Peter Brown, perhaps the greatest living authority on Mediterranean civilization in late antiquity, traces the growing power of Christian bishops as they wrested influence from philosophers, who had traditionally advised the rulers of Graeco-Roman society. In the new “Christian empire,” the ancient bonds of citizen to citizen and of each city to its benefactors were replaced by a common Christianity and common loyalty to a distant, Christian autocrat. This transformation of the Roman empire from an ancient to a medieval society, he argues, is among the most far-reaching consequences of the rise of Christianity.
Peter Robert Lamont Brown FBA is an Irish historian. He is the Rollins Professor of History Emeritus at Princeton University. Brown is credited with having brought coherence to the field of Late Antiquity, and is often regarded as the inventor of said field. His work has concerned, in particular, the religious culture of the later Roman Empire and early medieval Europe, and the relation between religion and society.
A helpful and engaging set of lectures on the relationship between eloquence (and paideia more broadly) and statecraft in Late Antiquity, with a fascinating concluding chapter on how Bishops both assumed and transformed the role of the local elite and that of the philosopher, resulting in the move “toward a Christian empire” with a very distinct understanding of the political hierarchy.
Focused on the East, but with regular cameos from Augustine and Ambrose.
Brilliant. Brown traces the capture of speech and power from elites of the old religion by leaders of the new Christian religion, and the concomitant loss of a representation of society bound by a shared paideia of cultivation and restraint, supplanted by a new representation of a society bound by the Christian emperor's divine right of absolute power. Much more going on here, but that's a glimpse.
Another phenomenal work from Brown, which he perfectly summarizes in the introduction:
"It attempts to describe the expectations with which upper-class subjects approached the emperor and his representatives, to ward off the cruelty and fiscal rigor that characterized the government of the Roman Empire in the fourth and fifth centuries A.D. It will not describe all the mechanisms by which such approaches were made, nor all the strategies employed: rather, it will concentrate on the cultural and religious elements that were thought to have played a role in making the imperial power, for all its domineering majesty, amenable to persuasion."
It was this art of persuasion, learned through the paideia acquired through elite educations that later enabled Christian bishops to intercede into political matters on behalf of Christian congregations
First, my rating means nothing. I am not qualified to judge this book. I read it because 1) I know nothing about late antiquity and thought I would like to learn something and 2) it's short. As it turns out, this is not the book I should have read. It assumes a general knowledge of the historical period that I do not have. Even so, I soldiered on to the end and actually did learn some things. I learned a little bit about the paucity and problematic nature of ancient sources. I also learned that broad phrases like "the Rise of Christianity in the Eastern Empire" refer to complex social and political developments that we don't fully understand. All in all, I'm a little smarter for having read this book--but not much.
Christianity as the first populism? Bishops behaving like mob bosses and monks like the thug arm of the church? This is kind of uncomfortable. A thought provoking read about how the ancient and sort of ceremonial role of the philosopher in his political role as the one who is allowed to speak truths to power got taken over by the 'lovers of the poor,' which in turn makes 'the poor' a political interest group that can enforce their displeasure by rioting. The bishop then takes an almost explicitly Althussarian role as Ideological State Apparatuses, ie, guys who get to retain their power because they keep the poor quiet without bloodshed.
Everyone should read as much Peter Brown as he or she can find and stand to. His books are all perfect. Imagine wanting to know about a niche corner of society in the 5th and 6th centuries... He's probably explained it in one of his books, which all focus on interesting cultural tensions.
I definitely need to reread this to understand fully. Peter Brown certainly did not hold back in this one. I found it immensely more challenging than the Rise of Western Christendom, which was not an 'easy' read either. Still, the fact that it is worth reading again says something...
I enjoyed Brown’s dense prose, and this is both engagingly written as well as packed with interesting information and references. The main focus of this book is on the continuation of paideia among the aristocratic elite, and the transference of the practice of parrhésia from the philosophers to the bishops as the Roman Empire became Christianized – the book deals mainly with the eastern provinces however. While Brown makes repeated references and comparisons with the decorum found in connection with the autocracy of 17th century France, there’s only little mention of, or comparisons made, with the paideia of the early Greek city states, or the Graeco-Roman world in general, in the centuries leading up to the period of late antiquity discussed in this book – except, indirectly, when briefly discussing (the image of) earlier philosophers in the subchapter about parrhésia. Brown also mentions only as an aside that parrhésia was never simply the exclusive domain of philosophers, without getting much further into that. Also, the way Brown presents it, you could easily get the impression that the Christian bishops were the first to ever give any attention to the existence of the noncitizen, and, as well, that this had never been used as a political argument before. However, he does show how increased immigration and urbanization lead to an upsurge of the noncitizen class in the East Roman cities, making it a more pressing social issue, along with that of underemployment, and how the bishops became "Controllers of the Crowds" (p. 103) and developed this argument (on behalf of the masses of noncitizens and abject poor; noncitizens were not necessarily poor) into a stance of moral authority, as representatives of the general populace, because "before the emperor, as before God, all subjects were poor" (p. 154).– Make no mistake about it; perhaps complementing the title of his book, Brown aims to persuade, and he generally manages well with that within the narrow focus of this study – yet, just because of its narrowness, it appears to some degree incomplete. Still, within its own limit, this is a noteworthy and compelling analysis.
This is a well written book that takes you into the life and thought of the Christianised Roman empire.For anyone thinking about the relationship between the great theological debates eg Arianism) and the emperor this is a must. Peter Brown takes what could be quite dry material and makes it a fascinating read.