Chosen Family

by Madeleine Gray

Books about friendship are not often described as love stories, but this is one.
At the age of twelve, Nell has accepted that hers will likely be a friendless existence. She's not interested in boys or makeup or competing to see who can eat the least - so fitting in at her all-girls' school feels impossible.

But then, a new girl arrives at school.

Eve has short hair like a boy's, a wicked sense of humour and an unshakable confidence that she will find her place in the world. And the moment they meet, Nell begins to rethink the whole friendless existence thing.

As they grow into themselves, Nell and Eve will love each other and hurt each other - through the chlorine-scented savagery of adolescence; long, drunken nights in share houses and gay bars; the highs and lows of parenthood.

And always, despite unspoken feelings and sexual confusion, they will choose each other. Again, and again. As friends, as lovers, as family.

Genres: Fiction, Queer, LGBT, Contemporary, Book Club, Literary Fiction, Audiobook

354 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 29, 2026

About the author

Madeleine Gray is a writer and critic from Sydney. Her first novel, Green Dot, was an international bestseller. Her second novel is Chosen Family. She has an MSt in English from the University of Oxford and a PhD in feminist literary theory from the University of Manchester.

Reviews

[Tom Murdoch · Rating 3 out of 5]

So, this book did irritate me.

However, I was irritated insofar as I was challenged to think beyond my own, perhaps rudimentary, queer experiences.

Gray is a fun writer and I always enjoy her prose (it can be a bit verbose at times). I don’t love the constant pop culture references, as I feel it takes you out of the moment, but that’s just me (I would also argue some of the language choices used in the 2008-2014 chapters were anachronistic and needed editing).

Ultimately the core characters are extremely frustrating and flawed, and I struggled to root for them making objectively manic decisions (and frankly they often acted out of indulgence, not queer altruism as they would purport).

Also, I hate hate HATE the trope of young, naive people having babies because “they know they’ll do it better”. So that bothered me, but also challenged me to listen and consider to their perspectives concerning family dynamics and queer love. Ultimately it’s a neat love letter to the queer community and for that I guess I enjoyed it.

[Holly Pedler · Rating 3 out of 5]

Wow this book is irritating! The main characters are incredibly unlikable, it’s full of unrealistic, cringy dialogue and the timeline jumping is annoying especially when we have to read about high school drama. The whole scenario of Eve and Nell having a baby together and platonically co-parenting while Nell is completely in love with Eve and never says anything just didn’t feel real at all. I would’ve given this two stars but added an extra one for the beautiful cover design.

[❋ Booked Out Today ❋ · Rating 5 out of 5]

Chosen Family by Madeleine Gray
★★★★★

Nell and Eve’s friendship is decades long and is full of love, heartbreak, and unspoken longing. Bound by loyalty and complicated affection, they navigate growing up, identity, and the blurred lines between friendship and family.

Let me check something! I’ve read 80 books already in 2025. THIS HAS BEEN MY FAVOURITE READ OF THE YEAR! I am so blown away by Madeleine’s craft in composing a heartfelt, funny and captivating story.

The book constantly pulled me back in every single time. It was like the little plot twists were perfectly placed in the story to keep it going. I lost a whole night of sleep because I just couldn’t put this down. So girl you owe me a full night rest tonight. But I’ll probably be up tonight thinking about the ending now!

This book was so relatable as a mother. I connected with so many ideas and themes in this book. I felt connected with Eve and only really understood Nell’s character in the final chapter.

I usually find books that switch timelines difficult to navigate. This was controlled perfectly. Switching back to time at the right moment, pulling everything together nicely.

I laughed so hard about Lake’s artwork. That scene is the funniest thing I’ve ever read. I’m not even joking. I have Green Dot sitting on my shelf and I can’t wait to devour that now.

I am swept away by how heartfelt and amazing this story was. I’ll be telling everyone I know to read this.

👶🏼🍷🎨📝

Thank you to @netgalley for a copy of this book.

💭 What’s your favourite read for 2025 so far?

Pour a hot drink, it’s book talk time.
Instagram
TikTok

[Ruth · Rating 2 out of 5]

I wanted to like and enjoy this but I was just left annoyed and a bit angry that I'd lost time reading to the end. Eve is one of the worst fictional characters I've encountered in a while - selfish, unaware and a coward, seemingly driven through adulthood by petty teenage girl revenge and confusion. Nell turns into a soggy doormat enthralled by the awful Eve. And Lake - no 5-7 year old child speaks like that and that should've been knocked out by early readings and edits. Lake and Bridget did the emotional hard work for Eve in driving Nell away because Eve is too selfish and cowardly. Chelsea was belittled as 'basic' but in the end, she's educated, rational, compassionate and functional - without that care, the too neatly tied up end isn't possible.
I wanted more but didn't get it from Chosen Family.

[suzannah ♡ · Rating 5 out of 5]

oh how STUNNING. although this has completely broken me. perhaps my favourite read of the year????

[Sheree | Keeping Up With The Penguins · Rating 4 out of 5]

If you’ve ever found yourself longing for a queer version of Normal People that’s set in Sydney and has a few more laughs, look no further: Chosen Family is exactly what you need, especially if you enjoyed Madeleine Gray’s previous novel Green Dot.

My full review of Chosen Family is up now on Keeping Up With The Penguins.

[chloe · Rating 4 out of 5]

what an intense homoerotic friendship in adolescence will do to a dyke 😔 lowkey this is a lesbian horror novel!! enjoyed this quite a lot! i enjoyed the writing style and the alternating timelines between the chapters and the exploration of queer family dynamics and of course, what it means to have a chosen family. but at the root this was also genuinely quite horrific and distressing in relation to the dynamic between eve and nell. like lesbians can be scary as fuck!

[Emily Michele Smith · Rating 3 out of 5]

Ahhhh. I didn’t really know what to expect with this one. Just blindly went in because I knew it would be good.
Madeline has done it again… Written a book with characters I thoroughly dislike, a story I find incredibly frustrating and for the most part far from enjoyable. But somehow I still really enjoyed the reading experience. It was an easy read and I feel like such an insane amount of content fit into such a normal sized book.
I don’t think Madeline sets out to write books with loveable characters… (going off her last book), but I do think she is a great storyteller. It was really refreshing to read something abit different.

Torn between 3-4 stars…
4 star reading experience of a 2-3 star story hahaha

[Siobhan · Rating 1 out of 5]

This was sooo corny man, an easy read and quick to get through but soooo full of cringe queer archetypes and unrealistic dialogue. Would avoid all characters here with a ten foot pole. The growth of the characters made no sense. No one goes from being a highly repressed high school lesbian to suddenly eating pussy like a mad man with the first girl you hook up with. This was like some whacko fantasy fanfic or something. Screamed at the line “she was wearing suk workwear. She was a lesbian”. Author never heard of show don’t tell

[Rose · Rating 2 out of 5]

This was my first DNF of the year. I really wanted to love this book. And while I certainly didn’t hate it, I found my feelings about it came in ebs and flows. I loved the relationship between the 2 main characters, Eve and Nell to begin with, and the hook question (“What did Eve do to make Nell leave?”) kept me turning the pages. However, I found the dialogue between the girls as teenagers/young adults to be too unrealistic. While hindsight makes us all insufferable in early adulthood (insert personal cringe here), I found their dialogue too Dawson’s Creek-esque mixed with Sally Rooney’s style. I wanted more clumsiness out of the characters in that age bracket and more relatability. Think more Hannah Horvath and her friends in Girls.

That being said, I would still recommend it to those who enjoy novels by Meg Mason and Sally Rooney. It wasn’t a hard pass but rather a “not for me”.

[Carm · Rating 4 out of 5]

Was this book set in an alternate universe where communication doesn't exist??

[cyd · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.75
Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced readers copy in exchange she for an honest review. This book was so insanely good I was shocked. It was so messy throughout but god i couldn’t put it down. The time jumps did make the book feel a little clunky at times but it honestly didn’t bother me too much. The only reason I didn’t give this a full five starts is because I think the baby thing ( although being foreshadowed throughout) came about in a kind of unrealistic way? I don’t know it makes sense for the characters in a way but that whole transition felt a bit misplaced to me. This book definitely will not be for everyone and if you don’t like annoying protagonists you won’t like this. I personally i’ve reading about annoying people and the mess they get into and if you add a homoerotic friendship into it you’ve basically created my dream book. I will definitely be checking out other projects from this author because this was just insanely good.

[Emily Conaghan 🐛 · Rating 5 out of 5]

It must be pretty exciting for Madeleine Gray to write two books and then for me, Emily, to rate them both five stars!

[Thomas · Rating 5 out of 5]

So beautifully crafted, Chosen Family is a love letter to the queer community and what it means to grow into one’s self. I devoured this novel, the characters and Normal People esque plot… everything about it. Giving this anything below 5 stars would be a disservice. Do not miss this one when it comes out!!

[Brittney · Rating 3 out of 5]

Tw: Gosford mention

2.5 ⭐️

[⋆｡°·☁︎ sydney ⋆｡°·☁︎ · Rating 3 out of 5]

Look. There was nothing wrong with this book.
I just can’t say that anything really wowed me, or that I resonated with any of it greatly.
As a book, I don’t think it’s bad at all. I like the authors style and the writing, I think there are definitely some interesting motifs and ideas, but I just don’t think any of it quite hit like it was supposed to, for me at least.
Thank you so much Netgalley for the arc!!

[Anneka Parker · Rating 2 out of 5]

Lost me at the neoliberal socks and didn’t get me back. Main characters were annoying and unlikeable and the writing style was just too Gen Z for me (sooo many pop culture references)

[Annie Martin · Rating 2 out of 5]

Feels a slightly unfair rating as I did enjoy the plot, but the feeling I left this book with was frustration - the dialogue was really lacking for me which took me out of the story, especially because of how reliant the book was on it. There were moments of great insight into the characters but broadly I felt like I didn’t really understand them. I did love the visceral setting in Sydney’s queer scene, especially being away from home, but not enough to redeem the book!

[Chiara Osborn · Rating 4 out of 5]

I learnt three things from reading this book:

Every all girl high school experience from 2008-2012 was the same, from trying to kiss your best friend to being worried about your pubes during a swimming carnival.

The best way to ask if someone is a lesbian is, “Are you licking the light fantastic?”

And if you love someone…probably just tell them for goodness sake.

[Azzzz · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was gonna give this a 4 the whole way through, until the last chapter. The ending felt really unsatisfying for me. Multiple loose ends I wish got tied up. It was a real page turner for me, a really cool idea and concept, not really like anything I’ve read before. Just personally wish the ending was better!

[EmG ReadsDaily · Rating 4 out of 5]

’And why is it that the things we really mean are usually the hardest to put into words?’

[Jess Richards · Rating 4 out of 5]

After sitting with this for a few days, I’m going with a 3.5⭐️ I was sitting at about a 4 the whole read, but felt a bit empty at the end, maybe could have been fleshed out a bit more. However, had an excellent time reading this!

[Lauren Renshaw · Rating 2 out of 5]

One of those stars is simply because of a joke about getting a dog and immediately breaking up

[Meghan Grant · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Chosen Family by Madeline Gray is a tender, sharp, and deeply validating exploration of love, friendship, and the messy work of becoming yourself.

This novel captures something rarely articulated so honestly: the quiet, life-shaping power of chosen family. Gray writes with a clarity that feels both intimate and disarming, illuminating the ways friendships can sustain us, disappoint us, and ultimately shape who we are just as profoundly as romantic relationships ever could.

The characters feel achingly real—flawed, loving, selfish, generous, and painfully human. Their connections unfold in ways that mirror real life: through small moments, miscommunications, shared meals, emotional messes, and the slow realisation that love doesn’t always look the way we’re taught it should. Gray’s prose is understated but emotionally precise, trusting the reader to sit with discomfort, longing, and growth rather than tying everything up neatly.

What makes Chosen Family truly special is its emotional honesty. It doesn’t romanticise friendship or queerness; instead, it honours them in all their complexity. It’s a book about learning how to show up, how to let people change, and how to choose each other again and again—even when it’s hard.

This is a novel for anyone who has ever found home in people rather than places. Quietly powerful, beautifully observed, and deeply affirming, Chosen Family is a book that lingers long after the final page.

This novel broke me, put me back together and then broke me all over again. It’s definitely a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ read for me 🫶🏼

[Emily · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is an example of why you should give authors a second chance. When I read Green Dot, I hated the characters and the plot, but really enjoyed the writing. I did not think I would read another one of Gray’s books, but the lesbian plot line intrigued me and I am SO GLAD i picked this book up! It’s only January, but this is a strong contender for my favourite book of the year. In the first half, my heart broke for Eve, and in the second half my heart broke for Nell. Like literally heart broken for her. I would’ve loved a bit more of a resolved ending, but I am going to choose that they finally lived happily ever after. While I think Gray’s writing is so clever and witty, I also love that she can portray an emotion so vividly - some of my favourite examples are “Eve feels like if she’s grieving anything, it’s the mother she never had rather than the person who just died” and “It’s like a police officer coming to your front door and instead of telling you your child is dead they instead inform you that they’ve found a wallet full of wash and it’s yours.”

[Jessica Martin · Rating 5 out of 5]

A shockingly fantastic book. I had no idea what I expected going in, but it was certainly not that. I felt the full spectrum of human emotion through this, I loved the queer representation, the moments of found family, the calamity, the flashbacks between past and present.

All my Eve is evil haters stand up because holy sh*t did I want to throttle that woman. I loved the emotional turmoil of the characters and the way in which Eve and Nell swapped roles through youth and adulthood. I do wish however this painful stereotype of queer especially lesbian love being messy and really hurtful wasn’t portrayed as often, I wish for safe and healthy family roles being shown in this community but do certainly adore this book for saying what it said.

Ate. No crumbs. Delicious.

[Cathy Lang · Rating 3 out of 5]

3⭐️ I quite enjoyed this one but, as always, was just frustrated by the lack of communication between the main characters, it was painful. The first half was better than the second, I enjoyed getting to know the characters and understanding their backstories.

[Heather Fox · Rating 3 out of 5]

Not what I was expecting & I’m not quite sure what to make of it. Liked but didn’t love! Characters were tricky and unlikable, with lots left unresolved. I normally love a found family storyline but I did feel it got lost in this one

[Tonje Beisland · Rating 4 out of 5]

4.75✨

[Jess Prowse · Rating 1 out of 5]

this was the worst most insufferable bullshit I have ever read in my entire life oh my god