An extraordinary exposé of the industry flooding our world with plastic—and now ramping up to make more than ever
“Deeply researched, sharply written, and totally compelling.” —Elizabeth Kolbert, author of the The Sixth Extinction
“It is impossible not to compare Beth Gardiner’s Plastic Inc. to Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring.” —John Vaillant, author of Fire Weather
“A breathtaking and revelatory exposé about one of the world’s most reckless industries—and also a fascinating secret history of the modern world.” —Christopher Leonard, author of Kochland
Plastic, the foundational material of modern consumerism, is everywhere in our daily lives. But the oil and petrochemical companies making it are hiding in plain sight. Because for all the vivid coverage of where plastic ends up, there is remarkably little discussion of where it comes from. Today, industry is pouring billions of dollars into plans to double, or even triple, the amount it churns out, even as individuals concerned about plastic’s out-of-control proliferation try to use less. As Big Oil stares down a future of diminishing demand for fossil fuels, plastic has become its financial lifeline.
Award-winning journalist Beth Gardiner gives readers an up-close look at the plastic industry’s relentless growth, its extraordinary profits, its toxic pollution and its hidden role in exacerbating climate change. Every chapter in Plastic Inc. brings new revelations,
How Big Oil sold us the lie that recycling was the panacea for our plastic worries, even though companies always knew it couldn’t work at scaleThe hidden health crisis caused by chemicals in the items we use every day, and scientists’ growing fear that microplastics may pose even bigger dangersHow the industries making and using plastic have wielded political muscle to stop bans on single-use items like plastic bags, while blaming us for the global mess they’ve created—and profited fromThat Big Oil’s plastic dreams spring directly from decades of denying climate science, and draw on the playbook of deceit this industry wrote—one later borrowed by tobacco and pharma companiesThe characters and personalities behind a hidden corporate and political scandal perpetuated over decades Plastic Inc.’s gripping stories will reframe for readers a problem many of us think we understand, but which has deeper roots, and greater dangers, than we know.
Beth Gardiner is an American journalist based in London. Her work has appeared in publications including the New York Times, the Guardian, National Geographic, Smithsonian, Time and the Washington Post. These days, she focuses mainly on stories about environment, health and sustainability, but she’s written about everything from politics, education and feminism to food and the arts. Choked, her first book, has been recommended by NPR's Science Friday, the Washington Post, Scientific American and Library Journal. The Guardian said "You couldn’t ask for a better guide for non-specialists and concerned citizens," and Refinery29 called it "incredibly readable."
Beth spent 10 years as a reporter for the Associated Press, based first in New York and then in London. She has discussed her reporting on NPR's All Things Considered, MSNBC, WNYC's Brian Lehrer show, the BBC's World at One, Sky News and Canada's CBC, among many others. In 2019, she was a speaker at TEDx London at the Royal Festival Hall.
This book excelled as a piece of long-form journalism that exposed the way that our habits to treat plastic as disposable is not our fault-- these are patterns of behaviors that companies have thrust onto us through advertisements and lack of choice.
After reading this book and LESS IS MORE earlier this year, I am more convinced than ever that advertisements need to be regulated.
The TL;DR : Single use plastic is terrible and companies have forced us into using them over the last 100 years. Capitalism continues to be absolutely terrible and our government has been pretty worthless to regulate plastics.
On recycling: The recycling chapter talked about how difficult it is to recycle many plastics. The most recyclable plastic is PET which is has the digit 1 (♳) as its code. Each type of plastic is given a "recycling code" but not every plastic can be recycled easily. The official term is "resin identification code" So the recycling symbol around that code are extremely misleading.
The problem with plastics is we treat them as disposable. When in reality, these "disposable" plastics that we create will likely be around for hundreds of years.
My biggest issue with this book as a chemist, was that it lacked specificity and nuance. One example is the difference between phthalates and BPA. BPA is the monomer of polycarbonate, so it is part of the polymer chain, once the polycarbonate has formed. BPA is considered by some to be "estrogenic" meaning that there is evidence in birds and fish that it can mimic estrogen, when it is on it's own (not as a polymer)... so like a nalgene water bottle made of polycarbonate can release the BPA monomers but only if the polymer is exposed to heat/light/acid that breaks up those covalent bonds.
Conversely, phthalates are molecules that are added into the plastic that disrupt a weak type of crosslinking called pi-stacking. phthalates turn a rigid plastic into a plastic with more flexibility. But because the phthalates are not part of the polymer chain, it is easier for phthalates to seep out of the plastic (especially when heated, or when a solvent passes through the plastic). Phthalates are not estrogenic, but there is evidence that they interfere with our sex hormones.
I was hoping for a lot more nuance around the toxicology of plastics, so if that is what you are looking for, you won't find it in this book.
Also, I was hoping for a more nuanced discussion around plastics & disability as plastics can be life-saving and how do we balance the risk to exposure from plasticizers with the benefits of a sterile material that is used for IV antibiotics for example.
Also, in the chapter on Saudi Arabia, the author made reference to it being a country that treats women terribly but did not make that type of statement for the US, so that felt bigoted to me personally.
But I really appreciated the chapters where Gardiner highlighted the work that concerned citizens have done to reign in companies such as the Wilson vs. Formosa chapter.
What I learned: In the final chapter, Gardiner talked about some places (like Hawaii) that have successfully banned single-use plastics. The key was starting small. It is easier to pass a city-wide ban on single-use plastics than a state-wide ban because fewer people need to say yes.
"Plastic Inc." will blow your mind and change the way you think about plastic. It's a gripping and fantastic work of journalism and research. The author Beth Gardiner makes the case that consumers are not to blame for the ever-increasing mountain of plastic trash in our lives and our world. Rather, the infiltration of plastic into every conceivable product, purchase and delivery in the world is the result of a deliberate strategy by Big Oil, which needed to find a market and a way to dispose of the petroleum byproducts that are turned into a variety of plastics. But the real shame and horror is that the oil industry turned the disposal of this waste into a problem for us, the taxpayers and consumers, hoodwinking and bribing government officials the world over to relieve oil companies of the logistical and financial responsibility of taking care of their own garbage. Oh and the recycling of plastic? Unfortunately, it's mostly bullshit. Highly readable and an important book for every consumer.
Let’s start with a visual experiment. Look around the room which you are in and see how many objects you can spot which are made of plastic. The television? The television remote? Your laptop? Your phone? Those pesky pieces of Lego?
Which plastics are in your television remote? When you upgrade to a new tv, or upgrade to new plastic, what will you do with your old remote? Can it be recycled? Will you drop it into your recycling and watch it be carted off- relieved that you have ‘done your bit’, without seeing the journey it makes?
In ‘Plastic Inc’, Gardiner urges us to notice and be aware of the tide of plastic objects, which we have been encouraged to bring into our homes and which have quietly taken over. She urges that this is no accident, but a deliberate campaign by fossil fuel companies to maximise their profit- often creating a need for plastic where none existed. ‘The news that big fossil fuel companies were pouring billions of dollars into plans to make more plastic than ever in the years to come-even as so many people, worried about plastic’s proliferation into every corner of modern life, were trying to use less.’
Gardiner argues that this ubiquity of plastic causes distress for many of us, as it has become a global mess, with no end in sight and indeed, production of plastic is ramping up even more to new heights. ‘Plastics’ spread into every corner of our lives is also taking an invisible toll on our health. The chemicals that leach from them have been linked to heart disease, cancer, fertility problems, and even neurodevelopmental issues such as autism and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.’ She adds, ‘The plastic drenched world we live in today didn’t just happen. It was built by an industry that has slowly, steadily- and stealthily- drawn us into its web. The links between plastics and Alzheimer's and other neurological diseases, such as Parkinson's, are being explored with more frequency and more depth, as the rise of these cases continue.
How did we let this happen?
It would be too easy for Gardiner, simply to turn ‘Plastic Inc’ into a long angry rant about the evils of plastic, but she acknowledges the benefits of some of the technology that has been made possible through its manufacture. ‘Of course, this is not a simple story of an evil material. Plastic has many invaluable, even essential uses. I wouldn’t want to live in a world without the medical equipment it makes possible.’ What Gardiner wants to do is to shift the focus from the product itself, to the manufacturers, to the plastic industry that lies beneath the surface- hidden from scrutiny, but in plain sight.
‘While plastic itself is easy to see, the industry bringing it into the world is invisible to most of us. This book aims to shine a light on it.’
The rise of plastics
Shine a light on the industry is done thoroughly by Gardiner, as she charts and chronicles both the rise of industry and of individuals who have ignored the views of the public to foist more unnecessary plastic products on them, to keep us addicted to their product. Gardiner names the fossil fuel companies which are to blame and notes the shift in their output of plastic products as oil demand lessens. She explores the intentionally flawed thinking of the plastic industry, as they encourage consumers simply to ‘recycle’, as if this was a panacea to all the plastic ills. ‘We can’t recycle our way out of the plastics mess.’ She warns that the iconography of the ‘recycling arrows’ has led to consumer confusion, which the industry delights in. ‘Consumers would treat anything labeled with the chasing arrows as recyclable, and flood local systems with material they were unequipped to handle.’
Big Oil created a narrative for the public that all plastics could be recycled and pointed the finger at the public’s behaviour when they couldn’t understand the various PET numbers on plastic packaging. They urged that the public should be educated about how to dispose of their product and emphasised that ‘Plastic is good. Pollution is bad.’ channelling ‘The Crying Indian’ advert for the modern world. ‘What’s more, talk of recycling often focuses on “education” and “behaviour change”- a handy way of shifting responsibility from industry to individuals.
Nothing is ever thrown ‘away’
Another key factor in the plastics waste cycle is that of disposal- a factor which the fossil fuel companies seem very uninterested in. We have all seen images of plastic and waste mountains in Kenya, Indonesia, Malaysia, India and many other countries around the world. Countries which are not equipped to deal with the levels of waste plastic that the Western world produces. ‘When China closed its doors to foreign plastic waste in 2018, it could have been a moment of reckoning- a firm nudge pushing wealthy countries to look clearly at the mess we are creating and find a different path, Instead, from Los Angeles to Rotterdam to Seoul, those with waste to get rid of simply found new places to send it.’
The blame about who was badly managing this problem remained with countries and individuals- the fossil fuel industry has successfully created this shift in blame. That poorer countries around the world are to blame for managing the plastic waste which we create. Shame on them! Who escaped this blame spotlight? Why, the fossil fuel industry once again.
Shifting blame
Gardiner also details the impacts of fracking, endocrine disruptors and microplastics in this wide ranging book- the chemical cocktail which surrounds our lives and poses clear physical risks to humans, marine life and many other life forms on this planet. Fossil fuel companies have unleashed a ‘plastic chemical virus’ on the planet and then have blamed us for its impact. ‘It’s painful to look clearly at the ways huge, extraordinarily profitable companies have foisted plastic on us for decades and convinced us it’s our fault, while wielding their money and power to squelch any efforts to stop them.’
Gardiner acknowledges that solutions won’t be easy unless governments act to regulate an out of control industry. ‘There are no simple answers to the questions posed by plastics’s spread into every corner of our lives.’ She urges us not to give up hope though, as we are being harmed by yet another product of the fossil fuel industry. ‘Reversing plastic’s relentless proliferation, and the harms it is wreaking, won’t be easy, but it’s not impossible either.’
‘A less plastic world can seem like a utopian dream, unrealistic and out of reach. It’s certainly hard to envision after decades in which the trajectory has gone only one way, and we’ve felt so powerless to change it.’
‘Plastic Inc’ allows us to see that this plastic pollution of our world has been a concerted and calculated strategy by the fossil fuel industry over decades, intent on profits at all costs. A strategy which has infiltrated every part of our lives and flooded our world.
This was really great. A look at how companies and capitalism moved us from a reusing culture to a consuming single use culture to better line plastic (big oil’s) pockets. It looks at the lobbying and force big oil exerts to stop any change to their empire - from a change as small as a plastic bag ban in a small town to any regulations on advertising their plastic is recyclable (it likely is not!) Very great read but docked a point for two points: 1) I’m going to click bigotry and bias and in the chapter on Saudi Arabia and its desire to keep people using oil she mentioned she only thinks of human rights abuses and the way they treat women when she thinks of them. While actual bad things they do she does NOT mention any such thing when discussing other countries like the US and China - which also treat women badly and have human rights abuses. The only use for that aside was bigotry. 2) I listened to the audiobook and it had about every five minutes a word or line that was noticeably re-recorded and I was like ummm did you get all this info wrong in the first recording? Maybe read this with your eyes and not your ears.
A fact I never knew about, and learned in reading 'Plastic Inc.' stood out for me as an analogy of what plastic is, and why it is so difficult to even consider eradicating:
In many very poor parts of the globe, people simply can not afford the price of what we in the First World would consider trivial, like a full bar of soap. Shops in India will cut a bar into eight pieces, so a person can just buy what they have the money for at the time. This gave rise to an entire industry selling 'packets' of products. A 'packet' to us is what ketchup or soy sauce comes in at a take-out place, but they are used elsewhere for shampoo, spices, etc. So, a solution to a problem (immediate affordability) aggravates another problem (pollution; these packets are notoriously non-recyclable, and thus usually just dumped or burned.)
I didn't really find a 'secret history' or 'shocking future' in my reading. The future will have plastic in it, just like we have it in ourselves now. The different variants of plastic were often 'solutions looking for a problem,' and that shows no signs of doing anything but growing.
Terrifying and unsettling to read, but everybody must read this book. We are being played by the petrochemical industry so that they can increase their profits while we pay with our health and a ruined environment. Let’s not buy into their lies that it’s because we’re not recycling properly. Plastic is one of the least recyclable materials and further pollutes when it’s being recycled. Let’s vote with the way we live our lives and step away from single use plastic and unnecessary items that are being foisted on us.
This book is a must read for everyone on the planet, while it goes extremely in depth beyond what most of us may need to know, it weaves a tale of how we got to the nightmare that is plastic taking over the world. I already was finding ways to change habits to reduce my consumption of all things but this gave me a little extra nudge that I needed.
Horrifyingly informative - things I knew, things I wondered, things I didn't know (and wish I still didn't). The stories get repetitive and sometimes a bit overwrought (who can blame her, immersed as she was in this stuff?), but the message is unmistakable - we have been and continue to be screwed by the oil/plastics industry.
A great work of investigative journalism that blows the claims of Big Oil about recycling clean out of the water. Gardiner’s work serves as an incisive indictment of an industry that sees "the profit that plastic offered" and allows it to override the environmental and biological health of the planet.