Thank you so much for Sophie and the team at Scholastic for managing to get me a proof of this book... you best believe it'll be on everyone's TBR (and anyone who follows me) in the spring.
I had the pleasure of read Sophie Jo's debut in 2023... an underrated gem of a book, and one of my absolute favourite YA reads, a book I recommend an awful lot. It was tender and heartwarming, soft and realistic, and I loved Sophie's style of writing... the soft brush of romance, realistic familial upheaval, and twists on the typical coming-of-age genre.
This book is completely different.
It's a rom-com, yet British and YA, which excited me in so many ways when I first saw its announcement. It's also set in Birmingham, however subtly, and in the same universe as Sophie Jo's debut, which was a pleasant twist. We follow Poppy, a feisty, orange-haired feminist who's dead-set on finding her Dream Man, and Cam, or Cameron, who's always scared to get attached to girls, and bucks at the first hurdle. What follows is a delightful love story set in a sprawling British sixth form... lies and confusion and denial, and two teens, at the heart of it all, who can't deny their attraction to one another.
If I'm honest, I couldn't stand Poppy for most of the book - and if she hadn't changed, I would've been very upset. I was praying and praying for her redemption the whole time. Without spoiling (because I don't think it's a spoiler to say that a protagonist in a well-written book has a character arc), I was so relieved when Poppy's mum, in the final chapters, told Poppy exactly what I'd been thinking all along... and how I think a lot of teens today think and act.
Poppy is a very black and white, or all or nothing, person. She sees people as good and bad. Dream Man or Nightmare Man. She thinks she's right an awful lot of the time, and struggles to see why people - her parents, or her best friend - might stay in unhealthy relationships, however much they're hurting. There's one scene in the beginning where she's on a date in Nando's, and said date is embarrassed by any talk of periods, therefore blacklisting the poor boy from her potential boyfriend list. While my own boyfriend luckily enjoys menstruation talk, my mother can't even say the word out loud... not because she's a terrible person, but because of the stigma in society and how uncomfortable this topic still is to most of the world.
Cam, on the other hand, is a sweet and authentic teenage boy, and experienced genuine heartache and turmoil throughout the book. I loved the inclusion of a grandparent in the book, because I don't think we see it enough in YA, despite a large amount of young people living with their grandparents in this day and age, and being hugely effected by their age, often causing grief and stress around times such as exams and university applications. I found Cam's relationship to Stan beautiful and realistic, and such an important plotline.
'The Nicest Girl' still reigns supreme, but I loved this new genre for Sophie Jo, and I can't wait to read her next work. I really hope this book works to entice new readers into UKYA, with its contemporary feel and relevant title... and I'll be waiting eagerly to read whatever she writes next.