1/2/2026 update: I see that a new edition of Deadly Vows is available. First, THANK YOU to the author for not automatically changing the eBook. Apparently when authors edit the eBooks, if your eBook is connected to the internet, it is updated. PLEASE STOP EDITING YOUR BOOKS ONCE THEY ARE PUBLISHED OR DO A NEW EDITION. Sorry for all-caps insanity, but I love this book, perfect as is, and I don’t think anything needs to be changed or added.
9/26/2023 UPDATE: Deadly Vows series is being rewritten and polished Kindle Vella (!?)
I subscribed to Haley's Patreon this month to try to read the next Deadly Vows book but immediately gave up after it took me too long to figure out how to read the chapters, and was getting a little letdown by the hero being immediately infatuated with the quirky dressing grouchy heroine who, of course, is working at a bakery.
However, I would get Vella just to soldier on. Reading on Patreon is hard to get used to.
2/5/2022 UPDATE: FULL REVIEW.
I enjoyed Deadly Vows so here's a review with more thoughts :)
I was skimming Danielle Lori's The Sweetest Oblivion, which I DNF as it was too sweet for me, but I started Deadly Vows at around the same time but also put it down because I was worried this was going to be another "big bad mafia don" with "good girl mafia princess" and I don't generally vibe with the "picture-perfect good girl" heroines. Similar to the ice queen society girl. What can I say, perfection just doesn't interest me.
However, I gave it an honest go and it picks up *fast* In fact, Deadly Vows is like a periodical or a serial. The first half of the book is Elise witnessing or experiencing violent acts by Luca, each act worsening in horror. Luca reminds me of a bodice ripper villain. There was no humanizing of Luca by Elise's POV or his own POV, and I liked that. There is no blurry edge between obsessive love and hate. Luca sees no conflict in his actions and his love for Elise.
At times, it does seem as though he may be emotionally stunted, because Elise constantly reels back with confusion about Luca. She wants to be loved but doesn't see in Luca's actions any love, despite his obsession for her. She doesn't understand how Luca can love her, want to protect her, but then backhand her, intimidate her into submission.
If Deadly Vows was just violence against the heroine, it would have been a bit repetitious, but the political intrigues gets twisty.By the time Elise is abducted, I was Team Deadly Vows. I completely gave in to the story. Elise begins to move on past the sheltered girl. She develops from her idealistic innocence to becoming stronger, thoughtful, even as her mental health deteriorates from her trauma.
She is stronger in that she saves herself.
She is thoughtful and her POV becomes more interesting:
On Luca, she thinks, "He is fucked up. And that is the fault of this family we have both been born into. It is his job to be fucked up. Being the capo, you can't be soft and sane. You have to be hard and maniacal. Being with Alexander, I've seen firsthand the type of people he deals with. Luca has been protecting me from people like that. i know he has been way overboard with me for no justifable reason, but with everything that I have been through, just the thought of being near him, near safety, makes me feel comforted."
And... "Luca isn't a good man, that I know, but he has good tendencies... But I know the good tendencies must be something his mother has instilled in him. He is a mix of both of his parents, and he's been with his father the majority of his life. But now that his father is gone, he has moments when he looks at me with so much love that I almost forget the hell that he has dragged me through. Almost. And I have his mother to thank for that."
Her ruminations on her survival as a mafia wife are also poignant.
Luca doesn't necessarily become more thoughtful, but his loyalty to Elise is never in question, even as he backhands/chokes her at times. But he never loses faith or is persuaded to go against her. Major points for this.
Truth is, Haley Stuart never redeems Luca, but shows a realistic portrayal of what it must be like to live a criminal life. I really liked this argument they had where he tells Elise:
"Elise, you act like I chose to be this way." He finally looks over to me, and I am shocked to see the hurt in his eyes. "You act like I was born into a normal family, with normal parents, with normal jobs, and i just chose to grow up and be this way. You act like the world is filled with nothing but love and rainbows."
He gives a bitter chuckle before continuing.
"Well, I hate to be the one to bear the bad news, babe, but it's not. We live in a world where such a thing called the Mafia exists, and I was the lucky bastard born into leading it. And you were born into it also. Except you led a nice little life where your biggest problem was your father not paying attention to you. my biggest problem was shooting someone in the neck instead of the head because if I kept them alive, it was my life on the line. My biggest problem was learning to interrogate people, hurt people, kill people because it was my duty to my family. And if I didn't, I was beat and starved by my father."
They have great arguments like this.
And Luca's POV also becomes humourous towards the end. Understandably, Elise is traumatized from her experiences and sticks to Luca:
"I literally have to give her a pep talk for three minutes just so she'll let me use the bathroom. She hates being alone, and she trusts no one but me."
I'm always a sucker for a doormat turned strong(ish) heroine. And I respect that Luca is a complete villain. The romantic logic of their romance, twisted absolutely, made sense to me. Very satisfying love story.
RTC. 4.5 rounded up. As other reviewers said, about halfway through, this just clicks. I was surprised by how invested I got into the plot and cared about how the characters were going to get out of the next jam. It is romance. It might not be cuddly but there is introspection on the relationship where both characters mature and have HEA.
I have a lot more to share about this but the big question is - their kid is having their own book, right?! That bonus chapter got me wanting the next book now!