yearning — it’s all so delicious and well worth the wait. I’m excited to see how their relationship continues in the next book!
"Thank you, for seeing me as more than I am. For making me want to be better."
Overall, I was blown away by First Oaths. I was wrapped up in this fictional world, lost in the story of these two men and the scary cult, and loving every minute of it. I can’t recommend this book enough!!
-ARC review-
“Everyone has scars. Some are more visible than others, but they make us who we are.”
Penny is such a lovable mess that struggles with his insecurities after being bullied by his older brother his whole life. Kit is a grumpy loner that just wants to escape his past and forget his history with the grave-robbing cult. As disparate as they seem, it soon becomes clear that these two are more alike than you think.
"“We were both desperate to live up to the expectations of someone who would never be satisfied no matter how close we got. Unable to fit into the molds made for us. Doubting every action because we were told so often that everything we did was wrong.”
The romance is a slooooow burn — after all, we have four whole books with these two, so don’t expect to get the whole song and dance within this first book. But the slow build, the rising tension, the flows of jealousy, the pining and yearning — it’s all so delicious and well worth the wait. I’m excited to see how their relationship continues in the next book!
"Thank you, for seeing me as more than I am. For making me want to be better."
Overall, I was blown away by First Oaths. I was wrapped up in this fictional world, lost in the story of these two men and the scary cult, and loving every minute of it. I can’t recommend this book enough!!
-ARC review-
September 10, 2025
Disclosure: I received an Advance Reader Copy (ARC) of this book in exchange for an honest review. As someone who loves supporting indie authors, I always aim to share thoughtful, fair feedback. While I have personal reading preferences like a love for fantasy, horses, or specific tropes, I never let that impact my rating unless it is relevant to the book’s intent or audience. I review with the genre and readership in mind.
Star rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐. 5
Spice rating: -
Darkness/Bloodiness: Dark topics, please check content warning, recommended to adults only!
I came across the cover in a group and absolutely loved it, just look at the details, the character's expressions. That desperate grab and the look of surprise grabbed my attention and I just had to read. I love diverse, LGBTQ+ representative books, so if you are looking for such and so far the book grabbed you, check the blurb and read on!
I know you are wondering, so yes the cover is a scene from the book, and it is so much better than you expect! Sweet, slow burn driven by the desperate will to right wrongs. The dark society, with its oaths was so exciting, so twisted and absolutely addictive. The side characters and the events were all keeping me focused and thinking what comes next. The Older MMC, Kit was such a fantastic character! His morals, all the reflections on past actions and his nurturing nature made me really love him. Penny with his more rash, chirpy nature is such a good match to balance both characters!
The details of the society are frightening and really cool in a thrilling way I would say, I am so glad that the author focused on the depth! However, the world building was sadly the part that didn't hit the excellence for me, I wanted to know a bit more how such a dark community could develop and more about how the world looks and works. It is clearly different from our world, but the details were not clear.
I am absolutely sticking with the series, I am excitedly waiting for the next part and I hope to see more history and world building that would also hit that 5star level for me. I recommend this book to dark fantasy lovers, especially if you are looking for some diversity in your read!
My favorite quote:
“If you're going to think about anyone's ham, Kit, it should be mine.“
Star rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐. 5
Spice rating: -
Darkness/Bloodiness: Dark topics, please check content warning, recommended to adults only!
I came across the cover in a group and absolutely loved it, just look at the details, the character's expressions. That desperate grab and the look of surprise grabbed my attention and I just had to read. I love diverse, LGBTQ+ representative books, so if you are looking for such and so far the book grabbed you, check the blurb and read on!
I know you are wondering, so yes the cover is a scene from the book, and it is so much better than you expect! Sweet, slow burn driven by the desperate will to right wrongs. The dark society, with its oaths was so exciting, so twisted and absolutely addictive. The side characters and the events were all keeping me focused and thinking what comes next. The Older MMC, Kit was such a fantastic character! His morals, all the reflections on past actions and his nurturing nature made me really love him. Penny with his more rash, chirpy nature is such a good match to balance both characters!
The details of the society are frightening and really cool in a thrilling way I would say, I am so glad that the author focused on the depth! However, the world building was sadly the part that didn't hit the excellence for me, I wanted to know a bit more how such a dark community could develop and more about how the world looks and works. It is clearly different from our world, but the details were not clear.
I am absolutely sticking with the series, I am excitedly waiting for the next part and I hope to see more history and world building that would also hit that 5star level for me. I recommend this book to dark fantasy lovers, especially if you are looking for some diversity in your read!
My favorite quote:
“If you're going to think about anyone's ham, Kit, it should be mine.“
October 2, 2025
First Oaths
A sweet cozy vibe story! I enjoyed the slow burn romance between the characters and the story itself slowly reeled you in with each page!
The story had plenty of thrills and loads of drama that made it exciting and had me eager for more by the end of it.
I enjoyed the dynamics between all the different characters and how there’s connections and also a past as well.
The cult aspect of it was intriguing and I look forward to learning more about what it all entails.
Now for the characters… Penny. Penny was a ray of sunshine! I loved his positive and glowing personality! He was also a man on a mission and wasn’t afraid to back down even when he was afraid! He has a little bit to him but he’s a cute golden cinnamon roll overall.
Kit, now he was mysterious and grumpy! He had a tormented past and I enjoyed seeing glimpses into it. I enjoyed his growth of character as well in this one.
The two of them together were cute and sweet! I loved the heartfelt vibes between them and I can’t wait for more!
If you enjoy cozy vibes, young adult romance, dual pov, first kisses, protective MMCs, morally grey characters, cult, inner strength, family drama, traumatic past, hurt/comfort, village vibes, and so much more then be such to give this one a read!
A sweet cozy vibe story! I enjoyed the slow burn romance between the characters and the story itself slowly reeled you in with each page!
The story had plenty of thrills and loads of drama that made it exciting and had me eager for more by the end of it.
I enjoyed the dynamics between all the different characters and how there’s connections and also a past as well.
The cult aspect of it was intriguing and I look forward to learning more about what it all entails.
Now for the characters… Penny. Penny was a ray of sunshine! I loved his positive and glowing personality! He was also a man on a mission and wasn’t afraid to back down even when he was afraid! He has a little bit to him but he’s a cute golden cinnamon roll overall.
Kit, now he was mysterious and grumpy! He had a tormented past and I enjoyed seeing glimpses into it. I enjoyed his growth of character as well in this one.
The two of them together were cute and sweet! I loved the heartfelt vibes between them and I can’t wait for more!
If you enjoy cozy vibes, young adult romance, dual pov, first kisses, protective MMCs, morally grey characters, cult, inner strength, family drama, traumatic past, hurt/comfort, village vibes, and so much more then be such to give this one a read!
October 6, 2025
First Oaths is a solid start to the Bone Men series. I closed this book with a good foundation for the story and anticipation for book two.
For a story about grave-robbing cultists, the overall tone of First Oaths leans surprisingly cozy. The steady pace allows for dread to creep in but keeps urgency and angst relatively low while Penny and Kit find their footing. While I started this book expecting to feel unsettled, I don't mind subverted expectations.
Thanks so much for the chance to check out an advance copy. I also purchased a copy for myself because how could I not, LOOK AT IT. I'm leaving this review of my own accord.
For a story about grave-robbing cultists, the overall tone of First Oaths leans surprisingly cozy. The steady pace allows for dread to creep in but keeps urgency and angst relatively low while Penny and Kit find their footing. While I started this book expecting to feel unsettled, I don't mind subverted expectations.
Thanks so much for the chance to check out an advance copy. I also purchased a copy for myself because how could I not, LOOK AT IT. I'm leaving this review of my own accord.
December 10, 2025
When I saw this was about a cult, I did not expect it to be as cute as it was :’) Penny was adorable from the very beginning, and I was extremely intrigued by Kit and his story. He has one of those personalities that just makes you want to know more about him. These two are complete opposites, which only makes them even cuter together.
I have no idea how the author pulled it off, but the cozy atmosphere in this book was eeeeeverything!!! The cult element definitely adds to the sense of mystery, but because the story takes place in such a rural area, it almost feels like a medieval old town, which makes the cozy vibes even stronger 🥹
It’s definitely a slow burn, but you can feel that something is developing between them. Their level of comfort with each other slowly grows, and Kit goes from dreading Penny’s existence lol to being protective of him.
It was really good! Definitely unlike anything I’ve read before, and I can't wait to start reading the second one!
I have no idea how the author pulled it off, but the cozy atmosphere in this book was eeeeeverything!!! The cult element definitely adds to the sense of mystery, but because the story takes place in such a rural area, it almost feels like a medieval old town, which makes the cozy vibes even stronger 🥹
It’s definitely a slow burn, but you can feel that something is developing between them. Their level of comfort with each other slowly grows, and Kit goes from dreading Penny’s existence lol to being protective of him.
It was really good! Definitely unlike anything I’ve read before, and I can't wait to start reading the second one!
September 4, 2025
Arc Review
I came here not knowing the authors previous work so this is my first impression.
I was expecting it to be darker, given we are talking about a cult that worships some kind of eldritch entity, while it does have some dark details/bits what I found was a cozy town and people... being people. It gives you a different perspective about the villainous, wicked followers, making you feel some sort of sympathy for those who are blinded to horrors on their search for love, community and safety. The authors do a great job bringing together the dark lore with mundane situations throughout Kit and Penny's views and experiences.
Loved the dynamic between Kit and Penny, it is incredibly sweet and tender, two broken men trying their best to do right while helping each other heal (tho unconsciously. Talk about bonding over traumas..)
I'm eager to learn more about the lore in the next book
I came here not knowing the authors previous work so this is my first impression.
I was expecting it to be darker, given we are talking about a cult that worships some kind of eldritch entity, while it does have some dark details/bits what I found was a cozy town and people... being people. It gives you a different perspective about the villainous, wicked followers, making you feel some sort of sympathy for those who are blinded to horrors on their search for love, community and safety. The authors do a great job bringing together the dark lore with mundane situations throughout Kit and Penny's views and experiences.
Loved the dynamic between Kit and Penny, it is incredibly sweet and tender, two broken men trying their best to do right while helping each other heal (tho unconsciously. Talk about bonding over traumas..)
I'm eager to learn more about the lore in the next book
September 29, 2025
Can you hear me absolutely squealing in delight over this book?! I absolutely ADORE Kit and Penny. First Oaths is a swoon-worthy, fresh storyline with all of our favorite tropes. I’m obsessed with where this story is heading. I was absolutely taken with everything and flew through this story far too fast, honestly. I can’t wait to see how their relationship evolves through the hardships they are yet to face and experience the darkness the Bone Men cult truly holds.
October 16, 2025
I have a habit of not reading blurbs before starting a book so the sole reason I bought this one was because of its cover. But it turned out to be nothing like what I expected. The book does feature a cute relationship between the main characters, but beyond that, it also has an interesting storyline involving a cult and the dead.
I thought this book was great, and I hope more people read it. I can't wait for the next one though !
I thought this book was great, and I hope more people read it. I can't wait for the next one though !
Displaying 1 - 30 of 123 reviews