Normally, I'd give something like this only three stars, but... Something about this manga has a special charm to it that makes me feel warm, safe, more innocent like I used to be. I guess it brings me back to better times somehow, and that coupled with the absolutely adorable and pretty art style gives it an extra star from me.
So, I've known about Chaika for many years now. Three or four at least. And I knew it was fun to watch, had good animation and such, but I never really knew much about the stories or the characters.
I always pictured Chaika being intelligent and like a mix of the main girl from Gosick and Rachel Alucard. I always pictured Akari being some badass adventurer or something (I guess she kind of is). I had never imagined the main cast would consist of an autistic loli, a beautiful badass woman with a brother complex, and a lazy ass ordinary protagonist... Or that was my initial reaction anyhow, watching three minutes of the anime then reading the first few panels of the manga. But I told myself I knew it was worth another chance or two. So the very next morning (today), I read the entire first volume of the manga. I realized my first assumption after attempting to dive in wasn't correct, not entirely.
Chaika is an intelligent young lady, 14, and Japanese/English is her second language, evident when she speaks perfect Laake and is able to understand others almost perfectly in their own language but she herself struggles to speak it. That's exactly how it is when you're not fully fluent in another language. So, after coming to that conclusion, I simply imagined her with a broken English Russian accent, much like Simon from Russia Sushi but with a cute little girl voice. Because that's basically almost exactly what she is. A little Russian girl who can barely speak a language that isn't her native tongue. She's intelligent, durable, and focused. But being that she's only 14 and who knows who or what raised her after Gaz was killed, she's not perfect at any language other than Laake.
Now, as for Toru and Akari... I'm still a bit disappointed. Toru, I like him (aside from his stupid X HAIR). He reminds me of Hiro from Darling in the Franxx, just a little bit, as well as a soldier returned from home who no longer has any purpose and just waits to either waste away or a new purpose come knocking. Because that's exactly what he is. His sister too. They're both ex-soldiers in a world that has faced five years of completely blissful peace. Except to ex-soldiers like Toru, that peace is much more morbid, depressing, and eery than anything else.
And Akari... So much potential in her design. So much potential in her capabilities. But she's just a horny younger sister who can't stop making sex jokes if not jealous remarks because that's all that ever seems to be on her mind. Please stop, Akari. Please stop. Hold it in, keep your pants on. You are free to feel what you feel, but please reign it in.
Oh, and that Fayla unicorn.. Damn, that hurt. And even more so when its master went to investigate and holds its remains. DAMN, that HURT. I don't want to have to see anything like that again, and not that specific thing ever again.
Ah... And as mentioned before, I do really love the art in this, ohhh yes. I rented a copy of this volume from my local library but I am almost tempted to buy it nearly solely for the art work! Ahh, but that's what art books and posters are for. So I'll settle for those, they'll likely satisfy me more anyhow.
Well, I expect improvements in the next volume. With what this story is building itself up to be, I can't see it either 1. lasting long, or 2. not playing the exact same tropes and storyline over and over so long that it's boring as hell because everything is the same yet slightly different.
So much potential, so much creativity. And as for the characters, SO MANY DAMN OVERPLAYED TROPES. Oh, please don't just be another squandered amount of potential. This story can do so much, please don't just be another stereotype with a base story cooler than anything it ever delves into, without ever developing anything substantial. Ugh.