'Mesmeric from the first page. A twisting, haunting tale.' Lucy Steeds, author of THE ARTIST
The Knock hill is a carcass unintelligible as any dream.
Wouldn't you rather be a witch than a victim? I didn't realise those were my only options.
In need of a fresh start, Thomasin leaves her toxic boyfriend, absent father and empty friendships to spend the summer in the Scottish Highlands with her eccentric Aunt Agnes and stern little cousin, Nina. But amidst the sprawling fields and ragged hills thrums a secret that has cursed the land for generations.
300 years earlier, Kate McNiven labours in The Big House by the Knock hill, wishing for a brighter future far away from the lecherous clutches of her master, the Laird. When she is exiled as a witch for refusing to succumb to his advances, Kate finds the escape she so desperately seeks in Thomasin, whose vulnerable body becomes her unwilling host.
In the thin place between centuries, through a pulsing wound that bleeds out history, the truth of the past is finally ready to be revealed . . .
A mix of literary/historical fiction with magic realism sprinkled with an eerie atmospheric vibe set in Scotland in dual timelines from 1715 following Kate and what I assume is present day following Thomasin and how their stories/ lives intertwine.
This is more of a character driven story (my personal preference is character over plot) and I never felt it dragged. I enjoyed the format and pacing. The writing was rich, I felt transported to the settings and could vividly see the characters interacting. Favourite bits being Kate's poem POVs starting each part and any scene with little Nina.
It could be slightly confusing as we switched a lot from Kate and Thomasins timelines/ POVs but it helped that the former is written in third person and latter in first person.
I read the arc version via my Kindle so the published version may have speech marks which would have made following Thomasin's thoughts vs actual speech easier. That being said, no speech marks made it feel like everything she was thinking and doing was blurred for her as well as for us, which honestly, is very on brand for her.
Thank you NetGalley and John Murray Press for allowing me to read the ARC for an honest review!
I’m afraid this wasn’t a match. I loved the cover, which is why I requested it on NetGalley. As for the text itself, the interludes in the form of songs were excellent, and I wish more had been done with them—perhaps even a novel in verse. The rest, however, felt frustratingly incongruous, especially in terms of its underlying rationale. I simply couldn’t fathom the reason(s) behind much of what was happening.
Thomasin was an interesting character, I enjoyed the parts with her Her interactions with the people around her (physically, or at the end of the phone). The rest of the book didn't grab me so much unfortunately. It's qute possible I missed the bigger picture because of this.